Тёмный

Barbie Ushers in World Communism 

Marxism Today
Подписаться 79 тыс.
Просмотров 40 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

16 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 367   
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Enjoy this? Support the Marxism Today media co-op on Patreon: www.patreon.com/MarxismToday These videos wouldn’t be possible without your incredibly generous support!
@austinobambino1360
@austinobambino1360 Год назад
It's Joever, Capitalism.
@Simonjose7258
@Simonjose7258 Год назад
I Googled "Joever" 😅✌🏼
@sasho_b.
@sasho_b. Год назад
Joe Bidenism-Leninism
@projectpitchfork860
@projectpitchfork860 Год назад
​@@sasho_b.God damn, don't you dare insult Lenin like that.
@nanashi420
@nanashi420 Год назад
I'm Bidone
@joshmorcombe4907
@joshmorcombe4907 Год назад
KENpitalism
@Jonnie1905Boom
@Jonnie1905Boom Год назад
I am a novice communist, that is to say, I am fairly new to communism and have only read few essential books. When I saw this movie, I could immediately tell that it is a liberal feminist movie but couldn't give a coherent explanation for it. This video both affirmed and cleared my views on this movie. Huge thanks to Marxism Today :)
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Happy to help :)
@canyildiz5966
@canyildiz5966 Год назад
Can i give u some personal advice, friend? Read the essential texts, emerse yourself in the existing literature and learn what it has meant to be a Marxist and revolutionary in the past. Then, once you have done that, abandon the texts. Do not become dogmatic as mamy do and yet claim not to be. Abandon the texts and be guided by your intuition. Return to them when u see fit, as an experienced, well-meaning and thoughtful revolutionary. But never rely on them. History is capricious. We must be diligent and forgiving in our analysis✊🏼
@tsumugijohnson3220
@tsumugijohnson3220 Год назад
​@@canyildiz5966I think the teal advice to someone that's already reading is "join an organization" tbh. Just reading gets us nowhere
@manuellanthaler2001
@manuellanthaler2001 Год назад
@@canyildiz5966 hah yes so important. lot of people get addicted to them and really become dogmatic or whatever. Thats why the most important marx quote is: Philosophers have pointed out... and so on you know what.
@Shot5hells
@Shot5hells Год назад
@@canyildiz5966I sympathise with this considering all the hostility between so many different tendencies over things that happened in a different country 60 years ago and that has no immediate relevance to whatever we could be doing here. Like, there’s so much bickering about modern China, but honestly I don’t see how it matters; we should be looking at our conditions and making decisions in the here and now, and aiming to forge our own path best suited to this place, not arguing about somewhere (and somewhen) totally different. It’s not about supporting or not supporting an array of countries, leaders, revolutions etc, it’s about learning from them what’s applicable to our path and then doing. And whatever is not of major and current relevance shouldn’t be allowed to divide us needlessly.
@josemaria8177
@josemaria8177 Год назад
Did I watch Barbie? No Do I want to watch Barbie? No Am I going to watch a 40 minute marxist deconstruction of Barbie? More than once
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187 Год назад
🤭
@sentientnatalie
@sentientnatalie Год назад
Absolutely!
@sentientnatalie
@sentientnatalie Год назад
@@Ivan-bw6iw Liberal idpol, deliberately lacking the class lynchpin required for true liberation.
@rb5519
@rb5519 Год назад
Same! 😂
@bhhaaaal
@bhhaaaal 5 месяцев назад
🙂‍↔️🤝
@duccsy2058
@duccsy2058 Год назад
Can't wait for barbie 2 where they tackle the issues of landlords
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Barbie Maoism incoming 🫡
@Matthew.E.Kelly.
@Matthew.E.Kelly. Год назад
Landlord Barbie charges all of her fashion & accessories to a Kohl's credit card then raises the rent on her tenants to pay it off 😭 Then she uses her Kohl's Cash to buy clearance espresso machines, air fryers, & waffle makers that she gives to relatives for Christmas 😭😭😭🤦🤦🤦
@maya07_11
@maya07_11 Год назад
Barbie the great leap forward
@GG10010
@GG10010 Год назад
You don't need a sequel for that which is perfect
@nanashi420
@nanashi420 Год назад
I don't think I've ever heard something as cool as "fully automated luxury gay space communism."
@Superior-Brick
@Superior-Brick Год назад
Average r/CommunismMemes flair My favorite is definitely kgb ball licker And For the noog Source (r/TheDeprogram)
@nanashi420
@nanashi420 Год назад
@@Superior-Brick fuck man, I need to use communist reddit more often. I too am a great fan of the noog 🙏🏽
@Superior-Brick
@Superior-Brick Год назад
@nanashi420 True, r/TheDeprogram and r/CommunismMemes are one of the best communist subs , especially for theory.
@XS-03_Apollo
@XS-03_Apollo Год назад
@@Superior-BrickI’ve heard of r/TheDeprogram. Hakim seems to be quite fond of it lol
@Shot5hells
@Shot5hells Год назад
⁠@@Superior-Brickehh, I think it’s a bit mixed in the deprogram but I definitely run into a lot of good leads there. Definitely as far as reddit goes, the deprogram is pretty good, but real learning comes from reading and analysing and organising with people close to you. That said, the podcast let the genie out of the bottle for me and basically made me a communist. I also love the memes.
@grady7420
@grady7420 Год назад
I liked how fragile the Ken's were when the Barbies fought back. While it was exaggerated, this part of the movie made a good point about how insecure men really are and how they try to cover it up by appearing tough and dominant.
