It's not sushruta it was CARAKA(Medicine Doctor)in kaniska's time. Sushruta was the Father of plastic surgery in indian history Bishamitra's son Maharishi sushruta was born in Varanasi
When you invite a 20 year old boy as a historian in your podcast reflects your intellect level as a host of a pakistani podcast. Pakistan for you👇:- 1. Converted Muslims from Hindus(Sanatani) by force. 2. Radicalised by a book. 3. Divided a piece of land from India over Islamic radical thoughts.
@yashpednekar331 Yes he needs to study from Abhijit Chavda and Sanjay Dixit, bottomline from Amu Darya to Bay of Bengal is one people, one culture, one lingua franca and one civilization! Gangadesh mata ki jai!!!!
The best part of this podcast is every time the guy states a fact, he adds “I might be mistaken”. This one sentence shows the difference between a learned and an ignorant man.
As an Indian I think my ancestors have been in this land for thousands of years . They may have different religion but I am Muslim now . But that’s still don’t disconnect me from my land . Unless Pakistani who starts their story from 1947 .
Yes, according to the standards of education in history prevalent in India. You probably didn't even listen to this podcast at all but if you start listening from 8:05, the answer to your POV is already there.
"Unless Pakistani who starts their story from 1947 ." We start our story from when our ancestors began, which is thousands of years old, we aren't disconnected either and good, keep connecting to your own country.
In India we still teach at school that “Taxilla, Nalanda ka itihaas laut ke aayega” which means Indian universities shall once day reach the glory of universities like Taxilla and Nalanda where all students from Asia will come to learn.
You are gangudeshi. India doesn't exist eastern side of Indooz aka Indus Valley. There's a difference between British created India and the India of Sindh which is connected to Kashmir, Balochistan, Western Punjab and Gandhara civilization of Afghanistan. Basically current Pakistan.
1:16:29 university of taxila could not be establish during Achaemenid dynasty because panini's time is during 600 bc and panini himself wrote that before him there was also a long tradition of teachers at taxila, even many kings during mahajanapada time were students of taxila 1:20:03
Non Muslim Indians feel more attached to historical sites like Taxila and ancient culture . One example of this is that they still name their kids in the same language as their ancestors and identify more with them.
@@Thestrong11 abe gadhe international authors k history books hi padh le.....purushpura naam tha.....tere se pakistani education system ne sb chupaya h...thora jahaalat se baahr nikal...duniya bahot bari h
@@Thestrong11Hindu kings had better things to do then make tombs for dead people 😂😂😂😂. BTW truth will be pit soon. Babri Masjid was built on temple. Islamic kings were too arrogant to remove all the proofs of existing temples. what a bunch of fools. Thank God all the fools migrayed to Foolishtan
Well! Cowards who submitted to Islam got converted. For so long, they tried to become arabs and now when they are kicked from everywhere, they try to become who they ceased to exist long ago. Coward converts have no claim to history.
Wow I’m amazed the things he’s talking about are taught in Indian schools at such young age My son is in class 6 and he’s learning about Taxila…n spread of Buddhism and Jainism in India…along with tht all about the great Indian rulers…The Mauryas…The Guptas…The Cholas… No wonder Indians sense of identity and cultural pride is so deep rooted…Huge respect fr all the Indian educationists and Indian Historians.
He clearly mentioned that this stuff is not taught to kids in Pakistan. Try taking into context of why he’s saying what he’s saying instead of boasting about the teaching of history in ur country
@@umerghaffar4686 He also clearly said that Maurya and Taxila are heritage of Pakistan and India doesn't exist on the eastern side of Indus valley i.e current India. The cholas hated Indus valley and its kings cuz these kingdoms have always invaded and plundered ganga jamuna. Mauryans alone killed millions of ganga jamuna
It is a matter of Pride… a Heritage we Indians have always been proud of something you guys have woken up after 76yrs and suddenly realized is a shared heritage…Obviously we are going to boast about it good, bad or ugly…we have owned up to our history.
The fable he is talking about is Panchatantra written by Vishnu Sharma. The book by shuruta is called shusruta samhita.. detailed anatomy of human body and plastic surgery. Takshshila (Taxila now) and Nalanda were the top educational institutions of the sub continent.. it is said that when the books in Nalanda were burned, the fire kept on going for weeks... More than 10 millions books were burned. To learn more about the golden age of Islam ( which Westerners term as dark ages cuz according to them nothing happened in the entire world before renessaince) kindly refer to lectures by Dr Roy casagranda.
@@0bajwa0Nalanda University was built by Kumaragupta of the Gupta dynasty in the 5th century BC. Prominent rulers of the time, including King Harshavardhana of Kannauj, Pala Rulers, and many scholars patronized Nalanda.
Story of Ghazni was "created" by British.. How conveniently he says kings of same religion also used to loot each other's wealth.. And why was Mahmud ghaznavi called Butshikan then.. what does that word mean?
a pakistani muslim always know how to twist facts which goes against his/her faith. you can easy identify these traits with pakistani community anywhere in the world. These shameful people identify themsleves as Indians in europe. their current socio-economical state tells the truth which almost all Pakistanis try to hide.
Ghazni had zero respect for the culture that came to loot.. Indian kings fight with each other but they never harm culture.. that's why culture always remains the same know the difference
You may not like to use the word Indian subcontinent because you think it’s political word , but the term is geographical representation of tectonic plate which is called India so you may like it or not you cannot remove India from Pakistan if you talk about history, the problem here is Pakistan never considered non-muslims born in Pakistan region as there heroes , and for India anyone born in this region was Indian
@@m.aryaanamiri2755 the Pakistani river originates from India, the word Sindhu is Sanskrit name, the Greeks would call Indica based from Sindhu, Arabs will call Hindustan again based on Sindhu. The Pakistani identity is merely on paper, Pakistan people itself are called Hindus by Arabs. I have been restaurant overseas and found large numbers of Indian restaurants owned by Pakistani / Bangladeshi that itself speaks identity
@@embeddedprojects2336 I'm gonna stop you right there because the Indus starts in china.And,the Nile starts in Ethiopia but,everyone counts it as an Egyptian river because it has the most of the Nile,so your arguments are invalid.And the Pakistani identity is that of the Indus valley,not Arab or turk.
