Nirmala sitaraman should go to the retail market and find out the prices of cooking oil, fruits, vegetables, medicines and essential commodities. Then she will understand what inflation is. Sitting in public's ac office will not work out.
@@rajx7120 Yup, every state in India other than the two have achieved the vishwaguru status which is why we witnessed the highest number of citizenship renunciations in the last two years.
@@Humble.fool05 Citizenship renunciation is because of factors like reservations, and poor return on taxes paid. We have so many freebie socialist policies that, nobody worth their salt wants to raise their kids in India. It has nothing to do with inflation. These are rich people who would not care about inflation, that left the country. And they took their wealth, that could have been invested back into the country.
Did you compare it with countries outside in the world? You lack knowledge of how COVID and war affected supply chain and inflation, so don't speak kid
@@nps7742 And he was using wrong metric. WPI doesn't include food inflation. That comes under CPI, which has come down at 5.88%. He was misleading people!
Ya still he got busted by numbers. Instead of believing if only you could Google or check your own expense rise given qty and std of living remains same.
This is the best winter session of parliament since the tym i started watching these speeches.. congress president kharge is fearlessly questioning modiji standing infront of him.. that's what we wanted.. a healthy Q&A
This lady is the main draw back to our nation.. Such a comedy lady she is .. Fighting for pm s poster on the wall.. In hyd..instead She would have concentrate on poor ppl lives.. Covid is become a money machine for bjp govt.. All lies ..pls stop amma
@@cnu_vlogs ya we need a FM like in Srilanka or pakistan or bangladesh or nepal.. who gives subsidies on fuel and freebies to people so india can just go into recession and kill it's own people in name of freebies and inflation.
@@aspiringca05 ya but if opposition is doing the same mess in their states and telling the center how to cure it. It appears a fat obese doctor telling you about diets and what to do to cure obeseness.. these things will not bring change.
Nirmala Madam you are replying to one incorrect statement that Raghav Chadha made in an election rally due to slip of tongue. But you failed to give appropriate answer to ten very logical questions that he asked on the floor of the house.
@@utkarshagarwal5103 -_- books have all sort of data when RBI is now headed by governments minions. Real scenario we poor people know. The cost of basic things has almost doubled. Basic things like soaps etc are double costly or quantity is reduced
@Spell Check i mean i have a manufacturing business of my own. All i can say is macros of our economy is much better. I get all sort of demand for my products (which is related to construction). Tells a lot about the things on ground. Since you are talking about ground check. I have no political affiliations. I am just saying what is on ground. P.s. macros weren't that bad even during upa regime.
and if you use a person's english as an excuse to disregard his/her statements shows how incapable you are to counter the facts but rather choose to demonize him/her based on english because its easy to demonize a person rather than to counter him/her on facts
😂😂😂 if she is so truthful then why so much price hike, so many job losses, and so many hunger issue and people are getting poorer, stop lying nirmala tai
@@skwazeedali8448 You mean to say that all that is happening wouldn't have happened if she was not FM. Your perpetual hatred towards bjp leaders is quite understandable.
@Ahmad Rahman haha yes I have 2GB data ... Understand the difference between RAM and DATA...... Oh sry how can u know this, if it didn't mentioned in quran
Did she not expose the laughable numbers put forth by a fraud CA Chaddha in his questions? She was only refering to the stupidity of a CA degree holder and his previous gross public lies as habitual things. You can't be lying day in day out publicly and expect to be taken seriously by a genuine person like Dr Sitharaman.
@@rakshithac3520 3:48 Listen 👂 carefully my friend . Don't behave like mindless Troll of political parties. Have patience to take criticism specially if you are defending any government in power.
Someone in the background said about Raghav, "Institute should take back his degree." These goons have no idea what it takes to become a Chartered Accountant.
That someone is Mr Piyush goel for you who too is a qualified CA and all he said was please do not consider that only mr. chadda represents chartered accountants, many of us are embarassed by his chartered accountancy. He stood up and sad this just when Chadda was interrupting and talking in between the lady's speech. Don't spread lies.
that somesaid very right because how can he say something nonsense like that how tf he don't know about deficit budget and it's good for our country its soo damn basic even i think a 12th grader economics student knows that what he said is idiotic
FM smartly reported the debt of central government in percentage of GDP not in absolute numbers. As GDP increases, even if the debt is same in percentage terms it will come down.
