Are the Parents of the Prophet in Heaven or Hell? | Ask Shaykh YQ #92 

ﷺ

Hahahahahahahahah figh of nothing

@@zijdes111 I hope you have some proof that sahaba's used to laugh at the hypocrites.

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BYZrGIbPguI.html

Ameen

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BYZrGIbPguI.html

He gave no answer??

We mustn't respect them, but we arent supposed to talk bad about them. Like Abu talib, father Ibrahim (AS) , Wives of Lut and Nuh (AS)

​@@nufailanoonIndeed

Muhammad prayed and Allah denied him

Allah (SWT) is justice about it. There's no such privilage.

​@@maluillIt was Ibrahim AS not Mohammed

@@aaaaok1057 Sahih Muslim 976 b Abu Huraira reported: The Apostle of Allah (ﷺ) visited the GRAVE of his MOTHER and he WEPT, and moved others around him to tears, and said: I sought permission from my Lord to beg FORGIVENESS for her but it was NOT GRANTED to me, and I sought permission to visit her GRAVE and it was granted to me so visit the graves, for that makes you mindful of DEATH.

It really doesnt matter what the christian preachers say at the end of the day. We as Muslims cannot speak on the afterlife of specific individuals. As soon as the question or accusation from these preachers are addressed, they bring 20 more.

I really don't understand the relation between the prophethood of Muhammad (saw) and his parents religion brother... Prophet Noah's son was a disbeliever.. Prophet Ibrahim's father as well... and examples go on

@@veli1495 wrong analogy here brother, the people you mentioned received the message and rejected it but the prophet(scw) his parents did not receive the message and they died before the revelation, this question has more depth into it

@@greenabdullah9613 there is a difference of opinion in this question and when we are equipped with that knowledge its always helpful brother and if they bring 20 more it doesn't matter at least you made one question clear who some people where having doubts with

@@jakemawlid4714 true brother i understad ur point 👍... i mean the concept altogether is irrelevant to the prophethood of Muhammad (saw)... if they really insist on arguing i would ask them is it a criteria? Based on old testement? New testement? I dont think so.. their prophethood criteria is clearly mentioned in their old testiment somewhere i dont remember.. And Allah knows best

Search - Do all non-Muslims to go to hell? on RU-vid. I'm sure you'll find a more articulate answer but basically it's not our job to place people in heaven or hell. Allah is the most Just and Merciful and every detail will be taken into account, and that you have to worry about yourself.

@Hassan Ahmed here is the problem with that you see: Our prophet said in a sahih hadith when a man came to him and asked is my father in hell? The prophet replied yes. The man got upset so the prophet told him my father and your father are in hell. And this is sahih. The Hadith about his mother is that the prophet was rejected from asking forgiveness for his mother which made him cry and we know you can only not make dua for the non Muslims after they die.

Hello guy who attacked subboor 😁

@@ray620 yes and you're welcome.

How nice!

Usually there 20 minutes answers 😂

your parents?

Dont bring your emotions in between dalalil

It is very common that such questions can come into mind. Nothing to be frowned upon.

I am not frowned and I liked the simple answer that these things do not benefit that much to anyone!

Make us think that Prophet Muhammad (SAW )cannot help his parents, so we have to do more good deeds our self than wait for shafawat.

Muhammad was a false prophet

We love them

Obviously because there are reasons against that position. You do realized the scholarly discussions behind this are really nuanced.

* realize

You can write an e-mail to askyq@epicmasjid.org ✌🏼

Not true. Only some of the Quraish did

It is on the day of judgment but Prophet PBUH knew where will people go cause Allah has told him that,thats why he knew where will some sahabas go hell or heaven

In the transition world called Barzakh there will be already a small version of hell or paradise.

