Ranking starts at 1:05 I know I’ll get some disagreements (and some hate) here so please leave your ranking down below! Thanks for watching! Please like and subscribe!
I agree that the big mistake a lot of groups made was songs that didn't play to their strengths. I watched some practices and some of them were noticeably better . So I guess nerves or just bad days got some of them
I especially feel for the G group, having to do the whole thing in another language. I do think it looks like they're being held to unfair standards though. They're being treated like they're all supposed to be all rounders, all top singers and all top dancers... but some of them are rappers not singers and we've seen plenty of idols debut before they could do everything, as long as they stood out doing SOMETHING.
That is so true about all of them be judged as all rounders! Some idols who have trained for some years still struggle. Especially like you said with G-group singing in a language they’re not their primary language. You can say mnet is trying to train the best of best trainees. Even still these survival shows are not based on talent, they’re popularity contest.
honestly if you think about it too they're sitting there for more than 24 hours without eating, drinking, or sleeping and still having to perform so them performing like that is already incredible. According to ziyin from girls planet, she wasn't allowed to drink at all except for 1 tiny spit before she went on stage, and the theme song took 2 consecutive days to film!
I realized that my fav performance is K- group Wakeonez (The real) All 5 of them are so good. They were really crazy all-rounders: taerae's high note, lee junghyeon's rap, Phanbin 's amazing dance skills and legendary MunJung's CHEOTTOROGAYO♡︎ I'm really obsessed with watching this performance every day
K-trainees did so well most of the group speak hard. But, I like perfomance with individuality and put personality into the performance. So, my personal top 3 pick is: 1. G- group Yuehua. Zhenghao, Ollie, Ricky, Brian. 2. G-group, Indipendent. Seok Matthew. 3. G-group. American. Jay and Kamden
My rank 1 is the USA duo, Jay has a really good voice and was also upset when they cut Kamden's rap. The two made such a good collaboration. And I didn't even know Zihao dances like that, I just thought he did well dancing the signal song because I first noticed him there. All in all, I think mnet did so well in making the G-trainees look less talented or lacking a lot 🙄 Like bro, they're generally so good.
the rewatch value is rly high thoo- also seung eon’s vocals & yujin’s aura definitely elevated their performance to the next level, which rightfully earned that top spot 👍
@@iplaboyou Seungeon has potential, but he seemed more like he was yelling Taeil's highnote than belting it. The others had a tendency toward being flat which makes me unlikely to re-watch.
@@flaggov6949 i agree with the others being flat at times, but having G-Group's version to compare with, Zhang Hao was more shouty while Seungeon's high note had an added vibrato to it 😬
@@iplaboyou True, but I'm not arguing that G-group's kick It should be number 1. I'm arguing that K-groups Kick-it shouldn't be number 1. I'd put Hui as number 1.
Personally, I love Seok Matthew's stage the mosst. It is just so refreshing and happy to watch (it doesn't mean others' are not^^). My top 3 is: 1.G-Group Seok Matthew(All I wanna do) 2.G-Group Jay & Na Kamden (Rush hour) 3.G-Group Zhanghao, Ollie, Ricky, Brian (Kick it)
i totally agree with your comment with hanbin.. in every survival show, i always root for the underdog.. i dont usually like the most popular ones.. but man shanbin just shatters that mentality.. even if he’s the most popular contestant, he always proves that he deserves it.. and that’s why i was rooting for him til the end.. just a shame he didnt get that center on the finals 😢
I think the top 3 really depends on which aspect is more important to the viewer. As for me, I would focus more on vocals and rap which is why I'd rank them like this: 1. G-Group America 2. K-Group Lee Hoetaek (maybe I'm biased bc its Hui but idc it's my ranking) 3. K-Group YueHua Ent. Really appreciate how you aren't just bullying them tho. You're actually giving criticism and acknowledging their potential.
I can see why that would be your rankings. I like how you prioritize vocals since I notice vocals haven’t been prioritized lately in kpop. Also thank you, I want to be fair as possible!
