Тёмный

Busting a myth: Rosewood vs Maple. Do fretboard woods make a difference? 

astringsuk
Подписаться 13 тыс.
Просмотров 65 тыс.
50% 1

We try to dispel (or prove!) the idea that fretboard materials affect the tone of an electric guitar. Using two Fender American Pro II Stratocasters, we A/B them both and leave the decision up to you!

Опубликовано:

 

12 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 263   
@mindphaser23
@mindphaser23 3 года назад
Maybe maple sounds brighter than rosewood, maybe it doesn’t. But I have never understood this discussion. It’s only a difference one would hear when the two are played against each other, such as in this video. Not once have I listened to a song and said to myself, “Oh, this was played on a maple fretboard!” Who does that? Would anybody think less of David Gilmour if he predominantly played Strats with rosewood fretboards? I say if you have a choice of fretboards on two otherwise similar guitars, pick the guitar that looks best to you aesthetically and move on.
@fbee6844
@fbee6844 2 года назад
Yes.
@gonza.shreds
@gonza.shreds 2 года назад
I agree, I feel that rosewood has more bass.
@DRIIC-qw8us
@DRIIC-qw8us 2 года назад
I'm 100% sure David Gilmour has a preference of fretboard material.
@LNSANTOS779
@LNSANTOS779 2 года назад
Tenha as duas..
@Mossy5150
@Mossy5150 2 года назад
I can't play VH tunes on anything other than a 5A birdseye maple fretboard, personally... 😛
@tooka5777
@tooka5777 2 года назад
I like that slick lacquer that's on a maple fretboard just feels better
@timothymallon
@timothymallon 3 года назад
It's funny, on the blind test, I was opposite what they really were. I thought the attack on guitar A seemed to be maple, whereas the attack on guitar B seemed warmer to me and was rosewood. I guess my ears were lying
@GoldSeals
@GoldSeals 3 года назад
Thats exactly how I picked it.I think he playing with us.I am sure A was maple,and B was rosewood.
@ereh3423
@ereh3423 2 года назад
@@GoldSeals me too
@Zombie_13x33
@Zombie_13x33 2 года назад
I thought b was brighter. I'm only listening with ear buds tho
@soots-stayingoutofthespotl5495
@soots-stayingoutofthespotl5495 2 года назад
Same here Timothy. During the blind test I thought 'A' was more musical and brighter, and 'B' was less tonally-complicated and not as bright/ more dry. But surely that's the complete opposite to what you might expect given the reveal of which-is-which wood at the end? I think a slight mis-match in EQ might be throwing things here then, either that or the guy mis-spoke and got them the wrong way round himself in his concluding words (seeing as multiple people in the comments apparently had a similar perception i.e. that A must be maple).
@Glicksman1
@Glicksman1 2 года назад
Please read my comment above.
@jonathonrich8061
@jonathonrich8061 2 года назад
I definitely heard a difference. They sounded very similar, however the maple had more honk and attack with the lower mids a little more present. It sounded more percussive to me. The rosewood fretboard strat I heard more harmonic content less pick attack more high end content but the lower strings seemed kind of dampened or dark.
@Glicksman1
@Glicksman1 2 года назад
Of course you heard a difference, they're two different guitars and no two guitars sound exactly the same..
@warshipsatin8764
@warshipsatin8764 Год назад
​​@@Glicksman1 so which part(s) of the guitar are responsible for the sound then, and to what degree?
@Glicksman1
@Glicksman1 Год назад
@@warshipsatin8764 Are you sincerely asking me to go into all of the possible theories and opinions about this enormous subject, or are you just baiting me? You ask this "question" as if you think that that either it is unanswerable (which it likely is), or you think that you know the answer and are ready to pounce on me, or anyone else who says anything different. Sorry. I don't play that silly game.
@andym28
@andym28 Год назад
I'm hearing that honk a lot but I'm not hearing it in nickel frets. It would be good to test if I could dial it out as its pretty harsh.