Because no one has to be punished before messege of the Messenger of Allah.

gmail :)

@@nufailanoon thanks brother

@@Kamal_AL-Hinai thanks brother

@@afifsalvi it was my pleasure 🌷

Stop watching lies

The Prophet's Parents are in Jannah Alhamdulillah. I feel much better now

​@@Yaqeenan21 alhamdullah ❤❤

"In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful." 1:1 Quran

Watch Sheikh Assim Alhakeem video...He has based his opinion on Alhadith of our prophet

Hmmm , interesting 🤔

@@kanizfatima1377 What is your point. Abraham was the grandparent of our prophet, so our prophet was a descendent of Abraham. When Abraham ask Allah about his descendent with respect to forgiveness, Allah said my covenant does not apply to wrongdoers. Therefore, whoever born after Abraham and are wrongdoers will face the same punishment as everybody else. There won't be any favour for anybody. This applies to the parents of our prophet, too but on the day of Qiyamah, our prophet can intercede for his parents as well as for us. Allah will give our prophet anything that he asked. He cas ask jannah for his parents.

Allah already knows what will happen to all of us. We dont know what happens in the future because we live in time, we are influenced by time. But Allah created time, Allah is not influenced by time, so Allah knows everything in the past and in the future.

There's a minor judgement day for people who die and then a major judgement (which is yet to happen).

The reason we know why the prophet father is in hell is because he told us. And the reason we know his mother is in hell is because Allah refused for him to ask for her forgiveness.

@@istagfar7705 that hadith is daeef and regarding asking for forgiveness was refused. How does this now mean she is in hell? Maybe she didn't require forgiveness because she was already forgiven? We are told in surah tawbah not to visit any graves of disbelievers so why did the prophet peace be upon him visit her grave?

@@jakedaniels9565 umm no it's not. It's graded hasan (sound) (the Hadith about his father being in hell with the other person's father) you are very incompetent. Regarding the forgiveness being rejected. The proof we have is of prophet Ibrahim (A.S.S). He asked Allah to forgive his father because he was a disbeliever when he had died. Guess what Allah told him? It is not for the Prophet and the believers to seek forgiveness for the polytheists, even if they were close relatives, after it has become clear to the believers that they are bound for the Hellfire. surah (at tawbah ayah 113). This is clearly stating that it is not for the believers nor the prophets to seek forgiveness for their parents. Thus the prophet muhammad (SAW) was denied his request. I hope you learned something today.

@@albatross7 I hope this will end all discussions any discussions about the parents of Rasulullah (SAW) and any parents of any other Rasulullah (AS) syaiun fil ardhi wa la fii samaai or any parents of any righteous person. Want more elaboration why these kinds of matter are NOT worth debating for? This definitely is not about a matter of geniuses amongst the hukama’ or has anything to do with ignorant; rather it’s a matter of maximum (absolute) pursue of truth. What’s new? No wonder, we’re all just human. Even great Rasulullah Moses AS dared to challenge Allah to see Allah’s face. Not to questioning Allah Wujud but only to satisfy his curiosity and the need to know the haqq till the einul yaqeen!!!That his soul is at ease and peace. Allah knows best His (I don’t like this his pronoun) this particular creation. The Ar Rahman Ar Rahim did not get angry but granted this insane wish. (Do your own research, find this in your Holy Book) >>> first assignments. Devour this “… aminu billahi wa malaikatihi, wa kutubihi wa rasullihi …. Wa qolu sami’na wa ‘atha’na … (Do your own research, find this in al Baqara in your Holy Book) >>> Second assignment (am not asking you about the pillars of IMAN >>> but I want you to research the Al Baqarah!!!) Analyse the sadaqoh and or amal Jariyah … Do your own research, find this in your second Holy Book) >>> third assignements. Now … questioning the whereby the parents of Rasulullah (SAW) means (literally) you’re doing kufr YOU HAVE LEFT YOUR DEEN >>> YOU ARE NO LONGER MUSLIM >>> YOU deny YOUR ROSUL >>> YOU DO NOT BELIEVE IN HIM >>> AND HENCE YOU DO NOT BELIEVE IN ALLAH >>> DON’T SAY YOU’RE A MOSLEM!!! Questioning the whereby the parents of Rasulullah means (literally) YOU ARE CURSING HIM MUHAMMAD RASULULLAH (SAW)! IS HE (MUHAMMAD RASULULLAH (SAW)) A CURSED PERSON? A SINFULL ONE? IS NOT A RIGHTEOUS PEOPLE? He is NOT the holy shit like those TRINITYRIAN!!! He is THE RASULULLAH!!! HOW DARE YOU? SERIOUSLY!!! ARE YOU THE CHOSEN ONE? OR IS IT MUHAMMAD RASULULLAH SAW? ARE YOU hollier THAN muhammad SAW? Moslems know everything (the secret of ALLAH, heaven and earth from the lisan of Rasulullah SAW! Now you know why you will be burnt in hell just by questioning the existence of the parents of any Rasulullah!!! DO NOT POINT YOUR FINGER TO RASULULLAH (saw), RATHER DO YOUR BEST (in the eyes of Allah) to EARN YOUR JANNAH!!! Submit your paper research next week. The grade A students will be granted TO DO THE SYAHADAT 1000 TIMES AGAIN! No offend, nothing personal brothers and sisters >>> be proud TO BE A MUALLAF >>> A FRESHMAN (WOMAN) DESERVES many things!!! >>> Do your own research (about muallaf), find this in your second Holy Book >>> fourth assignments!

