@@sawanarora2627 so what..to make few pandits you want to enslave millions of kashmiri muslims. No one cane from outside pandits and muslims..all are native😊
@@RakeshSharma-tz1wi yes, our country is in mess but, it is as a whole in mess, not just Kashmir. That doesn’t mean we’ll leave it in hard times. Humne Pakistan ka khaya hai india ka nae.
Actual game is to force the pakistan armed forces to be remain as close to loc as possible so that the baloch freedom fighters could do their job in the western front fearlessly . According to the famous quotation of Nsa Ajit Doval "if another 26/11 happened , Balochistan would be free .
He is neither thorough nor accurate, the Germans did not go through the Maginot Line, they went around it. Todays war is about air superiority, bunkers and fortifications can be destroyed. This is nothing more than a Communist analyst trying very hard to give China some face saving.
@@amalchakrabarti2357 This statement was given when India had ghost consulates (training camps) in Afghanistan and Kulbushon Yadav was running his network at Iran / Pakistan border. We have destroyed both of them.
Indian military has attacked India more often than face the battles against foreign militaries. Indian military that attacked Sikhism in June 1984 but gets smashed by China frequently.
@@clintwestwood5187 Khalistan was is better than current Hindu ghetto rashtar in India. Khalistan shall ensure security equality justice to all without bias of caste religion. So stfu and apologize to Punjab for 1984 thug military attack by chutiya India
bevakoof khalistani .... first, will sikh dharm survive in the next 50 years ?? In ur quest to be like Abrahmics , all sikh are converting to christanity.
He did an excellent, very honest analysis of the political and military situation in Pakistan. He said all the good things about Imran Khan. Thank you sir for an excellent job.
let me provide you one more piece of information, the current defense minister of China Gen Li, who has been the commander of PLA strategic supporting troop. which has a whole brigade stationed in Pakistan, remember the 2019 Balakot strike, IAF total failure? got the connection? any idea what strategic supporting troop means? and what it is for?
@@mr.n0ne India is very powerful...in a one on one fight...Pakistan will be beaten twice😂😂 Isme puchhne wali kya baat he?? And India is exactly planning that...how to take over PoK within 15-20 days without giving China a chance. Israel n America will be helping secretly if that happens
Col. Pravin Swahney was an Indian Military officer and a greatest military analyst - he is impartial and unbiased on his subject and there is no one who could deny his claims and reported analyses except barking foul. Col. Swahney was warming Indian military establishment time and again not to mess with Pakistani military troops on the western border on LOC since they are heavily armed and entrenched and dug deep to sway any or all attacks from Indian military who have no battle field experience except ATO - Anti Terror Operations which is low scale local operations while fighting a battle hardened Pakistani Military is a daunting challenge which India could never was successful - do listen to this greatest Military Analyst in Indian history
The second Maginot Line equivalent that comes to mind -- was the Bar Lev Line which was obliterated by Egyptians while crossing the Suez Canal during their Sinai offensive of 1973, the Yom Kippur War. A superb vlog, Sir, after a long wait!
That's why you should understand that the loc is not permanent . Pakistan would reject the Simla accord the day by themselves when they would be able to achieve military superiority by alignment with china because the treaty is severely compromising their national objective to internationalise the Kashmir issue with its strict clause to solve all the mutual problems through the bilateral talks .From the abrogation of the article 370 to the , surgical strike, Diplomatic isolation of the pakistan in the international arena , reduction of the water flow to the pakistan according to the clauses of the indus water treaty is all part of the same game . A pakistan in chineese lap is in the best of our interests than a pakistan in American lap. China needs an agrssive pakistan against India badly to balance it's weeknes in its primary front which is Taiwan . Usa have already one carrier group in guam and one in Japan . One additional carrier group with a balistic missile submarine should be permanently stationed in the South Korea according to the new treaty signed between the usa and the South Korea .That's everything is too close to the economically important most populated region of the china . They can't afford to send it's all aircrafts and ground troops to india border to help pakistan by leaving it's most important population centers at the mercy of the usa
And then what.. Egyptians lost whole sinai peninsula, Syrian lost whole golan heights and Jordanian lost whole Jerusalem 🤗🤗🤗 Arabs got so humiliated by this defeat that they put oil embargo triggering 1973 oil crises. Then in Camp David accord 1978-79, Egypt gave in written that they will never attack Israel again and in return Israel returned Sinai peninsula to Egypt as good gesture. 😅
@@amalchakrabarti2357taiwan recetly reported to have observed russian warships in taiwanese strait. So im not sure whether you are dumb or unaware of the south china sea. And japan and south korea will already be dealt with diplomatically to ensure their absense to the conflict. Which is why the americans are urging to talk with china about reseting its relations to cool down the situation. So ultimately pakistan closeness to china is major threat to india.
