England's historical telling of it's relations with the Jews agrees with your statement. It goes further, leading me to understand the Jews have found themselves unwelcome in nearly all of Europe. Sweden I think it was, treated the Jews among them, admirable as told when Nazis came hunting them down. It's too bad every people weren't that way.
@@1czechit1 @1czechit1 I have academic datas that proves the opposite, underlined with historical documents. You're ungrateful people!! And with "you" I mean the Zionists, not the Jews in general because there are many Jews and even Israeli Jews defending the Palestinian struggle and calling the State of Israel --> "Colonial Project"!! For example Ilan Pappe, Noam Chomsky, Avi Shlaym and many others!! You could have lived with us in peace till end of times (like in the Iberian Peninsula) but you're foot soldiers of the white supremacy!! Ask yourself, what is the destiny of every occupation force since human beings set on Earth??? The time has come for you to leave, my dear cousin!!!
@@mixed-media Canaanite is an ancient civilization which evolved into several groups among which the main dominant ones are the Phoenicians (Modern Lebanese) and the 12 tribes of Israel which later formed the Kingdoms of Israel and Judea. Both of my parents are Jewish, my true ancestry genetic test reflected Canaanites as my ancient civilization. Jewish is an ethnicity, while "Palestinian" is a nationality which never came into nationhood and it isn't composed of one ethnic group, but many from different regions who seeked refuge in the occupied Jewish indigenous territory over the centuries. Most Palestinians today are not necessarily linked to the ancient Canaanites, but if you are it means you either have Judean/Israelite or Phoenician/Lebanese ancestry. Rest of Palestinians are Syrians, Arabs, Iraqi, and Egyptians who settled into the region during the same time period as Jews migrated and reignited the development and agriculture under the British Mandate.
That podcast was a true disgrace. I had given JBP the benefit of the doubt before, but after seeing him give zero pushback to that sociopathic racist war criminal Nuttyyahoo, lost a lot of respect for the guy.
@@dharmabum1925 @@dharmabum1925 i know, I was shocked. Maybe they had some evidence against him. That's what they did ruling families in the Gulf. Filming them secretly having all sorts of perverted experiences in europe then using the footage to pressure them.
@@dharmabum1925 I hope that eventually we can all see that guy for what he is. Beyond the “but Dostoevsky said” arguments. Without Christopher Hitchens I’m afraid it goes unchecked. Harris wasn’t mean enough to actually expose him.
@aseel "Don't mock the words of Allah" - You are clearly confused and cannot tell the difference between words of Allah and someone telling you that Allah told them all your stuff belongs to them. Take your time, it may sink in.
@SimpleStupid "implying Muhammad is a prophet for any reason other than him claiming he rode through the sky on a donkey lol. Bruh sit down" -- Strip the "Simple" part off your nickname, then show me where I implied any of the sort.
Beloved, I don't know you in person but God knows you. God ministered to me in a revelation when I was on your profile to see things around you,I saw blessings but spiritual attacks holding onto them,in prayers,i saw a woman in the realm of the spirit monitoring and plotting delay in your life, with an evil mirror, and with a motive to destroy. But as I speak to you now her time is up, Render hand of favour with Anything you can afford or give to these motherless foundation (DIVINE MERCY ORPHANAGE HOME🏢🏢) in kebbi state nigeria before 2DAYS with faith, as I Rise my hands towards heaven and pray for you they shall serve as point of contact wherever you are, you will receive double portion of grace to excel and total restoration of breakthrough in your life and in the life of your family. Ask for their acct details and help them call the MD in charge of the orphanage to get their details on (WhatsApp or call them now on +2348165774209) tell him I sent an you. For it is not by might nor by in apower but of the spirit saith the lord (zechariah 4:6). You shall testify to the Glory of God in your life. God bless you!!
Yes, they remember all the crimes committed by innocent Jews against the Palestinians. Whatever the Jews do, they should not be held accountable because this is considered anti-Semitism.
@Newbuild Muse It seems to me the soldiers sent abroad to murder, rape and torture in your (the citizen's) name are also citizens. If you elect your leaders to the Mother of all Parliaments, and they elect to send your fathers, husbands or sons abroad to destroy citizens of other nations, WHO is responsible? Just a few days ago your Army were found guilty of the murder of innocent civilians including a clergyman 50 years ago I a city your country claims as part of the United Kingdom. Of course they were all terrorists innit? If Germany and Japan were guilty of the war crimes committed in their name by their armed forces, then so is Britain, so is USA, so are all nations, my own (Ireland) included. The victims of the crimes are not responsible, the perpetrators are the perpetrators. Nazi Germany is not the only country that had Desk Killers amongst the population.
