NINGNING LOOKS SO HAPPY AND CHARISMATIC HERE. SHES ACTUALLY SINGING LIVE LOOKS LIKE SHES ENJOYING HER TIME. If you look at times where she was lip-syncing you can cleary see how bored she was and she wasnt even trying to hide it. Im so happy for her
omg, i can't believe it. I read a lot of horrible comments about their performances on social media but when i watch this fancam.....i can just say that they did so freaking good, Stan Aespa right now
I think when they start performing in front of crowds again in Korea they will sing live. Many companies don't want to waste the vocal strain on empty audiences
I hope SM of even Kpop music show or so allow idols to perform live more. Spmetimes its the program that dont really recommend or allow groups to perform live cuz of certain issue .. n maybe for live they go live performance but broadcast they will show edited one cuz of certain issue ,sound quality etc. What i heard .. idk tho. But yea. Hope more live vocal from aespa!!
why are people saying that the crowd are dead and they did not do good. aespa literally slayed, nailed, and left no crumbs in their performance! People would really make wrong narratives to put aespa down but ot won’t happen bcs they are so good!! aespa fighting!!
Haters are showing and spreading a fancams that is so so far away from the stage and dumb people believed it. We can't hear the crowd in those fancams because the one taking the video is far away from the large crowd and stage.
@@heart8143 i see, these people really have nothing to do. I am so sad aespa have to deal with these haters but i do believe that greatness will always come upon them, these girls deserve better
@@kingaeri7722 another fun fact: they used the clip where Giselle is saying "Are you ready coachella?" Then suddenly cut the video even before the crowds reaction
Edit: This video got mass reported and taken down for "inappropriate content." I appealed and RU-vid denied!! I finally got in contact with someone at RU-vid customer support and they escalated it to get the video back up. Seems the haters just want to take aespa down. So glad the video is now back up for everyone to see! Please share with everyone!! People deserve to hear how they ACTUALLY sounded live at Coachella. After filming this fancam in the front row and then going online after, I was shocked that people were commenting that the audience was dead and that they couldn't hear aespa's live singing over the back track. It must have been the livestream!! But in person the girls were GIVING!! (and so were the fans) This fancam is proof!!
Hard to believe this was the first time aespa performed in front of a REAL audiance, it was basically their first performance (they debuted during covid) and they were still rookies. Sadly the backaudio was really louder but i'm glad ppl are posting the fancams to show everyone they were singing live and that you could hear them singing. Them all nailed.
people meant it was compared to other big artists but I guess that's normal since aespa is still fairly new ig? but they did have a very lively crowd nonetheless
@@pechiemy No, they came to that conclusion based on that one video that was taken so far from the stage. People just hate aespa, no need to cover their actions.
@@ayeon5609 yeah I saw it too lol, unnecessary hate for a good group. But apparently that was their reasoning or whatever. Also I'm not covering anyone so dw. :)
I'm satisfied watching fancams of Aespa in Coachela than its live. The audience is not dead during their performance. 💖💖 And My Winter is so stable 🥰 and who said that she has no stage presence? I understand now the hype that Aespa gave in this performance. Singing live and people cheering for them.
Same. I dont watch their Korean 'lives' because they lip sync there and its not entertaining for me. Im not alone when I say their stage presence is lacking even with the fancy stage and camera. Im not yet a fan but Coachella (with the shaky cam and all) is addicting to watch for obvious reasons.
"Life's too short to pretend you don't like aespa." They performed really well. It's better to perform live for real audience than scream your lungs in music shows when there is no audience nowadays. They did their best and their raw voices, i love the little imperfections and slips. Them singing after being breatheless, and being this stable, now that's what i call a performance. As a SM stan,i have big expectations from their artists and i take huge pride on their vocals, i was waiting for this moment. Live singing really brought out the best in them. I just hope SM can make their songs a little hype keeping up with their concept and i wish they performed Dreams come true. I can't stop watching these Coachella performances,it's too good. I don't stan them but the hate they have been receiving,it can't be unseen and was honestly upsetting. It's a slap to the haters. I'm definitely going to stan them now, these girls have proved themselves,I'm really proud. I'm crying because i have seen them debut,how people have been hating on them and they're still standing strong like it's nothing.
i won't even blame SM. These music and award shows disrespected their idols multiple times. Example is MNET and it's MAMA award show and SBS. These shows treated their idols like shit,they don't deserve SM artists and their amazing vocals. And even they didn't let their idols sing live on music shows but they were singing live in their own concerts where they have real audience which actually appreciates them
They said Aespa doesn't have stage presence but this performance is a bomb! Best fancam! Just watching this makes me feel the vibes. I could feel the energy! Agh. Wish I was there. T.T CONGRATULATIONS AESPA!!!!! GREAT PERFORMANCE! 🥰🥰🥰
according to their standards But the standard of the festival is not passed.He wasn't ready for this kind of stage.Because when people in the event set the standard at Bp Search size in coachella that the result by google Bp is also high don't talk to me don't compare, since you still use the word GG kpop too, comparison will always happen.
@@parkpark6976 Why not spend more time improving your English instead of spending time hating on a group that other people obviously like and enjoy? You go cheer for the group that you like, and we will cheer for ours. If you don't like being talked down to, then don't talk down to others.
@Boobear • Sunshine 🏳️🌈 #proudofliam no one paid them for those music shows... totally valid not to force them to destroy their voices each time when there's no audience.