Amid all insanity going on in India under Modi regime, it is good to see sane, logical, mature, and professional thinker in the country. Unfortunately, in Pakistan I have not seen any defense analyst of his caliber yet.
He is lying. In 1965 Indian Army crossed the international border and reached till Lahore. Indian Army captured Haji Pir pass too. Overall Indian Army captured 2800 sqkm. Most of his story is based on assumptions
Nonsense & Terrible analysis! USA controls PAK nukes. USA owns PAKSITAN. USA needs India to fight China PAKSITAN is financial ruined. PAKSITAN Does not have spare parts and $ to maintain military. China will not waste money and arms on PAKSITAN when they need to face USA in a naval war and repair economy PAK has Taliban & Baloch insurgency and protest by POK. They'll give up POK to keep Balochistan otherwise they'll be land Locked.
Pakistan is the largest junk yard of the Chinese junks . On the other hand india is grabbing more share from world's defence export market during every passing day .
You have to compare against China ,not Pakistan since China is fully behind Pak, as mr. Sawhney mentioned…India lacks cyber warfare capability, space surveillance, etc. in fact China wants to keep india focused on ladhak, etc to keep it from developing technological capabilities..it’s obviously serious gap-in security…
@@humblesanalysis9790 That's why you guys are trying to achieve everything with just one tactical nuclear weapon called Nasir . Barely 70 km range . India is not just purchasing 150 km class 155 mm glided artillery shell from usa but IIT Madras is also developing its own ramjet powered long range shell. Even without breaching the nuclear threshold india would be able to take care of the pakistani nukes . Against normal artillery fire tactical nuclear weapons can't be justified . Unfortunately ceasefire violation by the Pakistanis in the line of control is a very common practice . Electro magnetic rail gun project of Drdo is quiet secretive that's why it's details are not available in the public domain but according to the assumption by the defence experts the range should be between somewhere 150_400 km
let me ask a simple question, if war happened, now Pakistan bought 24 J10C from China, if war start, how do you know who is the pilot? Pakistani or Chinese? remember it is in POK, even if J10C shot down it will be in POK India has no way to know who is in the jet.
@@jioboy2676 and facts are wrong and truth is bitter for Pakistanis no diesel for tank black smoke from jf 17 engine most of the jf 17 exported to myanmar is actually grounded not a single air defence system to track bhramhos like missile this is the truth hard to digest for Pakistanis but truth is truth
@@ankitdeep3302 Indian forces can't even stop Quadcopter drone from entering the Indian control area. What do you think, Inside Pakistani control area, how will they compete with Akici like beast with Long range standoff weapons? And Formidable force of drones in quick engagement?
Thanks from Pakistan, sir for a realistic and info-based analysis favoring India and Pakistan, both to avoid a foolish duel. Soon after Rahul Gandhi's All-India Yatra we witnessed media debate in India, suggesting that Modi will need to do "Something Big" to win elections in 2024.and that something big could be most probably a bloody gamble over PoK. We know that greedy, vote-hungry politicians make decision contrary to the national interests yet bringing short-term political gains for them and politicians world-over do it blatantly and selfishly. I wish Indian military establishment has guts to understand the military scenario and has balls to say 'No' to a firebrand, populist politician like Modi.
He said India will be totally isolated in the region when taliban took over Afghan . Same taliban hammering Pak daily😅. Use brains please and ignore him and put his video in trash
Indian political establishment is much more mature than most people ( Pakistan and west) and psychologically more peace minded than the news papers would like. But not cowardly, as this gentleman is implying. Otherwise, despite Pakistan's severe attack in 1965 using infiltrators India would not have gone deep in POK to seal the haji peer pass.
Many Indians might feel this very critical analysis of Mr Pravin Sawhney offensive after watching and listening to war mongers like Major Gaurav Arya. Reality seems bitter but one must depend on reality as compared to wishful thinking. Amazing analysis, most of the analysts knowingly sweep the facts under the carpet and depict India as the United States for the sake of grabbing some views but salute to this gentleman for an avid analysis.
