I can honestly say I lost my mind when I was at the OTR tour and I heard her start singing this. And what makes it so great is that she didn't try to be Lauryn, she stayed Beyonce. Amazing cover this is.
jcr89 Beyonce has a beautiful voice but it seems like she's trying too hard, she's over doing it. It doesn't seem natural like lauryn hill's version. Lauryns is more heartfelt, more sad, u can really feel what she's saying.
"she's trying too hard" - her sound is kind of "acidic" isn't huh, when going for the "aggressive delivery". I think that's in her voice though..that brassy, trumpety thing. She always sings like this. just her style.
Because they're haters !!!!! Lauryn herself wasn't even screaming all over this song she sung it soft and elegant yet for some reason they talking about "Beyoncé lacks soul" on a song that doesn't require belting at all.
I feel pain when Lauryn sings this song but when beyonce sings, not that much. Lauryn's voice has pain, soul, lots of emotions that most singers lack in this generation. We need you, Lauryn.
+Nevatar de Portal we all free to state our opinions. If you not agree with me that's fine. I like Beyoncé tho but she just not that great in this performance comparing to the original one.
+Nevatar de Portal Just because I stated that her voice is not as great as the original one in this song, it doesn't mean I'm a hater(I even told you I like Beyoncé) Of course I respect your fans opinions too. This is a comment section, which is open for everybody's opinions. I'm done.
mmiikk5 a diseased comment panel that allows you to spread your hate all in the name of opinion. How convinient. And like I said before, of you don't like it, go listen to the original version. It's that simple!
1.Kiss the back of your hand 2.say your crushes name 3.close your hand 4.pick a school day 5.say your name 6.post this on 15 songs and your crush will ask you out
JP Brown Yes. It's a cover obviously. I based my comment on the fact that other people were writing in the comments that "this was better than lauryn hill." So i stand by my statement that the difference is wide - no one can touch lauryn hill. Why thank you so kindly for agreeing with me!
The only people that should ever sing this song is me and Lauryn Hill! Me, because I just feel it too much and you will never hear it in public and Lauryn, because nobody could ever make me feel this song the way she did. Everybody don't need to touch everything!
Lauryn Hill TWEETED "I heard a snippet of Beyoncé performing Ex-factor. What a beautiful voice she has and what a wonderful acknowledgment. Soooo gifted. -MLH" . So haters, take several seats!😒
Beyonce is a good singer no doubt but... She ruined it with her superflous acrobatic singing... Two cents. I'm allowed to critique her songs. If its bad its bad. Im allowed to say it. In what world is it not ok to voice your thoughts about something someone has published for everyone? This was simply crap
right!! ppl complain that bey doesn't sing enough r&b and soulful songs but then when she covers an r&b classic she gets so much unnecessary hate. she was paying tribute to Lauryn.
To me it's not that one sang it better.... it's just that all the nuances of the original aren't there.... I wouldn't say it's worse, it's just not the original. I would say the same thing if Lauryn sang a Beyonce song!! Both of them are bomb, but you have to admit that when someone covers a song, you miss the riffs and nuances of the original singers voice!!!
@@Smartkid2387 My point is that... just about anyone who does a cover isn't necessarily worse, even though I like the original better... of course I expect her to put her spin on it... I think you missed my point... but that's ok... lol
I think people are doing the most. Lauryn Hill sang this amazingly. Hands down no argument. However, Beyoncé sang this just as well. WHY? Beyoncé sang this in Beyoncé's best way, not Lauryn's way. They are two different and non-comparable artists. Beyoncé did not do this to say she has a better voice. She is marveling in Lauryn's beauty. They are also two very accomplished artist. Initially Lauryn broke the record for most Grammy's in one night for a woman, even winning album of the year. Beyoncé came back and broke the record with six in one night, but it is so wonderful to see two beautiful black women being the ones to make this achievement in musical history. Please stop the Beyoncé and Lauryn war. It's not necessary.
+Kierra Barrings Maybe Bey can outsing her NOW but no one can f*ck with early 20s Lauryn. From spittin savage bars to hitting whistle registers. Who else does that though?
Haha it's soooo weird how nobody wants to give props to Beyoncé. She's got one of the testers voices of all time. I honestly think if she wasn't so pretty people would give her vocals more respect, but since she's got it all, people are hesitant
TaylorBold Looks has absolutely nothing to do with it. Lauryn sang the hell out of this and Bey did an awesome job but no comparison. You got it all wrong queen bey does get lots of recognition but artists like Lauryn don't.
TaylorBold ....Whitney was pretty and they gave her all her props..... Beyonce has one of the best running voices but not the best soulful.....which is what I believe people think is missing in this homage to Lauryn..Also the difference with Whitney, Lauryn, Aretha , Adel and other greats is that they don't have to do vocal acrobatics all over the place to get their point across. This was still an awesome performance though.
