aespa 에스파 'Forever (약속)' The Performance Stage (Cozy Winter Cabin Ver.) 

This is not a comeback, this is actually a game, a game called "guess who's the main vocalist?".

When Boa said aespa can do everything she didn't lie.

This is not a comeback, SM just wants to flex aespa vocal

Ningning's voice is so unique. Sweet but strong Cute but powerful. Her voice is perfect for SM main vocal.

FACT: All of æspa's members are main vocalists

This song is cute Giselle: Main vocalist Ning Ning: Main vocalist Winter: Main vocalist Karina: Main vocalist

Karina's beauty is so different, swear I'm straight girl but I can't take off my eyes of her

Ningning puts in great effort to learn Korean and she articulates the language so well.

winter’s voice is like winter season personified 🥺❄️

i see a lot of people are saying they don’t like this song and isn’t as good as black mamba, but aren’t aware that this isn’t an official comeback song, it’s only a remake that shows off their vocals :))

SM debuts girl groups with less girls each time, truly means they select the best of the best

Just our Maknae Ningning showing that she's a sunbaenim trainee among the members. Look how talented this girl was.

They make it look so easy. Especially Ningning and Winter. The surprise here though is Giselle and Karina, who knew they also could sing that well. They are all amazing vocalists. With great tones. SM signature here. They never fail.

Giselle being a main rapper but serving those vocals 👏

Ningning looks so elegantly beautiful. She looks super cute with this hairstyle.

Can't stop adoring Karina because you know..she has it all

aespa is a K-Pop girl group with the best vocals in generation 4.

*"Who is your bias?"* *Who sings the best* *"All of them is best at singing'* *Exactly*

SM 팝 강렬하게 가다가, 이런 분위기 발라드 한곡씩 내는 거 되게 좋아요.

Winter and blackpink Rose's voice is the sweetest voice i've ever heard from K-Pop industry 😩❤️

GISELLE SAYING "MAH BABY" WILL FOREVER BE ICONIC

Winter is just too pretty, plus her insane soothing and soft vocals melts my heart.

the highest compliment i can accord to Aespa is that they are the most talented SME group in terms of well-balanced vocal ability in all members since TVXQ5..

Even there’s not so many shoots on Ningning, her voice still caught me.

Winter’s vocal tone is so addictive

The fact that Giselle is main rapper, Karina is main dancer, and their vocals are so good. They could easily be lead vocalists in any other group. Love you Aespa❤️

That's why Karina is my bias I love her voice everything about her, stan aespa

They all look like a Barbie dolls representing different countries. Winter - American Barbie Doll Karina - Korean Barbie Doll Ningning - Asian/Chinese Barbie Doll Giselle - Japanese Barbie Doll

"so who's the main vocalist?" : all of them. periodt.

I just love how aespa lead vocalist and main vocalist blend so well, in black mamba and forever bridge. Winter and Ningning has that "Bada voice" but ningning is like the bada of today's generation. Stop shocking me winter on ur vocal! I can't wait for more! Aespa fighting!

Winter's my ultimate bias but i never knew Ningning also was this beautiful

They look like a Disney Princess Especially Ningning in her SYNK teaser. Winter and Karina Looks like a human Barbie dolls there features are unique. Giselle looks like a Anime Character, She's Japanese though.

NingNing looks so gorgeous and i still can't believe Karina's voice is that beautiful Giselle's live vocal is unbelieveable and Winter is just so beautiful

Winter's vocal really suits how she looks though, sweet and gentle.

Karina=Future Queen Kpop

I don't know about other countries but for my country(US) NingNing is a beauty Queen.

they can all become a soloist. SM did a good job selecting such good vocalists and debuting together. their lineup reminds me of SNSD's four main vocalists. good luck with their good future. they deserve a good and successful career.

GISELLE MY GIRL THOSE VOCALS ARE EVERYTHING she's the real deal totally complete

Winter, a perfect main vocal quality and outstanding dancer with the best visual and strong stage presence. How can she blessed with such talent for a baby chick?

This is my favorite song of Aespa so far because it expresses or show off their own vocal skills to us, not only they can rap and dance! Aespa is a talented girl group that they are all in one, they can do everything… ❤💖🥰🤧😭

interviewer: OKAY SO WHO’S THE MAIN VOCALIST? aespa: AESPA

I love how Giselle got more lines, and her black hair like Ugh gorgeous queen go off. Edit: omg 800 of Giselle's gf are present ;D !! Keep supporting our queen

Where the heck did SM find these girls.....literally.....I call....I got a full house......Well Aespa has 4 ACES! They are so young and stunning....and yet.....WOW!!!! Each one can really really sing!!!! This is a cheezy little girly song....but is sung by 4 of the most talented girls in the industry....gawd....i can't wait for more AESPA!!!!!

Winter is the best SINGER of this GROUP ❤❤

Forever with aespa

this performance is another proof as to why sm has the best vocalists. even tho karina and giselle are sub-vocals, they can sing. and i mean, sing really good. aespa vocal queens indeed!

I mean Aespa has such beautiful vocals, they should do more songs like this which will showcase their vocal more & SM should let them do live more often.

이건 라이브라 쬐끔 덜할지 몰라도 음원들으면 그냥 유영진 4명 만들어놈... 아무리 유영진 곡 리메이크라도 그렇지 진짜 창법도 유영진됨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 약간 엔시티유 커밍홈첨들었을때 그느낌....

Let's talk about Giselle i can't see enough of her vocals in black mamba but this song proves her vocals. A hidden gem.

