Тёмный

As Pakistan Implodes, India Rises | View from Across the Border 

Wajahat S. Khan
Подписаться 454 тыс.
Просмотров 190 тыс.
50% 1

#pakistan isn't too well. The country's "polycrisis" has it struggling economically, politically, constitutionally and even socially. Meanwhile, #India is rising: now the world's fastest growing economy, India is also the darling of the global multilateral order. What is the view of Pakistan's problems from across the border? #barkhadutt of ‪@mojostory‬ is #wajahatsaeedkhan's guest for this episode.
Based between New York, London and Pakistan, Emmy-nominated journalist #wajahatsaeedkhan breaks down the latest from New York.
Subscribe to his RU-vid at / wajahatskhan
Follow him on Twitter at wajskhan
Like him on Facebook at journalismwsk
Bio: Wajahat S. Khan is an Emmy-nominated journalist and author reporting on Indo-Pacific security and focusing on the Af-Pak conflict. An Adjunct Professor at New York University’s Center of Global Affairs and a Non-Resident Senior Fellow at Washington’s Atlantic Council, Khan is a graduate of the Columbia University School of Journalism and the University of Michigan, and Pakistan’s only Shorenstein Fellow from Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government. He has reported from 16 countries covering conflict, diplomacy, and media for digital, cable and network news. During the final years of U.S. military operations in Afghanistan, Khan was bureau chief in Kabul and Islamabad for NBC News, and embedded with over a hundred NATO, Afghan, Indian and Pakistani military units as he covered South Asia for leading British, Indian and Pakistani networks and publications since the beginning of the 2001 U.S. invasion of Afghanistan. He frequently dabbles in cricket, and is the author of the 2019 Amazon / Harper Collins sports bestseller, Game Changer: Being Shahid Afridi. He lives between New York City, London and Karachi and drives a very, very fast car.

Опубликовано:

 

28 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2 тыс.   
@malikmahmoud9125
@malikmahmoud9125 Год назад
India is not run by establishment, people are empowered to run the system by their representatives. In Pakistan Army decides who will run the country, Army means few generals on top not armed forces as institution. We overseas Pakistanis urge , appeal establishment not to support autocratic PDM regime whose base is illegitimate. Crackdown on innocent workers , citizens, journalists and PTI leadership will bring the country to total disaster.
@jess-qe5ed
@jess-qe5ed Год назад
Pak 93000 surrender army: never won a war outside pakistan, never lost a war inside pakistan
@janjavaid7270
@janjavaid7270 Год назад
Absolutely right
@banksterkid5930
@banksterkid5930 Год назад
​@@jess-qe5ed arrogance and self awareness seldom go together
@Bohra681
@Bohra681 Год назад
You have rightly pointed out that Army in Pakistan is commanding the country. Whenever, and we also can see the past record as well, India tried to develop the cordial relationship the Pak Army destabilized by involving by terrorist attacks. To put army under democratic system somehow Imran has voiced. But again army successfully with the help of present Govt nearly calm down.
@sunildhuper2450
@sunildhuper2450 Год назад
What other source of lively hood Pakistan provide their youth?
@qctr
@qctr Год назад
I am a South Indian with almost no common ground with a Pakistani. I share more of my culture with the Thai or Indonesians than with Pakistanis. Here is what we (atleast many of us) think of Pakistan. Pakistan is a great nation with wonderful natural resources, fertile lands, and talented people. We seriously think Pakistan needs a national identity that isn't mere India-hatred, fueled by religious identity. We have absolutely NO interest in invading Pakistan - we merely want to be left alone. We are busy in our day to day lives and usually don't give a thought about Pakistan unless there is a cricket match. We think of Pakistanis as misguided, radicalised to certain extent to hate, dehumanise Indians and specifically Hindus (and Yahudis), so much so that there is serious othering. We still don't think the 'two-nation theory' is valid. We think Hindus, Muslims, Christians can live together in a pluralistic, tolerant society. When I meet a fellow south indian who is muslim, the fact that he is muslim hardly matters to me - it does not affect me in any way, has nothing to do with my interactions and it is as natural as meeting any other human being. Same for females. As a nation of 1.4 billion, we are bound to have a lot of people who aren't quite as tolerant as everybody else, but there is no systemic fault lines here.
@michealanderson2282
@michealanderson2282 Год назад
fantastic,agree with you completely.
@biorig
@biorig Год назад
Nailed it. The North Western India including some from UP harp on 'Shared Culture' (Even Nehru did that). Especially our languages are so similar and our food is the same. But nope, I have idly, gunpowder with ghee and coconut chutney for breakfast. Rice with Sambhar, Rasam and Curd for lunch and Dosa with Mint Chutney for Dinner. Chapatis once in a while too, but not my staple. Almost nobody in Pakistan will understand my language Telugu and Tamil while I can completely understand Urdu (because of Hindi). Whatever we had in common is now tedious and culturally divergent.
@aatmaja3
@aatmaja3 Год назад
True we are not at all interested to them 😂
@jaideepc786
@jaideepc786 Год назад
What an excellent, perfectly summarized essay of the realistic situation, esp amongst the educated urban Indians.? I can say almost the same from Pune, Western Maharashtra. Growing up in convent schools, university life, it hardly occurred to us that someone is a Muslim or Christian, I mean we were certainly aware, but it never ever got in the way in establishing deep friendship bonds and professional relationships. Yes we are 1 Billion plus, and actually a bunch of 4-5 regional countries, (say tell me a similarity between a Punjabi HINDU and an Andhra or Kerala HINDU in terns of food, customs, skin color built, language, except say celebrating versions of Dassehra, Diwali, Ganesh Chaturthi. When it comes to the educated upper middle class in a Amritsar, a Pune, Bombay, Hyderabad, Bangalore, Cochin or Chennai, Christman or Eid festivities will be enjoyed with equal fervour,. more specifically the food, the gaiety and enjoyment angle.. India is such a great melting pot of myriad cultures, and frankly so engrossed in getting prosperous (last 2 decades) and getting their children & relatives into top European, American, Australian & Singapore schools /colleges, that hardly anybody thinks of Pakistan, except maybe from a security or terrorism angle.
