Since everyone's comparing, I just made a compilation of their mr removed, this is for their current and faster songs. The videos are not mine. Check out their channels by clicking the annotations above! :)
My ranks. 1) Red Velvet (their voice is clear yet they have the most harder choreography here) 2) BlackPink 3) .....Jungyeon Twice dont deserve to compare with BlackVelvet
SM pls give RV a freaking reality show mamamoo is way above normal girl groups. I don't think even red velvet can surpass them. no hate tho! I love all these groups! it's just that mamamoos aptitude is too high
SM pls give RV a freaking reality show please don't bring up mamamoo in this. They are not even part of the groups that are being compared. Thank you 😊
the reason why RV didn't get as popular as twice because SM never promote rv, no variety show, no good cordi,no dance practice. but sure rv still slayed over the chart .. RR still charting high on melon.. even got over 97xxx likes..
bae bae ummm clearly RV members are appearing in many articles more than blackpink. esp. Joy and Irene in 2016. gurl if you are saying SM didnt promote RV right what will you say about fx???
Yes but the entertainment itself should promote them abroad same with my kings Exo. But I guess Sm believes in real talent and the artist should be independent
If you check SM artists live, they are stable. Even old groups like SNSD and SUJU. They just have this training with regard to voice shakes during performances.
@@monster3033 well if we count popularity of 3 of them it's 1. Blackpink 2. Twice 3. Red velvet Red velvet are 100% not underrated other 2 group are just more popular but i think they can be more popular same goes with twice and blackpink
I agree. Even if they're not as famous with Twice and BP, RV is not underrated. They're also very famous in SK and other countries. Just look at their awards.
SM is honestly the best at vocal training. They don't give a fuck if you're tone deaf , they are going to teach you how to carry a note. Yet people like to shit on them for being untalented when they have the best singers by faaarrrr
rv is one of the biggest ggs so i think they already have so much fame, not to mention theyre the number 1 gg in korea (im pretty sure i saw that somewhere) don't get me wrong tho lol rv r one of my ults
Red Velvet is the best group in this geration, im not biased, my fvs groups is Twice and Blackpink, but look; - Concept ✔ - Dancers/ Dance ✔ - Rappers/ Rap ✔ - Vocalists/ Vocals ✔ - Visuals/ Visual ✔ - Versatility ✔ - Cute ✔ - Sexy ✔ - Badness ✔ - Stability ✔ - Cothes ✔ - Hairs ✔ - Music ✔ Red Velvet is just all
@@heronyolo5254 i think rap is the only think blackpink is "better" at. Seulgi is a better dancer and red velvet are literally the queens of concept while blackpink just has girl crush every single Comeback
Im Awkward its hard because you have to sing and sound stable, which hard to esp if you're turning and jumping, try it 2x faster Or atleast try it with red flavour and as if it your last ---now try with twices choreo ... its easier
Abigail Twice choreography is actually more difficult than BP choreography. Twice has more dance steps than BP. But it's not hard to sing while dancing one of their songs
Best Vocal Girl Groups (Rookie/New Gen): 1. Mamamoo (Mamamoo? Mamamoo.) 2. Red Velvet (3/5 members are Good Vocalist. All of them are stable but sometimes Irene and Yerim are tentative. Seulgi is the most stable. Wendy is one (if not the best) of best vocalist in the new generation of kpop, her technique makes singing looks so easy. JoyWenSeul invented eating CD. if in doubt, watch OOTN mr removed and bless your ears) 3. Gfriend (Hard Choreo? No Problem. Gfriend invented stable vocals. Yuju.) 4. Blackpink (same as Gfriend. Hard choreo but stable vocals, sometimes tentative but who cares. All of them can sing. Rose voice is so soothing) 4. Jungyeon (yes she's a group now because Herself alone can outsing the rest of twice. Unbiased. Just Facts. Popularity is not everything. Stan Talent not just Visuals.
Lexi Bernil I would put JungYeon on 5th, and my doxie on 4th. Srsly, if you whistle she barks and it's so cute and stable. "Stan talent, no visuals" Big RT.
Why not acknowledge Jihyo as well? People always ignore her, but she's amazing, she was on masked singer and also did a few side performances (the one I can think of off the top of my head is U Go Girl). This is coming from an all time Red Velvet fan btw:3
0izzi0 Well Jihyo can sing but she is so tentative and she has a really bad singing technique makes her vocals look bad, she don't deserve the main vocal position but she has the potential to improve. if JYP makes her the main vocal just because she can hit high notes, well high notes are not everything, she's the main vocal so she has to be always stable. Sometimes I find Nayeon and Jungyeon or even Tzuyu more stable than her.
