Love your design, very stylish, very strong. However one weak spot: the foundation. Not the concrete part, enough strength to carry the weight. But I see only 12 screws total attaching the whole greenhouse to the concrete. A little uplift by wind could take that quickly apart. At least double the number of screws, anchor bolts would be better and it would also be a good idea to attach those brackets to the wood with bolts and nuts instead of screws. Would be a pity to see in a storm that whole beautiful structure being sucked into the air ... just because of 12 screws.
Можно проще сделать - вместо клея использовать болты M6. Верхнюю косынку можно не делать - сразу крепить к коньковому брусу (50х50, закрепить под 45град). Если использовать поликарбонат, то горизонтали не нужны. бетонные столбы тоже не нужны.
Hello. Thank you very much for video list of greenhouse (3*5*2,8). Please tell me what board size (width, thickness and length)? Bar length? How many boards did it take in meters? What glue was it glued to? Thank you in advance for your reply. Respectfully!!!
I hope you treated the heck out of that flake board. Any moisture like that in a gh will destroy it in short order. Let us know how it holds up. Sometimes good old plywood is worth the extra $. Having said that it looks great👍😎👌
Your craftsmanship is truly an amazing art form, that is absolutely incredible. I can’t wait to watch the rest of this build. Great job and thank you for sharing! 👍
absolutely, he is so wrapped up in how fucking great he is that actually what and how it is doing is unimportant. The god of instruction. I dislike every one of these ninnies I find. Dont know if it hurts but it certainly cannot help the egotist.
@@g.r.4853 Maybe just get a basic understanding of woodworking and woodworking tools before making such a dim-witted comment. Very clear what he is doing and perfectly brought to your screen.
Really nice craftsmanship, however the fact that all that beautiful raw lumber will begin to decay almost immediately due to this being a greenhouse and moisture, heat and cold are continually breaking down the structure. I'd be concerned. Without the raw wood being treated thoroughly, especially where it meets the soil it will become a dinner plate to termites and other species of unwanted bugs. To put this much effort into building such a nice structure and not consider how the elements will break down the raw wood is disheartening. Maybe there are other considerations I'm not taking into play, such as environmental but being a retired Contractor I would weigh that factor and protect my build for its longevity. P.S. I really appreciate the video editing. It moves along nicely, and hearing the audio at greater speeds is humorous and entertaining. Great job.
Totally agree! That much effort spent and structure is going to fail in a year or two. Not going to last through 3 seasons being covered. People will start to build like this without realising that it is going to rot very soon. 20mm Pine planks ? ))) Bad Idea
Out of curiosity, and as a beginner to carpentry, how would you treat the wood to last a long time when building a greenhouse like this? or should I be considering other materials?
@Norbury53 Thanks so much for the very informative reply! don't think anyone has replied so thoroughly on youtube before. Really appreciate it! I'm doing a lot of research into setting something like this up for the garden, but It's a really unfortunate fact that eventually wooden structures seem to rot away and spending thousands on something I'm not sure I still want standing in 30 years is another argument entirely.
@@joshthemighty7700 Just keep it off the ground Josh and it'll last years. A lot of folk over-engineer unnecessarily. Benni's done the right thing here by sitting it on stilts.
This is a tutorial that explains very little. More a show off than an attempt to help people replicate your "excelent" work. Sadly, I feel it is worthless to most people. Thanks anyway.
I know I'm about three years too late to the party but I gotta say . . . I LOVE this design!! Not a word said and you spoke volumes!! Well . . . . except at 3:10 when I swore I heard you mutter something under your breath. :) Well done!!
Валерий, а чего собственно амер помалкивает? За год вполне мог бы язык подтянуть! Хотя бы до уровня понимания комментариев! Ему лайк за смелость, а вам за прецедент: почему наши стесняются комментировать понятное видео на не понятном языке ?!
Hi Benni, Vladimir here with NTD Television. Our team was very impressed by your videos and our editors would like to showcase them by uploading and crediting you on some of our social media pages and websites so that our fans can see it. We are one of the world's fastest growing media companies with over 100 million fans and 1 billion monthly video views across all of our social properties. Our motto is truth, hope, and humanity. Can I send you more information in my next message / email? Thank you! Warm regards
Добрый день дорогой друг. Скажи пожалуйста как ты изгибаешь древесину? я пробовал - у меня ломается при изгибе Good afternoon, dear friend. Tell me please, how do you bend wood? I tried - it breaks when bent
This is great! Any way to achieve R-30 insulation value on the ceiling and R-13 on walls with a structure like this? Could something like this ever pass Florida primary dwelling building code for Structural, Energy, Wind?
I hate this video. I can’t stand it when I see someone do something much better than I have done when I know I have much better tools. You have used creativity and smarts to create a wonderful project with what looks like limited tools. This is what makes a true craftsman in my opinion.
Hey Benni, Just want to follow up here. This is from Family Handyman we are really interested in your video and want to partner with you. Please contact us back so we can discuss more. Thank you
Just a question. Why didn't you put your bracing in the concrete footings while poring it but instead drilling then in after? You mustn't have wind at all. But build came together well.
if you leave a space at the top you can do a ridgepole i would do 8' sections make them modulrar easy to put up and take down of course you would have 2 touching every 8' but that would make it much stronger and 1 person could easily put up by themselves i have made them this way and there very handy
I really like these designs. Simple and effective with plenty of height. I think what I would have done differently is build a ridge piece into it so that the each side buts up against it.
@@pugsymalone6539 I am not sure of the flexibility of cedar. BUT that being said, if your cedar boards weren't too thick, and if they were as knot free as possible and if you steamed them before you them in the jig hot, then I believe they would work out fine.
@@pugsymalone6539 I just found a channel yesterday that showed building the Gothic arch trusses in greater detail and with instruction. He was building a styroaircrete shed. To get his arches he cut his stock to half inch thin and he bent those strips into his jig, gluing laminations as he went. It looked less labor intensive. I definitely want to give it a go, whether for a shed, greenhouse or as a roof on another structure. If you are interested the channel was ... Stephen Williams.
@@renaissancewomanfarm9175 Hey good neighbor, thanks very much for sharing this with me. I'm going to build a Gothic Arch structure to shelter firewood, so I'll definitely check it out. Thanks again!
I wonder if one could find a way to do this with PVC rather than wood, as wood is prohibitively expensive here. The main issue would be the join of the two pipes at the top. Any ideas?
@@Vlolg89 Берем арматуру пластиковую. Делаем шаблон на земле для 2х дуг одной стороны.Соответственно, в основании расстояние между дугами больше, а вверху сводим в 0. И собираем ферму с применением эпоксидки. Ферменная конструкция очень жесткая сама по себе. Плюс форма арки. Можно вспомнить Гауди с его системой получения формы цепной линии. Но это не обязательно. Фактически имеем две части окружностей соединенных в верхней части строения. Времени и трудозатрат на изготовление таких дуг уйдет гораздо меньше. Материала так же.
А самое интересное что суть данных дуг что бы сэкономить на стоимости леса, но это бред. так как тут используются рейки. а не брус, а рейки в кубатуре в 2 раза дороже получаются. пересчитал брус и сравнил с рейками. цена получилась гораздо ниже. То есть такой величины прямоугольная теплица получается выгодней по цене. Что по форме , то прошерстил интернет, везде одно и то же - прямые теплицы крепче и надежнее если конечно нет много снега зимой и это единственный плюс арочных теплиц
