BRUTALLY Rating MY Youtube Thumbnails 

Jack should make a sequel to this video where he remakes thumbnails for the videos he BRUTALLY rated. But maybe instead of creating totally new thumbnails, try creating a similar thumbnail just with better quality and fixing his own critics.

i love how he noticed every single little detail about every one of his thumbnails, like especially the geography one with his glasses 😂😭 btw amazing video Jack

Jack: I need a shadow. Also jack on some thumbnails from at most 12 months ago: Doesn't add a shadow

the ocd i had until jack put the point in his hair down is mental.

I still cant believe becky is posting pre-recorded videos with an ai jack and ai voice ♡ rip big lad

POV: Every person on the Jacks subreddit

Jack should do a part 2 to this with more thumbnails cause there is a lot of them

us jack-offs are so pleased that Jack is moving past his narcissistic days

You know it’s a good day when JackSucksAtLife BRUTALLY rates apparently THOUSANDS of THOUSANDS of his thumbnails

Yessss Jack Thursday videos are the best! Love the twice a week videos Keep it up for 2024!!!!

Im Still Unbelievably Impressed That These Are Jacks honest opinions on the thumbnails And Anyone could have any opinion btw good video jack

5:58 yes jack, it has.

Jack is my fav RU-vidr for an amazing reason

The part where Jack realised his hair was still sticking up I started laughing at that so hard lmao

this is so good! keep up the good work!

I would rate them all 10/10 and I was very brutal while rating that

45 minute club hit me up ❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂

Great video again. Loving the extra ones recently

really enjoying this content of 2024 so far jack!!! hope to see more like this throughout the year

Jack i really love these types of videos and i feel like you should upload videos on Jack Massey Welsh monthly!

Jack theyre all good, The editing , The Videos, The Title. You've Done A Great Job. Well Done!

Jack: I didn't erase the hair strands in the thumbnail, oh no Also Jack's hair:

7:12 "spear"

he has done the thumbnail test again

I just realized I haven't watched a Jack video in months. I need to get back on that grind!

4:20 Jack finally admits his hands look a bit weird.

Jack is trying to prove to us that he isn’t a narcissist now

loved the part when jack rated them

Hey jack! Do another no skipping post Reddit video 😂

For the lighting in your face you should probably use a reflector

Jack is the new celebrity 🎉🎉

0:27 the willy warmer

Today I am brutally eating my videos!

Don’t u underestimate me I’ve watched harmony hollow dozens of times 🤣

Hey jack u are my favourite ytuber and you always make my day when u upload a new vid also i like how u are just talking to the camera while other ytubers are obviously reading a script, never change❤

Jack what camera do you use? im just wondering because i got a camera for my birthday last year and its quite good for photography, Its a canon 100d and i use the kit lens that comes with it

Jack you make amazing videos

Something this video made me realize is how much I hate how bright teeth are made. It makes my eyes jump to the teeth and it just feels like it’s too bright for the rest of the thumbnails most of the time.

I wanna send u fan art how do i do tht. Cool idea btw and u should defo re create and improve some of those thumbnails would be interesting to see how u improve it

Jack your the only reason I'm amazing at geography before I seen your channel I thought Africa was a country

Jack make a part 2 where you fix the bad logos and see if they get more views

I thought the reward was the willy warmer so sad it wasn't😅

It can’t just be me who only now realised the billion view video is a year old. It feels like a few weeks ago

Double videos, LETS GOOO

I've never been this early to a jack video

you should take the majestic man of the thumbnails

All of these are better than I can do!

those red arrows...

Us Jack-Offs really appreciate the Thursday videos, Jack

Jack should make a video where he successfully beats the password game

I think I am genuinely getting overstimulated by these thumbnails See I loved the original play button collection thumbnail, it was very… brown toned, and it was great. Homey

1:03 Willy warmer

i really love that he didnt even rate them

You make really good thumbnails.

On the last one it looks a bit like one of those vicar collar things

I’d use curve layers on photoshop for faces on thumbnails, there’s good videos on it too (17:34)

What i thound on our family calender: Prety woman on my mums part of the calender. I told her and she said it jacksucks at life day when pretty woman kitchen was created. Rofl😂😂

how does this video only have 53k views in 24 hours, insanely good video

jimmy vegas is back

Why does this have only 66K. views? I think this video deserves 265K. views

wait jack your 2 years older than mr beast,he looks older

hi jack love your videos😁

I liked the thumbnail with out the green background

idk about most people, i have never looked at a thumbnail for more than 2 seconds

02:53 Hello there.

"This thumbnail is bad too much green"

2:11 how dare u miss taiwan on the thumbnail

Jack a thumbnail is the time now if it works, then don’t complain

Bro This it the content I like and this is the only content you do! keep up the great work! the greatest fan, Merkats (can I have a shout out)

16:15 Not gonna lie, you look like a grandma there

I like the Thursday videos

At least this tital did not give me a heart attack

jack

Dear universe: I still don’t like the new profile pics. There, now I feel better.

POG innit bruv fam

Hello Jack!

Oh yeah

The 1b views thimbnail looks like the willy warmer

Only a narcissist would make this

Monkey hee hee hee haw

Womp womp

Ok, hear me out, but what if you just uploaded an unedited video of you just making thumbnails??

Real

i just read the title

You should try this on your phone and let me see it when you do that I can show it on your phone

You are the best

Yars

As a Jack fan I can say this is narcissistic

hi jack

heyo jacki boi

Never going to get u out never will let u down!

DRAW CORNELIUS NOW.

Hi jack

Excuse me, did he call talking tom an AnImAteD cAt

Stopping kids from saying first

Jack saying people need faces and eye contac. i was telling a freind the other day if weird people, pulling faces or staring are in the thumbnail i avoid it. But i mostly grab videos from my subscriptions area aswell and dont really like the recomended or home page and my friend says many people use that to find videos. Id much rather just an image of a thing or colours and words saying what the video is about. I know whos in the video from the name in the corner, i dont need to also see your face. But im also a kid of youtube before most people did face cams and it was an awful lot of gaming videos with no facecams. and lots of creators in the minecraft world still do it. and therfore the thumbnails are just things not peoples big weird faces

2:26 NARCISSIST

Jack, you didn’t actually RATE any thumbnails! 🥺

preventing kids from saying first

I don’t click/watch a video based on a thumbnail, I usually click/watched based off the description. If the description sounds interesting to me then I’ll watch it. Maybe I’m in the minority but a thumbnail could just be blank and I’ll watch the video if the description catches my eye.