@user-mr6ge9nl7h They have a very serious benchmark measurements. Their top list is pretty much on par with real life. Do you really think you could decide in this video wich one is best. Photos are way to small. This video is to get views.
Hey guys. I think the best way to truly have a versus between these phones is to have them compete with at least 3 different pictures set. This 1 off is tricky bcos any phone can get lucky/unlucky as the case may be, and this does not truly represent its capacity
I agree. At first I was suprised they included gaming phones such as redmagic 8s pro and rog 7 ultimate. Then when I saw them doing good and asus winning it I laughed out loud. There's no possible way rog 7 ultimate has better camera than s23 ultra. Neither redmagic 8s pro is better than iphone 15 pro max
@@0xBlez even when the truth is right in front of your eyes you deny it? so you wanted the s23 ultra and iphone 15 pro max to be lucky? I think this shatters the nonsense of particular phones always being consisted, especially iphones.
I can agree, but the nicer photo was of the Asus. Just overall nicer and warmer to a Christmas picture. Pixel's was too cold, although real feels empty.
Sony takes either too dark pictures or too bright! The only time I can take a picture with auto mode and the balance is right is at golden hour. Then it takes good pics
I really really hope they can make their Zen phones like this, I'd rather they made the battery smaller and dumped a much larger camera in it to compete with the iPhone Pros (not Pro Max) since there's really not much 'small' phone options Edit: it'd be funny if they just didn't bother with telephoto and managed to put something like a 0.9/1" main (with high MP so you can crop/zoom) and nothing else for the rear cameras
i have moved from huawei to sony just days ago. and yes, the cameras on this thing is EXCELLENT! although the photos are soft, but i don't mind because they're supposed to be soft if there are less post-processing applied, making the photos very realistic. most may not prefer sony's approach, but with all the AI's, over sharpening, over brightening and color boosting in most flagship phones today, i still prefer what's real to my eyes
I own the S23 ultra and I thought the top 3 in my eyes were 1. iPhone 15 max pro, 2. Sony Xperia, 3. S23 Ultra. I'm shocked that the Sony didn't win the final vote. The ROG photo was so DRY, crunchy and oversharpened.
Whilst I'm happy that you actually took time to use the Xperia properly and pleasantly surprised that the gaming phones came as far as they did, i feel like the process could get better
Damn nobody talks about how the s23 ultra hold up than other phones that came out in the same year with it. Pixel has always been the winner of these type of review very happy samsung made the phone of the year ❤
@DariuszTech for real that phone didn't even aged a year its more like it was released yesterday kuddos to samsung now am more excited what s23 ultra will bring 🔥
I mean there's too few samples to say and there's too few scenarios. But ROG phone did really great for a gaming phone. Doubt it will win on lowlight scenario tho or even just videos
I'm at the half of the video, and till now, i liked all the photos from phones that lost. I can understand the reason of this way you do the duels, but when you put 2 great phones to compete in 1st stage in one photo circumstance, it's not fair at all. Some are better in other conditions than others, and it all depends on that specific photo you choose to compare. I would love to see 8 vertical photos same time and vote.
I love those blind tests in everything, because most of the time, it reveals that most people think they have a preference of a thing, but they almost everytime don't even know what they are talking about. For exemple: most people I know says that they prefer iphone cameras, but when they do blind test, the iphone always lose to some other phone.
But iPhone has been consistently winning against the Samsung in most other comparisons. The voters are obviously all android fans as Apple people are too cool to participate in something so mundane 😏.
@@deckhead33 But the voters didn't know which was which, so your comment doesn't make any sense, they didn't know which one was the iPhone but somehow it still got voted out... maybe that tells us something 🤔
Buy a Redmagic 9 Pro, trust me it's camera and gaming is better than the ROG 8 Pro, look at side by side, plus it is cheaper. Redmagic is better look more into it, please reply asap
For me main camera -iphone because of shutter speed Ultrawide oneplus 9 pro's ultrawide Best portraits- vivo x100 pro or xiaomi 13 pro telephoto Night mode-google pixel Video-iphone ❤
I feel like you could improve the vote by having 2, 3 or even 4 comparison photos, where you take the same one with every phone, and then have a vote where every phone is compared with the other ones, more in style of the MKBHD test. While similiar, it would be great to see the comparison of a HDR shot, a lowlight shot and a portrait as MKBHD did too. While obviously you would want to differenciate a bit, this comparison feels too "unfair" as i for example find the iPhone better than the S23U, but you have never come around to compare them as the 15PM got eliminated in the first round. Just my 2 cents.
Not testing the physical camera but the built-in post-processing. should have did a few images for each test. low light, portrait, and a landscape shot.
It would be great to see these phones compared in much more photos instead of just one.The more no of photos will hive us an idea of whonis currently the best.
The following were my standings : 1) Find X6 Pro > iPhone 15 Pro Max 2) Honor Magic 5 Pro > S23 Ultra 3) ROG Phone 7 Ultimate > P60 pro 4) Pixel 8 Pro > Vivo X90 Pro+ 5) Xperia 1 V > Xiaomi 13 Ultra 6) OnePlus 11 > RedMagic 8S Pro 7) Find X6 Pro > S23 Ultra 8) Pixel 8 Pro > ROG Phone 7 Ultimate 9) Xperia 1 V > Redmagic 8S Pro 10) Xperia 1 V > ROG Phone 7 Ultimate > S23 Ultra I must say, that since I was supposed to choose one, that I did. However with many of them, it was a comparison of tradeoffs. So any one of them could've been the winner should the prioritization of factors be switched.
