@@Ophelia_Pain your telling the person who’s posting these videos what to do, that’s not your job or your right, he doesn’t work for you, yes that makes you entitled, and what makes you think you know what generation Im from 🙄
Most teachers would be pretty happy if everyone knew everything already. If it is literally everyone, you are basically free to teach whatever you want at that point.
I think the lesson is that they may have known the facts, but there's way more to art (and life) than just names and dates. Art invokes your imagination...your emotions. And you can't understand that by just reading and memorizing the textbook.
@@jessicawilde4530 Yeah, though most place still require you to learn specific things. So if you fulfill the requirements right away, it gives you the freedom to freely explore those other things you mentioned.
Most art history classes would discuss a lot more than just the name of the piece and where it was from. It would go into composition, form, line, detail, construction, and then discuss it's importance in the context of the history of the time period so you get an understanding of why that piece is still important today.
I'm sorry, but I would NOT be flummoxed by my students getting ahead of the lesson plan. I would be EXCITED by it! An entire CLASSROOM full of students digging into the subject for which I have the passion to teach? AWESOME! Let's move on to the advanced material! How many of you are interested in this subject as a profession?
When I was in class 1, my teacher reprimanded my mother about me studying chapters of her class way before the normal school schedule. Apparently I was looking outside the window because the class became boring as hell. I don't blame my parents, they weren't much aware themselves, but I would have been saved a lot of time had they continued with this. Heck, I may have completed my syllabi of future classes beforehand.
@@DeathnoteBB It was a different time period. This movie was set in the 1950’s and the role women had in society at that time was vastly different to today. I don’t think you’re aware of what “time periods” can apply to, or what the 1980’s looked like lol. 🤦🏻♀️
Any real music would be copyrighted. Though, this is a clip from a movie so it is probably already copyrighted anyways. So yeah, stop using this music.
I’m sick of people dubbing in music over completed masterpieces. No one would add new paint touches to Starry Night. No one would put a mustache on Mona Lisa. They usually use the same three or four tunes, snd keep the volume so high that we can’t hear the dialogue. They need to learn that silence can be an important element in a movie or play, and what doesn’t get said or played speaks volumes. I’ve immediately blocked some creators entirely because of their overdubbed music. So if it’s required, as one of you said, they’re defeating themselves because I won’t watch it and block them entirely. They “shoot themselves in the foot” and lose my attention forever.
Human intellect is far beyond. We are extremely intelligent! Our brain is the most intelligent tool . The saddest part is that we can’t use it at it’s maximum potential 😊
@@elenairannezhad648 Who fed you this garbage? Ever since real-time brain imaging became common, it's been proven that our entire brains are engaged and used, by everyone. The notion that we typically only use 10% of our brains is completely fabricated -- Debunked -- as an attempt to appear knowledgeable about a subject that few had any insight into.
For everyone questioning if her lecture was just going to be naming slides of artwork… She *was planning to discuss the works in detail. Including why they are important, what impact they made on humanity as artists & the role they played in documenting history etc… However, she pretty quickly realizes that the students have already read the entire textbook and therefore know all of these talking point already. So she doesn’t have anything else planned since it was the first day of class. In other edits they keep the extended clip of Kirsten Dunst’s character explains why that particular work is distinctive from others of the period. This is literally just an *edit. If you’re critical/curious about it, then watch the movie. It’s not super long, and very good. Hey, you might even like it. 💁🏻♀️
to be honest in a situation like this i would assume the students conspired together and each of the 20 or so students memorized their own 1/20th of the book to fool the teacher in hopes of just getting all the boring unimportant lessons as free study time instead...
