I saw this song sang live as good if not better than this and anyone saying this is pre recorded is wrong. she was right in front of me bent down and I could hear her voice up close coming out of her mouth not out of a speaker or the mic. I was not a huge fan going into the concert, had gone with a friend but I walked out a super fan haha. she was amazingly good!
it's incredible how it involves the crowd she is not like other artists, you just do not watch the concert you sing and dance, I felt the music beyonce is so adorable with their fans ! QUEEN
I just want to tell to Beyoncé, that I am from Hungary, and my 18th birthday present was a ticket for this tour in Zagreb. I went there with my daddy, we danced the whole time through the show, my voice was extremely weak for to days after it because of screaming the whole night :D, and i didnt even had a phone with me at the show. Love you so Much !!! I mean it really much :)
No they're not. At all. I believe this is live. However, the VMA performance of Love On Top IS suspiciously similar to her Roseland performance, if you listen to the audio.
***** yeah i know but think for all the love on top performances it's pre recorded because it's a very hard song to sing especially at the end when it's getting higher and higher
not going to lie, i've seen her in concert and she does lip-sync (on certain songs, generally towards the end) and someone coming from a background in music yes ARTIST USE PRE-RECORDINGS especially at concerts, their voice is tired after a while so it's necessary, now I will give it to Bey, she can sing a majority of her concerts but YES there are certain songs that are pre-recorded, Artist are also given a choice if they get sick (cause they are humans too!) to cancel the city date or to sing to pre-recordings to prevent the hassle of disappointing fans. NOW I do not care what the stans say! I LOVE BEY and you are a true fan if you acknowledge the good and bad! she is not perfect!
Well yeah I’m a BeyHive since forever and I do not care that she use pre-record tunes cuz we all know she sings lot of her songs live and for all the people that say it’s not true she admitted herself but it won’t take away her credit as a singer cause gosh she sings like an angel 👼
beyonce is never lip syncing ill tell you that if she does anything on this performance is SING WITH THE TRACK but what i love about this performance wheather she did or didn't i love how she always does a acapella skit at the end to show like if i wanna do this live i can so chill
Why everyone say that she lip-sycing or not bitches please as beyoncé said put your negativity damn down and just enjoy her performance and if you know what's your problem if she lip sycing? have you ever seen her perfom acapella i just wanna say BOW DOWN
No she doesn’t this song is so hard live, and she doing too much at the same time . But sometimes she does some concerts like Coachella she did it live
She can give us her all if she is pregnant. You're talking about a woman that was 5 months pregnant performing at roseland & she gave us her all then & we didn't know she was pregnant until the next month. B is an exceptional singer & dancer. Who knows if she's pregnant? If she is, she'll announce it on her own time. The rumors have got to stop & wait for her to say she is. Her 'fans' even saying she looks big in the costume is only going to bring her down if she isn't pregnant! BEYHIVE STANDUP
She is also my favourite singer, and don't get me wrong but I think she didn't lip-synced. She sang it live 1000000000%. All her performances of this song are similar, but not the same. You can clearly hear her breathing! You should listen her performing this song live in Manchester. :)
I think this wasn't live, her voice when singing live is kinda deep but on this performance her voice was like in a studio u can't barely hear the power when she really singing live.
LOL - ela fala isso porque ela pode se ver no espelho todo dia, mas os fãs nunca sabem quando vão ter a chance de ficar perto dela desse jeito de novo, eu não desligaria a camera! Beyoncé que me perdoe!
I never record the concert.. That's stupid! I usually take a few pics every now and then, stuff my phone in my pocket and enjoy the moment. Photos would be more than enough , you can always find videos of the concert online.
That's also what MC fan always tell, and that doesn't make it true..... Being there at a live concert is actually the worst to judge if someone is singing live, with all the excitement and surrounding noise (people, very powerful sound), you judge better when you are watching this home and analyse the voice. Not saying she was not live( even if I have doubts) but being at the concert is not a good argumentation.
I agree! She couldn't lose the track syncing... and she also didn't want them recording it! I mean all that hair tossing, for what in this song? Bloop!
Sorry have you checked out her Performance of "The way we were" "At last" "I care" "Listen" "Dangerously in Love" "1+1" etc..? I would pay for a concert where she just stands and sings her heart out, without any dancing moves just in jeans and a sweater. But she can do both...so why not? I believe that she can do both. Beyonce is a workoholic. She works hard until she can do it. I think this is lipped (because it's exactly the same Track as on every Carter Tour) but she can do it live.
You're exactly right... especially since two seconds after Bey moved it, it was moved back by one of her entourage. Ah well, girl doesn't need to prove herself.
She is singing live! A Lot of stars sing live & you can hear it echoing. It can be the mic. background music, or her mouth is too close to the mic. That does not necessarily mean she's lip syncing. Grow up!
I'm a stan..I know she lip synchs. I'm not that dumb. No one can go through an entire concert dancing like she does and not run out of breath. This is a hard song to sing.
Keep in mind.. 4 was not filtered and majority of the songs were recorded live and raw.. So that's why she sounds just like the track. If u listen to B'Day and then listen to 4 you'd notice the difference.
Playing the devil's advocate here, but it could very we be a pe-recored version of the track. That's the most convincing way to manage it. Thus, it's still a live version of the song, but recorded in studio standing in place verses singing on stage, dancing about, which is significantly more difficult. End and beginning are definitely live either way, though. And, either way, she's a fantastic performer.
ashrick718 Like I said, either way she's fantastic. XD Honestly even if she DOES lip sync (and if she does, she's brilliant at it - way more convincing than most bother to be) that doesn't make her any less amazing. I'm fairly sure she does a mix of both, especially on dance heavy numbers. Moving around the much while maintaining enough breath and energy to carry notes properly would be horribly stressful. xD
BartimaeusTrilogyFan Even if she did lip sync she has to have the voice to even record it...Lmao. And, i think she def is singing over pre-recorded because dancing while moving up that register would be sooooo hard o-o.
She is singing live! Went to her show in Dalls and Houston. What you guys don't see is the Moma's on the other stage singing background! I love this performance but check out why you don't love me and bow down in Houston was off the chain! You must experience her live! You will want more:0)
