All I Ask of You - John Cudia, Beth Southard, Gary Mauer 

Gary is by far one the the best Phantom’s, I only wish there were more clips available on RU-vid.

All of their voices are beautful! They're all extraordinarily talented.

The way her voice sort of echoes at the end of “soar” is absolutely angelic

Gary has the greatest Phantom laugh of all time. He is in my top 5 Phantoms.

Cudia makes an awesome Raoul! Love their voices together.

So handsome and that voice!! ☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆

Fantastic!!!!! I almost cried with the Phantom in the end

Wow... this performance left me speechless.

I forgot how much I love Gary Mauer. One of the best Phantoms ever. He is a such a vocal beast. His voice had all the colors necessary to handle this role. He could be intimating and imposing, while also being incredible tender and vulnerable.

Such a good cast!

That chandelier crash... damn!

I love John Cudia so much as the Phantom but he's a great Raoul too!

i would soooo kiss john cudia:) hes a perfect phantom and raoul!

Ah! It's a beaded 'Countess' gown before the company switched to brocade. Absolutely stunning costume- it's my favorite out of all of them!

I wonder how Gary felt when they performed this scene?. remember, he and Elizabeth are married in real life, I can only imagine how uncomfortable it is for him to see his wife kiss another man, and he has to act jealous and heartbroken about it. I wouldn't be surprised if in real life, he had a discussion with Elizabeth about this scene, and whether she can give him some reassurance

Unpopular opinion.... these 3 were better than the 25th ann.

John Cudia, it's in the title of the video.

Wonder what was going through Gary's head during All I ask of you and the reprise? Haha

I should! I thought there was all the proper tags there, thank you for seeing that!

You wouldn't happen to have the full 2 hr recording of this would you? If so, please post it. Thanks!

The chandelier is supposed to fly onto the stage?

you should add some more tags!

Too bad John's back is to the audience for a lot of this clip.

Mauer kills me =(