Barstool Pizza Review - Proto's Pizza featuring Colts Punter Pat McAfee 

McAfee just taking a bite of the slice without tasting the crust, such a punter type of move.

Mcafee is a great guy for offering that guy pizza without hesitation

Every Barstool Pizza Review: 1) Can’t remember intersecting streets 2) Can’t figure out how to open the pizza box 3) One bite, everyone knows the rules, takes 5 bites.

Pat officially wins the best special guest contest. 4:05: "Albanian. Are they known for their meatball subs? Of course, everyone knows that."

That chef looks like a scaled down version of the big show

I'm absolutely addicted to this series. I love the intro song. I really wish there was more than one good pizza place in my entire city

Pat worried the Albanian was gonna stick him in da trunk and drive him out to Brighton beach so gave him a high score

Pat: “I’m a pizza guy, pizza and wings” I felt that.

Pat: "This is my 2nd meatball sub in a decade" Dave: "You've only had 2 meatball subs in your life?" Pat: Decade. Chef: Decade? Pat: Decade? Chef & Dave: Decade? Pat: Decade. 10 years.

Rocketman playing as pres shreds macafee was a perfect monologue and gave me goosebumps.

The fact that Rocket Man was playing in the background was beautiful. Solid score.

McAfee changed his score (1st offense) to a round number nonetheless (2nd offense) then gives out a perfect tenner in front of the owner (3 strikes you're out). Fouled up all over the place, he's shot

I would pay to see a whole show of Dave and Pat on prime time

I laugh every time Dave says 'One bite, Everyone knows the rules' and then just devours the slice

Who knew a punter would be the best guy on the radio/RU-vid

As guest reviewer McAfee gets an 8.6. I guess punters do have to have a sense of humor.

"Final Answer Regis" hahahaha

the chemistry is unreal.

For Albania

One nibble, everybody knows the laws.

These characters are the same person lmao you can feel the vibe in the air they both respect each other throughout all the tension

i've watched about 50 of these reviews and this one is making belly laugh harder than ANY other episode, my god you guys are funny as hell, amazing, just amazing. McAfee's energy is addictive as coke

This deserves millions, AND MILLIONS, of views

These 2 are great I want more reviews together

Still can’t wait to hear the real story of how Portnoy let McAfee get away

Pat Mac is awesome! Great guy oozing with confidence to leave the NFL early to do what he wants! Great clip! Go Colts!

This guest is perfect

5:28 music fits well the situation

I love the rocketman in the background 😂

The beginning of the legend that is Patrick Mcafee

Dude @ 3:58 has a hell of story. Saw that camera & immediately started thinking his pass life is gonna finally catch up to him.

I love how they raise the volume on rocketman for the pres. review. 🤣🤣🤣

Pat Mcafee > Marquette King

"final answer Regis" lol

Pat: Where you from? Guy: I'm originally Albanian Dave: Are they known for meatball subs there? Pat: Of course, everybody knows about that lmao

4:37 “one bite, everybody knows, I mean you take a bunch of bites” NEW LAW

One of the biggest choke jobs of the century. Surprised McAfee was able to even swallow the sub after that.

One of the best I’ve watched so far

These two are a great team!

One of the best reviews

Val looks oddly like a skinny, shorter Big Show.

*Lmao @ "It's an 8..... I can't!! That's his fckn American dream!!!!!"* #ClassicResponce

Would love to have a podcast with these 2

This is probably the best guest episode. 9.9!

Get Mcafee back on here. He needs redemption for that rookie performance.

6:20 “but that’s his American dream” this guy is great

What Ive learned from these reviews is that Albanians are like the bootleg Italians of pizza. Also Pat, great guest

McAfee got tossed in the spin cycle on this review

"Six and a half, yup thats my fucking score i dont know what to tell ya" hahahaahha

Automatic 10/10 meatball sub for Rocketman playing in the background. Dave that was a rookie move

Pats also a better human being, “that’s his American dream” sincerely a life long subscriber

The Albanian worker looks like a really slim and smaller version of the Big Show

Awesome review gents

"That's my score. I don't know what to tell ya." Lmfao

Best review yet.

Absolutely electric

Pat eats his pizza like a new yorker

The dude working in the restaurant dipped aht when he saw the camera like he could not pass a background check or should not be where he is. Lol

Great chemistry

greatest punter ever we miss you in indiana..

u should come try the pizza from my place, its in pittsfield, mass, few hrs from nyc everyone here says its the best, i think it is pretty good but would love to actually have a pro try the pizza and see what they think, and always hear the meatball sub really good too, homemade meatballs but sliced like deli meat but thicker. should come out give us a try. its called Tyler St Pizza House

These dudes give the same vibe

The Algorithm brought me here and Pat found his meatballs! That last few seconds of the video was all the motivation McAfee needed!

Davey wish you mentioned price of the items.

When pat was eating that meatball sub he was vibing

“One bite every knows the rules” -eats entire thing

3:56 when you realize you don't have your papers and you're on film..

No one noticed Aaron Rodgers walked in at the end and ordered a slice.

One view. Everybody knows the rules we watch every one bite episode until we watch them all. Gotta live the shoutout to the homeless man that was a real class act. Meatball sun extra view big fan of that. Oh man shooting the gun with the pizza bite. Oh man this is awkward now. Dave just attacks the pizza today he must be hungry or feelin it. Homeless guy analogy not on point at this place. Feel like the pizza review was rushed and suffered because of the meatball review. Just an ok episode today nothing special. 5.8

I knew it. I knew it Frankie. What type of rookie ball is that

How are you going to say it's one of the best meatball subs you've had in a really long time and then give it a 7.2?!?!? By the way Pat and him were reacting to it I was assuming it was at least an 8.7.

Complete polar opposites but we got 2 absolute legends right here boys

the competition for best bite lololol

3:59 when the Mexican dude pops out of the shot because he realizes that he's being filmed.

"We make our own bread here...Every day we go get it."

Everyone knows a decade is ten years except Dave Dave- "In your life?"

Fuckin love the combo no one better than pat and Dave

We need another pat review

So what did Dave rate the sub?

Gotta love Pat

“That’s what you need in this game Frankie” - Dave Portnoy | 2017

the big balls dance from portnoy is amazing

2 champions in the game of Life

Matt groning the gig is up ⬆️, you’re a time traveler ⏳🧳- pat is a funny ass dude!!!

We need a new updated episode with Pat again. Make it happen Dave. Please lol

Did the big show make your meatball sub?

Pat I love you

3:49 how did nobody point out this is the Big Show minus a few pizza slices???

5:28 what's the song??

Pat!!

3:50 is that the Big Show?

Pat Macafee has charisma, can talk, and can wrestle. Much respect. He knows how to work.

Someone please tell me the story behind his perfect score that Dave gave in Boston. I can’t imagine it was legit perfect.

It's really difficult to get a horrible slice here. I live in Queens and every corner you turn has decent pizza. Some places are just better than others.

Watching from oldsest to newest. This is the best so far. Excellent undercarriage and the sauce of a punter. 8.4

try Charlie's pizza in Wilmington de

Mcafee is a stand up guy one of my fav NFL players even tho he was a punter still a boss

6 and a half and Davey's face bruh lmfao "Just did it. Yep.' That's my fucking score, I don't know what to tell ya.' I was excited.' I was hungry.' There's a homeless guy, that turned this down.' 6.5." Hahahahahahaha

McAfee and Portnoy are the Spider Mans from the meme

This guy looks like the home alone villain