Billionaire Accused of Stealing Sand from Malibu Beach

Подписаться 61 тыс.

Просмотров 91 тыс.

50% 1

Don’t forget to subscribe for more videos like this one! Thank you for watching!
Follow me on Instagram:
- / real.estate.report
In today's episode we are talking about some of the most petty real estate disputes that I have ever heard of. First, we start with a story about a billionaire who is accused of stealing sand from a public beach in Malibu. Then we get into a story about a "California Karen" who claimed part of a beach as her own in front of her beachfront mansion. And last we talk about a petty dispute between billionaires around a glass art sculpture outside of their beachfront properties.
I hope that you enjoy this video and if you have comments please leave them below! See you next video!
-Scott
#realestatenews
Disclaimer: This channel, and any communication shared during these videos, should not be taken as financial or legal advice. Viewers should retain their own legal counsel or financial expert(s) before making their own decisions. If you need legal advice, please contact an attorney directly. If you need financial advice, please contact a Certified Public Accountant or a Certified Financial Planner or other licensed professional. I (Scott) am not a CPA, attorney, insurance, or financial advisor and the information in these videos shall not be construed as tax, legal, insurance, construction, engineering, health and safety, or financial advice. Opinions shared in these videos are my personal opinion and are for entertainment purposes only. No comments should be construed as fact. Always do your own due dilligence. And one more thing.. Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service with the links that I provide I may receive a small commission. There is no additional charge to you! Thank you for supporting my channel.

Опубликовано:

15 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 315

@danrogy 16 дней назад

Laguna Beach lady doesn't even own the house! IT'S HER MOM'S!!

@deemushroomguy 16 дней назад

Yeah... Meth. She needs to stop doing meth.😅😂

@stenbak88 16 дней назад

Ya that’s pretty funny. I am born and raised in Laguna, still here… that lady is insane

@okiedokie2557 15 дней назад

That’s crazy

@cindyhudson2834 14 дней назад

@@stenbak88 I live here too and I heard the same . But really, everyone of those people roped their spots there forever ago and I don’t blame them. The beach they roped off wasn’t wide, maybe just enough for a couple of lounge chairs, and frankly they needed a cushion around their homes. The way people using beaches here behave now, I would not be at all surprised if owners woke up one day to find strangers making coffee in their kitchen while waiting for the load of laundry they threw in the owners machines. I would not live on that beach at all under any circumstance. I live a thirty second walk from there, and I just can’t take it anymore as it is, so I’m moving. People using the beaches are the worst now. If you live here, you know.

@jamesarnold6059 5 дней назад

@@cindyhudson2834yah... but it's public property. It was before they roped it off, & it still is.

@christenawalker2944 15 дней назад

Damn as a California resident I want in on the lawsuit. This is a beautiful stretch of beach that we have fought hard to have access to! RICH PEOPLE DON'T OWN THE BEACH EVER!

@I_Dont_Answer_Questions 3 дня назад

Fought for access? State law. There is no fight.

@user-oe5ft5ll4y 15 дней назад

You can buy truckloads for less than a grand. This guy deserves jail time

@coastuncle1965 9 дней назад

Hey, yeah I immediately went to how to solve the problem and how much would it cost too. 30k in fines....ouch.

@tedthurgate 5 дней назад

If he even knew. It is likely he hired a contractor to build his project and he wasn't around or involved in the construction or the acquisition of materials.

@I_Dont_Answer_Questions 3 дня назад

Not buying truck loads for less than a grand. You just watched a piece where 21 people are paying 31M... Think or get checked.

@TeeDee-j9u 13 дней назад

Shes not the home owner. she's the daughter of the home owner. The city dealt with her real quick, and she took the rope down, and she does again. She's going to get arrested.

@bf6159 14 дней назад

A Billionaire stealing from the public for personal use? Say it ain't so!

@jenniferburkhammer837 12 дней назад

😂😂😂

@machone539 6 дней назад

Homeless people have been doing that for years.

@moonshinefuel 3 дня назад

I knew a Mayor of a small town who used to steal blocks of cheese from the community center donation supplies all the time. It's not like they don't have the money they have this penchant for getting stuff for free.

@machone539 2 дня назад

@@moonshinefuel Some small town mayor is a low to non-paid position. Kind of like volunteer fire dept.