@AnandKumar-qn6rt
@AnandKumar-qn6rt Год назад
Correct..And As Tarek Fatah used to say the roots of the problems of pakistan has been Urdu. There is a supremacist attitude about Urdu ..71 breakup was also related to that. And here Bollwood is also still fascinated with Urdu ..Johars ,Chopras ,multiple Kapoor families ,Khans etc have ensured that.
@kunal25roy
@kunal25roy Год назад
Barkha Dutt defending current Indian Govt. Really really surprised...
@SPmis
@SPmis Год назад
Is it so?? Strange..... Then I have to watch it. 😄😄
@venkatganapathy3123
@venkatganapathy3123 Год назад
Where is she defending it ? She is very diplomatic and careful in her expressions so as not to offend the other side.
@Demigod110
@Demigod110 Год назад
That's rare clip it😂
@subhajitguha3283
@subhajitguha3283 Год назад
Line me chala aya.She d oes not have any choice the way she has been marginalised after Modi came into power.
@vg82
@vg82 Год назад
Roti khani hai isko bhi , congress ne bhi isko chor diya hai
@jawadahmed355
@jawadahmed355 Год назад
Indians are very hard working guys. Very focused. Above all help eachother .. rather than pulling legs
@javedchaudry4520
@javedchaudry4520 Год назад
As Moeed Pirzada said recently in one of his VLogs: Pakistan’s problem #1 is ….. Its Army Pakistan’s problem #2 is ….. Its Army Pakistan’s problem #3 is ….. Its Army …….. and so on ……… I agree 100% with that. Lots of educated people in Pakistan, especially outside Pakistan, agree with the above. So what are we doing to get rid of Pakistan’s problem #1? If, this is not the problem, what is? We surely have to identify the problem or problems. Are we trying to identify the problems? If we cannot identify the problems, then obviously we cannot resolve them! And we have not resolved any. Hence the status quo remains, glaring in the face. Where do we go from here?
@hunk3891
@hunk3891 Год назад
He was wrong. The problem lies somewhere else.
@harishpatel1988
@harishpatel1988 Год назад
The Pakistani Army are running the country, they have been running the country and will be running the country for the foreseeable future.
@Jvs-eq3iy
@Jvs-eq3iy Год назад
I was just now looking at the last days of Jinnah. He was just left to die by Liaquat Ali Khan.
@dodiraj1
@dodiraj1 Год назад
Peerzada types were on the payrolls of the Army. To be taken seriously he should donate all his previous earnings from the Army to charity
@AshokSingh-nw1pr
@AshokSingh-nw1pr Год назад
Mood pirjada not correct ,in ancient times goon King were corrected by Brahman to make them welfare king , I mean literate people are not fulfilling their own men because force is always cruel
@adityajoies
@adityajoies Год назад
Am I living in a parallel universe? Barkha is that you defending India's position in such a great manner!? I am bloody impressed.
@rupesharma
@rupesharma Год назад
She is always good when defending position with non Indians. She is smart and intelligent.
@SodiumSyndicate
@SodiumSyndicate Год назад
@@rupesharma Nope, only with Pakistanis. There is an interview of Barkha with Ayan Hirsi Ali & she rants against Hindus in a discussion on Islamic reforms.
@narasimharao9492
@narasimharao9492 Год назад
She tried and she has given up on criticizing Modi.. Nowadays she has more or less calmed down on Modi..
@agrippa-theskeptic9346
@agrippa-theskeptic9346 Год назад
Barkha does not hate India. Barkha hates Hindu, Hinduism!
@adityajoies
@adityajoies Год назад
@@narasimharao9492 Yeah it's kind of weird because she calmed down after according to her became an independent journalist! She is ideologically the same Barkha Dutt but she stopped pushing her agenda down the throat to everyone.
@vipulguru1
@vipulguru1 Год назад
Pakistan was long dead both financially and structurally but US interest in Afg kept it at the life support. It was actually US withdrawal from afganistan which accelerated Pakistan downhill trajectory. In fact the USA is now covertly but actively supporting the fall for backstabbing it in Afghanistan.
@mekaielqazi6808
@mekaielqazi6808 Год назад
She rightly mentioned Mr Lambah’s book, In pursuit of peace. Mr Satinder Lambah and Mr Tariq Aziz, who both passed away recently, were the only 2 diplomats in history who actually promised peace between India and Pakistan and made actual progress.
@namansrivastav2008
@namansrivastav2008 Год назад
It's a fabulous read and I am on second last chapter. I was astonished to read how closely diplomats from both sides mingled together through back channel diplomacy.
@Victor-y9g1w
@Victor-y9g1w Год назад
liar. tariq made fool of lambah. tariq ne lambah ko lamba kar diya.
@FilesdocumentsAndreposit-kr3vb
Lambah was a Punjabi naturally Punjabis are very sympathetic to Pakistan
@FilesdocumentsAndreposit-kr3vb
Lambah was a Punjabi naturally Punjabis are very sympathetic to Pakistan
@Victor-y9g1w
@Victor-y9g1w Год назад
@@FilesdocumentsAndreposit-kr3vb maje detee hai kafiron ki laundiya
@muhammadsohaibtariq3087
@muhammadsohaibtariq3087 Год назад
Pakistan & India have no competition in any field. India is taking all initiatives on its own as an independent/ sovereign state while on the other hand Pakistan is moving forward with the help of its proxies & so-called friends as Pakistan's pockets are completely empty and cannot breathe without international financial assistance. (Tariq - Peshawar, Pakistan)
@harminderkaur4994
@harminderkaur4994 Год назад
Article 370 is suspended & still part of Indian constitution, its clause 1a states that Article can be suspended, that's what has been done.
@phoenixmux
@phoenixmux Год назад
Countries have armies and our army has a country
@NRDSmokeShop
@NRDSmokeShop Год назад
Pakistani establishment would never allow politicians to succeed in any way specifically economically coz that will weaken the military grip on the power & control on Resources of Pakistan.
@rothmensone1
@rothmensone1 Год назад
first time i have ever hear barkha dutt. i must say she presented her country very well. very well informed and well spoken lady. i really enjoyed listening to her views on india pakistan situation. much love and respect from 🇬🇧 🇵🇰
@SodiumSyndicate
@SodiumSyndicate Год назад
Barkha did not bring up the r*pe genocide of Hindus in Pakistan while Wajahat Khan brings up the nonsense issue of minority rights in India.
