I appreciate your work on this project. Yaxşı gününüz var 😊 And here is a text in Khalaj to see if a Turkish person can understand it Asəmanda orda yulduzdur
Ässalomü alayküm qardoşım man özbekman siz hozır rostdan ham Şarqiy Turkıstondamısız aytmoqçımanki uyğurlar Şarqiy Turkıstondan turıb You tube platformasıdan foydalana olıshadımı bunga qarshılik bor ekan deb eshıtgandım
kardesim sunu fark ettim uygur Turkcesi Turkiye icin anlasilir bir Turkce yani sizi rahat anliyoruz ,azerbaycani da ,ozbek ve kazak kardesleri daha zor anliyoruz bize daha yakin olmalarina ragmen
Tüm dünyadaki Türkler Kardeştir. Bir zamanlar orta asya'da atalarımız hep birlikte yaşadılar fakat hayat şartları dünyanın değişik yerlerine göç etmelerine neden oldu.
@@oguz74000 daha çox Azərbaycan ləhcəsində yazmışdır. " Uyğurstandan bütün türk xalqına salamlar olsun, biz bir millətik. Yaşasın turan " Bu Türkiyəlilər bizi niyə anlamaqda zorluq çəkir. Biz azərbaycanlı olaraq hər türkü anlayırıq. 🇦🇿❤️Turan eli
Brezilyada her ne kadar Latin etkisi görülse de aslında yerli halk daha fazla ve kültürlerinin özünde Amerikan yerli kültürü çoğunluğu var. Bu da Türk/Asya kültürüyle neredeyse aynı. Birbirimize benziyoruz. Bizim burda buna "kan çeker" derler, anlamı "aynı kökten olan kişiler, akraba kanlar, birbirlerinden haberdar olmasalar bile karşılaştıklarında gariplik hissederler ve birbirlerine yaklaşmak isterler. Aynı kandan olan kişiler (en azından eskiden öyleydi) birbirlerine anlamsız bir yakınlık hissederler ve artık aralarında görünmez bir bağ oluşmuştur" Ben de Brezilya ve Amerika (Kuzey ve Güney Amerika) belgeselleri izlerken, işgal öncesi yerli halka aynı duyguları hissediyorum. Sanki kendi büyükannem ve büyükbabamı televizyonda görmüş gibi oluyorum. 🇧🇷❤🇹🇷❤🇭🇺
@@burock4965Hm güzel bir bilgi süzgecin var ancak ben brezilyalıları bir ırk olarak görmüyorum. Zamanında Portekizliler oradaki ırkı yok etti. Hiç soyu kalmadı diye biliyorum. O yüzden oraların kendine ait ırkı varmış gibi görmüyorum.
I'm a Tunisian living in Poland and I know that there's a minority of Tatars living in the north West of the country(near to Bialystok) I think you forgot to mention their language, otherwise great content and Turkic languages are one of my favourites
Yes they forgot mentioning the Lipska Tatars living in Poland for 4 5 centuries. Part of Kipchak branch. I think they are near asimilation with maybe only 1000 to 3000 still speaking this language close to Tatar
As a non-turkic I'm amazed how diverse and historically / culturally rich turkic peoples are. I discovered so many turkic peoples and languages in this vid. Keep going the quality is very good.
From Europe to Siberia, from Mediterranean Sea to icy Northern Arctic Sea, all these magically enchanting languages are spoken. Tengri is waiting for you to awaken the Infinite Oneness within!!!
Dostum videonun 8. dakikasındayım ve kısa bir ara vermek istedim.Sana kültürümüzü detaylı bir şekilde anlattığın ve Uygur Türkleri'nin yaşadığı zulme sessiz kalmayıp bu konu hakkında da değindiğin için teşekkür ederim.Videoda ki anlatım,arka planda ki müzik,zengin görsellerle desteklenmiş olması beni mutlu etti.Ellerine sağlık. Ne mutlu Türk'üm diyene!