I was SHOCKED to see a Rog phone winning a camera Phone contest! I have the Rog Phone 3 myself, and while I do like its camera, its definitely not what I was looking for when I bought it. I was thinking on upgrading it in the future, and really loved my Rog 3 so going with its next generation seemed like a good idea to me, the only draw back was that now I am interested in a better camera, and turns out, some how after randomly searching for "the best Phone camera" it came out as the Winner! I was even surprised at first to see it on the list, so even more surprised I am now seeing it winning! Thank you so much for the review! made my choice much easier!
Couldn't watch this video because of those gestures and maneuvers girl... Be simple and please dont make gestures so much. Otherwise people had to fast forward the video
It's so interesting. MHKB's blind test placed the Xperia like dead last, and here it's in the final. And I don't think either got it wrong. These photos are great, and they were garbage in his testing.
Why not compare all the cameras at the same level with all the photos. That'll enable your followers to know the best bcos some can shot better photos in a certain lighting condition.
I always say that these days cameras are all so nice that its more a preference. Rog 7 winning just shows you that, because its one of the worst cameras around, but is still capable of some decent photos
Because it really is, except the part where it's considered to be the worst. Some processing is necessary to improve image quality for sure, but to do that on the next level where it alters the true colors and dynamics of the photo relative to the actual scene is already way too much, and is what must objectively be considered as the worst photo. If AI will be used so much to just make the image look more eye-catchy, then I might as well just go to the limits and ask it to make it a cartoon art instead of an actual picture.
IMO on final round X6 vs S23U x6 performs better (controlling highlights on the ceiling), subject is naturally illuminated, the overall pic is better on x6 P8P vs R7 pixel performs better in controlling lights and subject isolation on the doll is better and look at the floor its far better than R7
What is consistency for the winner and runner up consistency is bigger factor here over against galaxy and iPhone or pixel 🕷️ that's why it's unmatched
I miss that male host, Ozzy, as well :( I think those phones will be compared early next year when their higher-end variants; Xiaomi 14 Ultra, Vivo X100 Ultra, Oppo X7 Ultra, and the Galaxy S24 Ultra will come out...
I don't understand the classification of s23u? I changed my s23u for an Honor 5pro because of the poor photo quality of the s23u.... In Dxomark the honor and the pixel 8pro are ranked in the top 5, the s23 and 17th and you find yourself the best s23u in picture ? Explain to me why?
Please also add different lenses comparison like the ultra wide and a portrait comparison with there zoomed in options cause almost everyone nowadays click pictures using portrait modes right so I guess you should add this category
Juzgar una foto solo en una toma es algo incorrecto. Hay configuraciones que ayudan bastante en el modo noche en Xiaomi, Oppo y One Plus. Es más difícil editar una foto con falta de color que editar una foto con ausencia de luz o con una focal que haga aparecer el grano en la fotografía... Es difícil juzgar una cámara solo por una sola foto
asus also won in marquze as well in previous years blind camera , so i wasn't suprise at all. by the way, add nubia z60 ultra for next year or z60s pro which will come next year o your comparison. a really solid rear camera setup
This is like ohh that RU-vid channel released best photography phone 2023 comparison. We have to do it. There is no RnD i see in this video. At last it's all about versus making money.
Well actually comparing 2 phone's cameras using 1 photo from both is a very useless way of judging which phone has better camera. This comparison doesn't show the true story and your test methods are dumb just like most other youtubers. This type of comparison are tend to mislead people.
the only place iphone does better is in the reviews from reviewers. in real life i rarely liked my iphone photos. because they are simply too dark, less saturated, less dynamic range, and less zoom.
Amazing result. Blind camera test showing overrated iphone and pixel their place. Tech reviewers and fanboys overrate and hype their favourite brands but blind camera test there's no bias and we see the true result.
its very sad how people choose a photo. the winner was the samsung s23y by far. in the last 3 phots the rog has blown out the sky, the shadows in the right are bad and the hair wasn t exspose right. again! its crazy how people choose a photo because maybe it has more saturation!!! anyways thanks for the video
That haze was very nasty for sure, even if it meant that it tried to balance everything out. It was already way too processed that it did not look good at all because of excessive processing. The more saturation on the ROG was all because it focused on the main subject while trying to put the background a bit under control without excessively applying post-processing effects. It did it naturally like, you know, how a REAL camera would behave, and the result was a pleasing photo that looked to be taken by a proper camera more than a smartphone camera. Even without labelling them their names and knowing which phone took which photo, I'd already be able to immediately tell that the first photo was taken from a smartphone because of the way it was processed. No real camera would behave like that unless there is some severe post-processing done.
Can someone explain why people like "more realistic" i mean, come on ... its much nicer just to upload your photo without million filters. This is not e professional Camera where you need it in RAW.