My favourites were: Jay (amazing vocals), Dang Hong Hai (I loved his smooth dance), Hanbin (perfect performance), Zhang Hao (amazing), Matthew (so good) and Krystian (very stable and I agree, carried the performance) And there was something funny and cool with Bak Doah performance.
@@peteislostinthesauce his brother's name is June, he's in a j-pop/k-pop group called orbit, they're very nugu so maybe that's why the show didn't bring it up
I totally agree there are many good and impressive performance that Mnet cut (and i still angry),as Lee Yedam, Wang Zi Hao, G group Vietnam performances and Na Kamden rap part...I really hope people will watch their videos
This gonna be a late comment but if I will rank them. 1st - Jay and Kamden 2nd - Hui (as expected of him) 3rd - RedStart Trainees (Nunu Nana) 4th - Osaka Team (Keita's team) 5th - Mirotic Team This is only based on my personal preferences though but I respect yours.
This is a perfect rating except personally I would switch matthew and the osaka japan group. Also, the dark version of attention just didnt't hit for me too.
yesss the k grp kick it performance is one of my favorites too!! seungeon's voice stuck out to me, he's definitely one of the best vocalists on the show
ichika ouju and itsuki (g-group / shinee pentagon) were suppose to perform w 3 other members: hyo yutaka toui, but something happened and mnet still hasn’t disclosed why the other members couldn’t perform but the 3 that did had only 1 hour to prepare. PLEASE SUPPORT TEAM TOKYO. i’m side-eyeing mnet hard af rn.
I am also still mad they cut Kamden’s rap. At least he rose up in the rankings but I feel like he would be much higher now if they showed his rap. And his dancing is amazing. I’ve been voting for him at least 🤷♀️
I love our leader nimm hui huhu KSHKGDJ SO YEAH, HUI AND JAY(DAMM HIS VOICE IS SO GOOD, LIKE YOU WON'T FEEL BORED AND TIRED LISTENING HIM SINGING) PLS VOTE FOR THEM
Im 3 months late but my top 3 will be wakeone K group, sunghanbin, jelly fish. With honourable mention for k group who performs mirotic. That performance is really genius. The low octave>>❤
At least right now, it doesn't seem like these boys suffered a lot of what the girls did during their auditions. I agree with your entire ranking and what you thought about them. I'm hoping to see them all get better and be able to do better in whatever they end up doing! I probably won't watch the epis but the performances.
ive already been ranking all the performances as ive been watching so ill do all 39 lmao (in order of priority--stage presence, stability, vocals, dance, rap) 1. america - rush hour 2. hoetaek - shut down 3. wakeone k - the real 4. wakeone k - freak 5. individual - mirotic 6. redstart - nununana 7. osaka - conduct zero 8. first one - attention 9. yuehua g - kick it 10. wakeone g - glitch mode 11. jellyfish - gbtb 12. beijing - call me baby 13. wumuti - un village 14. wang zihao - veil 15. seok matthew - all i wanna do 16. top media - who 17. woolim - damdadi 18. wakeone k - bloom bloom 19. taipei - tiger inside 20. sung hanbin - beautiful beautiful 21. thailand - kokobop 22. takuto - instead of saying goodbye 23. oui - love scenario 24. yuehua k - kick it 25. individual - lullaby 26. guangdong - gods menu 27. 143 - replay 28. shanghai - reveal 29. jeon wooseok - criminal 30. aichi - crown 31. choi jiho - mmmh 32. tokyo - shine 33. vietnam - view 34. lee donggun - criminal 35. park doha - my house 36. jung mingyu - my house 37. lee yedam - gambler 38. hyogo - maniac 39. sichuan -
I agree! Tbh though for the first performance I was a bit upset since no one got a 4 star. Like they performed so well, and I understand the vocal part but Gunwook was stable throughout the entire performance. Anyways though, it was the very first performance and that can be a disadvantage. Rooting for their debut!
