Тёмный

Arab Israelis: How are you different from West Bank Palestinians? 

Corey Gil-Shuster
Подписаться 328 тыс.
Просмотров 176 тыс.
50% 1

HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...

Опубликовано:

 

25 апр 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,5 тыс.   
@saraearriazola4915
@saraearriazola4915 8 месяцев назад
i’ve watched Hours of this channel since oct 7th and think it’s important for everyone following this conflict to watch these interviews they are incredibly insightful
@allo5170
@allo5170 7 месяцев назад
Muhammed chasing the jews out of their LAND Why are Muslims worldwide now hating the jews as they become a nation once again Jami` at-Tirmidhi 1606 Narrated 'Umar bin Al-Khattab: That the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "If I live - if Allah wills - I will expel the Jews and the Christians from the Arabian Peninsula." Sahih al-Bukhari 4557 Narrated Abu Huraira: The Verse:--"You (true Muslims) are the best of peoples ever raised up for mankind." means, the best of peoples for the people, as you bring them with chains on their necks till they embrace Islam. Sahih Muslim 22 It has been narrated on the authority of Abdullah b. 'Umar that the Messenger of Allah said: I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify that there is no god but Allah, that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah, and they establish prayer, and pay Zakat and if they do it, their blood and property are guaranteed protection on my behalf except when justified by law, and their affairs rest with Allah. Surah (9:29): “Fight against Christians and Jews until they pay the tribute readily, being brought low.” Surah 5:51 O ye who believe! Take not the Jews and the Christians for friends. They are friends one to another. He among you who taketh them for friends is (one) of them. Lo! Allah guideth not wrongdoing folk. - English Translation (Pickthall) THE WAY OUT Christ Jesus the way, the truth, the life Peace, Love, Forgiveness JESUS CHRIST IS COMING SOON REPENT.
@MAZ440
@MAZ440 7 месяцев назад
That's not exactly true. It should be taken into account that on the Israeli side there is freedom of speech (for Jews and Arabs of course) and on the Palestinian side there isn't.
@KnafaLover
@KnafaLover 7 месяцев назад
@@MAZ440 "Freedom of Speech" As Israel arrests professors who say they shouldn't be killing civilians, and as they mass arrest thousands of palestinians in the west bank for liking tweets and changing whatsapp status's to "May god protest us all" Give us a fucking break.
@guccidonbuzzflightyear4440
@guccidonbuzzflightyear4440 7 месяцев назад
@@MAZ440a lot of them stay hidden
@MAZ440
@MAZ440 7 месяцев назад
@@guccidonbuzzflightyear4440 yes, I know. If it is not something that will put them in trouble they can answer what they want. By the way, even in the Arab Israeli community is the same. They can't say whatever is on their mind if it is not according to what's dictated in their community. You have a video on this channel of a Jewish guy who speaks in Arabic and he seems to capture the mentality very well. I only saw comments that agreed with him and also the people who were in charge of the translation agreed with what he said.
@stevendzik7312
@stevendzik7312 Год назад
The first difference I noticed when I was in Israel was that many Arab Israeli women dressed in western clothes and East Jerusalem and the West Bank women almost all dressed modestly and wore a hair covering. The Arabs in this video seemed more relaxed than the people in the West Bank I've seen in other videos.
@miavogel4903
@miavogel4903 Год назад
Not every Arab is a Muslim ! There also Christians.
@stevendzik7312
@stevendzik7312 Год назад
@@miavogel4903 I am well aware of that, however, the vast majority of Arabs on both sides are Muslim.
@user-we4ih1tp7n
@user-we4ih1tp7n Год назад
@@miavogel4903 sure. and in israel you even have christians who dare to identify as non arabs but assyriacs,arameans and armenians. but i know many women of bigger clans which are traditionally "muslim" who dress in western style and study in jewish universities and live outside traditional norms common among west bank palestinians. evident even in modeling and acting careers among them,and revealing/nudity photograpghs.
@ef2718
@ef2718 Год назад
@@miavogel4903 900 Christians under Hamas. 45,000 under the PA. 185,000 citizens of Israel.
@shainazion4073
@shainazion4073 Год назад
@@miavogel4903 Christians are 2% of the Palestinians. Almost 98% are Muslims.
@NoNeedJustFeed
@NoNeedJustFeed 8 месяцев назад
In these horrible times of war, our israeli arab brothers have shown great compassion to us, the jews, i have tears from each story i hear about the help they give us. Btw, arabs where also murdered by hamas on octover 7th. Thank you. I wish we could live in peace togather, inside israel and seperated with a palestinian state
@zizozzoziz6720
@zizozzoziz6720 8 месяцев назад
No the only solution is having one state with two prime ministers for each nation and hope they get along
@SRNK...2127
@SRNK...2127 7 месяцев назад
oh shut up YOU OCCUPIERS they don't have a choice but to be "nice" .... you lot are being exposed all over the world and soon you'll all be going to Europe where home is for you lot!
@okeydokey2293
@okeydokey2293 7 месяцев назад
Yeah... Israel provided financial aid to Gaza, and Hamas used it for military purposes instead of helping the civilians. Now, people are complaining that Israel stopped providing aid. You really can't satisfy people ah
@greyngreyer5
@greyngreyer5 7 месяцев назад
@@siimply_mee But you have THAT on the one side, and you have people excusing and cheering Hamas on the other. You also have the fact that the "Aid" was in goodwill. So no matter how you spin it, you cannot pin this on Israel.
@guccidonbuzzflightyear4440
@guccidonbuzzflightyear4440 7 месяцев назад
@@siimply_meeit makes sense to not want the PA on both sides they are just as much hellbent on the destruction of Israel just slightly less likely to crash out.
@oleanderpink4505
@oleanderpink4505 10 месяцев назад
I’ve been to Israel and I can’t tell the difference between Muslims and Jews much less where someone is from. They are all yelling all the time and have good hearts. The outside media lies. Most people live in peace and have friends on both sides, I’ve seen this.
@domhamai
@domhamai 8 месяцев назад
Most humans want peace. But our governments don’t represent us. You see the western people, they all support Palestine and want to see them liberated and given justice, yet the governments egg Israel on to commit genocide. In the same way, most Israelis don’t want to oppress the Palestinians or commit genocide, but the government is hell bent on ethnic cleaning and mass murder.
@tiltantheluckyone
@tiltantheluckyone 8 месяцев назад
you should watch his video where he interviews arabs from the west bank. they want to expel all the jews from israel, except one of them who was chill. Israeli arabs are living in israel like jews, but when problems occur, 50% of them have identity crisis and they cause problems. then, it's hard to differentiate between friend and foe which was what the guy at 10:50 was referring to. But the only thing he got half wrong is the thing about the police, the police in israel can be brutal to everyone, jews and arabs alike. they only treat the people of tel aviv nicely, but they shit on everyone else.
@sbaumgartner9848
@sbaumgartner9848 8 месяцев назад
Have you been to Gaza or the West Bank? Or the seen the Ultra-Orthodox Jews in Israel? The atmosphere would be different especially in Gaza and in the Ultra Orthodox Jewish areas of Israel and in Jerusalem (West Bank).
@MAZ440
@MAZ440 7 месяцев назад
The average Israeli is not the extreme Orthodox community as there are in certain areas of Jerusalem/Bnei Brak. @@sbaumgartner9848
@tamaramuratova9536
@tamaramuratova9536 7 месяцев назад
Oleanderpink👍👍👍
@alexseo9305
@alexseo9305 Год назад
hey man, this is a great project. dont stop!