Kudos to Raghav Chadha. He made the FM take note of the questions that had been dogging the psyche of the common man and FM had been ignoring them so far.
@@shodhitgoyal6539 inko inflation on primary and agricultural goods ke bare meh pucha gaya tha, par unho ne question ko average inflation ke taraf shift kar diya jo single digits meh he par WPI double digits meh he. Isshe industries ko sasti raw materials, equipment, service, etc milta he par common man ka jinna haram ho jata he. Asahi chalta raha to wealth gap increase karega aur middle class shrink karega. Hamlogo ko esa FM nahi chahiye jo parliament meh drama kar sake aur kuch nahi.
Speaker said try to digest as a certified chartered accountant and go through numbers. This is ultimate disrespect in house I enjoyed it. Meanwhile Chad piyush Goyal said Institute will take back his degree
In every devloped nation young people regulate the government but in my country old and tired people are ruling because we've set an minimum age for everything.
@@thememorylist please don't use Modern Infrastructure made by Modi Government I am from North India and here train were always delayed by 18-20 hrs but now Running on Time, Cause 2track were made and being developed that's require Money
@@shivammalikO1 Even president is elected in same way. So what has president done to be in that post? Don’t make vague arguments . Raghav is the youngest RS member and yes that’s an achievement . And at least for this debate he is definitely having an edge , honourable FM can’t explain why unemployment is high, why our economy after 2014 is declining.
@bala balw and you just copied the pattern of FM and dodge the real question and also called my statement vague? haha I ask, what he achieved to be the finest politician, and being the youngest doesn't make any sense, you hear the name chandrani murmu ?, you compare mp(selected by a LA , particularly from one group of party) of RS to the president(elected by every LA and parliament) doesn't make any comparison, but it tells ur limitation to understand the difference in rs mp and president of India and the value of their post.
Raghav took leave and was absent when FM rose to answer his questions - this speaks enough for the 'quality' of this chartered accountant's questions....
Seems respected FM mam doesn't know the reality faced by common man in day to day life. Talking about these fancy stats drafted by diff officers in AC offices have no value in terms of struggle a common man face.
Nirmala Mam u give profound answers. Can you please also answer why home loans, petrol prices and commodity prices all has went up for the middle class tax payer N why u haven't implemented Arun Jaitley's tax slab increase
AAP MP before asking any question to any minister at center, he should share economic/infrastructure/law and order contributions in the states where they are in power. Punjab and Delhi as we know are under free fall with their policies in place.
@Rakesh Dutt G If you step out of your house you will see infrastructure changes in the form of new and improved roads, new hospitals, improved trains, new metro lines, new IITs, new IIMs, water connections, border connectivity etc etc etc. As they say, if the eye doesn't want to see neither the water nor the glass will help.
Are you saying that MP is not part of this union government then. Lets agree that his party which is in ruling is corrupted one, so does it take away his right to question this government. That might be morally wrong but is it how you wish they run our country. One should ask about others wrongdoings.
@@thirdperson4705 1. law and order in Delhi is under amit shah, not aap govt 2. As far as Punjab govt is considered I agree they are not able to bring the peace completely in Punjab. It is jus a 9 months part. I guess we have to give them 2.5 years at-least. 3. Talking about infra in Delhi, they have the best govt schools, clinics.. I have visited one school in Delhi that cannot be compared with govt school at Karnataka at least. 4. Delhi govt budget is not in dept and the only govt which is not in debt(central govt is in debt). This happened after 2015 before that it was in debt 5. How can you elaborate the free fall situation in Delhi? I agree Punjab is in huge debt since last 15 years. And this has not happened in 9 months. Contrary to ur thought Punjab has not increased the loan after aap has come to the power 6. Talking about corruption, I can see majority of the mla and mps from the place I belong who come from bjp are both goons and corrupt.