Out of all these other artists, I feel like Beyoncé is more than qualified to pay homage and do a cover of Ex-Factor. Nothing will never beat the original but she sang the hell out of this song. +1 to the Mamas, she really knows how to choose her backup singers..
This is one of the best covers of Lauryn's Hill's song I've ever seen. The passion in her voice and delivery is enough to shake you at your core. Did anyone see the fire in her eyes when she sang "see no one loves you more than me.....and no one ever will." This is why I love Mrs. Carter. She puts her soul, sweat, and tears into her performances, live or studio. Black queen doin' tha' damn thang.....I ain't mad, ain't mad at all!!!!
well that's because that's Lauren hills song... beyonce just paying tribute to a Icon/Legend (Everything's not wrapped around what's better and what's not)
well, that's your (very biased) opinion but Beyonce is a pro at emoting in her music. when it comes to her live performances, her voice even more raw & emotional. She did not "fail" to do anything in this video which is why you're really mad.
I've heard Lauryn Hill sing this song live at Tidal (very recently) and truthfully it was very close to terrible, lets be honest here. I know you'd like for Beyonce to just be a pop singer & performer but she is far more than that and always will be. you can't state your baseless opinions and expect others to accept it as fact, that's not how it works, SWEETIE. let me tell you the facts, 1, I heard Beyonce sing this live & had an emotional connection to it which is why i'm here, why are you here? 2, Lauryn loved her cover and tweeted about it & 3, Lauryn fans like you insisting that her cover wasn't good enough for you will not change the fact that millions of people fell in love with it and preferred it to the original.
I love how ur deflecting to make your argument seem less ridiculous :) idgaf about how you feel about Beyonce's artistry. Yes, we are going to do that because you brought it to this point. Beyonce has more than earned all the acclaim that she has received as a vocalist, dancer performer & SONGWRITER. All the great artists have much respect for her as an all-around artist and I can back this up with receipts. Talk to me when Lauryn's full discography can match half of what Beyonce has put out. talk to me when Lauryn puts out another album & actually shows up to perform it. Art is subjective at the end of the day but I came with facts unlike you. Have a nice day.
You said Rihanna has more accolades and acclaim than Beyonce 😂😂 How dumb do you have to be to believe that? I love Rihanna but that's a no. where do u get ur info from? You said Beyonce has no classics, this again is false. Beyonce has classic ALBUMS. Her impact on pop culture & society has yet to be matched. You said she didn't do it justice I said she did. We're both on a Beyonce video but you're here arguing with Beyonce fans.. hmm,. Are you really that mad at her for making the song her own? If she didn't do it justice you wouldn't be so pressed, just be honest. You have no argument so u dragged rihanna, mariah e.t.c into it. You're the only one throwing out foolishness here & you know that. Do your fucking research.
I love how you continue to deflect 👏👏👏 #1 singles does not = more critical acclaim or accolades. Like I said, I love Rihanna but career is not touching Beyonce's. Google their respective tour gross & general attendance for 2016. Beyonce is also at a point in career where she doesn't need or care about #1s singles & only cares about her music. She doesn't do interviews, doesn't promote, barely posts on social media. Look at where Rihanna's album is on Itunes versus where Beyonce's is. Being known as a singles artist is not a good thing. Her being less successful compared to Beyonce doesn't take away from what she has accomplished & support both of them but nice try.
Lmfaooo all the Beyoncé haters under this post bloop she already sung it and Lauryn already tweeted she loved the cover your opinion ain't needed !!!!!
& y'all can continue to leave your negative comments under Beyoncé videos, you'll still be hating 20yrs from now like y'all been for the past 18 !! Hahahaha
This is a bit more than a homage to Lauryn -- it's also a way for her to heal through singing. It was after Jay Z had cheated, and the way she tilted her hat right before throwing it into the crowd, was to imitate Jay Z. It's so beautiful that she could transcend from the pain and aftermath of the betrayal through music, hence Lemonade was made!
For those saying step to the side. Why be so darn ignorant. She just paying homage.. Chill. When people sing her songs I cheer them on and happy that someone loves my favorite artist music. Yall may not think she has the best voice witch she doesn't but in this era she actually does. Money stands next to Rihanna Ciara kart perry and many more who cannot sing. So she at this moment has the best vocals hand down. You can't take the fact that with every performance she gives you 110% and tries her best to deliver. She not going anywhere anytime doing unless she her self quit. Bey is in her own run because she focuses on her, her music, her craft and out does her self. The problem with other artists is that they try so hard to outdo each other. Specially when it comes to negative feedback and attention. People throw do much hate at her and all she does is kill them with silence and continue to grind. That's why she last and that why she's still alive in the music. She had everything you can ask for in such a poor era of music. Because so many artist are all about the effect the look the sound the wow factor. Beyonce took this day the only one I know who can perform with just herself lights and a mic..