He is lying. In 1965 Indian Army crossed the international border and reached till Lahore. Indian Army captured Haji Pir pass too. Overall Indian Army captured 2800 sqkm. Most of his story is based on assumptions
@@nirmalbhel3231 if we take indian claims and Pak claims then according to india you gained 1700+sqkm And as per Pak we gained 2500+km Don't take only one sided narrative
@@zulfizakarya5703 U can find neutral stance with American, British and australian general quotation on wikipedia. In reality PAF on western Front fled to Iran in 1971 war and refuged to take sorties.. That's why in coming decades Pakistan kept searching strategic depth in Afghanistan 🤗🤗
We are sick and tired of status quo. Cease fire line was supposed to be a temporary arrangement but, India and Pakistan converted it into a Line of Control which is almost like an international border. All Kashmiris on both side of this illegal line want this line to disappear.. A war between the occupying armies is our best chance to liberate our motherland from all occupation forces. A war is needed to bring Kashmir in world focus back again. This is our only chance to resolve this bitter dispute according to the wishes of our people. In short, Kashmiris are in favour of a full scale war.
🤣🤣🤣 khaane ko nhi daane ammi chali bhunane. U r jumping here and ur generals have surrendered kashmir in UAE under back channel talks. That's why no reaction after removal of article 370 and 35A 🤗🤗🤗
@@kaiwalya3710 We are suffering since the the Karachi Agreement formally called the Agreement Between Military Representatives of India and Pakistan Regarding the Establishment of a Cease-Fire Line in the State of Jammu and Kashmir, was signed on 27 July 1949, supervised by the Truce Subcommittee of the UNCIP. That was a dark day for the people of the state of Jammu and Kashmir.
One of the finest analysts based on analysis. Sir pravin i want to ask a question, "is india ready to fight a two front war?" Does India really think that delhi is ready.
Both countries should just focus on what they have now instead of fighting endlessly. We are with Pakistan no matter what the situation is. Indian Kashmir has developed so much. Happy for them.
Javaid bhai...Assalamualaikum🙂 Kya halchal...sab khairiyat?? An Indian Muslim here...I hv one question...you know full Control of Kashmir by Pakistan and full control of Ladakh is very important for future of China. But I doubt China will support Pakistan in case of a Nuclear War...I mean why they will take such risk?? What do u think? And u know that Indian govt and agencies want to do Nuclear Attack on Pakistan.
Brother Jio Boy, I doubt India would want to resort to use of nuclear weapons. Simply because Pakistan has them too. And how can you say China will not come to )akistan's aid I case of war with India? I do not think Pakistan will be left in the cold. That will not happen and India knows that. So, all is well.
@@jioboy2676 india is least bothered about a country that is crumbling automatically, let alone using nuclear power. India as a whole is busy about building more roads, superfast trains, integrated electronics chipsets, improving business environments, securing higher marks, excel in world class institutions, earning more money etc. rather that wasting time on pakistan
Mohawk Bhatachataya, you have a good point there. Pakistan is indeed in trouble and fighting for its survival. But, please note, China has said that without Pakistan China will never know peace. That being the case, China will do its utmost to ensure Pakistan survives. Yes, India is making most impressive progress.
@@javaidzaidi x country will ensure pakistan survives, y country will help pakistan with money 😄😄😄 how long this dependency will continue? Mr Bhedbhaib Qaidi, when as a country Pakistan will be adult?
There is one thing which indian public doesnt want to understand that azad kashmir is a very difficult place to occupy because of its geography also desite all the corruption and negligence in the pak army its still a very powerful army and india never won a war against pakistan on its western border (kargil war was fought inside indian occupied kashmir/ladakh) Secondly and more importantly its the people of kashmir who wont let india occupy their land because i know the hate and anger they have for indian army for what they have been doing in IOK, indian already have to keep 7 hunderd thousand solidiars on ground to keep a small occupied valley in control they dont have engough military and recourses to face the people of azad kashmir and gilgit baltistan
As usual a deeply insightful, balanced & enlightening “what if” scenario in a potentially high voltage flashpoint theatre underscoring the imperatives of restraint & avoidance. Thank you again for another eye-opener Mr Sawhney🙏👍👌
How this analysis is enlightening to you . If china is installing pakistani officers in the Chinese army that's to just absorb the nato standard training and warfare doctrines from the nato trained pakistani officers . But at this rate pakistan is going too close to a direct military confrontation with the nato led by usa as the more than enough proximity with the nato pushed the ukrainians with a war with russia . May be you are observing that in spite of so much diplomatic efforts from the pakistan the washing based international monetary fund is not giving money to pakistan . At least not as easily as in the past .