And this is also applied to the father of The Great Father of Nabiy and Rasulullah Ibrahim AS. There are tafseer and commentary about the father of our Great Father Ibrahim AS that he will (would) be thrown into hell. That's their belief but I don't care, I do not agree with them. I am believing (my opinion) that the father of Ibrahim AS is going to heaven. if he is NOT >>> then Ibrahim AS will cry to HIS ALLAH >>> and ALLAH WILL NEVER REJECT HIS BELOVED SERVANT!!! The one who will be crying a lot is our FATHER ADAM ALAHISSALAM! Why? because the Ad, the Tsamud, the people of Luth AS, Fir'aun, Qorun dan the like >>> you name them >>> ARE HIS CHILDREN!! And the one who will be laughing a lot proudly would be our FATHER ADAM ALAHISSALAM! Why? because so many of his descendants/ children are THE NABIY AND THE RASULULLAH!!! But Allah is The All Wise ... wa ilallahi turja'ul umuur >>> fifth assignments >>> devour THE IRON!)

What answer ??

He gave no answer.. he should have referred to what Islam says about this matter .. and being a Muslim we must speak the truth no matter how hard it is for us to accept

@@kanizfatima1377, 2 prophets had came to people of mecca, prophet ibrahim and prophet ismail. But many years after prophet ismail died they started to worship statue. Prophet Muhammad died 1400 years ago but we (muslims) still worship Allah, we dont worship statue. People of mecca started to worship statue after prophet ismail died, so were they innocent? Does Allah consider them innocent for worshiping statue? I dont know.

@@happycheers6947 there is no evidence his parents worshipped statues. The time between prophet isa and prophet Muhammad peace be upon them religious knowledge was scarce in Makkah. There were people who worshipped idols but the family of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him were Ahlul Fatrah and Ahlul La illaha ilala

Muslim (203) narrated from Anas (may Allaah be pleased with him) that a man said: “O Messenger of Allaah, where is my father?” He said: “In Hell.” When he turned away he called him back and said: “My father and your father are in Hell.”

@@PokemonDude880😮

So sad…

There not in hellfire. Because the message of Islam has never reached them. It clearly says in *(Quran 17:15)* ⬇️⬇️ “And never would We punish until We sent a messenger.”

@@Crystalclear-so2yr use some brain... Before Prophet Mohammad S.A.W(pbuh) it was Bible(pure) that was not pure at that time when Islam was about to come.. . For the parents of prophet Mohammad S.A.W(pbuh) they must have to follow prophet Jesus(pbuh) but till then Bible was absolutely corrupted... . Use some logic before commenting...

@@Abu_Prodigy147 Isa (AS) was born in the *1 Century.* And Prophet Muhammad’s Parents were born in the *7th century.* There’s a whole 500 year Gap between Isa (AS) and The Prophet’s Parents. And in that 500 year Gap, the Bible was obviously corrupted

It is said the prophets lineage is of the best and the purest of lineages, so why would God throw the best human beings parents who brought him Into this world in hell fire. And who says they knew about the 1 God or prayed to idols. There is no factual evidence for this.