@user-xn1ku7gr8k 15 дней назад

Sand from the beach is the WORST type of sand you can use in Construction. It’s corrosive in building. Salt water in the sand.

@LeQuito 12 дней назад

I'm sure it was just to add to his beachfront

@missourimongoose8858 6 дней назад

I knew that desert sand is bad to use because it's not course enough but I didn't know salt water sand was bad to lol the more you know

@ShogunHull 6 дней назад

@@LeQuitoThat's what I think too.

@haplessasshole9615 4 дня назад

@@missourimongoose8858 Beach sand has a lot of salt in it. If you use it in a foundation slab or in brick mortar, every time it rains, a little more salt will dissolve. It eventually crumbles.

@haplessasshole9615 4 дня назад

@@LeQuito Yeah. No contractor worth his salt (so to speak) would use beach sand in actual construction. Unless, of course, the billionaire was building a cheap (to him -- not to us) place to use for a few years, then when it falls to pieces from the ground up, collect on insurance.

@janaka861 14 дней назад

The reason we need the California Coastal Commission is because of people like this.

@OutWestRedDirt 6 дней назад

Reason is no God, no 10 commandments, no sense of honor

@MrSloika 16 дней назад

A few years back a Wall Street currency trader wanted to expand his estate in New Jersey. He tried to buy public park land that abutted his property. The authority that ran the park told him that park land was not for sale. Not long after a hiker was walking a trail through the woods in the park only to find that the trail had been fenced off and tennis courts had been constructed. Puzzled by this the hiker made his way to the park police station and asked why the park had constructed tennis courts in the middle of the woods. This was news to the police who, being the inquisitive fellows that they are, investigated. As it turned out the wealthy currency trader had fenced off acres of park land, had most of the trees removed, had tennis courts constructed and was planning to construct a pool and pool house. The currency trader's lawyer claimed it was a 'survey error'. The currency trader paid to have the tennis courts removed and paid for the trees he destroyed without admitting any wrong doing. He did no jail time. That's what will happen here. Oopsie! Did I make a mistake? Here, let me paid for the sand. We're good now, right?

@McDLT999999999999999 13 дней назад

Jewish privilege

@epincion 5 дней назад

A similar thing happened in the Hamptons over a decade ago where a billionaire (one of the founders of Blackrock the world’s largest hedge fund) did not like the dunes that obstructed the view from his newly bought waterfront mansion. These dunes were a protected area under nature conservation rules. Well one weekend a bunch of heavy dozers pitched up and flattened the dunes. The local authority prosecuted him and he got a big fine and supposedly has to pay for a team of conservation experts to rebuild the former habitat. But the fine was a drop in the bucket for him and the dunes are no longer blocking his view (rebuilding will take generations if at all) and he does not give a proverbial about what he did. Zero morals. The story was covered in Vanity Fair.

@phlodel 3 дня назад

Caltrans cut some beautiful old oak trees on my brother in law's ranch. Caltrans crews cut them up for firewood for their supervisors. the settlement? The value of the trees as firewood.

@niveknospmoht8743 16 дней назад

There was actually a sand shortage couple of years back due to the amount of cement and concrete being made world wide.

@johnpatterson9219 15 дней назад

Neighbors suing neighbors. Welcome to the Southern California Coast!

@velvetbees 14 дней назад

It is getting dire in several areas of the world where famous beaches are now gone. Beach sand makes proper concrete. Deserr sand won't bond to make strong concrete.

@jabreck1934 14 дней назад

@@velvetbees very simple and logical reason….. putting up dams stops the natural replenishment of sand and causes coastal erosion. People in other states in California doesn’t put more dams because they are protecting a fish?!?! This is a daily comment from a poorly informed and ignorant

@jamesodell3064 11 дней назад

Sand from the ocean is less then worthless for cement. The salt in the ocean sand is very corrosive and over time destroys the cement.

@croatianbandz2763 17 дней назад

Really enjoyed this type of fun light hearted lawsuit real estate videos! Please keep up this series!

@Real.Estate.Report 17 дней назад

Thanks! Will do

@Mike_Davidson 17 дней назад

Get off my sand peasants! This sand is my sand! 😂😂😂🏝

@Real.Estate.Report 17 дней назад

😂

@nellermann 9 дней назад

structures and homes should have never been allowed to be built so close to the coast. insane!

