I really like your honesty! Because many people will say that baccarat rouge 540 is their favorite because it’s more expensive. But I definitely agree with you! Burberry her and Cloud are lovely
I completely agree with you everything you said. Cloud at first spray smells like BR540 but then dries down to a marshmallow/creamy scent which I love BUT Burberry Her at first spray smells like pure strawberries but the dry down is so phenomenal, pure BR540 vibes. Love them all three xo 🥰💕💗✨
I am a teacher and when one of my sixth graders came in today smelling strongly of BR 540 I had to ask her what scent it was. It was AG Cloud. When I tested Cloud I didn’t get the similarities but today I understood the comparison.
I have all of these perfumes, also Ariana cloud intense. They’re all great but my favorites even over the original baccarat are Burberry her and her intense. 🥰
@@micheller2906 hello :) Burberry Her and Her intense are similar but Burberry Her is like powdered strawberries its fresh but sweet. Burberry Her intense is like syrupy cherries/berries but also has a slightly powdery dry down. Burberry her is the day version and her intense is the evening version in my opinion. Both are compliment getters for me.
@Kamalita Rajagopalan I also struggle with perfumes lasting on my skin so I understand what you mean. Burberry her on my skin lasts about 4-6 hours the dry down is musky. Burberry her intense lasts about 6-8 hours on my skin and after a while I can’t smell it but others around me compliment me and im shocked. The compliments have happened after 6 hours. The dry down is a sweet powdery dry down but very sexy. I have a very hard time choosing between the two but if I had to choose I would say to go with Burberry Her it’s more of a year round perfume. I have been told that they can smell me through a mask while wearing Burberry her. I have both an will continue repurchase both. I have a 3.4oz bottle of Burberry her and a 1oz bottle of Burberry her intense. My Burberry her is already half way used and my Burberry her intense is also half way used. I got the 1oz because I wasn’t sure if I was going to like but I fell in love with it. I plan on purchasing the 3.4oz of the intense. But Burberry Her intense is not for everyone and not a safe blind buy. Hope this helps. :)
I totally agree, it seems like the Baccarat Rouge comparisons (and dupes) just keep coming! haha And honestly Baccarat Rouge isn't nearly my favorite Maison Francis Kurkdjian perfume. Grand Soir, Feminin Pluriel and Gentle Fluidity Gold, for example, are better IMO! 😃
BR540 is a very controversial perfume...people either love it or hate it...and to be honest in my country most people hate it especially men and kids. And the reason being that they get a strong vibe of hospital anticeptic and not really anything else. On me happens exactly the same. So if some people don 't get compliments it is because their enviroment doesn 't like it. Burberry Her and especially Her intense are 95% BR without the hospital anticeptic vibe. Personally i have the intense and i love it so do people around me. Besides both Burberry perfumes are creations of Francis Kurkdjian himself! 😉
Tha ks for that information! I smelled Burberry HER and fell in love but I needed something stronger and longer lasting. Going to check out the intense version
I get exactly that from Baccarat 540 which I unfortunately bought after thinking I liked the smell while in the dept. store. Once I bought it and was home, all I got was a heavy synthetic, too strong and very off-putting scent. You called it "medicinal" and I agree. It smells truly awful. I smelled Burberry Her on a magazine insert months later and really liked it. Never associated it with 540. After buying it and letting it dry down on my skin, lighbulbs went off - it smelled similar, but better, then my very first in-store impression of Baccarat 540!! I didn't even know people called it a 540 dupe. I love it. And will be selling the 540 as I can't stand it.
To me BR540 is perfect for family gatherings, work and dates. Where you dont want to offend, but smell gorgeous. Like if you have an office crush or something. I only have a decant, but Im sure gonna get the full bottle.
I love BR540 and Burberry Her and think that they have a similar vibe but still smell quite different, but I think because they are both by MFK they get compared so much.
I blind bought Burberry Her bc of your videos. I love it. :) I don't think it smells particularly like either Cloud or BR540, though. I far prefer Cloud and BH to BR540. Probably makes me a perfume peasant, but that's ok.
@@micheller2906 I think they are but intense is more blackberry and syrupy. I use intense at night and in the winter. Intense is discontinued so I bought a back up bottle just in case.
