I like how the cherries just win Pen back Also how Pencil doing worse in BFDI 18 kept her safe 24:10 also here, the only way they could pass the lava was with Spongy, but idk i dont have a solution for that Btw, here is every contestant on if they did better or worse Woody +0 Pin +0 Coiny -3 Blocky -7 Match -3 Rocky -10 Golf Ball +2 Eraser -1 Snowball +2 Pen +0 Spongy -6 Firey -9 Ice Cube -2 Tennis Ball +2 David +1 Flower -2 Pencil +4 Needle +15 Teardrop +15 Bubble +1 Leafy +1
Requests: What if Lightning remembered to fly in BFB 1? (As we know, lightning always forgets to fly in challenges, but what if he didn’t?) What if Match was safe in BFDI 14? (In the original version, match was supposed to be safe, but it was updated as she got a few more elimination votes to get the results we actually had with rocky at 49 votes and match at 66)
For the first one, It already exists on his Channel called “What if Bleh lost in BFB 1?” For the second one, It’s pretty interesting, especially since one of the writers wrote a Script where Rocky got eliminated in BFDI 14.
Great video. One problem though… Bubble would obviously pick Pencil to be immune alongside her due to their alliance. That doesn’t change the elimination order though.
One large thing is that leafy will not steal dream island because of the ferris wheel drama but firey and leafy will probably not know each other until seasons like bfdia or bfb
Great video,there is only 1 issue... 19:25 this is the timeline where Needle isn't slapping anyone,so i dont see any reason why would Pencil blink if Needle isnt slapping Pencil.
Unless this is the first time Needle slaps anyone for calling her Needy? Maybe she still hates the name but doesn't slap until then, maybe Pencil fights dirty or something.
19:25 what do you mean by that the whole point of the video is not to make Needle slap someone and then you make her win because someone called her Needy?
I'm gonna do what I think would happen from BFDI 17 at 17:23 cuz I thought leafy would actually be out instead Firey Ice Cube and Leafy are UFE The Needle and Teardrop joke still happens and they vote for Firey Bubble and Pencil vote for Leafy because obviously not ice cube, and they have better terms with Firey as seen in BFDI 1. Also Also, Leafy caused them to fight with the springy shoes and trying to befriend them which would make the alliance suspicious. 2-0-2 TB having better relations with Firey and he was also the one to say I didn't know you used bribes to leafy (although I think that was a different episode) votes for Leafy and Leafy gets 8th. BFDI 18 David > Firey from here it's hard to say cuz none of the other matches happened but i'll keep it similar to you Needle > Ice Cube Pencil > Teardrop i guess Bubble > Tennis Ball (maybe the springy shoes distract him, I don't want to change buble win and TB losing) I'll just go with you again, same points from there and Ice Cube is still eliminated in 7th BFDI 19 No More Points Bubble gets Immune Firey still burns David and becomes Immune Needle gets Immune Leafy is gone, so Bubble picks pencil (idk why bubble picked leafy over pencil in ur version anyway) Anyway Teardrop and Tennis Ball easily survive as David gets 6th BFDI 20 Firey, Bubble, Needle, Teardrop, Tennis Ball, and Pencil remain Bubble wins and picks Pencil again Firey Needle Teardrop and Tennis Ball UFE Coiny votes for Firey (1-0-0-0) Snowball hates golf ball and by association votes Tennis Ball because he's probably picky like that, he will then get his friends Eraser, Blocky, and Pen to do the same (4-1-0-0) Ice Cube would probably vote for Firey cuz he can burn her but I think Match likes Tennis Ball the least of everyone (5-2-0-0) Woody is scared of Firey (5-3-0-0) Rocky is friends with TB and Spongy is friends with Rocky and also voted armed contestants in the pasts, so they will probably pile on Firey to save TB (5-5-0-0) I forgot about Golf Ball lol she will vote Firey to save TB (6-5-0-0) I'm going to say Leafy votes Needle randomly for being too nice to want to vote someone out because Needle isn't getting out, and David randomly votes Teardrop because she's the closest thing to Ice Cube and he initially voted Ice Cube (6-5-1-1) Pin and Flower are left. I'm going to say Pin would vote for Tennis Ball because Firey was a Cherry originally and TB was not. I have nothing else to really go off of. (6-6-011) That means flower decides who's out. This is before she rejoined and gained an opinion of either of them too. I'll have to go to Tennis Ball since that's the closest to the real elimination order and maybe to spite Ice Cube after voting Firey (7-6-1-1) Tennis Ball get's 6th (but not really cuz someones rejoining!) BFDI 21 You said Flower rejoins over Firey so I'm assuming she will over Leafy as well, and the whole idea behind this was that I eliminated Leafy instead so what would be the point..? Doesn't matter though, she still will be re-eliminated again as I don't see her winning even with Leafy gone. I mean she literally just took a step forward and called it good. BFDI 22 Firey Needle Teardrop Pencil and Bubble remain It's a race like you said, Needle wins and picks Teardrop. Firey Bubble and Pencil all have pretty equal chances in my eyes. 1st safe is Bubble since she's popular. 