I don't understand why all are against discount brokers. In fact, they are helpful for those investing for long term and do delivery buying. For example Zerodha is not charging for delivery-based buying that is not good for people according to you. Common Vivek, try to be honest. Discount brokers are boon for small investors. In fact, government should do away with STT that they are charging because now there is long term as well as short term tax. Why should government charge STT? Don't you think so. Why don't you talk about unfair taxes like STT that government is charging?
To speak against govt, speak against sebi, think against this herd need some balls, Bhai... Generally, All are 🐐🐐🐐 nodding to whatever thrown at us, in the name of system
What is imposed on us is double taxation. We pay STT for the transactions we do & then we also end up paying Income tax on the profits earned. Now our great finance minister wants to tax us, so she & her accomplice SEBI chairman came up with a story, Retail khatree mein hi futures mein trade karkee" similar to the naive story "Hindu khatree mein hai". Now they want to tax us more on F&O trades as well. Hopefully they come up with a slab system to tax more maybe like profit above 1 CR or 2 CR in F&O will be taxed more & not tax the small traders.
Completely agree with what you are saying. Soon Zerodha is going to start charging brokerage for delivery based equity investment. All this happening because of moorkh people sitting at top in SEBI
@@tanmaysharma3285The brokerage fee amounts to ₹60, out of which ₹40 constitutes tax. This tax is mandatory regardless of whether the transaction results in profit or not. Despite the minimal service charge imposed by brokers, the government's substantial tax burden remains unchanged, leading to calls for reduced fees on brokers while suggesting that the government has the option to decrease taxes instead.
@@alenjose7350 who said trading less is good? It's depend upon various factor.. your setup, market condition etc etc. when time comes, I believe in punching as many trades as required. STT charges are way too high for such scenarios.
This is not good for delivery based traders. These are also small traders which need to be protected. Now they are paying stt and brokerage will increase for them How this is good for them
SEBI is talking about equality. If they really mean that, then stop allowing CO LACATION of servers at exchange premises for elite members. They get advantage in terms of getting prices earlier than the rest of the world. Roughly they can execute up to 30 trades before a retail trader sees the price quote. One can imagine the amount of money that can be made with this advantage. No wonder exchange charges hefty amount and there is a queue/waiting list to get space on exchange servers. I dare SEBI to stop this undue advantage to a few.
*brokers should reduce brokerage.....they are robbing traders in daylight....nifty lot had come to 25 from 75 and still brokerage is same.....brokers are making 3x profit....kindly make a video on this*
@vivekbajaj Hello Sir, I really respect you, can you give me an answer if you are owner of discount broker and your refund is stopped due to this rule, does not you will increase the brokerage for delivery also, what is the profit for retail trader on this. All the discount brokers will now increase their brokerage in delivery as well.
Sir ji ask the Regulator to stop manipulation of the Index nifty and Banknifty people are actaually losing money in this - brokers making money is passed onto trders by way of brokerage free schemes etc. Traders are being looted by the Index manipulators what SEBI has done is to stop brokers also from making money while allowing the big traders to loot from small traders and SEBI does not have the guts or the method to stop[ Manipulation of index period
Vivekji, can u explain how it will benefit retail traders associated with discount brokers? If exchange fee is uniform and brokers are unable to profit, they will hike broekrage, isme humara fayda kaise? Please explain coz after STT, brokerage is the biggest profit eater.
Haha he just being ambiguous... Nd telling half truth that due the brokers loss small retailers will get benefitted but it's just opposite bcs when discount brokers will face losses they will increase the brokerages to maintain their profits and ultimately we will have to pay more. And also it will discourage discount broking on deliveries by which small retailers benefited. Hope you all can understand the main thing not just Vivek telling MAYBE retailers get those money of brokers, just an absurd prediction...
Penny wise and pound foolish. char aana, aath aane ka exchange fees bachakar, hazaron ka brokerage dena padega. isme fayda kaise hua? Please dont try to justify this idiotic decision by SEBI who is out to just extract money from small traders. SEBI has become an extortion agent.
Zero brokerage की वजह से में धीरे धीरे सिख रहा था... अब अगर थोड़े से profile का बड़ा हिस्सा brokerage के नाम पे ले लेंगे तो अब मेरे जैसा नौसिखिया क्या करेगा....😢😢😢
Everyone knows discount brokers are very helpful to retail investors .. other plan of SEBI to hurt retail investors .. I don't undestand why you talk non sense.. this step will compell them to raise brokerage charges..