@@jioboy2676 PAKSITAN can't feed it's people while half the country led by Imran Khan opposes Army & is supposed to win a conventional war against India? Complete nonsense . This guy is an idiot
the fact that his fans are from a particular community and country, reveals how much hate and contempt praveen sawhney has for the indian armed forces and why he is a poster boy for all those who are enemies of India.
INDIA 🇮🇳 under RSS -BJP MODI “leadership” shouldn’t be AFRAID 😳 of PAKISTAN 🇵🇰 A DO ✅ or DIE 💀 “SURGICAL” STRATEGY is needed on BOTH Sides 👍to END the stinking STATUS QUO ‼️
As a inhabitant of GB , I have seen a huge number of chinese soldiers and military column in GB. They have made a huge number of tunnel, bunker and military underground city ,hidden turmack for AirForce . I wonder most of the general of India is talking to occupy GB. My estimate minimum 1 million indian army needed courrage and plan invasion in GB.😂
Nonsense & Terrible analysis! USA controls PAK nukes. USA owns PAKSITAN. USA needs India to fight China PAKSITAN is financial ruined. PAKSITAN Does not have spare parts and $ to maintain military. China will not waste money and arms on PAKSITAN when they need to face USA in a naval war and repair economy PAK has Taliban & Baloch insurgency and protest by POK. They'll give up POK to keep Balochistan otherwise they'll be land Locked.
Nobody is interested in bucketistan lol🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️ We r not giving millions of jehadists Or citizenship.. It's jst Pakistan and it's insecurities 🤭🤭 Pakistan is all time low begging door to door.. Have u seen any ceasefire violation on LOC by IA?? No.. We r happy with current demographic balance 🤗🤗
Mr praveen spreading lies...said indian army never crossed border into Pakistan.....,then Mr praveen tells us....what happens in Tashkent.......which territory Pakistan demanded to be vacated by Indian army......what about haji pir nad Lahore territory occupied by Indian army
You sir are one very well informed person. Rational and realistic in your analysis. More inclined towards not having war in our region as it would mean disastrous for both india and Pakistan.
But dont u think...since Mr. Praveen has said the Facts...Indian Military will be alerted and will improve their ability and Israel is secretly helping India...they would love to see Pakistan destroyed by N bomb...so is Pakistan prepared to fight the new India??
Such an adventure will end up in historic disaster for entire region covering India, Pakistan n China. We shall end up as a grassless landscape for decades, centuries.
Indians indeed have the best brains. I can only wish the Pakistan military can focus on their actual role rather than destroying democratic leadership. Their involvement has damaged the socio-economic capacity to deal with disasters, let alone conflict. I would request you do an analysis of how the Pakistani military will be the cause of destruction & failure of the state itself.
True...Pakistani Military and govt should make sure...Pakistan's Economic condition Improves...so that if any war happens in future...it can fight that war properly
As a kashmiri maii yehii kahooga we are not going to join pakistan but after 370 nafratein badny lgii hain..oll agr 370 hatana tha tou phly 370 haty usskay baad statehood cheen lety jb sy hum union territory ban gayeh hain...log both depression maii haii oll hamari state govt hamein central government sy ziyaada jobs deti thii but aaj unemployment har taraf yeh cheez dushmanoo ko fayeda dyy gii Log apny mulk k waFadaar tab tk rehty hain jb tak unhein apni apny institutions apni govt khush rakhtii hai Agr gAliyaan maarnii hai tou shock sy Maroo but sach yehii haii
greetings from Pakistan Mr Pravin you're the most realistic analyst I've seen in India & I'm not over exaggerating this statement since I believe you're lone voice in the country whose government & not necessarily it's people are full of hatred & envy towards not only Muslims but fellow low casts Hindus as well .. & that's the real tragedy that you're facing in this time & age..
He is lying to please Pak audience. In 1965 Indian Army crossed the international border and reached till Lahore. Indian Army captured Haji Pir pass too. Overall Indian Army captured 2800 sqkm. Most of his story is based on assumptions
@@jd6738even if your statement is correct.. the curse of radicalization is not on government level in Pakistan unlike in India where political parties come into power on the basis of how much you hate your neighboring country.. how pathetic & miserable situation in your country..