A narration of the prophet states that when in a battle the prophet shouted his rajz in anger and said "I am the true prophet of Allah swt which is the truth , I am the son of abd al muttalib "

Think about your own fate. Sayyid Abdullah's life is worth of 100 camels(price of diyat) And Sayyida Amina was visited by angel There is no way, hellfire can touch them

@@lordofpajeetsthedefecators5603 i too pray the same .. but the reply given by scholars hurts a lot considering the love i have for Prophet Muhammad (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam)

@@fboff7978 Try to hear opinion from another scholars. The scholars of Al Azhar, egypt and our Indonesian scholars mostly believe, that not just the parent of prophets, but all his ancestors , paternal and maternal, since Adam As, and Eve, were pious, muslims, and only worship one God. They were pure from shirk and zina

@@lordofpajeetsthedefecators5603 Muslim (203) narrated from Anas (may Allaah be pleased with him) that a man said: “O Messenger of Allaah, where is my father?” He said: “In Hell.” When he turned away he called him back and said: “My father and your father are in Hell.”

@@PokemonDude880 D you have any proof that the hadith is about biological father of Prophet? I BELIEVE YOU DONT HAVE ANY

Dont cross the line. We believe that Sayyid Abdullah and Sayyida Amina were mukmin. But the people who believe otherwise are not always munafiq. Just say they re jahl

What about this hadeeths which says "Allah continued moving me from pure backs of fathers and pure wombs of mothers.Never would a family line branch out in two except that I was in the best of two.." narrated by abu Nu 'aym... What do u mean by pure fathers n pure mothers here??? Do u think that means they were idol worshipers n pure souls?? Plzz stop listening to this ppl who cant even take out a proper answer from quran n hadeeths... All the prophets fathers n forefathers are believers as per quran n hadeeth... N alhamdulillah no doubt Allah has brought his beloved from pure souls ....

@@tahreenara9819 Do you have a source for that hadith?

@@ArdoBlueMoon muslimvillage.com/2019/10/29/60844/prophet-muhammad-s-birth-real/

Go thru the link.....ul knw many such things which ua scholars hide.....

@@tahreenara9819 its all lie its authenticity is proven only imam suyooti didnt take that he said allah will alive again parents of prophet and gave them time to say the shahahda then they will die but there is no basis for that if that would have to be happen then noah a.s son ibrahim father they should also have been given the same thing

@@albatross7 no man

@@veli1495 we need this so we can learn why someone would go wherever he/she goes so we can take them as an example or as warning for our lives.

You are crying

You are going to hell. Stop lying . The Prophets family were Muslims and worshippers of Allah

@@channelfive7883 I can prove your stupodity with one question: Was prophet's uncle Muslim? If you think yes, then why did Rasool Allah pbuh asked him to accept Islam on his death bed? Prophet's grand father was the caretaker of Kaaba which was full of Idols at that time. Can any Muslim take care of Idols? Use God given intellect.

@@ShowBizJunkie Only Abu Lahab was a ex Muslim who was jelaous of his nephew the only reason he didn't accept. The Prophet is from Banu Hashim who were pure worshipers of Allah, Since Ad'am. Why do you think Allah's prophets family were "karfirs: Allah will destroy you for your lies.

@@ShowBizJunkie In the beginning, the idols were less and he used to take care of Allah's house the Ka'bba

@@channelfive7883 It does not make sense. If Abu Hashim were Muslims then there was no reason for Rasoll Allah to be born. Moses was raised in the house of Pharoah so Moses can shake the foundation of Pharoah's power from within. Allah's religion of monotheism had to be brought back to Kaaba That is why Prophet Muhammed was sent with the true message to shake the power of Quraish and reclaim kaaba from the idolworshipper and cleanse kaaba from the idols. If prophet family were all muslum, then there was no need of the prophet.

True. Ahlus sunnah dont believe parents of the prophets are in hell. Only fanatics believe that

@@tahmidtouhid7785 ahl as'sunnah Not ahlus sunnah

We believe what the Prophet said. Likewise Ibrahims (as) father went to hell.

But the prophets parents died in jahiliyyah and they didnt have a prophet or messenger sent to them in their lifetime so they cant be in hell right?

please correct me if im wrong aswell anything that ive said wrong is with shaytaan and allah azzawajaal and his messenger (saw) are free from this

There was prophet Ibrahim before that in Arab who refuted Idol worship and was leading all the astray to straight path , I also had the same question as you brother but Allah had sent revelations before Prophet Muhammad ( SAW ) .