my opinion 1. Hui is the best singer on the show, followed by taerae and jay(he a on a totally different style, he will bring freshness to the group he debuts with). And personally I LOVE Cong's tone. 2. Kuan Rui best dancer on the show, followed by many, this season had some very good dancers like both hanbins haruto gunwoon kamden etc 3. I dont know who the best rapper is, even the final lineup is devoid of one, i think gunwook or jiwoong will take up the rapper position. 4. I totally dont like the final lineup cause it was obvious that shanbin Matthew jiwoong gyuvin and yujin will debut since like the second ep. taerae became obvious after like some 4th ep. ricky and gunwook are ig the only ones who got into the final line without much of mnets help. zhanghao is an Emporer lol, he had a very huge fanbase, wish his BFF got a fanbase too, we rui fans were too less:(
Yeah it sucks, the networks can edit this show and make someone look good or bad and decide what to show to the people! The fact that Ricky made it into the group chat as already an accomplishment on the fans part, bcuz it didn’t seem like mnet wanted him in the lineup
btw shine performance had and practiced w 6 members (hyo, toui and another trainee) but mnet cut the other 3 out of the performance, didn’t let them perform and sent the remaining 3 on with only an hour to practice the abridged version of the performance
lol at first what i saw the full stage i was furious over mnet for cutting off kamden! then that frustrated shifted towards jay as for some episodes he got some limelight and kamden got none. but then jay started getting completely ignored by mnet and then i forgot about him and just focused on kamden. then came the over me stage and boy did jay kill those vocals! now i want both of them to debut together. kamjay!
Freaking mnet even got Kuanrui's name wrong! he is a waste of talent! he is such an awesome dancer and performer! he created the butterfly stage beautifully! but mnet showed it plainly clearly that they didn't want him in the final lineup:( now the besties are separated:(
I agree with you for most of the performance. For me yuehua k was the only difference; I didn't rank that performance as no.1. It was in my top 10 though. They are all good but I guess the song didn't attracted me that much.
Ngl having “Attention” at 27 is a bit arguable. I mean they made it so it would more likely for boys(and i genuinely don’t care, but koreans tv shows do) and i also liked it. I mean Seowon was good thats about it
Totally see where you’re coming from. For me Attention is one of my fave songs and the way they changed it didn’t really suit my taste. And your right I did rewatch it again after wards and I admit he did do well!
I'm sure all the boys could have gave their best performace if they were the once choosing the song for themselves however i think mnet just doesn't like all the trainees so they gave them unsuitable songs for other contestants.
@@peteislostinthesauce especially the boys that perform hot like they certainly don't want to perform terrible but mnet gave that song to them and they because the laughing stock of the show
Well I’m not an expert but from what I hear, like trainees on survival programs like this and early debuts usually the companies style them. Then a couple years later down the road they get more control. That’s why you hear older artist not liking their earlier styles they had in their career!
why’s no one talking about anthonny🤨 and why everyone cutting off his screen time and high notes😭 first mnet and now you (jokes but srsly anthonny dropped from 19th to 31st like what the actual
Actually I see where your coming from! I remember before the show Anthonny but also Hiroto as well, ranking so high and have so much hype!! The lack of screen time is ridiculous and the ranking drop is showing it. Sucks some trainees can get up to 10 min , but your faves get none
I personally wouldn't put K group's first cause it really lacks vocals for me, more than half of the performance are just dance break. My top 3 would be Rush Hour, The Real and Nunu Nana.
I agree with everything you said (except I'd probably replace Nunu Nana with Shut Down in my top 3). As a person who values vocals way higher than other positions, K group's Kick It was a bit lackluster for me. Seungeon was amazing on the high note, of course, but the others shared a line (or half a line) each and then just danced the rest of the time whereas G group's (hate to compare, but) was more well-rounded and everyone had a fair amount of lines. But I know tastes are subjective, so there's no real right or wrong list. I enjoyed watching this ranking video!
I never insinuated that they had a choice in their songs. I said for some the songs they performed, it didn’t fit them well. If Mnet had forced them to preform these songs it would be very wrong, but I don’t know for sure and I won’t assume.