Glen Brown Personally, I am a big Bey fan as I am 33 ( the same age as her), and I have grown up with her music and I have experienced the impact she made to us. And I think that ppl throw so much hate at her because she is too popular and she is at the top of the game, so they try to pull her down a little bit.
Beyoncé slayed this song. She made it her own, she didn't try to copy Lauryn Hill version. I felt her conviction and passion. Plus technically the vocals were unmatched. Even Lauryn Hill praised her for this vocal performance( the only opinion that matters)
Lauryn Hill is one of those voices that not just anyone can cover. Many try, but unless they really have skills, likely they just butcher her songs. This was done very well.
Beyoncé isn't trying to sound like Lauryn Hill. She is simply performing a song that she enjoys & wanted to cover. No matter what, Beyoncé has an amazing voice. You all are ignorant for even thinking that she's trying to be like Lauryn. They're both two talented people who inspire. soooo who df cares?
Wait a minute back up Beyonce your nice but no one can get that like Ms. LAURYN HILL herself she does it best no mean any harm you have a voice but this song no hun
Lordpraisethe how do bey stans make you sick... but you're the one visiting a Beyoncé video? Most people would try to avoid what makes them "sick." *sips*
I'm not apart of the Bey hive but I'm actually pleasantly surprised... Not too shabby. She did a good job, but Lauryn is my girl and this will forever be her song. Still. Bey did good. No need to knock her. If anything covering Lauryn is a sign of admiration & respect. You have good taste in music Mrs. Carter!
Why do you guys(🐑🐑🐑) in the comments keep saying Mammas? It sounds stupid. Is that the latest dumb slang word? 🐑" Yes mammas" 🐑 "You did that mammas" 🐑 "Sang it mammas" 🐑 "mammas you better sang it" 🐑 "Do your thang Mamma's" 🐑 "Go Mammas" 🐑 "Never disappoints go Mamma's" 🐑 "Iove it yes Mammas" 🐑 "Mamma's yes" 🐑 "Yessss mammas" 🐑"I'm so proud of you Mammas" 🐑 "Love you mommas yes" 🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑"we love you mammas!"🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑
+leyonce war But haters gonna love the opposite of what they hate. Like lovers hate the opposite of what they love. So are haters always gonna hate then? And are lovers always gonna love?
+leyonce war 'haters gonna hate'' _But haters gonna love the opposite of what they hate._ _Like lovers hate the opposite of what they love._ _So are haters always gonna hate then?_ _And are lovers always gonna love?_
Beyonce is talented. but I myself did not feel no emotion and on top of that feel the song did not come out smooth. Lauryn Hill Still Remains a perfect fit for this song with the feel and the soul. Good try tho B
Whenever Beyonce delivers vocals superior to the original artists of the songs she covers, their fans' only defense is "She got no soul". Soul doesn't define the better singer, and Beyonce is not even a soul artist, but she's one of the best, if no the best vocalists of this generation. If she wants to cover an artist she admires, so be it. Another thing: although Bey ain't a soul artists, she slayed all the Etta James tracks she did for Cadillac Records; Etta's fans of course said "she lacks soul" though.
🙌🏽 she sings this songs better than the original and I'm not a die hard bey fan but I hate when people try to discredit her like her vocals aren't top notch.. Or like she didn't work to get to where she is today!
PetroleumJellay i can't stand it when people say bey doesn't sing with soul. her performances of 1+1 in her dressing room before her idol appearance was incredibly soulful and really touched me emotionally, so fuck anyone who says she can't sing with feeling or soul.
PetroleumJellay they hating. the thing about Bey is, she emotes. She sings from that place that moves everything. Don't worry about today. She'll be recognized till the END OF TIME!!!!
Beyoncé is just a vocalist and a performer, you cant compare her with a real musician like Lauryn. Thats why these discussions are pointless. Lets just enjoy the song.
Why are people mad? It's a tribute, she's not trying to outshine her or anything. And thanks to Bey, I get to hear a song from Lauryn Hill. I only knew her name, but never heard any of her song (or maybe I did but I don't remember any). But this perf made me want to listen to all her songs now!lol
I love beyonces rendition of the song. I'm not saying she singed the song better than Lauryn , it just the chooses of riffs and runs she does at certain points of the song makes it more appealing to me. But that's just my opinion
The mamas are truly incredible. They complement Beyoncé's voice so well and they have so much soul. They aren't given enough credit. They did this song beautifully, just like Queen Bey :)
Sorry Beyonce can't touch Lauryn's version of this song. I know there are tons of fans that thing she delivers on this, but her background singers made this even half way decent.
