Тёмный

BEST DIRECT DRIVE?! | Logitech G Pro Wheel Vs Fanatec GT DD Pro Comparison 

Geek Street
Подписаться 468 тыс.
Просмотров 290 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

26 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 591   
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Which wheel do you think is better?
@VM-xy5te
@VM-xy5te Год назад
Fanatec
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
🥳
@jeftesantiago
@jeftesantiago Год назад
I think you said that the ‘Best Wheel’ was the Logitech G Pro wheel because of the True Force feature. However, I believe that Fanatec has some wheels (like the Formula V2.5 & V2.5X) that include vibration motors to make up to a similar feature.
@charliegraham819
@charliegraham819 Год назад
had the g29 had it modded with the shifters and the brake was modded aswell got the gt dd pro and havent looked back in my mind was night and day difference have not tried logitechs gpro but the dd pro 8nm is strong enough for most people in my opinion i know was just enough for myself lv it got the mcclaren gt3 wheel and csw2.5
@sparklejess8003
@sparklejess8003 Год назад
@@jeftesantiago honestly that feels nothing like true force.
@talon1706
@talon1706 Год назад
I haven't tried a Fanatec system but the G pro wheel/pedals are great. I was looking at Fanatec but after converting the costs to my currency, taxes/import fee's and delivery charges it was too expensive for me. I bought the G Pro wheel / pedal combo that was offered. Coming from a G29 it's a massive upgrade. No regrets. My son has the G29 now. It's six years old and still works fine. Hope the quality continues.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Out of interest what would have been the cost of the Fanatec for you?
@camerong2172
@camerong2172 Год назад
I’ve had my g27 for almost 13 years! Expect your sons wheel to last him a while. I’m just now upgrading to the g pro!
@MrDannyboyhall
@MrDannyboyhall Год назад
Either way you can’t really go wrong really they are all quite good I personally prefer the Fanatec wheels as it’s the eco system that I’ve been in for quite a while but the logi does look like a good solid unit enjoy
@trackjunky3338
@trackjunky3338 Год назад
any DD is a massive improvement from FFB wheel base regardless of the brand
@maytag_man_i_am_3379
@maytag_man_i_am_3379 Год назад
I also went with the Logitech. It's my first dd wheel and couldn't be happier. The true force is terrible though. I'm really shocked that so many reviewers keep saying that it's a game changer. It feels weird and unnatural. It really just gets in the way of the rest of the ffb outputs. Please stop calling it a game changer. The only thing that changes is that I turn it off. As for price , none of the reviewers tell anyone that if you buy the wheel and pedals together, you get a discount on the pedals. They're discounted by 90 something US dollars. I'm happy with my purchase. I've been using Logitech since the 2000s so I'm sure I'm biased, but I wanted something that I knew would just work. My G25 and G29 put in a lot of work without any issues and would still be chopping away if they weren't in the closet now. I'm hoping I get the same from the pro.
@cuddles.monster
@cuddles.monster Год назад
You're not supposed to use them at full power, you can see the wheel shaking the frame and this is not at all comfortable or nice to drive with, it will be clipping the force feedback in the corners
@BoosiveFPV
@BoosiveFPV Год назад
That's more an issue with the cockpit tbh. It doesn't look the most sturdy does it. The Simlab PX1 seems to be the best cockpit.
@seebarry4068
@seebarry4068 Год назад
Tbf, the big green racing line was a giveaway.
@colinwu7344
@colinwu7344 Год назад
@@BoosiveFPV bro what r u talking abt, ffb has nothing to do with the rig bro. He’s talking about the reviewer turning the ffb too high making it clip/oscillate like crazy. If the ffb is turned to an appropriate level, the rig, especially an 8020 aluminium profile rig, shouldn’t shake at all.
@BoosiveFPV
@BoosiveFPV Год назад
@@colinwu7344 your comment barely makes any sense. A 10nm wheel shouldn't cause a 8020 rig to move like that. Which is why the issue looks amplified because of the play in the rig. This rig is advertised to take wheelbases like the simucube pro etc.
@mamenhr9126
@mamenhr9126 Год назад
Clipping is not related to the total force of the base. It is related to the ammount of FFB the game sends to the base. Wheel bases must be set at maximum ffb level to obtain best response. You have to set ingame ffb to not reach clipping.
@jaritsu
@jaritsu Год назад
I really wanted to grab a GT kit from Fanatec but I struggled to catch any stock for like a year. I only recently discovered Logitech had a new DD wheel out and through it was about 400 bucks more expensive, I picked one up to FINALLY replace my old G29. They are readily available direct from Logitech, which is incredibly refreshing. I figured the Logitech would just be cost premium over Fanatec because of the branding but it's legit as far as build quality. The pedal base and setup + the default wheel are so much better than I expected and IMO look better than the Fanatec. The GT wheel from Fanatec looks like some fisher price toy, and the Logitech wheel shifters are scores better. A shame I still have to use the awful G29 manual shifter though, that thing is hot garbage. Mostly though I like that I can adjust FF settings without having to go into the game settings or ghub. Truforce is better, but I only ever leave it set to about 5 / 100.
@buddy5088
@buddy5088 Год назад
I’ve been using the Logitech pro wheel and pedals. This wheel is incredible. I love the true force. The pedals feel great as well. I was able to get an additional discount on the wheel and pedals using a Logitech promo code. Loving it so far. Being able to change wheel settings on the fly via the wheel base is incredible as well.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
❤️
@teggsy2165
@teggsy2165 Год назад
I got the Logidays £50 extra discount paid total for wheel and pedals £1212.48p it's big solid and works just fine on my sturdy desk 2 lumps of blue tac keeps the pedals firm and cushioned to my skirtng board so I am loving my G Pro so far.
@KnowerofThings
@KnowerofThings Год назад
@@teggsy2165 what is the logidays discount ? how do i get it?
