Nice reaction! Other can Empty Box, I love Siren, Work, Blind then Shaboom. Shaboom was too much for me I think. I knew it was going to be a different sound since they traveled back to dimension A. If they continue to do more hip hop on the Golden Hour series, I hope they put a little bit more punch to it. It will be a fun journey to see where they go next.
First of all, not trying to stir any drama or spread negativity because I just love Ateez. I just genuinely want to know atinys' thoughts on the line distribution of blind. I know that there's always gonna be a member who gets the least lines in a song and that's a fact. Also, the line distribution may vary according to how well the tone of a member goes with the genre. I get that. If all the members have 20-25 seconds and one member gets like 12-15 seconds then that's still understandable. But if all the members have about 15-20 seconds of lines and only one member gets LESS THAN 3 SECONDS then that line distribution is kinda concerning to me given that the member in question is the one who has the most number of songs in which he is the last place in line distribution. You all must know by now who I am talking about. It's Yeosang. Also, I wouldn't have been so pressed about it if his voice didn't go well with the song but his voice just suits this song so much. They literally made their other vocalist sing in their deeper tone instead of just making the member who naturally has the deepest tone in the group to sing those parts. I really wanna know if other atinys even noticed this and if they did what are their thoughts on this? The fact that this could've been their title track really scares me. All I want is for atinys to share their thoughts. Whatever it is, whether you agree or not? Am I wrong or am I missing something here? You could literally just say that you don't care about line distribution and that would be fine too. But atleast share your thoughts. Why is it so hard for atinys to comment on this matter? Also, I am commenting this under a lot of reaction videos because I just want to hear from a lot of atinys.
@@purpleantidote6120 I completely agree with you. His part in siren is really good. What I am saying that whatever his parts are in other songs, having less than 3 seconds in a 3 minutes 20 seconds is just really weird especially because it's not like his voice doesn't suit the genre that is why he got only this much. That's not true and even if his voice didn't suit the song that line distribution is still really unfair. But the fact is that his voice actually suits the song really well. That song has a lot of low parts and he has a naturally deep voice so he would've suited those parts really well but he still didn't get those parts. Which is weird. Don't you think? The producers made other vocalists to deepen their voices and change their tone instead of using the member who naturally has that lower tone to sing those lines. Like the producers could have easily made the line distribution a little more balanced. But they didn't. Especially knowing the fact that he is the member with the least amount of lines in this album as well as their entire discography. I hope you understand where I am coming from?
Line distribution has always been a talk in the Kpop industry, im not really a full atiny but more of a casual listener so idk is there is a like a actual explanation to why Yeosang usually gets little lines but It all would really depend on how their production team works behind the scenes cuz in some cases it’s the actual members who get to decide what they want to sing and how much rather than them being given the lines, which ex kpop idols have said they were ok with because well, (long story short) it made their job easier and less complex besides that sometimes lines are just given to the member who sounded best after production but I doubt that’s the case since like u said Yeosang could fit some of the lines but who really knows maybe Yeosang isn’t confident (which I hope not) and I really hope the reason isn’t cuz company mistreatment but like I said I’m not really a atiny soo idk if somewhere among their journey they have explained a reason but I hope maybe I have given more info that could start more conversations
@@garyxp5252 I agree with you to some extent. There are a lot of groups that have line distribution issue but since you are not familiar with Ateez's issue, I'll explain it to you. First, for Ateez, their production team (Edenary) is responsible for line distribution and not the members. If you go through Ateez's discography, you will notice that there are two specific members (Yeosang and Wooyoung) who consistently getting the least lines in most of their songs. But this is the case with every group because when groups debut, during the first few years the producers are still trying to understand what are the strengths of each members voices and what suits them the most. Also, some of them are young so their voices are still changing so line distribution being weird during the first few comebacks is understandable but with Yeosang this has been going on for six years. When I first got into Ateez, some atinys told me that Yeosang wasn't confident enough and himself didn't want lines. Some even said that he isn't good enough. And I actually believed them until I heard his solo cover(Hug me). He sounded so beautiful that I started questioning whatever I was told so I started digging up more about it(since he is my bias but I would've done this for every member). What I found out just broke my heart. Firstly, Yeosang has NEVER said that he is not confident or he doesn't want lines. On the contrary, he has openly said that he WANTS more lines in their songs since 2019. And I have proof as to where he said this. I don't why atinys would do this but some atinys just used his shy nature to make up a lie that he wasn't confident to cover this all up. Knowing that he had to ask for lines openly means he must have tried asking for lines privately too. Not only Yeosang, Wooyoung gas also said quite a few times that he wants more lines. A lot groups have line distribution issues but not all groups have had the mistreated member openly ask for more lines for years and not all groups have had their fans make up lies so that they can cover the mistreatment of the members they supposedly stan. If you ever find someone claiming that he himself didn't want lines, ask them for the source. If want the source as to where he said he wants more lines, I can provide you the proof. In some of their songs, Yeosang almost has no lines. I actually have a lot more to talk about this issue and I can provide you more proofs of his mistreatment but I don't want to overwhelm you with a lot of information. If you want me to talk about this is detail, I would be more than happy to do that. I actually wrote the comment with the purpose of either understanding the point of view of people who know about this issue at the same time I can talk people who are not aware of it and stop the misinformation about him not being confident from spreading any further and actually help the newer atinys know tthe truth because this how I found out the truth. Thank you for replying and reading such a long reply.
@@TS-wr4sq Interesting, thank you for filling me in with more details. In that case it is very weird for them to not receive any more lines upon requesting especially since they are so deep in their career that there really couldn’t be many excuses on why their system hasn’t changed. I mean I can think of other reasons but with what you have said I don’t really think they apply as much for a reason. At this point I think their production team has probably just gotten used to other members filling in the roles which would suck for them but who knows hopefully with more time they realize their talent, I mean for example jong ho at least from the songs I hear is usually just used for high notes but recently I have felt as if he is being given more lines to like sing if that makes sense. But anyways I really do hope they get more lines to sing because getting 10 seconds or less is crazy unless they get more attention for their dancing.