Тёмный

An Impossible Job or Grounds for Optimism? 

Economics Help UK
Подписаться 52 тыс.
Просмотров 24 тыс.
50% 1

Labour have a big majority, but what kind of economy do they inherit?
0:53 Problems Facing Government
3:44 Reasons for Optimism
7:00 Reasons for Pessimism
9:42 Questions on Housing
10:36 Question on Min Wage
► Please SUBSCRIBE!
► UK Economy - www.youtube.co...
ABOUT
-----------
► www.economicsh... was founded in 2006 by Tejvan Pettinger, who studied PPE at Oxford University and teaches economics. He has published several economics books, including:
► Economic Short Cuts amzn.to/3IgxupC
► 50 Essential Economic Ideas amzn.to/3IgxndG
► Cracking Economics. www.economicsh...
► What Would Keynes Do? Amazon amzn.to/2xShqq4
► Economics Without the Boring Bits amzn.to/48T1hA9

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 355   
@winthorpe2560
@winthorpe2560 3 месяца назад
We have been in a per capita depression since 2008. Remove £15 billion deficit spending per month and there is zero gdp growth.
@stephfoxwell4620
@stephfoxwell4620 3 месяца назад
The lost decade about to enter it's 17th year.
@graemebarriball303
@graemebarriball303 3 месяца назад
@@stephfoxwell4620along with another 700,000 pointless immigrants.
@stephfoxwell4620
@stephfoxwell4620 3 месяца назад
@@graemebarriball303 That's Net. We let in 1.35 million and 600,000 leave.
@graemebarriball303
@graemebarriball303 3 месяца назад
@@stephfoxwell4620 yes true. 🙄 I have a feeling it only gets worse under Starmer, who was a human rights lawyer in the past defending many terrorists that the UK wanted to deport.
@MrHighRaw
@MrHighRaw 3 месяца назад
I really don't understand what all the fuss is with immigration. Get them into jobs and paying tax. There are plenty of jobs out there that other people don't want to do. 700,000 people paying say 3,000 per year in tax generates billions.
@luked4587
@luked4587 3 месяца назад
Labour got 1.5% more of the total vote than they did in 2019. Our voting system is broken.
@l3eatalphal3eatalpha
@l3eatalphal3eatalpha 3 месяца назад
Conservatives highest share of the vote: 1979 43.9% 1983 42.4% (landslide) 1987 42.2% (l) 1992 41.9% 2010 36.1% 2015 36.9% 2017 42.3% 2020 43.6% Always fine margins, never represents the electorate proportionally. In recent years policies to move tiny demographics. And the triple lock pension. The nation has paid heavily to keep the Tories in power.
@sergiosilva7528
@sergiosilva7528 3 месяца назад
When the votes are divided between 3 or 4 parties is natural to have lower % giving bigger majoraties. It's simple math!
@mikerodent3164
@mikerodent3164 3 месяца назад
... and hey, none of these percentages reflect anything accurately. No-one knows the distortion introduced by tactical voting, or by indifference due to living in a safe seat (I lived in Hackney North, D. Abbott's seat, one of the "safest" in the country, for 19 years and never bothered voting). ALL this is due to FPTP. Fun factoid: in September 2021 Labour Conference Labour members voted in favour of PR for Westminster. This was then vetoed by some of the thickest people in the country: not the membership of the trade unions, who were never consulted, but their leaders. If Labour hadn't had a landslide last night (e.g. if Reform hadn't disrupted so much), Labour might have been forced to go into coalition with the LDs. Davey isn't QUITE as stupid as Clegg, so would have insisted on PR, and this would have been jumped at by many senior Labourites. As things are, however ...
@patdbean
@patdbean 3 месяца назад
2020? 2019 surly? ​@@l3eatalphal3eatalpha
@mikeroyce8926
@mikeroyce8926 3 месяца назад
​@penderyn8794😂😂😂 A bunch of English aristocrats from Normandy😂
@3d1e00
@3d1e00 3 месяца назад
Personally I think business in the UK has pushed down on workers so hard now they have devalued them to nothing. Now the workers are just reflecting that same behaviour back to the companies.
@robbailie5878
@robbailie5878 3 месяца назад
Cheap Labour. We have had an open doors policy since the Blair Creature was in power and continued by Cameron and his Ilks continuation of said policy.
@1ForTheShieldz
@1ForTheShieldz 3 месяца назад
I started foreclosure of my business today. Ir35 destroyed it, I had to fire everyone. 80k of personal guarantees I'll have to sell my house. 😢
@annaclarke7643
@annaclarke7643 3 месяца назад
​@@1ForTheShieldzwhat a personal and national tragedy. I wish you well.
@graemebarriball303
@graemebarriball303 3 месяца назад
You can’t have more regulation and more pay. Businesses have to pay 5% in to your pension pot, pay the admin costs, fund paternity and increased maternity pay, pay consultants to ensure they meet the endless requirements of work place safety, pay massive business rates to fund the public services you all demand, pay large insurance premiums to cover them for the many legal hazards there to trip them up, police work place language and behaviour for fear of prosecution for staff on staff abuse. Workers are a liability, I’ve stopped employing anyone on PAYE, now using only self employed contractors, I’ll be winding the company up completely as soon as I finish my present scheme. I’m going to invest outside of the UK now, small employers are totally under valued in the UK. Good luck with your pay rise.
@PGHEngineer
@PGHEngineer 3 месяца назад
The STATE is the biggest employer of cheap labour.
@uham999
@uham999 3 месяца назад
Lack of supply in housing is caused by the broken planning system. The cost of putting a roof over your head has a significant effect on the cost of living. The new government could radically change this if they actually realised the magnitude of the problem. If supply met demand it would be a factor in reducing the cost of living. Land would be available more cheaply, therefore housing would be cheaper to build. More housing would get built and there would be real market competition driving prices down. Planning reform is the key to it.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
I dont follow you. How would land become cheaper?