Muslims have never lived in peace with any other religion unless they were in the minority. once they are in the majority they start charging that jizz tax or whatever it's called and if you don't pay it they kill you or they force you to convert. the only reason they were peaceful prior to the British showing up was because the Ottoman empire camp things in check more or less. but as bad as it is for the 700,000 Palestinians who had to flee their homes in the middle of a war... no one ever seems to mention the 800,000 Jews had to do the same thing from every other Arab nation. after the passage of the 181 resolution which inflamed the Arabs. and you don't see Moroccan , Egyptian, etc Jews asking for their land back
Actually it was dead, malaria infested and where people did live they suffered from trachoma. It was the Zionist economy which allowed (Jewish) tax money and (ZIonist) ingenuity to bring the land to life and improve the living conditions... that is why the Arabs immigrated to the land of Israel from 1904-1947 (950K of them)
What kindness? The kindness of attacking Jewish communities and demanding a complete ban on Jewish immigration by revolting against the British in 1936-1939?
@@slamwall9057we are talking about a time were zionist settlers were trying to take over the land, middle easterners might get be recieving less and more primal education than the west but not to the point where you cant realise an external invader is slowly stealing your land and trying to kick you out, it was on the news bro everybody knew it, the british knew it when they supported the zionists the palestinian knew it when they realised that those zionists intended to "replace" them rather than "coexist" with them, and the zionists knew it because they were the ones doing it, you can be a guest but not try to kick people out of their home
The problem was and is that to make room for Jews, Palestinians had to be kicked out of their homes. The British had conquered the area so they got to decide who lived where. Then in 1948 it got too hard and then they told the UN, "You solve this problem."
15:35 if the Jews helped liberate Italy from fascism, then maybe Italy should set aside a piece of land for Jews. And if Jews were discriminated against and murdered in Germany, then Germany should set aside land for Jews. Makes no sense for Palestinians to be displaced and justify it by appealing to European atrocities. Utterly shameful history.
Palis IMMIGRATED from their native homelands on the EAST BANK (now Jordan), to the Jewish WB, for economic opportunities. Jordan IS the Arab homeland in Palestine. Always was.
Why? The Jews helped free the land of Israel from Ottoman occupation. for that they got the Jewish state in 1920... called the Mandate for Palestine (to establish a Jewish state.) See UN Charter article 80 (then read a history book to understand what that is.)
@@Sundancer09 According to historians and TE Lawrence, what the Arabs did in WWI was a side show to a side show. (in 1915 the Arabs gave the British vague promises and the British gave the Arabs vague promises and both ended where they started from by the end of the famous correspondence) The ones who really helped the British were the Jews...1. Chaim Wizeman invented a chemical compound to help the British bombardments 2. NILI provided intelligence on Ottoman/Turkish military and helped the British army located underground water so they would not need to carry it 3. Jewish Legion and Zion Mule Corps fought in Gallipoli and protected Alenby's right flank on the east bank of the Jordan River. the difference was the Jews did not bring this up at the Paris Peace Conference. Maybe because they did not need to, but it seemed from the minutes they they had a rightful claim based on historical connection to the land.
@@DanielHozin this very same video, everything is called Palestine including in the official documents. There were very few jews in their and the video literally mentions that those people were brought from elsewhere as refugees and immigrants and now they claim the place is theirs. Can you please explain how this makes sense?
Palestine (Jewish state) Mesopotamia (Arab state) and Syria (Arab state). That was the Mandate system established by international law in 1920. The video touched on it.
The pro-P protesters on campuses worldwide have not any idea at all where the G strip is. No idea which river or what sea they are chanting about. Clueless, and PhDs yet.
the British are responsible for the Nakba Damn those who have hurt the Palestinians for years.....Arabs could say they have a covenant with God........and God assigned those lands to them 150,000 years ago......And that appears in a magic book that no one else can see
Try to learn history the British blocked Jewish immigration to Palastine after opposition from the Arabs. The Jews then launched a terror campaign against the British administration one hotel bombing (st David ) killed 100 people they also started assassinating British military leaders ( one in Egypt). Weakened after the second word war the British could not sustain the situation anymore. If was after the UN took control Jewish immigration flooded into Palastine and shortly after the war started.
