"Are You A Dedicated National-Socialist, Major?" | Valkyrie (2008)  

There were ‘two’ arrest orders. Giving conflicting priorities!

Hitler survived the bombing and issued the order himself since he knew who tried to kill him. The conspirators hadn't yet lost communication as the telegraph office hadn't chosen a side yet so their own orders to purge the SS also went thru. The contingency to purge the SS was also approved by Hitler (he didn't read the order before signing) so the purge order didn't seem weird when it came in.

Thats not what happened. The crows nest presumed Stauffenberg was the failed asassin and put an order in for his arrest, while at the same time Stauffenberg was putting orders in to arrest Goebells, the entire SS command and all members of government that weren't with them. The comms office at the time saw the conflicting orders but in the beginning chose not to pick a side and chose to pass both communications through

​@@mattw4k266germans man, always following the protocols

Did you like your own wrong comment on your own short? Really?

Charlie Chaplin! is that you? I'm a huge fan sir!

@@mothpo XD

​@@mothpoI probably would have been arrested back than for not stopping to point out the similarity 😂

​@@Delta_3VIIII wouldnt ve surprised if someone close to him joked about it atleast once. He wasnt like Stalin and otgers in the sense that he was kinda nice with his inner circle, they joked around and talked a lot, he was a weird person.

As a native The German accents for the nazis in movies always puts me off in every franchise. only Waltz gives me the feeling that he is German. Wait….

Worst case scenario, he gets used to take over, best case scenario to has disobeyed orders. It was the only way to know for sure.

Bro what on earth is that pfp

I wish I knew what is happening here...I have trouble hearing.

​@peterruiz6117 In 1944, a group of high-ranking Nazis attempted to blow up AH during a meeting. However, the plot was unsuccessful and the conspiracies in the video attempted to hand out arrest orders not knowing AH was still alive! Goebells is on the phone with AH and the Major we see handing out the arrest orders is told by his superior Goebbels to hop on the phone, AH is on the phone and orders the Major to capture the conspirators alive

😮😮😮

I mean when people get disappeared at night that’ll put a fire under your heels

It's called snapping to attention.

That officer really was a dedicated nut-zie, i watched an post war interview of him.

​@@elektronischemusik1903 OK rabbi

@@elektronischemusik1903You can say Nazi bruh don’t have to censor yourself in the comments.

Lmao

"umm define dedicated, sir...."

*loads gun*

"Actually I have some communist leanings myself"

@@jmjedi923Goebbels would have come unwound if the Major said that. Brother would have flung a Bible at him with one hand and would have been reaching for his pistol with the other.

Hugo boss is the producer 😅

​@@RenSavoyHugo Boss was just one producer out of many

alastor

@@Glaze_119 yea

Mostly just the SS

🤣🤣👏🏾 this actor is either usually a Nazi or Hydra lol

Fake news, he lived and linked up with HYDRA!

😂😂😂

Lo curioso, es que antes estuvo al mando de un submarino y se enfrentó a Harvey Keitel y Matthew McConaughey. Algo de la máquina Enigma, si mal no recuerdo. ¿Cuándo pasó a la Wehrmacht?...🤔🤨🎥🎞📽🎬📺😂🇨🇱

😂

LOL

Go balls

Lmao damn that's good

​@@OswaldM_14 To the walls.

The events leading to the night of long knives ensured he would never trust anyone ever again.

@@bartsanders1553 huh? The NOTLK was what gained him the support of the military. It was generally met with approval.

@@Ras_al_Gore It was carried out against military officers who were seeking continuous revolution, i.e. overthrowing him. It was a sizable number of well respected officers. It wasn't so much what gained him support of the military so much as it removed all viable opposition in the military.

@@bartsanders1553 no, the only officers killed were Schleicher and Bredow, and specifically because they were plotting to bring others into the cabinet (they were not respected by the military establishment). The primary targets were SA leaders, not officers. Strasser because he wanted a “second revolution” to overthrow the industrialists and conservatives, and Röhm because he wanted to replace the Army with the SA. The military loathed Röhm and considered the SA a threat. What removed his opposition *within* the army was the Blomberg-Fritsch Affair.