@msr7373
@msr7373 Год назад
I think Indians are really ungreatful for not accepting her calibre and running after people like Arnab.
@csheru
@csheru Год назад
Uske pas options nahi hain...hum usko bahut acche se jaante hain
@xijinpig8982
@xijinpig8982 Год назад
​@@msr7373 this lady justified the genocide of Kashmiri Pandits on National TV. There's a limit to tolerance.
@msr7373
@msr7373 Год назад
@@xijinpig8982 same can be said about multiple Indian journalists and even commoner Indians who deny the killings of thousands of Kashmiri Muslims (much higher then the pundits , even Kashmiri Pandit organizations put the pundit death toll to a mere 400-500 of which 90% took place in the 90s only unlike the Muslim death toll which are around 90000-10000) or even justify the killings of Muslims so is there a limit to that as well or only for the pundits ? Atleast pundits had an option to go to rest of india Kashmir’s off and on get roughed in rest of india on slighted today pretext
@koibatnahi4683
@koibatnahi4683 Год назад
Impressive discussion. Both sides making clear their respective povs yet having a sane discussion. This is how things should be.
@artyzan
@artyzan Год назад
After the longest time,i have enjoyed Barkha Dutt's point of view on the indian stance on the pak situation today....she is bang on in her synopsis.....i am glad she has put it out there!!! Great conversation between Wajahat n Barkha....
@gunjanagrawal8195
@gunjanagrawal8195 Год назад
Yes it's true that BJP does Hindu, Muslim polarization.....but only for electoral purpose , when it's comes to transfer benefit of central government, state government schemes then all the minorities it's get benefitted...... Btw our Indian Muslim population is likely equal to Pakistan Muslim population, but in Pakistan no Hindu population can even 1% of that .......forced conversion, religious extremism, violence in Hindu festival like Holi and Diwali ruined their lives😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
@asmanoureen3923
@asmanoureen3923 Год назад
With due respect Gunjan, I believe that forces conversion is more of political stunt used by opportunists in Pakistan. Yes, there may be few incidents , perhaps, less than india. However, it shouldn’t be allowed anywhere on this planet. Everyone has the fundamental right to choose their faith & way of living. Let’s try to bridge the gap & spread more love & acceptance. Lots of best wishes for you from Pakistan.
@yourend3177
@yourend3177 Год назад
Nope, completely wrong in certain aspects. Yes, BJP does hindu-muslim polarisation for election benefit. But if need arises for election win, we will see repeat of gujarat. Yes, muslims, esp in cow belt are very violent, but so are hindus. Not even justifying religious conversions in Pakistan. There is none, not even for any political benefits. Karma is real and it bites back. State benefit in India----nope, you are completely wrong in that. Most benefits are given to corporates, then the ministers(even opposition is being financially ruined), then bureaucrats, and the rest to general class public. Muslims are completely marginalised, except for one or two businessman, few politicians, and rich nawabs of mughals, who licked british boots to retain their wealth, like many Indian royals. You will see the violent rise of SC, ST, OBC if this continues. It has not happened yet, coz of food programs. But things always change, economies tether. But when you have masses on food rations, it always resulted in violent uprising, against those who oppressed them. Has been true in China, France, Middle east, Russia, Ireland, would have been in pakistan, if not for Imran khan hope and army boot.What makes you think India would be any different? In case of India it will be against general class(more specifically those in power) who are seen as oppressors. Godi media is reaching masses, so is unemployment and poverty. Alternate media is rising rapidly and we see protests, coz ''shining India'' is not possible with masses under poverty. While masses see what is being discussed here--- so close, yet so far, they are frustrated.
@muhammadahsansaleem9536
@muhammadahsansaleem9536 Год назад
I am totally against forced conversions (if happening). FYI, Hindu population % in Pakistan by year 1951 ----- 1.58% 2017 ----- 2.14%. Actually, the Hindu population has increased.
@madmax-bu6wt
@madmax-bu6wt Год назад
@@muhammadahsansaleem9536 pls quote numbers of muslim population in india
@muhammadahsansaleem9536
@muhammadahsansaleem9536 Год назад
@@madmax-bu6wt 14.2% as per 2011 census. But what purpose will this argument serve?
@zeshaan2282
@zeshaan2282 Год назад
I believe that the current situation is because of our own attitude and approach towards life and the society. We as people and as society are mostly corrupt and at such big level that we dont recognize the day to day corruption we commit
@mshamirtaloo
@mshamirtaloo Год назад
Conclusion: India is far ahead in the race Even Bangladesh has left us behind WHERE IS PAKISTAN? WHOM we are competing with NEPAL? SUDAN?? Who is RESPONSBILE for THIS?
@madmax-bu6wt
@madmax-bu6wt Год назад
People. Pampered their Army, trampled on minorities, supported terrorists , constantly lied and back stabbed one and all, religious bigotry , backed megalomaniacal imran against corrupt Nawaz.
@prince_playhouse
@prince_playhouse Год назад
Even Nepal's currency is valuable more than Pakistani rupee 😂
@richardsking
@richardsking Год назад
Wajahat sir, as an Indian I must say, now Indian people are not that interested in happenings in Pakistan except for some who are very optimistic,here mostly people are busy in their own works.
@Victor-y9g1w
@Victor-y9g1w Год назад
even then you spent so much time here.
@pipipupu5104
@pipipupu5104 Год назад
​@@Victor-y9g1wdude he is not troll
@Demigod110
@Demigod110 Год назад
I wrote this is 2014 that it's high time we stop comparing ourselves with pakistan, we must compete & compare ourselves with developed nations & I'm glad this govt. has done that exactly bharat way to big & rich culturally, civilization wise to even compare itself with a country which disintegrated within 30yrs that to by defying the very logic on the basis of which it came into existence.
@subramayamrvr8774
@subramayamrvr8774 Год назад
The pressure of sharia from Afghanistan and attraction of democracy from India and communist dictatorship in China theocracy of Iran are lessons for Pakistan.
@contrarian322
@contrarian322 Год назад
No mind of their own .