@uham999
@uham999 3 месяца назад
​@@peterquennellnycThere isn't enough land available to build on at the moment due to the planning system so demand for land outstrips supply creating scarcity and therefore higher prices. Making land easier to get planning on will balance supply and demand so prices will fall as they do in any market where supply is plentiful.
@graemebarriball303
@graemebarriball303 2 месяца назад
@@uham999 Sounds simple enough but the planning system is so tied up in legal knots it’s really not going to be easy. The latest anti house building measures include the habitat net gain laws. They take a year to collect the base data, costs tens of thousands, then a scheme has to be built that finishes with the same habitat plus 10%. Guess what happens if you can’t achieve that? You can’t get planning or you have to buy off site credits, such as paying a farmer to remove land from food production. 🤔 I don’t see the actual cost of land changing even if supply increases because much of the cost is built in to the system by government, habitat credits, social housing cost, education contribution, open space contribution, CIL payments of anything up to £500 per sq meter built. In many areas the land cost could be zero yet building houses would still make a loss. That’s why many planning consents never get built. Yes I subscribe to the point you make, but the government costs limit the supply cost dynamic of a free market.
@uham999
@uham999 2 месяца назад
You are right and yes, it is easy to make a loss building houses and the risk is significant. I have built many houses. The layers of pointless overhead costs add significant cost and delays to a build and gets worse every year. I'd say 25 percent of the cost is pointless overhead. All of this adds to the price of the finished product. The whole existing planning system needs scrapping and replaced with a redesigned system from the ground up. Turning a field of mono culture crops into housing with trees, ponds, wild spaces adds significant habitat gain and a good thing. Expecting the same gain from a new build in a town centre is not realistic preventing regeneration of dying town centres. The problem the current law is that there is no discretion or common sense applied. One size does not fit all in the real world. I will only do permitted developments from now on because its the only thing that makes sense now.
@graemebarriball303
@graemebarriball303 2 месяца назад
@@uham999 me too. I’m winding up my new build business and finishing off my last development. I’m also going in to PD and refurb.
@themindgarage8938
@themindgarage8938 2 месяца назад
The UK's tax burden is higher than ever and higher than many countries in Europe that some are quick to labe as "socialist", yet our public services are so much worse and there is so much more poverty. Over 14 years, the Tories have managed to simultaneously massively increase debt, slightly increase the overall tax burden and kneecap public services. The math isn't mathing. Where's the money going? Chumocracy.
@jonkayl9416
@jonkayl9416 2 месяца назад
agreed. Torys want small government so taxes are lower but we are paying more for less. Where has all the cash gone?
@xtc2v
@xtc2v 3 месяца назад
About 10 years ago the cost of an acre of agricultural land was about £4, 000 an acre. So a 40 acre plot would cost £160,000. Back then, with planning permission , a farmer near me sold 40 acres for just over £ 7 million. Planning permission is a massive windfall for land owners. Labour should introduce a windfall tax of 60% to 70% on the rise in value due to the issue of planning permissions and use those millions to subsidise building the 1.5 million homes. This would not only be a tax on rich asset holders but avoid Labour running up yet more government debt
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
I understand your waybif reasoning, but what do you think will be the effect of ducha windfall tax... No farmer willing to sell his land, waiting for better times when that tax might be gone, and thus no land available to build on, driving up the price of available land... You can never win such battles. If someone possesses a commodity in eager demand, the are King.
@jamesthomas4841
@jamesthomas4841 3 месяца назад
@@ab-ym3bf The Land can and should be compulsory purchased at a small mark up on it's agricultural value. Landowners are being turned into multi millionaires overnight just for happening to have a few acres in the right spot. This is a distortion that should corrected.
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
@@jamesthomas4841 "compulsory purchased". I assume you mean "sold", which means you robb someone of a possession he doesn't want to part with. This must be a last resort option, only justifiable if the interest of the country is greater than tha tof the individual. As I understand it, builders and investors are sitting on a lot of land designated for building but are holding out in the hope of higher prices. Better start with those before start confiscating farm land.
@xtc2v
@xtc2v 3 месяца назад
@@ab-ym3bf Councils have the power of compulsory purchase
@xtc2v
@xtc2v 3 месяца назад
@@ab-ym3bf Planning consent often has a time limit within which work must start. Builders often buy land as in investment. There are no business rates on agricultural land so there is no overhead unlike with property. Labour has promised 1.5 million new homes. There will be drastic changes in order to achieve their commitment
@ecognitio9605
@ecognitio9605 3 месяца назад
It's pretty simple outside of a few niche value add areas such as bio-science and aircraft engines and parts (often reliant on foreign precursor chemicals and metals) the UK isn't competitive in the slightest. And it's services breadwinner of financial tinkering is facing stiff competition from Paris, Frankfurt and Geneva post Brexit. Unless you change the very fundamentals nothing will change.
@Willopo100
@Willopo100 3 месяца назад
agreed
@WaterhenBloa14
@WaterhenBloa14 3 месяца назад
Why would the first part of capital (tories) and the second (labour) engineer the economy in such a way over many decades if it just leads to all these chronic problems for them as well? Or has capitalism become so predatory and parasitic thet all it leaves in its wake is debt ridden government's, companies etc for it to feed off.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 2 месяца назад
Paralysed systems. The UK walked out of the EC because of purported paralysed systems, having done nothing about them but sneer, and now find the real systems rigidity problem is closer to home, made worse because BREXIT did immense destruction to integrated systems. How to fix? All high value, all growth, occurs at the lower end of the systems adoption S curve. Simply foresee a way forward toward this and things will come right. Read The Innovator's Dilemma.
@BIGDZ8346
@BIGDZ8346 3 месяца назад
Problem is we have a real stupid way of spending money in this country. Everything is so much more expensive even whennit doesn't need to be. Eg even the example between the London bridge plans costing more than fully building a 27km tunnel in Norway (a more expensive country than UK) for 1/3 the cost of the UKs plans for a bridge. You need to get rid of wasting money and start spending it moee sensibly.
