Bach - Brandenburg Concerto no. 5 in D major BWV 1050a - Sato | Netherlands Bach Society

Подписаться 478 тыс.

Просмотров 95 тыс.

50% 1

In the six 'Brandenburg' Concertos, Bach explores every facet of the genre 'concerto', with regard to both instrumentation and the way in which he handles the form. A concerto nearly always involves a solo instrument (or combination of solo instruments) and an ensemble. The key idea is the alternation between one or more soloists and the whole ensemble, in a sort of light-hearted competition. In this Fifth Concerto, Bach introduces a novelty: the harpsichord as a solo instrument. At first glance, the flute, violin and harpsichord seem equivalent, but then suddenly the harpsichordist takes the lead with a solo cadence at the end of the first movement.
In this performance, an early version of this cadence is played (hence BWV 1050a instead of BWV 1050). This version is shorter than the later version, which we recorded with harpsichordist Richard Egarr: • Bach - Brandenburg Con... . Both versions share some of the same material, that recalls the character of certain youthful fantasias by Bach (such as the Chromatic Fantasia). If the longer version (BWV 1050) compensates for the almost stormy material with a long introduction full of light and a conclusion full of hope, the shorter version (BWV 1050a) has unique passages, such as those dizzying chromatic descending scales, difficult to find in other works by Bach.
Recorded for the project All of Bach on October 2nd 2018 at TivoliVredenburg, Utrecht. If you want to help us complete All of Bach, please subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2vhCeFB and consider donating bit.ly/2uZuMj5.
For the complete performance of the 'Brandenburg' Concerto no. 5 BWV 1050 go to: • Bach - Brandenburg Con...
For the interview with musicians on 'Brandenburg' concertos go to • Musicians on the Brand...
For more information on BWV 1050a and this production go to allofbach.com/en/bwv/bwv-1050-ii/
All of Bach is a project of the Netherlands Bach Society / Nederlandse Bachvereniging, offering high-quality film recordings of the works by Johann Sebastian Bach, performed by the Netherlands Bach Society and its guest musicians. Visit our free online treasury for more videos and background material www.bachvereniging.nl/en/allo.... For concert dates and further information go to www.bachvereniging.nl/nederla....
Netherlands Bach Society
Shunske Sato, violin and direction
Marten Root, traverso
Diego Ares, harpsichord
0:00 Allegro
8:12 Adagio (affettuoso)
13:25 Allegro

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

8 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 160

@sundayoliver3147 8 дней назад

The beautiful facility of all these players makes the Brandenburgs (I've known them all my life) new to me.

@dr.utekarasch-stingl8443 2 года назад

Lebensfreude,Energie,Leichtigkeit,großes Können und Virtuosität. Danke

@dr.utekarasch-stingl8443 8 дней назад

Noch einmal Danke für diese Freude

@AndrewHewing 2 года назад

I first fell under the spell of the Brandenburg Concertos nearly 60 years ago! This wonderful performance still has me spellbound. Thank you.

@jamallabarge2665 Год назад

My parents bought "Switched on Bach" when it came out. I was a toddler at the time. As a child I loved the sound effects.... Something happened along the way. The music stuck around, and never left me. Even today it has a haunting presence in my life.

@Vitali_Osandor Год назад

Good to know I'll probably still enjoy them when I'll be older. Thank you. 🙂 And all the best to you.

@grahaml3449 2 года назад

Those who claim that this piece is "just as good" with a larger ensemble and modern instruments, should simply listen to this one. The music sings out in a way often lost in larger groups. Minimal instrumentation allows Bach himself to be the centre of attention. That said, of course even modern interpretations of this sublime work are enjoyable, but this one is superb. Now about the cadenzas, long vs short -- let's leave that for another day!

@jgunther3398 2 года назад

it's all good. some of my favorite bach is casals and the marlboro festival orchestra, which brings a lot of magic out that's usually overlooked, which i assume was symphony orchestra size.

@johnzielinski9951 Год назад

Agreed. It has a wonderful lightness of being in it's original instrumentation.

@herrickinman9303 Год назад

What is commonly called "the cadenza" is actually a _capriccio,_ not a cadenza.

@kellynch 2 года назад

#5 is my favorite of the Brandenbergs. No matter how often I hear it, I need to hear it again.

@randomoneforstuff3696 2 года назад

It’s the same for me, but with #4.