@@vvaqas_ no atta in your country and your country minister says always things like we have nuclear weapons and tag smart people as raw agent pravin is smart making money after his pension
He is lying to please Pak audience. In 1965 Indian Army crossed the international border and reached till Lahore. Indian Army captured Haji Pir pass too. Overall Indian Army captured 2800 sqkm. Most of his story is based on assumptions
Before making comments, I tried to know something about Mr Pravin Sawhney, who happened to be an ex-military man. I couldn't confir whether he was prematurely retired of sought premature retirement. So comming to the point, I do agree to the extent that one should not under estimate one's adversary(ies) or overestimate ones power and abilities. Extrapolating this phenomenon, I must say that does Mr Sawhney believes that his knowledge and wisdom is more and better than the collective knowledge and wisdom of the three Army chiefs, heads of Indian intelligence services with loads of information and inputs and the political and other executive collegium of the nation. I can't stop myself from saying that his opinion, comments and reports are more or less negetive towards Indian state and I don't know the reason for such negative sentiments.
excellent analysis..above all india and pak share a common future and a common enemy of poverty lack of education infrastructure energy medicaone health..❤❤etc etc
India is committed to spend 5 trillion dollars till 2030 for infrastructure development . How much are you spending for the infrastructure of the pakistan?
Just imagine an undetectable Rafael goes deep and fires laser guided missiles on all the bridges connecting occupied Jammu, G and Baltistan with Punjab, KPK and Chitral and turns them into rubble. It destroys all the aircraft parked in Skardu and Hunza. After this, for how much time your army will be able to survive.
Pakistani’s lack common sense due to lack of proper education and thus talk without looking at the facts and without realizing their current situation. They look upon India as a threat when they must know that it is matter of few days for Indian Armed forces to capture and occupy Pakistan. But who wants to attach dirt to themselves is one of prime reason Pakistan exists
Politicisation of army is what, unfortunately we're witnessing from last 9-10 yrs, which is very dangerous. US'S generals have been making many political statements and even lying for geo politics, but India is not US.
Advanced Nations are looking for opportunities in other countries to test their newly formulated weapons, A war somewhere far from their shores is the best scenario to get this done.
I agree with most of the things about the shortfalls in the indian army but the current pakistani establishment which the army is the center of are busy in buying pizza shops, properties, housing associations grabbing land from Pakistanis. Pak army making music, dramas honey trapping politicians, judges, mullahs. They are more busy in bringing governments down then preparing for the war. I would think the leadership on top is so weak that not most soldiers would not fight for
mr praveen ...no one can afford a war now a days. recent example usa in afghanistan.. neto and ukrain vs russia...there are lessons for pak and india ❤❤. we both living far behind the world only because of this rivalry..
After the Feb 2019 debacle ala Abhinandan, talking smack is mere hollow rhetoric intended for the ballot box. But how many times is such humiliation acceptable to India?
looks like many pakistanis are happy drinking this pravin guys sharbat lol 4 wars and humiliation is not enough seems like … what difference would one more make? only this time indian forces should not stop at pok but liberate baloch and sindh territory
IAF bombed Balakot. Abhinandan was flying 3rd gen Mig21 but you should appreciate his dare ness to take on superiors F16. All Migs forced F16 not to cross LOC. JF17 which was much behind had to release the bombs much far away from LOC and had to go back when Mirage-2000 arrived. Just imaging PAF had deployed over 40 jets and India stopped them by using only 4 Mirage-2000, 8 Mig-21 and 2 SU30
*The only way for the Indian Army to know if they can capture Kashmir is to attack Pakistani Kashmir instead of making empty threats. They should do this immediately and try to capture the Kashmir.*
Anil - stop watching stupid Indian movies that is giving Indians false hope of being powerful nation - if India could take back Pakistani Sovereign land of Kashmir- they would but they can’t. Learn from Pakistani Airforce Operation Swift Retort where Indian pilots were completely blinded by Pakistan ground and air Controls to know where they are going - don’t mess with the enemy that you can’t see.
very nice analysis sir.,..greetings from india mumbai///a very realistic and to the point unlike majority of godi media generals and ware mongerers who one sided portray everything as if its some bollywood film.....sir i hope you also added the answer to indian cold doctrine,,,,the pakistani small tactical nuclear war heads....which weight hardly 10 kg and can be fired from any mobile system and can hit the entire batallion of invading army wiping it completely
I am extremely wish India will go to militarily grab POK, we are anxiously waiting the chance, we will make sure India get trapped into this action, then start the east sector in South Tibet. good thing is for majority of Indians, they would not listen to your analysis, it is the nature of this nation, they cannot judge things by facts and reality, but do things with wishful thinking, they can see the results after, can never based on fact to predict any results.