@didd2810
@didd2810 Год назад
You know what! I was just searching about Israeli Arabs, curious about their conflict of identity with the Palestinians and then this pops up. Thank you, Corey!
@ask825
@ask825 Год назад
First of all they are not Israeli Arabs they are Palestinians living in Israel. You can’t just come to a land and strip away people‘s identity
@deborahbluhm8828
@deborahbluhm8828 Год назад
@@ask825 Well technically and ironically if the colonizing Roman Empire hadn’t changed the name when they conquered the Kingdom of Israel and the Kingdom of Judah they would all be Israelis! Palestine was a name given to the geographical area of the land not a people. Arafat coined the term for them in 67 but before that they were just known as Turks or Arabs and Jews. The Arab caliphate conquered first in the 7th century so they aren’t an indigenous tribe.
@ask825
@ask825 Год назад
@@deborahbluhm8828 great Paragraph. It doesn’t change the fact of colonialism and apartheid.
@deborahbluhm8828
@deborahbluhm8828 Год назад
@@ask825 Thanks ☺️ What colonisation? You can’t technically colonise your own homeland also they were penniless refugees at the time, there was no colonial entity like an empire, sultanate or caliphate etc. straight out of the KGB handbook. Arafat was schooled there and did a dissertation on Holocaust denial 😵‍💫 Also there’s no apartheid, thatl a lie as well. The corrupt UN had to change the definition of Apartheid completely to use it on Israel btw of which they gave them 15 resolutions last year, Russia 6, USA 1, North Korea 1, Nigeria 1 Syria 1, Iran 1. Bearing in mind that Israel kills a few hundred a year, mostly terrorists, and the rest kill multiple thousands of their own citizens. Check their fatality rates. They have banned foreign press and control their own media so it amplifies Israel to make them a scapegoat for their own atrocities.
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 Год назад
​@@ask825 roman and british imperialism.
@jonstnr
@jonstnr 8 месяцев назад
You're doing amazing work man!
@BigSana25
@BigSana25 Год назад
Super interesting video. Love this channel!
@mmalf
@mmalf 8 месяцев назад
Great impartial journalism! Wonderful to get the perspective of everyday people. It’s a start to a solution for peace.
@maxs.5112
@maxs.5112 Год назад
4:04 "There aren't many differences" The dude is wearing a (awesome) fedora!
@dribbens91
@dribbens91 Год назад
As an Israeli, the first thing that comes to mind is, "you are different 1st thing by speaking Hebrew almost fluently".
@mounafmakhlouf6665
@mounafmakhlouf6665 Месяц назад
The difference is: some people have some rights, the others have much less rights. Israhell controls the life of the palestinian in the west bank, but just while refusing to give them rights. Neo apartheid if you may.
@dribbens91
@dribbens91 Месяц назад
@@mounafmakhlouf6665 you are correct! Would you mind say thank you to your pedophile prophet? Let him teach us some about rights and moral. LoL
@MsBhappy
@MsBhappy 26 дней назад
​​@@mounafmakhlouf6665it seems you haven't watched the videos on this channel asking about apartheid and asking which government they'd prefer. The laws in Gaza and the West Bank are horrendous and that's not on Israeli leadership.
@user-jt3fp8yc6p
@user-jt3fp8yc6p 10 дней назад
@@mounafmakhlouf6665the Palestinians in West Bank and Gaza have their own governments and if they wanted to live better they wouldn’t commit terror attacks against Jews every day
@envt
@envt Год назад
Love the project
@Gamemake
@Gamemake 7 месяцев назад
“The problem is not with the people, it’s with the leaders” 100% true.
@judymckee5992
@judymckee5992 7 месяцев назад
It is islam that is the problem, Domination.
@mottom2657
@mottom2657 6 месяцев назад
@@judymckee5992 As if Christians didn't try to dominate the world? As if Jews aren't dominating?
@---tx9xx
@---tx9xx 6 месяцев назад
Nope, problem is the ppl. The leaders are representative of them in this case.
@lucascreediv1283
@lucascreediv1283 5 месяцев назад
@@judymckee5992the people under occupation are Muslim you bigot
@985476246845
@985476246845 5 месяцев назад
i've seen enough of these videos to say its the people too, not just the leaders. almost everyone are dead set on conquering Israel from the Jews and expelling them all.
@mangoWHOAman
@mangoWHOAman Год назад
Thank you so much for this video. I especially liked the longer conversations with people who opened up more, it's nicer to watch than those short more rash conversations.
@LiranZamir
@LiranZamir 4 месяца назад
Thank you for making those interviews
@ashleykasim6873
@ashleykasim6873 6 месяцев назад
Thank you for this insightful video.
@Eliana3173
@Eliana3173 8 месяцев назад
Great sources and interviews. Thank you for sharing. It gives us great insight to how the arabs think.
@liselotte1474
@liselotte1474 Год назад
I recognize, that Arab Israelis speak English well in contrast to West Bank Palestinians
@frenkli9815
@frenkli9815 Год назад
Probably because of different education systems in both places
@Makib99
@Makib99 Год назад
that's not true. as a Palistinians in Israel (Arab Israeli), we speak English as a third language after Arabic and Hebrew. and only the young generation speak it well. while Palestinians in West bank and Gaza speak it very well as it is the second language for them.
@idan895
@idan895 Год назад
​@@Makib99Interesting, I actually thought that your'e learning Hebrew as a third language. I'm Jewish from Israel and few months ago my school had a meeting with a school from Qalansawe and we actually had to speak English with them because many of them barely knew Hebrew
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 Год назад
​@@idan895 qalansawa is not part of the PA. The kids there dont speak hebrew because they dont recognize je ws as humans.
@idan895
@idan895 Год назад
@@dogbert52 qalansawa is an Arab city in Israel. The learn Hebrew in schools and the majority of the adults speak Hebrew
@invictoveritas3956
@invictoveritas3956 Год назад
Corey, thank you !
@loveandmercy9664
@loveandmercy9664 Год назад
The last guy is wrong. You don't get the full Bible from the Qu'ran. The Qu'ran doesn't have a narrative structure so many nuances and the historical contexts are lost. Especially regarding Jesus.
@naceraher9632
@naceraher9632 Год назад
lol
@omryr
@omryr Год назад
I just discovered a new iteration that says Jews were right all along, it’s better because it also has the Quran in it
@gg6886
@gg6886 7 месяцев назад
Quran is copied verses from Jewish and Cristian books.
@Butterscotchbutt
@Butterscotchbutt 8 месяцев назад
This is a great video for the people that conflate Arabs, Muslims, and Palestinians. None of these are interchangeable. Arabs have had a long history in the Levant before the arrival of Islam. The Nabataean kingdom ruled over Jordan, southern Palestine, and Sinai for a whole millennium before Muslims ever set foot in the area. Another example would be the Ghassanid kingdom, which was a Christian Arab kingdom over vast areas of the region. Keep in mind many ancient Jews converted to other religions to avoid expulsion/death. Another important distinction is that conquests under Arab rulers made it law that the language of the state would be Arabic. Compared to European colonialism of the new world, where the native population was mostly eradicated to make place for the invaders, instead the conquered people were mixing with and coming to identify as their conquerors without being physically removed, if not as Arabs, then as Muslims. These are still some of the same indigenous people living there who changed how they identified over time. This includes the descendants of every group that has ever called that land their home. When regions change rulers, they don’t normally change populations.