@@m.aryaanamiri2755 Pakistan identity should be Indus valley but what percentage of Pakistani believe that ? Also Indus valley was discovered in early 19th century before that there is no such direct historical records of trade or anything, only Vedas have some mentioned of that region along with a river Saraswati whose flow over time reduced. Much of Arab, Greek, Persian and East Asian trade history is again with modern day India. Most of the present region of Pakistan was always under foreign rule starting from Darius in 500BC.
@@embeddedprojects2336 as husaifa said,only the British discovered the Indus valley in 19th century,but the locals knew of it's existence because if the existence of monuments and cities.And only a small amount of the population claims to be foreign.Most people either take pride in their local identity,or they simply point out that their ancestors were foreign,while they themselves have adopted local cultures.
He is way younger than you but loved the fact that he’s more mature in his thinking about why we are the way we are instead of focussing on the fact k jese hain hum wese he rahein ge.
Let's take a step back and remember why we're all here. We clicked on this video to learn something new, to gain insights, and maybe even broaden our horizons a bit. But instead of diving into something meaningful, we seem to be stuck in a loop of arguments that might never reach a satisfying conclusion. Let's be real, none of us came here to watch a weird TV show, right? We're all sensible folks, and we know that getting into heated debates over something as ambiguous as the ownership of the Indus Valley civilization won't get us anywhere. It's like trying to solve a puzzle with missing pieces. So, how about we put our energy into something more productive? Like sharing our perspectives, listening to each other, and maybe even finding some common ground along the way. And hey, while we're at it, let's not forget to treat each other with respect. We're all here to learn and grow, and that's a lot easier to do when we're not at each other's throats. Let's make this discussion a space where we can all come away with something valuable, whether it's a new idea, a different perspective, or just a better understanding of each other. Sound good? Let's dive back in with that in mind.
Your point is pretty fair. But it is the sheer hypocrisy of these people where they try to portray themselves as an “Islamic country” and conjure hatred for us. And then they’re off to claim a pre-Islamic Indian civilisation all for themselves. It does not make sense.
@@rizwanhussain645 Dholavira, Rangpur, Lothal, Alamgirpur. Bro, the civilisation was that of Indus, and Indus was an India valley. Just because the Pakistani government managed to get a land in the place where many Harappan cities exist doesn’t make them Pakistani. Sudan has more pyramids than Egypt, but still those pyramids are recognised as Egyptian remnants. So Stop being delusional. Get real. Btw, your grandparents were likely “Gangudeshis” as well, since it was all India before 1947
jizya was 1.5 percent of yearly wealth.The zakat,the tax for muslims is 2 persent.Meaning being a muslim was more expensive so your logic seems incomplete.
@@12SPASTIC12 Salman Rashid couldn't differentiate between Balochistan and Sindh.Calling Balochistan the Indian satrapy when the very name of India comes from Sindh.
"Islam is in its origins an Arab religion. Everyone not an Arab who is a Muslim is a convert. Islam is not simply a matter of conscience or private belief. It makes imperial demands. A convert's worldview alters. His holy places are in Arab lands; his sacred language is Arabic. His idea of history alters. He rejects his own; he becomes, whether he likes it or not, a part of the Arab story. The convert has to turn away from everything that is his." ---- V S Naipaul
This comment has to be one of the top contenders for the biggest piece of bullshit that is part of this vast and mostly ludicrous comment section. Whoever Naipaul is, that man is smoking on some filthy stuff, I’ll tell you that.
Har convert ko lgta hai ki vo original hai. Ye case me toh jo role model se related books h usme bhi idols ko destroy krne ki baat hai. Yaha toh originals bhi converted hi hai
@@Fgghhnh2345 Right, Now what would a butthurt anti-Islamic ultracrepidarian such as the likes of YOU, know or feel about the sheer beauty and blessing of being a Muslim. These petty comments don’t faze us the lease bit, lad, never will. So whatever helps you sleep at night lmao.
Dear Junaidbhai Greetings from Mumbai. Interesting conversation with young history buff. Guest expressed his opinions on varied topics / eras and also admitting at times that he is not sure of authenticity of what he was narrating. He comes comes out as honest , sincere lad , trying to learn. Few general comments : 1. Pakistanis surely has misconception of their identity , which isnt surprising. As Pakistan was born out of political case presented by Jinnah the lawyer , rather than a grass root politician. In any society the identity can be fluid...at local level one may be Pasthun or Sindhi ...at other level...may be Muslim ...at other level could be Pakistani or even South Asian . 2. Jinnah andMuslim League never fought for freedom of India or Pakistan from British rule . They always attacked Congress leaders and termed them into some Hindu leaders , which is falsely taught and understood by majority of Pakistanis. 3. Modern "Pakistani" History is very old , may be even older than Mohenjo Daro era . Pakistani students and people are main losers when they are taught incomplete or motivated history ..which leads to confusion of their national identity. Even the guest conveniently forgotten to state that great Emperors like Chandra gupta maurya, Ashoka the great etc were all from the land , which is modern day Pakistan. Such selective cherry pickings is prevalent in most of Pakistanis , hence they remain rudderless. 4. If the "Real / Honest" History of today/s Pakistani land is told to the children of Pakistan...new Pakistan will emerge . Till then, confusion shall continue. People need to read books written by credible Historians , Anthropologists etc rather than go by hearsay / anecdotes / sweeping generalisations/ conspiracy theories , unscientific ideas etc. Keep up the good work JunaidBhai to awaken the people to challenge the false narrative being churned out by propagandists.