Hi, can you please look into adding "Relative Rotation Graph" in stockedge? Really hard to find this one in India, only few US based service providers have this feature available.
STT, GST, Trx charges, Stamp Duty and now brokerage will get added to delivery trade. Good plan to eliminate retail traders, so that only corporates can earn profits.
Bht log bolte hain BJP aake market ko reform kiya hain….Bht fayda karwaya hain market participants ka Me yeh baat se completely disagree krta hun…..Finance minister ne Long term investing me Knife chalaya hain after 10% tax introduce krke…. Agar Har waqt 10% hi tax denge compounding hoga kaise…..I invest in saregama,LT foods in covid times….when i want to sell saregama to enter Anand Rathi I pay hefty tax in name of so called LTCG….(that’s really painful ,we investor also pay STT,exchange transactions,Stamp duty aur bhi na jaane kitna hi taxes))
Jis din modi ke chahete adani ambani is field me aggressively aa jayenge tab TRAI ki tarah SEBI bhi aakho pe paati baandh legi or recharge ki tarah yaha brokerage bhi manmane dhang se liye jayenge. Inflation should come down, this govt is making this country cry.
If exchange fee will decrease ,then brokerage will increase sure ,and for retailers it is a pure curse .i dont know what sebi wants to do ,are they want to close stock merket for retailers?😢
Ultimately the broker will raise the brokerage. Anything that happened in the name of retailers interest actual hamper the retailers most and eat out their profits portion
sir gold me gst 3 percent hai, jo ki bahut km hai. lekin making charge companiya 20 se 50 percent charge karti hai. agar sarkar kisi chij me tax 0 bhi kar de to capatilist log munfakhori se nahi chukenge.
No they were not taking brokerage on delivery based share investment. Now they will start taking brokerage charges on that. It was completely free on zerodha . For example if you buy reliance share and sell after 5 days there was no brokerage on zerodha. Now zerodha will charge brokerage.
Retail investor ki bhalai ke naam pe uska harm kiya ja raha hai.. Lets see with time that they are level fielding for jio.. And if thia is true.. This govt is crap.
Unki kammai to kum hogi hai. Magar hamaare bhi charges badh jaayenge Bhai jaan..aap itni choti si baat kyon nahi samajh rahe .lag raha hai Sebi aur Sarkar ke chaploos ho gaye ho aap bhi.. very disappointing Boss😢
kese in sab ko overcome kar jayenge sir, har bar jab v baat hoti hai to hum traders pese loot ne ki baat hoti hai. hum ko kuch benefits mile aisi baat to kabhi Nehi hoti. tax badha denge, inko bahar kar denge, itne log kyu trading kar rahe hai, pese kyu kama rahe hai ye sab irritating ho raha hai.
@@narendravasan2806 khulli loot machaa rakhi hai even on zero brokerage at MSTOCK...there are so many other charges its really too much...and no one makes profits on all their trades
Sir, won't Zerodha and Groww like discount brokers will start passing the cost to customers because earlier they were earning from daily trading and providing benefits to delivery. I thin now they will start chah ng for investors too. Ultimately, the customers bear the cost, no matter whatever the rule is
Hi sir i am following you from last 1-2 yers recently i became stock edge member it helps alot thank you for wonderful tool🙏 One small question sir aap ke recent tranding view setup me ek table dekha quarterly earnings and pe ratio wala can you plz tel me name of that indicator Thanks again god bless you 🙏
Vivek sir, I have a suggestion regarding big gap-up and gap-down. SEBI should make a rule that, the next day opening should be within the high-low range of previous day. This will help retailers to reduce the loss and exit from trades which are not in their favour.
Kind request to our FM please do not treat F&O as speculative income. Agree that we retailers take losses when we enter into this business without any real market experience, but once we learn then it becomes a game changer even for retailers, and it cannot happen by pure speculation. There is lot of market study requires if anyone has to earn money by F&O business. Yes, it's a business only.
Excetly, may ek newbie in market, fy 23-24 may mara profit Rs 120000 but brocker 30% charge cut liya hai us say. Sbicapsec may mara account hai. Mara account pay karibon Rs 90000 aya hai....
Govt khud tax kam kyu nhi karta-- stt lagna hi nhi chahiye. Jab stt aya tha to government n bola tha ki ya to stt rahega ya stcg or ltcg. Ab govment stt bhi leta hai, STCG OR LTCG BHI LETA HAI