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
That is not wasted money. It is money spend on supporters of the parry. Outside the UK we call this corruption.
@Makalon102
@Makalon102 3 месяца назад
The massive court wastage on the war on drugs in the court and prison system At the very least cannabis being legalised would be a good thing
@gerhard7323
@gerhard7323 3 месяца назад
Labour has its mandate to govern, but it's far weaker than it looks at first glance. Starmer's own vote in Holborn and St Pancras has pretty much halved since 2019 from 36k to 18k.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
Far weaker? A mandate is a mandate. Starmer's majority was hurt one-time by pro=Gazans (good on them), nothing to do with mandate.
@jonkayl9416
@jonkayl9416 2 месяца назад
yea, but 14 years of Torys, think about it.
@gerhard7323
@gerhard7323 2 месяца назад
@@jonkayl9416 I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, but I won't be getting my hopes too high. Starmer, in my opinion, isn't to be trusted and Labour today is Labour in name only. He's basically long been an establishment shill but, like I said, I am happy to be pleasantly surprised.
@rjScubaSki
@rjScubaSki 2 месяца назад
That was due to Gaza, completely meaningless in the long run unfortunately (Gaza will not be in the exact same situation in 5 years)
@mikez2779
@mikez2779 3 месяца назад
I do not agree with you at the slightest that the benefits are the way to lower house cost. Exactly.the opposite in fact - I had this discussion with my landlord myself when he was telling me to apply for benefits, he's gonna put my rent up, and essentially take the taxpayer money for himself So he could have me (non benefit claimant, as im not eligible) in that room paying him 700. Or he could have some benefit claimnant there and get 860 between what tenant and government would be paying. 700
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
Very insightful.
@Daytona2
@Daytona2 3 месяца назад
As a former landlord and tenant I agree, this is exactly what occurs, as it is occurring to sale prices with all the housing market support wheezes (Right To Buy etc).
@matthewharding-ew1ts
@matthewharding-ew1ts 3 месяца назад
We will be in exactly the same position in 5 years time but with even more national debt.
@davidgardiner4720
@davidgardiner4720 2 месяца назад
Evidence or just your personal prejudice?
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 2 месяца назад
V unlikely. Leftie governments around the world grow their economies faster. Average 1% more. Strong proof in UK before & after 2010.
@jonkayl9416
@jonkayl9416 2 месяца назад
what the torys got back in?
@anthonyinglis4078
@anthonyinglis4078 3 месяца назад
What a great fun way to start the day, watching this doom and gloom.
@buntyjoy1800
@buntyjoy1800 3 месяца назад
Isn’t it incredible Tories were fine with first passed the post until it doesn’t work in their favour. `Now they won’t stop whinging
@adam7802
@adam7802 3 месяца назад
Not to mention blaming Reform for their implosion 😂
@samfyfe2949
@samfyfe2949 3 месяца назад
Not incredible at all. Is just self interest
@wizzyno1566
@wizzyno1566 3 месяца назад
Labour were the same.
@buntyjoy1800
@buntyjoy1800 3 месяца назад
@@wizzyno1566Labour have been talking PR for years and Tories pushed against it, until now of course
@onassi
@onassi 3 месяца назад
@@buntyjoy1800 yeah but they (labour) aint gonna do shit now that they've won through that system. If you think Labour is going to reform it, you're kidding yourself. They will pull a Trudeau.
@Alex-fm5ke
@Alex-fm5ke 3 месяца назад
Definitely hope. There are a few simple but very effective policies that labour would implement but will angers a large but still a minority of the population (mostly the Tory base) this can be replacing council tax with a property tax, matching capital gains tax with income tax, carbon taxes on the largest polluters, and a potential wealth tax on billionaires. These policies can plug the gaps in social care, local government and the justice system. They can also rollback NHS privatisation and nationalise utilities.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
Excellent ideas. On my growing list now. Note that these are all adjustments to systems. UK (and EC) needs a lot of these, but not (yet) very good at it (read The Innovator's Dilemma for the knowhow). Left-wing governments do better at this (and at growth, globally) in part because they are more team-friendly. Asian growth happened because teams could easily put in new systems.
@ThomasBoyd-gx9wr
@ThomasBoyd-gx9wr 3 месяца назад
Awesome. Brilliant content. Spot on.
@marumaru6084
@marumaru6084 3 месяца назад
Taxes just take money from other areas of the economy so sure we can waste more on the public sector but there will be even less private sector to pay for it.
@Vroomfondle1066
@Vroomfondle1066 2 месяца назад
Would a workers revolution that transferred the ownership of the means of production to the proletariat be helpful?
@bomberbolton
@bomberbolton 3 месяца назад
AI reducing costs yes, but also reducing jobs I would think.
@JohnDunne001
@JohnDunne001 2 месяца назад
AI isn't at a point yet to start taking jobs. Businesses are only just beginning to try figure out how AI can benefit them. I'd bet that the current AI frenzy is just a bubble forming, untill businesses realise AI isn't ready to deliver the promises people hope/fear it will bring. We're another couple of generations away from general AI that replaces enough jobs to worry about job loss.
@dcphillips1991
@dcphillips1991 2 месяца назад
There is a fairly easy solution, we need to reduce housing and necessity bills, once people have more disposable income, the economy will take care of itself.
@user-jj9eh9vf7u
@user-jj9eh9vf7u 3 месяца назад
Ok for more housing but how do we get them not to build this in the dreadful current style
@robc1014
@robc1014 2 месяца назад
The style is bad, the quality of the build is even worse.
@davewright9313
@davewright9313 2 месяца назад
The minimum wage has gone up but inflation and food prices have risen More.
@PKSiAMiAM
@PKSiAMiAM 2 месяца назад
It would be good to see some graphs overlapped with trends and what's been projected and see the growth trend needed to meet the target.
@foppo101
@foppo101 3 месяца назад
We have to talk to the E.U.At least get trade sorted out because what is happening now is ridiculous.We are not a desert Island in the North Sea and we need our neighbours like they need us.