@hishamalaker491
@hishamalaker491 Месяц назад
Expulsion and death by the crusaders right? Even Jewish sources claim that Crusaders kicked them out even when they were living with Muslims in Jerusalem and Spain while the Muslims either Accepted the jewish refugees from Spain and before that when Salahudin liberated Jerusalem he re-allowed to go there since they couldnt under the crusaders. I read that from a Jewish source btw, not a hippy one a pro-israeli one. They admit that Muslims throughout history helped them while Europeans genocided them, the Roman Europeans created the diaspora, the Byzantiums prosecuted them, the Crusaders genocided them in Jerusalem alongside the Muslims, The first crusade btw was in Europe along the rhine against Jewish civilians. They were expelled repeatedly from England and most of western Europe, The Spaniards kicked every jew out who had done well for themselfs in Al-andalus (Muslim spain) while the Muslim Ottomans accepted them as refugees when the catholic spaniards decided they dont belong there anymore. The Pogroms in Russia were no mistake but on purpose and finally the holocaust. Then after a millenia of living together the arabs decided to expell them out of well idiocy because they supplied Israel with neccesarry population to re-settle ethnically cleansed lands in 1948. So riddle me this, After a thousand f*cking years what suddenly made the arabs hate the jews? Tell me? Its pretty obvious you dont know? Its zionism.
@davidtrak2679
@davidtrak2679 Год назад
Loved the one at 11:00. Yeah, when there's no problems, everything is great. When there'e bad stuff happening, bad stuff happens
@yaronfeldberg
@yaronfeldberg 11 месяцев назад
🤣
@Anisky123
@Anisky123 8 месяцев назад
It’s so true. These guys were all telling the truth.
@michaelh5442
@michaelh5442 6 месяцев назад
Yea he was speaking facts. Having lived in Yafo for a long time, thats exactly how it is. Day to day, we all get along great, but when bad things are happening it feels really tense. You kinda get the feeling like people just want to fight you, and that probably goes both ways. Its unfortunate.
@user-xd6nc6rg7b
@user-xd6nc6rg7b 4 месяца назад
He means that people live normally, and then when problems happen, the Israelis’ masks come off and they show how they really feel. On a normal day, they stop in his shop, buy some food, and talk about the weather. On a bad day, they try to provoke him so they can beat him to death using his reaction as justification. It wasn’t hard to understand him.
@valeried7210
@valeried7210 7 месяцев назад
Amazing how different the answers are for this one.
@mmalf
@mmalf 8 месяцев назад
Thanks!
@makouras
@makouras 4 месяца назад
This is one of Corey's most insightful and interesting videos. And I believe the Arab Israeli's perspective can give an outsider a very thorough look into the situation.
@NLTops
@NLTops 8 месяцев назад
The man at 5:30 is so well-spoken and contemplative. A man after my heart. What he said about his 2 fathers is especially powerful. It shows that the force behind his thinking is love and respect. I always wonder what Hamas would do to people like him if they live closer to Gaza. Because those rockets they fire at Israel don't have eyes or thoughts. They don't know whether they will land on Jewish heads Or Arab heads. Only that they will fall on Israeli heads. May those who seek peace find it together.
@mattiamele3015
@mattiamele3015 8 месяцев назад
Same with Israeli bombs, they don’t know if they will kill Jewish hostages or just Muslim and Christian men, women, children and babies who are Israel’s target. Eh.
@curiouscat5229
@curiouscat5229 7 месяцев назад
What a stupid thought.
@cagdas135
@cagdas135 7 месяцев назад
You wonder that and I wonder whether he would feel the same if he lived under constant threat of death, robbery, segregation and harassment.
@NLTops
@NLTops 7 месяцев назад
@@cagdas135 The fact that he lives in Israel and feels that way proves that those who "live in segregation" do so by their own choice. Palestinians who left Israel did so urged by the leaders of Egypt, Jordan, and Lebanon, who wanted them to keep fighting the Jewish people. Hate others and they will learn to hate you. If Palestine put down its weapons today, there would be peace tomorrow. If Israel put down its weapons today, there would be no Israel tomorrow.
@The30115
@The30115 Год назад
I like the answer at 10:40. Pretty much a good summary.
@yaronfeldberg
@yaronfeldberg 11 месяцев назад
The attorney is a proud Israeli, and I am proud of him as an Israeli. An Arab who lives his life and enjoys everything that Israel can offer an Israeli citizen. He is certainly not a leftist LOL
@sivannatalie
@sivannatalie 8 месяцев назад
He was impressive. Very charming too. I’m not surprised he’s been successful
@FairyCRat
@FairyCRat 7 месяцев назад
You can be a patriot and a leftist as well. That used to be very common in Israel and the Arab world alike, sadly not much anymore. If I were Israeli, I would support Hadash, they seem to be the last glimmer of hope for cooperation between Jews and Arabs.
@Nad906
@Nad906 5 месяцев назад
He is called a coward traitor
@FairyCRat
@FairyCRat 4 месяца назад
@@Nad906 You are called a racist.
@user-bf2vd9uv7k
@user-bf2vd9uv7k 4 месяца назад
That coward betrayed his people to benefit from the Zionist state, which suppresses and kills the Palestinians. Traitor!
@adamdudley8736
@adamdudley8736 5 месяцев назад
I have so much admiration and respect for the lawyer guy at 9:40.. we need more intelligent Palestinian voices like this
@KK-up2rm
@KK-up2rm 5 месяцев назад
Guess what, still no one state or two state. Both are “threat” to be a majority voice genius
@KK-up2rm
@KK-up2rm 5 месяцев назад
You can’t take one persons experience as a general experience. Look at 11:06 and listen to his brain rot
@Nad906
@Nad906 5 месяцев назад
You mean traitors ???
@ElisaAvigayil
@ElisaAvigayil Год назад
Wow Corey great video. The Golani lawyer, the 42 year old who has clearly had a rough life ("they're always listening"), the 2 guys arguing about the questions over a box of Osem (hilarious). Loved this.
@maxsimes
@maxsimes Год назад
Couldnt agree more. Some good people on here, some very good reflections
@mohammedal-mashehdi1271
@mohammedal-mashehdi1271 Год назад
The Golani lawyer is a Druze, not a Muslim. The Druze are microscopic part of levantese Arabs so their beliefs and values are different from those of the majority of Arab people. Therefore, it is inaccurate to say that the Golani lawyer's views reflect the mentality of West Bank Arabs or the vast majority of Arab people.
@omarankit9757
@omarankit9757 7 месяцев назад
@@mohammedal-mashehdi1271ok makes sense. I was surprised by his rhetoric. How did you know he’s druze?
@FreePalestine1948
@FreePalestine1948 29 дней назад
@@omarankit9757 Wearing gold and huge tats on his chest.
@SirChristian100
@SirChristian100 8 месяцев назад
How are you doing in these interesting times, Corey? Hope you are ok.
@ntheg
@ntheg Год назад
Great video!! You were asking "how are you different from pt arabs" which in Arab culture can translate to "what makes you different from pt Arabs". Id suggest asking "how are IL arabs different from pt arabs".
@hishamalaker491
@hishamalaker491 Месяц назад
One has rights and lives in a decent country, the other is occupied by the country that gives rights to his fellow arab. Same people but split by a foreign power that being Israel and yes its a foreign power and always will be.
@LiranBarsisa
@LiranBarsisa Год назад
On 15:20 he said that there could be peace, and then later on 16:17 he says there will never be peace...
@KaramKettanie
@KaramKettanie Год назад
He said it was an option before.. now it’s impossible.
@LiranBarsisa
@LiranBarsisa Год назад
@@KaramKettanie No. He said that it's never possible because of religion. Not because the time has passed. He probably didn't think about it in the beginning. Only thought about it later.