@@Ras_al_Gore I have to wonder though at the end when he was sitting in the bunker cursing all those officers if he had any regrets not going the other direction and purging the old military structure completely as Himmler and Rohm suggested. Long knives was basically where Hitler chose who would fight for him and who would be disposed of and very likely he chose wrong.

Imo he doesn't sound like him at all and I've listened to pretty much every recording that is publicly available. Not that it would really matter for this scene or the movie as such..

I heard that one recording too. Yeah. He spoke with normal tone, and affliction. I know it's a poor comparison. Have you heard Gilbert Godfrey's normal speaking voice as well? It's shows when a personality is on versus off.

@@patrickkrohl3612 your thinking of his "public speaking voice", not his "talking voice" there is only one recording of his talking voice, if your interested Mark Felton has a video showcasing it.

@@patrickkrohl3612 It's spot on. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Rz0HNlsSpgE.html

@@themanformerlyknownascomme777 I wasn't thinking of the conversation between Hitler and Mannerheim if that's what you're refering to... There are several recorded speeches where he talks normally and doesn't shout or anything. I would assume they were held infront of a rather small audience and I'm not sure If the ones I'm thinking of were broadcasted back then.

He was very calm talker. In punjab there are still old people who were in free indian army who met him. My friends grandpa met him.

@@Elya-ou3kfcan you share what he said about his experiences?

@@subhadeepbhatta1212 okay so he is died in like 2014 at the age of 94 or something. Lets call him grandpa. He was born in late 1910s. We are not sure because in that time in india people in village didnt care about date of births and stuff. I am not from punjab, my friend from my city went to punjab to see his family so i went with him and there i met that old guy. He was in Indische Freiwilligen Legion der Waffen-SS (Indian Volunteer Legion of the Waffen-SS). He could speak some german, not much. He was friends with SS-Oberführer Heinz Bertling, commander for the Indians and only german he talked to properly on daily basis. He saw Himmler like 100 times because he was personally friend with subhash chandra bose. He would be around talking to bose and Bertling but personally never talked to grandpa. He said Bertling told him Himmler was interested in hindu stuff. He saw hitler only once in person from like 10 feet away for like 5 mins. Bertling told everyone not to smoke before hitler came. He gave a like speech or something to Bertling and indians but grandpa said he didnt understand a word because hitler had weird german and weird accent. He said hitler had a cold and flu. He was calm and friendy to everyone and shook hands with few indians who were interested and had better german and could talk to him.

@@Elya-ou3kf Fascinating story sounds like your friends grandpa was an interesting person. I do know of course Hitler had quiet and nostalgic fireside chats with his closest people that could go on for hours. I am of course referring to his on stage persona at the podium making speeches as most knew him. Plus, its satirical.

@@WarriorsSon yeah i know

Hitler: “Fine. I’ll do it MYSELF.”

@@Jefafa824 he really didn't want to be captured by the Russians.

If Hitler got captured by the Russians, he would get pimp slapped and interrogated

He spent his whole childhood narrowly avoiding being assassinated by time travellers

@@Jefafa824Funny thing is he didn’t. The skull of Hitler? Yeah, it was a German woman’s. They just figured that one out not too terribly long ago.

Especially in prison or dead.

@@bencarter8423 why do you have to hate on nice uniforms?

​@@bencarter8423Azov battalion still have some nice uniforms. Ukrainians are looking good in those uniforms, but they shouldn't be blamed for being nazis 🥹🥹

Their uniforms are made to look cooler in hollywood movies than they did in real life as a subtle manipulation to make simpleminded cowards idolize them. Its just one of the ways fascism is pushed on the people so the ruling class has an army to quell socialist uprisings when rising inequality causes a tipping point in public attitude.