@seashackf1 16 дней назад

There’s a billionaire in Massachusetts that did the same thing to his neighbors. Ernie Boch Jr. inherited the car empire his father started. He bought an old mansion that had most of its former land surrounding it turned into a middle class neighborhood. Boch wanted the land back to create the create the estate, build pools and a huge garage for his car collection. Some of the owners wouldn’t sell. One was also a car dealer, only much much smaller. First he started cutting down trees that affected only their property. And kept escalating from there. He had bright lights on all night and also blared music late at night. He’s also a musician with a band. This went on for a couple of years. They all ended up moving and Boch created his estate. He also built a mausoleum where he will be interned. It’s near the sidewalk and road with houses on the other side of the road.

@RoseNZieg 14 дней назад

I'm sad they didn't turn their properties into pig farms. I heard it's very deterrent.

@tizzlekizzle 16 дней назад

Dirt is so cheap. Why you would steal sand? Cheapness and pettiness.

@thomasallen6980 16 дней назад

Try to buy a dump truck load of beach sand. It's expensive.

@jeremyweems4916 15 дней назад

Dirt and beach sand are wayyyy different. Much different in price too.

@Nova-m8d 16 дней назад

Lol, It costs $300 for a 20-ton triaxle dump truck load of screened sand to be delivered. Odds are the homeowner had no clue where the contractor was getting sand. The corrosive salt water would do more than $300 in damage to the excavator. This video has to be tabloid news. 😂

@codydabest 16 дней назад

Honestly, at least I can somewhat understand the neighbours fighting and the woman annoyed with the beach goers, but the stealing sand for the sloped side of the yard completely boggles me hahaha

@Real.Estate.Report 16 дней назад

@@codydabest haha me too

@planetaescapa6099 17 дней назад

Poor Billionaires in trouble again ! What a life 🥺😬✅🇺🇸🇫🇷

@tewekdenahom485 15 дней назад

Beach sand is not even the best sand for construction. Hes never gonna be able to sell that House

@sd906238 13 дней назад

A co-worker bought some ocean front property in the Philippines. He had to hire some guy to stop people from stealing his sand and selling it to a local cement factory. The guys he hired were probably the same guy who were stealing his sand.

@gsmmakeit3442 17 дней назад

🤣 🤣 🤣. I wish I would have these silly problems, Scott. Your BH neighbor 😊

@bobbicatt 9 дней назад

I had lived in Malibu since 2008 , Broad Beach is barely there anymore. During high tide, not just broad beach but most of Malibu’s beaches are near gone.

@CuriousMouseExploration 15 дней назад

Those contractors should know better - they should know that this illegal. As soon as the State finds out, those contractors will be fined as well. He's stealing and destroying the beach.

@RockyToussint 13 дней назад

So blame the contractors? Not the billionaire paying them probably good money to do the work

@dmpi483 17 дней назад

Using an excavator to steal sand is total overkill. How about a shovel and a wheelbarrow?

@larrybruce4856 16 дней назад

He's a billionaire because he steals things and doesn't pay.

@velvetbees 14 дней назад

Or a teaspoon and a cereal bowl. 😊

@joegott9391 16 дней назад

Woman who hit the wall + easy life = Karen

@sashamoore9691 16 дней назад

Men who are balding by 20+ invest their dads money into some one else’s up and coming company = male karen

@kwi5331 16 дней назад

You might want to look into Florida real estate issues, gov tried to build golf course concessions in state park. County and other orgs are moving quickly too.

@epincion 5 дней назад

Yup that’s the state park that Gov DeSantis is claiming is not a park but a ‘disused military base’ so he can sell bits of it off to developers with deep pockets

@juledaniels 16 дней назад

That rope Karen was disgusting…scaring the poor kid, she should be fined

@paulalim1476 15 дней назад

Aaah. The problems of the privileged. I almost shed a tear. SMDH.

@LucasFerreira-cq8qz 17 дней назад

The whole video is about crazy real estate news from California Is everyone going insane over there? 😂

@supersoldier2887 16 дней назад

As a Californian…. Yes.

@SamLopezI 16 дней назад

My neighbor is a huge karen who grows weeds, 6 ft tall weeds, that find their way onto my yard.