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187 Год назад
True :)
@gabrieldavis7128
@gabrieldavis7128 Год назад
Exactly. Most men are merely flesh cretins that are easily disposable. It’s disgusting that the drone species has somehow tricked the world into thinking that it deserves control over it.
@kzisnbkosplay3346
@kzisnbkosplay3346 Год назад
Can't exactly count on capitalists to accurately represent anti capitalism can we? It seems to me, without watching the movie yet, that it is a way to capitalize on the current wave of anti capitalist sentiment while at the same time, controlling it. If they can lead baby leftists to fight only the obvious signs of patriarchy instead of the capitalist root of the problem, then they get off scott free and get to continue business as usual. It's a sign that they are scared.
@VicStrange9
@VicStrange9 Год назад
No, its not a sign of fear. Its them knowing they can marketize everything, including those feelings. Like selling a t-shirt with the face of Che Guevara, or using the gay flag on a particular month. And people keep buying. Much to everyone's dismay, a movie wont change much, neither will a thousand youtube channels, unless the people watching them do things in the real world, which seems to be way harder.
@iateyursandwiches
@iateyursandwiches Год назад
@KairoStark , I think most members if the LGBT community aren't stupid enough to fall the the pride month bait by corporations and at very least see it for what it is: a disingenuous attempt of reaching a wider customer base that may also have the benefit of sometimes helping LGTB organizations with donations from the sales.
@jacob6672
@jacob6672 Год назад
Inshallah may the cadres wear pink as chairwoman Barbie did when she smashed the status quo 🎉
@dftp
@dftp Год назад
Mašala, chairwoman Barbie knows what's best for you, comrade!
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187 Год назад
Pink is the new red!!
@JohnLemieux
@JohnLemieux Год назад
I’m a materialist girl living in a materialist world.
@stookful
@stookful Год назад
I'm a dialectical materialist living in a dialectical materialist world.
@thoughtful1233
@thoughtful1233 Год назад
Dang, I didn't even notice Barbie presenting nationalization of industries as the definition of fascism 😬
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
It was a sneaky distortion to slip in there! Disappointing. You'd expect that kind of thing from a Margaret Thatcher-style neolib. Didn't expect in this film
@kerishaw8991
@kerishaw8991 Год назад
Big same. I laughed on queue 🤣 😅😮
@sentientnatalie
@sentientnatalie Год назад
Which is hilarious, considering that fascists privatised way more than they nationalised, they limited their nationalisation to anything related to their war efforts (fascists love wars of conquest), so ofc there was some interventionism. A fascist government and corporations operating within fascism won't necessarily have the same specific goals, except largely economic ones.
@sentientnatalie
@sentientnatalie Год назад
@@Marxism_Today I feel it also plays into the "muh totalitarianism!" horseshit theory. Not at all surprisingly, fascists favour privatisation over interventionism, and what interventionism they do prefer has more to do with cementing the basis of wars of conquest they've got planned in their FIFA-style war rooms, none of this really compromises the private nature of *ownership* which corporations under fascism still enjoy and the profit they derive from that ownership. The Nazi policy of reversing WWI nationalisation efforts was called "Reprivatisierung", meaning "Reprivatisation", which suggests that they were nationalised at some point but not to help the masses. I also agree that liberal "democracy" is preferable to fascist dictatorship, though it is only bourgeois democracy, I used quotes because it's not really democracy for the rest of us, since hardly anyone we get to vote for (we do not choose who get to be candidates) actually serves our interests beyond, at best, the occasional breadcrumb.
@yuchitairans2-035
@yuchitairans2-035 Год назад
Yea privatisation of public assets is the defining characteristic of fascism
@ramenbomberdeluxe4958
@ramenbomberdeluxe4958 Год назад
For anyone who may be concerned by the ending of Barbie being a slap in the face to what it was trying to preach, bear in mind that it was meant to simulate the situation we have in real life; progress was made on gender equality, but it didnt become perfect overnight. Its not saying that matriarchy is okay but patriarchy isnt, its supposed to mirror a sad, warped situation where the Kens only had mild progress in Barbieland, mirroring real life. There's still lots of work to be done because while women do have it better than ever in some cases, they're still struggling in places, and conservatives are fighting more viciously than ever before to roll back the progress we've made. In short, the movie had one last poignant message, and it didnt just throw away its desire for gender equality.
@ramenbomberdeluxe4958
@ramenbomberdeluxe4958 Год назад
Hell, the narrator openly states that progress would come over time, so it even goes out of its way to emphasize that the Kens werent even stuck in their roles, much like how women in real life werent stuck in that same spot forever, and that we have moved forward with time.
@vincefitzpatrick9206
@vincefitzpatrick9206 Год назад
I'm a little conflicted about this one because I think it's a good example of the movie's tonal dissonance at times. It is sick and twisted that women were straight up excluded from any power for a long time, and that even after several waves of feminism and increase representation in major institutions progress has been slow. But this scene doesn't make President Barbie out to look sick and twisted; if anything it makes her look prudent, because the Kens were so irresponsible and dangerous when they had power, so they're obviously not ready to share it. Then the narrator's line implies that this is actually the opposite of the intended interpretation. That's because, in this movie, Kens are simultaneously the analogue of real world women AND avatars of real world toxic masculinity and patriarchy. Both of those choices individually are great ways to satirize patriarchy, but when you do both of them at the same time sometimes the message gets muddled a bit, and you have to resort to showing one (haha of course President Barbie can't let these dummies have too much power, they nearly destroyed everything!) and telling the other (haha of course it's wrong to not allow for gender equality - just like with women in the real world), and hope people will just interpret the scene according to whichever one best resolves the dissonance for them.