@MH-rn1tp
@MH-rn1tp Год назад
What stand are you using? I just got it but haven't put it up yet
@grahamkelly8662
@grahamkelly8662 Год назад
@@MrWhoopwhoop10no it’s just messed up on all base. Just need to turn that crap off
@sparklejess8003
@sparklejess8003 Год назад
Having owned the Csl Dd 8nm, with v3 pedals for over a year. It is a solid setup. I now have the logitech Dd too. My preference is Def the logitech in terms of ffb. The wheel on the logitech itself is okay but not my favourite so hoping more options come. Having said that the fanatec gt7 wheel is terrible, so had to buy a new wheel which is a lot better for sure and many fanatec wheels are nicer than logitechs wheel itself. V3 pedals may have the slight edge over logitech pedals but not by much as do like the logitech pedals too. So in summary I think the logitech is better out the box by a fair margin and has more potential for new wheel etc. But fanatec have more options atm and is more compact. Both are great!
@Andybarney555
@Andybarney555 Год назад
So your a greedy bastard? When there is limited stock..
@sparklejess8003
@sparklejess8003 Год назад
@@Andybarney555 If that is what you think, then sure. I dont expect to change your mindset 😁.
@nickenyfiken4096
@nickenyfiken4096 Год назад
Are you playing on console?
@sparklejess8003
@sparklejess8003 Год назад
@@nickenyfiken4096 both ps5 and on PC
@SSmallwood
@SSmallwood Год назад
do you have the hydraulic upgrade for the v3s? or use the pedal vibrators?
@Rhaziell30
@Rhaziell30 Год назад
I have both wheels: the Fanatec with 8nm and the Logitech pro wheel. The Logitech is a little better in terms of direct drive. With 11nm not only stronger, but also much more differentiated and works out the track details much better. The Logitech is better as a total package, which is of course reflected in the price. That's why I only wanted to go into the comparison to the direct drive now. I find the Tru-Force a bit annoying. At least I have not yet found a suitable wheel settings for a good driving experience. Maybe someone has a tip, or can post times his Wheelsettings for GT7!
@hamdsheikh9205
@hamdsheikh9205 Год назад
I started out with trueforce on, and now I can never turn it off (I tried, it feels very bland). It gives soooo much information. I know exactly where the limit is for the tyres thanks to true force. I guess it's one of those new technologies where everyone hates the new weird feeling at first, but eventually, it becomes the norm once you get used to it. So I get what you're saying but I would also suggest that you try to get used to it. Now, sometimes, when leading I will intentionally kick out the car's back in hairpins because the G Pro gives me so much confidence.
@Dark_Starr2030
@Dark_Starr2030 Год назад
On GT7 set vibration in game to 35 and on the G PRO Trueforce Audio set to 15
@trackjunky3338
@trackjunky3338 Год назад
ive got the fanatec gt DD pro but i upgraded the pedals - this system for people on a budget is fantastic !! add the fact you can add a handbrake or a sequential shifter to the wheel base and run it through one usb port to your pc is a massive bonus -
@humanze
@humanze Год назад
I'm leaning towards getting the Logitech because of the poor customer service history many report with Fanatec. I'm sure either will impress compared to my t150.
@DonVincenzooGame
@DonVincenzooGame Год назад
true force on logitechlook very important to obtain perfect little details .... this is part of the wheel and an amazing game changer that logitech bring on the table. they don't just jump in DD world ! they jump in with inovation that can make it to an other world !! i love it !
@kingofkings89pl
@kingofkings89pl Год назад
Logitech G pro got True Force and this is a game changer. That make this wheel best in the market for PS5 PS VR 2 GT7 Period!
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
💯
@PauloOliveira-xg9xt
@PauloOliveira-xg9xt Год назад
I have a T-GT II, ​​if i were to buy would be the G PRO by TRue Force. I've already tried a DD PRO but I miss the T-FDB, whether it's fake, lose detail or whatever, the immersion in Gran Turismo is another level. Maybe buy it when the price of the G PRO with pedals goes down.
@Substance2020
@Substance2020 Год назад
I went from the logitech G25 to the T-GT2 and was devastated by the notchyness of it- it's terrible. Never been happy with it so I ordered the Gpro today. Never did or will get to try the T-FDB though. Pretty stupid that it was only for GT.
@teggsy2165
@teggsy2165 Год назад
I found a very useful household item to protect the pins and connectors on the G PRO base it's your average spray can lid ie body spray can furniture polish can it was not hard to find a perfect fit you may have a choice of different colour lids lying around will keep your pins ect safe.
@vincenttremblay2483
@vincenttremblay2483 Год назад
Got the dd pro gt but didn’t liked much the pedals so bought the clubsport v3 inverted with another damper kit added, feels much better
@TheLaughingLion
@TheLaughingLion Год назад
Looks like the Logitech G wins this head to head comparison because of the high quality true force feature. It's a fascinating performance comparison and in the beginning, i thought the seasoned Fanatec would win out. like 345
@SSmallwood
@SSmallwood Год назад
is this a joke? true force is a gimmick lol.
@thecow8824
@thecow8824 Год назад
@@SSmallwood It's only a gimmick to people who won't benefit from it. If you're using the wheel for casual racing games then yea, true force won't do you much good. If you're using the wheel to do some actual sim racing and want to improve your lap times, having physical feedback of when your tires are slipping in the corners or on the brakes is a massive advantage.
@BenFilley
@BenFilley Год назад
@@thecow8824 lol if you cant feel when your tires are scrubbing from the wheel itself then the gimmick of truforce isnt going to help you any. ffs im on a csl elite thats coming up on a decade old and feel front end scrub no problem. trueforce is a gimmick.
@richpoor146
@richpoor146 Год назад
@@BenFilley dude, it’s glaringly obvious your opinion is extremely bias due to the fact that you do not have the ability to experience this. Lol.
@BenFilley
@BenFilley Год назад
@@richpoor146 think what you want. I have 20 years of racing real cars under my belt. Not just pretend ones. It’s a gimmick.
@viperx220racing3
@viperx220racing3 Год назад
I’m currently using a Fanatic DDpro with Shifter & Handbrake. Only playing on console for me the biggest plus is both PS & Xbox/PC compatibility. I have a NLR HF8 pad for haptic feedback all for less than the Logitech set up. They definitely need to lower their prices to be more competitive 🤔
@JWalker379
@JWalker379 Год назад
Does it work with PS5? I couldn't any info about compatibility. Simhub?
