I love the Metaspeed Sky+ but longer efforts beat my legs up. Forefoot runners dream, these look promising! ASICS has been killing it, Superblast 2 looks good too!!
Looks like other reviewers keep saying Edge is better than Sky this time. Just hope you can do comparison of this vs Edge Paris to see what’s your opinion.
I relegated my Metaspeed Sky+ to half marathon and below simply because of that more firmer ride (compared to other brands). I am super interested in this model now
I really appreciate the way you clarify what you mean by "soft." It seems to mean different things to different people. I'm looking forward to hearing how you explain the differences between the new Sky and Edge.
I've loved running in my Sky+ and was the first race shoe by Asics.. I've run over 600km so far and the shoe is still amazing and everything is still in good shape.. These look like they'll follow the same path thankfully. I did find the Sky+ a bit hard for the first 250km. Then it just became magical...
Just what I needed in a review! I just can't with Asics having these 2 shoes and trying to decide which would be better for my use without trying them for a while. Can't afford to just buy both. I really didn't like the sky+ at all. Also sent the Endorphin Elite back. Big no's for me. 15 miles in both and shoes I never wanted to run in again, especially a marathon. I'll just skip these both since I can't figure which to buy. Sorry Asics...
I personally liked Edge Paris more after having an opportunity to jog briefly in both. The plate on this one is flat and the rocker is very late. Edge Paris had much more directional bounce thanks to more scooped plate and a better rocker feeling. I think Edge Paris is the real deal this time around.
Much as I can see why one might not compare against the Puma DNE2, I want it. The DNE2 fits me so well, but my daily trainer of choice is Novablast/Superblast. Puma and ASICS are doing it for me. Side note - if Adidas could get their heel situation figured out, I dare say I like their foam the best.
Always though the sky would be my preferred shoe of the stable but after seeing Thomas’ review at BITR this morning, I’m wondering whether the edge is maybe for me. I have tended to agree with your preferences (novablast, saucing etc) so will hang tight for your edge review
I've only had the chance to try the Sky+. It felt like I was landing flat footed, no matter how much I tried to change my foot strike. The Edge my fit me better with the rocker.
Would you say the Metaspeed Sky (and Edge?) is a good alternative to the Adios Pro 3 in general? I love the running dynamics and feel of that shoe but the upper just does not work for me over longer distances 😢. Great review as always, thanks Kofuzi!
thank you for the review, i am looking forward to hear your thoughts about the metaspeed edge paris that it seems this year is even better than the sky?
I just order the Sky Paris for my Boston Marathon next month. I went Edge+ last go around and and I do find it to be a fast shoe, Just not set up for Marathon Distance.
I am totally a front foot runner and do not use my heels. Which version do you recommend? Mind you I am a very slow runner but with a high cadence and small steps. I found the Saucony Endorphin speed 3 to firm under the front foot when I wore them. Is this softer? I do mostly 10 K. Also are you a forefoot striker, midfoot striker or heel striker? Because that makes a big difference I think.
Oooh, interesting! Still never tried a Metaspeed, might have a look for a deal on a Sky+ as generally not a fan of 'softer' foams though. Was there any mention of the plate in this review? If there was i must have missed it. Obviously we all know it's there, but might be useful info for someone thinking about their first marathon shoe.
I like a narrow arch, but I don’t consider it any less stable than the prior version. Also, I recently interviewed ASICS pro Lisa Weightman who overpronates heavily on her right foot. She believes it’s more supporting in the arch than the prior version
How’s the relative bounciness compare to the Endorphin Elite? That’s still my favorite in terms of bounce. I liked the Metaspeed Sky+ alright, but it wasn’t bouncy enough for me to want to race a marathon in it
Kofuzi, do you have any recommendations for 5k shoes I can race cross country in? I usually wear Vaporfly 3's but I'm wondering if there are faster shoes that have come out or are going to come out this year before September (Takumi Sen 10 or Eliot Racer for example)
What shoe would you recommended for someone who already has a high cadence of around 180-210, would the sky be better to help improve my stride length as my cadence is already high? Hope you understand my question ok.