@jamesn3122
@jamesn3122 Год назад
​@@vincefitzpatrick9206analogies are tricky, we see this all the time. Like when fantasy movies use orcs or aliens or whatever as an analog for racism. But simultaneously they make the orcs or w/e inherently violent or somehow irrevocably different. So they try to do a "racism is bad" message while making essentially racial stereotypes just true in their world
@gabrieldavis7128
@gabrieldavis7128 Год назад
Great. For a second I thought the movie was based.
@genericytprofile852
@genericytprofile852 Год назад
I saw the headlines spout that barbie was "woke, feminist, communist propaganda" and I was like, "Damn dude, they ain't even paying you to advertise but yet here you are selling this to me."
@georgeni5963
@georgeni5963 Год назад
i was dead laughing when Anna had that mental breakdown at 22:32. It was such a real feeling as a marxist i feel this way so often ;p
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187 Год назад
😭IM GLAD YOU RELATE
@ComradeAurelian
@ComradeAurelian Год назад
I really like the idea of movie reviews from a ML and MLM perspective, I think a similar video for Oppenheimer would be wonderful!
@uhohhotdog
@uhohhotdog Год назад
Yes. I think a channel dedicated to just that would be a great idea.
@Reed5016
@Reed5016 Год назад
@uhohhotdog I’m considering making a channel like that, except with novels, comics, and manga.
@Somebodyherefornow
@Somebodyherefornow Год назад
WHAT IS THE MEN LOVING MEN PERSPECTIVE
@georgekostaras
@georgekostaras Год назад
I mean, we could totally make a bootleg barbie who's a revolutionary. She can come with accessories like a Kalashnikov and a guillotine
@JamesConollyLives5353
@JamesConollyLives5353 Год назад
Maoist (NPA) Barbie Red Army Barbie Pan-Africanist Barbie NVA Barbie Red Guard Barbie M-26-7 Barbie Union Organiser Barbie Irish Republican Barbie What else?
@arthurvu-van8685
@arthurvu-van8685 Год назад
Antifa Barbie Peshmergha Barbie Viet Minh Barbie Spanish Republican Barbie Zapatista Barbie Black Panther Barbie Partisan Barbie (WW2) Student Organizer Barbie Cuban Doctor Barbie
@georgekostaras
@georgekostaras Год назад
@@arthurvu-van8685 Okay I love the idea of Viet Minh Barbie
@CordeliaAurora
@CordeliaAurora Год назад
​​@@georgekostaras Palestinian barbie with a Hijab, toy missile launcher made from scrap, and instead of a Barbie house she has a small tunnel system that goes under a settler colony (her original house was destroyed by colonizers and can be bought separately). Ken has a Kaffiyeh and a stolen M16 🇵🇸
@robynology101
@robynology101 Год назад
I read Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s essay “We should all be Feminists” right after watching Barbie. The timing was perfect. I will definitely have to read Anuradha Ghandy’s book next!
@WhoOneIs
@WhoOneIs Год назад
The sequel needs to be about the Barbie National Liberation Army, with Barbie taking a leaf out of Anuradha Ghandy’s book ‘Scripting the Change’.
@jeffemshoff103
@jeffemshoff103 Год назад
Everything should be seen through a proletarian feminist lens
@kylezo
@kylezo Год назад
yea it's one of those things where the words shouldn't be necessary to simply say "just and fair", but in the overwhelmingly normalized context of patriarchal colonial classist society, you have to use all these extra words simply to describe a neutral non-oppressive framework. it's one of the more insidious complications of normalized oppression, kind of like how misinformation and lies travel so much faster than truth because it takes 100x more energy and words to put out a hundred small fires than to start them with a single sentence
@insane_troll
@insane_troll Год назад
I'd try it with astrophotography but I'm not sure how to attach it to my camera.
@thetinygangsta6252
@thetinygangsta6252 Год назад
Barbietariat of the world unite!✊ Great video comrade Paul and comrade Anna!
@sannir807
@sannir807 Год назад
the movie was strongest when it focused on womanhood through the individual experience and weakest when it tried to make broad political statements. when your movie is funded by mattel any political message will inevitably be lukewarm
@marcusnguginganga2829
@marcusnguginganga2829 Год назад
Awesome video. I especially agreed with Anna's criticisms of the film. Her statement on the Barbieland government being the US government in pink, reminded me they basically had a version of the Mount Rushmore monument with Barbies that was replaced with horses when the Kens took over. So does that mean that, there were some Native American Barbies that were removed from their ancestral land?? A lot of the positives you guys mentioned I didn't really notice because I'm new to stuff but the one that definitely hit home was Barbie having the feeling of being ogled at and objectified by men in the real world. Sasha was a huge positive for the movie as well. I did enjoy it. Awesome video, I've learnt a lot. Thanks
@RedYellowBird6889
@RedYellowBird6889 Год назад
*Sees Title* Man, if only then, life would actually be something to look forward to for once regardless. This should be an insightful discussion as always for this channel.
@jeffisfine
@jeffisfine Год назад
That opening was hilarious! Rest of the video was great, too, of course. A good example of critiquing a capitalist depiction/cooption of ostensibly revolutionary ideas.