@jdm1152 5 дней назад

Not that steep for the sand guy? Minimum: $16,200,00 per year, not defending him. I was surprised a put back the sand wasn't in the order. This seems reasonable and would annoy sand guy in the right way by denying him a story. He couldn't brag to his friends; "look at that sand patch, cost me millions, fought the neighbors, the law, and won, see, there it is." This is like admiring your neighbor's lawn a few blocks away and then just taking it with a huge excavator, mid-day, while they were home watching.

@jamesodell3064 11 дней назад

The winners in the Bill Gross case are the lawyers. Much better for neighbors to just be reasonable with each other.

@seashackf1 16 дней назад

That heavy equipment in the water on Malibu beach is wrong on many levels. The oil and grease they are putting into the water is least of those reasons though. It’s absolutely nothing compared to what ships and industry put into it. The bigger problem is for the owner of the equiptment. Giving those tracks a salt bath will not end well for them. Hope the billionare is paying enough to cover fines and maintenance.

@rockyBalboa6699 12 дней назад

Who even uses damp salty sand from the beach! 😂

@FauxQue-yk8dt 16 дней назад

About that glass sculpture. The whiney neighbor lied about his view of the beach being blocked. Neighbor probably had to put the net up to keep the whiney from breaking his glass artwork

@pauldec10 16 дней назад

Great content as alway Scot! Keep up the good work.

@billw5189 16 дней назад

To my knowledge, essentially all of the ocean front land in the USA is public….However, the public portion only extends inland to the standard high-tide water mark….so if it’s high tide, and you’re standing on dry sand, or rocks, you may (?) in fact be on private land

@N0xiety 7 дней назад

Hmm, what if a billionaire actually builds a beach from nothing? Spending millions to basically dump tons of sand and maintain the erosion over the years, would it still be considered public? The moment he stops maintaining, that beach would likely be gone in a decade, so idk how it would work to consider it public if it can't even exist without the billionaire being there to build and maintain it.

@stenbak88 16 дней назад

Those machines are absolutely leaking

@velvetbees 14 дней назад

The billionaire may have a point. It is an ugly net. I would move the glass sculptures straight back, almost up to the house. Why? Because it is glass!

@Rainy_Day12234 16 дней назад

When the other beach houses fall into the ocean the other billionaires will sue him into bankruptcy.

@benz500r 13 дней назад

A similar „Karen” came out in Malibu some time ago and attacked 2 women that were sitting on a public beach. I was passing by and she didn’t attack me, but I told those two women that she didn’t own that part of the beach. Well, they didn’t want to get involved in fighting and walked away.

@richardw3470 15 дней назад

I commented on the sand at another site. Yes, some beaches are having sand trucked in because of construction screwing up the tide and other reasons causing sand to wash out but not wash in (easy explanation as I understand it). He's also disturbing - ah, wildlife. This guy says he has permission from someone to 'shift' sand. But most entitled, know-it-all rich people are nuisances. CA should know, it's filled with them.

@ashishpatel350 16 дней назад

Doesnt seem he made a fortune if hes stealing sand 😂

@lasura 12 дней назад

5:50 They were probably mixing that sand into their concrete.

@fishimust4766 16 дней назад

Just speculation, but maybe the contractor is removing some sand to be able to install some large boulders and rocks as a surf break to stop the erosion. The sand would more than likely be used again in the surrounding area.It appears that he already had a concrete wall built because it looks new and the rocks would slow down the erosion against the wall. I couldn’t imagine someone, contractor or otherwise, doing work on the beach like that without some kind of permitting. I’ll reserve judgement until all the facts become known.

@ddrowdy2 15 дней назад

It's not like sand is expensive or hard to find for sale.

@kayhalas4974 3 дня назад

In Malibu there are people who try to claim that the beach behind their homes is private property. They are wrong.

@steellio5526 8 дней назад

The arrogance of this guy. Stealing tonnes of sand off the beach for personal use is outrageous. There could be massive implications for established ecosystems, and it could cause erosion issues further along the beachfront, which could eventually damage properties.

@thebiggerman6975 3 дня назад

I have found people who have waterfront property are usually jerks, They are either fighting amongst themselves, fighting with the town or telling people on public property to move on ,not worth it to me

@machone539 6 дней назад

Imagine the 911 call: 911: Hello, 911 what is your emergency? Caller: There is an excavator on the beach. 911: You mean like Tonka? Caller: More like John Deere.

