Blue Ivy Makes SURPRISE Appearance on Stage With JAY-Z at the GRAMMYs 

🙄

They all look beautiful and cute at young age.

She is not pretty, let's stop

⬆️⬆️ yeah great job mouthing off about other people's win.. and teaching her it's ok to think you are better than others? She had no business on that stage!!

Doing a great job pushing a 12yr old into adulthood. Ok

I think they should teach her about posture though. She's kinda slumped over.

@@NewLife4GVN She's twelve years old a child you shouldn't even be noticing her posture

@@NewLife4GVNhalf of America does this shit

If you're featured on a grammy winning song, you deserve a grammy. There's no age limit

​@@frankie7636no

Now we know hahahahaha

She also wrote what she sang so she qualified for it.

Exactly

There are more hard worker artist who deserves it. They just got connections and Grammies rigged.

Ohhhh What intelligence! Ya doofi! Even you like us all, has literally, just written more than a line! ☝️ See! 🏆 Ah Thankya! Where ma Grammy!! (Grammys are respected as much as a chocolate teapot... useless and ridiculous)

@@_hmineee That’s what you think 🥴🤡

I was thinking the same exact thing! People be trying to sexualize their kids way too early especially in that industry! For God's sake, she's only 12!!😟

Thank you! I was scrolling through the comments to find even 1 person who felt the way I did about this 12yr old kid at a grown people event showing cleavage .. craziness!!

​@@irvinsimmonds9245 Me too! I was like" what is wrong with people?!" Don't they see what a child looks like? It's not normal for her to be dressed like that! She just turned 12. I don't know what's wrong with Beyonce.

The dress looks fine, so does blue. Elegant for the occasion. Nothing is wrong with Beyonce for allowing Blue, at twelve to dress appropriately for the occasion. If it was a Kar-Jenners child, I am 100% the comments would read differently even if the child wore a transparent plastic bag. (My opinion) I own it.

@@aquarian1314 my statement has nothing to do with race or social status. Her cleavage shouldn't been shown at twelve. PERIOD!

Yall* are triggered at just the assumption white mediocrity. The majority of Grammy winners selected by the academy are undeserving honestly.

Where was the lie? Some of them don’t deserve it. Because he told the truth, he has you haters all mad and up in arms fr. It’s quite funny

it seems the fanboys are more riled up. it's all rigged which explains his own 24 grammies in the first place.

He said some of you shouldn't be in the category which is correct. The grammy's often put artists in the wrong categories which isn't fair.

USED to be a drug dealer. Give credit where credit is due, he's turned his life around and is quite successful.

@@miloperrault2614 Did he turn his life around and have integrity? He cheated on his wife. Bought his fame with drug money and made bribed the entertainment industry to speak nice of him. Do you know he can buy any gangster to silence anyone?

And u must've forgot he can casually purchase ur entire bloodline now 😂

@Q.T-T ...naw ...my soul isn't 4 sale ...Jay Z and Beyonce soul their souls to Devil for fake gold and their due date is coming 👹

@@miloperrault2614 Exactly. Rotten people like this only wanna focus on the bad side of people. Never the good. It’s entirely what’s wrong with today’s effed up world

what is it with black men that they think they are owed everything

Yes

Agree

Cry harder

@@AngeBiampandou cry harder is 2024-ian for "I don't agree with you but I am to lazy/dumb to write anything else than this".

I mean she should've though.. It obviously doesn't make sense that she's just now winning a grammy?.. If anything, YOU must think the grammy judges are the actual Gods who mustn't be questioned..

No matters what is said or done Blue Ivy is still a 12 year old child trying to be an adult.

@@ChloeWhites And that’s what has you fuming and so pressed? 💀😂

@@ChloeWhites You’re all up in her business and while she has the emotional maturity of an adult, here you are acting like a child fuming over the way someone else’s whole child is being raised and carries herself. We got far more children growing up to be spoiled entitled brats and you’re here worrying about a 12 year old that’s mature for her age and conducts herself well with the public. Beyond f*king sad

@@ChloeWhiteshow she looking like an adult ? How can you tell that from a 3 minute video? How do you know that maybe when she got home she started jumping around like a kid her age and maybe even acts like a teen queen like most 12 year olds now a days I know 12 year olds that act more like adults and make a fool out of themselves then she ever will now do you know all this from 3 minutes I wanna know? I think she reads the crowed very well and acts appropriately according to the people around her which only means she’s raised right doesn’t mean that if she doesn’t run around and plays or acts like a 12 year old on stage doesn’t mean she’s acting like an adult . I was 10 Acting like that at my dad’s meetings and moms get together . But as soon as they left trust me I was the biggest child ever . It’s just about reading your surroundings I was able to be a kid but at meetings or church I acted the best because that’s how my parents raised me. You sound like the kind of parent that lets their kid run around and scream and yell at restaurants and do what they want or throw themselves on the ground screaming when they want to just because they are “ kids” that doesn’t make them kids that shows what kind of parenting you have .