@PageCrowes
@PageCrowes 11 месяцев назад
​@JWalker379 yes, I'm using gt dd pro ps5 gt7 with nlr hf8 thru simhub for real-time live haptic feedback. It's awesome with vr2. The immersion hf8 gives is incredible with all the options.
@viperx220racing3
@viperx220racing3 11 месяцев назад
@@PageCrowes I need to look at running the HF8 through sim hub. I’m currently using sound only through a DAC. I use Sim Tools for my traction loss motion system in GT7. So I’m already running telemetry on PC 🤔
@michaeljamieson3582
@michaeljamieson3582 Год назад
I love the stiffness on the fanatic lc, it’s an instant pressure response. If there were any more travel I’d probably be more inclined to lock up more.
@heddshot87
@heddshot87 Год назад
I just bought the T300RS. A more priceworthy upgrade to go belt driven from gear driven.
@radiospank
@radiospank Год назад
Ordered the g pro over moza r12, Logitech is a complete package and it feels awesome. I do feel the 11 nm of torque is nice to have and sometimes I have to dial it down on certain cars so imo, the Logitech true force feedback coupled with their high quality pedals and wheel make it a perfect match for me. I don’t care so much for a variety of wheels but perhaps you do. I think the g pro wheel is awesome with the quick release and the magnetic shifters 😊
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Nice enjoy!
@natedagreat6704
@natedagreat6704 Год назад
Yeah but theirs no good shifter or a hand break with the g pro?
@radiospank
@radiospank Год назад
@@natedagreat6704 honestly I don’t care, I enjoy just the paddles and it’s faster then shifter anyway
@des6631
@des6631 9 месяцев назад
So true. But I'm gagging for a F1 wheel.
@christian_clark
@christian_clark 9 месяцев назад
@@natedagreat6704truthfully I think people buying the pro probably have a pc and can use other peripherals in tandem with the Logitech over usb
@edwinvandenberg3633
@edwinvandenberg3633 Год назад
I have both. The DD pro's wheel is cheap and you notice that after hours of racing. The steering wheel lining crumbles and I am already working on my second wheel but it is just as bad. And the aftermarked sale is not their best side either. The Logitech base is big but it doesn't bother me. The pedals are good, the steering wheel is good and the treuforce also works well with the FFB. And the compability with non-racing games is also fine. Just try to get the DDpro decent with Snowrunner, it won't work because the screen keeps spinning. I am now happily playing with the Logitech and am going to sell the DD pro. Hopefully Logitech will come out with a formula wheel soon. I think most people are negative about Logitech because it's Logitech. Most are hyped by Fanatec but forget that Fanatec is also just a relatively entry-level brand.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Thanks for sharing your experience!
@reviewforthetube6485
@reviewforthetube6485 6 месяцев назад
You csn adjust the load cell at least you used to be able to on fanatec. Just had to get the extra pieces of rubber.
@enmitynz4613
@enmitynz4613 Год назад
I am in a predicament where I feel like my logical step would be to go Fanatec as I already am using a mash up of Fanatec V3 Pedals, Fanatec Shifter, but a rather old school Thrustmaster T500RS wheelbase with all of it's belt driven notchiness. So I should probably get a fanatec DD wheelbase and wheel. That way I could just plug all my gear into the wheelbase and only have to worry about the single connection to my PC for my regualr sim mracing titles (AC, ACC and Automobilista 2)however I do plan on getting a Ps5 for gran turismo 7 also which is the next part of my predicament. I hate dealing with Fanatec when things go wrong, and it takes ever so long to get the products I want from them in my country. And they really do love to hammer the absolute crap out of us with shipping costs. I really love my H-shifter and the V3 Fanatec pedals are just much better pedals in general than the ones Logitech provide according to most reviewers I have checked out. So switching to Logitech I would lose the shifter and have to solely use paddle shifters on GT7 which takes a lot away from the experience if you are driving cars that have H-Shifter in real life (which I just have always found much more fun to drive with) So I dunno, If Logitech brought out a really nice H-Shifter then I would probably be like f*ck it, sell all my gear and just go all out Logitech because that Trueforce really does sound like a game changer according to all the reviews I have seen. but right now, it does seem that for me and my current situation, Fanatec would make the most sense and it kinda pains me.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Thanks for sharing your experience with Fanatec I'd say hang on until the end of the year. I recon Logitech will introduce some new stuff by then if they don't go for the Fanatec route. I really do wish Logitech introduced more accessories early on just would have made it easier for console gamers to choose.
@BluD
@BluD Год назад
almost all of the issues fanatec has been having has been everything but the wheelbase. so id say go for it.
@buzzbuzzard3809
@buzzbuzzard3809 Год назад
@@GeekStreet So with AC2 being due for release in 2024 what sort of deals do you see coming up from Logitech, Fanatec etc. in terms of good prices with current offers as well as new wheels perhaps cuz I´m thinking on holding out on buying something new until then.
@enmitynz4613
@enmitynz4613 Год назад
@@jeffreybankers3988 thanks for your comment man, yeah I have seen that Truforce is considered terrible in pretty much every game/Sim...other than gt7 where apparently it is implemented and supported very well in that title. But it's not a huge draw for me as I am primarily a PC Sim racer. I just love having the ability to use the wheel on console if need be. My best bet at this stage is the fanatec DD Pro, since I already have fanatec pedals, and shifter.
@carlitosverduzco3643
@carlitosverduzco3643 11 месяцев назад
Yeah what a predicament, I’ll tell you what I would do but just my opinion ok. I would sale all my fanatic and go all out with logic tech. Why? Bc you want to play with or on something that your going to be the most happy and satisfied with. Plus your only goin yo spend that money once, after all is said and done and bought 😂 your going to feel like a champ playing on something you truly wanted. Go with your gut felling even if it’s goin to cost you more money F it you only live once right. I’m going all Logictech; yeah I think it’s to expensive but F it I’m just goin to save up for it little by little than Bam I will have it ohhh yeah.