LISA Slays lmao. all songs of twice are always about "cute concept". TF can't they grow up? RV tries different concept that makes them better than twice😂
[!!!] WATCH EXO MONSTER MV Can you relax? If you don't like their concept them don't listen maybe?? Y'all are so filled with hatred😗 Twice didn't invent the 'cute concept' and aren't the only ones with it. Twice rv and bp are amazing groups and are all friends. When will y'all "grow up"??
Considering the RV has the most bumpy or jumpy choreo and that they also sing the adlibs live, I think that they deserve more recognition. THEY SHOULD BE MORE POPULAR EDIT: I'm not even comparing them, I just simply said RV should be more recognized for what they put on the table for us.
She always upgrade every. f*kin’. time. I’m really so proud of her! 😭 Esp. when I saw her perform at the concert last Jan. 1. Dang! Everything’s just perfect. 💜
In nayeon Joon jeongjeon Momo Jang Sana Jang Park jihyo Mina jang Kim dahyun Son chaeyoung Choi tzuyu Twice ❤❤ Kim jisoo Kim Jenni Park rose La Lisa Blackpink No me Se el de red velvet
xime xd For BP is Roseanne Park and Lalisa Manoban (you didn't know how to spell their names). Red Velvet Bae Juhyun Kang Seulgi Son Seunghwan Park Sooyoung Kim Yerim
But we already know in terms of singing rv is the winner but if you put mamamoo and gfriend here i think the list would be. 1. Mamamoo 2. Gfriend 3. Red velvet 4. Twice 5. Black pink
I think the reason Red Velvet did so well is because the work they put outside of their vocal strength outside of performing and vocal practices. I believe it was mentioned somewhere that they also practice their singing while they dance in practices and while they jog and exercise. You can tell they put a lot of work into how strong they sound and it really pays off.
introhellevator I think most SM groups practice like that, I know that Shinee and SuJu have done that to improve their lung capacity so they’ll sing better live
Yes. Even though is not to the same degree, I do show choir in school and our director make us song full voice while dancing when were rehearsing. Even if we are just learn the dance so we look and sound strong. It really helps.
「 introhellevator 」 look how all sm idol be trained that's why all sm artists including RV have such a good vocal than other artists. Support RV and others SM artists
listen to all of their b-side tracks like blue lemonade, butterflies, with you, and many more, you will listen to their perfect and angelic harmonization
Crazy thing is that Red Velvet sing all their choruses together and they have 5 members. They don’t alternate like other groups and have to harmonise. They really don’t get a break on stage and still sing and dance consistently and are very stable.
JeonGyeon Makes Pink Lemonade never said that all of them are UNTALENTED ... if you can't read .. I meant the one with the most talent .. dumbass ... And I don't need to be the most talented person to identify someone with no talent
I'm just here to see how talented REDVELVET is. Their talent and visuals made them FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR FAR different from the others. I stan a TALENTED GIRLGROUP.
Lets accept.. BP is popular because of their music style. Its trendy. Twice got popular by applying the cute side,which is very wanted in Asia. RV is very diverse and versatile,so they have a lot of sides.they can't feed any certain category for long time. Am a real hard Reveluv. So for me RV is ulti. But many people doesn't have patience to check their all sides. People got attracted to easy ones generally. They don't like to go deep. We can't blame them, it costs more time. So they enjoy the ones they got easily.
@Aneeka the comment didn't imply that. No one stops you from preferring a group that have more generic or basic music and concept and it doesn't make your taste worst because there is a thing called PREFERENCE. Music is subjective we know but RV already has better musicality and more innovative music and concept than both but is less appreciated and less popular because they are overshadowed with generic concepts and music.
THUNDER DUMPLING I don't understand with jyp too. I see he the worst about find the real talent. See on kpop star he missed out so many talent. I feel sad for jungyeon. she don't deserve this.
THUNDER DUMPLING She can hir high notes perfectly fine and was always stable everyone said she save twice vocals in every mr removed she sounded the best in sixteen she slayed with.vocals no visual AND THEN SHE GETS ONLY LINES WHEN JIHYO DO HER HIGH NOTES OR DO SUPPORT JIHYO LIKE ALWAYS LIKE WHY
Just as everyone said, RV vocals are clearly the best, but being the most successful and popular group don‘t always acquire the best vocalists. While Bp and Twice went on with the same concept most of their career, being safe, RV played around with quirky and unique concepts. But the risk with this is that they lose fans with every concept and (of course gaining some) But luckily psycho did extremely well and made some people open their eyes and actually appreciate RV Talents. I personally loved and stanned RV for since Rookie and I loved every cb since because they pulled of every Single concept and made me like every song, even though they were unusual to me.
