Arthur Morgan Tribute | Knocking On Heavens Door 

VideoLudix Xp I just wish you had put the clip of him saying thank you to his horse into it, then it would be perfect. Nobody ever seems to put that part into their videos and it was one of the most heart wrenching scenes in the game imho

@Madison ill keep it in mind thanks for the suggestion:)

I heard those words and not gonna lie at the end I knew he was gonna die, so I started crying.. when he said “I gave you all I had, Dutch. I really did” and thinking about what Mary said.. I cried that whole night just about.

"But he is fighting a giant"

The wet desert and that giant wins....time and time again

Yeah I remember hating him in the trailers.😥

As Arthur would say “me and my big mouth”

Rockstar definitely changed our expectations on this one, one of their best characters by far!

Well I wasn't like that, somehow I knew he would be great but he was even better

Pretty much, I hate playing as john. It doesn't feel right in this game, I've completed this game at least 7 times and each time I finish it, I play as john for 1 hour then start a new game.. everytime. Doing the same now as we speak

Although Arthur was a good man, I do not think he'd land himself in heaven..

@@anthoniespaanderman9257 you shut your damn mouth

@@Dagger_323 my son made it to heaven. You leave me to my emotions

@@Dagger_323 ayy you know I'm not serious right. I'm not even religious

TheGamekid01 Fuck off you lil shit

James Roper your father sounds like a top bloke and i am sorry for your loss

I am sorry for your loss your father sounded like Arthur a great man

Nobody’s indestructible pal get over it

@@savagewaygames9365 Just expressing my reasons for liking this game and the character of Arthur so much. No reason to be a dick about it pal. Oh and don't tell me what to do, what to think or what to feel. Nobody, not even God himself dictates an individual's free will.

@@markwhite5419 Thanks, but I'm fine. It's been ten years since he passed away, I've learned to live with the loss a long time ago. I was just sharing my reasons for liking this game and the character of Arthur.

😭😭😭

I know Arthur but I was only asking for faith

Loyal to what is realy matter

You know that all that really mattered to me was loyalty....it’s all I ever believed in

When did he say that? I don't remember that

Vexing Data John gave us that in RDR1 as well.

UgotREKT id argue its done better in rdr2 tho

Vexing Data hey man he showed something that everybody can relate love,loss,betrayal,and his real emotions

You know that is saying something

Tell that to jack Thompson

Chow fur beautiful

You bet he did

Don,t we all partner

No he's dead I shot him

No. He died.

I think many people gave up on it because it was slow at the start. There's colleagues that told me it was too slow of a game. I told em go play little big planet then 😂

@@MohammedMuhiUddin I was told by my friend "uh it so boring it takes to long" so i looked him dead In the eye and said "shut your fortnight lovin ass up"

Yeah

@@violent_knight69 don't have to get too serious about it. Its a just fuckin game for fucks sake. I made a joke about it. If people don't like something, fine by me, to each their own.

It didnt? Wow i thought it won. What won instead? You might have a good case if you argue its thr best game ever made.

There’s no alcohol in Heaven.

@@Dagger_323 I don't wanna go then. "When I die, fuck it, I wanna go to hell 'Cause I'm a piece of shit, it ain't hard to fuckin' tell It don't make sense, goin' to heaven with the goodie-goodies Dressed in white, I like black Timbs and black hoodies God'll prob'ly have me on some real strict shit No sleepin' all day, no gettin' my dick licked Hangin' with the goodie-goodies, loungin' in paradise Fuck that shit, I wanna tote guns and shoot dice"

I doubt either of them went to heaven

ThatUJohnWayne be careful what you wish for. Be very careful.

LOL

into sunrise

Arthur: beaten by a maniac before dying peacefully John: shot to pieces by dickheads Dutch: suicidal master plan

Dutch always has a plan

@@sleepu6186 even in the afterlife he still has a plan

Dutch first word p p p plain

Same

Yeah me too

He is a family member

Same and he’s my favorite character

I would've too, if it hadn't been obvious from the beginning he was gonna die. Lol