@wulf67
@wulf67 10 месяцев назад
It has nothing to do with the fretboard.
@bentlyist
@bentlyist 2 года назад
You need to pick your fretboard material by the feel you like. Truthfully I could barely tell when he was switching guitars when I just listened to the audio. When I watched and listened, then I could tell. The difference (on an electric guitar) is so minor compared to even the slightest tone adjustment on your amp or guitar that you really need to just pick the one that feels best when you play it! Good video by the way. 😊
@bulutergor
@bulutergor 3 года назад
I prefer maple, just for it looks
@Glicksman1
@Glicksman1 3 года назад
Well, a maple fingerboard also feels a lot different from a rosewood one.
@engell3707
@engell3707 3 года назад
Rosewood looks more elegant.That’s why the first years of the Strat they did rosewood, because they were competing with the Les Paul, which is a guitar that was design aesthetically so it could look good with a tuxedo. So Leo Fender had to use rosewood first. Then came maple, but it wasn’t yo appreciated until Clapton started playing with it and making it famous.
@eliandean9806
@eliandean9806 3 года назад
sorry to be offtopic but does anyone know of a tool to log back into an Instagram account?? I somehow lost the login password. I love any help you can offer me.
@ismaelalijah1760
@ismaelalijah1760 3 года назад
@Elian Dean Instablaster ;)
@eliandean9806
@eliandean9806 3 года назад
@Ismael Alijah Thanks for your reply. I got to the site thru google and im waiting for the hacking stuff now. Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later when my account password hopefully is recovered.
@JohnMichaelBurns
@JohnMichaelBurns 3 года назад
Ah man. For the blind test I was like: Yeah A is way brighter, it's obviously maple. Then for the non-blind clips I was like : Yeah, maple is so obviously brighter. This is not the first youtube blind test maple vs rosewood video where I've been convinced that the answer is blindingly obvious and have gotten it totally wrong. I think the moral is that it's not worth choosing a guitar based on which fretboard wood you prefer. The best guitar (for you) in the shop might just be the one with the "wrong" fretboard wood. I bought a guitar last week. I tried out 25 guitars and ended up getting a hardtail bullet strat (Indian Laurel board). While I was trying out those guitars I wasn't even really aware of what the fretboard was made from. The body and neck shape had a much bigger influence on my choice. You could swap the neck on my strat for a one piece maple neck and I doubt I'd care.
@DougMen1
@DougMen1 Год назад
Rosewood has that upper midrange that jumps out at you more, and some perceive as brighter. Maple is more even across all frequencies, with less mids, which makes it sound brighter overall to me. And, i always find the difference to be most pronounced on the neck pickups, and less so on the other positions. But, on the neck pickup, the RW always has that rounder and woodier tone that maple doesn't have as much.
@Voxman5
@Voxman5 8 дней назад
I'm an experienced player and own several rosewood and maple board Strats and Teles. If you listen with your eyes open your brain will fill in what it thinks you want. If you go back and listen with your eyes closed, there's no discernible difference - it's a wierd effect but it's true. Now, even though both guitars are from the same series, no two guitars are identical and you'll still get minor variances in guitar body woods and pickup winding which can all impact on tone. I'll try and find it but there's a similar test using a single Fender Stratocaster where the neck was changed to one of identical shape, thickness, same strings, but one was maple board and the other rosewood. This was an even better test because it cut out the other variables - and the tone was the same from both. It was also wired up to an oscilloscope and whilst there were some very small technical variances in the signal, these were so small that these were scientifically acknowledged as not within the range of even the most perceptive of human hearing. So I think it's fair to say that there is no humanly discernible TONAL difference as between rosewood and maple boards. But of course there is a 'feel' difference and maple boards being smoother and harder can feel faster to play. Any preference is therefore purely down to feel and aesthetics.