@erikafrasch9956 2 года назад

Its exactly the same with me

@ChrisThorpe4508 2 года назад

Thoroughly enjoyed this concert - thank you. It reminded me of my visit to Bach's grave in 2013 at St Thomas Kiche in Leipzig. Bach died thinking he would be forgotten, but thanks to the invention of the printing press and the enthusiasm with which musicians embraced his music his memory was revived with a passion.

@jamallabarge2665 Год назад

"Bach died thinking he would be forgotten, but thanks to the invention of the printing press and the enthusiasm with which musicians embraced his music his memory was revived with a passion." Forgive me... but there is just a bit more..... his Students. Long after Bach passed on his students were teaching people. Among his students? His sons. KPE Bach referred to him, sometimes, as "The old wig". Other times he admitted, "I never had another teacher in composition than my late Father. "

@HarpsichordHymnsTimRemington 2 года назад

Bach's 5th Brandenburg Concerto is my favorite composition ever written. This is a wonderful fresh performance. Thanks for playing and sharing this!

@philipaggesen 2 года назад

Wonderful wonderful wonderful. Played with grace and musicality. And a LONG cadenza in the first movement. I LIKE! 👍🏻

@bach 2 года назад

This cadenza is indeed an earlier, shorter version than the final version, which we recorded in this performance: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-LHjbRMIIhuM.html

@helenphillips2051 2 года назад

Bach Society

@helenphillips2051 2 года назад

Bach Society

@helenphillips2051 2 года назад

Bach Society

@jihanjoo 2 года назад

Everything in black and white except for their colorized shirts and blouses! Now that is cool!

@eventme 2 года назад

Absolutely outstanding performance. I love the flutist. And of course Bach, the king of kings

@annefrancoisepolonini6982 2 года назад

J'écoutais sans arrêt ce Concerto à tel point que j'ai fait travailler mon violon..... C'est un des souvenirs les plus forts que j'ai. On ne peut pas s'imaginer dans la tête d'une adolescente ce que cela peut avoir comme répercussion. Bach nous " travaille" idem pour l'orgue.

@cathykroll8433 Год назад

Exquisite, joyous music performed by truly inspired musicians! You continually lift our spirits! Thank you!

@katbullar 2 года назад

Perfection with a highlight for the cadenza that is exquisite! Love it!!!

@jimbuck795 2 года назад

Another gem from the NBS.

@Darkboy2525 2 года назад

This is such a gem of a treasure. I just felt in love with the harpsichord his solo. Sato is always the star, but in this performance, they all took their shining moment. LOVE how Bach makes all instruments have a solo moment. Such grace.

@bobsteiner9209 Год назад

Bach is the most democratic and egalitarian of composers. Studying the Well Tempered Clavier, we see how every musical line and every note has its place, contributing to the whole, shining at moments, then receding into the background so someone else can shine.

@Darkboy2525 Год назад

@@bobsteiner9209 Yes !! You are absolutely right, I have had the pleasure to have played piano for over 10 years, sadly I stopped for a long period, but Bach was by FAR the most interesting to play, his nuances in voices are so beautiful and mind breaking when practicing ! Bach is something else, he is truly my all time favorite. Thanks for your message man, you are totally right !! Happy you enjoy Bach that way ^^ so many folks just listen but don't know what is going on, the superp brilliance of Bach.

@hiw9528 7 месяцев назад

Yes, I agree. I am very fond of most of the Sato interpretations. And when I heard Diego Ares playing the Goldberg variations ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-oqaCEzAaXq4.html he became my favourite harpsichordist. For me it is the non-plus-ultra interpretation of the Goldberg variations. A sensitive and powerful playing. On a Ruckers instrument!

@sundayoliver3147 8 дней назад

@@bobsteiner9209 When I was studying cello, my teacher gave me this assignment on one of the Bach sonatas: go into each measure separately, and find out where the phrase is coming from and going to. A practice that brought so much musical and other understanding. I'm not sure you could do this with other composers, and I have sung and played a lot of them.

@FabledFrame 2 года назад

Bravo! Thank you for lifting my spirits.