Verdade

Fucking a lot of times

Wilm Hosenfeld was a true German officer, who saved Jews from the Shoah, not a nazi.

@@Fulcrum-27 Even wehrmacht officers had to swer an oath of allegiance to Hitler and besides he literaly says hes a national socialist in the clip

@@Fulcrum-27so cringe

@@KolchaksGhost haha troll.

Hes typecast as a German officer in every film

Yeah, Thomas Kretschmann is known for that. His latest one was Indiana Jones and dial of destiny.

​@@PcGamerifyit's a decent gig, if you can get it. Be tall and have a strong jaw. Or short and creepy (melted face dude from Indiana Jones lol)

Pretty much but it’s because he’s actually German. Born in East Germany and speaks it fluently so his accent is legit. Even in King Kong he plays Captain Engelhorn but he’s still “the German captain” accent and all. Might as well have the actual German guy play the German characters.

He also plays goebbels in other movie, and officer in Stalingrad 1993 😅

Sounds like a good guy. Wonder why he didn’t join up in the SS though. Perhaps his rank wouldn’t transfer or something.

@@Aqueox Would be a bit silly to move a reliable man from a position where he is useful in both a military and political sense (that is, as a counterweight to the wishy-washy elements in the Wehrmacht officer corps) to a place where he would just be another officer. Would be kind of like pulling Doenitz from the KM and putting him in command of a separate SS naval force. There's an 1987 interview with the man that I recommend checking out.

​@@Aqueox"Remer was a devoted nazi and killed for his ideology" does not translate to "sounds like a good guy" lmao. and the SS are kinda over hyped. they were Hitlers personal army but that didnt make them "elite" or special in any significant way. there was alotta conflict between the Werhmact, SS, and Luftwaffe. officers of the Werhmact were pretty proud of their positions within the professional military and wouldn't want to "degrade" themselves to ranks of what is essentially a militia. The SS were intergrated with the professional military and obviously had military training but in a way thats more similar to how Partisan Divisions were formed in the USSR. the SS was largely propagandized and was mostly used as a security and occupation force until the later stages of the war. to summarize in a way that hopefully makes some sense, the SS were more so political activists who took up arms for their beliefs and less so an organized military designed to wage war on other nations. their ultimate loyalty was too Hitler and his ideas, not to their country. the Werhmact was the establised army of Germany even before Hitler rose to power and their loyalties often tended to fall more towards their country and the lives of their people and less so to the dominant political power.

​@DRGEngineer this is true, the part that people forget is militias like the SS were necessary after WW1 because Germany could only have so many soldiers in the wehrmact, so the treaty put limits on those soldiers but didn't say anything about extra militias like the free corps or the SA or brownshirts. After the start of WW2 the SS handled interior assignments like running concentration camps and would see battalions used on the front once they began to retreat from the russians

@@DRGEngineerthey were functionally the same as the Whermacht and the difference is overhyped one way or another cause of politics. (They also were the same in war crimes but they pushed the clean Whermacht myth after Nuremberg so people could say “no I wasn’t NS I’m a good goy!!”) I will say the armored units of the waffen SS were often elite and better but it depended on the unit. And many of the foriegn volunteers were milita tier. Ultimately they were pretty much exactly the same the Waffen SS just had some training in ideology but you can see in movies like Stalin grad Hollywood really pushed this clean Whermacht myth thing for a bit

Would have been fiction, but could have been awesome to see!

I'd have to think the plot ended slopilly. Even with Hitlers death you still had enough Radicals in power to continue on the war. It would be difficult to imprison Himmler, Goebbels and keep them imprisoned.

Watch the mini series man in the glass tower, very interesting

Man in the high tower, and that explores the opposite of what op is suggesting. ​@@derrickclayton2544

@@derrickclayton2544do you mean Man in the High Castle?

Please tell me more about it. I would really like to know.

Sure. And Hitler was your grand grandfather.

Your cousin was a brave soldier. While he might have initially failed in his attempt to kill him that day, hitler was never the same mentally, emotionally and physically. He killed him, but not right away. He died only a year later.