Greetings from South Turkestan, this is very good information for you. Although there are great nations around us that are against our unity and want to kill us, we hope that all Turkish people will be more conscious of their brothers and sisters and become closer culturally.
In Uzbekistan, there are many nations living happily together❤ In my group at an institute, we have kyrgyz , turkmen and tajik people and we all understand each other and bonded as family members! We are best friends! O'zbekistondan salomlar!👋
This is a fucking masterpiece ! RU-vid must be greek for not putting you channel on every single person's fyp , i LOVE your channel , well done bruv consider yourself with a new sub
The closest relative languages to Türkiye-Turkish are Balkan-Turkish, Cyprus-Turkish, Gagauzian and Azerbaijani. Linguistic communication with each other is possible without any problems. The other Turkic languages become a little more difficult.
Всем Салам от Тюрков-Кумыков всем тюркским народам и всем остальным нас чаше всего везде забывают хотя предки кумыков хазары царство гуннов и тарковское шамхальство были сильными государствоми но такое поведение можно понять кумыков на земле около милиона человек не много и не мало
I’ve been studying Turkish the past couple of months and I think I want to focus on just studying Turkic languages from now on, they’re so beautiful and a very interesting family of languages. I’ll have to come back to this video in the future to choose one then.
Thank you so much. This is an academic level summation of the Turkic language family. It is delivered without any subjectivity and in a clear informative manner. Thank you againf or providing a source that can be used in any serious study of this fascinating language group.
The best video about Turkic languages I've ever seen! thanks RU-vid for recommending it to me and of course huge thanks to the author for making such great and difficult job! I've been to Türkiye in 2015 with my family and loved it!
Мен Қазақстаннанмын, қазақ тілін жақсы білмеймін, бірақ қарым-қатынас үшін қарапайым білімім бар. Мен түркі тілдерін әлемдегі ең әдемі тілдердің бірі деп есептеймін, түркі қыздары ең әдемі: олардың дауысы, көздері мен мінезі ең тәтті және мейірімді. Түріктер бірге болуы керек, өйткені біз бірге күштіміз. Алға, Қазақстан!
Really excellent video. I appreciate the smooth visuals along with the way you present the information in a very short yet full way. Most importantly, I appreciate the way you shine light on the Turkic people and often forgotten smaller Turkic languages ❤️ Keep up the good work brother
I was very proud and happy for this. Absolutely, your video is very valuable and precious, you have put a lot of effort into it and I can see it. I hope your video gets the place it deserves.
I have met two Gagauz people in real life. Their turkic identity is very strong. They cling on to it very hard since the pressure of assimilation by others around is very strong because they are christians by religion.
I am half Gagauz myself and from what I’ve seen their Turkic identity isn’t strong AT ALL. They’re heavily influenced by the Slavic culture and language. They prefer to speak Russian among themselves and they see themselves closer to the Slavic people. Maybe this doesn’t apply to all of them but this is my personal observation from my family.
@@tarakkiyot what does it have to do with me? I’m talking about my FAMILY as in my grandparents, aunts and uncles. They all feel themselves closer to the Slavics than to the Turkics and my other half is completely irrelevant on this matter.
@@karpuzvenar in your attempts to object you keep proving my initial argument to be true: Gagauzs are under immense pressure for assimilation. If that is the case, what would their natural response to this pressure, you tell us.
There other Turks residing in the Markazi province such as Shahsavans and Qashqai. these two groups also have strong presence in sorrounding nearby provinces such as Isfahan, Luristan, Qom ,etc. Most of the maps displaying ethnicities and minority groups in Iran are often inaccurate, depending on the person making the map it could be over exaggerated in favor of an ethnic group or an Ideology, like the city of Mahabad and west Azerbaijan province in general, some get ignored completely such as Turks in south eastern Provinces of Iran or Tat people.
I felt the same while I was checking the ethnic map of Iran. They are so different than each other and not very accurate. Language maps seem more accurate because they show the Turkic presence better imo.
@@turkchap True but A lot of them would still be left out since they do not use the language as much anymore even though they may consider themselves as Turks. More research needs to be done in order for an authentic map to be made and hence no proper research could be done bc of the political situation in Iran we have to wait until something happens.