What an interesting video, showing all the good modern side of the people who moved in, and some even bought land but for most of the owners of the land, they were pushed out and their land stolen, and that contributes to the ridiculous ongoing anger. Why didn't Britian offer a piece of land from their own country to give the Jewish people? As the video says, oil was one reason another was all the other product, and of course, arrogance. All people from these areas have a long history of fighting, but also contributing a lot to our world. The farms are good, but the Arabs were eating, and had many methods of farming that didn't involve chemicals and GMOs. Arab housing is cool in the summer, animals are healthy, children are educated, men and women strong and very spiritual.
@@ash_tree71 Well this should be interesting, as your a AI bot you asserted, Educated, really they were illiterate, no infrastructure, open sewers no sanitation, and generally barbaric, look at the state of them today, you can dress a pig in a suit but it will still grunt.
I wish people understood history the Romans called it Syria Palestinian after they put down the Jewish revolt destroyed the temple and kicked all the Jews out. the British took over what would eventually become Israel and Jordan after WWI . they named it Palestine from 1920 onward. they also created Palestinian passports and coinage because they didn't want the Palestinians getting British passports and showing up in London
The British Mandate for Palestine (to the Jews) and the British Mandate for Mesopotamia (for the Arabs) was enshrined in International law. There was no country called Palestine, there was a Mandate to make the land a Jewish state. The British betrayed that obligation (because of Arab terror) and closed the area to Jewish immigration (in breach of article 6 of the Mandate) to Jews. This allowed 700K Arabs to immigrate illegally form 1918 to 1947. These Arabs that came as late as 1947 are today claimed to be "decedents of Canaanites" and "been there from time immemorial" while they strap bombs to their kids to muder Jews.
If you win a land in a war you have it as long as you can hold it by force. 75 years later one must ask is it worth it? Perhaps it would have been better to have treated the indigenous people a bit better.
So there's no problem for Russia taking lands from the Ukrainians, Moldovans and Finns then... Why are Westerners so upset about Russia taking Ukrainian lands?
Once upon a time, good humans sought to honor WWI & WWII by rising above “the law of the jungle” through international laws & procedures. It’s really sad that British & American officials were betraying this ambition even before the war was officially over by recruiting & repurposing fascists to create a new empire &, of course, paving the way for a new ethno-state in somebody else’s homeland as a power projection point. After WWI & II, humanity should have known better than to tolerate the rise of yet another ethno-state & settler colonial project.
It certainly wasn’t empty but it was sparsely populated and not well developed and that’s a fact even looking at all of the footage and reading travelogues this can be clearly seen.
In the end, it’s about 2 visions: 1) the Jews sought to build a homeland of protection, peace and prosperity. 2) the Arabs sought to build about where Jews aren’t in charge. It’s interesting that’s there is a tacit admission that much of the land was undeveloped until the Jews arrived and Arabs moved there to enjoy the prosperity
No, "the Jews" didn't seek to build a homeland; a small number of Jews sought that, and most Jews of the world, before 1948 were either uninterested or completely against the creation of a Jewish homeland in Palestine. It was only after the founding of Israel, that there was majority-Jewish support for Israel, after years of white-washing the Israel creation story to hide its terroristic roots of ethnically-cleansing non-Jews. Almost all religious Jews, before the founding of Israel, were against it. Some Hasidic sects today are still against the existence of Israel, and the whole "Orthodox Zionist Settler" cult is only decades old.
Palestine includes what is today called Jordan, which is 4 times the size of Israel snd is the original Arab state in Palestine. Arabs in Israel are illegal invaders from Jordan-Palestine.
The divine Israel is Spiritual. The fleshly Israel's time is long gone. Jehovah, Yahweh if you prefer, isn't backing this Zion State. The more Palestinians they kill, the less chance they have to ever enjoy peace there. This was not a good plan. Opposite actually. The moment they had to displace another people, taking control of them, the rights they had before... The moment the hairs on the back of the Jewish necks should have alerted them "hey, we're becoming what we hated done to us."
Gloating over your eventual damnation is a weird flex. Are you certain that being a fool is without consequence? You will be accountable for your sins soon enough. Though I imagine your pride will be somewhat muted in His presence...