@@Christrulesall2 Was also a psychopath that believed in lebensraum and extermination of other nations. Staufenberg did not try to assasinated hitler because he thought he is wrong. He tried it because he believed he is too soft and strategically inept. Basically that others would do what he started better.

The world is still pretty big, you just happen to be related to someone. If you think the world small then ask yourself this… could you paint it?

The Master of Antics is still the Master of Antics

feigaline! 😂

@@lightning2150jaja good one❤

"so fucked!"

Now that I realise he's fegeleine, this was so funny and ironic of a cast set up

What?

​@@triez9570 Oh, you don't know huh 😂

@@slowmercy69 probably not, mind explaining?

Downfall Hitler may rant to him once again

It's a scene from downfall the movie where Hitler was banging his table and screaming to find fegelein (the character Thomas played)

Is like the Moscow coup from Operation Prigozhin. Although is sad, even if he manage to capture Moscow, he will still end up something like the film.

@@KPPO200 I totally read your comment with a Russian accent. Was awesome

I bet his wardrobe doesn’t change that much

@@chrispepper121 Slightly. The uniform just goes from Wehrmacht to SS, with the rank going from Major to Generalleutnant der Waffen SS. And maybe the title of Master of Antics.

Kretschmann: “I get to play my ancestors, but I have to speak like the winners.”😂

FEGELEIN!

There were no AIs back then.

@@thiagodeandrade7081 womp womp

This made me remember how fucking uncanny Goebbels looked in downfall lmfao

It would've happened anyway, even if they had arrested Goebels. As soon as it people found out that Hitler was alive, the whole thing would've come undone. In order for the plan to work Hitler had to die in that bunker. It's kind of like the Godfather. Once Vito survived, Solazzo was SOL.

It would've happened anyway, even if they had arrested Goebels. As soon as people found out that Hitler was alive, the whole thing would've come undone. In order for the plan to work Hitler had to die in that bunker. It's kind of like the Godfather. Once Vito survived, Solazzo was SOL.

No, they were caught unawares. Contact across Germany's borders was extremely limited, and to the extent they had contact at all, Allied spymasters regarded Stauffenberg's group as just one more clique fighting for position as the Third Reich imploded.

You think it moved as well? Even a little?

@@RobertMc0811”oh it moved baby!”

@EricSoldadito Thanks.

Even Satan feared the Fuhrer

Fararge wishes he was half as popular

LOL not even close

Omg, op, I WISH farage was half, even a quarter, of the leader that the blessed furher was.

They did.

they already rounded up the jews

​@@Ras_al_Gore How them boots taste, goose-stepper?

@@justaguy723 I’m confused, am I wearing the boots, or am I licking them? I don’t think I’m flexible enough to do both.

@@Ras_al_GoreWith those mental gymnastics you do I’m sure you’re plenty flexible.

It just migrated to US and some part of europe

LARP

Cope you lost the war

@@Palestine4palestinies jt isn't over yet. But in reality the real "losers" weren't simply Germany it was all of western civilization. Thankfully there are more and more of us every single day who learn the truth. Thousands a day wake up and realize they've been lied to. anyway, have a good one.

No he asked if he was cool

Had you been in Germany at the time, you 100% would've been on board with Hitler just because it was the popular position.

Pretty much 😂 "Say how messed up is your moral compass exaaactly major?"

​@@josef1391 I highly doubt Goebels thought his movement to be corrupt...

The conspirators that attempted to assassinate him of course.

Actually, that was a rather accurate take of what Hitler's "normal voice" sounded like. Ie, what he sounded like when not making grandiose speeches but having normal conversation.

@@themanformerlyknownascomme777 No it wasnt lol. Hitlers natural speaking voice was deep as hell. In the video that was literally just an average voice, if not slightly higher pitched than average speaking in a whispering tone LOL

Yes, it is him

Спасибо, святой человек

Almost all of hia films are made in the UK. He lives there in a mansion