@giogamer4825
@giogamer4825 Год назад
I have the Fanatec DD Pro 8nm, V2.5 formula wheel with V3 pedals (mod to 2 pedals) on my reinforced Playseat Challenge. Love it. I play ACC, GT7 and F1 on Ps5
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Nice!
@blastu2fool
@blastu2fool Год назад
I have a question Bro, I have a CSl Elite hub and ClubSport Pedals V3 (CSP_V3) setup with the playstation wheel ..I assumed everything should work with the PS5 but what's crazy is everything lights up even seeing the speed on top of the steering wheel...not understanding how I can't steer the cars, like I can do it from the duelsense but I can't figure why it's not working out ..I even the peddles are not connecting any ideas on what you think I should do ? I would love to have the DD Pro but my setup is practically new. I just haven't been using it as much..
@giogamer4825
@giogamer4825 Год назад
@@blastu2fool Hey, not sure what you mean with Elite hub? But, the DD Pro works perfect on the Ps5 and V3 pedals, no issue on this side. I dont know if you have different compatibility options on your base/wheel, as I do have on the DD Pro. I have to put it on "blue" light to use it on Ps5, otherwise "purple" for games like F1 2021, as the DD Pro does not support the DD Pro native, so purple light is compatibility mode on the DD Pro. If I can help in some way, let me know
@giogamer4825
@giogamer4825 Год назад
@@blastu2fool 1 more thing, for me to have the DD Pro be reconise on the Ps5 everytime, I have to first press the "PS" button on the wheel. Just like your Dualsense controller. Do you do that?
@blastu2fool
@blastu2fool Год назад
@giogamer4825 I had sent you a response awhile ago saying I was trying to avoid buying the DD Pro because I have the CSL Elite but I think I may have to pull the trigger ...the thing really didn't use my set up as much so going to buy dd pro at 600 is not the ideal thing at the moment...as yo your question about Ps button for a start up i have to try it and see what happens
@calvin12112000
@calvin12112000 Год назад
I am a Fanatec owner and own the GT DD pro, boost kit, load cell and shiter. Exact one in the video. I cannot recommend Fanatec. The shifter has a common mis shifter problem. The load cell pedal stop working after 9 months. Updated: Both shifter and load cell pedal went back to Fanatec for repair and working at the moment. Now the Wheel starting to have problem with PS5, which will disconnect very freqrently. Sometime every 2 seconds. I have done the fanatec 're-seating' as per their video but same problem would still occur. Having 1 deflective product is unlucky, 2 is a coincident, 3 is consistent. That is saying something about Fanatec product.
@Bautistatwins
@Bautistatwins Год назад
Are you still experiencing this issue?
@snoopy_peanuts_77
@snoopy_peanuts_77 7 месяцев назад
If you turned off trueforce are you really getting a fair comparison? Trueforce is part of the appeal of that wheel...its a big feature....its a huge advantage for the wheel in comparison
@AL71B
@AL71B Год назад
Great review. But I’m surprised at the movement in that rig. Not what I expected to see at all.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Thanks, yeah my bad with that I realised 2 weeks some of the bolts on there weren't tight as I'd previously made some adjustments.
@notsure2211
@notsure2211 4 месяца назад
Ha! Even a year late, I stand for MOZA wheels. The main reasons are: - Access; - Price; - Extras; - Variety.
@samgao
@samgao Год назад
I’ve banked on the Logitech g pro wheel under the assumption that it’ll eventually get a shifter and perhaps an e-brake. Also bought the next level gaming GTElite rig with a chair
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Nice!
@bryanrobles87
@bryanrobles87 Год назад
Anyone bought the Logitech and experienced a horrible ship time? I placed an order over a week ago and the items have not shipped yet. They also don’t know when my items will ship. Their customer service personnel are very polite, but so far all I get is “your order is approved and being processed, everything is in stock but being processed “.
@diggsasura
@diggsasura Год назад
I have the G Pro for PS5 and I think it's really good - HOWEVER, it's getting closer to Forza 8 release and we still haven't had a single word about a replacement wheel for it! I plan to play that on Xbox. I tried to talk to Logitech on several occasions but they show absolutely no interest in easing this issue. They won't even confirm it will be more wheels as of end of March 2023. This is insane if you ask me and I'm gonna jump to Fanatec if nothing happens this spring. I would assume they would release a McLaren F1 wheel due to their collaboration but not a single word there either. Frustrating Logitech, frustrating. This on top of super poor customer support, and straight up lies about their delivery date on page.
@mraycgz
@mraycgz Год назад
Same as you, but I think they’ll put out a wheel we can swap, and I’m not exactly sure about Forza yet anyway lol.
@bwavert
@bwavert Год назад
Get a Brook Ras1ution 2 converter and you’re good
@playstationracer67
@playstationracer67 11 месяцев назад
It is now October 2023 and I am undecided and I have been reaching out to Logitech about any plans for new wheels, shifter, etc. I am getting absolutely no where - total silence.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet 11 месяцев назад
I've spoken to my contacts there and no news on this so far
@des6631
@des6631 9 месяцев назад
Argh. I need an F1 wheel! Love this unit tho
@RJ-cq8dd
@RJ-cq8dd Год назад
Had some bad recent experience with Fanatec customer service. Went with the Logi Pro wheel and i love it! The FF feeling is just so good and detailed. And i love they went with hard leather on the rim. Now i dont have to wear gloves to not wear it out like alcantera rims.
@Bobbarker23455
@Bobbarker23455 Год назад
I had great customer service with Fanatec
@RJ-cq8dd
@RJ-cq8dd Год назад
@@Bobbarker23455 i had a hardly used csl pedal set v1 (with potentiometers). The potentiometers have a habit of breaking down. I wanted to order a couple from them so i would be safe for a while (and save on shipping €10 and handling €10 costs). But instead Fanatec insisted i ordered just one every time. Screw that.
@Bobbarker23455
@Bobbarker23455 Год назад
@@RJ-cq8dd seems fishy on your part honestly
@RJ-cq8dd
@RJ-cq8dd Год назад
@@Bobbarker23455 lol why? I had a faulty potentiometer after hardly using the pedals. So it is only logical to order some spares for the inevitable (and save money like i said). You sound like a Fanatec fanboy to me.