@@A.R.V_02 No my friend. The subcontinent has a shared history. And we are the same people. The only people who alienate you from your roots are your own citizens and politicians.
@@AmeyVikram16 I am sorry to inform you my friend, we are not the same, like I said north indians are the closest to us Pakistanis and that's it, Bharat follows a reformed shape of hinduism that was made years after the original vedic scriptures which was made in our land, those scriptures were reformed in the 5th century in heartlands of ganga and jamuna, I respect your culture and the ancient, rich history of both ganga and jamuna and I claim none of it and give credits to the people that live there, That is literally all that us Pakistanis ask, please stop claiming our history and lands, your opinion about our government alienating us is although very true, but I am glad many people are waking up, a whole historical renaissance is taking place in Pakistan right as we speak, people like huztory and thousands of others are spreading the light, soon my generation will then be able to teach the generation of our children, our whole history that was unfortunately defied by the generation that came immediately after independence who were too emotional religiously since they saw the oppression and slaughter by the disbelievers onto them
brother you can be proud on buddhism which is originated from patna but a guy from patna cannot be proud on its own culture and history just because some muslim elite from UP want to remain in power and create their own nation just by drawing a random line on map. 🙏
Exactly ..he can be proud of the fact that buddhism sort of spread from that area(a religion that has nothing to do with present day pakistan ) to far east and west but a person from Patna should not be proud of his cultural and religious histroy that has roots in Peshawar even though he follows that religion in everyday life
@@sonamkumari-od9nv Biharis have as much similarities to Pakistanis as Pakistanis have to Arab Muslims. Stop making us your fathers. Celebrate your sex temples.
@@ahmedajd164 yes ofcourse ...because there is no relation bw patna and Japan😂...but a Buddhist can be proud of its presence in Japan ...thats how it works... Hope it helps!!
उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम्। वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र सन्ततिः॥ "The country (varṣam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhārata; there dwell the descendants of Bharata." The Bhagavata Purana mentions (Canto 5, Chapter 4)[31] - "He (Rishabha) begot a hundred sons that were exactly like him... He (Bharata) had the best qualities and it was because of him that this land by the people is called Bhāratavarṣa" Bharata Khanda (or Bhārata Kṣetra [32]) is a term used in some of the Hindu texts. In the Sanskrit epic, the Mahabharata (200 BCE to 300 CE), a larger region of North India is encompassed by the term Bharata, but much of the Deccan and South India are still excluded.[33] Some other Puranic passages refer to the same Bhārata people, who are described as the descendants of Dushyanta's son Bharata in the Mahabharata.[34] The realm of Bharata is known as Bhāratavarṣa in the Mahabharata (the core portion of which is itself known as Bhārata) and later texts. According to the text, the term Bharat is from the king Bharata, who was the son of Dushyanta and Shakuntala and the term varsa means a division of the earth or a continent.[citation needed] The use of Bharat often has political overtones, appealing to a certain cultural conception of India.[35] CNN reported in 2023 of president Droupadi Murmu and prime minister Narendra Modi using the Bharat name in connection with a G20 gathering, speculating on a possible name change for the country.
Bharata tribe was Vedic. The Rigvedic culture formed in Punjab. Most of Punjab is in Pakistan. Your country is named after a river in Pakistan (the Indus). It's best you stick to remembering you are an inheritor of the British Raj, and that's it.
He has a preference for referring to our region as "South Asia" instead of the "Indian subcontinent," despite acknowledging that the term "India" has its roots in Sindh.
That's pakistani mentality for you. For the past few years most of these overseas Pakistanis are slowly trying to seal Indian history and claim its their. That's because in the world today pakistan is called terrorist country. That's causing embarrassment to these overseas pakistanis
The Vishnu Purana mentions: ऋषभो मरुदेव्याश्च ऋषभात् भरतो भवेत्।भरताद् भारतं वर्षं, भरतात् सुमतिस्त्वभूत्॥Rishabha was born to Marudevi, Bharata was born to Rishabha,Bhāratavarṣa arose from Bharata and Sumati arose from Bharata.-Vishnu Purana (2,1,31)ततश्च भारतं वर्षमेतल्लोकेषुगीयते।भरताय यत: पित्रा दत्तं प्रतिष्ठिता वनम्॥ (विष्णु पुराण, २,१,३२)This country is known as Bhāratavarṣa since the times the father entrusted the kingdom to the son Bharata and he himself went to the forest for ascetic practices.[30]-Vishnu Purana (2,1,32)uttaraṃ yatsamudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam varṣaṃ tadbhārataṃ nāma bhāratī yatra santatiḥउत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम्।वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र सन्ततिः॥"The country (varṣam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhārata; there dwell the descendants of Bharata.
it also says Vishnu Purana 2.12.36 “From the waters, which are the body of Vishnu, was produced the lotus shaped earth, with its seas and mountains.”💀😂
hey don't copy paste it is too long --- just write about bharat from himalaya mountain to the sea & give reference of VP with chapter and verse number.
@@urrasscal8380whats the historical evidance of that bs myth? stop living in delusional fairytale, how old is the oldest vishnu purana preserved till now with evidence?
This podcast is a classic example of how hatred towards a certain religion and region makes one not acknowledge ones history and culture. Despite being asked several times, the gentleman keeps lamenting that Indians should not claim Indus valley civilisation as a part of their history. The dichotomy of the sad fact that it's a shared history, but Pakistanis do not want to associate with it and Indians do.
