Тёмный

After Postmodernism | 6. Metamodernism, Part I 

Brendan Graham Dempsey
Подписаться 7 тыс.
Просмотров 21 тыс.
50% 1

Finally, we turn to metamodernism, the most influential and wide-ranging paradigm for post-postmodernism yet proposed. This video covers the articulation of metamodernism by cultural theorists Timotheus Vermeulen and Robin van den Akker. "Ironic sincerity," "informed naivete" and "pragmatic idealism" come into view as the metamodern presents us with an oscillation between paradigmatically modern and postmodern attitudes.
⚡ Support my work on Patreon:
/ brendangrahamdempsey
www.BrendanGrahamDempsey.com

Опубликовано:

 

2 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 46   
@shepherdessofskymeadow
@shepherdessofskymeadow 3 года назад
What continues to intrigue me is how many folks are finding their way towards this kind of pragmatic idealism or informed naïveté without having the words for it, knowing why they're drawn to it or even being particularly conscious of the shift. It feels like a seismic force moving the plates beneath us. Truly amazing videos, they are so thorough and clearly explained. Great work!
@shepherdessofskymeadow
@shepherdessofskymeadow 3 года назад
@Lisa Kellar I haven't experienced any "uber-extra-wordism" personally - I like the insights I get from listening to the way others articulate things I've also experienced. Nothing wrong with conversation.
@kelechi_77
@kelechi_77 9 месяцев назад
Exactly it feels like the zeitgeist and culture is shifting into this metamodernist direction without people even knowing we are entering metamodernism
@immanuelcan3310
@immanuelcan3310 2 года назад
What I can't figure out is the WARRANT for the new optimism. It's well and good to say that Postmodernism is too negative and skeptical, even to the point of being unliveable and inhuman; but if Postmodernism had anything to communicate when it critiqued Modernism, then it's not possible to simply return to belief and optimism for no reason but that we find skepticism debilitating and unfruitful. The mere need does not create the warrant, the justification, the reasons-to-believe-again. It's just makes us needy. Something is still unexplained here; and the warrant for metamodern "sincerity" (while still "ironic") or "hopefulness" (however "guarded") is what's missing. Any new "Romanticism" still cannot be merely a brainless return to enthusiasms: not after Postmodernism, surely.
@immanuelcan3310
@immanuelcan3310 Год назад
@@KL0098 What an astute analysis. Yes, I agree with you. Very relevant. Thanks for your time and energies. Having read some Metamodernist theory now, (this is a few months after my initial response) I find that it's really just a kind of lame excuse for Socialism. It's actually nothing new: and honestly, I have to say I find its whole tenor and approach a little...sophomoric and faux sophistique, to say the least. It shares with Hegel and Marx the blithe confidence that it can foresee the utopian future, and dispense the wisdom that will get us all there. I marvel that nobody realizes how hopelessly pseudo-prophetic these movements are, or notes how utterly disastrous the historical legacy of these kinds of historicist dreams have proven to be. Nothing's been more disastrous to economies, and nothing even close to so homicidal. Metamodern theory, I have noted, comes off like a first-year undergad who's home for the weekend and is lecturing his parents over dinner with his eyes closed. It has that air of simplistic smugness and superiority. It's kind of an embarassing and naive thing, really. I now don't marvel that it hasn't really caught on. And I think we can all be rather thankful it hasn't.
@veronica_._._._
@veronica_._._._ 9 месяцев назад
​@@immanuelcan3310Great name, 2 great posts. Yes, metamodernism is a pose.
@HighlandUrgentCare
@HighlandUrgentCare 5 месяцев назад
Metamodernism begins the clumsy attempt to explain the life force as its edges begin to appear out of the dismal cloak of post modernism. There is an inexorable drive we call hope that is a fundamental quality of human essence. Our ability to push forward despite the odds, despite the setback. The gloves are off and the naivete of the Enlightenment vanquished forever and a at the same time the hopelessness of Postmodernism is challenged the force of the human soul on its mission moving forward. Language can only juxtapose the concept...This movement needs to be felt on a deeper more emotional and less intellectual level.
@tedshafer633
@tedshafer633 4 дня назад
The warrant is that the ontological emptiness of postmodernism is just toxic to the human soul. Without some type of sehnsucht the human soul will wither away to nothing.
@tedshafer633
@tedshafer633 4 дня назад
