Andy's death is super moving, and from the character's point of view, I understand that he would rather stay dead than put Prue at risk. But technically, the sisters could risk making a new loop: with Phoebe's power, they would have understood even faster. The problem is Rodriguez's unpredictable actions: how do you know he wasn't going to act completely differently the fourth time around? If they had had more experience, they would have been able to create a spell to retain their memories after the rewind. In retrospect, it gives even more weight to Piper's thoughts in season 4. When she reflects on her life, she thinks that if they had had their powers from childhood, they would have been much more powerful and competent. Here, it is typically a situation that experienced witches would have handled without problem.
The most spectacular episode in the show,that repeating the same they 3 times,first time Phoebe dies,second she and Piper and finally Andy😢 There is no show like this today, really amazing episode with Tempus about déjà vu and destiny.I think there was no more reseting time because Andy was meant to die,it must happened like in a Phoebe's vision, incredible episode that deserved Oscar👑
Hated this. The Charmed Ones had the smarts and the power to figure this out. Don’t blame Prue one bit for thinking they didn’t try hard enough to save him. Killing Andy off after 1 season was a mistake. Prue had nothing to do with herself for the next 2 seasons, no wonder they killed her off too.
Agreed, no love interest, they brought in after Andy held a candle to him. Just as Leo is Pipers soul mate, Andy was Prue's. Had Andy not died, I think he would have left the Police to become a private eye or something similar. So he could help them without breaking the rules and would come around to marrying Prue. A piece of Pure died with Andy. I could even see Andy, Leo, and Henry all being close because they would be mortals with extremely powerful witch wives.
This is season 1 and they were still newbie witches, but the biggest reason for Andy having to die (other than the actor leaving) is that as we’ve seen in other episodes, when death comes for you it’s because it’s your time. This is simple how (the angel of) ‘Death’ operates, nothing the sisters did would’ve made a difference.
Andy Trudeau he's always be my Big brother I'm crying 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔 because he's dead gone forever ♾️♾️♾️♾️♾️♾️♾️ I gonna miss you 😘💕💕❤️❤️😍😍 Buddy 😭😭💔💔😘 you always be my one of my favorites as ever I always love you 2 much but at least you always be the most popular greatest and legendary of all times I hope Prue hallowell she will reunited with you Forever and she will always gonna have U in her life and put her arms around you also she will love and misses you 2 much but after when Prue hallowell dies
Andy is so annoying. He literally could've let Prue and her sisters handle it but he felt the need to swoop in to save the day. I always found that so aggravating about him. He could've been alive all this time had he just listened.