@dgronzega8073 9 дней назад

Charge/arrest the contractor

@govinda102000 День назад

I go to Calabria yearly and this past couple of years the local beach town sold off rights for a local construction boss to excavate sand from a quarter mile inlet. He also took over passage so no trespassers are allowed near there anymore.

@thormidthagahast8914 5 дней назад

My new neighbor has a loud cockatoo.....i blast "screaming cockatoo" on the blue tooth speaker to get even. When the other neighbors complain, our landlord laughs at em and tells them to get rid of the stupid bird and then ill stop with the speaker action.

@CuriousMouseExploration 15 дней назад

Guys - just talk to your neighbors first. Get the permit. Etc. You're correct, the art piece is not that bad, but the net is ugly.

@coobay4786 15 дней назад

The sand steeling guy is probably friends with Gavin.

@MultiPetercool 15 дней назад

The glass art looks like something by Dale Chihuly. I’d be happy to live next to this guy!

@liam1428 16 дней назад

I'm guessing he took the sand thinking it would stop the public from enjoying the beach located between his property & the ocean.

@MashaB-pk8hl 7 дней назад

It’s fairly common for people with property near the beach to post signs saying private beach or private property. Another tactic is to put signage on a public access trail to the beach claiming that is private. Any alternative path to the beach may then be at such a distance as to discourage beach goers from visiting that section of the beach. Some property owners go further by fencing off the “private” portion of the beach. A property that claims to abut a private beach will have a higher value than a property that is next to a public beach. You can in California own a path to a public beach, and decide to forbid everyone from using that path. However, some claims to ownership are spurious, and could be challenged in court.

@maschwartz55 10 дней назад

Next thing will be your stealing air

@desertdan 4 дня назад

If he’s using beach sand for construction, his building will crumble. The salt in it will leach out over time.

@mouser485 13 дней назад

That billionaire, Bill Gross, when it showed his pic, I first thought it was a pic of Bob Denver who played Gilligan. However Bob Denver passed away a few years ago.

@rileybri 11 дней назад

The lady who roped off the beach doesn't even live there and was just visiting family. And oddly enough the fine for the fake rope is potentially more then actually taking the whole beach with construction equipment.

@bonnitaclaus2286 5 дней назад

Florida, around Saint Augustine, is spending millions on reclaiming the beach. Adding sand. I don’t think they would like it if somebody took the sand away

@glike2 17 дней назад

Subpoena the construction crew

@mostlikelywedoitservices6926 16 дней назад

If they can build islands of sand with those dredger ships, WTF. Why can they use that same ships and throw sand back onto the beaches?

@paulgithens635 15 дней назад

Put the government in charge of beach sand and the entire state will have a supply crisis of sand.

@RC-mi2bp 15 дней назад

The Coastal Commission didn't issue Laguna Beach Karen a citation. They just sent her a warning letter..

@AxtionMag 13 дней назад

People with too much money and not enough humility. Love Thy Neighbor. ❤️💯😇

@ydne 15 дней назад

Using beach sand also brings salt. The last thing you need on a beach lot is more salt. It limits the kind of planting you can do there.

@ipman4715 5 дней назад

Not surprised.. during drought and limited water usage or penalties.. I've seen the extremely wealthy homes using excess water during the summer

@FR-tb7xh 12 дней назад

Anyone whom steals dirt or sand from elsewhere is stealing. Plain and simple. However, anyone whom owns property owns it from border to border, period. If part of it is sand, then part of it is sand. Just because part of it is a beach doesn’t mean it’s public. With a permit, the homeowner has every right to erect a fence or ropes on their property.

@r.j.martin1818 13 дней назад

The fine and court costs are probably lower than buying the sand from a commercial source.

@shadowfilm7980 16 дней назад

The “Karen” claiming that’s her own Beach is really insane. Her screaming like that too. So mean. Evil. Karma is now getting the best of her!

@brederbeeld 16 дней назад

Sopanos Whitecaps episode inspired loud music scene 😂

@nepenthe_gal759 14 дней назад

The Coastal Commission needs to fine him MILLIONS !!

