Automated Ball-Strike Challenge System in Action!

Подписаться 2,5 тыс.

Просмотров 20 тыс.

50% 1

Here are 8 borderline pitches that were challenged and immediately reviewed during Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp home games (Marlins Triple-A affiliate). Do you want to see something like this implemented in the big leagues?
Pitch 1: pitcher Louis Head, hitter Jacob Amaya, catcher John Hicks
Pitch 2: Trey Cobb, Austin Allen, John Hicks
Pitch 3: Jesús Cruz, Jacob Amaya, John Hicks
Pitch 4: Chris Vallimont, C.J. Hinojosa, Anthony Bemboom
Pitch 5: Robert Garcia, Colton Cowser, Austin Allen
Pitch 6: Dillon Tate, Jerar Encarnación, Anthony Bemboom
Pitch 7: Archie Bradley, Colton Cowser, Santiago Chávez
Pitch 8: Logan Gillaspie, Santiago Chávez, Maverick Handley
Become a Super Subscriber: bit.ly/FOFSupe...
Complete Miami Marlins coverage: fishonfirst.com/

Опубликовано:

26 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 71

@roryh2241 Год назад

This is really cool! This the perfect system for me. We need an ump making the calls, but let players challenge just like this. And it will evolve so players get better at knowing what to challenge because a few of these challenges are clearly a waste

@Ghostrider6A Год назад

This is what Tim McCaffrey has said for years. I'm not a fan of the ABS, but this I can get behind 100%.

@wormydiaz 3 месяца назад

this is incredible. i think its worth adding a couple extra minutes worth of time to each game to get the utmost accuracy, while also preventing arguments and unnecessary ejections. keeps everyone happy.

@KennethJLave 2 месяца назад

Oh yeah, this is the way to go! It's actually entertaining. ..In fact though, it would be better if the Home Plate Umpire was given an immediate signal through an earpiece from the automated strike zone system.

@baugh3162 3 месяца назад

I've seen this type of system used in Cricket ... it's fantastic

@SFAPowerhouse 5 месяцев назад

Can't wait to see this in the majors.

@daveborn1971 3 месяца назад

each team only gets 3 per game, so this won't be happening all game.

@SFAPowerhouse 2 месяца назад

@daveborn1971 That's a start. Save them for most crucial times

@NoName-gf6xo 2 месяца назад

@@daveborn1971should be 1 challenge per at bat, or 3 an inning

@wyethhines 4 месяца назад

Why can’t they just signal the Umpires ear piece with the call, immediately? Why is the challenge necessary? Just “ding” the left ear for a ball and the right ear for a strike…🤔

@SLC-Smudge42 4 месяца назад

Whether you agree with it or not it is to add drama to the process. Also the graphic this year tells you how far off the plate the pitch is.

@rjhutc 3 месяца назад

because the computer can't make the call *immediately*, it takes time for the data to process. it's not a lot of time, just a couple of seconds, but in practice that's too long to wait on every single pitch

@markk2745 28 дней назад

@@rjhutc Maybe that's true for these tests but for sure a computer can do that instantly (sub 1/10 sec) if they get the right programming and computer. There are a hell of a lot more complicated calculations your home computer does instantly so in MLB there should be no delay at all given the money they have for good computers and programmers. I think they might actually do this slowly on purpose to give some drama to the game.

@The.Jedi.Wizard 7 месяцев назад

We NEED THISS

@ka-pop2243 5 месяцев назад

MLB would likely reject it because: 1) It would slow the game, 2) It would further remove "the human element" and 3) It would immediately put Angel Rodriguez out of a job.

@ep9691 5 месяцев назад

it takes 5 seconds for the challenge.. that does not slow the game down. just like the pitch clock. it speeds up the game and makes the games quicker so you get out of there in 2:30 hours

@DanielOrteez 5 месяцев назад

Angel Hernandez wouldn't be out of a job. He'll be instantly corrected and will HOPEFULLY adjust and correct his strike zone for the rest of the game.

@jamiesachtleben2946 5 месяцев назад

@DanielOrteez Angel Hernandez and correcting calls are in completely different ballparks, because he won't be an official after 2024 xD

@carlhannah1884 5 месяцев назад

@@DanielOrteez I honestly thing he just has horrible peripheral vision out of his right eye. Not sure that's fixable.

@randominternet5586 Год назад

A note that I think the number of challenges is limited. So we are seeing a bunch here but normally you'd see fewer.

@RamsayboltonSnow 7 месяцев назад

If they win the challenge they don’t loose any right. So it could stay at 3 2 or 1 challenge for ahwile

@Michael-gu5kl Месяц назад

This was from different games as each team gets 3 per game!

@markk2745 28 дней назад

I'm not a big fan of this automation however given the stakes on the line in winning just 1 game in MLB this or some version of this is definitely needed. After watching this its actually fun to see what happens but that might get tiring if people are constantly doing it on obvious calls so 3 times a game sounds good to me.

@alexthegod2 Год назад

if the system is good enough to be 99% accurate I'd prefer for the system to make the call. It would suck to not have a challenge and have a really bad pitch end a game. Or feel like you don't want to waste one early. either way it will be an improvement for the game.