@talon1706
@talon1706 Год назад
@@Bobbarker23455 Lol.
@Q50BeastTv
@Q50BeastTv Год назад
Best Wheel Great Video as my DD Pro is on the way. Stepping up from a G920, and T150!
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
❤️
@nunoferraz
@nunoferraz Год назад
Great video! But I have to say 2 things: 1) The Fanatec GT DD Pro (and the CSL DD) can not be mounted on the front! Just side mounting or the base. 2) The Trackracer TR120 cockpit looks great and you state as it has "zero flex", but at 7m41s with Fanatec and at 7m50s with Logitech, we can see the base and the aluminium profiles going sideways. Why is this aluminium profile cockpit having so much flex?
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
The cockpit was previously dismantled and re-assembled but I didnt fully tighen the the bars holding the wheel mount at the sides and only realised a few weeks later hence the movement
@davebell771
@davebell771 Год назад
I prefer the logitech and I'll let you know why. Having previously owned a simucibe Pro 2 I always found 14nm was my preferred strength. I would turn down the ffb in games as it would be to strong at that nm. However the dynamic range was just better, like weight transfer etc. Also having owned in the past a csl dd, I liked it but found the 8nm to low comparing to the sc2 Pro. Maybe not a fair comparison. Now going on to the logitech that I currently have. I like my bumps to be more dampaned so always ran every base with high filters to make the bumps less abrupt but would also lose some effects as a downside. What I have found logitech does super well is have that filtered feeling by changing settings and then with true force, having the nice bumps too. So after some testing I actually prefer the logitech over the sc2, which Iam surprised about as I thought it would be more on par with a csl dd. Having said all that I think each wheel can suit each individual differently. So the best wheel is what suits you :)
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Thanks for sharing your experience and your right different wheels can suit each individual differently.
@FreakCanal
@FreakCanal Год назад
@Infinity Dave ....Definitively you dont know how to set SC2Pro. What you are saying is just nonsense.
@davebell771
@davebell771 Год назад
@@FreakCanal I had a SC2 for about 2 years I certainly do know how to set it up for what felt best for me. It is a really great base, I just prefer the Logitech with the statements I mentioned above. You don't have to agree and imagine you have never tried the Logitech for a long period of time? Which is okay as it's all subjective but certainly not wrong from my perspective.
@DonVincenzooGame
@DonVincenzooGame Год назад
fell the bumper and still having amazing details is exactly what i need ! ty
@sonyx5332
@sonyx5332 10 месяцев назад
Do you have any recommended settings?
@fernegri
@fernegri Год назад
So... I am looking to upgrade my G29. Maybe Logitech base/wheel and keep the gear shift plus the Logitech G Racing adapter to keep my old pedals and shifter for now. way cheaper than change to a Fanatec system.
@chadharris6625
@chadharris6625 Год назад
I feel maybe the logitech base should have been compared to the simagic alpha mini! I know this is for consoles but still would make a great comparison. Fanatec has gone downhill big time with their products
@glovebox9000
@glovebox9000 Год назад
Yeah, my next wheel is gonna be a Moza R5(.5?)
@KnowerofThings
@KnowerofThings Год назад
Since im not planning to spend a fortune, logitech g pro is the best option. If i went with fanatec, i might be tempted to get other wheels and upgrades. I feel like with fanatec you will pay a little less now but you will be paying more at the end. Also, true force sounds very interesting to me since i have a buttkicker and enjoys it alot, having a butt kicker device for the wheel is such a bonus. To save some money, i plan to skip the logitech pedal and use my current g27 pedal instead since it was upgraded with truebrake mod giving it a loadcell feel already.
@schullestulle3360
@schullestulle3360 Год назад
Just take a closer look to the logitech wheel-base conection, close to the fanatec one. More wheels confirmend imo! :D
@azazaz8220
@azazaz8220 Год назад
But the dd pro is cheaper
@hoihoi13
@hoihoi13 Год назад
I’m thinking to just get the wheel and use my old g29 pedal. So how is your experience using the wheel + d27 pedal? Is it annoying to set up with the adapter?
@KnowerofThings
@KnowerofThings Год назад
@@hoihoi13 i found a used csw 2.5 very happy i didnt spend so much but the upgrade feels amazing compare to g27. i didnt need an adaptor, i just keep the g27 usb plugged into the pc you dont even need the power supply and the wheel still works just no force feedback. the g27 pedal and shifter works flawlessly with csw 2.5.
@sonyx5332
@sonyx5332 10 месяцев назад
I'm looking into adding at least two bass shakers to my rig that I use with the console but I don't know which amp to get. Do you have any recommendations?
@abbasiiftikhar34
@abbasiiftikhar34 8 месяцев назад
Logitech has recently introduced G racing adapter where you could use shifter and pedals from Previous generations with G pro wheels.
@tonybucca5667
@tonybucca5667 Год назад
My G27 (bought in 2015) is in death throes, so I'm looking at DDs. I advise people on camera purchases, and your review showed the pros and cons clearly! I am waiting on a real estate transaction, then I can jump into the DD ocean. I like the idea of the different wheels..Fanatec is looking good
@Alejandro_Palomo
@Alejandro_Palomo 6 месяцев назад
I went finally for the Logitech PRO.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet 6 месяцев назад
👌
@hughxthexhand
@hughxthexhand Год назад
I own them both, also fanatec DD1, moza R9, R16, simucube 2 sport and accuforce v2. I chose the Logitech Pro over the CSL DD with boost kit any day
@DanBallard
@DanBallard Год назад
How does the G pro compare to the Moza R16 or Simucube 2? I know different price points, but same ball park? I just got the g pro as a first serious wheelbase and love it, but wondering if I made the right choice. I use it at 11 and wouldn’t mind just a bit more, plus it’s so limited with wheels. Thanks
@dilip_1997
@dilip_1997 Год назад
How does the Logitech pro compare with the dd1, I would like to know , please!
@seebarry4068
@seebarry4068 Год назад
I’d be happy with either. I prefer the fanatec.