@hawkgeoff
@hawkgeoff Год назад
I appreciate the time you put into this. The thing that most people don't realize, or want to accept, is that every piece of wood on the planet is different. There are generalities that can be made, but in my experience buying a maple neck strat does not guarantee you a brighter or sharper tone/ attack. This is why I sold a CS strat and my main guitar is a partscaster. There was just something missing with this guitar. The partscaster is all Fender stuff, but that custom shop body and neck just didn't like each other... Your odds of them getting along are much better if you go CS, but I've heard Japan Squiers that are ridiculously good that most guitar guys would never pick up. Guitar price does not mean sonic joy...
@EdCalavera777
@EdCalavera777 Год назад
I feel you man! YOU SO RIGHT! I really understand because i've done same stuff! and agree with japan squiers.
@astull12
@astull12 2 года назад
In my experience I've noticed I can hit harmonics more consistently on rosewood. Aside from that I think they sound similar enough to base your preference on aesthetic.
@strummercash5601
@strummercash5601 6 месяцев назад
@astull12 Hello! 2 years later and want to thank you for this insight. I’ve played acoustic for decades, finally plugging in. I love harmonics on electrics, so that would really be a deciding factor for me. 🙏🏽✌🏽💙 from Minnesota, USA
@Juno58
@Juno58 28 дней назад
And a preference of the feeling. Laquered fingerboards are sometimes somehow sticky.
@johnperry9082
@johnperry9082 2 года назад
My 77 year old buccaneers being subjected to years and years of loud amps had a bit of trouble picking out which was maple or rosewood in the blind test. But I did hear a very slight difference (or did I imagine a difference in tone?) In the visual comparison a couple of riffs on the maple did (I think) have slightly brighter tone. I own and play both Maple and Rosewood Strat's but with different pickups so I've never thought about the neck affecting the tone, just the pickups. I think the feel difference of maple and rosewood fretboards may affect the way you play slightly, which maybe could affect the tone.
@bobowrathsovine.
@bobowrathsovine. 2 месяца назад
Guitar A the white one sounds better throughout the test. Guitar B blue one is muffled/dull/muddy compared to Guitar A. But I suspect even though Fender claims they're both identical guitars somewhere in the circuitry there's a mismatch. A resister/capacitor/shielding/wiring is slightly altered between the two. I doubt it has anything to do with fretboard wood altering frequency/clarity of the chords and single notes coming out the speaker of the amp.
@rocktorrocks
@rocktorrocks 3 года назад
I was so sure Guitar B was rosewood, it was warmer sounding and I preferred it thinking it was the rosewood one lol. Seems I was wrong lol!
@benallmark9671
@benallmark9671 3 года назад
Don’t feel bad , a least you can admit it.
@CubensisRecords
@CubensisRecords 2 года назад
I had the exact same feeling.
@sammyowen4655
@sammyowen4655 2 года назад
I don't know how people say Maple is brighter. A and b blindtest you can clearly hear the rosewood ping in A. Maple is not brighter it's more compressed.
@TheUnkwnonOne21
@TheUnkwnonOne21 2 года назад
This and maple has an obvious dip in the mids which makes it percussive, whereas you get more control and a better string separation with rosewood.
@natalea.1858
@natalea.1858 Год назад
I totally agree with you
@andersj.p.eskilsson3655
@andersj.p.eskilsson3655 Год назад
Just what I was looking for. Superb presentation.
@asmongoldsmouth9839
@asmongoldsmouth9839 10 месяцев назад
*I ripped this video and separated the audio track and took samples of 1 second each of guitar A and B on all of the examples except the last one (bolume and distortion were not set the same. So there was a difference.* *I ran the audio track samples through my editing software, and the frequency fluctuation was almost identical between both. A tiny difference. But barely at all.*
@KennedyIvy
@KennedyIvy 9 месяцев назад
the differences were probably due to his strumming not being 100% consistent. Only way to fully test, is have a machine do the strumming
@PaulWilliams-j3j
@PaulWilliams-j3j 4 месяца назад
Warmth or brightness or any fingerboard has no effect on frequency ... any guitar playing the same note will have the same frequency (assuming they are in tune) that's how a guitar tuner works !!
@pb25193
@pb25193 Год назад
I like the feel of maple. Makes me want to play more.