The problem is not hatred, it is the definition of word India. What does India means to you? How do you define it?Which definition are you referring to?
@@TruthPrevailzyour mentality is the typical Indian mentality like what he said. In pakistan punjabis says we we are punjabi phuktoon says we are phuktoon and we together becomes Pakistani. And on other hand Indians says we are Indians the name which was given by Britishers. We are not Indians. We are real sons of indus valley we live in south asia and stop stealing our identity
Only thing which connects subcontinent is " Hinduism "..this guy is trying hard to project separate pakistani identity before partition..but al mashudi too has written sun temple in Multan..bhai koi alag culture nai h tumhara..
Their whole nation is based on the fact of proving a different identity somehow. Anyway, I have no hate in my mind. But I seriously hope that people accept their true history and roots.
Your Santana dharma has nothing to do with us, our ancestors followed vedic religion which opposed idol worship, There's a reason why there are more Buddhist stupas in Pakistan than Hindu temples
@@bojpuri423 Pakistan ki tension le bail buddhi. Humara jane de. Balochistan alg roo rha hai. POJK aazadi mang rha hai, election tum karwa paa nahi reh ho, army chal nhi paa rhi...unka kbhi fuel khtm ho jata hai kbhi himmat, industries aane ke jagah jaa rahi hai, log khane bina mar rahe h, 1-1 billion dusro se mang pad rahe h. Aur tu yaha ye bakchodi kar rha h. Dimaag h ya inbreeding k karan khtam ho gaya hai vo bhi?
Buddhism became the predominant faith in Gandhara when Kanishka embraced it and became its patron. Subsequently, the Budhism spread from Gandhara all the way to Korea and Japan.
u guys have nothing to do with iindia or indus valley civilization or kanishka u guys are nothing but iinvaders go worship ur aarrabic god & aarrabic rreligio. iindians have their own religion, culture, and festival.
I find it hard to resist comparing this proud Pashtun/Chitrali with several shallow and self-loathing Punjabi “intellectuals” whose only mission is to ridicule their own people at every forum and every opportunity.
indus velly civilization is indian history then pakistan created from india , if you think indus velly civilization is only pakistan history is wrong becasue there is lots indus velly civilization center is in india . so only selected history is not workable remember chankhya studied in taxsila but he make chandragupta king and its capital was patliputra in modern bihar .
But Pashtun Baloch do not belong to Indus Valley Civilization pashto Balochi language both are Persians Farsi language har Pakistani Punjabi sindhi Nahi hota dono civilasation Ka mixture ha Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@priyanshukumar7697 Ok Sanjay Dickshit is well read, the one who claims Saraswati Saxenas are responsible for the birth of the Anglo-Saxons.Regards Mrs Priya
@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 dude I'm not here representing anyone I only meant that the guy is factually incorrect and is just tryna make a intellectual image of himself . He wants to represent Pakistan's ancient accomplishment but the very Pakistan wasnt present then ,it was the history of India and it still is .Pakistan is a recent creation the only history it has is after the partition that's all.
@@priyanshukumar7697 He is referring to coterminous Pakistan not your "Rep of India" ( a day younger than Pakistan), as for Sindhu & its many cognates, Scylax was clear about it's geographical makeup, it was strictly folk residing ALONG the might Sindhu (ancient Pakistanis) not those an 1000miles East.Regards Ganga dweller
Thoroughly enjoyed the podcast as I am a big admirer of Huzaifa! Also as a Chitrali, I felt extremely satisfied when you discussed our problems. Allah tate khair korar!
I feel very ashamed that we have been mistreating our Chitrali community. In Punjab the only concept we are given of Chitral is that it's a very backwards area and you can buy their beautiful women for marriage. The fact that we as the people of Punjab get the most development just because we are the majority and politicians live here and Chitrali people don't, goes to show we are an ungrateful nation and we will never succeed in the world.
It is unfortunate that there are negative perspectives about different ethnicities in our country. Similarly, we have been taught many misconceptions about Punjabi people, which may be incorrect, just like your perspective on Chitral. Chitral is one of the most beautiful places in Pakistan, with its lush greenery, welcoming people, and warm hospitality that is difficult to describe in words. People from Punjab, Sindh, and other parts of KPK take advantage of this hospitality. In Chitral, there are Muslims, Kalash, and Ismaili communities, and despite religious differences, we coexist happily. The Kalash have a wedding ritual where, after serving meals, the boy takes away the girl (bhaga k le jana). But it happens ""within"" their community. This doesn't imply that anyone else can come and say, "I want to bring you to my home," not even a Chitrali if he is not from the kalash community. The literacy rate in chitral is very high as compared to any other district of kpk. This huzaifa nizam is a prime example that our soil has the ability to produce many talents, intellectuals and heroes.
They want to mention everything even Buddhist, Jews but not Hinduism lol 😂 …This guy knows the truth but still pushing back lol.. guys who converted 300-400 yrs ago (aka talwar k zor pe salwar) are explaining us our history 😂
Also they criticizing everyone including British but not Islamic invasions and burning of taxalia university and demolishing others temples and recent Buddhists stupas by islamists!
Absofuckinglutely. Itne dishonest log hain. The hatred is so deep rooted they don't even realise people outside Pakistan can still sense it. Not our fault that these guys have been stripped down of all past and been indoctrinated with hindu hate.
