Babur's Sexuality, Marxism, And The End of Indian Left | Dostcast w/ Historian Aabhas Maldahiyar 

Bhai Vinamr I can't believe that you really don't know what happened to Nupur Sharma.

Vinamre doesn't even know about the murder of Kanhaiya Lal and 7 oyhers, how unfortunate is that.

Who wants j sai deepak. .Comment it.

This 1 hour 35 minutes has taught me more than 6 years of history classes ever could

22:59 How effortlessly Vinamra said, "Muh par toh bolte hain," but if the same were said about Muslims whether they are radicals and loyal to this nation, he'd nod vigorously and launch into a passionate defense, adding two more lines to their commendation. Now, that's what you call narrative! Hindus gets labeled as the castiest by default, while Muslims are painted as the Eternal Victims / BHATKE HUE LOG of this nation. Despite evidence to the contrary, it's become the accepted norm.

Do podcast with India biggest Ex-Muslim!! That is "ExMuslim sahil". Bring him on the showww!!! Ex-Muslim Sahil!!!

Vinamre is so high that he doesn't know nupur sharma whole tragedy And he wants to become a podcaster

The host is really unaware of current as well as historical facts... Amazing

Hi Vinamre, please invite J Sai Deepak on your podcast.

Kalma/Shahada/Azan which you hear daily from loudspeaker says Ash-hadu alla ilaha illa Allah, wa ash-hadu anna anna Muhammadan Rasulullah” I bear witness/ I give testimony that there is no god but God(Allah) and muhammed is his slave and Messenger. This is foundation of islam if you know......This statement is completely political and you have to hear daily that there is no god other than Allah and muhammed is his only Messenger and slave.....shariyat goes then on say that if muhammed is slave of Allah....every person is slave of Allah.....and and job of a Muslim to convert every one muslim so that another Day of Judgement (akhirat) comes and we all go Jannah(heaven) and hell... And there we get 72 virgins to enjoy....

In Hinduism, there is no criticism. There are questions. In fact, the three central questions (who am I, where have I come from, where am I going) are the basis of Hinduism. In other religions, these three questions are forbidden. The answers are preset, and fed to the ‘believers’

And now i can call myself a true history student as i already knew the fact that Babur didnt liked the his Mongol ancestory and thus not the word Mughal

Not being expansionist is actually counterproductive because when you don't have expansionist ambitions, people tend to find differences within and country breaks from within.. but when you are expansionist and entire country has a common enemy it becomes more stronger and United.

Bhai ye monkey balancing ka keeda hinduon me hai hi. Anchor is no exception. He is kushal mehra western learnt intellect brigade.

1)Nationalism started in India by Chtrapathi Shivaji Maharaj.... Hindavi Swarajya......all leaders from Maharashtra were nationalist.....Savarkar Carried the legacy forever.....Every other State lost to mughal at some point.... Aggressive Maratha resisted and won.......

Vinamar bhai trying hard to defend "peaceful community" but aabhas Bhai spitting facts

Please invite j Sai Deepak please 🙏

Vinamre dont have Hindu tatva within him......Hindu tatav = material/realism of Hindu being = existence of being Hindu

Please bring J Sai Deepak and Rajarshi Nandy to your podcast.... It will be a great experience for everyone. You will be able to create an amazing experience for the audience.

Turkish born nun who worked for decades with persecuted Christians and Yazidis in the Middle East, Sister Hatune Dogan: “ISIS is Islam, Islam is ISIS”

Where does this interviewer come from?? He doesn't know what happened to/after Nupur Sharma??!! My 10yr old son was also asking about the details after seeing all the news reports and decades that had happened about this incident...then that killing of a poor tailor in Rajasthan for supporting her...

Isn't aware of Sar Tan se Juda episode??? Makes me label you the newest LIBRANDU!!

I bet just like him...that no hesitation guy ranveer chudabadia also is not aware about the sar tan se juda wale julus

Humayun fell and died from the Steps of his Library at Purana Qila. Delhi.

Bhai Babar kya tha, kisse bhaag raha tha, bisexual tha ya nahin, mujhe kya karna !!! Mere purvajon ko kyun mara.!!!??? He is just a demon from another World that's it.

Vidyaranya was guru of Harihar and Bukka Rai and his life was very similar to Chanakya and played very important role in establishing Vijaynagar empire.