@@pavanandagiganapati8179 I am not sure if you are lying deliberately or you don't have complete information but let me tell you this, AAP government has already borrowed 30,000 crore rupees in only 3 quarters of this year for Punjab.
She has forgotten to highlight one point that the center has not paid the state govts GST share, now the state govt does accounting on accrual basis and if center is not providing the funds how would they pay salaries.... GST ka unka share jab tak nahi doge to kaha se salary milegi states ka to share hadap rakha hai tum logo ne
Unfortunately Our beloved FM passing personal comment upon Member. As citizens we are expects Honourable minister needs to be focused on Economic issues instead of Personal allegations. And don't pass qualified accountant like personal skill issue in public. Shame on FM.
When Raghav is talking about inflation and unemployment then why is Nirmala mam is answering about the loan. We the people of india doesn't want loans, we want jobs and we want our states to plan to removesthe headed debts.
Raghav Chadha itni young age mh CA hai ✌🏻 Jawaan hai , Padha likhe log ki tarah baat karta hai, speaking and presentation skills bhi ache hai 🙏🏻 god bless young talented people like him
Still punjab is highest loan to GDP ratio and punjab is reeling under debt well highest debt in all the states.. and AAP has no answer to it.. so blame modi..
@@deepakmanchanda5196 haa congress ne usse 40% bada diya.. aur AAp ke paas koi scheme nahi hai kam karne ki.. RBI bhi warn karta hai ki freebies doge tho loan kaise kam karoge.. simple logic hai .. agar tumare credit card main 3 lakh bakaya hai tho tum.. swiggy se khana order karoge(here freebies) ya khud kahna banakar loan kam karoge.. jaayda loan main interest hi freebies ki cost k barabar hai.. tho kam kaise hoga?
FM speaks targeting one person while she fails to address the falling currency, unemployment and rising inflation. Raghav Chanda is one of the best ministers India has today. And it's a shame that FM chooses to mock the opposition party despite their own failures.
In what context does honourable finance minister Mrs. Sitharaman says that liabilities of Central government are coming down ? I see the specified no. shooting up and coming down by fractional changes, she should also revisit her Golden data before mocking upon someone's profession😐
Honourable Finance Minister tried hard to manipulate the reality and challenges but she doesn’t realise that what RC said was actually true and it’s clear in the minds of citizens. We are facing inflation and unemployment. Her reply to this issue is very embarrassing. Instead of arrogance she should display some maturity and seriousness to these rising challenges of INDIAN ECONOMY.😢
On one side you are saying Indian economy is rising. Rest of your statements come from andh-virodh. Inflation is all-time low in last 21 months. Unemployment increases because population increases exponentially. Proper population control has to be there to reduce unemployment rate.
See inflation has been very well controlled by RBI and it is within 6%(CPI has been brought down to 5.88% and WPI to 5.85% as she quoted) govt is also trying to brought down it's fiscal deficit within 3%. We are lot better placed than Other world economies where inflation is in double digit. If you don't believe govt. Look World Bank's projected Nominal GDP growth which is revised to 6.3% which is fine compared to rest of others. The situation is very bad worldwide. FM and RBI governer somehow steered economy in such conditions. They worked well and deserve some consideration from us. Yes unemployment is all time high we can't deny that. But govt. Can't give everyone employment, it is impractical. Also subsidy issue is very apt. If all the taxpayer's money go into developing infrastructure instead of Giving freebies then Growth and Job opportunities will grow. For that Govt. Also budgeted high Capital expenditure previous year and Do even in upcoming budget also, to support growth. Adhaar has made our lives easy in many Ways. Same is the case with UPI. After some days you will see even digital rupee(retail) in the market. Govt. Is working but it just cand't do magic in a day.
@@Un-broken Tell me one country that are not facing challenges in economy. Because of Globalisation, the entire world is connected by one way or the other. Today, from developed economies to underdeveloped ones, every country is facing challenges in economy and it will rise in coming future because of many reasons. But what matters, how well you prevent the economy to become worst. E.g. UK has seen 3 PMs in half year just because of economic blunder. In a globalized world, you can't expect that India will be safe and secure from the world happenings.