@greyvoice7949
@greyvoice7949 2 месяца назад
And what do you think is happening or just blindly believing what you are told to believe!
@jhwheuer
@jhwheuer 2 месяца назад
🎉who in the EU needs the UK?
@CactusGirl-x7f
@CactusGirl-x7f 2 месяца назад
Europe is happy that you left it. Who needs 3rd country in their alliance
@johndover3626
@johndover3626 3 месяца назад
Their first job, in the new parliament, will be to agree on an inflation-busting pay increase for all MPs.
@tonygyles7351
@tonygyles7351 2 месяца назад
The UK economy has no growth. We have no world leading companies. We heading way of Italy and Greece.
@James-yl3kk
@James-yl3kk 3 месяца назад
1.5m over 5 years isn't that much more than the conservatives is it? 5 x 300k , I think we've had 250k new houses this year right? Surely the issue will be how many new immigrants we get in 5 years? 1M, 2M , 3M?
@Daytona2
@Daytona2 3 месяца назад
Yup, it's the same. And it's insufficient. 2019 Conservative manifesto - "300,000 homes a year by the mid-2020s" Using house price inflation is the sensible benchmark to base policy on. The target should be zero nominal until the 70 year backlog is cleared and then general inflation. And yes it'll be a slow business.
@KanLedbetter
@KanLedbetter 3 месяца назад
Hallelujah!!!! The daily jesus devotional has been a huge part of my transformation, God is good 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻was owning a loan of $47,000 to the bank for my son's brain surgery (David), Now I'm no longer in debt after I invested $8,000 and got my payout of $270,500 every months,God bless Christy Fiore 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸..
@SimplotElbie
@SimplotElbie 3 месяца назад
Hello!! how do you make such monthly, I’m a born Christian and sometimes I feel so down of myself 😭 because of low finance but I still believe God
@BoshersYarzabal
@BoshersYarzabal 3 месяца назад
Thanks to my co-worker (Carson ) who suggested Ms Christy Fiore
@IvanPaula-ck9sl
@IvanPaula-ck9sl 3 месяца назад
After I raised up to 525k trading with her I bought a new House and a car here in the states🇺🇸🇺🇸 also paid for my son's surgery….Glory to God, shalom.
@NadineSigle
@NadineSigle 3 месяца назад
She's a licensed broker here in the states🇺🇸 and finance advisor.
@MeislerFoulger
@MeislerFoulger 3 месяца назад
I've always wanted to be involved for a long time but the volatility in the price has been very confusing to me. Although I have watched a lot of RU-vid videos about it but I still find it hard to understand
@frank834skinner3
@frank834skinner3 3 месяца назад
Given the chaos in the US and the lurch to the radical right in France and to a lesser extent, germany the UK is looking pretty good to international investors. That will likely help us.
@jhwheuer
@jhwheuer 2 месяца назад
😂 keep up the dream. Nothing beats friction in trade to end interest of investors.
@CactusGirl-x7f
@CactusGirl-x7f 2 месяца назад
With Lebour, Britain is even worse then all of them
@rebelfactsmedia4333
@rebelfactsmedia4333 2 месяца назад
U mean the elctionin of a hard left labour govt who will tax and spend is good? U must b having a laugh
@ukporkpie7829
@ukporkpie7829 2 месяца назад
If you can expect companies to grow and profits to increase (on the backs of people on minimum wages) then yes you can continue to increase the minimum wage. Maybe it could be tied to company performance, like the executives are happy to avoid by with their remuneration....
@Nobumblegumforyou
@Nobumblegumforyou 2 месяца назад
It should be done by company size. Business with 20+employes have to pay min wage +£2 h/r. No harm done to small businesses and stops big businesses impoverishment the country.
@WobblycogsUk
@WobblycogsUk 3 месяца назад
Building enough houses wouldn't lower prices, how does that work? Personally, if I could get my hands on a decent sized plot at a reasonable price I would build a house in a heartbeat. The rules around planning are so draconian most people and smaller building firms aren't even looking at it any more. We've ended up with a handful of massive businesses building nearly all our houses and being the only ones able to get land.
@Daytona2
@Daytona2 2 месяца назад
I completely agree. I believe the report used the insufficient government target of 300,000pa. GIGO.
@erongi233
@erongi233 3 месяца назад
What about the £30 billions interest being paid yearly to the bankers on their QE reserves? Why is that never mentioned by the Tories or Labour? It is entirely windfall. Other central bankers are not paying out more because of higher interest rates. The whole of the state pension increase was around £8 billion for 24/25. All the "experts" say we cannot afford that.In 25/26 that state pension increase will be around £2 billion. All the "experts" are, of course friends of the City which is doing very,very well,thank you very much out of taxpayers and QE.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
Doesn't the government in turn profit from the reserves?
@erongi233
@erongi233 3 месяца назад
@@peterquennellnyc no. The QE related reserves are held in the BoE . The reserves are held for 2 reasons . If 700 billions were let lose into the real economy they would cause massive inflation. In addition to the interest received the commercial banking sector gains stability by holding such vast reserves.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
@@erongi233 Gotcha. Are the banks paying interest to customers for those deposits? There's no actual free money? As you describe it bank customers seem to me to be gaining in the billions, maybe 30 billion a year?
@erongi233
@erongi233 3 месяца назад
@@peterquennellnyc The interest is paid by the BoE to the commercial banks like Barclays,Lloyds etc. It increases bank profits. It doesn't go to bank customers.
@erongi233
@erongi233 3 месяца назад
@@peterquennellnyc The Labour Party are talking about the possibility of means testing the meanest state pension in Europe. The Labour Party has never mentioned this £30 billion getting paid from the taxpayer straight into increased bank profits every year . Completely either incompetent or corrupt. They don't want to upset the bankers.
@Murmilone
@Murmilone 2 месяца назад
Instead of rearmament, the UK government can just stop sticking its nose everywhere in the world.