@@nekozombie Do you seriously believe your own incredulity? Do you really think there are no long term consequences for our actions? Do you really, truly think that we won't be held to account for our time spent here on earth? Especially as it relates to one another?
What an interesting video, showing all the good modern side of the people who moved in, and some even bought land, but for most of the owners of the land, they were pushed out and their land stolen, and that contributes to the ridiculous ongoing anger. Why didn't Britian offer a piece of land from their own country to give the Jewish people? As the video says, oil was one reason, another was all the other product, and of course, arrogance. All people from these areas have a long history of fighting, but also contributing a lot to our world. The farms are good, but the Arabs were eating, and had many methods of farming that didn't involve chemicals and GMOs. Arab housing is cool in the summer, animals are healthy, children are educated, men and women strong and very spiritual.
Before the Brits everything except Iran was Ottoman land. Jewish money was spent to improve the land and Arabs from other lands came to work ... and stayed.
Contrast with the Muslims. The entire Muslim world can hardly even set up a bicycle factory while the Js build computers, aircraft, pharmaceuticals and collect Nobel prizes. No wonder they don’t want their own lands (like Jordan-Palestine) but want to take over Israel, instead.
I'll ask the random viewer: what's your definition of "indigenous"? everybody knows that there have been multiple waves of "takeovers" of the holy land throughout history. Ever since the crusaders were beaten, the land was under Muslim dominance. But it was scarcely populated and many of its inhabitants in the 19th century (by the end of it there were 400k muslims) were descendents of immigrants arriving 200, 300, 400 before present. Very few could trance back their family tree to Salah Al-Din times (circa 1200). So the Average Arab/Palestinian (a term that was born, to describe a community, only in the 20th century) had a history of 300 years, let's say, by the time of the UN resolution. Now, would you say that the Mayflower's immigrants (1616) were "indigenous"? did they have any significant advantage over immigrants arriving 250 years later? could they claim to be "the owners" of the land and deny anybody's else right to live there?
The Jews need to find a new home that’s not in the midst of a muslim continent. The hate between the two is too strong and will never end of the Jews stay. Too many lives have been lost in this conflict.
The animosity between Jews and Arabs goes back to the beginning. Israel returned to their ancestral homeland. Neither side will find peace so long as one denies the other's existence.
Doesn’t justify displacing a whole country to regain your homeland. Is that what we’re doing now, returning the world map to 400BC ? If so a lot of countries are going to be at war. You can’t simply make such a statement.
My father was a Palestinian. We still have his ID cards. And he was J as can be. Ms invading from the EAST Bank are most certainly NOT indigenous to the Holy Land. They’re now doing to Europe what they did to I.
According to the Holy Bible, assumed by many to be the basic history of the Jewish people, Abraham is from what is modern day IRAQ, the city of Ur. The Hebrews were not much different than the people around them.
Where was the jews when Arabs and muslims took palestine in 600s from romans and fought crusaders in crusaders wars and kicked them out from the holy lands? Did the crusaders mention any jewish force fighting against them or mentioned jewish population in palestine? The zionists jews are invaders. Arabs have lived in that land longer than jews have.
Абрам.. ирак.правильно. Фалестина - Куддус - земля ВЕРУЮЩИХ!-А НЕ СИОНИСТОВ УБИЙЦ В ФАЛЕСТИНЕ. МИР ВАМ МУСУЛЬМАНЫ !- уверовщие в Таврат .в Инджиль и в КУРЬАН. СМЕРТЬ ТЕРРОРАМ.УБИЙЦАМ.ОККУПАНТАМ.
By October 2023, it is clear enough that this is not yet resolved. Maybe they should revisit the “two state” ideas that were if I recall correctly, briefly considered back in the early-mid 1990’s.
Israel has presented the 2 state solution 5 times and 5 times the Palestinians walked away from the bargaining table because the Palestinians will not concede that Israel has a right to exist!
for that to work both sides would have to be willing partners for peace. Israel has not had a Prime Minister serious about peace with their Palestinian neighbors since the 1998 election. the two state solution essentially died November 4 , 1995 when PM Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated by a member with the Jewish settler movement. the stickiest issue has been the Palestinian demand for "right of return" where Palestinian refugees get the right to return to Palestine. that number grew from approximately 700,000 1948 to God only knows the true number today other than several million.
