This is a question I've had on my mind for a while. So, we're going to see what'd happen if Pin saved herself with her Win Token! All songs belong to their rightful owners
Also, theres a problem with the video-you said Pencil got 8 votes during points introduction phase, but also eliminated her for her no vote streak so...
loved this sm omg it’s so cool, my pencil bias is kicking in tho and i think in 33:16 pencil would survive here, firstly pencil has gotten less votes then blocky twice (once even when people were voting her because she never got votes) and i think all pencil, match, bubble and even icys fan bases at the time would vote blocky since he was mean to bubble and ice cube, mind you the alliance was VERY popular and could easily beat out blocky.
I am biased too towards Pencil, but I still agree that Blocky would get more votes. Pencil's zero-vote streak wouldnt have happened (she lost 6 points to votes by the start of the merge)
Yes youre totally right, in BFDI blocky came 17th and 11th while pencil came 9th and this was before BFB plus its not just the alliance fans disliking him its mostly the whole fanbase (at the time)@@mackycabangon8945
Here are a couple ideas: -BFDI 14 But Match Survives An Elimination Instead Of Rocky -BFDI 22 But Rocky Survives An Elimination Instead Of Flower -BFDI But What If Blocky and Woody's Rejoin In BFDI 7 Wasn't Scrapped -BFDIA 4 But Teardrop Survives An Elimination Instead Of Coiny -BFDIA 5 But Match Survives An Elimination Instead Of Golf Ball -BFDIA 6 But Puffball Survives An Elimination Instead Of Golf Ball -BFB 2 But Pencil Survives An Elimination Instead Of Fanny -BFB 4 But Bracelety Survives An Elimination Instead Of Gelatin -BFB 5 But Liy Survives An Elimination Instead Of Pie -BFB 8 But 8-Ball Survives An Elimination Instead Of Golf Ball -BFB 9 But Stapy Survives An Elimination Instead Of Puffball -BFB 12 But Match Survives An Elimination Instead Of Snowball -BFB 13 But Firey Jr. Survives An Elimination Instead Of Naily -BFB 14 But Dora Survives An Elimination Instead Of Lollipop -BFDIA But It's Vote To Save
Pencil shouldntve gotten out here, as you said that by the time merge happened, she had 8 votes, therefore eliminating the 0 vote streak, and making her safe
This is an inetersting what-if that could be confinued into BFDIA. Blocky would probably join BFDIA in this timeline, and Leafy would be present in Goiky and could compete. Flower and Bubble would still be dead, but Blocky and Leafy likely replace Puffball and Yellow Face. Plus, the outcome would be very different with the fanbases and interactions of each contestant changing by a lot.
What if Leafy chose Woody to be on the Squashy Grapes instead of Rocky in BFDI 1b? +What if Coiny was Not Allowed onto Dream Island instead of Leafy in BFDI 25? (If Firey still wins in the Grapes Woody timeline)
35:45 instead of a tiebreaker challenge, you should get the other 5 contestants who didn’t vote blocky or pin to vote on whether those two should be out.
Idea: What if Woody was picked on the Grapes instead of Rocky I suggest this cuz I think it was stupid Leafy chose Rocky when she interacted with Woody in a positive way in 1a
I wonder how BFDIA would’ve turned out if this video was canon considering the fact that in this timeline Firey doesn’t win the show, which means that he wouldn’t let Leafy into Dream Island because of her not liking the lava ferries wheel. Or maybe it would be the same as the canon ending except the roles are reversed.
In BFDI 21 Flower Is Most Likely Voting Teardrop As She Said In The First Episode “Teardrop Must Be Stupid! She Doesn’t Even Know How To Talk.” Plus She Voted Leafy To Win In The Finale Since They’re Both Plants. Spongy Also Wouldn’t Vote Leafy As He Would Most Likely Vote Pin Since Shes Seen To Be The Meanest To Spongy During The Early Episodes. Still A Good What If, Probably Might Do My Own That’ll Be Different.
Late to the scene but I doubt the votes would have allowed Firey to rejoin at the final 6, mainly due to Coiny still being in the game. I do think it could be close but realistically, I doubt it would happen, mainly because Firey’s rejoin message may be very similar to Coiny’s in canon. I think Bubble would end up rejoining here due to the alliance fans wanting to see more of her since she got very limited screen time.
So in bfdia leafy would replace puffy and pen took pins place so that will also not include pin and dora being present means neddle dosent get to join either and the woah bunchers are gonna be replaced
Okay Pencil would survive against Blocky because she had more than 1 vote. When you subtracted points to people who had a vote, you said Pencil had 6. This wouldn't cause her elimination and Pencil wasn't that mean in BFDI. But Blocky could potentially survive with his friendship with Coiny. Oh and I don't think we need tiebreaker for the eliminated contestant vote because Spongy would just vote for Pin instead of Leafy because Pin has arms and was the reason he was eliminated. And I think Rocky would vote TD because she pushed him off in BFDI 1. That's my thoughts though.
Great video, but at 42:13 the largest rank drop would actually be Flower going from 4th to 21st (dropping 17 places), not Bubble going from 3rd to 17th (dropping 14 places)
Heres is how i would think it would go. Same stuff until bfdi in lofty aka bfdia 11 another name gets 2nd while the cherries are ufe with pencil win because she would target the charries becase she dosnt want match to be ufe so the grapes are ufe and pin and snowball get the 2 most votes and she picks pin because of snowball meaness and her is familiar with pin and ice cube, tennisball, golfball, and rocky are ufe with golfball getting out due to her rudeness and bosyness next up match, eraser, ice cube and coiny with bottom two being match and coiny with match being out and now for coiny, eraser, leafy and spongy being ufe with eraser being out next up is spongy, leafy, and pencil with spongy getting out when he just rejoined blocky would be the only one not ufe with bottom three is teardrop, rocky, and pin with pin being out because she would'nt have any character development. Now for Frisbee with ice cube, pencil and rocky being ufe ice cube would get 0 votes, rocky gets 2 by coiny and blocky, and pencil gets 3 by leafy, tennisball, and teardrop. David joins still. Next up torney challige with coiny, ice cube, and teardrop being ufe and ice cube bearely gets out. Teardrop, coiny, and leafy are safe and teardrop chooses tennisball to be safe. with blocky being first safe and bottom 2 being david and rocky with david getting out. Tennisball barely survied space and chooses rocky to also be safe, coiny is the first safe and leafy is next safe and teardrop dosnt have as much contestants hating her so, blocky is out. I think bubble rejoins and leafy is still safe with giveing it away to bubble for being popped and just rejoining, because of this she is the 1st safe and then tennis ball is 2nd and lastly coiny bottom 2 is teardrop and rocky and rocky loses getting 6th again. Sience firey and flower are not here they wain and a escape the volcano still hapens with bubble being safe an choosing leafy. TB is 1st safe and in the bottom 2 leaving is teardrop. The final contest is all the last contest combined with coiny being safe. Becaus of this bubble leaves because she is a rejoiner. Third place is tennisball next is leafy with coiny winning bfdi. Flower buys dream island thinking she deserved it an bfdia still happens with puffball not joining and leafy joining instead. But thats it with how i think this would go!