The warrant is that the ontological and moral emptiness of postmodermism proved toxic to the human soul. Without some sort of sensucht the human soul withers away.
@gorgeeshmorgee4660
@gorgeeshmorgee4660 3 года назад
Political post-postmodernism is exactly what I've been waiting for. I can't wait to see what's coming.
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 2 года назад
Video on this to be posted tomorrow!
@1rapsluchaczq
@1rapsluchaczq 3 года назад
ok, this is the best creator that i found this year
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
Thanks! :)
@patod4
@patod4 Год назад
Thanks for the video. I howeverfind the background music not helping you at all. We listeners are in the attention mode, concentrating on what you say, and so the music, which has nothing todo with your lecture, becomes distracting noise. You really don't need it.
@stin18x
@stin18x 3 года назад
Hey just wanted to say that I appreciate your videos. They are basically the only well-made videos on RU-vid covering the topics so keep it up!
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
Thanks so much. The encouragement is much appreciated. Helps keep me motivated. All the best.
@Dino_Medici
@Dino_Medici 7 месяцев назад
That thumbnail goes hard brother
@Mithoswashere
@Mithoswashere 3 года назад
Hey Brendan. Thank you for the video. Your video essays brought me into metamodernism and its a huge help to understand the current changes and themes in a variety of subjects (from philosophy to arts and so on)! I wish you well and hope you can gain more subscribers! Best wishes from Germany, Martin!
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
Thanks, Martin! I really appreciate it. Very glad to hear the series has been helpful. Thanks for following, and stay tuned. :)
@theselfishmeme1935
@theselfishmeme1935 3 года назад
I can't thank you enough. Your videos have helped me understand so much. Thank you so much for making them!
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
Awesome. So glad to hear! Thanks for watching. :)
@marcusanark2541
@marcusanark2541 3 года назад
This video really spoke to me; I'll have watch again a few times to process everything.
@jonathanwoodvincent
@jonathanwoodvincent 2 года назад
This all feels bodyless, tedious and quantized
@keencole
@keencole 3 года назад
I found your set of videos in the middle of quarantine. Im always looking forward to your content. Health and well being to you.
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
Thanks, Cole. Much appreciated. :) All the best to you and yours.
@zacnewford
@zacnewford Год назад
so basically modernism with the post (news). or postmodernism without the post (trash)
@MikeFieldsSculptures
@MikeFieldsSculptures 2 года назад
Great video! Nice to finally have some language to go with some of my thoughts on this. I wonder if oscillation is the only way for a union of the poles? Not sure time is necessary for transcendence and imminence to unite for example, and this union through time isn't really a union.
@veronica_._._._
@veronica_._._._ 9 месяцев назад
It's mental compartmentalisation, you can do it in anticipation of trauma or thru trauma. It's a maladaptive response to chaos, complexity and information overload.
@chrisf8898
@chrisf8898 2 года назад
It is refreshing to come across something new since being in University and writing/ thinking so extensively about post-modernism
@Zoee934
@Zoee934 2 года назад
in love with metamodernism
@moonlitseacapeandthedesert7167
@moonlitseacapeandthedesert7167 3 года назад
Thank you! Will recommend these series!
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
Awesome. Thanks!
@thembamabona9809
@thembamabona9809 2 года назад
Ahhhh.... the struggle to come up with a new, adorable theoretical label whereas what matters is acting&thinking sustainably (plantbased, public transport, 1child max), overcoming pervasive irony/egocentrism (being sincere & altruistic) and working towards inner peace (meditation/buddhism). Most of this can be achieved with spiritual practice (e.g. in the Buddhist tradition), environmental informedness and good literature. The academic grandstanding is quite unnecessary but entertaining....
@brandiemaddalena8793
@brandiemaddalena8793 3 года назад