@erongi233
@erongi233 Месяц назад
To buy an average house now costs 7 or more times income compared with 3 times when I was young. So money now spent on buying a house could be saved or spent on something else. QE has a lot to answer for ,as has the resulting ultra low interest rates. We need better Governors of the Bank of England or a better more impartial system who will stand up to the pressures from interested parties to further cut their interests when it is not necessary. The UK economy is too much about the banks and has been for a long time.
@paxundpeace9970
@paxundpeace9970 3 месяца назад
From 2000 until 2009 the number of GPs increased by 10,300 thats an 25% increase. 39,098 ->> 49,347 From 2009 til 2018 it went up by about 130 49.437 - 49,569
@nighttrain1236
@nighttrain1236 2 месяца назад
Let's see some costings and feasibility studies before we declare GB Energy an automatic success. Labour said the it will create 650,000 new high-quality jobs, but this energy is also supposed to be very cheap. This doesn't add up. At the very least, a monumental investment in the electrical grid is required.
@g.p616
@g.p616 2 месяца назад
Society has to change. The end of the two parent family unit is the root cause of most poverty. What are the stats for single parent families since WW2? I guarantee its been climbing and has never been higher!
@Kenone1988
@Kenone1988 2 месяца назад
Unless they remove economic growth barriers like #ir35 there is now hope for growth. #ir35 only helped Indian IT consulting companies which outsource UK IT jobs to India. Guess what Rishi Sunak's father in law owns the biggest one.
@Seek-Light
@Seek-Light 2 месяца назад
Talk about immigration and the terrible effect it has had on our economy
@ENoob
@ENoob 2 месяца назад
Deregulation is the only answer that doesn't cost money. Reducing planning restrictions and getting rid of all the ridiculous levies on house building would drastically reduce the cost of a house. Great British energy won't lower bills. Renewables are expensive especially compared to gas (which we have plenty of) and nuclear (which we could build faster if we had the political will) Want more investment and higher productivity? Make it worth investing (fewer restrictions and lower taxes in capital) also restrict the importation of cheap labour. Firms will have to raise wages to hire and invest in technologies to make it economical. Lastly, the benefits bill is insane, the number of stress related reasons for being out of work is ridiculous. By all means top up wages, but unless you are physically incapable you should be finding a job. There are plenty of vacancies. The problem labour face is that the solutions to Britain's problems run counter to all their instincts. In fact the existence of the problems is in large part due to the continuation of the blairite consensus since 2010.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 2 месяца назад
"the existence of the problems is in large part due to the continuation of the blairite consensus since 2010." Hardly. UK growth has averaged !% less since 2010. You make some sound points; this isn't one.
@jhwheuer
@jhwheuer 2 месяца назад
😅enjoy your swim in the Turdmes
@wokelefty
@wokelefty 3 месяца назад
I think if we've learnt anything from this election, no seat is safe & don't take the public vote for granted. If Labour make positive changes they might get a another term after, but if the don't, they'll be out. It will be good to judge the labour party in 5yrs based on what they've done or haven't done. I'm personally very positive about the future in the UK, but only time will tell.
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
We read those same words after every election, no matter who just won.
@CactusGirl-x7f
@CactusGirl-x7f 2 месяца назад
You should be negative. The UK is doomed
@outtheredude
@outtheredude 2 месяца назад
It's looking like the best Labour can do is halt the rot, before the Tories or Reform are brought in to finish the job with their slash and burn policies such as further reductions in direct taxation, especially for the rich, resulting in further defunding of public institutions and infrastructure that has already been cut to the bone, while encouraging further vampiric privatisation to suck away what little resources are left from front line services straight into shareholders profits.
@greyvoice7949
@greyvoice7949 2 месяца назад
Surely Labour can fix it , after all the Tories were mostly using Labour policies! Surely they know/knew how their own policies work...
@tancreddehauteville764
@tancreddehauteville764 3 месяца назад
I believe things will improve, but it will take Labour two terms, if not three.
@mrmeldrew693
@mrmeldrew693 3 месяца назад
Nasal globalist middle manager out.....nasal globalist middle manager in. Yay.
@robbishop3080
@robbishop3080 3 месяца назад
'A Shame Economy is Broken' - what does that headline mean?
@Just_another_Euro_dude
@Just_another_Euro_dude 3 месяца назад
It means not even the new government will help UK cause brexit is stronger than any party, including the Labour.
@joanneburford6364
@joanneburford6364 3 месяца назад
Until you introduce mandatory voting you will never get a true reflection of what the eligible voters think - only 66% bothered to vote. If you think mandatory voting wouldn't work, it does 🇦🇺
@messier58
@messier58 2 месяца назад
Would a wealth tax help?
@Ligerpride
@Ligerpride 3 месяца назад
This wasn't a vote for Labour. There are vast swathes of England, such as Manchester and Liverpool, that blindly vote Labour out of protest against the perceived establishment in London via the Tory party. At this point I don't even think they think anything will improve, they just resent the conservative party. The Labour party though have no intention of making things better for people economically. Their entire approach now relates to gaming the system to keep themselves in power through immigration and giving votes to younger people. Their strategy is to stay in government. Their policies will now focus on social issues such as LGBT, feminist issues but more to the point they will keep the borders fully open and will subsidise this to the hilt.
@richardh8082
@richardh8082 3 месяца назад
@Ligerpride You are entitled to you ill-informed opinion
@seany8787
@seany8787 3 месяца назад
Are you a conservative? People like me vote labour because the tories do really well at persuading normal people that they are in ‘the club’ with them, but that exclusive tory club is the 1% If you had a swimming pool in your house growing up, then you might have an excuse to vote tory. Although Starmer has been gifted the election it goes to show just how bad the tories have been over the past 15 years. How labour can be blamed for anything Tory voters dislike such as immigration or gender studies in the past 15 years is sheer deflection..
@Cassp0nk
@Cassp0nk 3 месяца назад
Sounds about right
@robbailie5878
@robbailie5878 3 месяца назад
Exactly this.
@barbthegreat586
@barbthegreat586 3 месяца назад
Nurse!