@Tom-mu2ci
@Tom-mu2ci Год назад
President, senator, hockey player, actress, news anchor, doctor. I call these lego-people jobs, they generate extreme amounts of survivor bias, and they are a very small percentage of actual real-world jobs. Add cops to that list too.
@LP-zc4gy
@LP-zc4gy Год назад
Hey, come to think of it, has Barbie ever had a “blue collar” job? Where is cashier Barbie? Manufacturer Barbie? Automotive mechanic Barbie? And even if these do exist, why weren’t there any trade or service industry Barbies seen in the film? EDIT: So I looked it up (Wikipedia has a page listing her careers!) she’s at least been a service worker (including Pizza Hut cashier Barbie and McDonald’s cashier Barbie!) I would make the critique that these are idealized versions of those jobs, but all of her careers are idealized. I’d argue the disconnect between real world cashier and idealized Barbie cashier though is much more steep. Still wondering why there wasn’t a Barbie with a blue collar job in the movie. Unless I missed it.
@iateyursandwiches
@iateyursandwiches Год назад
@LP-zc4gy they had barbie trash collectors and construction workers. They even talked about it in the video
@7th808s
@7th808s Год назад
Your comment on the "pink USA" got me thinking. I think it makes sense with the premise of the Barbie world being a matriarchy, and not necessarily a feminist utopia. It's the same world, but now with women being the oppressors. I think the movie could've delved into this more, showing men what this oppression - that women experience daily in real life - looks and feels like. Additionally, I expected at least a little bit of a "wait, are we the baddies" moment for main character at the end, after experiencing what patriarchy was like and knowing that Barbie world is the opposite of that. This would probably not go down well with the liberal audience who have no concept of nuance, and introduces the risk of - equally nuanceless - conservatives liking the movie. And even though there was somewhat of a nice ending for Ken, it was a personal one. The same goes for the ending Barbie got. Never underestimate the power of liberals to gaslight a whole nation by pretending to listen to people's genuine problems, and then tell them it's just in their head. Insert Obama quote about how African countries should stop using past colonialism (as if it's not currently happening still) as an excuse for their underdevelopment (yes, he actually said that). Once again, emancipation to liberals has to be framed as at the expense of the other. "Women doing better means men having it worse", "black people doing better means white people having it worse". And that's why things like affirmative action are more easily implemented than more tax money going to black neighborhoods, or equalizing paternity and maternity leave. Emancipation is supported by liberals only in as far as they can use it as a tool to separate the working class.
@iateyursandwiches
@iateyursandwiches Год назад
Isn't the EXACT opposite of patriarchy though? I keep emphasizing this to people complaining about it. I also made another comment above. The barbies did not actively mistreat the kens. They did not control them or force them in to servitude, they just mostly ignored them/left them alone to their own devices most of the time. The part about Kens potentially being homeless I think was a gag. They just don't know where they actually live since they are too busy ignoring them most of the time. Also, points to how the Ken doll is viewed in the barbie franchise as a whole; girls don't really buy Ken dolls like that nor care
@WhySoSquid
@WhySoSquid Год назад
It is *invaluable* to hear impressions, opinions, and analysis from people I trust before I make certain decisions (even something as seemingly "simple" as deciding to watch a movie 😅) As always, comrades, thanks so much for all you do 💕🙏
@Naheed_Ahmed1917
@Naheed_Ahmed1917 Год назад
Mashallah Marxism Today has uploaded
@Apd766
@Apd766 Год назад
Barbie is a definition of capitalism
@KozelPraiseGOELRO
@KozelPraiseGOELRO Год назад
0:18 Luxury Gay Space Communism. I've never expected to hear this in my life, even less from more serious channels like this one, even as a joke.
@eleaticeyes813
@eleaticeyes813 Год назад
It's a semi-popular joke actually. Coming from the "Fully Automated Luxury Communism" book title, with people adding things like "gay" and "space".
@mayarasp
@mayarasp Год назад
I find it hilarious that literally every man I've seen talk about barbie - from right wing to liberal to communists - start by saying that they went to watch it with their wives, girlfriends, or that their producers made them go etc. not picking on anyone though, just having a laugh here. I did really enjoy the video, thanks for this!
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Lol you're right. It's like "Don't worry, fellow men. It was actually a woman who brought me here". A reflection of the influence of patriarchy even on men's minds where such "cover" has to be presented. Good point. And really ridiculous now that it's pointed out - Paul
@mayarasp
@mayarasp Год назад
@Marxism_Today hahahaha yes exactly. but again, great, great video!
@St_Fish
@St_Fish Год назад
Probably the best critical review I've seen of this movie.
@bluecellspy
@bluecellspy Год назад
Yet another incredible video! Please go on another episode of The Deprogram! Love those collaborations! 🎉
@brodieorr5393
@brodieorr5393 Год назад
You've heard of CEO barbie, now get ready for revolutionary comrade barbie
@ArtakaWorksStudio
@ArtakaWorksStudio Год назад
Abolition of privately held Dream Houses ✊
@markmeteor575
@markmeteor575 Год назад
Personally my two biggest problems of this movie was that it made the more emotional parts less great, like for the example the movies solution to ken hierarchy in barbie land was to revert it back to the barbie hierarchy from the start. which felt dumb, like the barbie hierarchy was to the ken’s like how the real world Men Hierarchy is to women. Even the side character in the end of the movie who helped the barbie’s restore there rights. Got none for himself, it was even commented that the kens didn’t even have home’s or at the very least was segregated away from any of the barbie’s, not to mention that the ending of the movie literally said that the kens will not get any of there rights at all. And also the young girl in the movie felt like a stereotype of a leftist and was very dumb for her to call barbie a fascists, it made her seem unhinged for no reason. But other then that I liked the movie and would rate it somewhere between a 6.5 to a 7/10 (Edit) I also 100% agree with both of yours class analysis of this movie good job👍
@Sqelson
@Sqelson Год назад
on the fun factor alone i LOVED this movie, hilarious at points honestly but i'm glad to have the political critiques put into words where i kinda struggled !! love this content
@3PointNemo
@3PointNemo Год назад
My wife and I went with a few friends on opening weekend and I laughed hard at more than a few parts. Smart writing and silly at the same time.