Don't you indians feel insulted that you guys are imposing your history on a different nation and the people of that nation curse your Gods but still you beg them to recognise your history as theirs 😂😂
The way he explained that conversion to Islam was peaceful and gradual is a suspect. We have many monuments desecrated whether they are Hindu Buddhist,Jain or universities palaces, forts. A tale of destruction followed since the advent of Islam. He talks about sun temple in Multan but doesn't speak that it was destroyed by Muslims along with so many other rich heritage sites in your part of the india sub continent. All in all that part of history is explained much to smoothly to my liking. Suspect
People of indus valley civilization believed in idol worship, they used to worship trees, sun, earth and idols. If pakistanis are claiming indus valley civilization thay have to claims idol worshiping also, pakistanis have to claim pashupati/ lord shiva 😊 Pakistanis are so confused about their roots, sometimes they find their roots in arabs then turks.we hindus preserve that culture for thousands of years and now some bunch of converted pakistanis claiming that their😅 And this civilization could sustain for thousands of years because there was no islam that time😊
@@Pakistan-_-388 if you can't except pashupati/shiva seal, idol worship, worship of trees,sun,soil which were the core of that civilization then you have no authority to say that you are the one who should represent that ? All those above things that i have written are not about relegion but about the way of living, again I'm saying if you can't except pashupati/ idol worshiping which was an important part of that civilization then you don't have any authority to call that civilization urs. In short your ancestors discarded that civilization and except a foreign concept of living. The real questions should be why did ur ancestors forgot about their real roots and except a foreign concept of living ?? May be they were afraid of Muslims.
@@Pakistan-_-388What does pakistan 🇵🇰 has of its own?? ♦️ Names - Arabic ♦️Religion: Foreign invader's religion ☪️ , was forced by invaders & they sold their mothers to i☪️ invaders then converted ♦️Language: Urdu , its origin: UP 🇮🇳, & other languages like Sindhi Punjabi baloch etc are from sanskrit 🇮🇳 ♦️Clothes, origin india 🇮🇳 ♦️Food origin: india 🇮🇳 mainly Uttar Pradesh's cuisine ♦️History: India's 🇮🇳 ♦️Indus valley: indus ppl worshipping Hindu gods like Pashupati, ivc majority part is in 🇮🇳not 🇵🇰 ♦️Sindu river: origin 🇮🇳 😂whats pakistani🇵🇰 ???? Check origin of everything in your daily life , at least on Google. It will always say 🇮🇳
12:53 exactly In "rig veda Mandal 1 sukta 35 sloke 8" supt Sindhu word has used which means 7 rivers or 7 tributaries of Sindhu rivers. Now the point is how they came to word India on that region, in old Persian language( Zoroastrians-parsi ) the Persian used to pronounce word Sindhu as Hindu cause they didn't know how to pronounce later S that's why they called supt Sindhu as hupt Hindu they were not mentioned the river here but the all that geographic region only which were basin of Sindhu river and it's 1200BC old written in their holy book "Zend avesta" or "Zen daschta"
You both are right that that land belongs to you but that equally belongs to people who had to leave in partition . My ancestors moved from Jhang district to Jalandhar district . It happened on the both sides but the cause of this happened is religion which originally doesn’t belong to this land 😊
Fantastic podcast! An exploration of ancient civilizations and mysteries, focusing on Pakistan's legacy, is a winning combination. I hope there will be more episodes to explore other interesting aspects of our past.
As both Urdu literature and world fiction reader, I was always fascinated how much our Sufi folk concepts relate with traditional Chinese folk lore and old fiction stories. Listening about the relationship between different dynasties and the history of buddhism in Pakistan has made me realize a lot about why the concepts seem so much similar.
India is, the cradle of the human race, the birthplace of human speech, the mother of history, the grandmother of legend, and the great grand mother of tradition. - Mark Twain
@@ProudMurtadtunnis are only in India but madarsachaap andhnamazis are in 57 islamic countries. So there are more madarsachaap and andhnamazis than tunnis
India me Class 9 se ancient India studies (history section of social science) me ye sab padhaya jata hai. This makes young Indians awar of his/her identity. It ensures that no amount of crisis can uproot indian identity.
@@zsa2000kisne bol nhi h . Every history book mention them abe repetitive ho gya issiliye syallabus kaam kiya . Jaise 9 th mein padha toh 11th mein bhi wahi padna h . Issiliye kaam kiya remove nhi kiya .
2:00:02 spot onnnnnnnnnnnn this mixing of culture was in sindh because it was all over india till 1947 !!!! It still continues in india but has stopped in paskistan !!!!!
@@HeliosKapiro you don't need to be from Europe to knoe what is happening in Europe. The point is about hindu hate that is taught in pakistani textbooks while textbooks in india teach communal harmony and brotherhood of mankind. Religion is not even taught. This feeling of brotherhood was prevalent in pakistan as well till 1947 but post independence, pakistan leadership including maulvis and leaders like zia ul haq have preached hatred for the hindus to the extent that minorities in pakistan have dropped from 17 percent in 1947 to less than 2 percent today. In india minorities have flourished and have increased both in percentage and number that theybare leaders of our country today. That's y u don't see any minorities around u because they have been converted or killed by an islamized radicalized society. Your media also cannot speak against the army because they will be abducted whereas india is a free liberal society where u can criticize anything and anyone. The recent killing of Christians and the rigged elections in pakistan are proof of what pak is and where it is heading. You may not like it but these are hard facts. All 4 wars against india have been initiated by pak and then lost by pak. Despite that, india hate and hindu hate is preached. Kashmir is a contentious issue but doesn't justify 4 wars and cross border terrorism killing millions of kashmiris on the india side. Till you don't educate children in pakistan, nothing will change.