@xavi2803 2 года назад

Very creative harpsichordist

@bach 2 года назад

*Additional note: In this performance, an early version of the harpsichord cadence is played (hence BWV 1050a instead of BWV 1050). This version is shorter than the final version, which we recorded with harpsichordist Richard Egarr: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-LHjbRMIIhuM.html 0:07 Allegro 8:12 Adagio (affettuoso) 13:25 Allegro

@mahmoudtarek9921 2 года назад

You have already uploaded the work What is the philosophy Of repeating the work??? You have no other recordings to purplish????.

@TheSummoner 2 года назад

@@mahmoudtarek9921 Entitled much? This audio/video is from a different concert.

@mahmoudtarek9921 2 года назад

But the work had already been published! what is the benefit?

@TheSummoner 2 года назад

@@mahmoudtarek9921 To have two different versions? The Netherlands Bach Society doesn't entirely revolve around the All of Bach project, they make concerts and maybe they found the recording of this one to be good enough to be published even if it has already been. Plus it is free.

@mahmoudtarek9921 2 года назад

they could have publish it in another day But not on Thursday, the day for the new recordings

@lenanielsen5903 2 года назад

Absolutely wonderful performance thank you NBS🍃

@ariadne4720 2 года назад

what a wonderful surprise to see this uploaded - you made my day NBS! Thank you, as usual, a superb performance

@MegaFount 2 года назад

Exquisite! Stimulating the little gray cells in the most pleasing manner. Thank you for your incredible performance as always!

@agnesgrey4799 2 года назад

Once again, Netherlands Bach Society prepared me magnificent performance of the beautiful Allegro of my beloved Johann. Thank you so much NBC 🎵🙂🎶

@KhalidTemawi 2 года назад

Probably this is the first keyboard concerto ever! Bach wrote the music for the future.

@MrBouguenec 2 года назад

You are righr, this is the first keyboard concerto, and the first cadenza written for keyboard, the harpsichord alternating the role of continuo and soloist. What a genius !

@KhalidTemawi 2 года назад

@@MrBouguenec 👍🏼

@antonellabaluganti8109 2 года назад

Non ho parole da come è meravigliosa questa sinfonia

@BelCantoization 2 года назад

Magnificent! A wonderful gift to the world that demonstrates in compelling fashion the timelessness of Bach. For me, I take pleasure in knowing that I was born in the same century in which, say, Copland, Rachmaninoff, and Gershwin lived. But it is a source of unending pride that I even belong to the same species as J. S. Bach.

@Rudi_F_Vienna 2 года назад

What a joy to hear! NBS never ever disappoints me.

@ZaWakingEagle 2 года назад

I love everything you guys produce. Thank you for sharing your hard work with the world

@josecubela9642 Год назад

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ BRAVO!!

@klausvinkelau8573 2 года назад

Thank you for this wonderful recording 👍I like the interpretation very much🍀

@lluisrafalessole-classical5068 2 года назад

Wow Spectacular Bravo 🎹🎶👏

@antonellamoles7234 2 года назад

Elegante, vivace ed affettuosa interpretazione, anche le cadenze sono naturalmente appropiate e originali! Grazie ☀️ veramente una bellissima esecuzione! 💞🎉

@dwergarend1 2 года назад

We heard the Nederlandse Bachvereniging with Diego Ares with this concerto in Enschede (The Netherlands) before Corona. It was an amazing evening. I don't remember them playing this alternate version. Shame, shame, I usely remember these kind of things very well. Anaway thank you very much for sharing this fascinating piece of music. This is definitely one of my favorite pieces, the Nederlandse Bachvereniging my favorite company and Diego Ares joined my list of favorite performers.

@skoromoh_ 7 месяцев назад

6:36 amazing performance cadenza... I am glad with it. . 161123

@scottwexlin6456 2 года назад

Impeccable performance, as always.

@MG-fh4ed 5 месяцев назад

Perfection.

@SantiagoKodela 2 года назад

Excellent as always. What a channel!

@bobh5087 2 года назад

Superb, as always ! 👍❤️

@sandraminnich1502 2 года назад

Awesome; one of my Bach favorites!

@w.p.958 2 года назад

Very well done! Best that I have heard in a long time!!!

@kathrynschenk7432 2 года назад

It's good to remember that Bach occasionally edited himself. Fortunately, we need not choose between versions! We loved the Egarr performance too.

@immabinnie2052 2 года назад

Absolutely sparkling! Love it!

@blumenlieder 2 года назад

Que linda linda interpretação! Amo esse flautista 😍❣️❣️

@kencory2476 2 года назад

Love the spot colour on the flautist's shirt.