Bbai the podcast was going so good yarr...bt the host kept on diverting concepts with his random questions with the impulsion to execute his preparation...jiski wajah se wo koi story complete hi nhi kr paya

Hindus get United and save our civilization values and culture.

Guy, why do you jump in so fast to defend certain peacefuls

Pls bring part 2 . Amazing podcast . So much enlightenment

अरे वो लोग करते थे तो वो सही थे अगर हम करने लगे तो गलत हो गए? मगर हम लोगों का तरीका अलग है। इन लोगों की वजह से देश का विभाजन हुआ था ये नहीं भूलना चाहिए।

The answer to question of muslims feeling insecure and what should they do was best answered by Sai deepak sir in the ranveer show

bring Ex Muslim Sahil as Guest 👍👌💪🙏

J Sai Deepak, Adam Seeker, ExMuslim Sahil!

Such an interesting conversation. I sometime feel that we learn history better from people who are non historians.

I applaud Vinamre's effort, but I reckon Kushal, Arihant and Ajeet are better interviewers - they seem to have a better idea of what's going on in the world. I've noticed this in earlier interviews I've seen Vinamre do (eg the Rahul Shivshankar and Smita Prakash ones) where the follow-up questions left a fair bit to be desired (eg suggesting Vinamre was not as aware of Indian politics and history as I thought he would be, given that he managed to get such big names on his show). Even Ranveer comes across as a better interviewer than Vinamre.

Can listen to him to multiple topics and way he explained Marxism, communism, architecture, and also world history and way he connected the dots was engaging. Can listen to him for hours.

ऐसे लोगो को मंच देने के लिए बहुत धन्यवाद ।

Super excited 🎉🎉

You should explore more on abhas's pov on marxism...that was interesting and please dont question random thing in between stay on topic

Abhas Bhai is awesome, thanks vinamre you rock ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Such a quick jump in advocating for the special community people

Jabse is vinamra ne ek porn star ka pod cast Kiya tha aur extra marital affair, physical relationship ko sahi thahraya tha tab se ye insan pasand nahi hai aur aaj Puri duniya aur Bharat me isi mahine(ramadan) itne berahami se hinduon ka murder, rape kiya lekin isko wo bechare lagte Hain. Such a waste of time. I was here to listen to Abhash sir but listening to this host guy it feels he invites people of Indic faith only for views.

The seer you were talking of is "Swami Vidyaranya". He is the founder of modern day resistance for the Vedic, Sanatani or Hindu. The Rayas ruled in the name of Virupaksha. :)

Mast podcast, easy to understand and learnt many new things

vinamre bhai can u tell something about the art piece in guest's background?

Finally we get to read some true, unbiased history.

Host ke hisab sa minority dara hua hai bharat ma Jab ki "sar tan sa juda " hindu ke verodh ma lagaya jata hai hindu ke hi des ma

I am here for Aabhas ji, the host is Hollow and superficial.

Fascinating ❤❤

Superb❤

Bhai na main marxist hon na main communist hon pr iss ex-marxist se zda to mujhe pta ha marxism ar communism k barey main , ullu bna gya bhai understanding marxism k naam pr

Nothing just a same ncert glorification of mughals.... Bhai indian minds were working with them did u got it

Bhai 1 bat batio jo vo dare hue ap ka muslim dost ha vo real muslim pe kuch kyu nahi bolte na kio action lete ha. So clearly vo darne ka natak karte h.

Savarkar jaise log aaj deshbhkt bn gye desh ka beda gark hona toh confirm hai 😢😢😢

Pls invite Mr. Ankit Shah. He's really popular these days.

Please invite Praveen mohan sir

I think it's a Lamy Safari that Aabhas is holding in his hand. Please correct me if I am wrong.

23:56 Bro lives on some flat earth with his muslim friends. 14:52 - 16:08 Bro trying to garner sympathy and play dara hua card. 4:33 Savarkar ❌ Veer Savarkar ✅ Felt good and enlightening listening to Aabhash ji.

he is very underrated but he have very deep way of thoughta

New and interesting point of views.

1:22:39 khubsurat jawan ladke 🥳

Babur didn't even control modern day Uzbekistan though. He was defeated by the Uzbek khanate and fled to kabul from Fergana.