Forced conversion toh tera gangadesh mein bhi ho rahe hai gharwapsi k Naam pe, 2008 kandhamal christian massacre hua tab hazaaro christians ko forcefully convert Kiya tha dinduo ne, history ki toh baat karo he Mat, pata nahi Kitne Buddhists ko maara or convert kiya Hoga Tum logo ne
Being an Indian, I used to think that there would be some logical and knowledgeable people in Pakistan who would have been isolated, but now I am able to understand that those whom Pakistani people consider as so-called intellectuals are nothing but Wikipedians with half-baked knowledge and Conspiracy theory believers and they are imaginary intellectuals who live in an imaginary world of their own. Finding intellectuals in Pakistan is like finding a pearl in the desert which will never be found.
if you’re brave enough to call someone a conspiracy theorist or a fake intellectual than why don’t you show us your level of education by countering our facts? oh you can’t! because your brain is filled with nothing more than RSS propaganda 😂😂
To claim ownership of one's history, one must show reverence for it. I oppose his view on the voluntary adoption of Islam in the Indian subcontinent. The majority were either coerced into conversion or did so for personal gain. It's challenging for Muslims in the subcontinent to acknowledge that their forebears were adherents of Hinduism or Buddhism.
Acha bhai we were coerced. Ab kia chahty ho ab to tum coerce ker rhy ho hamien change kerny k liye. Bhai dekh filhaal hamien islam appeal kerta hay tm apni zindagi jiyo or apny kam sa kam rkho. Ok?
I think present day muslims who were "coerced into conversion" also have Internet access and can read yet they are still choosing to be muslims even after all these years so what's your problem?? Im soo happy my ancestors accepted islam that's all that matters. Stop this forced to convert bs. Also side note when a non muslim accepts islam we don't call them "converts" but rather "reverts".
@@kankan5927 that's the thing. U guys got converted and now act as superior and try to convert others. Minorities har jahag mushkil mein hai but the fact is ki hindus kisi ko convert nhi karte na hi Esa koi concept hai but guys do .jis din tumlog Sach mein ye Maan loge ki tum forcefully ya for profit convert hue the maybe tab ye conversion band kar doge..again my comment is not Islam vs hindu. But it is for the followers of both the religion
@@Deira854 Making up words, making up identity. Indians have countless books that speaks about the land you call Pakistan dating before common era. You don't have one. Go and do some research on the net. Read western historians if you like. Net is not just for porn.
Crazy how he seems to have read all books by Muslim and foreign authors about Indian subcontinent except the very books that are one of the oldest known works of literature from the subcontinent. He might have actually learnt something new other than merely trying to understand his own land through the eyes of people foreign to it themselves. 🤦♂️🤷♂️
People should be praising the knowledge gained from the video instead of arguing about religions and cultures. What a gem this guy is. So young yet his knowledge is off the charts.
@@WajahhaiNaJanga Where does bias-ness factor into just getting knowledge? You are getting to learn about trade routes, different cultures, how people went about their business in older civilizations. The whole part about bias-ness is just isn't part of the conversation. People, specifically of neighborhood countries are getting triggered uselessly. Just watch it and learn a few things, why get into arguments over something that has already happened hundreds of years ago? Sounds very trivial to me.
Iam an Arab in UAE who has interacted with Pakistanis and Indians for the past decade. I more or less understand the language Hindi / Urdu which are very similar... Arabs conquered the Afghans and iranians and converted them to Islam. Arabs also conquered Sindh and thus conversion to Islam began. Pakistanis and Indian Muslims whose ancestors were undeniably Hindu/ Buddhist like to call themselves Arabs/ Turks is because they don't want to accept that their Ancestors were Defeated. It brings a sense of Inferiority Complex to them... Also, Babar who started Mughal empire was an Uzbek ( Central Asian). Muslims of India ( including Pakistan) were governed by foreigner Muslims 99.9% of the time...
urdu is only the national language of pakistan as a lingua franca to unite us all, that doesnt mean we are same with indians. we pakistanis first speak our mother tongue panjabi, sindhi, pashto, balochi, kashmiri only found in pakistan not in india except the panjabis of india but theyre a minority in india. pakistani ancestors before islam was buddhist, zoroastrain and pagans , no one in pakistan calls themselves turks or arabs. we dont have an !nf3r!0rity complex we are all proud of our ethnicities different from indians lol . we pakistanis arent indian muslims we share one ethnicitiy wit india the panjabis and theyre a minority in india and genetically different from other indians. we pakistanis were converted by arabs in the 8th century and sufi preachers in the 11th century . may god guide us all
Before the Islamization of the northwestern frontier of the subcontinent, the people and cultures in that region shared a common history, as evidenced by references to Gandhara in the Mahabharata. While the current demographic differences between nations may be significant, it is essential to acknowledge the deep-rooted similarities in the ancient history of the subcontinent. Regardless of the labels used, it is widely recognized that the region once boasted a rich and prestigious ancient civilization predating any Abrahamic religion. Therefore, it is fair to assert that this civilization was not inherently tied to Abrahamic ideologies. lastly Kudos to Huzaifa for bringing and taking a pride in his own culture. All the best, Brother for your pursuit. Love and respect from India.
He is not taking pride in Indian culture. He is dropping subtle hints again and again. He is a Muslim supermacist. He is saying that all the intellectual property produced by the ancient people of North Western Bharat is of today's Pakistan. Why we Indians are so naive. And can't see hatred eyes for us in their eyes.
@@Vk-sk7nm I dont agree with you. The thing is that even in India if you go to south people regardless of religion take pride in their history. But in north india ethnicity is not valued as much as religion. People of punjab and sindh should take pride in their past regardless of their religion.
@@zainsepticeye upanishad. BTW 8000 yr temple found in saudi(verify it on google) and islam came in 1400.(stop blsshit claims of adam eve come to archelogical evidences, show a single proof of islam before 1400, just sanchi stupa is older than islam 8tself 😂😂😂)
What an absolute gem of a video. This should be shown in every single history and culture classroom in Pakistan. The government should officially patronise and spread all this information. There is far too much knowledge, nuance and vocabulary thats so crucial to understanding the whole conversation and context around Pakistani history, and how it unfortunately gets lost and unclaimed, instead claimed by our neighbours. I hope this video, and every single post and article by Huzaifa never ever gets lost and remains on the internet forever. I hope it gets published in books and media programmes throughout the country. Pakistan needs some serious work done on recognising and being proud of all this. Instead we accept a very defeatist and self-loathing attitude, often stemming from current political/economical frustrations, which is unfair to do.