@Heisenberg0086
@Heisenberg0086 2 месяца назад
Would it be a risk to purchase from Fanatek at the moment? Was going to buy a GT DD pro for GT7 but wondering if I’m best going for logitech G Pro instead?
@DanTinnin
@DanTinnin 5 месяцев назад
Do you have any time spent on the Logitech G Pro and Pedals on IRacing. I'm having all kinds of issues. FFB, RPM LIGHTS. BUTTON MAPPING. All the reviews seem to be done on Grand Turismo. Any help would be much appreciated. I have gotten no response back from Logitech Support for these questions
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet 5 месяцев назад
Have you tried uninstalling the Logitech G Hub app and reinstall and check for firmware updates?
@alejandromontoyavel
@alejandromontoyavel Год назад
Can we emulate the TrueForce experience just by adjusting settings on the Fanatec? or what kind of changes does the true force does? more power? more level of detail? what really means to activate true force? (please do not answer just because it feels better... I don't know what means that)
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
I'd describe trueforce as more detail, and more coming though in vibration. If you had a simcockpit you could feel this vibrations in the frame.
@GeNetiX9871
@GeNetiX9871 Год назад
can we use the logitech g pro wheel with the fanatec pedals cause they are less expensive
@MajorOSC
@MajorOSC Год назад
Host; "11 Nm may be a bit much..." OSW owners; "hold my beer..."
@Jive_Mahoaney
@Jive_Mahoaney 6 месяцев назад
Great review. Helped me to make up my mind to order a logitech cause I've been waiting weeks for the fantec I ordered to even ship and it was in stock when I placed the order. Of course no way to get in contact with fanatec, so whenever they decide to ship it I'm just going to ship it right back. Logitech will be here in two days. I'm looking forward to trying that thrust feedback. Thanks.
@axxion231
@axxion231 2 месяца назад
How do you like the pro wheel?
@mikekorean5687
@mikekorean5687 11 месяцев назад
from your video, I can see logitech seems too shaking even on the straight road. seems too strong unnecessary feedback.
@leighdog5866
@leighdog5866 Год назад
"best wheel" that rig had some play in it compared to the f-gt elite ? ive upgrade my dd pro wheel to magnetic shifters for about 20.00 dollars , i also have the metal fanatec pedal covers over the factory plastic ones , also added a 3rd party parts springs & bushes to the load cell & throttle pedal which i feel made my csl pedals as good as any on the market , i have the 8nm boost kit , normally set at half in the in game settings , i find if u have the settings set to high or pedals to stiff , u will fatigue to quickly & reduce ur overall race lengths & gaming sessions , good video though which i thought was very fair , both have pros cons , if i was a noob again i would go with fanatec
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
The the Logitech wheel I had the force feedback on max and the TrueForce and had some play I'm suspecting this could be because I have the rig on wheels. I'm working on a permanent fixed location for the rig where the wheels will be removed so it should interesting to see if that makes a difference.
@leighdog5866
@leighdog5866 Год назад
@@GeekStreet i use wheels aswell on myn, it looked from the video it was moving around thats all , maybe the logitech is just a monster.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
@@leighdog5866 yeah the Logitech is a beast 😂
@patrickcanny2500
@patrickcanny2500 4 месяца назад
Best wheel?.... haven't bought yet... like the look and reviews of the logitech.
@jacylegault1713
@jacylegault1713 Год назад
Isn't the Logitec pro wheel and pedals price nearly twice the fanatec kit you tested? For the same price you can get a nicer wheel, pedals, and PS5/Xbox/PC compatibility.
@MichaelBd39
@MichaelBd39 Год назад
Buying the Logi when it goes on sale,,as I bought the G25 six months after it came out, at first sale-And still use it everyday
@aarongreen121
@aarongreen121 3 месяца назад
Hey dude, like I H-H-HATE using damper on wheels as you tend to lose surface details of the road but your wheels are oscillating to such a CRAZY extent 😂😂😂 you gotta chill out! Try using a bit of damper to smoothen out the FFB, that can't be good for the shafts on the wheel.
@rusty4104
@rusty4104 Год назад
If you buy both logitech pro wheels and pedals you get $100 discount and free shipping if you're in the lower 48 states. So for $200 more than the fanatec (figuring in shipping) you get adjustable pedals and true force not to mention a stronger servo. I was sold on the fanatec until I saw how everyone was raving about trueforce. Logitech pro will be coming to my house in the near future.
@TeaPea111
@TeaPea111 Год назад
I bought the Logitech after waiting months for the fanatec to come back into stock, happy so far!
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
It’s a real shame fanatec has so many supply chain issues
@TeaPea111
@TeaPea111 Год назад
@@GeekStreet sign of the times.
@TeaPea111
@TeaPea111 Год назад
@@GeekStreet I just hope Logitech bring out more accessories for the pro wheel, hopefully it’s selling well!
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
@@TeaPea111 yeah pretty sure they will
@RefrigeratedTP
@RefrigeratedTP Год назад
the quick release comparison is hilariously short. I have a CSL DD and the QR fanatec is using is awful. Any review of a Fanatec setup should include the price of upgrading to a metal QR. the plastic QR WILL break with a DD base. It's just a matter of time. You end up purchasing a metal QR either way. I'm not a hater I promise. I love my fanatec gear. It's just not perfect without spending a bit more.
@IamMarkSmith
@IamMarkSmith 11 месяцев назад
Great review. Thank you!
@lukescrapwalker
@lukescrapwalker Год назад
Nice review.... just a small point... 1000hz vs how much from the Fanatec?
@richardherrera9528
@richardherrera9528 Год назад
I went from g29 to fanatec dd pro 5nm with McLaren wheel and hurt my shoulders so can imagine what 11nm would do. if ur looking to just have fun go with fanatec price wise and can play Xbox n PC so why not
@X314G
@X314G Год назад
This makes me feel like my recent purchase for a Fanatec DD2 setup that supports 25nm of force feedback is severe overkill😂😂 can't wait to get it!!
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
😂
@dbzcollector9963
@dbzcollector9963 Год назад
Those things will snap your wrist if your not careful lol
@BenFilley
@BenFilley Год назад
@@dbzcollector9963 buddy, maybe YOUR wrists, but most peoples wrists arent made of dry spaghetti. its 18 ftlb. thats so little lol.