@wmpopper
@wmpopper 10 месяцев назад
Excellent informative presentation. Rosewood perceived for wider full spectrum bass, middle, treble overall spectrum tonality.
@prenticef
@prenticef 10 месяцев назад
Nice video. To my ears the differences were not remarkable. There may have been some slight differences tonally but as a few have stated, no two guitars sound identical. For me it comes down to visual preference. I absolutely love the look and feel of a maple fretboard. If there were differences in tone, to me it was not enough to pick the fretboard less visually appealing to me. What is great is that we can have a choice.
@dariohenriquez7773
@dariohenriquez7773 11 месяцев назад
i've always felt maple sound brighter and rosewood a little darker. it was never important for me because every guitar i owned had a tone knob and the fretboard is not for changing the sound. is for the FEEL, and i personally hate maple in my fingers, it's just not for me. Rosewood feels good, always go for that and it never was about the sound, just the feel. For the sound a lot of pieces of wood won't make any difference, is how you play and through what you play. the most important things are the pickups and the speaker for sound. in between them you can EQ everything to match almost anything
@alfredomoreno4956
@alfredomoreno4956 8 месяцев назад
I always dreamed of a maple fretboard (love the looks) until I finally went to buy one and it felt like I was playing glue. Hated it! I just bought a cheap squier with a urethane finished maple neck and I actually love it 🤷‍♂️
@scouser2230
@scouser2230 2 года назад
To my ears the maple sounds warmer and the rosewood brighter. I bought my Pro ll with a maple fretboard for myself.
@jamesnelson1443
@jamesnelson1443 Год назад
Maple is a little thinner on low notes, a bit snappier on highs! But overall what difference does it make? None!
@drlt9241
@drlt9241 7 месяцев назад
I don't care about the tone, I care about the look and feel, for me, I prefer rosewood, some others prefer maple.
@bdm1000
@bdm1000 3 года назад
I haven't owned an electric guitar in about 8 years. Before that I didn't play for about 15 years, but for about six years I played various guitars and really didn't know if there was a difference. I'm watching this because I am considering picking up a Fender Strat. I owned a Tele 8 years ago and regret parting with it. I owned a Washburn Strat with a rosewood board in my youth along with a Charvel (with a maple neck), but I never played them side by side, and I even had different amps when I owned them. That said, I have a fairly good ear for sound, and I definitely identified that B was a maple neck because it sound brighter and slightly punchier at times. There was one thing you played where I was surprised it was B, but overall I could definitely tell the difference. I can see why someone like Brad Paisley gravitates to a maple neck on his Telecasters. But I can also see why he uses a rosewood fingerboard on his Strat (i.e. She's Everything). That doesn't mean one's better than the other, and I assume the difference between fresh and dead strings can matter as much or more, but if I wasn't convinced there was a difference before this video, I am now. That said, there is a difference between what we hear and see versus what we hear and see that is recorded. I heard positively heard the differences, but I obviously wasn't there in the room. My opinion is that I would have heard them because they were that different. We also have to remember we all hear things a little different. Some of us are better at hearing some frequencies than others, so for some people they may not have heard a difference. But for me, it was evident there was a difference. Thank you for making this video because it really did confirm what I heard others say, and if you hadn't done the blind test, I wouldn't have been able to rule out confirmation bias.
@Jake_Reid
@Jake_Reid 2 года назад
get the strat doesnt matter rosewood or not ive owend both
@Silvertip1958
@Silvertip1958 3 месяца назад
Thanks for the comparison. I have a strat and tele with maple and I see on this video that I like maple better.
@Danieljevans92
@Danieljevans92 3 года назад
I have a limited edition fender strat with an rosewood neck and to my ears it sounds bright and snappy with clear definition like maple compared to the rosewood board /maple neck combo . It’s funny because I thought it would be darker and warmer because it’s fully rosewood, instead the opposite was true
@RalphDoe-r3o
@RalphDoe-r3o 2 месяца назад
Totally like the maple sound. I chose B as the maple and I was not wrong. Had a brighter cleaner sound.