@@Pakistan-_-388There was india, indica, Al hind, hindustan throughout history. There was never a Pakistan as even the concept of Pakistan never existed before 1930s. Even the present Pakistani territories were seen as hindustan only.
@@mukundmathers aur wo indica hamare Indus ko dia gya tha Greeks ne 😂 aur Tum is British ke diye huye India ko usse link de rahe ho Sirf Naam adopt Karne se ban jaoge Malik?
@@mukundmathers India bhi yahi generate hua Hindustan bhi aur hum real word use karte hai hind India nahi India kabhi bhi accept nhi kia humne na hi kabhi official Naam tha Tumne to bas Naam churaya hai and Pakistan is Indus valley real Hindustan dot.
@@Pakistan-_-388 1. Indus flows through India also. 2. India or hindustan was land beyond the indus stretching till bay of Bengal and Indian Ocean. 3. So you agree Pakistan is hindustan only?
He's quite an amateur - can you bring professional historians instead. He believes Patna or even Chandigarh has nothing to do with Gandhara for example. It's amusing. His opinions are coming not out of any academic insights but purely an emotional reaction to not getting global respect as a Pakistani. He needs to introspect because this won't take him too far. He's making the same mistake as previous Pakistan Studies - looking at history through an ideological agenda.
He gave the perfect counter reaction to how Indians claim history from our part of the land as theirs. Nothing wrong with that aspect. He is talking strictly from Pakistan's point of view and our OWN history from our part of the subcontinent. If you don't want to agree on that, that is a separate issue. Watch Ranveer Allahbadia's podcast if you want to hear what you already believe.
@@haziqajmxl nothing wrong with talking about history from a Sindhi, Panjabi or Balochi point of view. But to project modern borders to history and to say for example that Chandigarh region has no link with Gandhara region, etc. because the Radcliffe line passes inbetween is laughable.
@@noirdezzir8424 That is what he is saying. What happened in Chandigarh during Gandhara period is Chandigarh's or India's history. But what happened in our part of the that civilization is that region's or Pakistan's history.
@@talaltariqq_😂 pakistanis and their toxicity towards indians. 😂 indians are definitely not pakistani, our history is not shit like urs , we didnt do stuff like 1971 or giving shelter to terrorism
32:49 there is a book named BRIHATKATHAKOSHA written by gunadaya during gupta age , majority of its stories were similar to 101 arabian nights , and one of the story of sindbad was also mentioned in that book. Majority of historians believed that brihatkathakosha was the original text.
This guy is talking about history of thousands of years and using boundaries of today. On what basis he separates India and Pakistan in that period when there is no mountain range, no river between India and Pakistan. Harappa is just 80 Km away from India. You will reach India from Mohenjodaro in half the time you would take to reach Islamabad. These guys are seriously confused. Stick to calling yourself Arab mate. It's sounds less ignorant.
1:57:32 Moses Somake (6 June 1875 - 6 April 1947) was a British architect known for designing several prominent buildings in British India. His works, built before the Partition of British India and located in modern-day Pakistan, include the Edward House, BVS Parsi High School, Karachi Goan Association building, Khaliq Dina Hall, Mules Mansion and Quaid-e-Azam House.
Pakistan has large population of Sindhi and Punjabi speaking people but most the Sindhis in Pakistan can't read or write Sindhi (Khudabadi Script) and Punjabis don't know Punjabi (Gurmukhi) script.
Shukar hai mai in dono mai sai nahi ho 💪💪💪💪or maire aik hazar generations mai sai koi indian nahi hai na baap ki generation mai say na maa ki phir bhi is waqt mai Pakistani 🇵🇰 ho
@@UmairKhan-ht4ku Bhai proud moment hai tere liye bhai. Matlab tu kisi acche desh paranth ka hoga par tere hi purwajo ke karmo ne tje shithole P0rkistan me daal diya. Warna Arab ya Iran me hota. Kya hi baat hoti thi.
@@pkroninverse7307No it was always united as a single grand civilisation with a number of local manifestations to it. So even if not politically, it was always united culturally and religiously(Hinduism and other dharmic religions like Buddhism,Jainism,etc.)for a large part of history.
2:39:53 - During my childhood, I have seen PTV drams about Islamic wars as well as Islamic scientists. Though the content wasn't verifiable (owing to my limited knowledge), at least this was an attempt back in the days.
There is a ashoka's house or rest place in kotli pakistan side jammukashmir basically it is made by cutting the whole mountain if u look it looks marvelous and sorry for bad english.❤
This is benevolent revisionism, I understand the attempt being made , but a sizeable chunk of punjabis and Sindhis live here , a lot of people for up , Bihar went there . And unlike Pakistan we don’t have Stockholm syndrome for our invaders .
Biharis and other Indian races only make about 7 percent of our total population I wouldn't call that a "SIZEABLE CHUNK" and there is no revisionism, we are simply just acknowledging our history, OUR HISTORY, not our fault that every huge thing that happened, along with your religion and your religious places, heroes, folklore all took place in our homeland, the homeland we call PAKISTAN
@junaid - Out of all the videos I have watched on your channel, this video is the most beautiful, valuable and informative video you have ever ever and ever made. Thank you both.
Al Bureni and Al khwarizmi discoveries were heavily influenced by Indian treaties like Surya Siddhanta and other treaties by Mathematicians and astronomers like Bhaskara, Brahmagupt, Aryabhatta etc.