You can't deny that SM don't disappoint people with their artists especially when it comes to vocals. They can sing in live and you won't notice a difference or changes.

my first bias is winter when black mamba out buuuutttt ningning and karina made me think once again haha and now my bias is forever ningning (her eyes & smile is magnetic) and karina (her charisma & smile is pure)

Winter voice is sweet and other 3 voice are powerful

Giselle and Karina are really multitalented, they can dance well, sing great, and rapp very well

Ningning's voice is so matured for a rookie. IDK but sometimes she's sounds like BADA from S.E.S I also notice that on her SYNK teaser. And Winter sometimes like BOA, maybe I still have a hang-over from her cover on MAMA last year haha

They are called ACEpa for a reason. They are all Aces😍✨

yep, NingNing always pretty, This is a very common thing, but today look Karina very special beauty

Winter's vocals never failed to amaze me. She has this angelic, soft and beautiful voice indeed. SM's hidden ace.

This song not only show us their vocal talents, they show us aespa is alllrounder for any genre.

I am a fan of another boy group. But these girls look so pretty in this video and I decide to pay attention to them too.

Feels warm while watching this footage. It's freezing cold here in a tropical country. And my body is abnormally releasing annoying moist because my sweat glands became active. Now, I can't decently write for my homework because it gets moisty and dirty. But aespa is here singing so I will shut up and embrace every mesmerising matters that they emit.

MYs please always be humble. We are still a small fandom but we already experience lot of things just to protect this 4 precious girls! Stop the nonsense fanwar and just stream! Being the main vocalist does not mean she get the most lines! This is just a cover not official comeback! More comeback in the future, so more lines to come for Ningning so please just support four of them.

They were born to be a start. NingNing is a popular name in the Philippines it means shine. Just like the stars in the sky NingNing shines brightly.

Karina bias wrecking me so hard when she’s already my bias wtf 😭💙

their vocals are more stable than my emotional health

Waw Karina's voice in this live is so cool 😭 Life is so unfair how can she can rap, dance, sing and her visual is amazing

Karina with that hairstyle , with that dress , and skirt is AWESOME

Winter & Karina 's voice is so beautiful.

다너무귀엽다ㅠ 다들미모뭐야진짜ㅋ 어이없어서웃음만나오네.. 윈터야개이쁘다 선녀니? 자꾸그렇게이뻐지면 내심장책임져

I'm so in love with Giselle's tone and deeper vocal colour, she's amazing

Don't they all look like Chaebols?? They exude elegance and Royalty. Literally the aura I could see from every SM artists.

Ooohhhhhhh karina with brown hair ilove her easpa stan forever

they really show a lot of maturity with this song. more so than i would expect from such a young group. i'm liking them for that.

ningning's vocal is the best and she looks so gorgeous. karina's voice is so amazing. giselle is literally their hidden main vocalist and winter slayed this with her beautiful vocals.

Aespa Black Mamba: bring the dancers out Aespa Forever: bring the musicians out

I am an army though I didn't believe that kind of issue of bullying about Karina,Karina really caught my attention her talent,visual,and body proportion are killing it

Their vocals are all so pretty and unique, love them

Karina is a real-life angel that heals people’s hearts😭

They said nobody's perfect. Then there's Winter proving people wrong 😋

Full package aespa are really all rounders

i realllyyyyyy like rina's voice....want to hear her more :((

A lot of Kpop idols are beautiful but aespa is not just visuals that’s what makes them special ! EACH member carries their own weight and prove why they got the debut spot :D

i really love karina's voice. rapping and singing. she's just so unique and one in a million. i love her

No wonder Giselle's voice is because she was a member of the choir before her debut

winter looks like a barbie doll

I’m being serious tho, this set looks more gorgeous than the set in MV.

Giselle really be wrecking everyone just because she's change her hair colour the power she holds

지젤 왜이렇게 예뻐..?

Their voices are so powerful. I really like their voices

“Who’s the main vocalist?” aespa: yes

Aespa's visuals and vocals are no joke as expected for SM artists

Karina is very very very very beautiful with that outfit

Ningning deserving the title nation’s vocalist😍 if that exists

At this point, dragging aespa's vocals are just like asking for a public humiliation.

The way karina looked at winter when ningning was singing forever is just so oh my ghaddd i cant explain

In most of the groups there will be one Main Vocalist and one Favourite Voice.. Like in Red Velvet it's Wendy and Joy for me.. But in Aespa, NingNing holds both the position.. She's the Main Vocalist and also has a really really pretty vocal colour..

I know this is just me but Karina's voice reminds me of Pristin's Eunwoo for some reason

karina is so pretty, i dont know why people is hating on her. i saw some comments who called giselle fat. excuse me, are you blind? she's so healty and pretty at the same time. she is a main rapper and her vocals... winter's visual is killing me for sure. her voice tho. and lastly, ningning... her voice is like an angel. she is so cute at the same time. stan karina, winter, ningning and giselle. stan aespa for a better life people

Everyone: Who's the main vocalist? æspa: Yes

SM decided to flex aespa vocals in this song, SM knows they have treasure of vocalists in æspa.

Their voice, especially Karina voice😭❤️ 1:04 3:07 3:27 4:44 Full version for singing member parts... Winter 0:23 1:46 3:37 4:12 4:22 Giselle 0:44 2:16 3:22 4:28 Karina 1:04 3:07 3:27 4:44 NingNing 1:24 2:19 3:33 3:42 4:38 Shared parts 2:45 4:06 4:17 4:48