@tasneemiqbal6023
@tasneemiqbal6023 Год назад
There’s good and bad people in every country. Some of them hate us but mostly like us. Their love shows in Abrar wildlens RU-vid Channel. People in India love him and he’s from Pakistan.
@hunk3891
@hunk3891 Год назад
Idolaters and Islam, you know.
@harishpatel1988
@harishpatel1988 Год назад
Seeing India thru Abrar's eyes has been fantastic. Eagerly waiting to see Lahore thru his camera.
@ayushbadmosh
@ayushbadmosh Год назад
People love Abrar because of his nature and humility
@HarishSharma-uv1co
@HarishSharma-uv1co Год назад
Aise hi hai hum india wale .payaar karne wale.
@infotainment3817
@infotainment3817 Год назад
Well nice to watch such productive conversation , what i believe is India has done a favour with pakistan by parting its ways with us and eying for a greater economy. So one counterpart is clearly saying no to war, which means other one have to come to economic side automatically, so thanks to india im seeing a different south asia in next 10,15 years .
@arjunps6776
@arjunps6776 Год назад
Pakistan was a thought experiment which should have remained as one. But if you make a thought experiment a reality without any plan on how to implement it, today's situation is what you get. As Indians, we should be careful. Whenever Pak army has been weak like it is today, they do some mischief against India. Eternal vigilance should be Indian policy against a country that wants forever war.
@Nezavecemost
@Nezavecemost Год назад
Pakistan journalists must learn from Indian journalists , even though Barakah Datt is so called liberal journalist , when it come to patriotism And defending their country , they always have a very well defined lines
@realistuser
@realistuser Год назад
Still some people abusing her
@Anony479
@Anony479 Год назад
Nothing of the sort exists in Pakistan. We have journalists who go with the wind. Case in point, this interview.
@neutralmind6497
@neutralmind6497 Год назад
​​​@@Anony479 very true like this journalist. This is the sad story of Pakistan.
@hammadiqbal9971
@hammadiqbal9971 Год назад
Patriotic journalists are missing persons in pakistan.
@RaviKumar-tv9rf
@RaviKumar-tv9rf Год назад
@@realistuser yes, because we know her reality 😂😂
@GiridharKrishnasamy
@GiridharKrishnasamy Год назад
This man's anxiety clearly suggests that he is just not able to stomach India moving way ahead of Pakistan. He should learn to smell the coffee and move on, as simple as that. However hard you try to put up a different facade, your demeanor clearly suggests your visceral hatred for India. Have a good night's sleep Wajahat to wake up to another reality tomorrow.
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw Год назад
Like Dr. Muktadar Khan said - "Every achievement of IN becomes a source of acute pain for PK." And that increases their (PK's) import bill for procuring more Burnol to address that pain. 🙂
@Anony479
@Anony479 Год назад
Let’s not get carried away. Pakistan isn’t going anywhere. Crises are cyclical. Pakistan will stabilize and most Pakistanis don’t care much for what goes on in India. If a country of 1.4B people cannot manage a bigger economy and resources than a country of 220 million then shame on you. Compare yourselves to China with a smaller population and an economy that is 5x larger than India’s.
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw Год назад
@@Anony479 Regarding your comment: "....... most Pakistanis don’t care much for what goes on in India.": I glance through a few English PK newspapers every once a while. The amount of material/colums there on IN has convinced me that PK is over obsessed with IN. However - if you believe that PK is not obsessed with IN - I guess it is "whatever that lets you sleep better at night." 🙂 Now - I do not know what makes you say that "......cannot manage a bigger economy and resources....." You may wish that it were the case - but reality is quite the contrary - if you even happen to glance through only the PK newspapers items. 🙂
@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz
@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz Год назад
​@@Anony479good point.... As an indian.. I appreciate your critical and logical point of view...
@HarishSharma-uv1co
@HarishSharma-uv1co Год назад
@@ShyamKumar-zb2mw every 3rd youtuber is making money in pakstan showing india.
@SyedAliRizvi1472
@SyedAliRizvi1472 Год назад
What is happening in our country rightnow.. Just look at the last 20 years The only thing do u see in common is corruption everywhere.. We r morality corrupt..😞😞
@prince_playhouse
@prince_playhouse Год назад
As an Indian I'm really sad bout Pakistan bro. I think the biggest problem of Pakistan is low literacy rate and inocent emotional pepoles so it's easy for govt and army to fool out people on the name of religion and India
@sch1210
@sch1210 Год назад
What Jinnah expected from Pakistan at the time of Partition and how really it turned out to be a disaster is amazing!
@exo-gamerz2662
@exo-gamerz2662 Год назад
Unfortunate, Indeed 😢
@psk2266
@psk2266 9 месяцев назад
India is not just watching but even waiting for Pakistan to again become pregnant to give birth to 3 Children ie Baluchistan, Pashtunistan and Sindhudesh.. 😂😂
@prashants17
@prashants17 Год назад
Barkha did us proud here, excellent show overall
@thebestevertherewas
@thebestevertherewas Год назад
Born too late for sea exploration, born too early for space exploration. Born just in time for this
@ucomputerz
@ucomputerz Год назад
Great debate , Wajahat and Burkha. Enjoyed it thoroughly. I can actually feel your passion and sincere concerns for the Indo Pak issues on the geographical, economical, and political front. However, I wonder why we neighbors can't work it out like the USA/Canada situation. Right? I remember how during Gen. Musharraf's time we travelled from Lahore to Delhi by bus. Wow! An amazing trip with plenty of hospitality etc. Plus , during Gen Zia's regime we went to India by train. Another memorable experience!!😊☺️. At that time whoever we met in India were impressed with everything imported in Pakistan.😂😂. While we were impressed with everything made in India! Such polarized ideologies have brought us to where we are currently! Ironic, isn't it?☺️ . I'm from Rawalpindi, Pakistan, living in Chicago, currently. Please do get in touch if you wish. It would truly be an honor. Blessings to you both. 🙏🙏.
@zachariahtitus1210
@zachariahtitus1210 Год назад
The day punjabi Pakistani come to their senses and act like normal human beings all the problems of Pakistan will be solved. This is the truth.