Very nice content❤

Gr8❤

Sur you are genius....thanks to team for such a eye opener podcast.here in usa I work with Pakistanis who are proud of abdali....babar...... Only I can do after listening....nothing

The guest forgot to tell that , savarkar wanted annihilation of caste system along with utilities of cow, and not worshipping cows.. paving ways for non superstition or non demonised meat eater

Really enjoyed this podcast. You really do bring out the best in some of these 'right wing' intellectuals.

Too good and so much knowledge

What is there about pain in Hindu philosophy? As per Krishna in the gIta, you strove to become a STHITHAPRAGYA - one whose senses are under her control and see both success or failure ( pleasure or pain) in an even fashion. This is the goal of the seeker.

This so-called "self professed" Marxist has 0% idea of Marxism... Either he didn't read Marx or he didn't understand his works. One simple request, next time onwards as a litmus test, please ask anyone who claims to have read Marx to explain Dialectical Materialism, that's the core of Marxism. There's no harm in contradicting an idea but that must be done only if you've requisite knowledge on that idea!! Kudos to Vinarmra for asking relevant questions in defence.

Aise hi videos bnayiye issi ko dekh ke subscribe kiye h

YOU GUYS HAVE TO SEE MAHENDRA CAVE AND BAT CAVE IN NEPAL... these are natural made caves having deities inside

Vinamre please invite Acharya Prashant on ur podcast😊

Hindu expansionism was to increase civilizational footprint not just trashy demographics. Even today GOI despite such misbehavior of Maldives is still not taking it to task but extending benevolence.

It was not khilafat - it was khalifa/caliphate - Ottoman Empire- newly converted Bharathiya Muslims wanted to join that empire after British leave

Badiya

That intro got me to subscribe 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Vinamre please listen in to the guest than interjecting in between with your talk . Please just listen in 🙏🏾

@26:40 Right of center. Not center of right.

Bhai aap india hi rente ho ? aapko ' sar tan se juda ' k barei mai nhi pta ? Akbar pdha likha nhi tha Ye toh Jodha Akbar mai bhi hai

Why are u not aware of nupur case ?

Subscribe kr liya bhai

If you seriously wish to learn how Islam works, you talk to those who live or lived it. Not to those who observe it from a distance. Adam seeker is a such person who commands such deep authority over the subject of Islam. Bring him to podcast. He would join online only as he keeps his identity hidden

The guy is not aware that Ajanta Ellora paintings in dark caves were made before Mughals saw reflection. Whatever the the Mughal did or practiced in India was already present in India.

You are completely wrong. Karl Marx never wrote that everyone would have equal pay in a communist society. Karl Marx said that the more a person works, the more he gets paid. He wrote "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs". A person who has read Karl Marx cannot make such a stupid mistake. According to Karl Marx, the transition from capitalism to communism involves several significant political, social, and economic changes. Marx envisioned a series of stages that would ultimately lead to the establishment of a communist society, where the means of production are collectively owned and there is no private property or class distinctions. Let's explore the changes that Marx outlined for each stage in detail: 1. Capitalism: The starting point of Marx's analysis is capitalism, which he saw as characterized by private ownership of the means of production and the exploitation of labor. In this stage, the bourgeoisie, or capitalist class, owns and controls the means of production, while the proletariat, or working class, sells their labor power to survive. The capitalist mode of production is driven by profit and competition. 2. Socialism (Lower Stage of Communism): Marx proposed that the first transitional stage from capitalism to communism would be socialism, also referred to as the lower stage of communism. In this stage, the means of production are collectively owned and controlled by the working class, representing a shift away from private ownership. However, Marx acknowledged that certain elements of capitalism may still persist during this stage, such as the continued existence of wages and the principle of "to each according to their work." The main objective of socialism is to gradually eliminate class distinctions and lay the groundwork for a fully communist society. During the socialist stage, Marx envisioned several key changes: - Abolition of private property: Private ownership of the means of production is replaced by collective ownership. This means that factories, land, and other productive resources are no longer owned by individuals or capitalists but are instead owned and managed by the working class as a whole. - Planned economy: The socialist stage involves the establishment of a planned economy, where production is organized based on social needs rather than profit motives. The allocation of resources and distribution of goods are determined through democratic decision-making processes, ensuring that the needs of society as a whole are prioritized. - Socialization of labor: In socialism, Marx envisioned the transformation of labor from individualized and alienated work under capitalism to socialized labor. This means that work becomes a collective endeavor, with workers collaborating and coordinating their efforts for the benefit of society as a whole. - Reduction of inequalities: While some inequalities may still exist during the socialist stage, Marx believed that they would gradually diminish as the class distinctions between the bourgeoisie and proletariat are dismantled. The aim is to create a more equitable society where wealth and resources are distributed more fairly. 3. Communism (Higher Stage of Communism): The final stage in Marx's vision is communism, also known as the higher stage of communism. In this stage, Marx envisioned a society without class divisions, private property, or the need for a state apparatus. Communism represents the ultimate goal, where the principle of "from each according to their ability, to each according to their needs" is fully realized. Key changes in the communist stage include: - Abolition of class distinctions: In communism, there are no social classes, as the division between the bourgeoisie and proletariat is completely eradicated. All individuals are regarded as equal members of society, with no exploitation or oppression. - Stateless society: Marx envisioned the withering away of the state in communism. As class distinctions disappear and the need for coercion and control diminishes, the state apparatus becomes unnecessary. Instead, society is governed through voluntary cooperation and democratic decision-making processes. - Full abundance and free access: In communism, the productive forces of society are developed to such an extent that scarcity is eliminated. This allows for the principle of free access, where individuals can freely take what they need from the common pool of resources, without the need for exchange or monetary transactions. It is important to note that Marx did not provide a detailed blueprint for the transition from capitalism to communism, and he acknowledged that the specific path and timeline of this transition would depend on historical and material conditions. His analysis focused on the contradictions and dynamics of capitalist society, offering a theoretical framework for understanding and transforming it towards a more egalitarian and classless society.