Hopefully someone will make a mod for PC where it turns out differently

I wish they would do it like gta 5 and let you switch between characters

I don’t think this is such a popular opinion but, I think that it would be cool to have a game where Dutch’s plan works now it’s going to take some time to explain so settle in. First and foremost Micha Bell needs to die saving Dutch, this would make a lot of things turn out different. We start out in black water with Micha dead there is only one plan Hosea’s and Arthur’s plan witch is more planed out and a more solid plan, with this robbery going as planed they won’t leave in such a rush thus making them able to grab the money and supplies they need, now the plan wouldn’t work perfect thus making it so that they still have to go on plan B going into the grizzlies and then more East escaping the law. Since they weren’t rushed they don’t have to rob the train and they can leave faster leaving more room between them and the law. They now reach horse shoe overlook much faster and thus making them not run into the law as fast because of that they didn’t rob Cornwall and so now the law does not now where they are and have to search after them for much longer and they won’t receive Cornwall’s funding cutting them short on supplies. The gang will still leave at around the same time since they are worried about the law. When it comes to the robbery on valentines bank they will still do it when they are located in Rhodes this decision is made to throw of the law. They won’t make the wagon robbery since Bill and Charles are away and Arthur doesn’t want to do it. When it comes to the Braithwaites and the Gray’s Arthur will bring up that the gold is mostly a roomer they won’t try and play them this means that when the go to San Denies they won’t get set up on the two robberies this means that Dutch won’t hurt his head and they will have enough money to slip away to TAHITI and of course as a distraction he will start a war between the native Americans and the American military. I might have missed something but you can fix that in your head boah.

Erin gamez Tv same here. That scene gets me every time

Erin gamez Tv Didn’t we all cry?

If you didn’t you’re a complete sociopath.

Or “I gave you all I had Dutch”

I am a 38 year-old man and I still get tears in my eyes every time

​@Leap Of faith​, Shut your bum da dum head ass up.

Leap Of faith yeah I agree Dutch was bad news... not the kinda guy id wanna hang around.

Ur comment is cringey as fuck dude

No... it’s a Lifeinvader……

Amen

Arthur gave a family to john? Thats weird, that means thar they...

@@hortensioarnaldo4996 arthur was probably the sole reason why john made it out alive

Arthur is johns gaurdian not a angle or demon but in between so he can help him amd his family but still do bad so he can get him and his family out when the time is right

@@SWY1356 He saved Abigail, Jack, and John three times

@@SWY1356 not probably. Was

I can't believe you said that when your profile pic is of Kazuma Kiryu, the legendary Yakuza from SEGA's Yakuza franchise. 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣

@BrokenHeartRoxas For me personally I never actually came across the memorial hall. I donated to it as Arthur and then completely forgot about it until I saw this tribute video. So I'm not sure. Sorry.

Guys, when you’re playing as John in the epilogue and after, you can go to that building in Saint Denis and walk up to the plaque. John will look at it and say something about Arthur’s name being there

James Roper Fr

We will always remember him that’s why we have him remain in our hearts.

James Roper or you can change the ending to that Arthur goes on his own to find a better life since you can’t change the ending to rdr1

Nah, Arthur had to die for the events of RDR1 to transpire. Plus, the ending wouldn't have been impactful if he survived.

It’s a good idea but I preferred the epic death of Arthur and the fearless death of John

Was this at the bar?

Duncan Egberts Yes, and then Arthur tells him to shut up lol

And Arhtur stay very shocked with Sean death too, and Hosea, and Eagle Fly... oh man, he is so sad about hes fellas dying. Arthur is very emotionaly. I miss him. 😔🌅

They aint in heaven

John Rainey lol that was funny I remember that mission

This is true.

Well if it isnt Arthur Morgan, how is heaven, hope it is cozy up there...

Your up here too

Thanks Arthur ❤😅

Try watching Way Down We Go, compadre.

VideoLudix Xp no problem feller

What about john you basterd

jim milton john? I only ever heard of Rip van winkle

@@ollies1st446 rip van winkle? I only ever heard of jim Milton

@@hawkmanwalter4250 Ah yes so is he um, riding again?

@@ollies1st446 he be riding abagail yes

Didn’t we all lol

Arthur I thought you died

O Orthor

When he says his name I almost cry alot

Right, I think that was caught in actual gameplay since I don't remember that scene ever happening during that mission so that makes it even more impressive

Dude I'm sad

Thanks for watching:)

That's what arthur was he was a God damn man even if he was afraid of what comes before him

He died happy with his wish to watch the sun rise facing east And you see that beautiful buck and a warm golden aura if you are a good man

That's what it was originally written for wasn't it?

@@theAngryscotman yup during the random lawman who got shot and dying while his Injun wife look at him

Hanferd yeah the Bob Dylan version. Not this shit

My pp hurt Gang I understood that reference

We all now this game but they are make us to believe this is not just game this is got everything 😞😞😞

Arthur is an example telling us we can live bad lives and feel like bad men, but in reality we are not we just have to be willing to do the right thing.

thanks for watching:)

thanks for being here:) means a lot:)

No. I cried over the death of my horse too.

It was my pleasure:) thanks for watching:)

Thanks for watching ❤

Thats part of being a good man, the best a man gets.. the more aware of his failures he is. Best character in fiction for me.