드라마 이 노래가 원래 블랙맘바 - 넥레 - 세비지 - 드라마 - 걸스 순서로 블랙맘바5부작중에 4부를 맡기로 되어있었는데 아마 그 시기부터 에스엠내부에서 삐걱거리기 시작해서 걸스를 냅다 먼저 내버리고 그다음 컴백도 스파이시로 돌려버린거같아요 스토리전개상 드라마 가사내용도 그렇고 뮤비내용도 그렇고 트라우마를 부수는 내용인데 이게 블랙맘바의 환각퀘스트를 깨부수는 세비지 곡 내용이랑도 일맥상통합니다 드라마 뮤비 마지막에 닝닝이 칼로 화면을 깨서 유리조각이 나오는것도 세비지 뮤비 마지막에 눈알괴물(블랙맘바)를 윈터가 쏴서 깨트린거랑 비슷한 비주얼 표현방식이에요 드라마 뮤비에 나오는 지젤이 불빛속에 둘러싸인장면이나 멤버들이 무기로 싸우는 장면 빌딩숲을 활강하는장면도 에스파 세계관영상에보면 나오는 장면들입니다 그래서그런가 아직 가사에도 보면 브릿지파트에 I'nto the REALWORLD 다가온 클라이맥스' 이런식으로 세계관 단어가 들어가있어요 스파이시 자체도 멤버들이 블랙맘바를 부수고나서 현실의 이상현상을 자각하는 내용의 뮤비였습니다 아직 세계관은 유효한거같아요 다만 이수만의 kick은 좀 사라진거같죠 가사의 컬트적인 부분도 많이 빠졌고 좀 평범해진 느낌
those two dudes always criticize amyone that isn't from HYBE, we see you.. 🤑👀 they eat up le sserafim's dookie songs and rap but are coming for Karina and Giselle's raps 😂
저도 과거 넥레 걸스 좋아했던 입장으로서 에스파 색이 조금 옅어졌다?? 는 확실히 느끼는데 최근 곡들 성적이 워낙 좋다보니 그룹을 위해서도 지금의 톤을 유지하는게 좋아보이긴 해요 ㅋㅋ 쇠맛 안 버리는 것만 해도 다행... 별개로 수만리 나간건 경축 아니 근데 에스파 랩톤이 아니라 파트가 문제라고 하셨는데 사람들 너무 화났네 ㅠㅠ 여러분 진정요
as much as i love how detailed and honest these reactions are am i the only one who feels like they're a bit harsh towards SM artists in particular on this channel first dragging taemin guilty mv and nitpicking on riize now this lol the hybe dickriding is crazy 😂
I’m not even a fans of aespa, but compared to other group from their generation, aespa and g-idle are known as group with a strong rapp line. giselle flow is best for me
the lyrics in korean is bad. to be a strong "rapper" you need to at least be able to write your own rap. rap means Rhythm and Poetry. their comments are true lol
@@sofa5292 no their comments are just unnecessary. They were gagged over queencards lyrics, even though the lyrics were corny and had countless grammar errors in them.
the lyrics in korean is bad. to be a strong "rapper" you need to at least be able to write your own rap. rap means Rhythm and Poetry. their comments are true lol
@@sofa5292 Karina and Giselle both have taken part in writing and composing, proving that their well above average for kpop rappers. It's not their fault sm hires corny white rappers. Just look at giselle's solo concert song, the only good verse is at the end which was written by her, the rest was written by two white people.