@Back_Bay_Heeler 14 дней назад

Nobody stole any sand to build that sea wall. In that location the excavator has to be on the beach to rebuild that wall. The real tool is the neighbor who filed the lawsuit. The coastal commission found no problem with permit compliance. Do some investigative work rather than just highlighting a plaintiff’s juicy claims in a lawsuit.

@martinphillips7221 15 дней назад

reminds me of a guy in Australia ,lindsey fox ( trucking billionaire) who dredged an extra acre of sea front so he could enlarge his frontage yard.

@kymaneezmom 15 дней назад

Loved all the stories Thank you

@ferraridan4883 15 дней назад

You can't put dirt in the ocean !

@tonyczuleger4591 9 дней назад

I think it will be hard to prove the equipment is leaking any oils or grease, based on the pictures.

@seeker1432 19 часов назад

The more money some have, The more entitled they seem to be.

@eringemini7091 День назад

Not the same thing; ( but similiar), my Aunt & Uncles Neighbor has been building prohibited Seawalls on the Shoreline. These Sea Walls here in Hawaii cause massive erosion to the shoreline. This is killing the Reef, Sea Life, and rapidly eroding what beach & land separate the Sea from the actual Houses. In older Sea front homes, often the sewage was built in the yard on the Ocean Side of the property. Back when these homes were built; ( early 1900's forward), the land on the Sea side was a LOT bigger than now ( but due to uncontrollable erosion its shrinking rapidly). Building the Sewage system on the Ocean side of the land used to be no big deal. Now, each time there's a Storm or high Waves, more of the land is pulled into the Sea, pulling with it Sewage from the deep underground system;(Sanitary Sewer). This type of Waste system spills waste into the dirt.: Each time my Uncle's Neighbor builds a Sea wall, he's fined $50,000 by the State of Hawaii. The waves regularly bust down his silly wall, then he immediately rebuilds it. This is causing my family's historic Beach home to get closer & closer to the Ocean. Many homeowners are pretty wealthy in this area, especially those who own these shore front homes. Other Home owners also rebuild the Sea Walls, along this same stretch. The substantial fines are not enforcing the erosion/ Sea Wall problem on Oahu"s North Shore.😔

@lafotografa4791 14 дней назад

They can't do it in Mx. anymore..

@joerudnik9290 16 дней назад

This doesn’t even address the dangers to the public, when heavy machinery is used at a public beach🤨🤬😡

@guangxidavidliu 15 дней назад

Money didn't buy CLASS.

@OutWestRedDirt 6 дней назад

Doesn't

@travishancock2302 16 дней назад

What’s crazy is the city/state is just gonna slap with a fine and he’s gonna pay it and keep building his house. Hes probably already donated a shit load of money to the right people.

@jujube8067 6 дней назад

I doubt the guy having the house built knew anything about the sand dredging. That would come down to the contractor and those he hires.

@ThePhatGuy1776 6 дней назад

The h*** with Gilligan's island theme. You go by yourself cement mixer, from Harbor freight, then you go to home depot, and you buy a couple dozen cinder blocks, you put the cinder blocks n the concrete mixer, and you've let it run all day long top off when needed. Perfectly legal neighbors can't do a thing about it

@bjkjoseph 13 дней назад

Remember what Tyson said? Getting your ass kicked is a very humbling experience, that guy needs his ass kicked.

@lynn-deespencer4413 14 дней назад

Social media is great to show all the unjust these people with $$ take advantage of

@robertgray6631 15 дней назад

A truck load of sand cost a few hundred dollars a load. Cheaper and easier than doing what they did! Cost of labor and equipment is much more expensive and way more trouble!!!

@CougarSand 16 дней назад

We don't have the full story. It's important that you characterize this as all allegations

@jeffjames4064 9 дней назад

And down the road is the largest desert in North America. Change to a black net, it almost disappears.

@maureenbrophy7852 10 часов назад

Billionaire fined Penny’s for stealing sand.

@fredk9999 15 дней назад

Oh! No. If a billionaire will steal beach sand, that is only a “gsteway” crime and what will be next? Rocks?

@richardw3470 15 дней назад

The 'lady' with boundary jumpers had a defender who wrote that Teddy Roosevelt gave the previous property owner the land (beach) from 'some point' into the ocean. Haven't seen any more on that argument. That sounds interesting.