@madmax-bu6wt
@madmax-bu6wt Год назад
Tells how little you know of the situation. Must be from South
@zachariahtitus1210
@zachariahtitus1210 Год назад
@@madmax-bu6wt ..truth hurts huh! 😃
@ucomputerz
@ucomputerz Год назад
@@madmax-bu6wt The idea is to carry on with the current situation, which has existed over the past forty years or so. We commoners can't fix it, so live with it and enjoy all the positives it offers within your own communities. 🙏☺️
@Victor-y9g1w
@Victor-y9g1w Год назад
burka should wear burka and go with wajahat. she will be safe in paxtan.
@zubairarshad3143
@zubairarshad3143 Год назад
Sadly, Pakistan's current situation is very tough to own as Pakistani ... But as my skipper recently said that there is always a bright morning after the darkest of the night. IN THE END, i would try to request all Indo Pak people not to say hateful things about each other. Either you learn to ignore or just do good comments. And mark my words , if someone reads it... Only cricket and music melt our border & better relation of Pak with Indian Muslims and Ind Muslims role model relation With Ind Hindus .... I still believe that you never know, but we can become.states like Usa and canda even much stronger .. now bye guys .. dua , pratna mai yaad rakhna ... pakistan zindabad ... Jai Hind. ❤
@hunk3891
@hunk3891 Год назад
Idolaters, Polytheists.
@zubairarshad3143
@zubairarshad3143 Год назад
@HUNK Yes, guys , if somebody is reading further replies, just remember one thing .. I would rather like to igonre, but it's important to make it clear once and for all.. Chutiyas exist everywhere .... Doesn't matter what religion they follow or what race or country they belong .. chutiya will always remain chutiya ... either in Pakistan or India.. chutiya stays chutiya going to the moon to the pluto then towards anderoma galaxy and coming back to subcontinent, Earth. A chutiya will always remain chutiya .. Thanks .... 😊
@realistuser
@realistuser Год назад
Yaa amazing but only in text
@hamdeath1110
@hamdeath1110 Год назад
I have nothing against the Indians but you should really see on social media how much they hate Pakistan and the people of Pakistan As said by the guy who grew up with Indians and who surrendered in East Pakistan 1971 (General AAK Niazi): "Whatever the case is, we should never trust these Indians"
@nitinbhaskar7166
@nitinbhaskar7166 Год назад
Terror and talk can't go together...we don't want any relation with Pakistan
@debabrata9864
@debabrata9864 Год назад
The anchor has given a lesson to BarkhaDutta on Modiji
@kuk3543
@kuk3543 10 месяцев назад
I am Indian. India china ke muqable jiaada aaghe nahin bara . Lekin Pakistan apne kamo ki wajah se peeche raha hai. Meri dua karta hoon ke ye dono mulak aapas main ral kar aage baren ge. O God
@psrinivas1810
@psrinivas1810 Год назад
Too much religiosity is not good for both the country’s. I remember once in Japan a senior industrialist told me that we Japanese think of religion only when we are about pass away.
@IITTPPEEDD
@IITTPPEEDD Год назад
Yes spirituality! Not so much religiosity
@HarishSharma-uv1co
@HarishSharma-uv1co Год назад
When your neighbors r too religious it has some effect on u too
@arupkumardas8636
@arupkumardas8636 Год назад
Mr. Wajahat this is for the first time i am watching your channel. Honestly speaking I had no idea that Pakistan could have such prudent and brilliant journalist. thanks for inviting Barkha, she has always been my favourite despite i do not agree with her views in many a ways in terms of internal issues. But she is a proponent of nationhood doctrine and made India proud on several occasions. I think the basic difference between the citizens of these two countries are we do not put religion first and our education is emancipated from madrasa style affairs.
@pankaja7974
@pankaja7974 Год назад
see the interview wajahat took of the great lata mangeshkar
@HarishSharma-uv1co
@HarishSharma-uv1co Год назад
Cant u see he is behaving like regular paxstani.hum atomi mulk hai. China hamara naya abbu hai.kashmir hamari saarag hai.
@ash9x9
@ash9x9 Год назад
Dont get fooled by this Video. He is merely making videos for Indian viewers so he has to play this double game.
@HarishSharma-uv1co
@HarishSharma-uv1co Год назад
Fu....dduu. Mat ban all paxstani r snakes.
@Victor-y9g1w
@Victor-y9g1w Год назад
hindoo kafir
@ali.khalid88
@ali.khalid88 Год назад
Well done India 🎉👏
@msg4vickky
@msg4vickky Год назад
Came here to read comments.. Barkha doesn't disappoint.. she was mum on hindu minority rights in pakistan.. because deep down she is carrying FBI (F*** By Is***) syndrome.. Unfortunately for her most Indians have come out of it..
@dsaxena0601
@dsaxena0601 Год назад
He looks so angry with Barkha not siding with him. It’s funny, he is pulling China on India? Barkha is so sorted and talking facts.
@chaitanyakada1341
@chaitanyakada1341 Год назад
Nice conversations between TWO Pakistanis.. Very interesting to see their synergy and similar thoughts..
@msr7373
@msr7373 Год назад
The issue in Pakistan crystallizes to economy. It’s actually not that much about the democracy or anything else. Had that been the case China would have been snubbed by the world (they are anything but a democracy) but China has always focused on its economic activity and outshined the world esp in infrastructure development. If and only if the ruling elite of Pakistan understand that by growing the economic pie they can benefit as well, the situation can be different but the issue appears is that they have not been able to understand this .
@Seshamani99
@Seshamani99 Год назад
Impressed to learn from you of the current fame of Barkha Dutt. Didnt know that she is considered the most famous journalist in India - wow. When did this happen.
@Amayra-zd1ec
@Amayra-zd1ec Год назад
She is famous in India for being radical left wing, meaning of left in India is different. Here left wing is anti-national, anti-establishment and are puppets to foreign nations to work for their own interests.
@Amayra-zd1ec
@Amayra-zd1ec Год назад
She's most hated person in India I'd say. As u can see comment section we Indians are surprised that first time she's talking right about India of things as it is instead of putting any of her agenda. Maybe because she's now not the part of her former NDTV network .m
@shyamsundard.r1782
@shyamsundard.r1782 Год назад
I was impressed about Mr Wahahatkgan's opening remarks about India ❤. I had negative feelings about Barkhadutt and thought that she would speak ill about Mr Modi and the present Government ( Like Rahul Gandhi washes dirty linen in public) as she speaks in the debates within the country. I am she spoke well about India, especially about Kashmir in particular. Mr. Modi is definitely the light of India !!! Nice Podcast ! Jai Hind 👌🙏💐👍.