Wdym they're not good at rap? Giselle flow is one of the best in 4th gen group and i don't really think even in 3rd gen gg can beat her except blackpink
Do they not know LSM wanted this to be the song talking about planting trees. No they are fine without him. A whole 10 months worth of albums/concerts proves that. And for the last time this is real world Aespa, and this song is similar to Savage, but not kwangya lingo. They're grabbing more fans without the extra words
The rapping ✅✅ The vocals ✅✅ The ad-libs ✅✅ The harmonies ✅✅ The dancing ✅✅ The choreography ✅✅ The styling ✅✅ The fashion ✅✅ The lyrics ✅✅ The make-up ✅✅ The visuals ✅✅ The concept ✅✅ The storyline ✅✅ The cinematography ✅✅ The color correction ✅✅ The color grading ✅✅ The editing ✅✅ The camerawork ✅✅ The video production ✅✅ The instrumental ✅✅ The vocal production ✅✅ The music production ✅✅ The MV ✅✅ The song ✅✅
Wow seriously guys? Ur riding on the rap? U guys are bit harsh arent u? Karina and giselle are the best rappers to ever come through sm. Time to put up or shut up. How about u show us how u would write the rap verse for this song and let us critique u. Come on put up or shut up.
I think all the girls rap well but the mistake that sm is constantly doing is not putting giselle to actually have long rap verses,she already proved that she has talent,she can write/compose/produce,has a great flow good pronunciation and a unique tone.
First of all, I recommend that you criticize not only the title songs, but also look at their previous rap works and after you have enough material. Yes, it is a vocal-oriented group, but each member also has their own rap taste. I GOT THE BEAT Karina was excellent at rapping Giselle can rap very fluently, you can see this by examining her own rap or her foreign rap cover. I think it's a very unprofessional comment that they shouldn't be rapping. They're not a rap group, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't rap. Just because you don't like the rap written doesn't mean you will criticize them by bullying them. Please express your criticism by supporting people who love doing this job by saying they should improve themselves more, not by saying they shouldn't rap!!! I'm disappointed.!!!!!!!
리액션에 있어서 비판이든 칭찬이든 제작자의 자유입니다,, 마음에 안들면 안보면되고 이로 인해서 조회수가 떨어지면 알아서 고쳐나가겠죠 그리고 got the beat 이야기를 해주셨는데 그것도 누군가한테는 좋게 들릴 수 도 안좋게 들릴 수 도 있는거 아닐까요? 저는 솔직히 savage나 next level 때의 에스파를 더 좋아하기도 하고 그 이후로는 spicy나 drama는 노래보다 비쥬얼적인 측면으로 앨범을 기획하는 것같아서 아쉽습니다. 비판적인 시각이 필요할 때라고 생각하구요
@@Euwvsuxvzj2626 because their February comeback was scrapped... They had to spilt the album into two mini's and rewrite songs cause lee soo man wanted them to sing about planting tree's
@@fussy.567 here's english version of mine It's the RU-vidr's freedom to react, whether they criticize or praise, if you don't like it, you just don't have to watch it, and then the View count for this video should drop, so they'll fix it on their own And you told me about "got the beat," but isn't it something that might sound good or bad to someone? most of all, What they talked about was not about rap's ability and flow, but about the lyrics. They said they were disappointed because the lyrics were written by the lyricist, not by the rapper. To be honest, I prefer the sound such as 'savage' and 'next level' when aespa is in 'kwangya'. (Of course, smcu is childish), and after that, the two lead tracks of aespa, spicy and drama, seem to be planning the album in a visual aspect rather than a song. I think it's time for a critical view
I didn't like rap too but it was just not liking tone that much in this song not bcs of lyrics. I actually liked lyrics and i don't understand, u guys liked queencard, super shy, unforgiven etc. lyrics which were so corny and truly worst raps but hate this one.😂😂 And how can u say aespa should stop rapping. Giselle is one of best female rappers in kpop industry and Karina+Giselle are known one of the best female duo rappers.
Seriously you guys shouldn't reaction to other artist mv because just hate and biased to other group, you said that you kpop choreographer and whatever but nuguuuu artist hahaha and then comment to karina and gigi not to rap again
Honestly, by saying comments like that you are bullying them. okay if their rap lyrics are bad, but your comments saying they don't rapping so annoying. Who are you? what right do you have to bully them?