Sir, you once again came with depth of truth on Pakistan 🇵🇰. May Allah Pak safe you and bless you for speaking the truth. Now on the topic of Kashmir, no matter it is Pakistan side or Indian side of Kashmir. We as a Nation is eagerly awaiting for Indian Army to make a mistake (last mistake by India) on Pakistan 🇵🇰. After Kashmir of Indian side, we will move on to Khalistan (Sikh Punjab). Ladakh will be taken care of by China 🇨🇳. On Ladakh the Indian Army definitely open up 2 front war which will be disaster for India on 6 sister Eastern states as well. Do pls also tell your listeners what Chicken Neck etc meaning of this?
You are living in a fools paradise. Please remember Pakistan lost half of its country in 1972. Don't ever forget that. Regarding this buffon of you tuber, he was court martialed during 1990. We guys took half of your country when - our country was economically backward. - US, UK was in your side. - whole Middle east was with your side. Within 15 years, India will be $15T economy. India is the fastest growing economy at 6% to 7% and will continue to do that for next 100 years. Do you think a bankrupt country like Pakistan can go to war with a economic giant?
He is lying to please Pak audience. In 1965 Indian Army crossed the international border and reached till Lahore. Indian Army captured Haji Pir pass too. Overall Indian Army captured 2800 sqkm. Most of his story is based on assumptions
Even if I were to agree with you on the formidable logistical issues the Indian defense services face, I have a few questions to ask as follow: 1. Assuming that the US would step in with satellite surveillance, how quickly can our services disseminate such info to its field formations? 2. Since Indian weapons platforms are almost 90%+ of Russian origin, how would manual dissemination of US info eliminate time lag to reorient our equipment since real time data transfer directly to platforms may not be possible? 3. What is the extent of operational autonomy Indian field commanders will be allowed by the political establishment whose sole objective is to drum up nationalism before GE 2024, to the exclusion of winning a war? 4. Unlike China that has fully indigenized its war machine, India's is dependent on imports. Russia has repeatedly delayed supply of critical spares and ammunition over the years. The Ukraine war commits all Russian ordnance factories to divert full capacity to their war front, that will only delay supplies of spares and ammo. How would India get over the need for specialized ammo and critical spares if a conflict were to be prolonged? 5. Your assumption that any Indian attempt to capture PoK would end in a disaster for various reasons. What if it does not and India is mired in a prolonged resistance over an extended period and then has to reckon with Chinese aggression in West Bengal and Ar P? 6. India's Atomic Energy Commission whose Minister-in-charge is the PM has possibly not even met for over five years to chart its course. Just how credible is India's nuclear threat? Equally, how credible is our nuclear shield, if any? 7. Pak's state finances are in tatters and today entirely dependent on aid from the UAE and China. The past where Pak maintained the LOC with India gaining no tactical advantage may not be true with a gigantic economic crisis in Pak. Likewise, Indian govt. finances are teetering on the verge of bankruptcy and dependent on domestic and overseas borrowing. This looks like a zero sum game to me. How will China get over it? 8. Given PLAAF's Rocket Force capabilities, how credible is India's own rocket program on fire power and reliability matrices? 9. It is safe to assume that Western powers will not risk annoying China beyond sharing intelligence by supplying offensive or defensive weapons to India, unlike in Ukraine. Nor are our ordnance factories up to the mark with rampant supply and reconditioning delays, aside from major reliability concerns. If war happens, Indian defense services will have to stockpile ammunition and spares for at least a 30-day war. What alternative supply sources does India have?
South Park Movie, Operation Get Behind the Darkies (no pun intended both Pak and India are Darkies for the west), this is the expendable philosophy, in USA case India and in China Case Pakistan. Usa wants China to get bogged down with India thereby making China weak, like Russia is losing its resources in Ukraine. China will utilize the future war to get their contested teretory, while India will let it go. While the main War will be with Pakistan and India. Even I know now that Pakistan cant get IOK, and India cant get POK (as identified by both countries). If both countries use Nukes it will kill their own people down stream. So it will be a useless escalation, where in the end both parties sitting on the table to negotiate the terms like they did many times before. China will get what they want, while Pakistan and India will be the sore losers. Usa will do nothing regarding your above points. See the Pakistan relationship with them for last 75 years and you will know what Usa friends go through. It is never a happy ending for Usa friends especially in Asia.
Pravin is a fool, no one takes him seriously self proclaimed defence analyst ...notice that only Pakistani, muslims and Chinese follow his comments ..its suits their realty.