The difference is the FM gets numbers from the press and media which is actually their data. On the other hand Mr CA has the data from the right sources... Not at least from the godi media..
UX Reasearch a share market computerising system They say AI replace UX While designing forms investors feed, if the product raw material availability details needs to be fed only then needed controls to get input will be visible or enabled
Whatever explanation you give madam, tell common man like us, whether prices of essentials increased like anything in the last 5 years. We middle class and poor people are living with great difficulty during this high inflation regime
Amma we miss u love u from Uttar Pradesh Ghaziabad my eyes still got tears when u watch u I wish u her enlightenment forever do not take any birth amma u should be free from circle of life 🐼🐼this Indian panda loves u Amma thank u to born in India
Piyush Goyal though a CA could not sustain as Finance Minister we all knew... Raghav wasn't mocking anyone madam, rather you mocked million with that Onion jibe.
Udhar card is real lol. What happens to people after taking such loans, they get harassed by recovery agents if they are late or missing to pay EMI. People like Chowksi, Mallya, Bhadana, ABG shipyard. Just get their loans written off by the government and bank boards.
Dear respected, honourable and beloved Finance Minister Madam, at first namesker. Great work and great job for this Country (INDIA).I once again namesker to respected, honourable and beloved Finance Minister Madam. Thank You Madam!" JAI HIND JAI BHARAT"
Although Nirmala sitharaman is good in debates her financial performance is too much lacking. She instead of taking more people in income tax or increasing govt revenue has opted to squeeze the middle class even further.
Too much of lecturing, with reports given by officers. Ask her, why per capita income decreases, when GDP increases? Madam, could you please answer, how the GDP is calculated?
Under bjp india's fdi is at all time high,under bjp many manufacturing units are coming in india,be it in semiconductor, mobile units and many more,compare with total companies and manufacturing units from 2014,more emphasis on infrastructure be it inter,intra and border.This is what they have achieved not like 'revdival'i mean kejriwal.
IMF and World Bank report on india's economy says what,do you have any idea or just free water which is the only thing that aap and kejriwal can do and nothing else they have no vision.Even jds from my state can do better than him and his party.
@@bazigar9380 According to government's official data 9 lakh Indians gave away their citizenship and move abroad since 2014. According to BJP FDI was a threat to India and opposed when Congress wanted to allow 48% FDIs and soon after they came to power they allowed 51% and now it may be more than that. Btw I'm not from Delhi and not from any Congress ruled state too.
@@itsme-wn7gr Now you liberal leftist communist are the real andhbhakt. Finance minister proved every single claim false with proofs thatRaghav chadda claimed. she said go through numbers do research dhruv tatti ke chamche Raghav said inflation is high meanwhile numbers say that inflation is very low and also getting lower by time. As compared to developed countries like usa, European country ( again go and do research) our inflation is in very control. Budhijivi are so dumb they dont even understand what numbers tell. And also we were the fastest growing economy in this yrs meanwhile countries like UK had lost some economy (negative 1 growth). Keep frustrating Bjp is gonna be more stronger aap will just play politics on social media with you Budhijivi. Pichle bar 272 cross kiye Iss bar 302 seat aye agli bar 350 ayege. Kya Pata 400+ seats bhi a jaye. Tumhara hai social media pe bhok ke kuch nhi hone wala. Just look at Gujrat what happened vote share also got increased. Meanwhile social media just showing opinions of aap supporter. Wake up to reality. Modi jindabad 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🇮🇳
@@bazigar9380 exactly I also noticed they have no vision. Only free water, free electricity inhone itna karja Chadha diya bsdk usa ka debt to gdp ration dekha 120% India ka 60% bhi nhi hai tumhare pitaji ne intne project tax se complete kiye hai hote kya. Sara tax tumhare bap Dada ekbar hi collect krte kya loan Lena jaruri hai lekin apne terms and conditions pe bonds pe. (BTW aise bate Budhijivi ko kaha samjhne vo to sirf berojgarri, mehgai chill ate rehte hainchillao bsdk) aap politics start at social media and ends at social media. Social media pe kuch log pagal banaliye twitter bots kharidna se sarkar nhi banati beta. Is bar to 350+ jayegi bjp
U should be ashamed that u can't reach on her level and you better know you wouldn't be. I know she is not a bestest fm but with zero knowledge common u can make a comedian chief minister of Punjab but not m. Phil in economy a fm.