@sharamoore5554 2 года назад

Wonderful!

@hiw9528 7 месяцев назад

This is probably my favourite of the Brandenburg Concertos. I have certainly beautiful interpretation of the Brandenburg Concertos with Gustav Leonhardt on CD but somehow ... I always turn back to the NBS interpretations. Also regarding other Bach music the NBS interpretations are more and more my preferred ones. Thank you. I ofthen think it would be great to have this also (offline) on CDs.

@SuddenUpdraft 2 года назад

How sublime it would be to be this talented and able to play this piece with other musicians.

@lostsparrowshack 2 года назад

Sublime for sure

@jeffreyhirschfeld7761 2 года назад

Best version using period instruments. I like Richter’s and Paillard best. The cadenza should have used Bach ‘s version.

@herrickinman9303 Год назад

@@jeffreyhirschfeld7761 You don't know what you're talking around. Both versions of the cadenza, i.e., the cadenza in BWV 1050a and the cadenza in BWV 1050, are by Bach! The harpsichordist in this performance of BWV 1050a took considerable liberties with the cadenza's tempo, presumably to make it sound more improvisatory.

@francoisedhoossche3856 Год назад

The best for Bach !!!!❤

@Papeeloo1 2 года назад

As it is not my favorite of the six concerti (I like the 6th the most) it is the most popular along with the 3rd. However this performance of BWV 1050a is a jewel. The second mov. so delicately performed is definitely what makes this concerto such a master piece. Thank you NBS

@HenrikBergpianorganist Год назад

Ah, yes, no. 6❤

@joshmusic7748 2 года назад

Bravo!we are very happy to see all of you again..........

@notaire2 2 года назад

Wunderschöne und lebhafte Aufführung dieses perfekt komponierten Konzerts mit seidigem doch gut phrasiertem Ton der Solovioline, mildem Ton der Solobarockflöte und schimmerndem Klang des Cembalos sowie gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechneden Tönen der anderen Originalinstrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt echt schön und auch lyrisch. Der intelligente und geniale Violinist/Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Barockensemble in verschiedenen Tempi und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wunderbar vom Anfang bis zum Ende!

@user-de2yw7dk2e 2 года назад

bravo !!!!!

@biberfan 2 года назад

I went on a screed the other day about how it’d be more HIPP to record an authentic cadenza the performer develops than to always play the one by Bach…. Thank you, you did not disappoint and love the continual high quality of videography. The glances between musicians indicate you know you’re making some of the happiest music.

@ru99414 2 года назад

The cadence is just an earlier written version though so they didn't really make a new one. Just out from what I understand from their Additional note in the comments. But yes i would agree most historical informed performances wouldn't disregard the performers playing their own, and it might be something that will become more a thing over time, as historical informed means for some just to simply play the music on the historical correct instrument

@Rik77 2 года назад

@@ru99414 not sure about that in this case. It might a fun experiment but honestly one of the big features of this work (and its later final version) is the extraordinary cadenza that bach deliberately composed, not as a suggestion. Its flows out from the material preceding it and is fully integrated into the work. He usually has written out cadenzas in his concerti, but usually they are accompanied by the orchestra and not as long as this. But this one is quite unique and deliberate. I think I'd be dissapointed if I went to a concert and the performer stripped this out.

@ru99414 2 года назад

@@Rik77 yeah for my taste i would feel the same. Today the gap between performer and composer is so big that i wouldn't find it necessary. It's just a historical thing where a performers own cadenza would be what shaped or showcase their virtuoso abilities, but i think that was more around Mozart's time than the baroque, I'm not too sure, but it's certainly a part that might be better left as it is, when the composer actually left his own marks of it

@herrickinman9303 Год назад

You mean HIP, not "HIPP." HIP stands for "historically informed performance." "Cadenza" is a misnomer. What's constantly referred to as "the cadenza" of this concerto is actually a _capriccio,_ not a cadenza.

@herrickinman9303 Год назад

@@ru99414 Where they wrote "cadence" in the video notes, they really meant _cadenza._ But what's constantly referred to as "the cadenza" of this concerto is actually a capriccio, not a cadenza.

@Yair_Avidor 2 года назад

wonderful playing!

@skoromoh_ 2 года назад

Thanks for video. It's excellent performance Concert in D. I live it. BWV ! Bach is for ages...