@ef2718
@ef2718 Год назад
@@LiranBarsisa never impossible = possible
@LiranBarsisa
@LiranBarsisa Год назад
@@ef2718 Yes, "never impossible=possible", but that's not what he said. He said that peace is impossible, just a few minutes after he said it is (or was) possible.
@ef2718
@ef2718 Год назад
@@LiranBarsisa In your previous comment you've written "never impossible", that's not a typo?
@workingman-xl6xh
@workingman-xl6xh 8 месяцев назад
"The difference is with our leadership." I feel the same with our government in the US. Our leaders so often do not reflect the will of the people.
@shreyabagchi2266
@shreyabagchi2266 8 месяцев назад
That guy won my heart too!
@sumernoel1553
@sumernoel1553 7 месяцев назад
You should kiss the ground you live on in America. Are we perfect ? Definitely not, but we have rights, work, education, justice system, protections & and strong military. We also have water at least on 2 sides giving us natural border protection. Thank your lucky stars. These people are constantly eye to eye with their enemy & war is always looming. They have bomb shelters in their homes.Think about that. We need to be grateful for the life we have….a life many would die for.
@workingman-xl6xh
@workingman-xl6xh 7 месяцев назад
@@sumernoel1553 I am a proud American and served my country for 12 years. I don't take our rights for granted but question how long we will be able to keep them.
@hishamalaker491
@hishamalaker491 Месяц назад
The difference is that Israel did the Caesar treatment. for some historical background when Caesar conquered Gaul he genocided 1/3rd, enslaved 1/3rd and welcomed the last 1/3rd as citizens of rome with full rights. Gazans are the 1/3rd of Palestinians within Palestine being genocided, West bank Palestinian are another 1/3rd not enslaved but occupied and finally Israeli-arabs who are the last third with rights.
@eujinlee9936
@eujinlee9936 Год назад
Now this video was interesting, it’s interesting hearing the perspectives of Israeli Arabs
@ElSauxy02
@ElSauxy02 Год назад
I’ve noticed that Israeli-Palestinians tend to be less or not hostile at all compared to West Bank Palestinians. (not every one of them are hostile but a lot of them are)..
@didd2810
@didd2810 Год назад
Can't lose citizenship and some of them likely have Jewish friends/neighbours.
@trollnerd
@trollnerd Год назад
Please, do not call them "Israeli-Palesitinians". They aren't Palestinians. They are Arabs. Palestinian is a national identity, not an ethnicity, and one invented relatively recently, compare to Arab and Hebrew identities which are both thousands of years old.
@alfahim9iner
@alfahim9iner Год назад
@@trollnerd palestinians are simply descendants of people who have lived in palestine for several milennia: the canaanites, hittites, amorites, perizzites, hivites and jebusites. these peoples later became arabized when the rashidun caliphate conquered palestine.
@paschalumeh6197
@paschalumeh6197 Год назад
Wtf is Israeli-Palestinians or did you mean Israeli Arabs?
@y.l7455
@y.l7455 Год назад
​@@alfahim9iner palestines are mere arabs.
@interestingyoutubechannel1
@interestingyoutubechannel1 Год назад
The fact that they didn't answer only by saying "its our land" shows they're different, let alone how so many Arab Israelis bring *nuance* and know how to reflect on their ideas, and how to engage in dialogue.
@EuropeanQoheleth
@EuropeanQoheleth Год назад
It doesn't matter.
@interestingyoutubechannel1
@interestingyoutubechannel1 Год назад
@@EuropeanQoheleth explain
@ElSauxy02
@ElSauxy02 Год назад
@@EuropeanQoheleth what do you mean
@MelaninMagdalene
@MelaninMagdalene Год назад
That might get them arrested 😂
@didd2810
@didd2810 Год назад
The nuance is necessary, assuming they could risk their citizenship or worse if some extremists found out. It's nonsense to think that the vast majority of Arabs in Israel especially the Muslims wouldn't support the Palestinians if they ever saw a day where it seemed that side was dominating the Israelis. It's only because the Israelis have completely dominated Palestine that the Arabs in Israel keep quiet.
@joeporter4920
@joeporter4920 7 месяцев назад
it's fascinating that the guy who says 'i just try to live, not take land back' also can't identify the two differences from afar.
@mayabrain
@mayabrain 7 месяцев назад
Thanks
@regularbahamian
@regularbahamian Год назад
God bless Arab Israelis, jews and samaritans who love each other
@Wonderer473
@Wonderer473 8 месяцев назад
Oslo was never a peace process. Arafat clearly said it is a Hudaiba agreement. Right after Arafat went into Gaza, Buses started to explode in Israel massive terror against Israel.
@sowhat249
@sowhat249 Год назад
The people simply don't trust each other at this point. Even if you implement two separate countries right now, the problem is far from fixed. The relationship needs generations to mend to what it was before.
@kennethbrownsher1264
@kennethbrownsher1264 Год назад
Not solvable.
@jasmines.6325
@jasmines.6325 4 месяца назад
The psychological stuff goes both ways. When my nephew would get scared as a little kid he'd hit me, I think grown ups antagonize to check if they are indeed safe around that person, if the other person escalates then theyre not safe. So much of what we do we're not aware of why we're doing it. It's like people just grow up but they don't develop fully emotionally or spiritually.
@gilabola4642
@gilabola4642 8 месяцев назад
That arab old man said "I also want them to return". Unfortunately for him, his arab family are not allowed to return to their former homes, but any jews can. I cant imagine how such policy is not considered as racist or apartheid policy.
@monkeyb1820
@monkeyb1820 8 месяцев назад
Israel is about 1/1000th the size of the surrounding Islamic countries. Having a right of return for Jews, but not people that want to eradicate Jews is not racist, nor apartheid. The vast majority of Arabs that were displaced were fellahin and didn't actually own land, but in any case around 800K Jews were displaced from Muslim countries. So it's over and done. But this isn't about land, as the Hebron massacre of 1929 and numerous Arab massacres of Jews prior to 1948 confirm.
@gilabola4642
@gilabola4642 8 месяцев назад
@@monkeyb1820 eradicate jews? Arabs and jews lived without much problem until those white colonialist zionist starting to come from Europe in the early last century. Even brown skin jews face discrimination, so imagine how those zionist treat palestinian. Zionist have been trying to eradicate arabs from the first day they set foot on that land, because thats the aim of zionism. To create a jewish majority state, they have to eradicate the majority arabs which they have been succefully done, so who is trying to eradicate who? Playing victim card does not work anymore in this day and age. Israel is an apartheid state according to Israeli own & international human rights groups. No millions of PR money will change that fact.
@gorwelroberts7012
@gorwelroberts7012 13 дней назад
are they speaking Hebrew sometimes?
@gilabola4642
@gilabola4642 13 дней назад
@@monkeyb1820 nope, it started in 1917 when british decided to give the land they did not own to european jews. Massacre of arab by jews & british started before 1929, but typical zionist always starts history from when its convenient for their propaganda
@gilabola4642
@gilabola4642 13 дней назад
@@monkeyb1820 1929 massacre? So you think jews & british didnt massacre palestinian before that? How convenient, just like zio start history from Oct 7
@onezerooneo
@onezerooneo 8 месяцев назад
Of course you can see differences anywhere on earth. Even in Ireland I could guess exactly what part of our small island someone is from by their accent and sometimes clothes, even sometimes their religion. The question seems to imply that two sides are different and therefore how could they live together.