You become FM. She is taking good steps to steer our economy, doing heavy Capex to sustain growth, Doing asset monetization to fill up Fiscal deficit, Cutting corporate tax to incetivise Investment, these all will generate jobs. Infrastrcture building is not a one day job that you will see it's result quickly. It takes time. She is bit arrogant that i admit. But on rest fronts she is lot better than P chidambaram and Pranab Mukherjee. Try to see govt. Budgeting based on what work and reforms Finance ministry has done before pointing figure at anybody(FM).
@@mr.rachetphilanthrophist601 I have been watching her works from last one year. She is horribly failed in doing her work. Cutting corporate tax doesn't increase investment, instead Corporates use that saved money for their own purpose. Infrastructure building is happening but on other hand foreign debt of India is also getting skyrocketed. P chidambaram was far better than this lady. Also don't forget under her tenure, gov. imposed GST on basic food items too like Milk, Oil, Paneer etc. There is 18% GST on purchasing medicines(these all things put heavy load on middleclass person' pocket).
@@mr.rachetphilanthrophist601 lol good steps. 1)Cutting of 27 percent on corporate tax. 2) Putting GST milk, pulses ext. 3) Economy going down from 2014.. what more?
@@vickysharma9403 the dents only went up after covid not before that...and they have been coming down QoQ since late 2021. Secondly Cutting taxes does increase investment ever heard of laffer's curve u socialist
Mr. Venkayyanaidu while in opposition in 2013 shouted repeatedly to hike the exemption limit of Income Tax to 5 Lakhs in the light of inflationary trends and other reasons. No change till date. However, our politicians repeatedly prove their over-smartness in telling Cock n bull stories......!
This parliament members and minister s free of cost food free of cost traveling there are enjoying every thing free there is no chenge in there life caman man prablums poltisions not care the caman man prablums this veye of reply to parlament honorable f minister jai bheem
Nirmal gets angry as she can't answer questions. Old lady not matured enough, knowledgeable to understand economics. You are not qualified to be a accountant in a petty shop.
She said right, you are dummy who couldn't understand it. If two things are falling and, one is falling at faster rate, then that means former is rising with respect to latter. Now replace those two things with world's any currencies (one being our indian rupee). You will see indian rupee is rising against world's all currencies(except USD, which is cause for Every currencies fall in this scenario). So she said absolutely right, it is not that rupee is falling, but is dollar that is getting strong. She is a fine FM steering our economy lot better than Previous FMs like P chindambaram and Pranab mukherjee.
@@muktiprateekdas9769 it is making our imports costly. But at the same time our exports cheap. If we focus more on manufacturing sector and export more we can earn lot of USDs. That is why she is focussing on infusing High capex to strengthen our manufacturing sector. Recently, Foxconn and vedanta have started working towards making semiconductor fabs in gujrat. We will make Iphones(foxconn makes most of Iphone's semiconductors).
Very poor deflection skills by the FM. Raghav Chadha was clearly talking about the peak inflation this year, not this particular month. No answer on why the supplementary budget wasn't estimated in the beginning of the year. Only personal insults and bashing...
paji kise v desh di MSME kdi grow ni kregi je inflation wdhdi ghtdi nhi hougi tan, RBI ne 2.5 saal tak rates nhi wdhayi c jis krke inflation wdhi hai te hun continuously wdha rhe hai jisdi wjah nal inflation control ch aaye te aa v rhi hai agge nalo jo November da CPI dss rya h, je repo rate nu wdha te ghtaya na jawe tan stagflation hojanda jisdi wjah nal inflation tan ghat rhegi pr MSME sector grow ni krega, this is the logic
They make people fall for free schemes like free elecrticity, water, food,transport etc etc and doenst tell people where the money will come from and make states fall into more Debt. As long as there are freebies country will fall into more debts...