@@eazimhr5796 Prophet Ibrahim came thousands of years before Prophet Muhammad, and those revelations were not preserved. The book of Prophet Ibrahim is not even present among us. With illiteracy being the norm among Arabs at the time I don't see how it would be possible for them to follow the message of someone from thousands of years before. Chances are most pre-Islamic Arabs didn't even know who Ibrahim was.

@@Ahmed-ob6ec ya bro Allah made every non Muslim just to go to hell. Even i will go to hell because I am non muslim

@@Ahmed-ob6ec The man who tells people that heaven lies under mother's feet. His own mother is in hell. 😂

@@ShivamSharma-ei9lz There not in hellfire. Because the message of Islam has never reached them. It clearly says in *(Quran 17:15)* ⬇️⬇️ “And never would We punish until We sent a messenger.”

I'm pretty sure it's himself

@@saad9591 yes voice is pretty same Really a good voice..

Its A good voice

It’s him I think he has great voice

Allah has planned that the devil and his followers are going to hellfire

He does but he doesn't want you to push him like Muhammad Hijab did.

Don't say anything blindly, don't say there is a Hadith PROVE IT!

@@TechNaf I quoted two Hadith from Sahih Muslim, so what more proof do you want? The Prophet(peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) says clearly that his father is in Hell, and it was for him not permissible by Allah(the most Glorious the most High) to ask for forgiveniss for his mother. And we know that Allah( the most Glorious the most High) says in the Qur'an: "it is not for the Prophet and those who have believed to ask forgiveness for the polytheists, even if they were relative, after it has become clear to them that they are companions of Hellfire." (Quran 9: 113) What do you not understand from these Sahih Hadith and from the Qur'an?

@@alyunanie you still don't understand! you just randomly quoted two hadith but you didnt tell which hadith, i mean number.

@@TechNaf Please ask your question the next time more clearly, So then i can understand it in a better way what your real question is. But you can find these two Hadith in Sahih Muslim, Book 1( Book of Faith), Hadith number 203, and the other is in Book 11( Book of Funerals), Hadith number 134.

@@TechNaf And i like to note the next information, for the possibility of confusion regarding this matter. That Al-Suyooti (may Allah have mercy on him) was of the view that the parents of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) will be saved (from Hell), and that Allah(the most Glorious the most High) brought them back to life after they had died and they believed in him. This view was rejected by the majority of scholars such as al-Daaraqutni, al-Jawzaqaani, Ibn Shaheen, al-Khateeb, Ibn ‘Asaakir, Ibn Naasir, Ibn al-Jawzi, al-Suhayli, al-Qurtubi, al-Muhibb, al-Tabari, Fath al-Deen ibn Sayyid al-Naas, Ibraaheem al-Halabi, Ali al-Qaari, Ibn Taymiyah, and others, who ruled that the ahadeeth which indicate that are fabricated (mawdoo’) or very weak (da’eef jiddan). Moreover, this goes against the Qur'an and the Saheeh Sunnah.

Dude relax, you sound like an extreme person. No one knows the real truth of these things except Allah, so relax and listen to another opinion without your disrespect attached.

@@SG-nu7go Mashallah! this relaxed attitude by also the so- called companions and their followers of the prophet is what had the grandson of the prophet killed. If you can send the parents of the prophet to hell what is killing his grandson!

@@SG-nu7go btw sending prophets parents to hell you do not find extreme. Show respect to the parents of the prophet the same way that we are instructed by Allah swt to respect our parents! Unless you expect the prophet not to follow the advice of Allah in the Quran!

Brother, you must always consider what is difficult to emotionally accept. You stated: "All the prophets lineage are pure from one loin to another." Is this true? So all the progeny and progenitors of all prophets are pure? Consider if your claim holds true. Think then about Qabeel the son of Adam (a). Think about the son of Nuh (a) that didn't board the ship? Think about the father of Ibraheem. What about all of Bani Israeel who are descendants of Yacub (a), the son of Ishaaq (a), the son of Ibraheem (a)? So, though I understand and appreciate the passion, we must be level-headed and consider all the evidence. Though the prophets are not ordinary people like us since they received revelation, that doesn't mean that their ascendants or descendants are somehow also privileged against sinning or disbelief. All in all, we must all strive to correct our actions and beliefs because that's our current test and we will see who was correct in relation to these other matters in the hereafter.