@fredfishmonger Год назад

The issue is that the system takes a while, so it would extend games by a lot which would counter everything they’ve been trying to do with shortening games. Having a limited number of challenges adds strategy to it instead of challenging everything

@alexthegod2 11 месяцев назад

@@fredfishmonger the challenge only comes into play when humans are calling BB/K. I'm in favor of having the robo ump call all BB/K calls with no challenges

@fredfishmonger 11 месяцев назад

@@alexthegod2 like is said, the system takes a while to determine if a pitch is a strike or ball, however long a single challenge takes is how long every call would take with this system

@alexthegod2 11 месяцев назад

@@fredfishmonger the newest system is instant now no delays

@ep9691 5 месяцев назад

@@fredfishmonger it takes 5 seconds for the system to show the replay.. that's not a while

@smudent2010 5 месяцев назад

This is Angel Hernandez proof

@rwwilson21 5 месяцев назад

the game would be 5 hrs long when angel hernandez is behind the plate. everyone of his pitches will be challenged.

@MEATBALLmonty 4 месяца назад

@@rwwilson21 You can't challenge check swing calls.

@rwwilson21 4 месяца назад

@@MEATBALLmonty I'm not talking about check swings. I'm just talking about his pitch calling. read my comment.

@MEATBALLmonty 4 месяца назад

Tried to reply to OP so said the game will be Angel Hernandez proof. It won't.

@SuperJasondennis 3 месяца назад

I like the automated but there has to be consequences for wrongful challenges or a limit to how etc etc

@Michael-gu5kl Месяц назад

There is they lose a challenge

@KoreanBeautyOwner 2 месяца назад

In KBO all calls AI every calls now..

@LourdesSantos-gv6pg 4 месяца назад

I think every call will be challenged and drag the game out to 6 hours lol, they may need to put a limit of times you can challenge, if you lose one you're out of challenges.

@txfishingdude5121 9 месяцев назад

is there going to be any point for catchers to frame pitches anymore?

@FishOnFirst 9 месяцев назад

Depends on what system they decide to use full time. With the challenge system, your team only has 3 chances in the game to review pitches. That still leaves other borderline pitches where framing could make a difference. But framing would become less valuable overall, yeah.

@Michael-gu5kl Месяц назад

Nope!

@KoreanBeautyOwner 2 месяца назад

No challenge needed.. Just all calls by AI...

@Sp33dyBeanz Месяц назад

this is definitely great to see, but what the fuck is that virtual strike zone? homies are 6 foot 3 and the strike zone is literally a small box. i think we need to focus on defining the strike zone for each batter more accurately and implementing that into the computer algorithm

@bobcarp1239 Год назад

Remember the end of Planet of the Apes when Carlton Heston saw Lady Liberty.... that's what I'm doing in front of my monitor right now....

@TrumpTheImmortal 22 дня назад

Definitely need to totally take the umpire out of the ball and strike calling all together. This challenge rule is great but let’s skip one step to make it better. Don’t have umpires calling them in the first place. Just let the AI do it. They are using it in challenges so why can’t they just use it during the whole game. The umpires union shouldn’t have any problems with it. They are not getting rid of the home plate umpire position. They can still do the rest of their duties. But this needs to be dealt with.

@bryanb5895 10 месяцев назад

Why not just let the computer tell the ump what the call is and save a lot of time.

@TheKuLeR 5 месяцев назад

I’ve seen the computer make incorrect ball-strike calls in minor league games. I like this as a compromise until a roboump is infallible.

@bryanb5895 5 месяцев назад

@@TheKuLeR Are the mistakes at least consistant? What we have now is ridiculous. You never know what the umps are going to call.

@TheKuLeR 5 месяцев назад

@@bryanb5895 I'd say the errors are probably consistent. What I've seen most often are slightly but definitely below the bottom of the zone being called strikes. Might be caused by the heights of certain batters? Still a work in progress.

@bryanb5895 5 месяцев назад

@@TheKuLeR Consistency would be a major change for the better. At least the hitters and the pitchers would have something consistent to work with.

@Sp33dyBeanz Месяц назад

@@TheKuLeR theyre clearly making mistakes because that strike zone is insanely small for someone who is over 6 feet tall. when did the strike zone become a small box? i thought that was only for short batters lol

@APPALACHIAN_MOTH 4 месяца назад

This thing will be over ruling Angel Hernandez every pitch. MLB clone Pat Hoberg.

@cococock2418 15 дней назад

This is absolutely braindead. Just go to robo umps.

@Reese_Young 4 месяца назад

Never will make it to the majors

@griessee45 4 месяца назад

I don’t like this already

@donb4983 Год назад

This just slows the game down and is dumb.....

@benwhealler4278 Год назад

A lot better than idiotic umps making idiotic calls.

@yousuckatcod Год назад

Your comment makes no sense because game time has been drastically reduced since the pitch clock was implemented.

@baatar Год назад

Well, we still got the pitch clock so we break even

@baatar Год назад

Also, sorry to add on to this but if a walk is converted into a strikeout, it will actually speed up the game.

@Sly253 Год назад

Swing the damn bat

@iceveiled 6 месяцев назад

Or just hire umpires that aren't shit.

@lonniec7603 4 месяца назад

DAF

@josephtorres135 4 месяца назад

Yeah it’s cool but player are going to be constantly asking for a review it should be set how many time each team can review a call. Like 10 review for each team

@Michael-gu5kl Месяц назад

Nope they will get 3 per game