He is choosing ethnic identity rather than cultural and civilizational identity.Hindu philosophy i.e all 9 philosophy born in India starting with 6 Vedic philosophies(defined today as Hinduism) Buddhism,Jainism and Carvaka has played the most important role in defining the culture and civilization of Indian Subcontinent bcoz it amalgamated with local ethnic identities to form a large umbrella called Hindu Civilization.His knowledge about Ancient Indian history is based on books by biased leftist and secular historians of India like romila thapar,William dalrymple,Irfan Habib,Ram Guha,Shashi tharoor who tried their best to remove hindu civilizational identity of Indian through propaganda like Aryan invasion theory and many other which have been scientifically disapproved.Read the book by Sanjeev Sanyal "Land of the seven rivers" to understand the cultural and civilizational continuity of Hindu Civilization from Indus valley civilization till now.
Even if it got only 100k views, don't be disappointed junaid and keep doing such long form informative videos, these videos will go in millions one day
he is narrating a another type of pak studies , if hindu politician were cunning then they would have expelled all muslim from india but muslim population in india exploded from 3 crore to 21 crore isnpite of voting of Pakistan and Bangladesh
Correction: White Huns attacked the Kushan Empire, the White Huns were entirely different from the European Huns (Atilla) which attacked the Western Roman Empire.
He is trying so hard to justify that his ancestors accepted islam on their own by giving logic that he wakes up at night to perform some ritual by his own free will. If you are forcefully converted to be hindu today, after two generation your grandson will wake to perform puja by his own free will.
Us Dor me Bhi Fast Communication ke jariye the.. Aino ki Chamak or Rat ko Aag jalakar code language ke jariye.. Kabitaron ke jariye.. Or Badalte Ghodo ke Jariye.. Ak Kahawat hai ki Sindh ke Business lords 1 Din me hi China Tak Sandesh Pocha Sakte the .. Or Badalte Ghodon ke Jariye .. 1 Din or Raat me hi 1000km door Sandesh or saman pohchaya ja sakta tha.. par ye Facility sabke pass nahi thi .
Absolutely wonderful interview. I have also been a fan of Huzaifa for many years. It is truly sad that as a people we lack curiosity. And i mean not just Pakistanis but Muslims everywhere including the west ( perhaps to a lesser degree). I recently traveled to Egypt and the entire tourism industry is geared towards Europeans. It makes sense to some degree given the financial reach and allure of Ancient egypt. But there were almost negligible Muslim tourists, thus none of the tours focus even slightly on the Islamic history of this region. Similarly in Pakistan our entire focus is on “Pahaari beauty “, neglecting our very rich Archeological heritage. This is a goldmine waiting to be opened
Today he is cutting down the history to his region of India to give Pakistanis an identity, a few years he will have to cut ✂️ history to punjab only because nothing else will be left of them.😊 ❤ from the holy birth land of the great emperor Bharata.
Totally misleading fact🤦🇮🇳🇵🇰 Aap ne expert ne kitane Ancient literature read kiya hai 🤷 The Vishnu Purana mentions: ऋषभो मरुदेव्याश्च ऋषभात् भरतो भवेत्। भरताद् भारतं वर्षं, भरतात् सुमतिस्त्वभूत्॥ Rishabha was born to Marudevi, Bharata was born to Rishabha, Bhāratavarṣa arose from Bharata and Sumati arose from Bharata. -Vishnu Purana (2,1,31) ततश्च भारतं वर्षमेतल्लोकेषुगीयते। भरताय यत: पित्रा दत्तं प्रतिष्ठिता वनम्॥ (विष्णु पुराण, २,१,३२) This country is known as Bhāratavarṣa since the times the father entrusted the kingdom to the son Bharata and he himself went to the forest for ascetic practices.[30] -Vishnu Purana (2,1,32) uttaraṃ yatsamudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam varṣaṃ tadbhārataṃ nāma bhāratī yatra santatiḥ उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम्। वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र सन्ततिः॥ "The country (varṣam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhārata; there dwell the descendants of Bharata."
@@thesololeveller7175 the swastika symbol first appears in the archaeological record around 3000 BCE in the Indus Valley Civilisation. Today's Hindus or Buddhist Community warship Swastika.
@@thesololeveller7175 The earliest evidence of Yoga is recorded on the Harappan seals of the Indus Valley or the Sindhu-Saraswati Civilisation by renowned archaeologist John Marshall in the early 20th century.
@@himanshuvinaykumarvishwaka9299 me sitting cross legged doesn't constitute yoga, furthermore the language used by the Harappans has not even be deciphered yet.
Kuch shake nhi ho rha h bhai. Haa par usko ye podcast ke baad bht taleef Hui thi. Exam jane wala tha bechare.....par bachh gya issi bade aadmi ne setting lgai toh. Usko apne desh ki reality ussi din mill gai thi. Par vo hai besharam fhr se kisi podcast pr jayega aur prapanch karega. Aur jo log apni padhai likhai ko le kar serious nhi hote h voi log exam ke pehle ye bakchodi krte hai.
@@AliHussain-wq4zrbeta jitna bhi ertugrul ghazi dekhlo lekin rahoge tum hum hinduo ki hi aulaade 😂🤣 Aur kaise convert hua hai puri duniya jaanti hai 😂
@@AliHussain-wq4zr Bhai padhai kr liya karo..... RU-vidrs ki kahi suni baat pr mat chala karo. Indus river India se ho kar hi Pakistan me jati hai. Kya hai ye? Abhi itni chhoti chhoti baat b batani padegi kya aap ko?
who give a fuck about fake historian he doesnt even have credintials of being a historian, as a historian these wild claims doesnt have any value in the community history and historians