“Land promised to them by Moses.” It was promised to Israel by the One who spoke THROUGH Moses. That means only He can really decide whether or not to give or take it.
do you know that Moses and his followers never set foot in Palestine!! Do you know about Hagana, Irgun, Balmakh Jewish terrorists groups committing so many massacres against Palestinians and displaced the indigenous Palestinians to steal their homes and land!
Each country should host theses refugees , so their kids well being can improve . Also don’t forget they can built ships and steal diamonds . Definitely your country will flourish as the palestinian people had flourished. Now they are in refugee camps, lands are stolen , homes are stolen , women , children and men are killed on a daily basis. To flourish need to host Jewish refugee in your countries so we all can be on the same page.
😮Jews have never lived in Fiblastynisa.. A Jewish kingdom has never been established in Judea.. The only true millennials have always been the Ballestinians.. They have been here for over 5000 years. The Assyrians, Persians, Babylons, Greeks, Romans and Crusaders fought. They always won thanks to their kings Dawood Soleiyman Al Fustyn... Iseus was Palestinian, not Jewish. It is also written in the Kitab that she was the son of Muriem and Yuossuob.Israle is a name invented by the Romans who destroyed the mosque in Gesuralem.
it was named Syria Palestinian in like the first or second centuryby the Romans after they finally put down the Jewish revolt in force all the Jews out of Judea /Israel. it's hilarious to me that people don't realize that the Romans destroyed the Jewish temple or synagogue rather although I do think they call it the temple but whatever that was destroyed and then they kicked all the Jews out and then they renamed it. it was the Roman effort to try to wipe any reference to Jews off the face of the Earth because they are irritating to them because they kept on being a pain in the ass
Palestine includes what is today called Jordan, which is 4 times the size of Israel snd is the original Arab state in Palestine. Arabs in Israel are illegal invaders from Jordan-Palestine.
He says it clearly, it is a land occupied by settlers, at which this is not the Jews land, not even their home promised to them by mosses or anyone. This land is the Palestinians home and ancestral homeland, it was and will remail for the Muslim and Christian Palestinians, not jews
Wrong if the land is scared to Christians its because of Jesus who was there long ago and was Jewish just like Abraham Isaac and Jacob. The quran also admits Allah gave the the land to the Jewish
@@veridicusmaximus6010 I'm not getting my history knowledge from tiktok, you are. And you also are brainwashed byvthe media to believe that Palestine belong to the jews or the zionists occupiers. Read Balfour declaration and you will know everything. It's not a middle eastern problem, it's a European problem. Jews backthen started to leave eastern Asia like Russia and live in the western Europe like Germany and Italy and so on. So that was a big issue for the western countries, so after the British mandate on Palestine, the British (which had no right to do so) promised the zionist jews to be able to live in Palestine. And the zionists illegal immigrants can from Europe including Poland and many other countries (illegally) to Palestine. Then America and other countries provided arms and money to the zionists terror organizations/groups to intimidate the expell the native innocent Palestinians from their villages and towns. That's the simple mere truth that the world is trying to hide. Please go read a history book or something. And don't read or get your knowledge from tiktok or any biased sources like the western media.
The messianic prophecy In Babylon, these rabbis, the Amoraim of the Talmud, reinterpreted Jewish history. Yes, the Land of Israel was promised to the Jews, and yes, God will one day, in his own time, return the Jews to their land and give them control of it, but this will only happen in the future when the messiah arrives. And as a safeguard against future calamities like those brought about by Bar Kokhba, the rabbis came up with the doctrine of the three oaths, which appears in the Babylonian Talmud (Ketubot 110b-111a). Based on an extremely creative interpretation of the erotic love poem that is the Song of Songs, the rabbis decided that when Jews went into exile, three oaths were made between the peoples of the Earth and God: The Jews promised not to “storm the wall” (interpreted as, not immigrate to the Land of Israel) and not to “rebel against the nations.” The third oath was made by the nations (non-Jews), promising God they would not “oppress Israel too much.”