@shabirhussain-rf8nz
@shabirhussain-rf8nz Год назад
Well done India
@deepakpatil5405
@deepakpatil5405 Год назад
Actually the people of India are coming around to the notion of converting LOC into international border & once for all the Kashmir issue be Resolved. But then , would Pakistani army & Politicians agree to such a solution? I don't think so. Because then that will be " shuttre down" of their shops.
@mohakmilindsingh999
@mohakmilindsingh999 Год назад
*🕉️🚩 🇮🇳 INDIA 🇮🇳🚩 🕉️*
@sunildhuper2450
@sunildhuper2450 Год назад
No punjabi will stand with Imran, hundred years ago they did'nt stand with their Hindu religion.
@dr_talhatariq789
@dr_talhatariq789 Год назад
One Man vs All Political , And co. Ltd
@a.k.830
@a.k.830 Год назад
29:45 Wajahat is talking about nuclear weapons. 😆. When Pakistanis have got nothing else to talk about, they talk of nukes. After all, it is the only thing they have got to be proud of. He thinks that the military aggression is the only way India can defeat Pakistan or China can defeat India! 😂Unless India becomes very weak, China shall never attack India for some barren mountains (similarly, unless Pakistan becomes very weak, India won't attack Pakistan). Pakistanis think war is fun. War is a serious business. If China attacks India, it might win overall and may (or may not) gain its political objectives (to capture a few ridges in Ladakh and Tawang in Arunachal Pradesh) but that war shall be very expensive for China and shall reduce China's stature in front of the U.S. and that is what the U.S. wants (and an India-Pakistan War would reduce India's stature in front of China and that is what China wants; China would never want to attack India, China would rather want Pakistan to attack India and cut India to size. Chinese use vassal states like Pakistan and North Korea to keep their enemies engaged). Pakistanis don't understand that wars take developing nations 10-20 years behind as Pakistan has lived off a begging bowl its entire life. Theirs is an mercenary army and a beggar state. But Chinese are not like Pakistanis. They understand that any India-China War will cost China at least 1 trillion dollars and then there is a risk of nuclear escalation as well. Would China spend 1 trillion dollars for Ladakh and Tawang, or would it rather spend it to integrate a prospeous Taiwan? Between India and Taiwan, India is a more formidable enemy and gains from attacking India are much lower than attacking India.
@raveendranputhalath6993
@raveendranputhalath6993 Год назад
Delighted to see that Bharkha is talking sense for a change…
@isloooo
@isloooo Год назад
Very balanced analysis by barkha dutt.. Pakistans problem is structural.
@80sidd
@80sidd Год назад
Osama bin laden
@zirrasheikh762
@zirrasheikh762 Год назад
Just to add more on Barkha's Opinion. Men are said to have specific physique on television and in work places as well. Secondly abortion right means giving killing rights they shouldn't be given to anyone after a certain stage of pregnancy. Thirdly women with a healthy family tend to spend more time with their family than outside. That's a fact because women are designed more emotional and sentimental than men but ofcourse exceptions are there but those exception doesn't opt for the family in the forst place. Fourth is related to my third point men are paid more cuz they are willing to go the extra mile in our culture and religion men are supposed to provide for the family and in that sense they bear extra responsibility. You can disagree but these are my observations.
@ponchuronaldinho2752
@ponchuronaldinho2752 Год назад
Sahi pakda madam
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw Год назад
Great ideas, Ma'am - especially for the 7th century. 🙂
@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz
@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz Год назад
That's why barkha dutt has no husband and children like Normal happy family...... She says to justify her misery.... 😅
@MohsinRaza-uq2ow
@MohsinRaza-uq2ow Год назад
@@ShyamKumar-zb2mw lol zyada liberal bnoge to dusro k bche paloge khud Ki biwi k sath jese west m hota h ye 7th century Ki hi revolution h jise tu mazak bna rha h jo aaj b prevalent h Tera to koi wajud h n kapde European phnte ho aur bnna b unki trh h pr family system n chahte wesi. The western family system is so messed up u can see why many western influencers convert to Islam willingly only bcz of the 7th century revolution that u just mocked
@rajatrj5714
@rajatrj5714 Год назад
@@MohsinRaza-uq2ow but you missed that point many muslims also have been leaving islam after settling in western countries but they hide their identity because of fear of apostasy killing from their own family memebers or relatives ... .. you just just check you own ex muslims like harris sultan , adam seeker urdu
@Bandhu241
@Bandhu241 Год назад
Irrespective of whether you agree or disagree with her ideology, Barkha is one of India's most talented journalists. My wish is for her to be less driven by ideology and remain in mainstream media.
@hunk3891
@hunk3891 Год назад
😂
@sabrinakhan8217
@sabrinakhan8217 Год назад
At 11:40, Burkha ji, all those indians living in Australia and exploiting benefits gathered there to see Modi. These people don't buy tickets to see Australian PM. That's why the Australian PM said " you are the boss" cuz snowflake whites love to bend over backward to apease non whites. This is mixing up with 3rd world cultures and identity politics will drown the west soon. They have shot themselves in their butts by inviting that many non white immigrants refusing to assimilate. Sooner, Nonwhites will be in more significant numbers because whites are not reproducing and this is how the downfall of hard-earned western civilization will begin. Quantity over quality.
@ritushukla9284
@ritushukla9284 Год назад
🤣
@KingKong-lb3vh
@KingKong-lb3vh Год назад
Barkha is a secular 'roshan khayali' journalist, not 'driven by ideology' in the way Zaid Hamid or Oriya Maqbool Jan (Ghazwe e baqwas types)
@leenajohn136
@leenajohn136 Год назад
😂
@JSBatra-b4o
@JSBatra-b4o Год назад
Excellent exchange between both the journalists. I for one would love to visit the county of my roots. I cannot curse pak ever as my forefathers were born there.