@faha24 2 года назад

Danke!

@1974gringojuan 2 года назад

Луч чистого света в жутком нынешнем мире горя и смерти. Спасибо за потрясающее исполнение! A ray of pure light in a terrible modern world of grief and death. Thank you for this stunning performance! Bravi!

@ALEJANDROFERNANDEZ-in1vz 2 года назад

❤

@rf8640 2 года назад

Nicely desaturated video, the music speaks for itself as ever

@elena_l3373 2 года назад

Какое прекрасное исполнение, спасибо! Thanks for so beautiful performing!

@akkoishida9182 2 года назад

いつもすてきな演奏をありがとうございます 2019年9月京都バロックザール青山音楽記念館の演奏会に行きました　コロナ禍が収まりまた皆さんの演奏会に行くことができる日を楽しみにしています

@tjittekamminga5170 2 года назад

wow!!!

@therealzilch 2 года назад

Großartig wie üblich. Bedankt uit Wenen, Scott

@haidark9036 Год назад

Sublime performance

@goscott444 2 года назад

Very fine performance of this classic! GOD bless NBS in the name of Jesus!🥰😍🤩

@user-gp3fw6pt6e 2 года назад

我喜歡這位小提琴家和大鍵琴家！❤️

@jayneterry8701 2 года назад

2022 May loved it , gorgeous.

@litoboy5 2 года назад

great

@noodlemaniskorean 2 года назад

바흐의 브란덴부르크 작품의 맛이 깊고 그윽하게 이들에 의해서 표현되고 있다. 감상하는데 감성이 증폭된다.

@sarupyon 2 года назад

素晴らしい！

@brandonlongwell9583 2 месяца назад

Yes! Can you do please Bach - Brandenburg Concerto #4 in G Major, BWV 1049 - Sato.

@starnafin Год назад

A rather reticent flautist in what is a joyous piece.

@HaritheRenaissanceMan 2 года назад

Netherlands Bach Society, great upload, but PLEASE update your title and description. Some commentators on here are confused as to why you have two versions of the same piece, or they think this is a corrupt arrangement of the original. Please update your description so that it states BWV 1050a, not BWV 1050, and that this was Bach's first draft, which is why the harpsichord cadenza is not as long and why there may be other minor changes elsewhere. Thank you.

@bach 2 года назад

Done. Thanks for the tip!

@annoyingbrit5233 2 года назад

Interesting, this actually sounds lovely in C Major. It has a different mood but it sounds almost more well-spoken

@herrickinman9303 Год назад

It's absurd to speak of the key in which a piece is performed as if everyone is required to use a=440Hz as a reference pitch. 1) The so-called concert pitch (a=440Hz) that you use as your reference pitch didn't become a pitch standard until the 1950s, and then only after decades of lobbying by American wind instrument manufacturers. 2) No one is born with ears tuned to concert pitch. 3) I say "a pitch standard" because concert pitch is not the only pitch standard in use today. Some philharmonics tune higher than a=440Hz. Today's period instrument ensembles tune to the pitch standard appropriate to the period, which can be higher or lower than a=440Hz. 4) Wind instruments in Bach's time were designed to be tuned to chamber pitch (a half step below A440) or French chamber pitch (a whole step below A440). 5) The Baroque flute in this ensemble cannot be tuned to A440. 6) The entire ensemble is tuned to French chamber pitch because that was the pitch standard used in German courts in Bach's time. 7) This concerto was composed for and performed by the musicians at the German court of Prince Leopold of Anhalt-Koethen, when Bach was his Kapellmeister (1717-1723). 8) The piece in this video was performed in D major, not C major, at French chamber pitch, as opposed to D major at concert pitch.

@robertwinfieldstabler7697 2 года назад

Amazing performance as always! :-) Just how long do you expect this one project will take?

@RWAS073 2 года назад

Two remarks on this superb performance. I don't quite like the sound of the harpsichord. Reminded me of Ralph Kirkpatrick recordings from the 1960s en 1970s. Secondly, this alternative harpsichord cadenza (which I've never heard before) amazed me. Especially the chromatic phrases, which reminded me of Franz List...

@samueldykes6516 Год назад

Because the first bit is almost exactly 20 seconds I wash my hands to this music!