@aribelkinRN
@aribelkinRN 11 месяцев назад
I bought an American pro maple fretboard and love how smooth it is. Also maple ages so nicely looks great dirty.
@tigershell
@tigershell 3 года назад
Background props looks sick dudes!
@derekfromtauranga6012
@derekfromtauranga6012 Месяц назад
I built two teles with the body material cut from the same piece of wood. The necks were both maple. One had a glued on maple fingerboard and one rosewood. They both had the same electrics, pickups, strings etc. The maple Tele just sounded nicer than the rosewood one which I subsequently sold.
@Juno58
@Juno58 28 дней назад
It's a matter of taste
@ronmaison8690
@ronmaison8690 Год назад
Rosewood sound brighter and warmer.Rosewood for me.
@isaiahmarquez9717
@isaiahmarquez9717 Год назад
Under blind test, the Rosewood sounded snappier, harsher. With the blind removed, it was the exact opposite. I think his attack was inconsistent.
@DHKarol
@DHKarol 3 года назад
I picked opposite and was bummed because I liked B more and I ordered mischief strat with maple but end result got me pleasently surprised good comparison
@Robert-Smith
@Robert-Smith 2 года назад
I must have a light touch because I rarely even feel the fret board especially with the frets that come on guitars now they must be higher then the ones that came on the older guitars. To me they both sounded like a Stat I just personally like the look of rosewood.
@stevennaismith6289
@stevennaismith6289 3 года назад
I can’t hear any difference between the two guitars
@benallmark9671
@benallmark9671 3 года назад
And those who say any different, well we know those types don’t we.
@BigBobbyBoLo
@BigBobbyBoLo 2 года назад
I looked away for a second and didnt realize you had changed guitars
@sidrolf
@sidrolf 3 года назад
Felt the maple was twangier and rosewood felt more spacious
@NewHeart378
@NewHeart378 3 года назад
love both guitar but I'm a maple guy.
@joshs3905
@joshs3905 6 месяцев назад
I went to a music store recently to try to bust this myth myself. Grabbed 2 ultras off the rack 1 maple and 1 rosewood. Played them side by side with my former guitar teacher facing his back towards me, and he had a very hard time distinguishing the 2 and told me that he was taking a guess. I believe if you're looking for a difference in sound your ears can make you believe that something sounds different. For anyone shopping for a new guitar - don't be hung up on this. Maple and Rosewood should be a feel and aesthetic choice and not based off of sound. Some maple fretboards will feel smoother than a rosewood and vice versa. For example my previous strat was a Pro 2 with rosewood fretboard and was buttery smooth. Back in November I replaced my pro 2 with an ultra which has a maple fretboard and I am in love with it. It feels super smooth to play, but what sold me was the aesthetic look of the maple matching with the headstock which I felt complimented the mocha burst very well. A darker finish like dark blue or black, even a surf green, would look amazing with a rosewood fretboard in my opinion, whereas brighter finishes with shiny bursts I think look perfect with a maple. I highly recommend going to a store and playing both yourself to know which feels better and is most inspiring to play. Happy hunting :)
@GCKelloch
@GCKelloch 4 месяца назад
Assuming the pickup heights aren't significantly different, the tonal difference is the same as with all such comparisons I've heard. The RW has more midrange, and less high-end chime (I'd attribute the chime to the thick hard finish over the frets).
@fabrizioluccitti6960
@fabrizioluccitti6960 Год назад
This is crazy, in the blind test I picked two times guitar B, so the one with maple but in the rest of the video I would have picked the one with rosewood.
