Amb. Carlson: Hindi basta-basta ang pagkasa ng Mutual Defense Treaty | 24 Oras 

Durog durog na Tayo Bago sila tutulong sa atin....

malabong dumepensa ang amerika sa pilipinas.. mas maigi talaga na palakasin natin ang sariling bansa at wag umasa sa iba..

hindi ko alam kung need pa na ireport ito o isa publiko. tayo lang yata ang country sa asia na puwede isa public lahat pati strategy and details of strategy pagdating sa mga bagay na ito basta lamang me maibalita.

To interpret what US Amb meant. You have a free meal. But in order for your to avail that free meal, you have to comply with this endless list of pre requirements.

we cannot rely on other but ourselves as nation

Mahirap tlga umasa sa iba kaylangan mag palakas mag isa ang pinas

Naku dadaan pa yan muna sa kongreso ng US bako ma activate, dadaan muna sa mga legalities

Remember that Russia didn't help Armenia despite having a mutual defence treaty when Karabakh was taken by Azerbaijan because it was a disputed territory like the Spratly islands.

PARANG BALIWALA PALA EEEWAANN KO SA INYO, BULAHAN LANG PALA ANG TULONG NG US 😭😭😭😭😭😭

Mukhang may proteksyon nga tau sa Salita nga lang😢😢😢

That means we need to allocate more budget for our defense di dapat umasa lalo na ang labanan sa west phil.sea pangmatagalan.

Nakaka awa tyo😢

🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭💪!!!

yung ibang bansa wala namang mutual defence treaty pero palag palag naman sila sa china coastguard

subrang mag ingat sa mga decision making pag ganito na at hindi ito basta basta kasi mga pinoy ang ma iipit. Israel nga na may Irion dome hirap parin sa depensa at ang ukraine na higit na may kakayanan kisa satin wasak parin. tayo pa kaya. Kawawa mga bata at mga pinoy. Hindi tatalab jan ang experties ng mga pinoy sa Jungle warfare.

Kaya nga daoat mag palakas yung bansa natin to depend the teritory

We live in a divided world and alliances is the best option to defend our freedom.

Hnd tayo umaasa sa lahat, dapat ipagtanggol natin ang ating bansa,,,magkaisa tayo para sa ating bansa

Hay naku, dito nga ako nagtataka sa mga Pilipino, di kayo nag-iisip. Akala nila ganun kadali. Ang tagal na ng MDT pero di pa rin nila alam ang mechanics. Aba, daig pa kayo ng China! They know exactly how it works! 1. First of all, the MDT can only be invoked if there is an ARMED ATTACK. Water cannons, lasers, the blocking and ramming of ships ARE NOT armed attacks! Even if China's Coast Guards decides to beat up Filipinos and PCG and PN crews with wooden sticks, it's not an armed attack! Di ba kayo nagtataka why China don't use guns? Against Vietnam, China did not hesitate to use missiles to sink their ships and submarines in a confrontation years ago. 2. Second, unlike NATO Article 5, the US-PH MDT is not automatic! It needs to be invoked and it needs concurrence from US Congress to decide how the US will respond. Expect at least a week of deliberations and politicking. 3. Third, the Philippines is the ONLY country in the world with a defense treaty wherein the supposed protector is 10,000 miles away. Wala talagang sentido komon mga Pinoy. You want them to protect you but you don't want them in your country. So how exactly are they going to protect you? By giving moral support??? The US cannot respond immediately. It will take 3-4 weeks before the US can assemble and send a carrier battle group to defend the Philippines. 4. S. Korea and Japan pays the US tens of millions of dollars to stay and protect them. No, the Philippines cannot freeload and expect the US to send forces from those countries. Mahiya naman kayo! If you want that privilege, then ask the US to stay in the Phils. and pay for it. You can't have your cake and eat it too. Huwag naman natin abusuhin ang Japan. 5. Finally, huwag naman iasa lahat sa US. They expect and want you to fight too. Problema kasi mga Pilipino gusto lahat libre! Puro bigay! You have to spend for your own defense! Credible and strong enough to withstand attacks from China for at least 2-3 weeks. E kung 5 minutes pa lang, China already destroyed Malacanang, Camp Aguinaldo, Fort Bonifacio, Clark and Subic, plus the only 2 PH Navy frigates and the 12 FA-50 trainer fighters that the country has, e ano pa ang dadatnan ng mga Amerikano????? Hahahahha

Wag aasa dapat preperado lng lagi,,

bakit di nlng sana tayo maggawa nang sariling sandata kaya nmn eeeh

Now you know

U.S. Congress should agree to take effect.