@annascott-hinkle2367
@annascott-hinkle2367 Год назад
Great video Paul and Anna! ❤ I just saw Barbie yesterday.
@johnmcgrew7128
@johnmcgrew7128 Год назад
This is the most enjoyable and eye opening episode I've seen. And I thought Barbie was just a movie to bring your little girl to see. Yes, bring your little girl and boy and after the movie, explain what It should be like. All Power to The People!!!
@DSnake655
@DSnake655 Год назад
Oh that intro freaked me out as I'm high.
@WhoOneIs
@WhoOneIs Год назад
I have not watched Barbie but I plan to. I love how the right-wing crackpots are losing their minds. It’s got to be worth watching. Any film with female directors, writers and a predominantly female cast is worth supporting.
@iateyursandwiches
@iateyursandwiches Год назад
It's worth mentioning the outrage on how barbie land was oppressive to the men. While the Kens in Barbieland are not seen as important and overall have no rights, they are not specifically mistreated by the barbies or controlled. They are just left alone and maybe rejected while the barbies hang out with each other. Barbies don't solicit them for sex or force them to constant servitude(though the kens would actively volunteer im sure) It does say something about the nature of how a lot of men think. Apparently Ken not having much power AND being denied romance/intimacy with Barbie(despite being attractive to boot)is the worst insult to men possible. The way men are entitled to female attention, though, I'm not surprised... Moreover, Ken as a doll in the entire franchise is not that important. No girls really give shit about buying Ken dolls so it's that aspect of it too. A play on the barbie lore for laughs.
@insane_troll
@insane_troll Год назад
22:24 - The "Barbie National Liberation Army" sounds like the Barbie Liberation Organization that was switching the voice boxes in G.I. Joes and Barbie dolls in the 90s. The Barbies would go "Vengeance is mine!!!"
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187 Год назад
Omg what?!?! Yo?!?!
@JohnSmith-vm8rx
@JohnSmith-vm8rx Год назад
Dude that introduction sounded amazing!
@NicdeGroot
@NicdeGroot 8 месяцев назад
23 minutes; I was crying. Thank you.
@cat2think
@cat2think Год назад
I am so happy to hear someone talk about communism
@cat2think
@cat2think Год назад
The Barbie world is like capitalism but harder lines between proletariat and bourgeoisie
@cat2think
@cat2think Год назад
The US helped instate Pinochet
@IanNotChris
@IanNotChris Год назад
Enjoyed this! The only critiques I've seen of this movie have been from Indigenous people pissed about the comparison of their genocide to Barbie leaving for the real world, so it was great to have more. Wish you would have mentioned that, too, though.
@Товарищкоммунист-э3к
I found the movie to be naive and stupid. But you, the author, were able to give me a communist look at the film from a different angle, thanks for the interesting video
@NocturnalDoom
@NocturnalDoom Год назад
I haven’t watched it and doubt that I will. Hate musicals. (F socialist 30s) also I don’t feel empowered by bashing on men personally. If it’s anything like the Harley Quinn film then no thanks. Definitely not for me 😅 Edit: half way through the video. Can’t imagine the film being wholesome. Everything everywhere all at once made me want to hug my mum. Barbie’s look alone makes me nauseous 😂 always has by the way. The video is great and has given me a different perspective however I still won’t watch it. Mattel and co don’t need anymore money.
@rhumal
@rhumal Год назад
@@NocturnalDoom "bashing on men" In what way does Barbie "bash men"?
@NocturnalDoom
@NocturnalDoom Год назад
@@rhumalthings like portraying the real world as automatically meaning men are against us and/or always attacking us, while comical in the film and of course real, just doesn’t sit great with me. In my experience dealing with men, I’ve had the range, from unwanted sexual advances to assault, to great loving caring men. With all the division, I don’t see much benefit in adding to it by taking part. I’m not claiming to be right, but to me it’s like a reverse “mens locker room” and as I said before, just not me. You enjoy it by all means 👍
@ConanDuke
@ConanDuke 11 месяцев назад
What?! You mean to tell me that an hour-long advertisement for a Mattel is less than revolutionary?
@MilesDashing
@MilesDashing Год назад
23:39: It's stated in the movie that every Barbie has her own dream house. Also, Barbieland IS a fantasy, and an absurd one, and this is communicated to the audience in the first scene when Marbie takes a shower with no water. So it's not a criticism of the film that Barbieland is a liberal feminist fantasy--Barbieland as liberal feminist fantasy IS a critique of liberal feminism. Loved the video, btw.