I agree with Kiki: I had both, cloud original is cloud intense. I can’t tell difference. I got compliments from original but not intense, I don’t know why 😂😂
This video is so trueee I’ve tried both BR540 and Burberry HER and I agreed with her !!!! Base is very similar! They’re like cousins But I prefer Burberry more! I usually hate patchouli and sweet fragrances but Burberry changes my nose! This is just wow! Plus they’re the same perfume maker :-)
I actually can’t smell BR540 at all, and my sense of smell is very strong. It was such an odd experience! I ended up buying Her EDT (but had no idea Her was considered a dupe) and I absolutely adore it. The EDT is a juicier and more floral version compared to the EDP.
I got bored with cloud, I feel like I moved up with Burberry her. I smell bubble gum then a softer cloud version. I fell in love when I smelled it. I’m 45 and feel it may be a little young but I am all about smelling good so I don’t care.
Cloud is great especially considering the price point. But, we all know it just isn’t the same as BR540 no matter how we may try to convince ourselves 🤣🤣
Ion really get the comparisons. I have them all and neither of the smell BR 540 to me. Cloud have a similarity to it but my senses does speak BR 540. Burberry Her not even close.....matter of fact, I wore it once and was rather disappointed.
This was a very comprehensive comparison! I recently smelled Burberry Her on a tester and I'm still sniffing it - smells sooo good! Gotta get it. Also recently bought the 35ml of BR540 and there is a similar vibe, but I see why you like BH better.🙏🏾✌🏾
Hi Gabby, today will be the first time that I ever sent a comment on your channel. I just wanted to say you are awesome, I've been following several of you on RU-vid and I have a few of you that I absolutely love and you're included. As far as the topic of the day I'm with you I totally enjoyed Burberry her. I got a sample of BR 540 Extract, it is stunning but nonetheless I find it too expensive. So for now I will enjoy my Burberry her and cloud
I have all 3 and you are spot on! I also smell the medicinal scent in baccarat rouje 540 and cloud, not in Burberry her original and I think they all smell different, I don’t think any is a dupe to 540 :)) my favorite is Burberry her original
This is such an honest review I love it! I ordered the BR540 EDP and Extrait samples plus Burberry her Roll EDP On merucari japan ~ and I’m sooo excited! Only think stopping me from trying the cloud is the coconut sent - this note usually gives me a headache.
i feel you so much with the coconut thing, i HATE coconut in perfumes (makes me dizzy and nauseous), but the Cloud one it's really soft, fluffy & creamy... i don't know how to describe it, but it doesn't feel like the typical coconut at all! i advice you to just try it and see for yourself, because Cloud now it's one of my favorites perfumes which i didn't expected at all
I Loooooove BR540. It's my absolite fave,, i don't care. Don't like Ariana Grande Cloud but to be fair I don't have it.. so I'll give it a try. I'm also torn between Bueberry Her and Her intense.. I need to check it again on my skin
I prefer burberry her. 540 smells a little masculine on me which I don’t like. Burberry her intense kind of has an old lady vibe to it (I think they put more patchouly in the intense version). I haven’t tried cloud (not interested) 🤷🏽♀️.
I'll never buy Cloud simply cuz of the packaging. It literally looks plastic & cheap like something for a child. I'm not putting that on my dresser on display! I'm literally 30 years old! The hell?!
@@xtina_da_doll8681 to be fair it’s an Ariana perfume, of course she won’t do sophisticated packaging considering her fan base. They’re young and want something simply cute (and probably juvenile in your perspective). Gotta fit her brand ya know 🤣
A guy I’m dating wore BR540 but a dupe of it and it smelled amazing on him. I don’t have it but I do have a dupe of it from Julianna perfume. I have and love Burberry her edp. I don’t have the original cloud but I bought the intense. It kinda reminds me of BR540 so I think that’s what they were going for perhaps.
Girl whatttt give me your nose 🤣 I cannot pick up any lavender in Cloud and I love that note 😭. Honestly yes agree it’s fairly different from BR540, but I think we only notice cause we are in the fragrance community & have smelled a crap ton of perfumes. The general public who don’t wear perfumes regularly, will think they are exactly the same.
I have Cloud and Her Intense. The sample I tried of Her didn't hit me just right. I think the oakmoss note didn't smell good, I could smell the similarities in AG Cloud and Her Intense,though. If they are similar to BR540 then it must smell pretty nice.
Hi Gabby. Wonderful review! If you are so inclined would you make a suggestion or video for the discontinued Stella by Stella McCartney perfume (violet bottle). Thank you!