Typical Asics, always making us want to try both styles of shoes. I'm solely a forefoot striker and I picked up the Metaspeed Sky + after watching your videos. I needed the extra foam under my forefoot. Being a forefoot striker, would you recommend the Sky Paris or Edge Paris? Speed is important, but comfort is King.
I'm 210-215ish and I'd suggest the Boston 12 if you want a higher stack treadmill shoe. If you want something softer for slower/relaxed paces (if you're a lifter and running is solely for some cardio work) try the Nike Invincibles.
Hi comments and kofuzi. Can you recommend me a good running shoe that can be used for road-running, going to the gym, and casual wear? I'm about to go travel, so I don't really need something performance heavy.
What’s the target weight for the shoe? I’ve asked various people brands and zero response. As runners as example 65kg vs 80kg would see a vast difference with the midsole
weight force through the midsole will offer different results. as an example, 60kg female runner SuperBlast is firm and shes happy with no need to run without carbon plate as Superblast to me in kit 81kg is soft. weight changes alot and ive asked a few brands whats the weight target they work with for a shoe? @@kofuzi
Thanks for this reply - I agree re:relevance, I guess I am wondering what would *pair* best for a SB rotation as I'm sure many SB users are deciding between the Edge and Sky for this iteration... But that is a way more complex question for sure!
@@kofuzi Well, I'd say blue, which is identified with Saint Martin, and red, which is identified with Saint Denis, should be the two colors that stand out when we talk about Paris. These colors could be seen more or less incorporated in all of France’s official symbols.
I'm an Edge+ person, but am still watching this Sky+ review. Edge+ is my fastest shoe, even beating the Vaporfly. But I find it hard and uncomfy so I rarely wear it. The changes sound like exactly what I would want. Am now looking forward to your Edge+ Paris review.
@@jmbaug1229I agree. Nike is just hype. And they have gotten lazy with their overall shoe line. Coasting on their brand equity imho. And I gave up on Nike with their frankly 💩 build quality.
I really would like to know the difference between the Edge and the Sky so I can make sure I’ll be getting the right shoe for my upcoming race. Looking forward to the review of the Edge.
But i read the edge is better than the sky Paris !!! Heard the edge is more comfy and aggressive than the sky… aren’t the elite runners wearing the edge more than the Sky ?
Tried it yesterday at Tokyo Marathon Expo on treadmill at Asics booth: both Edge and Sky felt wonderful to run, definitely an option for me, nice shoes & nice review!! 😊
Yes. ASICS went out of their way in the first two iterations to call it specifically a nylon foam rather than a Peba foam, which they could have easily done. They’ve also gone out of their way this year to specify that it’s not Pebax. Bottom line, the foam is quite different. It’s more like what people think of when people think of peba.
🤔Looks kinda narrow in the mid-foot and rear-foot compared to shoes like SC Elite 4 and Endorphin Pro 4. Do you think it’s stable enough for us four hour marathoners whose mechanics get sloppy in the late going?
Looks awesome!!! 😍 I have loved Metaspeed Sky+! It does feel a bit more aggressive than other race shoes, but I really didn’t mind, especially towards the end of 26.2 (got me through Grandma’s to a PR attempt 😊) I’m very curious whether I would like Sky or Edge Paris 👀
Excellent video, as always, Mr. Kofuzi. I have a question, though. When you compare shoes and distances, you usually mention 5k, 10k and Marathon. The shoes for Half-Marathons are closer to 10k kind of shoe, or Marathon kind of shoe? Thank you for your fantastic work! Have a great one, every body!
Totally get what you're saying about the Sky+ not feeling soft. Even though I can squish it in my hands, that squish didn't translate with running. It felt much firmer than I thought it should.