Salamat President Quirino para sa Mutual Defense Treaty --- isa sa mga founder ng LIBERAL PARTY OF THE PHILIPPINES

Wala pa nga arm attack yung gumagamit talaga ng baril o missile di pa pwedi pindutin yang MDT.

tubig plng yan wag kayung mag panic ,

Increasing Manila's defense budget could indeed be crucial for staying ahead in modern warfare and ensuring effective protection for the country. Relying solely on external support, particularly from the US, might not always be feasible or sustainable in the long run, making independent investment in defense capabilities imperative for national security.

Wala tayong aasahan kung hindi ang ating sarili america kailangan may kapalit ang lahat

Hihingi pa sila ng pasangayon ng senate at Congress nila bago maging epektibo MDT.

yan nga ba sinasabi, two big countries naghahatian sa territories U.S doing it with mutual benefit yung china naman doing it by force! mahirap yan pag magka away yung big countries na to! at U.S interest mostly sa America lang talaga.

Yan ang kahalagahan ng edca site dahil kung sakali lusubin tayo may time para maactivate ang treaty

Its time to review & ammend to clear or crystal clear the MDT & seal it to steel. changing landscape & new treat from enemy needs new & stroner pact.

Nawa'y mawala ang katiwalian. Ang "makapili" ay mawala na sana. Alisin sa grupo ang sinumang nagnanais na maging hari at pinakamahusay dahil ito ay hadlang sa pag-unlad... Ilaan ang budget at tulungan ang mga siyentipiko, inhinyero, at mga developer sa paglikha ng mga modernong armas, sasakyan, at eroplano para sa digmaan.

Nagbitaw na ng salita ang US. Case to case basis. Matagal na nating nakasama sa laban WW2 pa. May punto ang ambassador kaya dapat talaga maghanda at huwag padalus dalos ang Leader natin. Ang ibang may treaty agreement sa kapwa bansa hindi nangyari dahil nakita nila na match ang laban at supplies na lang ang binibigay. Ibig sabihin kakayanin ng kaalyado. Pero sa case natin na mahina tayo pwede ng manghimasok ang mas malalakas na kaalyado.

Pg ayaw dami dahilan,pg walang kapalit,,asa pa,,ng full suport

Maliwanag na wala tayong ma pala dyan wag na tayong umasa dyan dapat tulongan nating sa sarili natin di na tayo aasa pa mga yan puro lang yan pa asa.

IN SHORT, there is no MDT.

Let’s build our own military up. If our economy and military is a force to be reckoned with, like that of Indonesia (which has the largest standing force in ASEAN), then we wouldn’t need the US or Japan to come to our aid so much. They can support us, but they don’t have to carry us. The onus lies on our OWN gov to build our military capabilities to acceptable defensive levels. Imagine asking someone from 6000km away just to look after our own house because we can’t even look after it ourselves. it’s embarrassing.

What’s the reason if not treason? What were the deals? This one & prior to this? What’s the price of dealing for peace?

I don't like what I hear from the U.S. ambassador, yes correct this is not a simple case of giving aid or something, but at least I'm hoping to hear non-military measures from her, like what they did in the Ukraine scenario like economic sanction at least as punishment to China, like at least a warning, so that China should refrain from getting aggressive. Useless MDT, is just a show of force, nothing else. It would be better if PH accepted the offer of India, France, and Japan of a similar Defense Treaty, at least the Japanese showed China what they could do in the region, or France and India who are eager to have such a Defense Treaty to PH.