Indeed. SM need a better lyricist to write their artists' rap section. In aespa's case, I personally think if they gave the rapping part to Giselle and Karina only, it will a lot better. I'm not saying Ningning did it badly but Giselle is the rightful main rapper after all. I don't know why the company didn't let a main rapper to do the rap lol
LMAO SM NEVER GIVE GISELLE A FULL RAP. WHY THEIR GIVE RAP LINE TO THE MAIN VOCAL? AND I KNOW U GUYS LOVE KARINA SO MUCH BUT HER RAP IS ANNOYING, ESPECIALLY IN THE BEGINNING OF THIS SONG
그렇게 말하려면 본인이 더 전문가로서의 면모가 보이게 보충 의견이라도 다셔야 하는 것 아닌가요~? 뭐가 문제인지도 언급 없이 대충 두루뭉술하게 그렇게 말하는 건 누구나 할 수 있어요~ 이분들은 그래도 전문용어 써가며 몇분짜리 영상을 꽉 채워 코멘트 할 수 있는데 그게 모자라다 느끼시면 댓글로라도 구체적으로 지적을 하실 수 있어야죠
맞아요 진짜 맞는 말 파티… 가사 엉망인 건 슴 전통(?)이라지만 랩이 진짜 충격임!!!!!!!! 이렇게 맞는 옷 찾아간다지만 저 쩌는 애들 장점 강점을 회사만 모르나 싶어서 아쉬워요ㅠㅠ 그건 수만옹이 잘 하셨던 것 같아요 진짜로… 그는 가사 빼면 천재ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 그래도 오랜만에 에스파가 잘 살리는 컨셉으로 나와서 보는 재미있음!!!!!! 진짜 너무 예뻐서 직캠 구멍나게 보는 중이랍니다ㅋㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌ
English comments relax lol They are not criticizing aespa's rapping skills. They talking about the rap lyrics. And as you know it wasnt written by the members.
@@vaanshichauhan9868 You could think that way when you read it in English Subtitle, but in Korean they are talking about the production in general. This channel isnt just about the singers' abilities. They talk about the overall production of the song. When they say aespa shouldnt rap, they are not just talking about the rapping skills, they talking about the lyrics and the production. You guys are being too senstitive imo. Also, aespa can sing well so I agree with the point that I would like to see more singing than rapping in their verses.
에스파는 정체성부터 찾아야될 거 같아요. 걸스까지 이수만 체제에서 강하게 밀어붙인 광야 세계관은 호불호가 강하기도 했지만 멤버들 스스로가 몰입을 못했어요. 진행자들이 보여달라거나 설명해달라 하면 민망해하거나 부끄러워하면서 슥 넘기고 그랬거든요. 이제 본인들이 그렇게 맘에 안들어하던 광야 세계관을 밀고갈 동력이 사라진 상태에서 연달아 발표한 노래 스파이시랑 드라마가 다른 컨셉의 곡이다 보니 앞으로 뭘 할건지 가늠이 안되네요. 에스파의 정체성을 새로 만드는게 숙제로 남은 거 같아요. 드라마는 광야도 아니면서 광야같은 쇠맛이 나서 혼란스럽기만 해요.
처음이자 마지막으로 말하겠는데요. 앞으로 SM 가수 리뷰하실때 한번만 더 이수만 애기하시면 두분 다 가만안둡니다! 그리고 랩 좋고 잘만 하는구만 전문가라는 사람들이 이상하게 말을 하질않나 에스파팬들을 기분 상하게 하는 말이나 하고 진짜 기분 나쁘고 더러워요! 그리고 저번에 뭐 NCT에서 잘 아신다는 분들이 누가 안무 했는지도 몰라 127과 드림 컨셉이 다른데 컨셉이 비슷하다 똑같다고 하질않나 그리고 지들이 잘못해놓고 뭐라고 하지말라고 하질않나 진짜 이 채널 너무 역겨워서 없애고 싶어요!