@andrewsage7164
@andrewsage7164 3 месяца назад
And what of the single market? We must rejoin and make more out of a relationship with our nearest and biggest trading partner if the economy is to grow.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
Unlikely all EC countries vote in favor of reentry unless at minimum UK adopts the Euro.
@DrBenVincent
@DrBenVincent 3 месяца назад
“Anything we can actually do we can afford.” - Keynes
@ErrolMorris-u4b
@ErrolMorris-u4b 3 месяца назад
hope that Labour stop caring for shareholders, foreign investors, bankers, all who ask for lower taxes and take their profits and store it in tax havens abroad . Actually start looking at the long term for the people of the UK think CO-OP's and Nationalisation not privatisation.
@muratdagdelen8163
@muratdagdelen8163 2 месяца назад
You voted for Conservatives instead of Reform, you got Labour...
@OVXX666
@OVXX666 2 месяца назад
3 words. land value tax
@sdwone
@sdwone 3 месяца назад
It's strange... We have a whole litany of problems that we face... Very SERIOUS problems! And yet, I've had arguments with numpties on here, who have an issue with my stance that we should NOT be sending even more billions on futile wars abroad... Because over here, people are REALLY suffering! It's like they don't get it! And that the lives of, say, Ukrainians is more important than the lives of Britains. No wonder Farage's party did well in the elections, with that kind of attitude!!!
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 2 месяца назад
Hi Vladimir.
@sdwone
@sdwone 2 месяца назад
@@peterquennellnyc He's NOT my enemy... And I don't give a sh*t what my government... Or other Western governments say! Putin ISN'T a threat to Europe!!! I mean how could he be?! WE have nukes!!!
@roryoneill9444
@roryoneill9444 3 месяца назад
Labour could save a lot of money end the occupation of the North of Ireland..... except I doubt the North of Ireland will not get a border poll...
@Thomas-uf8si
@Thomas-uf8si 3 месяца назад
Go outside please commenting all day isn't good for health
@adiintel1
@adiintel1 3 месяца назад
as a criminal in prison i hope they let me out 🙏
@TheOmfg02
@TheOmfg02 3 месяца назад
I wonder who lives in all the council houses? Dum dum dummmmmmm!!!! We all know why
@becjayne6097
@becjayne6097 2 месяца назад
Are these the same ones that turn their spare room into a prayer room.
@TheOmfg02
@TheOmfg02 2 месяца назад
@@becjayne6097 lol. Yeah it is weird how the video author never mentions how much of social housing is given to immigrants.
@namaewa-vx5rl
@namaewa-vx5rl 3 месяца назад
I've been following this channel for quite some time now. except repeating over and over and over some facts in multiple videos, and talks about many and many deadlocks between problems, whats your solution on the situation?
@PGHEngineer
@PGHEngineer 3 месяца назад
The country is not facing a mountain of problems. The STATE is facing a mountain of problems. Accurate language is important....
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 2 месяца назад
State and country (and nation) are interchangeable. Maybe you mean government or economy.
@PGHEngineer
@PGHEngineer 2 месяца назад
@peterquennellnyc I think in the context the use of the word state is understood, as it is in the term "state enterprise" or "state owned monopoly".
@musiqtee
@musiqtee 3 месяца назад
Well… GDP doesn’t help much - or rather waged work can’t. Housing, property, finance, debt and other assets have bound up more than “work” can carry. And, a government, a council or a person with decreasing capital ownership don’t “invest” - they all pay invoices with no ownership in return. Growth does happen, but not in the producing part of the economy. It happens in nominals, and those gains circle back into the above assets - not in “investment” outside the FIRE sector. This makes the public sector a very inefficient (poor) capitalist in a capitalist society. The last 40 years of legislation has killed off “trickle down”, as that meant regulations and limits to capital movement. Unemployment is not the worst threat, but ordinary people with no imaginable capital ownership questioning the point of “selling their labour” could be. If the single well functioning sector is the privately owned corporate B2B - how can we expect the public sector or individuals to cope?
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 3 месяца назад
As Shakespeare (and Paul Krugman) widely advised... first thing, we lock all economists in the back room. Getting incentives & equilibriums right is only a very small part of growth & development. ALL the heavy lifting is basically a process of bringing in new systems with a lot of value at the lower end of their adoption S curve. That is the Asian model - as even the powerdrunk economists in the World Bank admitted in a book in the 1990s (before instantly forgetting that rule of thumb). Keir Starmer needs above all systems-proficient people. Read The Innovator's Dilemma.
@hungo7720
@hungo7720 3 месяца назад
The UK has long been mired in stagnation and sluggish economic growth which seriously strains its citizens' disposable income. Labour may not help transform Britain overnight but is at least better than the pro-austerity crooked Tories. The UK insurmountable issues are systemic and could not be ironed out by tinkering on the edges.
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
And that is the problem for labour (or any other). It will take a long time for systemic problems to be solved, yet the public expects (partly based on "promises" from politicians) short term miracles. When they do not appear, next election the swing is to the other side again. New hopes, but the problems remain.
@blubblubee
@blubblubee 3 месяца назад
Epic regression to the pre-Roman mean realness moment
@richardh8082
@richardh8082 3 месяца назад
Confidence will fuel growth now we are out from under the Tory jackboot
@johnnyboyvan
@johnnyboyvan 3 месяца назад
Nothing much will change. All politicians are the same.
@matt49125
@matt49125 3 месяца назад
Reform 2029
@fazfinisher5598
@fazfinisher5598 3 месяца назад
Looking forward to hearing labour blame the tories for the next five years, that should keep the voters pacified.
@tfive24
@tfive24 3 месяца назад
And it will be actually true
@annaclarke7643
@annaclarke7643 3 месяца назад
In a world of financial pressure, high divorce rates, separations and no work security, people still think that having large families is their right to have corresponding social security support. Why should people still think in this way.
