@@jerieljackson8035wth no , first of all her shade of blonde is more yellow and nit the same as rosè’s and second of all blonde is not only rosé’s hair pls grow up
Karina is one of the AESPA members whose voice is the most stable, even during live vocals on stage, her voice doesn't falter, it's very stable, she could even be the main vocalist on another GG, so next time if you want to comment on something, use your brain first.
Gidle would be Miyeon imo. I’m a Soyeon bias and while soyeon has a full voice and always sounds great, she doesn’t have many impressive vocal moments whereas Miyeon is probably the most underrated 4th gen vocalist (coming from an opera singer) her vibrato, her vocal color, her vocals aren’t very impressive in the group as she doesn’t get any parts tailored to her as soyeon struggles to write parts for her but when she does ballads and other softer pieces her vocals truly stand out imo.
Honestly I think that Minnie and Shuhua sing really well. Miyeon sings well but nothing more. I always found that Rosé sings well but it's nothing incredible. Soyeon is also my bias (my ultimate bias) and I think she sings (and especially RAP) really well. She is really stable. Miyeon too. Minnie really has an incredible voice, she hits the high notes well. Example: Lion. Miyeon too Example: MAMA AWARDS 2023 . I always preferred Minnie's voice. Shuhua sings really well (in addition to being an incredible visual artist), she is not always stable, but she demonstrates these talents several times. Besides, why would Cube Entertainment choose which debut if they don't have the talent? Anyway, sorry, I got scattered
@@JEONSOYEONQueen Minnie has a smaller range than Miyeon and Yuqi. Shuhua is the worst vocalist in gidle when it comes to technique. Just because you prefer their timbre doesn’t mean they’re the better vocalist. Yuqi even has better technique than Minnie. Yuqi actually has a larger supported range but Miyeon has better technique in general. If gidles positions were correct Minnie would be a lead vocalist but a stylistic one like nayeon that gets to do highnotes from time to time 🤷♀️ obviously all the girls are talented but objectively Miyeon has the best technique.
You're right. But still I think if we only consider live vocal Soyeon actually know how to handle and pop up with her voice better. Maybe it's because she's a rapper. Miyeon live vocal sound bless but sometimes when she has too much schedule it's become less stable. 😢😢😢
@@MBJK_baby yeah, i don't talk about her technique. It's perfect. I just said that if we consider only the live vocal, stability is one of the factor to put on the table.
@@_EUNZUHA_ wrong abt what? Every group has a worst vocalist no matter what and ahyeon has that annoying nasal voice. And if ahyeon is not the worst in baemon, then who is??
The standards for these idols have fallen clearly, the fact that the "best vocals" in some of these groups still sounded mid and even off key. Beauty before talent is the motto for some of these agencies. Even after 10+ years of being a kpop fan, SM & YG still produces good quality groups and music
winter has always been the most stable in live, ningning before was stable but she had shaky vocals for example coachella. winter sounds exactly like studio version however since spicy nn has improved a lot
I'm sorry but the worst vocalist in Le Sserafim is Eunchae, although only Sakura's vocal is paid attention to, Eunchae is less stable, She doesn't control her breathing at all, she doesn't hit any notes, Eunchae is worse vocally than Sakura. You watch the performances and it's obvious that she doesn't know how to sing at all.
@@svnkyz9692not because she's an opera singer and you call her the best in the group💀Chaewon's live vocals are even better than Yunjin's (and Chaewon often gets high note parts)
Bro literally eunchae gets less hate about her vocals because she’s an actual minor. She has time to work on it.(not saying she’s the best or anything but not saying she’s the worst either)As in sakuras case she’s been in the industry for a hot minute and has been using bad vocal technique for awhile that has messed up her vocals over time.(also no hate to sakura)
Momo has great vocals Sometimes the songs are not in her comfortable range Judging her just because of few encore stages doesn't mean she's bad at singing. Her natural voice is actually good. JYPE doesn't let her sing in her natural voice
Moka is actually not bad, she only cried during the encore, if you really look for the right information, you can find out that Moka is talented at singing when she sings on Survival Runext.