I love Yasir Qadhi. Never saw anything from him that makes me change my mind.

Our prophet said that they are in hell there are Hadiths which are sahih. There is no denying.

@@istagfar7705 why do you follow a prophet who Allah honored by bathing their parents in fire?

@@maluill because Allah honored him in different ways. His parents are separate to him. Allah won't be unfair with others by putting the prophets parents who were polytheists in heaven while putting the rest of the polytheists in hell.

@@maluill if you're a Muslim, why do you follow a prophet (Ibrahim) whom Allah honoured by putting his father in the hellfire?

@@istagfar7705 Abraham wasn't a prophet in the classical sense. He was a patriarch. The Bible makes no account of Terah's destiny but Abraham is not our example Jesus is. The Mother of Jesus is honored both in Islam and Christianity. Yet Allah dishonors Muhammad by leaving his parents to sin and die in he'll. So Jesus who is alive in jannah awaited the arrival of his blessed mother yet Muhammad will never see his parents again whom Allah is bathing in eternal flames.

It is, but still stay quiet. Don’t open your mouth on this topic and don’t try to advocate a certain position

Lest you be thrown face first in the hellfire for slandering the parents of Rasūlullāh ﷺ. You’re on risky ground

sahih bukhari doesn't always mean it is the correct opinion

Majority say they aren't in hell like Qadi Iyyad, Ibn Hazm, Ibn Abd Barr, Abu Bakr ibn Al Arabi and many others

There not in hellfire. Because the message of Islam has never reached them. It clearly says in *(Quran 17:15)* ⬇️⬇️ “And never would We punish until We sent a messenger.”

Stop lying you man worshipper.

Asthagfirullah 😂

I think you missed the verses where Allah says Jesus A.S. was not hung up on the cross, nor was he ever killed. He's still alive and when he comes back, you'll become a Muslim at his hands or perish. Good luck

Well if you claim Jesus is God so why didn't Jesus say in gospel because he always say father is only true God ....... And I have a question for you too God is creator of everything and he gave many of creation to change shape and form so why God need a woman to be born why not become human by himself because God can do anything he want? So let answer this first then you allow to bark as much as you want🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😏

Bro but this is the truth. There us a hadith in Sahih Muslim that the Prophet said that his father is in hell, in another narration it says that both the parents are in hell.

@@ateebmujtaba Asktakfullah. You are not Muslim lying and cursing the prophet parents.

@@ziegngarcia8284 First of All this is the most authentic opinion. And Secondly how is this related to my eeman

@@ateebmujtaba There not in hellfire. Because the message of Islam has never reached them. It clearly says in *(Quran 17:15)* ⬇️⬇️ “And never would We punish until We sent a messenger.”

@@Crystalclear-so2yr didn't prophet essa come?

Yap, walaupun bisa jadi mereka benar. Nyampeinnya ga bisa pake bahasa yang lembut.

There not in hellfire. Because the message of Islam has never reached them. It clearly says in *(Quran 17:15)* ⬇️⬇️ “And never would We punish until We sent a messenger.”

@@Crystalclear-so2yr they died before the prophet Muhammad saw received revelation so their had to follow the nearest messenger sent to them which presumably was Prophet Ishmael. Given that the prophet's parents died upon shirk and did not believe in the pure message of their prophet Ishmael they must be condemned to eternity in hellfire.

@@drg312 Bro are you serious? Did you really just say they never followed their Prophet Ishmael? Prophet Muhammad’s parents and Prophet Ishmael didn’t even live in the same time period. They both died with no Prophet being sent to them. *Allah clearly says: “And never would We punish until We sent a messenger.” (Quran 17:15)*

@@Crystalclear-so2yr there is clear sahih ahadith that the prophet saw affirmed his parents are in hellfire. But you are probably some messed up shia. It must burn you that Imam Muawiyah is in jannah

@@drg312 sunni here 1) prophet's parents are not in hell 2) as of amer muaviya is concerned look in the Quran and hadiths what happens to people who revolt against a legitimate Khalifa and kill amar bin yaseer(ra)