What I love about this more is the casting directors intentionally casted look-alikes in one film. Kirsten Dunst, Maggie Gyllenhaal, and Julia Stiles. I was so thrilled they thought of that and I love them all! ❤❤❤
I've Always wondered what the purpose of that lecture was. Ok, so they can identify the paintings/art. Great. But its not a quizshow. I'm sure the professor has more to say/ask/discuss about the individual pieces?? 😂 (Yes i know it's a film 😋)
I think it is because they read and memorized and learned the ENTIRE curriculum. She has nothing of substance to actually teach them at a college/uni level. So she's freaking out a bit You don't need to sit for hours to listen to a professor make commentary😅
She's just first time at doing lecturing, it's normal to get know whole students' knowledgeable. Then later she ended up teaching valuable lesson that made them respect her afterwards.
As an architect student, i have art history, and boy do we only discuss the absolute little details about the time, civilization, the concept, the style, the materials, the artist or architect, the reason, the influence... Oh and we also learn the names😊. Well done they portrayed the class by only one fact we learn 😂
that's fantastic, you have class full of students who have a steady grasp of the base text to your subject. your now free to teach more complicated and advanced topics for the rest of the term
Not for nothing, I remember signing up for art class in high school, thinking it was going to be an easy “a”. Didn’t realize they were actually going to ask us art history questions and shit.
I know most of these lovely actresses from other films so it was odd to see the girl from 10 things i hate about you, snow white from once upon a time and julia roberts all together.
No, they are just studious. They're smart students but they're all set up to be wives of future powerful people. I like the movie. You should watch it to see the twists.
I thought they did it to get the lectures off. They learned the curriculum ahead of time and then in the first lecture, one of them asks if they can leave if she has nothing else to teach them, probably assuming that would work for each lecture. Later on, one students remarks that married students are not expected to be there for every lecture if they are on their honeymoon, so, they don't expect their teachers to be able to teach them more than they can learn on their own.
I hate it too, but its meant to avoid AI performing an auto take down of a movie clip, via the DMCA strike system RU-vid has in place. This song is royalty free, therefore AI doesnt recognize it as copy written material and keeps going.
Dedicated students are awesome. What I would have done after this is ask each student to write an essay on a piece of art, explaining its significance and critique of it. It's a good way to see if students have an understanding of the subject instead of just memorization.
I almost thought about Lorraine Warren who was also an amazing woman. She was a renowned paranormal investigator and clairvoyant medium. Her and her husband both helped a lot of people. "The Conjuring" film was based on their work.
If the point of college is to prove you’ve been exposed to some stuff and that you can learn facts, and let’s be honest, that is the point of much course work, especially generals, then give the final tomorrow and be done with it.
Yes, that is why in Afghanistan a we always got text books for all our subjects about 15-20 days after we got our final report cards so that we could study independently in our own time during 2 and a half or 3 months of the holidays before the start of the next school year and be prepared. And if some students who were fooling around and didn’t prepare during holidays they always had time to prepare a week of even a day before the new lesson because we had the text book with us until end of the final exams.
😊Fui professora por 26 anos da minha vida de 45 anos nesse planeta, A Terra. Eu lecionava varias disciplinas, e varias vezes eu pegava algumas " turmas assim" como essa do filme. Os argumentos era quase os mesmos do filme, e entao eu ouvia pacientemente: "Nos comemos os livros de cafe da manha. E fazemos aulas extras em cursinhos fora do colégio. " - Mas o que eles nao imagivam e que eu era "a caixinha de Pandora" em pessoa.😂Eu nao usava o livro indicado pelo colegio o tempo todo. Eu sempre trazia comigo conhecimentos extras! Era um aluno me subestimar, e na aula seguinte eles estavam me xingando, porque eu trouxe conhecimentos que nao estavam nos livros que "eles teoricamente comiam no cafe da manha". 😂 Vai entender? Eu nao me deixava derrotar em nada! Sempre deixei claro que eu era um ser humano normal, e uma professora que nao sabia tudo. Mas que fosse qual fosse a duvida deles, se eu nao soubesse alguma coisa, iria pesquisar e trazer as respostas que eles precisavam para sanar todas as duvidas. E com isso, quando um ex aluno meu passa ao meu lado na rua, eles me param para conversar e dizer que as minhas aulas foram as melhores aulas das vidas deles, porque as minhas aulas nunca eram iguais!😂❤ E esse e o melhir elogio que eu poderia receber. Pois com isso eu percebo quantas vidas eu mudei direta e indiretamente durante os 26 anos de profissão como educadora.😊 E por isso, que eu digo que todo o profissional da educação e de outras áreas, todos merecem respeito. Pois o professora e o guerreiro da linha de frente! É aquele que ensina todos os outros para que possam atuar em outras profissões! 😊❤Deus abençoe a cada professor e prossifional.