Gamitin nayan ang buster call

Wag umasa sa MDT dapat magpalakas din tayo

Public goverment at private agency mag tulongan sa defence ng pinas at mga inventor tulongan maimpprove pa ma mga makabagong defence ng pinas

If the US will not help us militarily, then we should change our course towards China and we should also start talking about the exploring the natural resources in the WPS for the benefit of both country!

😂😂😂sabi ko na nga ba tayo tayo pa rin ang magtutulungan...kaya wag na tyong umasa sa ibang bansa...pag nagka gipitan iiwan lng tyong kawawa sa ere 😢

mas ok pang umasa nalang sa sarili kaysa magtiwa na tutulunga ka pero pag nandyan na dun mo makikita pinaasaan kalang pala😅

Mahirap umasa dyan

Need pa aproval ng mga congressman nila qng ano lng action ggwin o anong gamit papadala, saka defense lang, kaya atakihin lng tayo ng atakihin pro ddpnsa lng tayo, after effect lugmok tayo lahat khit may ari kpa ng mga building, pwera nlng may mlking savings k sa ibang bansa. Tingnan nyo nlng lugar n myman nagka gyera.

defense treaty invoke automatics some people vessels attack by enemy some county territory treager of war

To the American government thanks a lot for helping our country. Mabuhay ang Pilipinas and America GOD BLESS for both countries 🇵🇭🇺🇸🙏👍

We need "Philippine Defense", period- Not Treaty, and No To Treason

Tama yung sinasabi ni Marcos Sr. Tsssk

Kaya kailangan natin gumawa ng sarili natin armas para hindi tayo inaapi ng ibang bansa, parang katulad ng south korea maliit na bansa pero napakalakas na bansa they are in no.6 in the world when comes to military power.

Maactivate lng yan kpg may nagpAlipad na ng missiles either Pinas or China

It will not happen. US will probably just give support through Equipment or Finance but not US soldiers. It will not benefit US.

Document pala,,

👁️

Thank U.S.A for helping my country Philippines

It's better that Philippines is under US colony territory again so our country is protected and people not poor because of kurakot❤ganda p buhay Filipino kc US dollar pera

Mdt will take effect if the Philippines already invaded

Kasi Europe comes first. The agreement between all allied "super countries" hasn't changed at all. During WWII, Nazi Germany needs to be stopped first and then help the folks from the pacific. Also, think about it. what do we export that makes us an essential country? why do they need to make us a priority? We are known for exporting 1 thing and that's OFWs.. but there are excemptions, Look at Taiwan, they have superconductors, Eletronic parts that are essential to every nation. That's why they're more focused at them instead of the Philippines.

Ewan ko bakit ipinapaalam pa sa mondo ganitong bagay nalalaman tuloy.🤔🙄

Dapat alam ng national defense treaty, at AFP chief natin kung ano ba ang mutual defense treaty na yan. Kung anong klasing tulong ba ang gagawin nila kung magpapadala lang ba sila ng armas o pupunta mga sundalo nila dito para tumulong.

ipapasa pa yan sa congreso ng amerika bago aprubahan ang MDT. ginigyera na tayo, sila nag dedebate pa kung tutulongan tayo

puro kase asa sa iba ganyan din nangyari sa pakistan date ayun sumuko sa india dami pa tumulong dun, ngayon nagsarili na sila alam kasi nilang wala ding tutulong sa kanila sahuli kundi sarili nila

Tama nman si ambassador.

nag ppatayan na ang mga tao sa WPS. n/pagddebatehan pa yan sa US congress kung to help or not, join or not 😂😂😂

The issue is that, bakit hndi pa natin e girahin Yung china. Kumpleto Naman Tayo sa war vehicles + allies

and still the winner is 🇺🇸

asa kayo sa us

bibigyan nyo ng sandamakmak na base dito sa atin tapos pahirapan pala humingi ng tulong!

so how strong is the treaty of the US Ambassador gives a vague answer like that?

Wag tayong umasa sa mga kaibigan na bansa.. ang gawin magkaisa lahat ng mga pilipino palakasin ang sandatahang lakas ng pilipinas . Bumili ng mga dapat na kailangan pang depensa

Translation: Di namin kayo tutulungan, bahala kayo sa buhay nyo.