@7th808s
@7th808s Год назад
Weirdly though, I forgot completely about the voting, while the ridiculousness of it didn't go unnoticed by me, even though not in an explicitly politcal sense. Somehow it seems that they - probably by accident - laid bare the ridiculousness of voting. They kind of represent this voting ritual as something magical, as if roads materialize magically if parliament votes for more tax money going to building roads. It turns the hyperreal of a social construct into actual magic (not needing social agreements for it to function). While in reality of course, the Kens could just riot and take power back. In the end the laws are just words written down on paper. I think this scene beautifully exposes this, but - again - I think completely by accident.
@IrishAmericanCommie
@IrishAmericanCommie Год назад
ANOTHER MARXISTPAUL CLASSIC
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
GRMA a chara! 50% credit to Anna who put in a ton of work to this, too
@RhydderchApRheged-rh7sj
@RhydderchApRheged-rh7sj Год назад
Shwmae pawb. Love a good Marxism today video. Horrifically unrelated question, but what do you think celtic nations should seek a revival of their language in the context of social change during socialist revolution? Many Cymreag MLs I have spoken to believe this could help.
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
I do! I'm a strong advocate for cultural revivals (that break from imperialist culture). Especially when it comes to the process of building anti-imperialist, proletarian states. Language and culture are some of the defining features of nationhood, so recapturing and reviving the positives aspects there will play an important role in combatting imperialism at the superstructural level. - Paul
@RhydderchApRheged-rh7sj
@RhydderchApRheged-rh7sj Год назад
Of course, but does this also extend to Cymru, Scotland, Cumbria and Kernow, which exist within the UK and are also part of the imperial core?
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
We in the Irish Republican movement support the right to self-determination (up to and including full secession) for all celtic nations, including those in the imperial core. Their struggles, particularly where led by the working class, play an important progressive role in weakening British and French imperialism. - Paul
@RhydderchApRheged-rh7sj
@RhydderchApRheged-rh7sj Год назад
Based iawn, diolch yn fawr Paul. (:
@CRABKoko
@CRABKoko Год назад
28:30 did they also capture and ship Black barbies and kens from Barbie Africa, and force them work to build Barbie america, along with the pink house, and oppress them up till now? this is a fun video. my wife and I are cracking up
@shoro12
@shoro12 Год назад
Anyone notice the scene towards the end of the movie where Sasha's mother rants at Barbie to snap her out of her brainwashing and how that rant parallels Michael Parenti's famous Left Anti-Communism quote in Blackshirts & Reds? Replace the 'Soviet Union' with 'women' and it's very similar.
@theonlymegumegu
@theonlymegumegu Год назад
24:02 this immediately brought to mind how i like to modify my favorite fred hampton quote; "we won't beat capitalism with black/feminist/etc capitalism" ^_^
@yeetgrenade7492
@yeetgrenade7492 Год назад
soy suficienKEN (I saw this somewhere as the spanish translation of 'I am KENough'
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187 Год назад
JAJAJAJAJAJJAJA
@lesscaib
@lesscaib Год назад
this channel is awesome, greetings from brazil comrade
@clarapilier
@clarapilier Год назад
I like the movie but when I left the theater all I could think is how I don’t want a sequel or a Mattel Cinematic Universe.
@caramelldansen2204
@caramelldansen2204 Год назад
Comrade Barbie has fallen down the capitalist path! The revolution is doomed! Great video, you two! A refreshing change of pace, though I'm surprised it wasn't a Left of Review video! Maybe I'm a little confused as to that channel's purpose... 😵‍💫 Nonetheless, keep it up!
@AWildBard
@AWildBard Год назад
haha introduction was brilliant great review probably the best review I've seen
@strawberryJen711
@strawberryJen711 Год назад
ok now we need the barbie sequal the barbie union strike lead by the sosha character
@numbersix8919
@numbersix8919 6 месяцев назад
OK, I made the decision to see Barbie on an airplane thanks to this analysis. It was MUCH better than I had thought it would be.
@justaguy6216
@justaguy6216 Год назад
Yeah, I also had a similar thought. It just wasn't anti-corporate enough, let alone anywhere near anti-capitalist. Honestly the story is best enjoyed through its interpersonal relationships rather than its politics,
@clarapilier
@clarapilier Год назад
I love this analysis. There's something about this movie that no one is talking about. Why are the politics of barbie land the way they are? Barbie land was created by children, mostly little girls. Every doll in Barbieland is been played by mostly little girls. These little girls don't know better. The only reason a stereotypical Barbie, it's having a mental breakdown and an existential crisis it's because she's been played by a grown woman.. It also explains why the Kens didn't get equality right away. This is a safe space for little girls and their dreams. They just tasted the patriarkey. They're not gonna give it away that easily. Just remember, they're not fully flesh adults. These are girls, mostly of them little girls. They're not going to be fully fleshed Feminist, the only feminist in this movie is Gloria. Because she is the only adult.
@semyonbudyonny1895
@semyonbudyonny1895 Год назад
“By the glory of Lenin, by the will of Stalin; all power to the Soviets!”
@eaa6347
@eaa6347 Год назад
for what?
@numbersix8919
@numbersix8919 Год назад
OK I'm subscribing, I looked everywhere for a good critique of Barbie, and found this channel -- it wasn't suggested by the algorithm -- in a roundabout way.
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Welcome! The algo isn't kind to this channel, but we're glad you've found your way here in spite of that!
@numbersix8919
@numbersix8919 Год назад
@@Marxism_Today Thank you. Since I have your attention, what is this channel's take on the CPUSA?