@dbzcollector9963
@dbzcollector9963 Год назад
@@BenFilley 18 ftlb is more than enough to snap your wrist if you suddenly hit a wall and your not ready for it. Just like how a 30 mph car crash can cause a concussion, maybe you should go back to school and learn some basic human anatomy.
@BenFilley
@BenFilley Год назад
@@dbzcollector9963 maybe you should try turning a wrench sometime. My smalles torque wrench holds 190ftlb and I use it all day long. 18ftlb is nothing. Spaghetti wrists.
@johncrowder8461
@johncrowder8461 3 месяца назад
What sim is it that you're driving with the logitech? Cheers in advance
@toxic_munchkin8307
@toxic_munchkin8307 Год назад
just sold my logitech set as ive upgraded to asetek invictor . not sim raced before and only had the logitech a couple of months and cant really feel much difference between the to . think logitech pro are under rated but they need to sort the price out and new wheels for the base. brilliant while i had it tho
@thesprawl2361
@thesprawl2361 Год назад
I have the 8nm CSL DD, upgraded from the old CSL Elite, all with the load cell and pedals, and the fana shifter and handbrake, attached to a frame. I use it almost exclusively for Assetto and drifting, and for that it is a definite improvement over the previous belt driven CSL drive. My drifting improved immediately. It is wary too powerful for a table clamp, and tbh it's too powerful at 100% for a frame. It shakes the entire room when I run off-track.
@EbNorth
@EbNorth Год назад
Is the clamp the issue or the table not being heavy? (Enough)
@thesprawl2361
@thesprawl2361 Год назад
@@EbNorth I don't use a table clamp, I use a driving frame, and it's too much at 100% ffb for the frame, which is why I know it's way too much for a clamp.
@thesprawl2361
@thesprawl2361 Год назад
@@EbNorth ...PS the weight of the table would not be the issue I don't think. There's no table stable enough for it, aside from one of those country mansion tables that fifty people sit at. 8nm of torque might not sound like much but it really is.
@lukefisher8417
@lukefisher8417 Год назад
@@thesprawl2361 this is a ridiculous statement. There’s hundreds of videos of streamers and people using it at full strength on tables and on Riggs with zero issue. You probably need some pads underneath your rig or some thing to keep it quiet there’s no reason for it to be so loud.
@thesprawl2361
@thesprawl2361 Год назад
@@lukefisher8417 Are they using the same racing frame I use, on the same kind of wooden floor, at 100%? Are they drifting, which involves constant use of left foot braking, with an first gen Fanatec load cell which takes an enormous amount of pressure, and which also which means positioning the frame flush against the nearest solid object because of the force required? Do they have the full 8nm of torque unlocked? If you say yes to all of those things and maintain that no-one has any problems with the scale of the FFB then I am calling either you or them a liar or an idiot.
@martineering.evoluzione
@martineering.evoluzione 4 месяца назад
True Force in Logitech simply eat exaggerated Fanatec on breakfast easily... You should test this on the real racing SIM games like AC or ACC where Logitech with his brilliant true force surprisingly or not is a mile ahead and far way superior from the Fanatec. GT7 is a simple arcade game and can't give the same or more realistic feelings like ACC which use the potential of the true force that's Fanatec can only dream about.
@vigorgaming8
@vigorgaming8 Год назад
I like the Logitech Pro wheel but it's way too expensive
@jordy700
@jordy700 7 месяцев назад
@geekstreet Is your wheel calibration correctly? Mine is slightly off to the left and it's very annoying... 😅
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet 7 месяцев назад
Yes both mine are calibrated, just connect to a pc and get it done, think you can also do directly from the wheel base
@Cwomack07
@Cwomack07 Год назад
Hey Geek Street! I think you may need a slight update on this. I just ordered the Pro wheel & pedals & Logitech gave a $88 discount on the set ordered together.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Nice enjoy!
@Cwomack07
@Cwomack07 Год назад
@@GeekStreet yeah it will be dedicated to console .. Gran Turismo 7 on PS5 …… maybe ACC down the line
@DileepaDilshan
@DileepaDilshan Год назад
Please tell me what is the best wheel to buy for pc..?
@JL-cn1qi
@JL-cn1qi 3 месяца назад
Quite a bit of wobble on our steeringwheel for it being mounted on such a massive rig.
@morbid1.
@morbid1. Год назад
this "trueforce" is very interesting... question is can be implemented for other wheels or is to closed format only for logitech
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
As far as I'm aware its just Logitech only.
@stoicllc2352
@stoicllc2352 11 месяцев назад
You are overlooking logitec ghub software. It makes it very easy to play and maintain update and custom setting wise.
@grpi8131
@grpi8131 Год назад
Cool review. Could You link those gloves ?
@keeganjacobs5913
@keeganjacobs5913 4 месяца назад
i don't like wheel shaking back and forth even going on straight line. Is that a setting you can adjust on that?
@one2tumble
@one2tumble 8 месяцев назад
“It has very smooth operation” (saws at wheel uncontrollably) 😂 Good review tho. 👍
@spawnandbatman6975
@spawnandbatman6975 Год назад
So if I were to go either route fanatec or Logitech. How do I get any of these two setups to work with both Xbox and ps5, maybe even pc?
@itsschiegg
@itsschiegg 9 месяцев назад
Why not compare the Clubsport DD base? The pricing (with wheel) is the same as the Logitech, force is the same, etc. It's a closer comparison
@ContentComposer
@ContentComposer Год назад
Pondering between these two. GT DD Pro has a better wheel rotation (Euro Truck Simulator 2) and is more compact for my temporary simrig solution (Playseat Challenge). G Pro has TrueForce and larger wheel size and is more easily available. Many of the racing games I play supports TrueForce, on both PC and PS5.
@hoihoi13
@hoihoi13 Год назад
Which one you bought finally? I have a playseat challenge too so whether it can handle these wheels play a big factor..