Kawawa ang pinas kung hindi pala maaring ikasa ang treaty

Turning your back and walking away from a hostility is the best defence ika nga nila. Seems like the MDT is what Carlson exactly describes.

Grabe n talaga ung china

pag sa taiwan, japan, south korea wala ng debate yan sa u.s kongress automatic na idedepensa nila yan pero sa pilipinas pag iisipan pa.

Ayan kasi nasobrahan sa tapang sa social media wag kayo umasa masyado sa America kasi may mutual defence treaty tayo sa kanila baka pagnaka gera na dito yung mutual treaty na pinagmamalaki nyo ay pag dedebatehan payan nila habang tayo nakikipagpatayan na kaya isip² rin wag sobrang tapang

Wag aasa sa mga dayuhang kaalyado tandaan nyu yan. Tayo mismo ang magdadala ng watawat natin pagdating sa gera.

Sabi lang yan kapag imminent and clear present danger na pwede na mutual defense treaty. For example in case of invasion of Taiwan kapa pumasok ang China sa Luzon strait may base ang USA sa parteng yan act of war na iyon sa USA mutual defense treaty ay pwede na

Ano naga talangka na pinoy gusto pa ninyo umasa sa U.S be wise sana tayo wag pa daloslos nang aksyon . Palakasin muna natin ang pwersa natin. Dami ma damay na kabataan pag nag ka gyera na .

Correct...Existential condition demanded for Edca to activate that is...if and only if the national security of both sides is breach as in an invasion by an aggressor state.Bruises due to confrontation or skirmish with an opposing nation may not trigger its instant activation...Judgement call is called upon the theater commander who qualifies that condition...so lets be content in playing this parlor game with the creepin panda until the time loses water in their pond...😢

Kelan pag meron nang namatay na ng pilipino??😢

Hindi pa kasi pasa sa "Act of War" criteria ang ginagawa ng China.

Dyan lang naman umaasa ang bansa natin sa MDT.

Hopping Amb. Carlson is reading the comments here.

Magaling talaga c Duterte..alam niya agad sa MDT kaya sinabi na niya dati pa

Kailangan pa mag agree ng US congress while if the philippines is invaded

iniwan Sa ere mangyayari nito hahaha

Hindi obligado na tulungan ang pilipinas... Kaya nga pinoy na ayaw maipit sa gyera lumikas na... Pero kami lalaban kahit walang tulong kahit kanino

Ilang panahon ng island country ang Pinas. Di man lang nag come up ng sufficient naval prowess. Nakakabobo na lang.

02:51 - umiwas sa tanong yung ambassador. Hindi man lang pinilit or nag follow up question si Pia sa tanong niya about "Chinese military preparing for war". Pero ang point ng tanong, naghahanda ang Tsina para sa gyera dahil sa lumalalang tension da SCS/WPS, kung saan Pilipinas ang tatargetin nila. At ano ang gagawin ng US kapag naapektuhan ang Pilipinas ng Chinese aggression dahil merong Mutual Defense Treaty. Yung sagot ng ambassador walang pake ang US kasi di naman sila agresibo sa China. So hindi exactly nasagot ang tanong kung susundin or iho honor ba nils yung kasunduan ng MDT satin. Wala man lang ka challenge challenge at di man lang nahirapan yung ini interview niyo. Taasan sana ng GMA ang standards sa pagtatanong kapag mga high profile ang internview. Tignan niyo mga journalist sa US,UK at other EU countries, pinu push talaga nila yung mga ini interview na sagutin ang tanong kahit panay iwas yung mga pulitiko.

kelangan mo niyo pa bang ibalita to?

This only means na hindi padalosdalos ang pag desisyon, i dont see na hindi tutupad ang America. Nagiging maingat lamang ang ating bansa at ang America sa pag gamit ng MDT.

tubig sa tubig laban tayu bombahin dn sila ng tubig,

we have failed to develope as a country

existential threat is much more of an invasion level threat imo. should there be any casualties sa WPS, i think hindi magiging sapat yon to enforce MDT.

Maubos muna tayo bago ma activate yan pinagmamalaki na MDT...

Muntik ng ma revise ang treaty noong nakaraang administration? Tama ba?