Тёмный

Battle for Afghanistan: Lessons from the First Anglo-Afghan War 

Brookings Institution
Подписаться 152 тыс.
Просмотров 26 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

24 апр 2013

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 71   
@brendaneduffy5946
@brendaneduffy5946 8 лет назад
and 3 years after this was posted, we are still there
@thomaskelly3474
@thomaskelly3474 2 года назад
And 8 years after this was posted, we're gone. The old Afghan man from the 1:00 hour mark was correct.
@brokenbulbs
@brokenbulbs 8 лет назад
A most blind confidence, completely unwarranted, brought about the danger. And that embicility, unprecedented, completed the catastrophe.
@sdlkfjhasiodf1477
@sdlkfjhasiodf1477 2 года назад
what is the word he is using at 27:11 :"declourt"???!!!
@BHASKARKRISHNATREYA
@BHASKARKRISHNATREYA 2 года назад
LOL at the prediction that it was unlikely for Taliban to return to power!
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg 4 года назад
Afghanistan's destiny is not effected by the neighbours but vice versa as the history of India is privy to that;
@Amaaaaan1
@Amaaaaan1 6 лет назад
Can someone please tell him to come close to the mic and talk!
@BlueWizard09
@BlueWizard09 2 года назад
Afghans 4 Anglo Saxons 0
@adambartlett7955
@adambartlett7955 4 года назад
3:16 to skip intro
@ashkisten3111
@ashkisten3111 2 года назад
Interesting material.... volume please. 🎙😐
@ragnarososo
@ragnarososo 3 года назад
Well looks like history repeats
@toobalkain
@toobalkain 6 лет назад
Isn’t this guy’s body out of proportion with his head? As if he were a body builder and the head couldn’t keep up the pace of growth.
@davemacnicol8404
@davemacnicol8404 Год назад
George Costanza my man! I knew he was really a brit!
@donny_doyle
@donny_doyle 2 года назад
6:01 starts...
@michaelsweeney4547
@michaelsweeney4547 7 лет назад
Can't hear you.
@ziawalizada3184
@ziawalizada3184 6 лет назад
coz he wants to hide the realty
@klmadan2071
@klmadan2071 4 года назад
Speaker is talking for himself. We canon hear him clear.
@michaelsweeney4547
@michaelsweeney4547 7 лет назад
Ah... microphone
@paulstone670
@paulstone670 8 лет назад
Poems real ending: Like a soldier who's INSANE. Would have never went there if sane.
@jimgray4085
@jimgray4085 6 лет назад
The way he calls him "Willie"!
@ENTERTAININGVIDEOS1
@ENTERTAININGVIDEOS1 Год назад
1:16:00 That is what exactly happened!! Everybody was aware that it is bound to happen!!!
@dbrannick9585
@dbrannick9585 3 года назад
23:58
@Affandy2010
@Affandy2010 2 месяца назад
Who is watching this 2024 😂😂 this history is inevitable
@knockshinnoch1950
@knockshinnoch1950 8 лет назад
Just read his book- fascinating. A period of UK history that has been "conveniently" ignored
@RicTic66
@RicTic66 7 лет назад
Ignored? There are dozens of videos and scores of books on the subject.
@matikhorasani3842
@matikhorasani3842 6 лет назад
Ignored in the sense that the conflicts role is downplayed and deemed irrelivent and portrayed as if the British simply weren´t interested in Afghanistan . All empires do this when they get their assess handed to them by the supposedly weaker foe.
@peshpraq5137
@peshpraq5137 2 года назад
That willy of mine should get closer to the mic we can not hear him properly.
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg 4 года назад
Even if Chinese come, they have Gangez Khan's blood running through veins.
@kelpticgoddessfibreartsstu9304
@kelpticgoddessfibreartsstu9304 2 года назад
Wow! how prophetic .... Kabul just fell to the Taliban and US is in disgrace....they left all their equipment and their people....yes China wants Afghanistans minerals so the show goes on.....this guy should be advising govt about Afghanistan
@sdlkfjhasiodf1477
@sdlkfjhasiodf1477 2 года назад
1:03:18 has meme potential
@jcbairmaster73
@jcbairmaster73 11 лет назад
You cannot nor ever will in against tribespeople,they have all the odds in their favour.
@thebeanymac
@thebeanymac 2 года назад
Audio is tragic.
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg 4 года назад
One and the foremost reason has been relying on the people like Shah Shuja and his direct descendant like Karzai and alike.
@TheAfghan72
@TheAfghan72 4 года назад
Karzai is not a descendant of Shuja.
@elhamhemat572
@elhamhemat572 Месяц назад
Shah Shuja was not even full popalzai, his mother was Indian and he was one of 300 children of Timur shah. he never lived in Afghanistan and he couldn't even speak Pashtu.
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg Месяц назад
@@elhamhemat572 Neither was Sher Shah Sori--Could even speak Pashto, had never been to Afghanistan, not even perhaps to Peshawar.
@elhamhemat572
@elhamhemat572 Месяц назад
@@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg At least he didn't sell his country like a coward but also Shah Shuja was mentally sick. he would torture his workers. most of the history was written by the British because he lived in a British captive for 30 years.
@HasnainKhan-lh6si
@HasnainKhan-lh6si Месяц назад
@@elhamhemat572 Shuja was the 🐶 of British and Sher Sha was loud, proud and wise Afghan.
@tattat44
@tattat44 11 лет назад
As if the Taliban need to be coerced grow poppy.
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg 4 года назад
Also this was not Afhgans who fought, but Taliban.... so Afghans did have little role to cause defeat because in every case they sided with the foreign invaders.
@TheAfghan72
@TheAfghan72 4 года назад
Lol what? Taliban didn't exist in Soviet times, the Mujhadeen were all Afghans who were aided by America to fight the soviets. All Pakistan did was brainwash young Afghan refugees into doing Jihad in Afghanistan sometime during the brink of the Soviet defeat. All Pakistan did was fund extremist groups and these groups would later become the Taliban. We can thank your country for terrorism in Afghanistan. Oh and just remember who converted you to Islam you former British slave.
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg 4 года назад
... So for this the punishment for converting to Islam, let us basal pora kawal an ghuri da muslmanawalo?
@zaroonyakhyakhan4514
@zaroonyakhyakhan4514 3 года назад
@@TheAfghan72 begheratthob ma kawa wrora
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg 4 года назад
and one thing UK is also responsible for the humiliation of US in Afghanistan for you fellows did not timely advised.
@MDM0915
@MDM0915 Год назад
Not very prophetic regarding the Taliban taking over again. Interesting to hear how convinced former CIA agent was regarding this. Obviously this is hindsight and it is great to listen to what very knowledgeable were thinking years in advance.
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg
@MuhammadYousaf-yf2pg 4 года назад
That is wishfull thinking
@Affandy2010
@Affandy2010 2 месяца назад
Amrullah Saleh was dead wrong 😑
Далее
Qizim 58-qism | Anons |Nimaga meni bolam o'ladi ?
00:47
What it feels like cleaning up after a toddler.
00:40
The Soviet Union in Afghanistan - Dr. Bob Baumann
1:03:02
Return of a King: Talk by Mr William Dalrymple
1:18:30
Просмотров 54 тыс.
Qizim 58-qism | Anons |Nimaga meni bolam o'ladi ?
00:47