Thanks to money. It’s easier to clean up with money you know….

He’s certainly better than your hating ass. And everything he said in that speech was full on correct. And who in tf are YOU to say what he’s allowed to do with HIS child? He brought her up there because he wanted to share the win with his family. I’m sorry you don’t know or never got to experience what that is like. Must be why you’re so angry and full of hate

True!!! Always find something to complain about.

He was just trying to point out his disappointment, but they just need to let it go. Everyone will not win. Some never win. These awards shows are trash. Beyoncé and Jay-Z should do like Eminem and other artists and stop attending these lame award shows. They do nothing for anyone's career. They are not comfortable giving big awards to people of color. TS will win AOTY again in 2025. The same people receive the big awards every year. Beyoncé is doing great. Let "these" people have their Oscar, Emmy, Grammys 66 years. It was more than 40 years before people of color first received an award. They still don't want people of color. Don't go where "they" don't want you 😮

Self centered there are mad coss new young artists won they should let others shine and what a shame dishing them.and him and Beyonce they have so much.money

These people??? Smh

"These people".. Have some shame bud..

Oh wow!! I didn't know you live with them! That's so dope! Oh wait..... you don't. We only know what's seen in the media. Come on now, you should really know better

Wow. Didn’t know you were her this whole time and actually live with them. Oh. I’m sorry you do NOT. I hate HATE HATE people like you that make assumptions about how a child’s life is. You don’t know whether or not she had a childhood. You go based off only what you see in the media and online. You’re what’s wrong with the world. Grow up and learn that blatant and loud wrong assumptions about people and their children aren’t cute in any way

Didn’t know you could enter her mind and read her thoughts and speak them for her.

Why would you think that? You think she didn’t go to school? Have friends? You think she never played with Barbie’s dolls? Or outside? She did. She’s simply grown now. Why then would you think she never had a childhood?

I’m profile, she is the spitting image of her daddy.

Yet he was receiving a Grammy honor…weird. It’s like getting over paid and complaining that you want more money right now!

Oh wow I didn’t know you were a telepath and can warp into this girl’s exact thoughts. Do you know and realize how dumb you sound making assumptions about how this girl feels about her own FATHER? Y’all are sad fr. Grow up 🤡🤡If he’s a crybaby then what does that make you talking shit about her dad online?

She's not a young woman, she's a 12 year old child! What is this makeup and this decolette at this age!

@@Phoebbouffay Once you hit puberty you're considered a young woman. If you're not a girl you wouldn't know

see; told you the fanboys were more hurt.

They can say what they want

​@@jackiebennett6304what is it with black men that they think they are owed everything

And that’s why you’re mad

@@KashiKay they are tired of the DISCRIMINATION

@@jackiebennett6304 .... while all the rest of human mankind, is just so damn tired of your petty, childish, conning, lying, jealousy ridden, feeling like you deserve everything and anything, without working hard for it, crybaby, disrespecting everyone and anything, everywhere-whinning! Ya' Dig???? LONG LIVE CAITLIN CLARK!!!♥️🤘 LONG LIVE TAYLOR SWIFT!!!🍻♥️🤘 ALL LIVES MATTER, NOT JUST YOURS!!!

💕

He’s right. Get over it. He didn’t just speak for his family. He spoke for ALL. Can you hear???

Lol. ​@@jackiebennett6304

He never once mentioned color. You're just exposing your own white fragility. There are some white artists that you probably wouldn't believe have never won a Grammy. He's just pointing out that it's all subjective. They choose who they wanna honor and who too snub. The proof is in the history.

@@YoungMr.H.5304 TELL HIM

White people don’t have the same history as POC in the US. I’m so tired of yall saying this stupid ass shit. Plus, he said NOTHING about race.

My goodness she's only 11 yrs old ...stop the sick fawning Sir

Cast blue ivy as melody in live action version from the little mermaid 2 return to the sea

@@zyajones9360 It's a woman...and she's just complimenting her. Calm down.

@@zyajones9360 Are you blind in one eye or can you just not tell men and women apart? That’s a female who just complimented her. Get your eyes checked

@@zyajones9360 Get your eyes checked. That’s a woman complementing her. It’s not sick fawning. Weirdo

Who was she up against that year?