@ianyoung8392
@ianyoung8392 3 месяца назад
Rosewood sounds wider with it[s mid range. Maple sounds more concentrated. Both guitars had good highs. But it's very hard when you don't use the same body because we've all been into a shop and picked up strats. The weight varies wildly and therefore the quality of the wood and whether it was at the top or bottom of the tree makes a big difference. But if you want wider or more concentrated in your tone then it's a part of the chain to think about. If you look at someone like Zakk Wylde. Mahogany has a wider grain and a wider sound. Zakk modernised the Les Paul sound with EMG's AND using maple set necks Whereas Eddie did something similar with bolt on maple necks, higher output humbuckers and basswood to be wider sounding than strat woods. If what you want is the tightest guitar possible then people start to use more and more maple in their guitars from the neck, fretboard and body top, in Jerry Cantrell's case the whole body. Which in turn helps you sound good with darker amp/pedal settings. Dual Rectifier, 5150, SLO100 etc. all had a lot more gain and bass than generations of amps before them. Hence why headless, stainless steel fret, multiscale guitars these days are on the brighter and louder side. There's a strong reason why Ibanez, Kiesel, Strandberg, Schecter, Ormsby, Anderson, Suhr, G&L, new design PRS (Weiner started it), Musicman etc. all have a scale of how much maple they generally use in their electric guitars. Maple has a magic to it that people can't deny that works so well in a huge mix or by yourself. What I see in the comments is that people don't realise how robust maple is and how delicate treble can be on a rosewood guitar because it sounds wider.
@mikeyJstiffler
@mikeyJstiffler Месяц назад
Ive always been partial to maple fretboards. They feel great to play. The only guitar I don’t really prefer a maple fretboard on is a jazzmaster and it’s for no particular reason 😂
@Steve-si8hx
@Steve-si8hx 2 года назад
Could have sworn the blind test that A was maple. But was actually rosewood. Ok so somehow rosewood is brighter than maple. Which I thought would have been the opposite.
@vvdisk
@vvdisk 6 месяцев назад
i have to say i heard the difference, and i spotted right maple was B. Maple sounded slightly more harmonic rich to me than rosewood. also on the neck pickup and playing around the 12th fret, i have to say it sounded slightly more hendrix'ish than the rosewood one (if you listen carefully on that kind of solo at 5:53/6:02)
@IsaacLausell
@IsaacLausell Год назад
I have heard that it does not matter and yet they do sound different. When one plays melodies with attention to maintaining tone quality, not snapping the strings or playing with a planky thin tone the differences are noticeable. Maple is flatter in terms of frequency response. Rosewood is more active in the low and some low mids which can lead the listener to perceive it as a darker sounding wood without considering what is happening in the highs and upper mids. They also respond a bit differently. One reason maple is perceived as brighter is because a lot of folks tend to “break the sound”. It is a term that refers to when you pluck a string harder than it’s natural threshold and instead of getting a clean bell like sound it snaps. This is what we find on some blues shuffle rhythm work or some funk guitar. Under such type of attack maple tends show some activity around 3.5k when you are digging in while the difference in timbre on a rosewood board at this dynamic range is less pronounced. In short it is not merely a question of when being brighter and the other darker. There are more variables at play in what they do when you pluck in different ways, when you play in different ranges as well as ranges of dynamics and all of this is just with a clean guitar. The differences become more subtle the more gain is introduced to the equation but yet they do something different even in that case.
@BrettSmithDaniels
@BrettSmithDaniels 2 года назад
Maple seems to have more scooped mids - where as rosewood has more controlled low end. There's definitely a difference... I'd say a substantial one!
@scubasteev
@scubasteev Год назад
Huh? The pickups and bodies didn't factor in at all?
@ALtheDoctorWho
@ALtheDoctorWho 8 месяцев назад
LOL I thought A was the Maple neck. It sounded warmer to my ears. The question I am interested in which Guitar did you feel more comfortable playing. Thank you for the demo.
@anythingoctane2561
@anythingoctane2561 7 месяцев назад
I did notice a difference, however is was the opposite I expected!