Worst doesn't have to mean bad just least good, so for aespa i'd say its Giselle even though her singing is far better than like 70% of current idols 😭
Because she doesn't sing . She uses her voice in the MVs melody and tbh her vocal isn't bad actually it's sm material so when he said no one tbh it's no one
Giselle is rapper but sometimes SM give her some vocal parts especially adlibs even though she has stable voice I want SM to give her more parts in the future
@@khckxfbfs384 having deep and husky voice Doesn't mean that she is not a great vocalist 😂 She is .. In fact in many aespa songs she showed her powerful vocals if u have listened to the whole songs instead of the chorus through shorts then you know what vocals she really have 😒😏
Moka does not have the worst vocal cords its just she and the other members just fit the dark concept more then this cute and bubbly concept and hybe is just forcing them to do this bubbly concept other wise if its like villan or a badass type concept they would have rocked their vocalism and etc
But didn't the other idols shown here sound the same right....I justfound it same. Aespa - it's even hard to hear. Twice- struggling with breathing. And in illit she atleast spelled the syllables right. I'm not hating . Cause I haven't seen other performances of them. I just said by seeing the given ones.
@@Julik_BPkkk what does copying blackpink have to do with this? This is not about how original they are, this is about talent. And you act as if illit did not copy newjeans
yeah tbh when i saw them live the weakest vocals were definitely either Eunchae or Kazuha. i think people are unfair to Sakura and discredit her too much
@@user-eb1xy6cl9m ? I don't think you've ever tried to ACTUALLY listen to their song except the same 4-5 clips of not so good singing of only some part of the performance
I have suggestion to make it better that it was cause it’s already great instead of worse you can use can improve and Best bb it it’s your opinion to use which one so ya btw great Video idea
She trained in yg for 3 months, stop giving the credit of her hardwork to yg. If yg could actually make star vocalists in 3 months, jisoo would've been a good vocalist 🤡
Wdym just look at the Coachella FIRST OF ALL GIRL in Coachella Sakura had a one of the best stable vocal you can watch again are u blind there was a Eanchue and Kazuha which has a worst vocal and @@Flwrtzu
@@nayana4393 If you can’t spell Eunchae then I highly doubt you know anything abt vocals. Js because other members were worse doesn’t change the fact that sakuras live vocals aren’t good. It’s a fact that *some* delusional fearnots can’t accept xx
@@nayana4393 chaewon has the best vocal in coachella and in other performances. And just bc other ppl are worse doesn't mean u are good. If someone gets an F on a test then someone else gets a D, obviously the person that got the D is better but that doesn't take away the fact that getting a D is bad. Pls fearnots are so defensive and they always fail at it
I had heard people talking about Moka singing in cursive and now I see what they mean. Absolutely adorable girl, don’t mean to be rude to her, I’m sure she’s great. But it did make me giggle bc I never understood what the phrase meant until now.
@@kpop_palaceOh crap not u again. Momo sounds really good in her Japanese subunit with Sana and Mina the problem is just that in twice the lines she gets are way out of her range which obviously makes her sound bad cause she want support that range
@@kpop_palace you literally just said she is the worse and don’t come at me with the “being the worse don’t mean she is bad” cause I didn’t say she was a bad singer either
It’s just that it wasn’t in their vocal range and if ur a kpop fan ur supposed to like kpop groups not be mean to them and then yall each other Kpop fans like bro 😢
illit has a huge number of live performances, they even have full live performance with jyp, but of course everyone needs to use one of bad encores,iInstead of good performances 🤩🤩🤩 bravo, author, distributing content for hate is very cool
@@kpoplol5 lmao shuhua's voice is horrible. From ur pfp, I can already tell ur gonna be deluli towards gidle. But okay girl, whatever helps u sleep at night
@@user-jf3fe5pk7b shuhua actually debuted on the same day as le sserafim! i dont think she'd fit the groups. shes older and doesnt fit cute concept. her personality shines with gidle and her live vocal abilities are probably better or at least as good as chaewon and minju. shes improving.
@@user-rn4jc9ml9y shuhua is a horrible vocalist. An chaewon and minju can easily beat her in vocals. And just bc she's better than others does not mean she's good