@mariechosgaire6984
@mariechosgaire6984 8 месяцев назад
Because they are wearing GAA jerseys with the county name on it? How else do you know which county someone is from their clothes? What would set a Wicklow person apart from a Laois person based on their clothing?
@onezerooneo
@onezerooneo 8 месяцев назад
@@mariechosgaire6984 pretty easy to spot a Dublin knacker from their clothes compared to a Kerry farmer. Laois and Wicklow maybe not unless they’re from the travelling community. Easy to spot a Galway crusty compared to Armagh unionist. Loads of examples.
@effectosis742
@effectosis742 Год назад
They won't tell you that something divides them . I remember when you were asking in one video something like "would you - being a West Banker - marry someone from Gaza ?" - and the answears were much more interesting . They thought that it is impossible even though they are one nation .
@guyeshel9316
@guyeshel9316 Год назад
Some, not all
@user-ud3yv1hl7k
@user-ud3yv1hl7k Год назад
it's difficult to marry from gaza when they've been closed off from us for so long.
@alonnehring402
@alonnehring402 Год назад
I live in עמק חפר in my school there are many arab teachers and when i see them compared to west bank Palestinians there is a lot of differences they dress different there are more liberal and much more educated
@user-gh6je5zs3g
@user-gh6je5zs3g Год назад
Arabs reject liberalism and that’s why I respect them, coming from an Israeli ☝🏻
@amouri0307
@amouri0307 10 месяцев назад
This "arab" teacher is 100 times more indigenous than you will ever be
@alonnehring402
@alonnehring402 10 месяцев назад
@@amouri0307no the Jewish people are indigenous to the land of Israel it's the land were the Jewish nation was born, it's the land that Jews always wanted to return to, it's is very connected to Jewish culture and it's the only land that Jews have a meaningful connection to. So if Jews are not indigenous to Israel to which land are they
@John-bravooo
@John-bravooo 3 месяца назад
​@@amouri0307arabs colonized 3 continents.
@nataliaustinovich8802
@nataliaustinovich8802 Месяц назад
@@amouri0307And what is u point? We can’t come back 1948 .Even before 1948 , if they will keep fighting for imaginary land , no solution for peace.
@MrBoazhorribilis
@MrBoazhorribilis Год назад
Arab Israelis would never change their citizenship or lifestyle to become Egyptians or Jordanians or Lebanese , not ever Saudis with all the incredible wealth in Saudi Arabia. Israel is it.
@Randomhandlename
@Randomhandlename Год назад
You’re acting as if that’s easily given to them without any hurdles
@MrBoazhorribilis
@MrBoazhorribilis Год назад
@@Randomhandlename All citizens of Israel get the same treatment by the state and its laws. No special hurdles to anyone, no special treatment for anyone.
@Randomhandlename
@Randomhandlename Год назад
@@MrBoazhorribilis that wasn’t my point nice deflection
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 Год назад
​@@Randomhandlename hurdles like being born? Or like not serving 3 years in the IDF?
@crustybomb115
@crustybomb115 8 месяцев назад
@@Randomhandlename if youre not an israeli you can easily immigrate and become a naturalized citizen... or gain immediate citizenship if you serve in the millitary...
@thekoshertourist
@thekoshertourist 8 месяцев назад
The last guy understands the reality...it's an unfortunate one ☹ Thanks Corey for giving us a glimpse into the Israeli Arabs and what they think and say, seems to be a bit different then what those on the other side say... As for the guy speaking about the cops and keeping quiet, cops will get on power trips with many people, I've seen them go off on a buddy of mine as well in downtown Jerusalem, they don't give a sh*t who you are....
@JoshuaRotimi
@JoshuaRotimi 7 месяцев назад
Fact. But something needs to give.
@dragilxcom4176
@dragilxcom4176 7 месяцев назад
The last guy hinting why there will never be peace, because the believe of Muslims that one day they will genocide the Jews even the rock and trees will shout revealing Jews in hiding. This is so sad, when faith shapes people to fulfill the horrible future instead of people making a better peaceful world.
@LeonSlobo-zj3vr
@LeonSlobo-zj3vr 7 месяцев назад
Last old man understands that religion not allowing to share:)
@user-xd6nc6rg7b
@user-xd6nc6rg7b 4 месяца назад
@@LeonSlobo-zj3vrNo, he means that the religions have different standards for conflict. The OT says to annihilate the enemy down to killing newborns and r@ping women. The Quran says to fight the enemy to the best of your ability and spare women, children, elderly, religious people not involved in the conflict, don’t kill livestock or destroy property unnecessarily, and only fight those who fight you until they are the are ready for peace, then have peace. Christians seem to be told to be pacifists or close to it from my understanding, but I haven’t read the NT. They’re coming at the conflict from two different perspectives. The Zionists want to dominate and will use the OT to justify their position even if they don’t believe in it, and Zionists tend to be atheists in any case. The Muslims want justice for the atrocities they’ve been living through for almost a century but ultimately want peace in Palestine for everyone who lives there. He pointed out that there can’t be peace without addressing the land theft, settlements, violence, etc., and when they asked about two states he dismissed it because what is left at this point? Disconnected villages here and there that require permits to travel through land occupied by the IDF to even travel from village to village? No right of return for refugees who were forcibly expelled and their descendants? The Israeli government has even taken control of Palestine’s taxes, so any talk of a two state solution is disingenuous. The Israelis will either successfully complete their campaign of ethnic cleansing and genocide and pretend to be sad 🎻 about it when they come out of the fog of bloodlust, or they’ll have to act like decent humans and join the entire land together with equal rights for all and stop obsessing over having a country completely and only for ethnic Jews.
@tamaralexander9379
@tamaralexander9379 Год назад
15 min was honest . There will never be peace because of religion.
@gg6886
@gg6886 7 месяцев назад
We are infidels and religion is course if problem.
@keeks123
@keeks123 8 месяцев назад
THIS! “I say the problem is not with the people, it’s with the leadership”
@Mrkva22296
@Mrkva22296 Год назад
10:28 he is 42 years old? Isn't it a mistake in translation or something?
@jwanfox7857
@jwanfox7857 8 месяцев назад
Nope Haha, he literally said 42 in Arabic
@Mrkva22296
@Mrkva22296 8 месяцев назад
@@jwanfox7857 doesn't look 42 to me at all...
@lise1255
@lise1255 5 месяцев назад
I noticed 1 big difference. The 1948 Arab Israelis don't hate jews and Israelis like Palestinians without a blue pass.
@amirardat1068
@amirardat1068 4 месяца назад
Palestinians in Palestinian Territories have been given every reason to hate Israelis
@scriptaman2888
@scriptaman2888 Год назад
Min 3 Still can t get over the fact that Corey carried an entire conversation for 2 minutes without making a single grammar mistake
@ElisaAvigayil
@ElisaAvigayil Год назад
@3:59 Ibrahim from Bilin for Knesset!
@diannshoemaker6419
@diannshoemaker6419 7 месяцев назад
One thing for sure. They don't get penalized, in Israel, for not praying 5 times a day....which has to be really hard, since it means getting up in the middle of the night, EVERY night,
@Nad906
@Nad906 5 месяцев назад
You honestly know nothing. Please humble yourself
@kareema7818
@kareema7818 Год назад
Corey you’re awesome! Coming from a Palestinian🇵🇸
@solvingpolitics3172
@solvingpolitics3172 Год назад
Please tell us what a Palestinian is?
