aespa 에스파 'Forever (약속)' MV 

Firstly, got amazed with Winter's Voice Second, got amazed with Giselle's voice Third, got amazed with Karina's Voice Four, got amazed with Ningning's voice This is proof that all member AESPA are vocalist.

Usually I don’t really like ballads, but this song stuck with me

If someone asks "Who's in Aespa's vocal line?" . The answer would be, ALL of THEM!!!! SM vocals 💯

2024년에 듣는 사람 나 밖에 없나..?

Karina high note seriously surprised me is like she was meant to do vocal but since she can dance and rap sm gave her that ,i also feel the same way for Giselle lmao

For the people hating on them, this is a cover of a prexisting song by another SM artist. They are showing their diversity and that every member has a beautifull voice even if their position isnt vocalist. Red Velvet and SNSD also did a cover as their 2nd single and recieved hate for it, and in the end both have been among the most popular girlgroups. Let the girls keep on with this tradition and support them while they keep trying new sounds. Btw i love the song

MYs, forever is not that launch to hit hair or break your leg like black mamba, but pay attention, especially to the vocals of future leaders of the fourth generation

Winter's vocals took me to sky. This song fit her alot

여러분 이 노래는 sm 막내 아이돌이 오랜 고전 슴덕들을 위한 선물로 준 번외곡 같은 겁니다. (유영진 forever 리메이크) ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

ningning proved why she is the main vocalist of this group.

this is one of the few ballads that I don't find boring, these girls can adapt to every concept can't wait for their album

aespa Karina Giselle Winter Ningning 💙🌙⭐️🦋

WE CAN ALL AGREE THAT THE LOWER TONES OF GISELLE GIVE CHILLS. HOWEVER, I MUST COMMEND WINTER FOR HER NOTES KARINA IS JUST TALENTED AS SHE IS. AND NINGNING IS ONE OF THE BEST MAIN VOCAL IN 4TH GEN

No one: literally one: SM:Let's make a group that include all main vocalists, main dancers!

Popular opinion: Everyone is healing after listening to this song

Who here, after streaming a new song, will definitely stream another MV too?

Aespa is one of the rookie group who got too much hate for getting more recognised and being successful just by their debut song

This song like the Christmas song and the concept too.

Im still here Black mamba = 126 M Forever = 35 M Fighting

this song is sooooooo underrated that hurts!!!!! this shows how every member of aespa can sing osts!!!

닝닝 목소리가 S.E.S 바다 선배님처럼... Suara ningning mirip kek seniornya Bada S.E.S

KARINA IS PROVING TO EVERYONE THAT SHE IS “IT GIRL”

Black mamba has 3 mins only while forever has 5 minutes they literally made us MY's satisfied on this song

933K👁 1.5M❤

Who’s the main vocalist of the group??? *aespa: YES*

Who's the visual? Aespa : YES Who's the main vocalist? Aespa too : YES

The difference between Black Mamba and Forever. I-

정형화되어잇지 않은 넥레때까지의 비주얼이 너무 조아서 가끔 보러 옴 ㅠㅠ 너무너무 이쁘고 잘해 얘들아

Giselle: start singing Me:start crying Popular opinion: giselle have to be a lead or main vocalist

SM: who wants to be the vocalist? Aespa: yes

Someone: soo... Who's the main vocalist? aespa: sorry we don't do that here

언제나 들어도 명곡🩵🩵

F: February 2021, the first comeback of AESPA O: Only 5 minutes for everybody to see AESPA R: Ready for more, MY ? E: Endless Christmas made by AESPA V: Vocalists are all members E: Everyone loves this song R: Really don't know why people still hate AESPA

Giselle is automatically lead vocal now.

First quarantine: Black Mamba is released Second quarantine: Forever is released Why do they know I need aespa everytime?! My medicene

I miss aespa era as a rookie😢 Without realizing, you guys really grew up so fast. Keep chasing your dreams my dear aespa ❤❤❤❤

Ok so i decided to stan them. After Mamamoo, Aespa is the only girl group who literally attracted me.