@talhahassan2649
@talhahassan2649 Год назад
باتیں کرنے میں ہم پاکستانی سب سے آگے ہیں 😂
@mohsinshahzad8262
@mohsinshahzad8262 Год назад
ایک بات ضرور کہو گا اگر پاکستان سٹیبل ہو گیا۔جو یہ دو پڑھے لکھے بکواس کر رہے ہیں۔ تو پاکستان ایک مثال بن جائے گا انڈین سٹیٹس کے لئے پھر انڈیا کا کیا ہو گا۔ کہتے ہیں پاکستان کہاں کھڑا ہے کوئی بھی ہاکستانی دیکھ لے 20 سال پہلے ہم کہاں کھڑے تھے۔ انڈیا بہت بڑا ملک ہے۔انڈیا کے چند لوگوں کی شکلے دیکھا کر ہمیں بیوقوف نہیں بنایا جا سکتا۔ آخری سوال تھا پاکستان کی عورتوں کے متعلق۔ہمارا معاشرہ ان بہت مختلف ہے۔ خاص کر پشتو اور بلوچ کلچر۔ انڈیا اور بنگلہ دیش کی رنڈیاں آپ کو ہر میں ملے گی۔اور پاکستانیوں کو یہ آفر ہے کہ فری آف کاسٹ ملتی ہے۔ ہم کہاں کھڑے ہیں ہمیں اچھی طرح پتا ہے۔ اگر تعلیم کی بات کی جائے تو ابھی ہماری ابتدا ہے 75 سال کسی ملک کی عمر ایسے ہی ہے جیسے نوجوان لڑکا۔امریکہ اور یورپ کی عمر 300 سے 400 سال ہے۔ انڈیا جس جگہ ہے وہی تو اس موت ہے ۔ انڈیا کا کوئی بحری جہاز یا ہوائی اور پاکستان کی پوزیشن۔
@aajjaayyuk
@aajjaayyuk Год назад
I'm not a fan of Barkha but this time she nailed it.
@gngmfi475
@gngmfi475 Год назад
Asim munir 🐕🐕🐶
@srikondapalli
@srikondapalli Год назад
Wow! Bharkha did so good.
@tridentmusic4833
@tridentmusic4833 Год назад
15:30 yhi to baat hai khud ko sbse jyda shi manne wale and maan se anti India wale ab hume Gyan pail rhe hai😂😂😂😂 wah Barkha 😂😂😂
@hiteshparmar8302
@hiteshparmar8302 Год назад
Mr. Vahajhat. Iam IND 🇮🇳. BHARAT. Not. A. Hindustan..... Hindustan ward is invedar...Real ward. BHARAT ❤
@tribhuwanchandrajoshi1078
@tribhuwanchandrajoshi1078 Год назад
Barkha Dutt outsmarted Wazahat Bhai!!! But we have all the love for Wazahat bhai as well!!!
@Iasassiv
@Iasassiv Год назад
Personally, I am no Barkha fan. But, her articulation skills are top notch. One of the best in India.
@ratneshpaliya52
@ratneshpaliya52 Год назад
Yes Modi is a dictator but being a Gujarati he's a great businessman too. He knows how economics play a major role in geopolitical standing of a nation. I think he's similar to China's Xi.
@afnansiddiqui8122
@afnansiddiqui8122 Год назад
Wajaahat bhai awaz slow ati hae ap ki
@SarbatdaBhala1469
@SarbatdaBhala1469 Год назад
Proud of you Barkha. Jai hind 🇮🇳
@hassanazad4627
@hassanazad4627 Год назад
India 's achievements in science and mathematics are superb. In the fine arts , it has artists like shahid parvez , who have made permanent contributions to music.
@pctheophilus
@pctheophilus Год назад
Of all the names, you had to pick a Muslim name ignoring the multitude of others. This is the very narrow attitude that has put Pakistan in trouble. Take a more broader approach and then you will really see that the world is much bigger and more brighter.
@xijinpig8982
@xijinpig8982 Год назад
​@@pctheophilus you're right, I don't even know who that person is😂 As long as Pakistanis believe (yes, they believe, not just think) that they deserve respect and are holier than thou just because they are Muslim, their country will always be in the gutter.
@subhashishbagchi2569
@subhashishbagchi2569 Год назад
Who is shahid parvez??
@kanvaljitsingh6912
@kanvaljitsingh6912 Год назад
Tsk Tsk.... Madam is full of sympathy for them
@gulfamh2448
@gulfamh2448 Год назад
Very fruitful discussion as always , just one suggestion if they openly call our side of Kashmir POK I think there is no reason for you to be hesitant to call other side of Kashmir IOK as it's an internationally recognized disputed territory
@gulfamh2448
@gulfamh2448 Год назад
Still it doesn't change the fact that it's indian illegally occupied Kashmir
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw
@ShyamKumar-zb2mw Год назад
@@gulfamh2448 - we can choose to be neutral about it and called them Indian Administered Kashmir and Pakistan Administered Kashmir - without injuring anyone's sensibilities - if you'd like. In any case it does not make a dammed worth of difference on the ground.
@arslanafzal1265
@arslanafzal1265 Год назад
​@@vaunsag bro you are funny😂😂 tea was fantastic 😂😂
@realistuser
@realistuser Год назад
​@@arslanafzal1265 but now Tea is unaffordable 😂😂😂
@realistuser
@realistuser Год назад
It's a pok it's our land we will take that in future just wait and watch for 25 yrs more
@adsd7349
@adsd7349 Год назад
why it's a race in first place ? we cannot compete with a country of the size of 6 times more than us. let's accept it. Seems like Pak army wants to keep the Kashmir issue alive just to remain relevant in the local politics, after all war is a business.
@saurabhmahajan4459
@saurabhmahajan4459 Год назад
Came here to see Barkha spit some venom but she surprised me! Rahul Gandhi should take some serious advice from Barkha on how to talk on international platforms.
@tridentmusic4833
@tridentmusic4833 Год назад
Iska pyar porkistan maar kha rha hai isliye party badli hai isne 😂😂😂... Agar galti se time change hua to dekhna iska rang
@Arman_Amjad
@Arman_Amjad Год назад
It’s 2023, Good Content, but please 360p Quality? At least 720p please!