@SebaX92
@SebaX92 Год назад
​@@solvingpolitics3172same thing you can ask what a Belgian is. 300 years ago there was no Belgium nor even an idea of it. But people came together to form a state. Palestine is for the Arab people living on this land and the name dates back to the Philistines tribes. And it's not in the West Bank, West Bank shouldn't be a Palestinian territory. If Israel came to surface as a historical root of Kingdom of Israel, then Palestine should also have the right to root itself to the Philistinian tribes and where they land was. In today's Gaza , a bit of Israeli territory that surrounds it and in north east of Synai. Palestinians that are in today's West Bank would move as they wish to the new state, those who will choose to stay will turn into Israeli Arabs. End of the story. The territorial situation in Europe after WW2 was far more complicated that this, yet Europeans managed to do it. It can be done but if there's no will - then nothing can be done.
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 Год назад
@@SebaX92 there should be reciprocity. Israel should treat the muz ar abs in the same lovely way they treated je ws in the 22 muz ar ab occupied countries.
@y.l7455
@y.l7455 Год назад
​@@SebaX92 The nowadays palestines have nothing to do with the ancient phillistines...
@guyeshel9316
@guyeshel9316 Год назад
@@SebaX92 These people are immigrants, we know exactly where they came from, they even say that themselves
@Tomer-oy1hj
@Tomer-oy1hj Год назад
Correy the interview looses its value when you tell them your own opinion/experience
@jessevarela
@jessevarela 8 месяцев назад
At least the last guy is honest about his religion and doesn't try to hide it.
@Stevo-klo45453
@Stevo-klo45453 4 месяца назад
The middle aged man with the hat and glasses has a good point. You can’t have one side that wants peace and to deprive the other side.
@jc.9
@jc.9 11 месяцев назад
6:52 It’s a shame that a lot of the younger generation don’t think like this. And soon the older generations won’t be here to teach them about what the people want vs what the leaders want
@xylospongium
@xylospongium 6 месяцев назад
Actually the question can be asked of any Muslim living and enjoying the values of non-Muslim countries. The source and origin of all their ills as countries and societies is Islam. The Westerner who believes that Islam has nothing to do with the Palestinian problem does not see it in his own country either.
@lasisitemitope4051
@lasisitemitope4051 3 месяца назад
Do you know the conditions of non Muslims living in countries like turkey, Dubai and others?. Islam is not the problem and can never be the problem,it's all about extremism on some parts or mislead people.
@amaanivand.8455
@amaanivand.8455 23 дня назад
Yes, come to Morocco and ask the expats here if they in any way are discriminated or feel like they're in danger. I dare you.
@amaanivand.8455
@amaanivand.8455 23 дня назад
I am a revert, meaning I have European ethnicity and nationality, and I didn't feel safe in my OWN country. I was treated like a pariah because of my hijab, and getting pushed or spat at was a real danger. Happened to my friend even. Don't pretend you are so much better
@xylospongium
@xylospongium 23 дня назад
A revert?.... What does this mean? A convert to Islam !! Go to any of their shithole countries and enjoy islam. moron!! Have you already changed your Christian-European name given? I recommend you ?Aysha". The 6 y.o. wife of their warlord pedophile caravan robber.
@sbaumgartner9848
@sbaumgartner9848 8 месяцев назад
I could tell the differenence between Egyptians from Cairo or Alexandria (Nile Delta) when in southern Egypt in Aswan. Even children from Cairo/Alexandria have different more open body language; the children actually look out around them. Aswanese keep their visual field closer to their body.
@megavide0
@megavide0 8 месяцев назад
6:43 "The problem is with the leadership!.."
@shainazion4073
@shainazion4073 Год назад
At 5 minutes the man said if there was a state for the Palestinians, the conflict would end? Just like giving them Gaza ended any conflict?
@tombuddy100
@tombuddy100 Год назад
For some reason, it seems that Israeli Palestinians want "West Bank" and Gaza to be Palestinian state, whereas "West Bank" and Gaza Palestinians want the entire land, i.e. "historic Palestine", to be Palestinian state.
@rxtr664
@rxtr664 Год назад
​@@tombuddy100 So what? You guys say the same thing
@eam3508
@eam3508 Год назад
You mean Gaza the open air prison? Why on earth would someone be grateful for being put in a cage like a bunch of rats and then highly surveilling their entire existence?
@eve-1
@eve-1 Год назад
If there is never gonna be peace, why should Israel give the Palestinians land? That would be stupid and Israel is not stupid.
@naceraher9632
@naceraher9632 Год назад
they are stupid but Evil
@zoybean
@zoybean Год назад
Remember the Nakba
@eve-1
@eve-1 Год назад
@@zoybean shouldn’t have started a war to exterminate Israel. Israel is forever. Palestine never.
@rxtr664
@rxtr664 Год назад
Because Israel doesn't want peace
@happydillpickle
@happydillpickle Год назад
@@zoybean Remember the Jewish nakba, from all the Arab countries? Without the Jewish nakba, there would have been no Palestinian nakba. Don't be hypocritical by not acknowledging the Jewish nakba.
@ddhh1270
@ddhh1270 7 месяцев назад
11:42 this guy is a realist and understands their position within Israel.
@sarahofer4368
@sarahofer4368 Год назад
1. Israeli Palestinians speak Arabic and Hebrew (PA not) 2. PA Palestinians speak Arabic; only a small minority know English or any second language. 3. Palestinians (PA) don't have Israeli passports or visas or work permits (there are many who get work visas for Israel). 4. Jewish Israelis generally don't know how to speak or read Arabic which is an official second language in Israel, but they do speak English, which is also an official second/third language in Israel.
@MZein-gs5gg
@MZein-gs5gg 5 месяцев назад
i think the question was hinting at identity rather than languages, locations, and types of passports each side holds.
@olegmedvedovski8146
@olegmedvedovski8146 Год назад
Arabs Palestinians and Israelis came from arabs countries and Osman Imparia brought Arabs for jobs..I ask Arabs from arabs Israelis from where family came one told from Iraq a other told from Suria another from Emen..
@rxtr664
@rxtr664 Год назад
Ask Israelis where their grandparents came from
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
@@rxtr664 If you go back a ways, the answer is Judea.
@rxtr664
@rxtr664 Год назад
@@starhopper1706 Proof?
@olegmedvedovski8146
@olegmedvedovski8146 Год назад
@R XTR Arabs came from Arabia in 7 century Jr's alredy was there 2000 years..we see same happened in Europe illegals muslims running from Owen country to the Europe in future will say it our country..
@rxtr664
@rxtr664 Год назад
@@olegmedvedovski8146 bla bla bla You're telling me Palestine was empty this whole time? Is that what you're saying? 🤔
@idontspeakminecraft1475
@idontspeakminecraft1475 4 месяца назад
הבחור שהוא עורך דין איש מדהים מבין הגיון בסיסי
@michealodrisceoil6595
@michealodrisceoil6595 7 месяцев назад
You ask the question "How are you different from West Bank Palestinians?" It assumes the person feels there is a difference and predisposes the interviewee to assumes the same. Better to ask 'Do you feel there is a difference between you and West Bank Palestinians?' . More open-ended questions lead to more real and honest answers.
@ThreePuttBogeys88
@ThreePuttBogeys88 8 месяцев назад
The sad truth is the last guy is probably right.
@Gideon01
@Gideon01 Год назад
קורי, אתה טועה כשאתה אומר להם "לא השפה". השפה שלהם כן שונה. ערבים ישראלים משתמשים בהרבה מילים עבריות.
@who167
@who167 Год назад
מה שאתה אומר נכון אבל באופן כללי כל הניב השאמי דומה מאוד, גם אם אלו הישראלים מוסיפים עברית והלבנונים צרפתית. זה לא כמו ההבדלים בין ניב מרוקאי לעיראקי, הכל יחסית מאוד דומה.