@freudianslippers6567
@freudianslippers6567 Год назад
I've found these two as well: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE--2vE-hFCpLc.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-RToUZJ0l7Pk.html This video and those videos are all wonderful and all go into different areas. We don't have a lot of Marxist analysis of films, I need more.
@maxbanker7210
@maxbanker7210 Год назад
6/10, didn't throw bricks at any cops
@crisvelundertale2159
@crisvelundertale2159 Год назад
conversely, i think the movie was expectedly self-aware, they knew that no matter what, the conversation around barbie and matter's controversies WILL take place, ignoring it would be completely disingenuous for the audience, but also coveniently ignoring other dark things like the exploitation and workers abuse to not hurt the company's image too much. This is a film cued by culture, it doesn't cue culture at all, any conversation it spread was already defaulted there by just the fact that mattel decided to sell a new barbie movie in 2023, giving the political environment today, things are crumbling all around us in different ways, so as you say, generally people now tend to be more socially conscious than ever before, to varying degrees, specially young people, so it takes progressive movements to its own gain, and this has been being done for a few years already, barbie ushers neoliberalism in this new decade.
@rlm66101
@rlm66101 Год назад
Y'all rock. Even in Barbie Land :)
@5driedgrams
@5driedgrams Год назад
Great video! Reactionaries are getting insane about this movie in my country.
@RayRassa
@RayRassa Год назад
just read the book rec at the end as well! thanks for todays education guys!
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Wonderful book! Happy to help :)
@TheSci-fiAnarchist42
@TheSci-fiAnarchist42 Год назад
Pink is the new red. 💗 ✊
@symmetry08
@symmetry08 Год назад
Yeah, in a way as a South Park Cartoon like direct ! In the end Mattel sells more toys and WB expands marketshare, and Producers are sharing their messages - however - with good payback for their stellar ideas.
@OhioJones189
@OhioJones189 Год назад
Another day another Marxism Today banger
@aimes2011
@aimes2011 Год назад
The way “luxury gay space communism” took me. 😆😆😆 Somebody please call me when this is a thing cause I’m all in!
@petrosstefanidis6396
@petrosstefanidis6396 Год назад
Fully automated luxury gay space communism ushered in across the entire universe🤣🤣🤣 What an intro!
@VeryUsMumblings
@VeryUsMumblings Год назад
As much as i enjoyed this critique of Barbie from a Marxist perspective, the critque of Barbie's view of fascism is an overreach. Barbie is not misrepresenting fascism by suggesting it is just the nationalisation of public services. She's making a joke based on history. Mussolini was famous for (alegedly) making the Italian trains run on time. He also introduced heavy tarriffs on trade, exempting Germany from these tariffs. These policies were what made him popular in the beginning of his gov't. When someone calls Barbie a fascist, she thinks of Mussolini (Haha!). Sometimes Barbie is just a doll... 😀
@dradenlol8667
@dradenlol8667 Год назад
Need me some gay space communism
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Don't we all?
@dradenlol8667
@dradenlol8667 Год назад
@@Marxism_Today it is the greatest cause in the world
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187
@OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO187 Год назад
Proletarian revolution in the stars NOW
@ViveLRoi
@ViveLRoi Год назад
Though, fwiw- I think the quip about fascism and railways was a joke at the quote that "at least Mussolini made the trains run on time".
@tmoody1000
@tmoody1000 Год назад
Yeah, that bit about railways and commodities really stumped me in the theatre both times I watched it. It seemed so absurd to me, and didn’t make sense. Neoliberals gonna neoliberal I suppose
@bnpixie1990
@bnpixie1990 Год назад
Something I have noticed, and I don't know yet if the video will mention it, is the number of posts that seem to be trying to resuscitate even early barbies. A lot of talk about how "Ken is only an accessory". And basically that barbie encourages girls to reach their goals. Of course, I can remember the number of times barbie has been criticized and image issues.
@ZenBen_the_Elder
@ZenBen_the_Elder Год назад
New to this channel, like the texture. The Scottish Marxist dude is droll and witty and Anna is lit! I bet they listen to Chapo.
@Illstatefishing
@Illstatefishing Год назад
Never thought a Barbie analysis would make me become a member supporter!! Also can we getna new discord Link? 🚩
@bnpixie1990
@bnpixie1990 Год назад
I also find the advertisement very odd. The real Malibu barbie house was made available for vacations (for how much idk). In California where homelessness is so bad. Plus all over the US people are having a hard time buying their first home. And then just after Mattel decided to sell weird barbie. Some people pointed out that weird barbie is supposed to be made, as explained in the movie. So whatever message the movie sends the Mattel or relared corps can undermine it to sell things.
@darkhero4040
@darkhero4040 Год назад
I am Kenough
@pjaworek6793
@pjaworek6793 Год назад
You guys are hilarious. Now I really want to see the movie. You get a sub.😊
@ViveLRoi
@ViveLRoi Год назад
I thought it was a good movie. I have balanced expectations- it's primarily an existentialist comedy, the social commentary is icing on the cake. I'm not going to expect a Marxist film if it didn't have a Marxist director.
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
Fair. It's a great existentialist comedy. But from a Marxist perspective, the politics leave a lot to be desired, which is why I ended up giving it two scores: one for entertainment, and one for politics - Paul
@comradetomtuttle
@comradetomtuttle Год назад
The only Barbie these conservatives want to see a movie about is Claus Barbie.
@joerosevino
@joerosevino Год назад
that was damn clever
@comradetomtuttle
@comradetomtuttle Год назад
@@joerosevino thank you! I didn't think of it until most of the Barbie discourse was over, so I'm glad I got the chance to use it.