@AJ56878
@AJ56878 Год назад
Beggars can't be choosers - Shahbaz Sharif
@SagarAbhishek
@SagarAbhishek Год назад
8:31 Barkha Dutt sach me Bharat me reh kar Pakistan ki hi zuban bolti hai. Le jao usko, Pakistan ki citizenship de do. India me kam se kam ek Saanpoli to kam hogi.
@tamannasalih
@tamannasalih Год назад
Thanks alot WSK I enjoyed this vlog alot 👍. Really sick of Pakistani politics now
@Indu-uw3nz2rt9i
@Indu-uw3nz2rt9i Год назад
The central point among India, Pak & China is CEPEC . China’s pride & money & long term security concerns are involved. All of china’s adversaries will not like CEPEC to succeed therefore they will do everything in their powers to empower India to effectively counter China ., in this process they will also get an opening into our huge Market and benefits.We also believe that after the COVID pandemic most of the countries who were helped by our Vaccine & who have suffered by the Chinese loans , will back India
@ghazmirmansur3091
@ghazmirmansur3091 Год назад
Need massive improvememt on your audio. it takes so much focus to listen to you through your laptop mic or maybe your editor is not good at mixing vocals
@murali2801
@murali2801 Год назад
Love you barkha ❤❤❤
@prateekdeoli1552
@prateekdeoli1552 Год назад
Barkha ka bhi software update ho gaya 🤣
@VikashSharmaVS
@VikashSharmaVS Год назад
tum na beta Major Gaurav Arya ko bulao…. you will get all the answers.
@equityboss5507
@equityboss5507 Год назад
Why is that when you have your pockets & stomach full you curse India as much as you can especially Hindus but when you're hungry and broke you start praising India? Why?
@saleemc
@saleemc Год назад
Excellent presentation. Thank you for educating the masses of Pakistan
@Kaafiristani
@Kaafiristani Год назад
Factoid Proving Panjabi Nonsense about Art 370. Since the time Art 370 was introduced in the constitution of India, Panjabi's rejected it till 05 Aug 2019.
@hohohaha1000
@hohohaha1000 Год назад
According to reports students from Haryana Punjab J&K Uttarakhand and UP will not be recruited by Federation university in Victoria and Western Sydney University in New South Wales. For all the videsh me danka baj raha hai, by muddiji.
@naherf385
@naherf385 Год назад
And our establishment will never learn the lesson! It's absolutely incorrigeable.
@sagarsable3191
@sagarsable3191 4 месяца назад
Answers must cater the questions In that perticular sector.😊
@Bahubali-en8hf
@Bahubali-en8hf Год назад
Barkha's reaction: She is sinking for sure.....
@abbasbaloch1211
@abbasbaloch1211 Год назад
Excellent Analysis 💯
@fahad788
@fahad788 Год назад
Wajahat, you were as honest as you should, but you know what interview were distracted for most of the time, i didnt se a single indian who is non biased, and she was a typical Indian person who looks on the pay roll of indian establishmen just like in Pakistan, i know an indian personality Ashok Swain "@ashoswai" i think you should call him for his honest opinion for Pakistan.. He will tell you the truth .
@rakeshpillai8564
@rakeshpillai8564 Год назад
Fatwa katega tho sabme batega aur halala katega tho mulla mei batega 😂😂😂
@Nitesh_Toppo_94
@Nitesh_Toppo_94 Год назад
18:30 hat's off 😊
@iiMuse
@iiMuse Год назад
That MF east india company, where ever they’d been they left a dispute for later on to benefit from
@sandeepvk
@sandeepvk Год назад
*Let's use the nomenclature "East J&K" and "west J&K"*
@gauravgeek
@gauravgeek Год назад
Hi Wajahat, I am from India, and a fan of your style of journalism. You deserve to share your platform with better personalities than someone like Barkha Dutt. She is a paid crony who can write positive or negative articles for anyone for the right price. Wajahat, integrity should be paramount for a journalist. Wishing you luck and discernment. Keep up the good work!!
@exo-gamerz2662
@exo-gamerz2662 Год назад
I don't agree with u, Gaurav. Barkha speaks out her conscience, without price. She is well trained with her journalistic ploys, having ready wit. On another note, she belongs to a Bengali family but her Urdu/Hindi accent is commendable. I am a Pakistani but I love ❤ her. I have gone through her write up n interviews on 1971 war. She is not biased though. আমার মন ভরা ভালোবাসা রইলো বারখার জন্য। ❤❤❤
@IITTPPEEDD
@IITTPPEEDD Год назад
Pakistanis love her, because she loves Pakistan equally:) she is by and large dislikes in India.
@dharamewada6922
@dharamewada6922 Год назад
Wajahat Dear, why are you comparing the two countries. We are different in many ways but yes, like many other neighbouring countries there are some similarities but our entire lifestyle , education ,culture , outlook is different . Thankfully and fortunately.
@AstonishSingh
@AstonishSingh Год назад
Barkha Dutt was a renowned Journalist..Once upon a time sir. Now she is a left mouthpiece and a modi hater. NOTHING MORE!
@abdullahali6461
@abdullahali6461 Год назад
As a Pakistani, i will just say, SUNTA JA, SHARMATA JA, no match with India
@MuhammadSaeed-zm8lq
@MuhammadSaeed-zm8lq Год назад
Good discussion and analysis on the importance issues
@sachinpuri76
@sachinpuri76 Год назад
Comparisons between India & Paxtan are done only in Paxtan For India, Paxtan doesn't matter at all
@harism5589
@harism5589 Год назад
Wajahat is longtime journalist who is quite unbiased based upon his years of his work. I have seen his India visit programs in the past. Of all the things why he select Barkha from India to talk? She is open and close case of JNU Communists trained (brain washed) journalists. She has lost credibility, fading away in current Indian viewers. People have used her to sale their agenda to hold on to power. Today they have lost power, long with them Barkha also lost her place and is outdated in India. Wajahat sir could have chosen someone better.
Далее
Modi in America | Hard Lessons for Pakistan
59:39
Просмотров 119 тыс.
Avaz Oxun - Yangisidan bor
14:29
Просмотров 446 тыс.
Pakistan's Donut Wars + Shehbaz's Birthday at UN
31:15
Clash of the Titans in Pakistan
23:49
Просмотров 168 тыс.
Is Pakistan Giving Gwadar to China?
26:16
Просмотров 65 тыс.