@Gideon01
@Gideon01 Год назад
@@who167 מקבל מה שאתה אומר. ועדיין, אפשר למנות גם את השימוש בשפה כאחד ההבדלים בין ערבים ישראלים וערבים מהשטחים.
@dragulamcfeisty199
@dragulamcfeisty199 8 месяцев назад
That last dude was "in the know". That man was truly in touch with reality of everything. No delusions or corruptions in his thought processes. Much respect to him.
@Rai2M
@Rai2M 8 месяцев назад
He basically said that muslims will never be in peace with infidels. He does believe he's on the winning side.
@nb6166
@nb6166 8 месяцев назад
​@@Rai2MThe exact same thing could be said of the Jews.
@gmallory
@gmallory 8 месяцев назад
Not infidels, what certain people are capable of**@@Rai2M
@bambooblinds
@bambooblinds 8 месяцев назад
@@gmallory He basically said that muslims will never be in peace with christians and jew and he's on the winning side.
@fartnutssupreme4930
@fartnutssupreme4930 8 месяцев назад
You mean in touch with your version of reality and your beliefs.
@naveedahmed2417
@naveedahmed2417 8 месяцев назад
Bruh! Why you are answering on their behalf. Is the channel name Corey asks and answers😅
@norfolkisle582
@norfolkisle582 Год назад
Palestinians will never deny their identity
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 Год назад
They will never deny their israeli ID , passport and welfare
@anthonyr963
@anthonyr963 Год назад
The 1964 Palestinian National Charter Article 24 says otherwise, when they call themselves Jordanians and Egyptians.
@okjj124
@okjj124 Год назад
@@anthonyr963 false, majority of jordanians are palestinian and we arent egyptian. DNA test prove we come from the levant as PALESTINIANS are the one of the most genetically similar groups to jews
@anthonyr963
@anthonyr963 Год назад
@@okjj124 We all have DNA from Africa does not mean I am from Africa.
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 Год назад
​@@okjj124 the blond bosniak clans from bosnia? The masri from egypt? The sudanese from sudan? The blue eyed al kurd clans from kurdistan? The hijazi clans from hijaz?
@CedrusDang
@CedrusDang 8 месяцев назад
Arab Israeli - One of The most beautiful people on earth. Love the time I work with them in 2017. So much respect they have to others.
@helloworld0911
@helloworld0911 8 месяцев назад
They should explore a B&H powersharing situation.
@hgeorges7849
@hgeorges7849 2 месяца назад
The last guy changed his mind in 5 minutes he said opposite things, dont know how it'is in his head😂😂. There will be peace, no there will not be peace in the same sentence. He is definetly from the middle east
@Tomer-oy1hj
@Tomer-oy1hj Год назад
5:00 You can see a proof that this video was filmed in Israel by that even the parking loot has a traffic jam
@B.D.B.
@B.D.B. 8 месяцев назад
I personally know that spot, it's not really a jam. The parking lot has another exit, this one is connect to a roundabout which leads into the shopping center so it's always takes ages to merge there, because anyone coming into the shopping center or even using the other exit has right of way. Just poorly designed. Filmed @ 32.811048807246955, 35.072906372722116 looking E.
@PTFighterBras
@PTFighterBras 9 месяцев назад
Portuguese guy here trying to understand better all this situation. unfortunately the last guy said it right, religium wise, there'll be never peace, they can have a 2 state solution but never peace. Hope i'm wrong and you all can live together and in peace.
@ahmedisa3723
@ahmedisa3723 8 месяцев назад
No, religion does not constitute a problem if people apply the teachings of their religion with understanding. Islam calls on us to treat Jews and Christians well and kindly. I believe that the Jews, before the founding of the State of Israel, lived in Arab countries in peace with their Muslim and Christian neighbors, and some of them lived a very prosperous life as merchants and were not exposed to harm. The problem is that peace will not happen because there is essentially an occupation and a state that was founded on seizing land from its indigenous people and displacing them abroad. Whether other regions in Palestine or neighboring Arab countries
@TheTruth-ko9ov
@TheTruth-ko9ov 8 месяцев назад
You mean Islam accepts that jews can rule Jerusalem and al aqsa?
@IamBuffal0
@IamBuffal0 5 месяцев назад
It's Great to see Arab-Israelis that are happy to live in Peace. It's quite the contrast to Gaza/WB.
@IbnSaifi
@IbnSaifi Год назад
You should ask Israeli Arabs what happened to their family during the Nakba (1948)... if you haven't already
@dorandacolbert5973
@dorandacolbert5973 Год назад
If the arabs had accepted the partition and not started a war, there would have been no so called nakba.
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
"We tried to kill you. We failed. We are the victims" Nakba in a nutshell.
@omaralfar1666
@omaralfar1666 Год назад
@@starhopper1706 No, the Nakba was the destruction of Palestinian society and the expulsion of 2-thirds of the Palestinian population from their homeland. That's what the Nakba is. Why do you think there was an era of quiet between 1948 and 1967? Because Palestinian society was destroyed.
@ZahidHussainMemon
@ZahidHussainMemon Год назад
​@@dorandacolbert5973 how jews refuges european claim there land when Palestinians gave them shelter
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
@@omaralfar1666 There was no "Palestinian" society, they were, and are, Arabs. And beyond individually owned properties, not one inch of it has ever been "their land". Furthermore, most left of their own volition to get out of the way of the war Arabs started, often at the direction of their leadership, and those that were literally expelled, were so for the Arab side making a CHOICE to be an enemy, instead of accepting the state they never had before and picking peaceful coexistence from day one. Anything else they lost was for the same reason. Their poor and hostile choices are not Israel's or the world's fault and no one owes them a d-mn thing for that.
@akent6393
@akent6393 6 месяцев назад
This is not a people problem, this is a religious political problem created by faulty ideologies and leadership.
@AK-ky3ou
@AK-ky3ou 10 месяцев назад
The last guy was on point.
@alshermond
@alshermond 5 месяцев назад
At 8 minutes you start getting some honesty.
@minskdhaka
@minskdhaka Год назад
One difference is that Arab Israelis and Jewish Israelis share the mannerism of saying "eee" every few words while speaking English, while West Bank Palestinians don't.
@Genius766
@Genius766 8 месяцев назад
What eee means?
@crustybomb115
@crustybomb115 8 месяцев назад
@@Genius766 depends on the context in speech... pretty much...
@user-ff6lm4xe5y
@user-ff6lm4xe5y Год назад
זה כמו שתשאל ערבי צרפתי מה ההבדל בינו לבין מישהו מסוריה.. יש מלא הבדלים
@zetto814
@zetto814 Год назад
A French Arab? You mean a French from Arab descent? An immigrant from an Arabic country that lives in France? You want to compare that "French Arab" to a Syrian? A Syrian is different from an Egyptian, or an Algerian if they are not from France, because you know the 22 countries that are supposed to be the perfect home for Palestinians are really not culturelly identical.
@dogbert52
@dogbert52 Год назад
​@@zetto814 your all migrants and colonists outside of ar abia
@canmanlam
@canmanlam Год назад
Arab Israelis and West Bank Palestinians share the same blood
@zetto814
@zetto814 Год назад
@@dogbert52 and?
@guyeshel9316
@guyeshel9316 Год назад
@@canmanlam There are countless nations in " Palestinians". There is no "same blood"
@z1az285
@z1az285 7 месяцев назад
6:14 summarizes the differences between them succinctly
@jonashelby02
@jonashelby02 9 дней назад
3.53 that guy looks kinda like one 9f my heros.Meir Dagan.