No teacher likes pupils/students who learn the next lesson before it has been taught because they are showing off, striving for high marks but not for knowledge. This case us worse, they are being malicious to the young tutor. They don't know yet what is in store for them once they are out of Uni, so they are too proud.
I don’t agree. As a teacher It would be fun to listen to what they know and what I could learn from them in return. If they have already learned the lesson the only thing that I could do is to measure how deep their understanding is, challenge them and help them explore more about what they already know. Students actually appreciate it if their teachers wouldn’t feel threatened or jealous of their intellect. But instead celebrate it and encourage them to always push the wall.
Maybe some but not all. So saying no teacher is wrong. There are teachers that care about the child, as well as ones that don't. Granted it seems few and far between but that's because we live in a world where most people want to get into flashy jobs rather than the ones we need, hence why we are going to be facing a job crisis within the next 2 decades. Doctors and nurses being one of the first main ones. When I went to school most teachers cared about the majority of the class, and that's what they are meant to do. They aren't able to just focus on the few that do want to learn because as a child we all just want to mess around and not learn. It's odd when a child doesn't. There was only 2 support teachers that gave me the time so I could study extra subjects and study the current ones in a different area for the rest of my time at school. If a child wants to learn you have to guide them to get better learning, why else do you think home schooling is becoming a bigger and bigger consideration for parents.
I took an art appreciation class at a community college. The teacher had super glued her slide reel of 50 of the great works when she started teaching 12 years earlier. She became very flustered when I pointed out her slide of American Gothic was backwards and had been since she glued it.
Things were going so well.... The students showed that they prepare well and know their stuff. They could most likely have had a breezer semester, at least in that course, but Elizabeth darling had to spew out that condescending remark at the end. Yeah, that is soooo not gonna come back and bite them on the ass...
With a Mona Lisa Smile that rests upon the Notting Hill, chase after her love and she shall be the Runaway Bride that'll leave you to Eat, Pray, Love beside a Pelicans Brief.
With a Mona Lisa Smile that rests upon the Notting Hill, chase after her love and she shall be the Runaway Bride that'll leave you to Eat, Pray, Love beside a Pelicans Brief.
Knowledge of a teacher is not confined to what they teach in class, if the whole class knows the whole module, the teacher would be thrilled to discuss the art and their forms with them, not acting like they have seen a ghost
The comment section is full of comments saying why is Julia Roberts upset if the students already know the content? On the contrary the teacher should be happy about it etc. To clear your doubts watch the movie. It's a brilliant movie & then you'll know why she was dissatisfied with her students.
@@catherinemerrill5511 No, just a coincidence. This is a fictional movie that takes place in 1953 at Wellesley College. Senator Elizabeth Warren was only four years old at that time and graduated from University of Houston in 1970.
Is the purpose of the class just to memorize ancient art pieces? No depth into the styles or how they were made or reflections of the time and culture. just a memory game of said pieces? Not even a time era specific either from looks of things.
Elizabeth Warren is our US Senator, and she is an extraordinary woman! Fighting her entire life for women's rights and for families. Helping lift up those most in need.
I was a music major. I took a humanities class (required) thinking it was going to be mythology. The professor took a pregnancy leave. The replacement professor was an Art History doctorate. We had to learn paintings: artist, time period, name of painting. On our final there was one music question; who composed The Messiah? I didn't retain any of that art information. Oh, and mythology never entered the classroom.