@ielle.
@ielle. Год назад
No mention of the forced smallpox "commentary?" It was such a disrespectful way of engaging with indigenous trauma and I don't understand how that didn't stay in the drafts. Anyway, this was my very short review that I texted a friend as I walked out of the theater: I think my biggest critique is Barbie doesn’t really achieve anything because it set limits upon itself by taking the male gaze far too much into consideration. It basically is a film that spends its time trying to educate cis men. Because of this, it never explores what to do about patriarchy, instead venting about it (part of why it’s a fun watch!) and begging for recognition, for cis men to walk a day in our shoes, basically. It’s an A-List star-studded summer blockbuster Hollywood huge budget production so of course it wasn’t going to be anything different. But I find it funny that so many are still so mad about it.
@quinnarrenzola5284
@quinnarrenzola5284 Год назад
Hi Comrad!!
@firelordOzai3
@firelordOzai3 Год назад
Enjoyed every minute. Thank you
@sacredcowmusicjukebox
@sacredcowmusicjukebox Год назад
Eh. The family wasn't a big Mattel toys buyer but loved Marx ! Anyway, growing up when I did, when THE Wall was still standing, most girls had Barbie's and most boys had the G.I. Joe's. Yeah, Gen Zer's. Society was weird like that, you say. It was just, uhm... "quieter". We all "knew" about Ken. Let's just say Barbie could trust Ken to babysit Skipper while she went on an "Only Girls" night-out with Midge. Nevertheless, there were some very creative kids in the early days of pre-Covid civilization. One of the ways we entertained ourselves was by making our own home movies. Boring? Too white suburban, tuna- casserole-on-a-Saturday-night entertainment? Not at all. See, Super 8 was the thing. Now in the hands of Dad, yeah, the usual: vacation movies; surprising-mom-in-the-morning-coming-out-of-the-shower-again stuff; first birthdays/anniversaries/drunk uncle dancing holidays...the whole middle-class thing. Except for Dad's hidden stag reels from Argentina ("Gretchen Rides Her Black Stag" was the best !) in the back of the basement, behind the wall, it was all clean fun. Now put that same Super 8 camera in the hands of little Dick, Jane, Leroy, Soon Lee or Irving, then you got the imagination ("the faculty or action of forming new ideas, or images or concepts of external objects not present to the senses" for those that ask...)! But throw in some Barbie's, and G.I. Joe's- hot damn ! You'd have an orgy of X rated kiddie toy porn made by unsupervised kids ! Today when we look at the ones we made, it's no wonder AI is a popular thing. We reached our limit early and it's been downhill after that! Ya see, suppression made for good script even when it wasn't about a script, just a natural "do as thou wilt" playtime for devilish children. When you don't realize you've been repressed and you gotta get it out in some way, it can be "shocking" to adults. And kids...shit ! Ya gotta love the lil' bastards! Always with the raw, unsophisticated ideas until some cigar-smoking wanker in a long overcoat, who sits watching them on the playground, and then gets his own idea on how to make a million bucks. Hooray for Hollywood. A blockbuster. Then you get the film critics and the academic elites and other assorted sociological eggheads and bottom-sniffers who argue, over-analyze, huff-n-puff contemporaneously on the film's "social more"- and, basically, have no fuckin' clue what they speak of. It just sounds good to them at yet another one of those white w(h)ine symposiums. Furry conventions are much more fun to cover, folks. Bottomline- if it wasn't for the corruption of children's imagination by adults, there would be no discussions about Barbie, Snow White, woke Disney, the Illuminati, Fox News...we'd just enjoy life in bear-skins and face-painting without all the fake-commercial rhetoric. Or watch the classic cult "Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things" and get the irony of living in a world where we, creatively, feed off the living, to inspire the dead. The Vampire Struggle Continues On, Comrades!
@flobblem1825
@flobblem1825 7 месяцев назад
What the literal fuck are you on about?
@aWomanFreed
@aWomanFreed Год назад
This review is more ridiculous than the movie
@runningbetweenspaces
@runningbetweenspaces Год назад
Thanks for this, mind if i use it for a template for a video about a class analysis of Chip n Dale Rescue Rangers and Who Framed Roger Rabbit
@comrademartinofrappuccino
@comrademartinofrappuccino Год назад
What about reviewing "breaking with old ideas"?
@josephgeorge5741
@josephgeorge5741 Год назад
I've had Kenough of the Bourgeoisie!
@Marxism_Today
@Marxism_Today Год назад
You dropped this 👑
@elijahrothman9038
@elijahrothman9038 Год назад
They said in the Film that every Barbie had a house
@unknowunknown9096
@unknowunknown9096 Год назад
I have a criticism on unrealistic body standard from barbie argument' Barbie is a doll it impossible to be accurate to human.
Далее
The Plastic Feminism of Barbie
27:18
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Marvel Defenders of The Status Quo
21:59
Просмотров 873 тыс.
Grand Angle : Barbie, film féministe ou immoral  ?
13:55
Did feminism FAIL men?
1:15:58
Просмотров 554 тыс.
Worker Co-Ops to Socialism?
39:51
Просмотров 13 тыс.
A Brief History of the Culture Wars
53:15
Просмотров 1 млн
How The Media Promotes Transphobia
49:18
Просмотров 1 млн
Interview with Literary Agent Eleanor Jackson
56:48
Просмотров 9 тыс.