I have really enjoyed your videos. Thank you! While I do understand you are relating the views of the metamodernist theorists, I question aligning Neo-Romanticism with this era, due to its overly didactic approach. This type of work does not foster the praxis of trust or respect needed in this era. We are past being force-fed meaning and instead crave the mutual respect that the viewers are able and willing the derive meaning for themselves in the way that best serves to find commonality. There are other lines of art that more clearly serve this new era, which allows the individual viewer to interpret through their own lens, but with the intent of transcendent and unifying experiences. I would ask you to consider investigating social practice as a form. Of course, view this form with an understanding that art has been processed through modernism and postmodernism, which brings art to a much broader scope of form than many people are educated to appreciate ( the folly of fragmentation and therefore loss in education, I suppose). You may also be interested in artists who work contemporarily to find art forms to speak of transcendence, unity, harmony, and ritual: Ann Hamilton, James Turrell, Louise Bourgeois, Richard Long, Bill Viola, TeamLab, Walter De Maria, Anish Kapoor, Wolfgang Laib, Tokujin Yoshioka, Olafur Eliasson, well, you get the idea. Not every work by each of these artists fits the bill for this conversation, but many, if not most do. I truly appreciate your work here and sincerely hope this comment is helpful.
@grantinvestments3159
@grantinvestments3159 3 года назад
Come to Boulder and galavant my good sir. A crew of quite adapt magic specimen has been assembled. The reveries are unmatched. Personal lodgings are already arranged. Come take a gander.
@kefka14
@kefka14 2 года назад
I feel that the oscillation also occurs between singularity and binary.
@ibrahimmorarech7396
@ibrahimmorarech7396 2 года назад
Thank you for introducing these illuminating ideas. Your presentations are just so effortlessly thought-provoking and engaging. please continue.
@AI-mg3hy
@AI-mg3hy 3 года назад
Hi! I just discovered this series and I binged it all yesterday. Thank you for putting so much energy into these videos, I appreciate all of this insight into metamodernism especially. What I wasn't expecting after watching your videos is the algorithm directing me to other videos people are making about metamodernism, namely videos by people who use these ideas to somehow rationalize their position as white nationalists. What the heck??
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
Hi. Awesome, thanks for watching. That's great. What isn't great is racists using metamodernism in the way you describe. It's something I've noticed too, and will be posting a video about this topic soon. Essentially, metamodernism is bound to be expressed politically, in both Left and Right forms. On the Left are folks like Hanzi Freinacht and Brent Cooper, who are doing really great work. On the Right are the sorts of things you describe. Metamodernism is expressing itself along the political spectrum, just as Modernism and Postmodernism did before. So that in itself is no surprise, even if some ideologies expressed via its ideas are repugnant.
@AI-mg3hy
@AI-mg3hy 3 года назад
@@BrendanGrahamDempsey thank you, I'm looking forward to that video. What I'm failing to understand is how this ideology connects in any way to metamodernism beyond a surface rejection of pomo, destroyer of worlds. From what I've been seeing there are people who are happy to have found a way to critique pomo without relying on the tired "SJWs are ruining art and culture" argument. For this particular subset of alt right youtubers, critical theory is the real enemy, and they are seeing metamodernism as a way to destroy critical theory with it's own set of tools. Paraphrasing one video I saw, they can use pomo ideas to destroy pomo ideas. That works, but it isn't really going beyond pomo. It's just more pomo. Does doing that while advocating a return to "traditional cultural values" make it metamodern? This is the kind of question I wish to ask these youtubers but I also don't want to interact with anyone populating their comments sections.
@BrendanGrahamDempsey
@BrendanGrahamDempsey 3 года назад
@@AI-mg3hy It seems, on the whole, like simple reactionary stuff dressed up in new lingo. It connects to the return of modernist idealism/fanaticism without embracing any of the pomo critique of those things. Without the latter, it's not metamodern as I understand the term, just sort of opportunistically hopping on the metamodern bandwagon, almost like a PR re-branding or something.
@ryanandrews2977
@ryanandrews2977 Год назад
Fantastic break down. Thank you
@raveltoexpand
@raveltoexpand Год назад
Wow this is well explained!!
@sethcronin
@sethcronin 3 года назад
Been waiting for this one for a while! Thanks for making such a complicated idea so much easier to understand
@aliadair390
@aliadair390 2 года назад
Blah blah blah whatever... and I love it, thank you 😊
Далее
After Postmodernism | 7. Metamodernism, Part II
8:37
After Postmodernism | 8. Metamodern Synthesis
29:30
Просмотров 15 тыс.
#kikakim
00:10
Просмотров 14 млн
Провал со стеклянным хлебом…
00:41
Why Do Movies Feel So Different Now?
37:35
Просмотров 4,7 млн
Barthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism
44:17
Metamodernism 101: What Does 'Metamodern' Mean?
8:27