@@jessinicole7998Taylor Swift

Rumors and hear say

No he’s not. Y’all are just hateful and petty angry. That’s all

@@KashiKay that describes him perfectly

She has 32! Just ridiculous to complain.

@@debsea2759 Where was SHE complaining?! Nowhere. Y’all are so dumb

Very greedy selfish and think they are entitled to everything

...Boom!!! Just straight up FACTS!!!

I guess you missed everything he said then if you deem his wise and TRUTHFUL words arrogant. Nothing he said was incorrect

Why not? She can't support and be alongside her father??

@@KashiKay 1. She had no choice really, she obeyed the father, also the moment was very intense. 2. How can an 11 (?) yo Support the 50 year old man? Support? On stage? Is he dealing with some hard stuff there to be relying on a child? He's got his wife there for Support if that's needed. Also the girl felt pretty uncomfortable staiyng by him being nervous because he was saying controversial and very emotional things. She may have not realized that fully, but that was not a happy moment he wanted to share. Doing that while holding your Child's hand For Support?.. Isn't she the fragile one there?

@@darya5293 And if it wasn’t happy why was she smiling and laughing with him? You people are truly blind and so ignorant fr. You and your assumptions about these people are what’s wrong with the world

@@darya5293 Oh and what was “controversial” to YOU was inspirational and the flat out TRUTH to others. Your opinion isn’t the only out there. And certainly not the right one either. The only fragile one is you because you can’t handle the truth of what is actually happening with her. She loves her father and he loves her. No forced obedience anywhere. I’m sorry the same can’t be said for you or yours

Get over it

​@jackiebennett6304 considering you're leaving several comments all over this video it's obvious you need to get over it lol. The Carters don't care that you're aggressively defending them in the comments of an ET video 😂

@@aussiejubes he’s tired of the WHITE SUPREMACY and DISCRIMINATION. GET OVER THE FACT THAT THIS WILL NEVER BE A WHITE AMERICA ✊🏽 😂 😜

Taylor made HISTORY. She broke Frank Sinatra, Paul Simon and someone else's record. That is why she was so happy. I bet you didn't get mad a SZA for crying. 🙄

@@ameliadavis1979 Amelia, I'm pretty sure the OP was talking about Jay Z lol

In my opinion very disrespectful towards other people’s work. This reminds me when Taylor Swift got ambushed by Kanye. Ivy got a grammy for singing a few words…really? When you get nominated you should be prepared to win or lose

They do what they want don't believe the hype. They have been taking and stealing since ancient times

Her mother is classy, dad is a a-hole. You don't put down other people because you or someone you care about didn't win. Bit-ass move. I am sure Beyonce was embarrassed. Her and Taylor are very supportive of each other. They both showed up at each others concert movie premiere. Taylor posted a very sweet note saying what an inspiration she is to her and said some other nice things. Jay is worse than Kanye. Everyone knows Kayne lives to insult/offend people. Jay knows better. Hate and disgusting of Jay.

... That's not even a real award, they just made it up so that you can shut the front door about anything and everything, regarding the already overly played and truly tiresome, "someone who looks like me", "we want reparations", " it's because we're black", bullsh_ _ whining and crying about someone or something who did you wrong garbage.... and by the way, please stop including us proud and hardworking, truly respectful and honest Hispanics when you start with your BS about all of things you are so long ago, even more now, well known for... it's ONLY when it's convenient to you!!! Eff' You!!! Don't mix us in with your "to all of us black and BROWN people everywhere... NO!!! WE'RE NOT HYPOCRITES LIKE YOU... DON'T EFFIN' GET US MIXED UP WITH YOU... ESPECIALLY WHEN IT'S FOR YOUR CONVENIENCE!!! FACTS!!! ALL LIVES MATTER!!!

It feels like that in a airy sinister way…I don’t want to think it

Never. Also, she always appears emotionally distant from her parents.

That is a lie

... except for all of the ones that you're telling yourselves... FACTS!!!

Exactly

@@alejandronovela3280 No it’s the ones you haters are telling yourselves

@@KashiKay ... I really think, no, check that.. I really KNOW that you're the ones actually drinking all of the Hater-Ade, trying to quench all of your huge jealousy thirst and hating on everyone else who you know are right about also having an opinion about everything, everyone and anything, and not just you. Peace 🎶🤘

Why is that YOUR business? Not your kid, you shouldn’t be worried. Nosy ass. Yikes 😬If she’s happy just being alongside her mother and father, that’s all that matters. And HER business, NOT YOURS! Ya know? 🤡

I agree the cleavage show for just a 12 year old is a no no

Why are you ‘sorry’?? She doesn’t owe you Beyoncé’s face or any face. Disgraceful comment

@@no_prisoners6474 💯