I can answer your 7th question.. Pakistan’s finance crisis has and will never be able to affect Pakistan’s millitary whjch in itself has its own finance capabilities and have their own businesses to fund them.. Sadly thats exactly the reason for Pakistan’s financial difficulties since 1971 that Pakistan army has control over biggest businesses/sources of income of Pakistan.
Excellent analyses. I am neither Indian nor Pakistani but I am on side of Pakistan. I am glad that Pakistan is more than capable of defending itself against any potential aggression from India in Kashmir with help from China. I hope there is no war in Kashmir between India and Pakistan, I hope it won't be Pakistan to start the aggression in Kashmir. However, if India starts the aggression thinking that it is able to seize PAK (Pakistan Administered Kashmir), I hope Pakistan, with China's help, successfully roll into IOK (Indian Occupied Kashmir) and liberate the entire IOK. But the best thing is for both India and Pakistan to come to terms with current realities in Kashmir and accept the LOC as an international border and move on.
Excellent analysis, like always, Dr. Sawhney. The recent statements from the Indian officials and political leadership made me think, is India a credible emerging power? Because the irresponsible statements these people make do not reflect the behaviour of a well-trained military officer or a well-aware and seasoned political leadership. Dr. Sawhney, you have explained Chinese-Pakistani inter-operability very well. Let me assure you, the Pakistanis are not a walkover for any military; the Russians in the 70s and the 80 were confined to Afghanistan; they did not reach Gwadar or Karachi. And the Americans and NATO never dared to cross the Durand line, other than a couple of incidents like the Salala Check Post to have a handle on Pakistani nuclear weapon facilities etc., one of the leading causes of sitting in Afghanistan for over twenty years. Pakistanis fought the last war, the Kargil War, on the Indian side; they implemented and tested their strategy for the next war on Indian soil instead of hunkering down on defensive bunkers on their side of the LOC. I hope the Indian policymakers are mindful of the ground realities and the challenges they face on a more than 6000 km long border with the Chinese and the Pakistanis. By the way, the Chinese are a formidable force to deal with; we have seen it repeatedly since 1962 to the most recent Galwan incidents. The Pakistani adventure in Kargil in the late 90s; and the PAFs most recent broad daylight incursion on February 27, 2019, are the proofs. Pakistanis out-classed IAF and put a big question mark on the Indian ground and air surveillance equipment's credibility and the quality of the training of their men. I don't want to embarrass my Indian friends about Pakistani mechanized divisions' capability to cut Indian Occupied Kashmir off from the rest of India in the first 72 hours of a full-scale military conflict.
It must take extraordinary courage to remain cocky after debacle of Panjabistan army in 4 wars and a monumental surrender that world has ever seen! Regarding capabilities of mechanised divisions, let me remind you that they tried cutting off J&K in 1965 but came down running with shalwars in one hand to save La-hore from Indians. 'Russians and Americans both afraid of Pakistan', this must be joke of the century. Do you people seriously believe this? You think too highly of those mobsters in Khaki but let me tell you they're no more than a cheap whore to these superpowers and their fascist mindset was precisely the reason behind Bangladesh. People should seriously ask themselves, what have we become. Is terrorism, bloodshed, war and coup Pakistan is all about?
Assalamualaikum bhai...Indian Muslim hun. Bhai listen...Indian govt and agencies r planning to do Nuclear Attack on Pakistan and dismantle Pakistan once n for all. I m serious...dont take it lightly. If they will go to war...it is their agenda. America ,Israel, France n other countries may support India secretly. Do u think China will support Pakistan in that scenario or will stay away in case of a Nuclear War?? I mean Chinese can't be Trusted u know. Pakistan needs to have its own strategy. And its not abt India-Pakistan...they Dont see it that way...they see it as Hindu vs Muslim fight. So pls dont lose this time. Since last 600 years we Muslims are losing n losing...will it continue like this😭
hallala ke kamai se Jena wala ko last umar me pata chalta hai ki unka baap hai unka Mammut. Ye qoam ke gar bacche nazayaz hote hai kyunki quran me likha hua hai " cover the face f##k the base" concept. TRUE😢 PLZ SEARCH...😅
me as a resident of Pakistan occupied Kashmir i would like to mention a very important point here that the reason why India could not advance in past wars in this region is that 90 % of the mens at border were kashmiri residents they were not fighting for Pakistan they were fighting for their own land where they were born. And India should remember tha every house in pok has a retired or in service army personnel because there are no jobs here and the main source to earn living here is to join army or other civil service pok has highest literacy rate in Pakistan and every house has at a shotgun used for hunting and remember the harsh tarrain tanks cant move here
Your videos are very analytical and prudently based on military merits.But I doubt if it carries message to the Indian dispensation.India has a tradition to ditch the nation.Nehru also did so when he became nervous about the victory of the first communist govt.in Kerla 1957 The first in the world duly elected with the universal voting system.Hence, the the unconstitutional dismissal in 1959 and forward policy at the instance of USA and debacle in 1962. Grave inflation started in India since then.Indian shall never learn to keep their own country safe.