Bae Tokki seeing a bunch of haters XD I think they're all talented. Also we gotta keep in mind they're singing and dancing. Their vocals can't be spot on perfect all the time XD
BLACKPINK & Red Velvet seriously don't need autotune in their voices. The reason why Twice have many fans is because the members have different nationalities, just think about how many supports they can get from each members family.
张强 yes couldn't agree more, I thought about that too. half of them are not korean. esp in japan, Most of male in japan like cute thingy. And 3 out of 4 are Japanese so yeah
its just that stupid ass 'shashasha' shit and TT that got them so famous, and maybe their visuals too, other than that they arent really famous for their vocals or talent or anything
Muntaha Rahman Stop hating. You don't know how hard it was for all of them when they were trainees. You don't have any right to judge them when you haven't experienced the pain they went through. All idols had to go through the same thing. You have to face the fact that Twice is popular for something. The world is like that.
Red velvet is consisted of 5 talented girls sadly, their label doesn't them treat well as much as they treat their boy groups. :(( PS. I don't hate SM's bgs but their treatment is just soooo unfair. Red velvet and their future girl groups deserves better treatment. #RedvelvetDeservesBetter
Im a hardcore Blink.. but i have to agree that Red Velvet is so slay af!!! They sound so fucking stable tho.. with that hard choreo, that is insane.. Okay i fall in love now.. i understand that most of you say "try to stand on stage and perform.. u never know how it feel, dont easily jugde their vocal".. Dude, i know all of us arent better than them, but the fact that they trained for so long but still dont have a great vocal on stage??
The reason why red velvet is obviously the best is because their vocalists wendy, seulgi and joy have such unique vocal colors and are powerful and mature-sounding as well. Even if people say irene and yeri are weak vocalists yall cant deny that they also sing really well and can even hit high notes considering theyre rappers. Literally everyone in red velvet not just CAN sing but are also REALLY GOOD at singing. As for blackpink, well they have good voices and unique tone and sounds as well i just would want to hear more from them so i could actually really see their vocal capabilities. I havent really heard them have so much power in their voices yet like mamamoo and rv. As for twice i really do enjoy their music tbh and i respect them but theyre definitely the least vocally skilled among the big 3 girl groups. Even irene and yeri could prolly be lead and main vocals if they were with twice.
jed, I respect your opinion. I am a once but I prefer red velvet's vocals over TWICE. But what do you mean that Yeri and Irene are can be main vocalists in TWICE? Yeri and Irene are considered the weakest vocalists in red velvet and you are saying that they can be MAIN vocalists in TWICE??? C'mon TWICE are not as bad as you are thinking. In TWICE we have Jihyo, Nayeon, Jeongyeon, Chaeyoung and Mina and the other members are improving massively especially Tzuyu. She was very stable during feel special. Go watch feel special and see how much they improved. I know no one can beat red velvet when it comes to vocals but please don't underestimate TWICE they are good too.
@@arfamo6823 i am not underestimating twice at all and thanks for being respectful. Idk maybe i just have really high standards bc sm just really have a good profile of gg vocals since s.e.s. to rv now. I really do believe twice has great potential. But they lack technique. Even their main and lead vocals do. Jeongyeon actually has the most technique among them altho its not so obvious as she is like srsly the most underrated twice vocal. Ive been saying this a lot since watching their ice cream perf at gda (then theres this controversy about their recent encore stages again) that jyp really needs to give these girls a break and have their vocals improve if the agency really cares about twice's growth as artists and not just the money they can generate thru twice. The girls are overworked that they dont get enough time to explore their potentials. Jyp has to step his game up. Also you may watch rv's latest reve festival performances and you'll see what i mean about irene and yeri's vocals. Theyre really good, just that they arent given enough opportunities to have their vocals shine in the general public. Edit: this is also just my opinion. Im not a once at all but i am obsessed with their songs and have huge respect to them.
jed, thanks for respecting ONCE and TWICE. Yes they may lack technique but their stability and power are really good tho. Also I barely hear their voices crack. And yes I did watch reve festival performances( I am 30% reveluv and 70% once)and all of their vocals were amazing. Maybe you are a hardcore reveluv so you may not know much about TWICE.
@@arfamo6823 i actually watch a lot of their live performances but not much of their concerts (i prolly will) but sometimes i end up getting disappointed cause its either back vocals are too loud or vocals are pre-recorded. Id have to watch mr removed perfs to enjoy their actual vocals. Anyways, just sayin i srsly have nothing against twice im prolly more mad on the agency cause i personally think its not just enough that their artists can sing. Techniques are important esp bc theyre almost on their 5-year mark and so many people still have the same criticism on twice which is their vocals. Maybe its putting pressure on their end but its for their betterment anyway and i know they themselves are eager to improve.