@@otiliamanuelajurj The things you said are inaccurate, first of all in the UN vote most nations supported the establishment of the State of Israel (29 Nov 1947), so "rebellion against the nations" is not exactly the case here, since the Jews 'rebelled' actively in the Arab nation alone -only the Arabs went to war and the rest of the opposition eventually accepted the UN resolution and respected it (and this is also not exactly true because there are now Arab countries that recognize the State of Israel.) Another thing that is more important- there is no prohibition on violating the 3 'Shvu'ot' because the things you quoted are considered "Aggadah" and not "Halakhah" so they have no binding practical 'halakhic' validity. And indeed, in all the books of Halacha written on the basis of the Talmud, such a prohibition is not mentioned... on the contrary, we know of many who immigrated to Eretz Israel throughout history as individuals and as groups , Including the one who cited the 3 oaths himself - Rabbi Zeira (violating the oath "not storm the wall"), according to another source he even admitted his mistake and repeated his words.(in "Shir -Hashirim Rabbah") The majority of the Orthodox Jewish public today does not oppose the very existence of the State of Israel (but a large part has a critique of its secular nature). Those who oppose the existence of Israel on the basis of the 3 oaths are just a small and negligible minority and that says it all.
British Palestine that was partially freed in 1948 and freed in 1967. It was free that is why it's called Israel. Interesting the narrator uses the term Judea and not West Bank
Beloved, I don't know you in person but God knows you. God ministered to me in a revelation when I was on your profile to see things around you,I saw blessings but spiritual attacks holding onto them,in prayers,i saw a woman in the realm of the spirit monitoring and plotting delay in your life, with an evil mirror, and with a motive to destroy. But as I speak to you now her time is up, Render hand of favour with Anything you can afford or give to these motherless foundation (DIVINE MERCY ORPHANAGE HOME🏢🏢) in kebbi state nigeria before 2DAYS with faith, as I Rise my hands towards heaven and pray for you they shall serve as point of contact wherever you are, you will receive double portion of grace to excel and total restoration of breakthrough in your life and in the life of your family. Ask for their acct details and help them call the MD in charge of the orphanage to get their details on (WhatsApp or call them now on +2348165774209) tell him I sent an you. For it is not by might nor by in apower but of the spirit saith the lord (zechariah 4:6). You shall testify to the Glory of God in your life. God bless you!!
@@rapidsqualor5367 Lol, I studied it for about 20 years as a devout christian, and for about 15 more as a non-believer. How anyone can land on "It's not fiction" can only be mentally ill, or delusional at best.
Just coz it’s Palestine doesn’t make it a country British mandate was ruling over Israel and Palestine that’s why it’s called British mandate Israel-Palestine and became 2 separate lands Israel was kept for the Jews and Palestine became the state of Jordan and Palestinians refused and wanted the full land they didn’t want Jews being their
This is absolutely sick to listen to. Hearing him praising literal settlers for stealing land is beyond repulsive. How did the world let this happen. How is the world STILL letting this happen. FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA PALESTINE WILL BE FREE 🇵🇸
all the clowns who think they stole land they purchased Land from the Arab landowners the problem is many Palestinians were squatting on land that wasn't theirs and so they got evicted. but far away the Jews were buying up all the swamp land in the mosquito infested crap which is why there used to be a malaria problem. it's pretty apparent the Arabs did zero to improve the land and the Jewish show up in the matter of a few decades they turned it into a first world country. malaria is no longer a problem because the Jews got rid of all the swamp land that was just a basically mosquito farm. and then resolution 181 was passed which basically guaranteed Israel was going to get a state and that's when the Civil War started and everyone started shooting. and then they came around in the British left and that's when all the surrounding Arab Nations declared war. then about 700,000 Palestinians left their homes and there's three reasons they left their homes but only one of them actuality was significant. yes I'm sure there's some Jewish militias that not so kindly ask some Palestinians to leave their homes and some quite rude ways involving shooting. I'm also positive they were asked by the other Arab Nations to get out of the way so they could kill the Jews in this upcoming War. but the main reason the Palestinians left their homes is the same reason civilians leave their homes everywhere on the planet since the dawn of time when a war breaks out you grab the stuff you need you run away because you don't want to be killed in your house during the middle of a war. oddly enough Palestinian refugees are the only refugees in the history of the world who are refugees by birth. after Israel won the war of independence in 1948... you should really ask yourself why the West Bank which was Jordanian and Gaza which was Egyptian why they never accepted those people a citizens. why are there Palestinians still in Lebanon living in camps where they have no right to vote and they aren't permitted to work in Lebanon proper. the Palestinians live for nearly 20 years under Arab rule. basically the Palestinian share one thing with the Jews it would appear that no one wants them in their country.