@@arsc2576A lot of Turks in Iran have Persianized, "big Iran" mentality. Persian national chovinism is unmatched. Persians are one of the most chovinistic people on earth! I have talked to them personally!!!!
@@Apistoleon I can confirm this since A lot of my own family members and friends have this mentality and stick to it firmly unwilling to accept who they really are. Although Turks themselves are not completely innocent either, If you take a look at Iran's modern history You'll see a lot of first Iranian nationalists and ultra nationalists were of Turkic origin themselves (mostly descending from Qajar nobility and aristocrats).
Böyle uzun süreçli araştırmanın ve emeğin olduğu nadir kanallardansınız. Türkleri yurtdışına tanıtmakta da çok iyi bir iş yapıyorsunuz sizin gibi insanların olması beni çok onurlandırıyor katkılarınız ve emeğiniz için teşekkür ederim.
I love how you managed to make a 40 minute video essay without drowning us in useless information, and its served in such an easy to understand way. Ellerine sağlık ❤
Hey dude, even though I'm not of turkic descend, nor do I speak any of the languages, I really enjoyed this video ! It was super informative. I like your editing, it's pleasant to watch. Are you going to do something like this with other language groups ? Or is this only a turkic oriented channel ?
Hey man, thank you so much for the comment ❤️ Yes, definitely! I am planning to make a similar video for the Mongolic languages next and will keep adding other language families to the list. The focus of the channel is generally the Turkic languages and Turkic world, but on the side, I also make and plan to make content about various topics 👍 My aim is to keep the niche not too narrow
There are still so many peoples missing who do not speak TURKIC, but still, according to my thesis, they spoke TURKIC in the past because they were once TURKS.
Being a tatar can state that number of tatar speakers is less than it's shown here. I'd say twice. The status of the tatar language is far worse than vulnerable. Education in tatar and studying tatar as the second language is being cut by russians, language shift is wide spread, language spoken domens are just inside families. The correct status of all turkic languages (in fact of all non-russian languages) inside Russia is Critical!!
Heres something you may find interesting. :) The name of my country has nothing to do with the interesting and delicious bird 'turkey'...... .....but the name of the bird does have a connection with the name of my country, let me explain. :) In the past 40 years 37 countries have changed their name, partially or fully. Obviously one can not change the name of an apple or an orange etc in other languages, but country names are like peoples' individual names, so if you're named John we don't call you Karen. :) Name of my country has always been Türkiye, it's been known as such since around the 1200's. The name it self has a suffix, '-iye', that is Turk-iye, where the -iye suffix means 'land of/belonging to', just like the Latin suffix of '-ia', which exists in such country names like Austr-ia, Austral-ia, Indones-ia etc. Basically, the use of '-iye/-ia' is the same as the the use of '-land' suffix in country names like Ire(Eire)-land, Po(le)-land, Eng(Anglo)-land and so on and so on. Many would remember the country Czechoslovak-ia which changed it's name to Czech Republic and a few years ago changed that to Czechia (that is Czech-ia). The Latin suffix -ia probably originates from Turkish -iye as Turkish been over 10,000 years is much older than Latin which is around 1300 years old. Spelled in different languages in different ways to phonetically resemble (to sound like) 'Türkiye' we got various spellings like; Turq-uía (in Spanish), Turch-ia (in Italian), Turq-uie (in French) Turk-ei (in German) Turk-ey (in English) Mind you this was way before the animal we currently know as turkey was found by the europeans when they explored the north americas. The bird was first sent to europe from north americas in the year 1519, so up until that point there was no bird named turkey.... ...they came across the bird and thought it was a specie of the fowl/chicken they had been buying from the country of Turkiye at the time, so they named the bird 'Turkey Fowl' to define 'Turkish Chicken'... ....just like how a dog breed is known as German Shepherd (because it's from Germany), American Bulldog, British Terrier, Greek Harehound etc etc. In time you don't get to call the harehound simply as Greek or you don't call the terrier Britirsh, or shepherd as simply German, but in time the Turkish Fowl started to be called just 'Turkey' and later 'turkey', and this went on for hundreds of years. Now in modern times, this caused confusion, especially when we have people across the world unable to point to their own country on an atlas. Basically we didn't change the name of our country, we changed the mistake made in the English language. : ) So, there's some tid bit information for you to have a great day, if you read upto this point you have a great night too, ohh just have a wonderfull life. : ) Best wishes. ;)
bro how can you say latin is only 1300 years old when that would be after the fall of the roman empire lmao, and 10000 years ago no language from any where in the world was the same as it was now, so while turkic language may have been around that long ago you cannot claim that its the same as the turkish you speak today, lastly if you have anysort of evidence or proof to back up your claim that latin did take said ia- suffix from a turkic ancestor language I would be most interested in seeing it
Thank you for all this information, I guess that it's the result of a long and fine work. I am basque, and everybody in my country has a small linguist inside.