jed, again thanks for respecting TWICE. And I agree that in TWICE only Jihyo,Nayeon and Jeongyeon are good but please support TWICE. They are very hardworking. And I hope that they will improve with their vocals. Also the ranking for me is 1. Red velvet 2. Twice 3. Blackpink
honestly twice shouldn't have been compared with bp and rv their coregraphy are less hard than blackvelvet's ones plus we all know that twice is kinda bad:/ i wish they give more line to jungyeon, an actual talented vocal
Slay HyunA no twices Choreographies are so easy everyone can dance to it they only do the TT with her Hands and this is Hard ?! stop comparing bp with twice bp is on higher level
Red Velvet has debuted 3 years ago, going into their fourth year. Twice debuted 2 years ago, going into their 3rd year. And Blackpink debuted 1 year ago, going into their second year. So there is not really much of a difference between them.
helloh gurl actually if you listen carefully to other mr removed blackpink songs that lisa has more lines, lisa us actually the most stable, but jisoo is also more stable than the other two. Btw not trying to attack you
Really sad that the most talented group, RV, is the one with the least amount of success. I know they have the most experimental sound (with BP having a wide international appeal and Twice sticking to bubblegum that never fails in Korea), but RV deserves better.
BP and Twice are the most popular, but Red Velvet has more talent, YG and JYP force the voice of their idols, like momo and Rose, In red velvet no one force their voices, Twice has normal dances, i alredy know all the choreography of twice, but Twice with easy dances they dont sing well, actually they are doing well, but they already debuted at 3 years ago and finally the can sing well,BP already has difficult coreographys, but their vocals... mmmm... i alredy dont like Rose Vocals, it’s like if she has a stuffy nose... they debut at 2 years ago and they are doing well, Red velvet is one of the most talent groups, when they debuted they have an perfect vocal, and they have one of the most difficult coreographys, but they still doing well... And im agree with the Red Velvet deserves better cause its the true, if we compare BP,Twice And Red velvet, Red Velvet are the most talented, but the less popular☹️ (Sorry for my bad english) Its just my opinion 😊
What do you expect? Like you said they use a lot of vocals, and their dancing, its hard to hit notes like that while dancing. FYI blackpink and twice have easy vocals *sometimes also sorry*
*Watching this after 2 and a half years* Red velvet - still stable queens and always have been Twice - incredibly improved their vocals, I'm so proud of them Blackpink - still on the same level, some members even below yet has grown their popularity so much...
I mean blackpink is not really a vocal group cuz yk they more rap and swag (YG style). They get people due to their style. They are talented but just not in the vocal department. Don’t hate on people, since what they are saying is true.
It’s sooo nice to see other fandoms talking trash about Blackpink because they are far more popular than the groups that they stan😆😆well with their “mediocre” talent they have reached this level imagine if they had been more “talented” your stans won’t even have the chance so be thankful 😘
actually russian roulette's dance is more difficult than dumb dumb. Watch russian roulette 2x speed on weekly idol , but in this MR removes video Red Velvet still slayy, their voice stable too. Daebak, I'm proud 👏 Seulgi Wendy Joy Irene Yeri unni ❤ Stan RV
Vicka Khayrunnisa blackvelvet always gets the hard choreo but they sing still stable its really wow lol im thinking twice how come they can be popular lol once are so weird
kei ss yeah right , i always amaze with blackvelvet's energic choreo but they still can maintain their vocal. they re really deserve more love. i dunno why twice is popular in K. i didnt think Tw is extraordinary. i have to admit that Tw have catchy song. but for their choreo and vocal they re far below from RV and BP's level. no hate, just my opinion.
I Stan Gay Bands - I know how it sounds when they are manipulated. You can hear that their voices are tuned. But I guess that's because I'm experienced in these things. Some people manipulate BPs MR removed to make them look bad. For example, this one here isn't manipulated. And all of them are stable even tho their choreo is tiring. I don't think it's realistic when they sound worse in DDDD when their choreo is easier and not as tiring as PWF. But in reality they don't sound worse. Most MR removed are manipulated for Blackpink. Ask questions if you want to.
Red Velvet Multi Fandom Yeas. I'm just so proud an happy that I'm stanning almost all TALENTED GROUPS OF SM 😘 #SuperJunior #SNSD #SHINEE #RedVelvet #fx #NCT FIGHTING SMTOWN
Random Shizz bitter spotted can't accept the truth. Btw i just want to share that Best vocals in kpop/steady TOP 3 1. MAMAMOO 2.RED VELVET 3.GFRIEND. (3rd Generation) That's it.
You don't really compare people's singing while they dance lol. But well it's a known fact that SM idols go through A LOT more ACTUAL vocal training. So yeah they're much better but you can't say the other 2 are shit because they can't sing as well while they dance..
This is why rv is more popular among the idols boys or girlgroups they really admire them since they are always in an event and RV is always slaying the live performances
