of course no haters bruh hating on a 17 years old girl just because she have an amazing vocals ace of baby monsters and it girl of 5th generation go make good videos instead of wasting your time on some sh*t ewwww 🤢
Live singing can still be autotuned/processed live. And being a pre-recorded show means the audio can be further altered in post. This is the case for maaany shows, including YT shows like LMJ Service, Killing Voice, It's Live etc
@@zahraa4149first one was a cover video do you think some one would allowed Lip-sync in a cover it's 100%live and meaning of singing live is actually singing in your own Voice without any autotune think before commenting
@@Blackberrypinklove-z9y live singing just means you're actually singing instead of lip syncing. If you don't know that live vocals can be autotuned just say that. And it's clearly autotuned. Sure, if you were actually there listening to it you would hear the live vocals. But keep in mind that you are watching this live performance RECORDED. What does mean? It means the can autotune the vocals for the aired/produced version of the show Almost all live performances on Korean TV shows are autotuned regardless of how good the singer is. Masked singer, produce 101, I can see your voice, duet song festival Any show you can think of
@@zahraa4149 uhh!girl don't fight with me just go and check her dangerously cover you will see the audience also guess what your favs can't do that it not autotune first grow up kiddo they are showing their actual talent first go you don't argue with me also live means singing live in your own Voice without any Lip-sync and autotune but also if your favs do Lip-sync in live cover that doesn't mean every single Idol do the same ok every thing doesn't revolves around your favs gurll
@@Arffff03No it was yg evaluation so yg not allowed idols to use auto tune it's not any compilation it was yg evaluation they were choosed the final members
@@blackpinklover9126Stop being delusional everyone using autotune these days and it not something bad ...you have to accept the fact live can be autotune too
Babymonster don't need autotune nor do they use auto tune they use studio versions with no autotunes but autotune needs them. Edit: since ya'll getting so mad lemme clarify, every artist uses autotune for one or another reason, yes, it's not a bad thing, yes; BUT in the survival show even though it was heavily edited little to no autotune was used, the only thing it could've been used for was pitch correcting slightly. (There was little to no difference between the survival show and Ahyeon singing live only her pitch is either higher at times in lives or lower so it don't make a difference and they really don't need autotune other than pitches.)
the mic could have (slight) pitch correction - in both videos that is not saying it does (directly at least) but there is a possibility, plus i wouldn't be surprised sounds like i'm hating, i swear i'm not, just speaking the truth by highlighting the fact that it is a possibility
@@doesleeknowreallyknowthothe first one was autotuned. She sang it live but they posted the video on YT and pitch correction in some lines was added for better quality. And the second one is clearly live without autotune.
@@cannycounterIt wasn't, she was live in both and without any adjustments, the difference is that the first one had the instrumental and the other didn't.
@@mei_sulli lol it's very obvious that pitch correction was added. She sang it live during that performance but they added an autotune when they post it. The second is definitely live. Btw, I'm a baemon fan.
I really think it doesn't have autotune, since they are tests for the fans to vote on who stayed and who didn't (although YG decided later). Also, they sound the same only that one has an instrumental and the other doesn't. If they had added autotune to the test, why wouldn't they add it to the other one, if it's not even that important? But hey, everyone with their opinion...@@cannycounter
@@drealexter7251 They're simply breaking it down for the less knowledgeable audience. The true meaning should be vocal processing vs no vocal processing, but it's simpler for people to understand autotune vs none
Guys it can be live and autotune at the same time 😂 (Just wanna say I'm not hating on her! I think she's talented! And she doesn't need autotune. I'm just saying it's most likely autotune and live-)
@artur4469 then why in the other clip did her voice sound a little shaky? Don't get me wrong, I think she's a beautiful singer and she really doesn't need it.
@jharmlee8353 I'm not a hater for pointing out the obvious lol- If you listen to the none autotune Clip, her voice is shaky, and that's okay. That doesn't take away from the fact she's a very talented singer. She doesn't need the autotune
@@simplenerdbreathing9110 that's because the first one have background music but the other one doesn't have any back track. They both are live clips. She slayed in both omg❤😊
first one is live but has some light pitch correction and effects like reverb and compression applied in post to smooth out the sound. not autotune but processing yes
Wow so good! Has a nice control of her voice and can hit those high notes! Really impressive and even though the first one was not autotune, she still slayed in both😊
@@Xian_Li847actually I don't completely disagree with you. the first was definitely edited with pitch correction .but the difference between auto tune is that with auto tune is that it's used at the same time the singer is performing and since it's a evaluation that means yg wouldn't allow auto tune so likely instead of using auto tune he probably listed to her completely unedited voice himself but edited her vocals with pitch correction for the viewers and that's completely fine if that makes sense
@@HelenBarnes-np5dr It was never cleared that YG does not allow autotune in evaluations. I don't know how people got that idea, it is used in evaluations. But then again, it could have also been pitch-correction, but edited afterwards. Still, it seems more like auotune than editing to me.