@@aliassyuhadah4735 Protecting their voice doesn't mean let them do lipsync in every performance. They can sing live while skipping some part if it's too hard for their voice. Just admit it, SM sucks. They're talented af and have a good vocal but SM rarely let them sing live.
@Boobear • Sunshine 🏳️🌈 #proudofliam no one pays for the music shows lol. and there's no audience. sometimes i agree with that decisions like why r they need to screams their lungs when there's no audience at all
was I the only one who got teary when ning ning hit that high note ? I'm so happy they can finally shut the haters up :) even though we all knew they are amazing singers and sm is just helping them preserve their vocals.
@@mmmm-bd4yf not true. karina is absolutely dominating china (the second most popular idol there) while winter has a chokehold on japan since savage. ningning is popular in usa tho
Winter is totally amazing ...she is main vocal for me because of her high thin treble , raspy and vibrato voice...by the ningning slay it ..she proved the she is main vocal ...karina and gislle on fire with powerful voice and great rap........ Visuals and dresses are top of world No word for them 🤐. They slay it. Agree or not ? Saranghae my ... Saranghae aespa
@@전봉준-l4v Winter is good and yeah she is so stable but overall ningning>>>>winter. Stage presence, dance, main vocal, connecting with audience she has it all
When netizen said aespa can not made loud coachella, but from this video we know aespa kill it!!!! No matters aespa doing, haters will be toxic. Btw thank you for this HD fancam video
I know all girls are good but Ningning stand out. The stage presence, energy, and Voice, she really knows. I'm about to stan them because of her. Keep slaying girls. 💙💙💙
They are just trying to finde something to hate on, and do they expect a kpop group to have the same audience as like harry styles or other bigger American artists??😂
@@Androids23 Ikr? And not even mentioning that Aespa is still a Rockie...not even 2yrs old group... So people need to calm down and let these girls alone and have their moment in Coachella. Perfect or not the performance was enyoyable, that people find any stupid thing to drag Aespa is another thing.
I was nervous and excited while watching this. This is my SM baby. Gosh! They did very, very well. They really prove to everybody that they deserve the hype. That they are THE AESPA!!! And Ningning knows. She knows!!! Go aespa!!!
So now that we’ve confirmed that AESPA can sing really really really well live while freaking performing hard core choreo .... haters should be shut up forever from opening their mouths regarding AESPA. Amen.
no now that we heared what they sound like live can we have them sing live for encore stages and then no one will doubt them it's the sm fault not the HATERS
The girls did so well, their live singing was amazing, and they killed the stage! Imagine having this kind of opportunity for a year old group, that is amazing!! The crowd was also amazing even tho most of them are locals and non-MYs. So proud of aespa, thank you so much for uploading this amazing fancam!
WINTER IM SO PROUD OF YOU YOU DID WELL YOUR VOCAL SOUNDS LIKE YOU ALREADY HAVE 2 TO 3 YEARS EXPERIENCE IN KPOP INDUSTRY AND TO OTHER MEMBER YOU ALSO DID WELL AND THANKYOU FOR THE AMAZING PERFORMANCE. WE ENJOY IT, FROM THE HATERS SHUT UP!!
nope, the hater wont shut up, now they'll complain about hearing breathing in their singing, expecting Aespa to be non-human or something... haters are really absurd!
Aespa’s haters are creative they come up with something new everyday to drag aespa. Now mostly the arguments are lack of stage presence and dead crowd 💀
I just knew their stage presence and performance would improve greatly if they could sing live and here's the proof! Thanks for sharing! Also, I just can't take my eyes off of Ningning she's such a queen and looks gorgeous (as always).
So some blinks said they had no audience? Or they lacked Aenergy??? Seriously, my friend went Coachella and they said immediately after next level people were googling who they were.If that isn’t the best thing SM did , then what is?
the first thing you must do when watching concerts in RU-vid or different video streaming platforms is to search for fancams. live streaming from the organizer themselves have been touched up with pre-recorded vocals and they lessen the volume of the crowd's cheer to highlight the artist's vocals. I really didn't believe that the coachella crowd was dead even if there are some people saying that they've watched perform live and can testify that they lack stage presence because I first watched in fancams before the actual live streaming. I'm glad SM let them sing live because they totally slayed.
MISS NINGNING ATE THAT HIGHNOTE UP, GISELLE’S STAGE PRESENCE IS REALLY SLAYING, WINTER IS DEF EATING CD’S, KARINA DON’T GET ME STARTED WITH HER, SHE EATING UP EVERYTHING.
Blackpink and Aespa both do their best in each of their performances at Coachella, why does everyone want to pick who is the best? Everyone knows who Blackpink and Aespa are because both groups are celebrities. Stop comparing Blackpink and Aespa. both groups are commendable. I am writing this comment because I am a MY and BLINK
i want to say im a blink and once, i want to apologize on aespa's fans for some of the blinks throwing hate comments despite knowing what blackpink suffered on their early years as well. I'm glad aespa performed and had a great time on stage they really needed that as a rookie. To my fellow blinks please think about our past struggles on hate and don't bring other groups down. I'm glad kpop is getting more and more recognition now on the global scene
galing talaga ng sm!! hope they will take care of their artists.. coz from rookie days pa lang, grabi talent for talent talaga .aespa you did great..my ningning..❤❤❤