Azeri is also official in Dagestan and written in Cyrillic. I think you should could have mentioned every country and region where a language is official/used and script is utilised, you only did that sometimes. Especially with the introduction of Latin to Uzbekistan, the transition has been very gradual, and cyrillic is still as widespread. Cool video 😊
Hi! Thank you very much for this awesome and detailed video! Btw I would like to point out to a very small detail. Nowadays most linguists consider Southern Altai in Kipchak branch while Northern Altai in Siberian branch. So unlike the classifications made in the past, they are considered as seperate languages today. Soyot and Dukha languages are not included in the video, they belong to Siberian branch and they are spoken in Russia and Mongolia respectively. Tysm!
You forgot Turkmen dialect spoken by Turkmens in Syria/Iraq. It's generally included in the Turkish or Azerbaijani dialect but I think it's still a distinct one even if they are close.
great video! i am one of the azerbaijanis from kars, turkey and i can speak our native azerbaijani dialect at some degree alongside with standart turkish. unfortunately, since we are ethnic turks, exact number of azerbaijani community in turkey (which includes azeris and terekemes as the local people calls) is not recorded and is unknown.
Selam kardeşim ❤️ My grandfather’s side has Azerbaijani roots and the rest of my family is Anatolian Turkish. I grew up hearing him mix Azerbaijani and Turkish which was pretty fun! But like you said, since we are all Turks, Azerbaijanis are not counted separately.
@@Ayxan72 yes for our local dialect. i am also trying to improve my standart azerbaijani, they are a bit different because standart language has much more russian loanwords. instead we use istanbul turkish version of newer loanwords. but we also have russian origin words like kartof, istekan, işkaf, sımışka, çaynik
@@utkuduman4276 Nice, thank you for this. I love that some Azerbaijanis who are natives of other countries still try to not forget their language. This gives me hope for the future of this country. Birdə sənə əziyyət olmasın amma zəhmət olmasa mənə Azərbaycan türkcəsində cavab verə bilərsən😁?
@@Ayxan72 verebilerem elbette amma yazanda grammer sehvi edebilerem. onsuz da anamdan atamdan gördüyüm qeder az çox bilirdim. istanbulda yaşadığımız üçün her vaxt öz lehçemizde danışmırıq amma evde birbirimizle bazen danışırıq zarafat edirik. men de özü özüme daha çox öyrenmeye çalışıram. bizim kars lehçesi de eyni qazax, borçalı lehçelerine oxşayır
Out of all Turkic languages, only 5-6 of them have a future: Turkish, Azerbaijani (but they are 2 languages, Azerbaijanis from Iran and Republic of Azerbaijan cannot easily understand each other), Turkmen, Uzbek, and Kyrgyz. All Kazakhs are bilingual, and without an effort, Kazakh soon will be replaced by Russian. All Turkic people who live in Russia will not be able to speak their languages soon, they almost exclusively monolingual Russian speakers, they may remember some songs in their languages, but they don't even have their schools. I'm scared even to think about what can happen with Uyghurs.