@MarKeMu125
@MarKeMu125 3 месяца назад
Because older generations had and sold this dream, and most still believe it calling their children / grandchildren lazy & work shy for not having the life they had when they were that age?
@nigelsutton8957
@nigelsutton8957 2 месяца назад
People don't have large families these days. My dad was one of 8, his mother was one of 13. If we were having large families, we wouldn't be relying so much on immigration to fill jobs.
@MarKeMu125
@MarKeMu125 2 месяца назад
@@nigelsutton8957 the cost of children is a luxury most can't afford especially as we've gone down the neoliberalism route than socialism (where a council house would've been great). I'm in the top 10% of income after housing costs according to the IFS, yet even I'm having issues finding a house I can afford the mortgage on in a nicer area as I don't fancy raising kids at my parents.
@nigelsutton8957
@nigelsutton8957 2 месяца назад
@MarKeMu125 I do appreciate that, me and the wife have a 38 and 25 year old still at home and the other 2 who have flown the nest have huge mortgages. My daughter and her husband don't even qualify for Child allowance for their 2 kids, as her chap earns too much. I lived in a council house until I got married and feel sorry for the current generation who don't have access to affordable rented accommodation.
@MarKeMu125
@MarKeMu125 2 месяца назад
@@nigelsutton8957 yup, it's a shame. Did you get child care raising them or could you count on the wife helping to raise them full time? A lot of the issue is housing needs 2 incomes a lot of the time.
@plerpplerp5599
@plerpplerp5599 3 месяца назад
The Tories' obsession with reducing the size and role of government has backfired spectacularly, leaving them politically irrelevant and facing electoral oblivion. They've essentially engineered their own political demise through their bat shit ideological commitment to a smaller state. Their cuts to public services have created crises in healthcare, education, and social care, turning voters against them. Austerity measures have damaged the economy and increased inequality, destroying their reputation for economic competence. The Tories are facing their worst crisis in modern history. They're not just losing an election; they're losing their relevance as a major political force. Their recovery, if possible, will likely take years.
@tropics8407
@tropics8407 3 месяца назад
Maybe Starmzy can get that infamous productivity up by asking nicely 😏
@barbthegreat586
@barbthegreat586 3 месяца назад
Why didn't Rishzy ask nicely?
@arthurdixon5890
@arthurdixon5890 3 месяца назад
Stealth taxes. Congestion taxes.
@cobbler40
@cobbler40 3 месяца назад
labour are expected to fix the problems. Why do the Tories get a free pass and are not expected to tackle the issues.
@macy8993
@macy8993 3 месяца назад
Having subsided government housing just pushes down pressure on minimum wages , because the gov is subsidising your living cost so you can afford the low wage . If you have all market rents then employers have to pay more otherwise no one will do the job in expensive cities
@juangomezfuentes8825
@juangomezfuentes8825 3 месяца назад
Or they close the business and the unemployment start to grow.
@reggie69.
@reggie69. 3 месяца назад
​@@georgeaird4637move out to Where the Streets you could end up spending more money on things like commuting by moving out
@Imagineering100
@Imagineering100 3 месяца назад
Now the UK Has Dick Emery as PM god help you or Allah.
@alainmellaerts8926
@alainmellaerts8926 3 месяца назад
Why not change the designation of some agricultural lands everywhere? You chose the most barren spots and demand developers that want the cheap land must include a certain % of the houses destined for cheaper social housing for people the council selects. You tell the farmers they can sell their land if they want for a price between agricultural land and building land. Everybody wins. Or do what France does well, open zones of a certain industry with tax breaks and create a cluster of companies that provide work in zones with enough space and people looking for work. Levelling up should be spreading out economic activity from too crowded south to west and north. And these run down coastal towns? In any country in Western Europe coastal towns are expensive to live. It’s a dream for many to live by the sea. Invest in them, such a waste to let them wither away. If they are gentrified and the sea is cleaner, tourists will return.
@GrahamGroovyUK
@GrahamGroovyUK 3 месяца назад
Need to stop being so generous with benefits. They should never be above what a minimum worker on a 36 hour week earns. Why? Because if a minimum wage earner has to survive off that amount then those who choose not to work need a reality check into what the real average worker survives on.
@speedyhillski
@speedyhillski 3 месяца назад
The min wage needs increasing
@AnthonyTolhurst-dw1nc
@AnthonyTolhurst-dw1nc 3 месяца назад
When all else fails, they send you to war. (Gerald Celente)
@SoloSi2024
@SoloSi2024 3 месяца назад
Just a nice salary and pension for the new puppets.
@Lawtasaj
@Lawtasaj 2 месяца назад
Ed Miliband is going to.desyroy whats left of any industry in the UK. We will never recover
@paxundpeace9970
@paxundpeace9970 3 месяца назад
The defense spending stayed the same from 1998 until 2009. Then it dropped Healthcare spending rose only because of covid. In 2024 it was alread back down.
@tubularbill
@tubularbill 2 месяца назад
What a disaster
@younube2
@younube2 3 месяца назад
All roads lead you to more money printing - bitcoin fixes this
@jamescat2386
@jamescat2386 3 месяца назад
AI is not inexpensive both to set up or to run
@graemebarriball303
@graemebarriball303 3 месяца назад
I haven’t bothered to watch this video, the guy is a left wing economist who supports a large interventionist state. He’s wetting his pants at the thought of an even more lefty socialist government than the one just ejected. Good luck Starmer, but as a small business man I’m already giving up, too much ted tape. I suspect many others will follow soon enough.
@CosmosChill7649
@CosmosChill7649 3 месяца назад
We need more taxes. So that more money can be sent to Israel by our Prime Ministers selected by them
@themackeler5011
@themackeler5011 2 месяца назад
Not my PM never will be.
@peterquennellnyc
@peterquennellnyc 2 месяца назад
Hi Vladimir.
@bortstanson2034
@bortstanson2034 3 месяца назад
We need a better educated and paid workers, and companies must be forced to train local staff instead of bringing people from abroad.