This prodcast is multiple subjects

Dear Abhas and Host please recheck the no of Muslim Generals with Shivaji Maharaj They were not Generals ...they were lay man and the no was 6...Only one Navy chief was there but he was also replaced after Kanhoji Angry ..... Shivaji Maharaj writes letter to his step brother Wyankoji Bhosle And says ...How you can win when You recruited turks in your Army....I will them

होस्ट की अज्ञानता ने मुझे इन्हे अनसब्सक्राइब करने को मजबूर कर दिया है। सर तन से जुदा ही नहीं सुना इसने कहा था दादा तू, तू इतिहास क्या पढ़ेगा रे जब तुझे की समकालीन जानकारी ही नहीं है।😂😂

so sad that vinamra dont know about nupur

Although 1857 revolt was called First war of independence by Savarkar... Savarkar was not wrong and not right in calling it First war of Independence....Savarkar rathar smartly used it as hindu Muslim unity to fight more big power British......But in reality 1857 revolt was not first war independence....... actually moslems ullems through muslims soldiers of british army wanted to bring back mughal empire .....Bahadur shah zafar was puppet of those moslem rebels and ullems.... they also contact Ottomon empire and perisan empire...... *The Moslem rebels also slaughter British women and children because it was JIHAD declared by ullema against british...the moslem rebel also killed Christian missionaries and his wofe and daughter.....one of moslem rebel forces a married english and anglo english women to convert and marry them....... NanaSahib Peshwa was also like Savarkar.....he supported rebels against British...but also not wanted mugajl Empire to come again.....He directly wrote letter a british and fought them with hindu rebels.......they lost and NanaSaheb disappeared....went to nepal...some say SaiBaba...maybe died..... don't know........Rani LaxmiBai and Tantiya tope was fighting for their territory with NanaSaheb......Sikh refuse to join because Mughals would come again......since many british women and children were raped and killed...news reached britian and therefore they brutally killed rebels both by blowing to cannons......

26:45 Centre of right or right of centre? Or obviously I've not heard this expression before. The expression is Centre-right? Which means slightly rightist. Centre of right would mean going left, leftist. How much left is left to your imagination. Anyway who's wrong here?

Invite jai sai deepak

kya aap un 11 generals ke naam bata sakte ho kya? Agar bata sakte ho to uska legal proof bhi dijiye

Feedback : Please stick to topic. I feel very less was discussed about Barbar.

Good Podcast

Bhai, kar diya subscribe apka channel 😂😂

Vijay Prashad can be another intellectual who would debunk everything this man said

Dosnt this podcaster know anything abt Hindutva? He sympathizes with momins but believes Hindus are only tolerant in theory. He isn’t well read on topics abt Nupur or how much violence there is against ordinary Hindus or those who live as minority within communities but he knows all abt suppressed Muslims. He didn’t even read Karl Marx we read in school. So much attitude.

JSD should be next. But hope Kushal is not influencing your guest list