I smelled cloud in stores and it smelled so good on paper I bought it. On me it smells like men’s Cologne with sol de janeiro 68 sprayed on top😭 so far my fav dupe for br540 is the sol de janeiro 68
The sample also gave me some Medicinal vibes too. The extrait seems sweeter? Is the extrait version better snd missing that hospital smell? I want the extrait smell without the Medicinal smell. Which perfume fits that bill?
Love this comparison. Would be curious what you think of AG cloud intense. I actually returned D&G garden because it had too similar vibes to AG cloud for me. I like to have unique perfumes especially if it's going to cost more.
I have Cloud and Burberry Her and love them both! Compared them to my sample of BR540 and they def share DNA. I'd love to get the Intense next but I'm worried the amber might remove the sweet fruitiness too much :/
I ordered a sample of BR450 and I'm so confused because.... I just really really don't like it. To me it doesn't smell like hospital at all. And it does smell sweet, but like a rotting sweet, not a true sweet. To me, it smells like yeast, or something sweet that is beginning to go bad... maybe like a bouquet of dying flowers when the stems are getting all moldy and its pungent and sweet. Its soooo confusing to me because the smell taht everyone online and in reviews mentions I don't pick up at all... like at all lol. I keep respraying every few days to see if I'm tripping and I just don't understand the hype, it literally smells like yeast, like a pastry that's wet and has condensation drops in the box and going bad! Does anyone else get this? Am I just going crazy lol
OMG,,,I hope you didn't destroy my love for BR🙈😂🙈 BUT I GET YOU WITH THE BAD PASTERY!!!!!!😝😝😝😝 Never thought of that before but you are right on point.
I adore U ❤ !! I've got B540.... Loved it..... Made my day.....going great.... I ask my son " Hey do u like this smell? " ........ His reply : " U smell like an old lady " ...... 👿 My world went dark...... I've been waiting for a compliment from someone .. Anyone..... Now I know 🤷 ..... Question to anyone out there........ I had everything removed out of me from ( cervix, uterus, tubes, ALL) .... Yup TMI...lol 🙈 All due to cancer..... I do not take hormones ( since 29 years of age after the birth of my son🥰) ...... Back to the point..... Is it that I don't take suppplents or is it a DNA 🧬 Chemistry👨🔬 thing going on?? Anyone out here know?? Gabby?? Anyone?? I can't get a straight answer from a doctor...... Odd huh?? 😤😤😤 please advise and love ur channel Gabby 🔥😍❤💋💯😍🔥❤🥰🌹
Hey I’m a cancer patient too…I’m in remission from a blood cancer. I had a stem cell transplant which put me in complete menopause. I’m on a maintenance chemo so I can’t take any hormones. I can’t hardly smell BR 540 on me at all! It’s so weird. I don’t get compliments either. 🥺
@@Mystified1978 Hey chica my heart ❤ goes out to u 🙏 ... I've not checked this comment section to see if there were more like us... Sadly it's u and I in hopes of finding the answer to this question WE ARE WARRIOR'S 🔥🥰💯 ( if I get a straight answer let me know , if u do let me know ❤💋🙏😊)
when I finally managed to buy her burrbery and happy to the fullest, what do you think could have happened? obviously, on my skin the notes change their smell into something unpleasant. I put it on paper and in the opening I felt how nice it smells and after it dried, I also felt on paper that something on the skin I felt and bothered. I was very disappointed, I really wanted it to work for me too, because I felt that the smell is qualitative, fine and gives that feeling of being expensive when you smell it.
Happens to me with some other fragrances too! If you really like the fragrance then I would advise you to try only spraying it on your clothes before returning / decluttering it. So far works like a charm for me.
I hated Burberry Her so much. To my nose it smelled like really cheap strawberry shampoo. Absolutely zero similarity to BR540 IMO and to my nose. I never understand the comparison. I guess my chemistry really messed that one up. I absolutely love BR540 (mainly the Extrait version), Cloud and Cloud 2.0 and I own them all. I also own Al Haramain's Amber Oud Rouge which is pretty spot-on as far as dupes go. So good.
I've tested Burberry Her and really liked it. I have the original Cloud and I love it. But from the beginning, I can't smell it in myself after the first 5 minutes. I smell it in my clothes the next day. But I want to smell it on myself because it's so good.
Good video. Good advice. I just bought the burberry her for someone special to me, and you're right, it smells banging. BTW I bet 20 sterling pounds you are Romanian. Cãz iu nou wen iu nou 😂 peace!