Who's still listening on this song on 2024 ? ❤

Best

Rappers cant sing and have high notes. Giselle: Hold my beer

One of my fave Winter looks probs my fave

Winter, Giselle and Karina's hair: we new hairr Ning ning: blk

we can go to the ends of the earth to try to find...the perfect peace so i think it is the greatest thing human beings can find in their lives n this real

Winter looks so beautiful here. SM please bring back this styling for Winter!!

Winter~

I will listen this song before xmas❤

I love this song so much

에스파 노래는 다 좋자나나나ㅏㅏㅏㅏㅏ❤❤❤

So beautiful. O e of my favorite Aespa MVs.

winter is so majestic

Anyone 2024?

Don't stop MYs Keep going and support the girls as much as we can

Aespa ballads are underrated

This song is absolutely beautiful 😭😭

❤

It’s so amazing ⭐️

I love this❤

aespa 1st Album 'Armageddon' May 27, 6 PM (KST)! pre-order & pre-save now! 🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌🌌

Have you ever cried when seeing someone really pretty.. It happens to me now when i see ningning... She's so damn beautiful.. ILU NINGNING 🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲

Happy Ningning 8000 days. Happy aespa 1400 days.

Forever really made me fall in love with ballads

kimse beğenmiyor ama bence aespa'nın en iyi sarkilarindan

ALL GEN LEADER aespa🎉

2024 anyone ?

2021 (fav)

feb 9, 2024 my first time to watch this i like the sound i like song like this🤧

🎄

Kangen winter era iniii

100 MILLION VIEWS PLEASE!

Let's gooo MY's 53M!!!

Black Mamba: 👺👿💀 FOREVER: ❤🥰💕💗😻

black mamba: dance forever: sing next level: rap

black mamba: older sibling that paved the way for the rest of the family forever: forgotten middle child next level: younger sibling that got all the attention

How many international MY's are here? 👇

Black Mamba=😎😈🤡👺 Forever=🥰🌈🍭😇🧸❄️

They only have 4 members, but I can't even choose a bias.

black mamba era girls: hrr 😈🖤 forever era girls: meow 🥺😽

Black mamba is Forever on the Next level for being a SAVAGE.

Black mamba to 150m Forever to 50m

Black Mamba - Fierce / Hot Vibes Forever - Soft Vibes

Non-fans be like: BLACK MAMBA era - who's the main dancer? FOREVER era - who's the main vocalist?

FUNFACT: This is not AESPA comeback this is just an sm groups tradition to remake song

Black mamba: 😈👹🐍🌑 Forever:💋❤💞 Next level:😻💙🌍🌈

Black Mamba: Karina's Era Forever: Winter's Era Next Level: Giselle's Era I'll edit this after NingNing's era!!

I want Ning Ning highnote and Giselle rap on the next 1st comeback

Only sm groups can have main rappers sing like main vocalist Edit:this is aespa video and this is an appreciation about aespa....please stop bringing other groups

40 million views on a remake ballad songg yess thats aespaaa its not even a comeback

NINGNING AND THE COMPUTER SHOULD JUST LIVE TOGETHER FOREVER

It’s a Valentine Song Not a Christmas song

Aespa basically serving Vocals, when they’re just rookies.

IT SEEMS LIKE THEY ARE ALL VISUAL AND VOCALIST !!

아니 뮤비 잘 보고있다가 마지막 아바타멤버들 보고 식겁함 제발

This song is so forgotten and it is criminally underrated

The main rapper can really sing. Before forever came out. I love watching Giselle teaser cause pf her rap skills but my goodness she can sing

This basically proves that Karina, Winter, Giselle and Ningning are now eligible to sing for OST's. Like did you hear that? WOW.

I mean they are SM artists, of course all of them can sing, not just the main and lead vocalist even the rapper and dancer too

I can’t believe these girls are the ones who sang black mamba and next level

Nuh uh this is better than stuck in the middle

These girls are a miracle that fell into the hands of SM

Karina Giselle Winter Ning ning Aku bangga dengan kalian semua