***** I thought I may have heard something, but its a damn shame. That unlike Lauryn who solely used her own beautiful voice. Beyonce could not even come close to replicate.
I thought bey did a great job Lauryn is the original but bey has talent her runs are smooth and flawless Lauryns are too but lauryn wrote the song it had more meaning to her i think, besides it was just a tribute she loves lauryn hill
+Annice Culp Why can't an artist pay homage. Is it really that bad that she paid tribute to Lauryn hill? We know that beyonce can never touch lauryn hill...which makes her Lauryn Hill and Beyonce is Beyonce. Her fans loved it so you can go to hell with your comment!!!
+leyonce war sweetie whether I can sing or not doesn't mean jack. What I do have is an ear for music. As well as a what makes a great voice. Beyonce does not have a great voice. She is simply a great show person. There are some things one should never ever do. Attempt to sing an iconic song when you don't even have the pipes to do it. Now run along and play with your Beyonce doll I am sure mommy bought you when she was with destiny's child.
no pain in her singing this song was made performed & sang with all of Lauryn Hills heart Beyonce Beyonce smh stop trying theirs no point ur trying wayyy to hard
Ughhhhhh. So sad to see her going through it at this time. She was literally crushed by his actions. It’s heart breaking. I felt it when she said “this is crazy”. Like I’ve been there girl. SMH. Most people don’t have it in them to make it through all the stages in Lemonade to get to the healing part.
When beyonce sings she performs, all you here is just her voice running over the song. But when Lauryn sing it, maan! you feel like the song is telling your story, it has soul. Like you're sitting round a fireplace talking to your homegirl.
It could all be so simple But you'd rather make it hard Loving you is like a battle And we both end up with scars Tell me, who I have to be To get some reciprocity No one loves you more than me And no one ever will Is this just a silly game That forces you to act this way? Forces you to scream my name Then pretend that you can't stay Tell me, who I have to be To get some reciprocity No one loves you more than me And no one ever will No matter how I think we grow You always seem to let me know It ain't workin', It ain't workin' (No, it ain't workin') And when I try to walk away You'd hurt yourself to make me stay This is crazy, this is crazy (This is crazy, uh-huh) I keep letting you back in How can I explain myself? As painful as this thing has been I just can't be with no one else See I know what we've got to do You let go, and I'll let go too 'Cause no one's hurt me more than you And no one ever will No matter how I think we grow You always seem to let me know It ain't workin', It ain't workin' (It ain't workin') And when I try to walk away You'd hurt yourself to make me stay This is crazy, this is crazy Care for me, care for me I know you care for me There for me, there for me Said you'd be there for me Cry for me, cry for me You said you'd die for me Give to me, give to me Why won't you live for me? Care for me, care for me You said you care for me There for me, there for me Said you'd be there for me Cry for me, cry for me You said you'd die for me Give to me, give to me Why won't you live for me? Care for me, care for me You said you care for me There for me, there for me Said you'd be there for me Cry for me, cry for me You said you'd die for me Give to me, give to me Why won't you live for me? Care for me, care for me You said you care for me There for me, there for me Said you'd be there for me Give to me, give to me Why won't you live for me? Cry for me, cry for me You said you'd die for me
Who else caught the "Why won't you cry for me?" line as an ode to Jay's 'Song Cry'?"I can't see 'em comin' down my eyes, so I gotta make the song cry..."God, I love song lyrics!!! ^,^
I loooove Lauryn, she is QUEEN and I enjoy some Beyoncé often but I'm really not feeling this, same way I probably wouldn't feel Lauryn Hill covering Beyoncé's "Listen". Just doesn't spark the same emotions as the original singer because you can hear their emotion and connection when they sing.
Great rendition of the song. Bey always excels at delivering a solid vocal performance. One thing I always admired about her is she sings emotionally and does the VERY BEST that SHE can do. I've never seen her half ass any of her performances. Great artist, great role model, and great human being. *tips hat*
Beyonce did the HELLLLLLLLLLLL outta this song man! Hands down, have yet to hear someone do Ms. Hill some type of justice and Bey did that. You can call her a lot of things, accuse her of many things, but one thing that can NOT be said is she's not talented!
This was directly directed at Jay Z with two things. Firstly the iconic cap style and the extra cry for me in the end while throwing the cap. Reminds me of song cry by Jay z
Renditions like these to me at least, really show Beyoncé’s gospel background She’s delivering this song like a sermon, the gut notes blended with the floaty trills, are so beautiful Backing singers are killing it too Beyoncé ‘gets’ music and it shows in how she sings. Fantastic vocalist.
Beyoncé is Beyoncé! Lauryn Hill is Lauryn Hill. Beyoncé simply paid homage to her idol. Is paying tribute a crime? Why are you guys so pressed about it? Stop with the nonsense. She did great. Period!