This guy seems to be the only respite for Pakistan. India doesn't need a military intervention to achieve it's goals. Pakistan by itself will fall to insignificance in the global arena. Pakistan is mere entertainment for India and sustenance for a few RU-vid channels like this, nothing more.
@@acorn4208 It's just that, you guys have a problem accepting reality. Pakistan isn't worth anything, just bullying the world of a meltdown scenario where the nukes would fall into the hands of terrorists! That's the only card Pakistan has left to play. Good luck.
Indian politicians and military general's have this habit of doing Diaohrrea from their mouths ‼️ more so since 2014 ‼️ AAP chronology SAMJHIYE Mitron ‼️
One thing should realize all 4 countries India Pakistan China and Bangladesh that we all should solve our disputes bilateral talks just like European did, they fought each other 100s of years and not only government their citizens also dislike each other but in Pakistan and India mostly peoples are friendly to each other only politicians are the biggest problems reason behind that they get more personal benefits in this situation
Never ever say Indian politicians. We Indians want war but stupid politicians do not want to. A war where 20 crore Indians walk into paxstan armed and kill at sight
True. Truth is truth... but bitter. Below average and idiot's are more in every society. So don't judge anyone by no of followers. Major plays with public sentiment. People like dream, facts are hard
@@ahmedkauser9996 Abe gadhe Thora padai kar leta. Thora Google kar le phele.apna madrasachaap Pak studies ki baat mat kar. 1971 defeat k baad pakistan had release a stamp of 90000 prisoners of war . Ye figure pakistan khud janta hai lekin apni awaam ko jhut bolta hai jaisi ki saare jung Pak jita hai jabki reality opposite hai.
1. POK retrieval by India will harm interest of China. So India should not take back POK. 2. India will take back by force. Indian commanders know how to do the job well. 3. PLA very powerful. And it has to prove the same in a battle field.
Thanks Praveen sir for a comprehensive and incisive analysis. For scoring political brownie points, BJP led Hindutva dispensation rake up Pakistan administered Kashmir and its annexation to India. In fact, it is an arrant hogwash being done to divert attention from a complete failure that we have witnessed in Kashmir. Indian armed forces are brough up as a secular entity however some of the army officers, who happen to be BJP acolyte, is spinning narrative that our armed forces can take on both nuclear armed states- The Pakistan army & The Chinese army. In reality, it would be a nightmare.
Nobody in India takes you seriously....This is good for those who despite losing in wars yo declare them as winners. Why shouldn't they feel happy ,like you and make you happy too.
even he is indian retired army office and showing reality of Indian army which has been planning against pakistan .if war started then what will.happend with India
Sir sir...Sam Manekshaw was always ready to cross the Western Sector specially in Sindh Province to create more pressure to Pakistan. It was Indira Gandhi who stopped him when she made a unofficial agreement with Bhutto. But yes, at present our defensive mentality need to be changed.
The author is a known Modisceptic so one would not expect anyting else from him. If he thinks Modi government is stupid enough to try and take back POK then, I am sorry to say Pravenn Sawhney is deluded. He probably does not understand the meaning of political bluster. As for Pakistan, may I remind everyone here that is a temporary/artificail and abnormal nation. The Balakot strikes were a success simply because it called out Pakistan's bluff. Everytime a 26/11, an Akshardham or a parliament attack happpened, past Indian governments could impose costs on Pakistan simply because, Pakistan made it clear that as soon as India crosses the LAC, then Pakistan will not hesitate to use nuclear weapons. Well in 2019 Indian planes did cross the LAC and Pakistan did not use any nuclear weapons. Pakistan also got a message that there will be costs next time for terror support. So look at the data in terms of number of terrorist attacks in India since 2019. You wil find that they have gone down after Balakot air strikes. Pakistan and Pakistanis are frustrated that after years of them being told "Kashmir banega Pakistan", after article 370 removal that is not possible. Likewis anti-Modi poeple are also frustrated that Modi government has got it right with their Kashmir policy with removal of article 370.