@JeSerra 2 года назад

♥️♥️

@yaroslav_kaiuk 2 года назад

06:32 - harpsichord solo (arranged)

@tobiasstudtheol 2 года назад

Yes, Diego Ares "slightly" variated the cadenza but that doesn't change the fact that he played it brilliantly.

@MiScusi69 2 года назад

Wait, it still wasn't on the channel?

@VideoFunForAll 2 года назад

Hmm..... what intonation/tuning is used here?

@bach 2 года назад

Pitch is A=400 Hertz

@davidriggenbach6672 Год назад

I know there are several versions of this concerto, but is this cadenza an original from one of those versions? Or the harpsichordist changed it?

@DouglasAmrine 2 года назад

Really nice performance. But it seems like someone forgot to explain to the cameraman and video editor that this is a TRIPLE concerto. The harpsichord is equal to the flute and violin! We don't even see the harpsichordist's face until almost 4.00 in. Very very strange film-making.

@Rik77 2 года назад

In a way I like that, because the way bach has written the piece, the harpsichord slowly emerges out from the texture over the course of the 1st movement. If you weren't aware its a triple concerto you might not realise until a few mins in compositional. You might just think the continuo player was just doing a lot of ott improvisation over the bassline for a while.

@kiera7455 2 года назад

I feel like the tempos are all over the place in the 2nd mvmt? The group and the 1st flute player are not in agreement throughout. Otherwise absolutely lovely and a favorite for sure!!!

@user-ow2lx5fk3p 2 года назад

This is BWV1050a, not 1050.

@HaritheRenaissanceMan 2 года назад

Correct. This needs to be put in the captions.

@ajnasreddin 2 года назад

I would love to be able to buy these recordings on Bandcamp...

@SilvioNobre 2 года назад

Lush!

@arturkuznecov154 2 года назад

Тише ... Bach звучит !

@antismatic 2 года назад

why the color filter?

@christianlecomtemedia 2 года назад

No need to colour-filter this beautiful music and interpretation

@andreamundt 2 года назад

Why not?

@Symphing12 2 года назад

Probably just to see how it would look, honestly

@kopik3229 2 года назад

Торжественно, празднично, прекрасно. Яркий пример современной интерпретации NBS концерта Баха. Ненаслушаться!

@carlobaroncini949 2 года назад

It is quite difficult to hear the flute

@haisheauspforte1632 2 года назад

I can hear it very clearly, maybe different depending on headphones etc

@TheSoteriologist 2 года назад

I wish I wouldn't have heard it.

@TheSoteriologist 2 года назад

@@declamatory See my own OP, haha.

@TheSoteriologist 2 года назад

@@declamatory Why are you hitting the reply button to me when talking to yourself ?

@lostsparrowshack 2 года назад

They voted this one in real fast

@b.d.r.4868 2 года назад

Are these guys high or something?

@Barbapippo 2 года назад

Someone should explain to the harpsichordist that writing a "new" cadenza does not mean copying/abridging the original one.

@momentosmusicales6245 Год назад

Perhaps YOU should have explained to Johann Sebastian Bach himself that writing a "new" cadenza does not mean copying/extending the original one.

@Barbapippo Год назад

In fact, I had not read the description of the video, which explains everything (and also explains why Bach decided to write a second, much better cadenza).

@anhal9353 2 года назад

Unfortunately the sound engineering is very bad, similar to the recording of Brandenburg Con. 2, which I assume was recorded in the same setting (or done by the same engineers) :/ It's very sad, that the sound quality is not same as in your other recordings, which are great!! The musicians are of course doing a great job! But the sound engineering is really really bad!

@sundayoliver3147 8 дней назад

Not my experience. I'm pretty picky. about sound, but ears vary.

@daniel3231995 Год назад

This just has way too many unnecessary close-ups.

@TheSoteriologist 2 года назад

I think they have to get another flutist. But more generally I found this to be a bit underwhelming. Seems I am pretty alone in this regard here for whatever reason.

@tamerlano 2 года назад

no, I agree. There were ensemble problems in the first movement. Almost like they couldn't hear each other. They struggled when they got finicky with rhythm...just play it!

@Rik77 2 года назад

I think he's fine, but in the first movement he's not as engaging as the strings and charscyises the themes very differently to the violinist. But I think that's a musical choice. But I do understand what you mean. This wasn't a sparkly energetic flute performance, but thats partly a musical choice. Not my preference though.