@ContentComposer
@ContentComposer Год назад
@@hoihoi13 Neither. Fanatec was out of stock and G Pro too expensive. I did choose Thrustmaster GT-II for 599€ (discount). Well actually 625€ after VAT change. It works with Playseat Challenge and the wheel's features are good, but it feels a little too expensive for what it is. Maybe for 499-550€ it could be recommended.
@hoihoi13
@hoihoi13 Год назад
@@ContentComposer I’m looking at this one too, in mh county it’s actually more expensive than the dd pro can you believe it. How r u liking it anyway? It’s belt drive good enough you think and does it get overheat like the t300?
@ContentComposer
@ContentComposer Год назад
@@hoihoi13 It does cost 849€ in my country also. Way expensive. I haven't really stress tested it and only used it with GT7. I'm using around 60-70 % torque and have not noticed it to lose power with these settings. I should try some other games too to know how much force experience depends on the wheel and how much it is about the game. If I would have had a working setup, I would have preferred to wait for the Fanatec. Anyway, I've had fun, won races, got near a world record lap time with GT-II and I'm far from a good driver. And I don't think a DD wheel would make me much faster, but it might feel more authentic, who knows.
@Heihei0
@Heihei0 Год назад
How do you Connect logitech g920 to iPhone or Samsung?
@stivenostas1185
@stivenostas1185 Год назад
Informative video!
@garnettslick1458
@garnettslick1458 Год назад
Great video bro thanks 😊 👍🏻 🙏🏼 👌
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
❤️
@andrewhiggins5262
@andrewhiggins5262 Год назад
Thankyou il be going for the Logitech 👍🏻
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
Nice, enjoy!
@MH-rn1tp
@MH-rn1tp Год назад
What stand are you all using for the pro wheel and pedals . I just got the pro but haven't set it up yet.
@Evo187
@Evo187 8 месяцев назад
why is the 1.5k€ wheel the only one out there with a nice real race car looking wheel out of box.. but if you want to use it on a pc and ps5 the gt dd pro is the most practical with the 4 sticks becaus you have 20 buttons alone there to remap
@Ride__OutRR
@Ride__OutRR 6 месяцев назад
I want to order fanatec but do they ship orders? Ive read so many bad reviews about people waiting forever to get there order. Anyone have issues with this in the U.S.?
@tijssens
@tijssens Год назад
Do logitech sell other steering wheels? I can't find any on their site?
@daud_christian
@daud_christian 6 месяцев назад
Like your video, Im just curious why you put your left foot on brake pedal?
@ktbeatty
@ktbeatty 6 месяцев назад
Don't go down that road! I made the mistake once. I came up learning to drive and never use the left foot for braking. I had a clutch as often as not anyway, so wasn't even an option. However, I've come to find that brake left foot, gas right foot is actually the preferred method in sim racing. I'll never be able to undo all that muscle memory, but it's what all the cool kids do now!
@skiez7430
@skiez7430 2 месяца назад
Left foot braking is preferred for racing and drifting
@f2cmadmaxx
@f2cmadmaxx Год назад
So what's the actual depth of the pro wheel from the desk mount point, backwards? Trying to compare this to the G27 :)
@chrisdettanascar9264
@chrisdettanascar9264 6 месяцев назад
I need a Ad on shifter,, is there one?
@gameurai5701
@gameurai5701 Год назад
I wish there were complete sim-rigs available in the 500-600€ range. I have a G29 and I'm not looking for upgrades that will cost over 1000€ or even just under. I'm a casual racer who is easily 5 secs behind top players racing times in ACC, so I don't really want to have pro gear until I improve several seconds per lap on most tracks.
@RicciardoRossouw
@RicciardoRossouw Год назад
Look at GT omega
@chrisdettanascar9264
@chrisdettanascar9264 Год назад
G pro , work with ps4 and GT7 and Nascar ? Thx
@imwidetoya5206
@imwidetoya5206 6 месяцев назад
Will the fanatec clamp to playseat challenge ?
@SuperSuperka
@SuperSuperka Год назад
Why nothing were told about "dead zone"? On common logitech g29 it was a nightmare, I couldn't bare it. Does these wheels has it?
@UberSynth
@UberSynth Год назад
12:00 why on earth do you keep wiggling the steering like that? 🤔 when I use mine it never makes me do that? It’s like an over exaggerated wiggle. Come on, let’s be real and be truthful.
@billy9995
@billy9995 Год назад
So i got a g29 first wheel ive bought dont like it wanna upgrade. I dont play on asphalt though play the new world of outlaws game and would do like rally racing all on ps4 so which would you feel more suitable? Thanks
@davidasfaha517
@davidasfaha517 Год назад
Is the wheel supposed to twitch like that 8:09 on the straights??
@des6631
@des6631 9 месяцев назад
The GPro is awesome son I fucking adore it
@Andybarney555
@Andybarney555 Год назад
Flex in that rig and wobble is hilarious!! People think these ali rigs are the best...
@mraycgz
@mraycgz Год назад
I have both. Logitech is the better wheel. And they sure are proud of it. Btw learn the track and turn racing lines off. It’s hard to take anyone serious when they can’t be bothered to put an hour into learning the track and braking points.
@mdftx1
@mdftx1 Год назад
I tried out my friend's sim for about a 2 hour session, and he has the fanatec dd, we turned the force feedback down a little from max, and let me tell you, the next day I couldn't lift my arms.
@GeekStreet
@GeekStreet Год назад
What game were you playing?
@BradleyGXP
@BradleyGXP 7 месяцев назад
Mario
Далее
G PRO vs G923 - Which Do You Buy?
24:51
Просмотров 72 тыс.
Ozoda & Dilime - Lada
00:36
Просмотров 1,4 млн
We finally APPROVED @ZachChoi
00:31
Просмотров 3,2 млн
The CRAZIEST Race I've Done at the Nürburgring
30:14
Просмотров 152 тыс.
Don't Waste your Money - $30 vs $10,000 Racing Setup
30:37
I Tested ENDGAME Logitech Upgrades (Console + PC)
31:54
Logitech G923 vs G PRO - Comparison by a PRO Coach
19:07
Ozoda & Dilime - Lada
00:36
Просмотров 1,4 млн