@winthorpe2560
@winthorpe2560 3 месяца назад
So called renewables are the most expensive form of electricity generation. British power is a huge mistake, unless it focuses on new oil and gas and new nuclear
@BatCountryAdventures
@BatCountryAdventures 3 месяца назад
Nuclear is looking like it will be incredibly expensive too. Hinkley Point C is heading towards a very bad direction.
@paxundpeace9970
@paxundpeace9970 3 месяца назад
Nuclear is then times more expensive then wind or solar.
@paxundpeace9970
@paxundpeace9970 3 месяца назад
​@@BatCountryAdventures30 Billion Pounds and already delayed by 4 years. Not ready until 2029 and they started 2013.
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
Solar and wind are the cheapest sources of energy, nuclear the most expensive. Almost every recent study comes with the same conclusions. If that is not the case in the UK, there is something going terribly wrong.
@nickharvey7233
@nickharvey7233 3 месяца назад
Just simply untrue.
@lionheart3429
@lionheart3429 3 месяца назад
Country it finished Be ready for low wage average to fall with open boarders More national debt More strain in the economy No businesses to open as the those nhaves will leave .
@paxundpeace9970
@paxundpeace9970 3 месяца назад
If the country would spend money on real projects it would help a lot. Waste 30 Billions on HS2 what they did not even finish. This was the only project that get money during austerity and still got scrapped half way. 30 Billion waste on the most expensive Nuclear power plant.
@lionheart3429
@lionheart3429 3 месяца назад
@@paxundpeace9970 hs2 could be great . Improving travel links in the north could open opportunities for infrastructure and business to set up in other cities and no continually.compress everything into London
@MrVidification
@MrVidification 3 месяца назад
Brexit swapped an open border EU for very high legal non EU country movement (largely with it's migration and mobility partnerships along with increased non EU trade). If the country ever rejoins the EU, then the open border will likely no longer be set or more limited, as some countries in the EU have parties that are revolting against it
@seany8787
@seany8787 3 месяца назад
@@lionheart3429 I’m not listening to anyone who can’t even spell ‘borders’ I mean most of the illegal immigration into ‘are boarders’ was during the last 15 years of the Tory era, the hypocrisy is phenomenal.
@coolbanana165
@coolbanana165 3 месяца назад
Isn't it wrong to say that the energy crisis was something the government couldn't prevent? If the UK used green energy, wouldn't we have had much better energy security?
@Lawtasaj
@Lawtasaj 2 месяца назад
Already giving a whole load of money to ukraine
@mikerodent3164
@mikerodent3164 3 месяца назад
Monbyotte? 😆😆😆
@SGIQ7
@SGIQ7 3 месяца назад
George Monbiot?
@blitzkriegsebastian
@blitzkriegsebastian 3 месяца назад
300,000 houses a year.... Do you have the man-power? If you do, can you deal with the labour costs after all the cheap labour left the country? The blueprints of the left wing have always been bluer than a blue bird, which almost always turned out to be a black bird. If my Engish makes you frown, just consider English is not my first tongue.
@jamessmith5554
@jamessmith5554 3 месяца назад
Why did the conservatives spend £20bn on reducing nic. This would have been better spent on Primary care in the NHS.
@ram3881
@ram3881 2 месяца назад
mr pesimist
@sirfinleygaming9490
@sirfinleygaming9490 3 месяца назад
'its easy to paint a picture of doom and gloom', lol that's all your channel does every video.
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
It is also easy to paint a picture of unicorns and sunlit uplands. Problem with both is that people believe those painted pictures without giving them a thought of their own.
@fly463
@fly463 3 месяца назад
Both extremes are bad
@patdbean
@patdbean 3 месяца назад
5:52 😂 All AI will do is reduce the number of jobs and keep the spending power of the average wage depressed.
@mountbatten2222
@mountbatten2222 3 месяца назад
IT´S A MISSION IMPOSSIBLE FOR PM STARMER ! HUGE EXPECTATIONS FROM HIS VOTERS TO CHANGE : COST OF LIVING CRISIS; HOMELESSNESS; HOUSING PROBLEM; IMMIGRATION; NHS ... VERY HARD TO ACHIEVE WITH NO MONEY; NO RESOURCES; ECONOMY DOWN !! MAKING EVEN MORE DEBT WILL BRING YOU INTO STATE BANKRUPTCY ! WHAT BRITAIN´S SOCIETY NEEDS IS A STRUCTURAL CHANGE; HAS TO START WITH EDUCATION; AND PROFESSIONAL SKILLS ( FOR BUILDING YOU DEPEND ON SKILLED WORKERS FROM ABROAD ...) THIS WILL TAKE AT LEAST A GENERATION; THERE IS NO QUICK SOLUTION FOR YOUR SITUATION... very long , hard way for you ahead! THE ONLY GOOD THING FOR STRAMER IS : WITH HIS BACKGROUND HE DOESN´T REALISE HIS SITUATION RIGHT NOW ...
@joannelewis3390
@joannelewis3390 3 месяца назад
AI politicians would save us a fortune
@irfanyr
@irfanyr 3 месяца назад
Why don’t you ever mention how legal, illegal migration as well as asylum seekers are the cause of all our economic woes?
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 месяца назад
Maybe he doesn't want to be seen as a liar?
@barbthegreat586
@barbthegreat586 3 месяца назад
Because they aren't.
Далее
LOLLIPOP-SCHUTZ-GADGET 🍭 DAS BRAUCHST DU!
00:28
Living life on the edge 😳 #wrc
00:17
Просмотров 5 млн
Why Norway Became Rich From Oil But The UK Lost Out
11:20
Is £90,000 a year a middle class income?
10:06
Просмотров 44 тыс.
The Real Reason Britain Stopped Building
10:15
Просмотров 27 тыс.
Spain Was a Warning
16:30
Просмотров 1,7 млн
How To Get Rich
15:17
Просмотров 647 тыс.
Economist explains why Britain is poor
32:23
Просмотров 1,3 млн
How Private Equity Ate Britain
8:05
Просмотров 1 млн