Imagine your singing voice being so perfect that even those who hate you have to find ways to think that you use autotune 😂 You can say anything but I think if you want to test your ears just go to their fan meetings. Dear
most mics these days have pitch correction and other autotune-y stuff which i think the creator is alluding too i'm not hating, i like bm, but ig there is a possibility that there is slight pitch correction in the mic - in both videos that is
I'm a baemon fan, but the first one has some pitch correction which is also an autotune. Ahyeon sang it live but yg added pitch correction when they posted it on YT.
Go stay in your own bubble then. I personally think that it's not a shame to use certain sound engineering to produce better sound quality and I also don't think it makes them any less talented. It's just the "reality".
@@jisung1399 Agreed, nothing is wrong with some slight embellishment. Its not like they're completely changing her voice or anything, its just a tad bit cleaned up. The girl can sing damn well regardless lol
We know in program like that they modified the voice to appear more clean and I think it compliment her voice, even without autotune it adds more character. She has talent it's undeniable ✨
Both of them are freaking live. What are up to????😂😂😂😂😂 Ahyeon just blushed at the second verse. That's why she was kinda out of tune. Please don't spread fake news. 😢😢😢😢
Hey!! The first clip was originally live but has post-production added to ensure the highest quality before posting the video online (mostly to protect the artists from hate since most recordings are “perfect” on the internet)!! It’s a mix of both and definitely has people confused, but I’ve worked as a recording engineer for things similar to this and it’s just what happens!! Hope this helped~~ ❤
That’s also just the music industry standard across all cultures and is almost always required to do for sound technicians/engineers when working with artists.
For the last example I’ll give, you can insert the first recording in any pitch-correcting software and it’ll show all the pitches either perfectly in pitch (called cents, which the absolute perfection would be 0) whereas the second would be quite a bit off (flat and sharp in pitch was inserted in the software). It’s the best way to check whether the post-production took place or not.
😂 people still trying to hate on one of the future stars of KPOp.... Ahyeon does not lack in VOCALS, RAP, DANCE, STAGE PRESENCE OR VISUALS ... THE GIRL IS THE REAL DEAL. MULTI LINGUAL, MULTI TALENTED PRINCESS❤
Honestly i just close my eyes when listening to someone sing. It lets you focus on the actual sound of their voice. She sounds EXACTLY the same! I just hate how toxic the KPOP industry is. She's got real talent but in a viciously destructive industry.
why is everyone commenting in Defense of her like Autotune is some bad disgraceful thing? Many artists use pitch correctors etc just to polish love vocals, happens all the time and is definitely not uncommon. I see nothing wrong with it anyway
first one is live but has some light pitch correction and effects like reverb and compression applied in post to smooth out the sound before being aired. not autotune but processing yes, this is totally normal in sound engineering
Idk why people are mad about the auto tune. Its obviously autotuned in the first one. You can tell by the weird metallic sound. Its likely just pitch correction but that's not a bad thing. She's obviously talented, so why but mad at the pitch correction.
The video on the left also doesn't use autotune, don't make videos like this if you don't know the facts. They do monthly evaluations before debut, obviously they perform live
do you even know what autotune is?. lmao if yourr not a producer then don't state stupid,. Also, as u said "facts".. ? where are these facts from, source?. like wtf. Y'all fans are crazy dillusional, It's very obviously autotuned
why are people so defensive against auto tune... its not like if its autotuned the voice is fake, its still good, it just makes it better especially for live performances
first one was an evaluation (if i remember correctly) so it was probably 100% live when done in front of the yg company. but because they are posting online they definitely added post production to perfect it for viewers. great vocalist tho 🫶🏼
Sigh.. so many comments with people thinking autotune has anything to do with a singer singing live or not. At this point it's like the entire Kpop community is fishing facts out of their asses. Pitch correction, Autotune (not the only preset able to do the job btw) may happen in real time, with a delay or in post production. It's just one effect out of many, reverb, compression, delay etc are important too. So for all of you able to take facts without getting your ego hurt, learn that, remember it, and there you go, you're out of the douche club. You're welcome.
She never used autotune ❌ You all need to know that autotune is just a program. If she didn’t sing off the key, flat/sharp, autotune doesn’t matter at all. A word you should understand is Equalizer. If you sing with equalized effect, it’s not called autotune. I think many people misunderstand about these.
She still sounds good even withoutout autotune tho. Not even a Kpoper, but I always wonder why you guys (biased Kpopers) always hate on some idols (especially girl idol) even they did great job 🤔