2nd Safe is... Pencil. Usually the what-if logic seems to screw over Firey and I can see that happening here. He might be uninteresting without Leafy (unless if he makes friends with Bubble) and the alliance haters would have to split between Pencil and Bubble (I also hate the pencil vote magnet thing.) ALSO also, The alliance is seen in a more positive light with Leafy gone earlier rather than Leafy's friendship. So Firey's getting 5th. BFDI 23 It's another race, Pencil and Bubble would work together, but Needle and Teardrop would as well. I think Pencil and Bubble do better in this case since Needle would get slowed down trying to help Teardrop in the volcano section before she evaporates. In BFDI 12 Pencil climbed the ladder first due to Bubble dying. I think since they are both here and the announcer wouldn't be dead, he would make them fight for it instead of letting each other wins, so he adds traps to the pole. This means I think Pencil wins. BFDI 24 Call me crazy, but Needle and Teardrop are a lot more fun in this season, and even better competitors, and get more popular. If it were the final 3, they would split votes, but since it's the final 4 elimination, they split haters instead. Bubble on the other hand will get piled on by alliance haters despite her popularity, and maybe being boring since she's not friends with Leafy and only Pencil. She will be less popular for the reason Firey was too. First safe is... Needle she has no reason to be hated, maybe Teardrop gets more votes due to being silent and as a result more boring. Do I think with all above said it would be enough to eliminate Bubble instead of Teardrop? Yeah, actually. Call me crazy but BFDI is crazy too and so are its fans. Bubble gets 4th. BFDI 25 Down to just Needle Teardrop and Pencil, that's a lot different. Hard for me to say who would win the contestant vote. Come up with a reply to this with a solution if you want. In 3rd place we have.... Teardrop. I think with splitting fans with Needle and that she's the less interesting of the 2, she gets 3rd in this case. Don't get me wrong Teardrop has many fans who would vote her to win, (me included given this top 3.) because she almost won the rejoin flower did in real BFDI. But I just don't think it's enough in this case. Now the top 2, Needle vs Pencil. Let's look at their cases. Needle doesn't slap anyone, is a fun competitor and a comp beast, has no reason to be hated and has a lot of fans from herself, teardrop, and others. Pencil was fun this season too, and got to be the spotlight of the alliance rather than Bubble now, the alliance fans would have her back. This is honestly a toss up in my opinion, maybe even with teardrop. So between the 2 who do I think would win BFDI: What If Needle Never Slapped Anyone?? We have... Pencil!!! Really this is a close one in my opinion but I had to go for Pencil due to vote splitting, and to keep it more closely with original BFDI since Pencil did a lot better than Needle. Also Pencil winning this what if in Bubble's place makes a lot more sense than Needle doing it, even if she was the star of this episode. Needle being in 2nd place really showed her true potential, all she needed was to not be an annoying slapper and I could see her being a fan favorite. Maybe removing Teardrop at 4th would've been a better move for her game. GG's everyone and honestly the top 3 is interchangeable in my opinion, feel free to reply some stuff I messed up or your order to add.
@@SigmaPebble BFDI 6: They would probably do better without Snowball literally having to carry Rocky around. I also think they would do better and secure the win easier in BFDI 8 because Rocky was slow af.
Leafy actually didn't recieve more votes than Bubble originally, they tied. The Announcer just called Bubble 3rd and Leafy 2nd because saying that Leafy and Bubble tied would reveal the winner too fast.
tbh they always vote eachother for small things that the characters have done in the previous episodes, so needle would probably vote for blocky in bfdi 9 imo 😭 but i rly like how you thought of everything what a great video!! 😘
Small mistake in this, in episode 18 needle beat pencil because “she probably accidently called her needy or something” which implies that needle slapping pencil made her win the match
Suggestion: What if David didn't debut? I would personally select Bomby to debut because he was in the top two in BFDI 18, let's see how he'd do! But... why not have the debut immeadiatly at the merge instead of BFDI 18.
Another requested: what if fanny rejoins? (i know it will be wierd because we know little of fanny but i think she will have his bfb/tpot personality or maybe she could be a threat to the others)
3:45 there is just no way the viewers would choose rocky over blocky, blocky was safe before leafy in bfdi 9. Leafy is way more liked than rocky, so the viewers would not choose rocky imo
Interesting! I have an idea: What if Spongy helped his team escape back in BFB 14? I think Gelatin would be very likely to get eliminated and it might shake things up, since Spongy wouldn't rejoin unfairly and get out immediately in Post Split! Just a thought!
Free food would've been safe way sooner then, but what about the losers? They were the ones who canonically answered glue. So i think it would be down to iance and the losers.
How would rocky figure out Match doesn’t like him in the future? Other than that and the elimination of Blocky right after rejoining, and bubble picking leafy over pencil. I really like the idea