@purel0ve87
@purel0ve87 Год назад
There isn’t much difference . Both are the same . Some are more secular than the others. But same manager, culture, religion and etc. The only difference is one more modern than the other and living in different areas .
@benploni7492
@benploni7492 Год назад
It's called the Ask Project but with the first couple of interviews Corey was also telling them the answer he wanted to hear 😅
@jamesp4132
@jamesp4132 Год назад
my thoughts exactly.
@Aricboccara
@Aricboccara 11 месяцев назад
​@@jamesp4132... Difficult for you to imagine that they're telling their truth....
@ivanmihaelmatkovic2464
@ivanmihaelmatkovic2464 9 месяцев назад
I think it's because they misunderstood the question. I think Corey wanted to ask something like, what differences exist between Berliners and Frankfurters (despite them being German).
@sergejspanier4932
@sergejspanier4932 7 месяцев назад
Why do you think that the people in Westbank don't want peace? Because I ask them :) ...Corey your Videos are great...
@Psychiatry.321
@Psychiatry.321 11 месяцев назад
It looks like many of Arab 48 does not speak Hebrew and/or can't understand it.
@Oseiwe
@Oseiwe 8 месяцев назад
I remember one of them stating that they the Israeli Arab citizens have more capacity (aka better humans) than those under the primitive religion-guided governments outside Israel. Of course! They learn skills and get education to improve their lives while the other side is fed religion, hate, propaganda and all the money the whole world wastes on them is diverted to fund terrorism. I am African and I fully understand why some peoples are never progressing while others are
@nodamage8011
@nodamage8011 7 месяцев назад
"primitive religion-guided governments" tell me you're completely ignorant about history without telling me..
@user-xq7tr6st5y
@user-xq7tr6st5y 6 месяцев назад
I am glad you understand reality. More people have to be aware of these issues...so good can prevail over evil at the end.
@user-sv9kf2yl8t
@user-sv9kf2yl8t 5 месяцев назад
Ты прав бро!
@MZein-gs5gg
@MZein-gs5gg 5 месяцев назад
"better humans"? is that what being brought up in israel teaches you? says a lot.
@markjenkins3609
@markjenkins3609 7 месяцев назад
That 42 year old looks older than me. Im 60
@NoNeedJustFeed
@NoNeedJustFeed 8 месяцев назад
Ask israeli arbs whether they like a palestinian government or stay under israeli
@RudydeGroot
@RudydeGroot Год назад
The guy with the beard and the hoodie talks about provokation. But his words clearly tells me that he is the one who is provocative.. He basically does the same as Christians do. He thinks they are good and the Jews are evil. The Jews are blinded and they can see. But I have some shocking news for them, as: _No one_ does good, not even one - "Ein u'sè tuv. Ein djam aeḥodh." - Psalms 14 or 53.
@zoybean
@zoybean Год назад
Anyone who allows building settlements and burning farms and blockading the populace is not merely provoking, but also breaking international law. This is something the Jews collectively decided (democracy). Therefore, they are bad.
@CanadianMonarchist
@CanadianMonarchist Год назад
I’m a Christian, but I don’t believe Jews are evil.
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
@@zoybean Name the law? (The UN does not make laws btw). And the blockade of Gaza didn't happen until they elected terrorists and started attacking Israelis. In reality, they deserve far worse than a blockade of the materials they use to do that.
@zoybean
@zoybean Год назад
@@starhopper1706 Tell me where else is burning farms of other people is okay? It's against the law in all countries. Nope, isntreal funded Hamas. Isntreal has elected a terrorist since the beginning, thus any claim of Palestinians electing terrorists can only be seen under the scope of pre-existing isntreali terrorists. (Also, the blockade is illegal as well). Your claim that they deserve worse is reflective of the ideology isntreal draws from, the Nazis. The abused becomes an abuser, as isntreal shows. They, and people like you, do not have the ability to understand that all such violence against isntreal is due to such actions like settlements, land grabs, farm burning, mass bombings, etc.
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
@@zoybean What farm? Where and when? Egypt blockades them too (for the same reason, it's a terrorist base). And btw if they didn't blockade them to minimize the issue, they'd have to fla tten that filthy pit instead in order to stop it. Would you prefer that? Israel foolishly supported Hamas some time ago for awhile before they evolved into what they are today, they didn't create or elect them. And if you want to talk about morality, Israel responds to the Arabs violence and protects it's citizens (including the Arab ones). They would be morally wrong if they didn't do that. "Settlements and land grabs"? All of it belongs to Israel. "Grabbing" is not necessary and they can build whatever they like in their nation, just like every other so called "occupier" of that land and their imaginary nation of "Palestine" has throughout history. There is no comparison between the holocaust and this conflict at all. Yet you'll notice, in spite of incomparable abuse leveled at Jews (and others) then, not one Jew in all that time ever hijacked a plane, slaughtered athletes, blew up a buses of German kids, or any of the other abominable things your pals have done repeatedly. Also, unlike the Germans with Jews, I have no desire to harm any Arab for being an Arab, I would much prefer peaceful coexistence, but if you attack or seek to destroy Israel, i don't give a f what happens to you as a result.
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
Almost all said that there were no differences, then proceeded to demonstrate those differences. lol 16: 17 Boooyah! Exactly. Most honest Arab award. 🏆 The family in the restaurant was great. Also appreciate their candor. Good vid, Corey. You deserve a donation for this one. Should have asked each of them if they would move to a "Palestinian" state if one was formed as a second part to the question. lol Would be good to hear the answer from those people's mouths, but I think it's pretty clear already. 😊 ❤ 🇮🇱
@zetto814
@zetto814 Год назад
Maybe it's because that's what you want to hear. Most of. Them naturally consider Palestinians from around the world as one people sharing, language, cuisine music... I know you would have really preferred that Palestinians living in Israel with Israeli citizen ship are from a different planet than those from Gaza, that are different from those in East Jerusalem, that are different from those from WB, than the ones abroad so when Israel bombs Gaza, there shouldn't be any reaction in the other territories... It would be wonderful I know but it's not the case
@az6802
@az6802 Год назад
They said there are no differences between the people. They stated the differences in how the people in the WB are treated.
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
@@zetto814 They reflected the sentiment that they are connected, but they also demonstrated differences. Rather clearly, imo. And btw, back when Trump's proposal was new, consideration was given to the idea of making the triangle (Arab villages that are now part of so called "Israel proper") part of a newly formed "Palestinian state". The Arabs there reacted by demonstrating AGAINST the idea of joining it ... but comically and ironically, they did it while toting around Pali flags. They are a confused people sometimes. lol
@starhopper1706
@starhopper1706 Год назад
@@az6802 The Arabs on the other side are groomed to be terrorists from birth.
@daoodalharbi8498
@daoodalharbi8498 Год назад
You don't want to hear that, there is no difference, that bothers you, I understand that
@Genarii
@Genarii 18 дней назад
To me, it is telling that the man who did not wish to show his face insisted that he *was* quite different from the West Bank Palestinians, and was willing to stress how much better his life and circumstances were living in Israel. When men like him are more numerous and willing to shout what he said from the rooftops, perhaps this conflict will come to an end.
Далее
🤯 #funny
00:20
Просмотров 2 млн
Israeli Druze: How do you define your identity?
18:52
Просмотров 259 тыс.
Palestinians: What do you think of Israeli Arabs?
11:07
Top U.S. & World Headlines - July 8, 2024
13:07
Просмотров 143 тыс.
🤯 #funny
00:20
Просмотров 2 млн