@bryanstarkweather
@bryanstarkweather 8 месяцев назад
This is the exact video I've been looking for. For all the people that claim they can tell the difference, I'm only going to show them the first part of this video with the blocked out guitar, and tell them to choose which one is which. People who think this stuff makes a difference are crazy. As soon as you showed the guitars, I could hear the difference, but I couldn't hear it when you weren't showing them. This is a very well understood psychological phenomenon. The senses use each other to fill in details. This is why when you show an instrument being played, especially in an orchestral context, people who know what that instrument should sound like hear it more suddenly. People who don't know what that instrument should sound like do not. This phenomenon has been publicized for many years. People who could clearly hear a difference between two instruments that they were seeing could not hear the difference when they didn't see the instruments. When people have made blind tests, all the people who claim that they can tell the difference suddenly dissapear.
@trioguitar
@trioguitar 3 года назад
I can't discern a difference in the sound, but it's certainly true that maple feels bloody different. I reckon when I first bought a Fender with a maple fretboard that it took me at least a year to get used to it, it just felt bloody weird.
@xiaco8309
@xiaco8309 2 года назад
Completely agree. I have only ever owned rosewood and just bought a satin maple neck strat. It’s for sure different but I really like it. It does just feel weird at first but it brought back some fun for playing because of the change.
@TySutherland
@TySutherland 2 года назад
I found this extremly interesting. I've only owned maple but thinking there's something satisfying about sparkle and snap of the rosewood. Guess I'll just have to buy one and find out for myself :)
@NotBenCoultry
@NotBenCoultry 3 года назад
Listening on a pair of Adams with my eyes close and periodically opening them, I knew maple by a sproing in the attack and I bet it's due to the way you're playing in reaction to the different feel.
@rowanmurphy5239
@rowanmurphy5239 3 года назад
I'll agree that the were close, but in the blind test, I preferred guitar A, and then rosewood in the non blind test. I can tell the difference. I have preferred rosewood for a long time. I also prefer the look of it.
@scubasteev
@scubasteev Год назад
How do you know it was the rosewood that made TGE difference...they were 2 different guitars, with different pick ups, different bodies, different strings, and different frets. Could be the rosewood made all tge difference...but I'm guessing not.
@juliensoyer5786
@juliensoyer5786 3 года назад
definitely sound different, the size of the difference heard depends on people. I spot the difference immediately because I am used to listen to it closely, in the past I could not hear the difference personnally. However the more gain and compression you had the less you can hear a difference
@robberman4554
@robberman4554 2 года назад
Great test! I got the blind test the wrong way round. Then when you did the sighted test I thought it was opposite and questioned if I had the blind test correct. They really are quite close
@kaneo67
@kaneo67 Год назад
guitar A is clearly more resonant.I dont know which fingerboard that is yet or if that makes a difference, because it could be the body as well,and the two different maples in each neck regardless of one having a roasewood board.and the quality of how the guitar was made
@sleevelessace
@sleevelessace 9 месяцев назад
honestly with the maple/rosewood board its whatever feels and looks better to your preference because you can get the same sounds out of both of them... where as pickups,amps,cabs, solid mahogany or maple capped, change the tone from very very slighty to Alot
@GoldSeals
@GoldSeals 3 года назад
Maple has a cleaner brighter sound,where rosewood sounds dull,and muffled.I have an american series strat with a rosewood fingerboard,and I hate it.I went out and bought an american series maple fingerboard strat a few months later,and love it.Im considering changing the neck out to a maple fingerboard.A few years ago I was looking at prices on the maple fingerboard necks,and they were running around $400.
@toddthomas4761
@toddthomas4761 2 года назад
Very interesting! I was just about to buy a Strat with rosewood and was doubtful it was gonna be bright enough...
@GoldSeals
@GoldSeals 2 года назад
@@toddthomas4761 I believe maple,or ebony fretboard is the way to go.Im not sold on rosewood.Each one has its advantages and disadvantages.My opinion.
@MrGuitarandvocals
@MrGuitarandvocals Год назад
I have a rosewood strat and the cleans are nice and bright. Not muffled at all. My buddy has a rosewood strat as well and his doesn't sound muffled either. Must be your pickups or your amp.
@GoldSeals
@GoldSeals Год назад
@@MrGuitarandvocals its not the amp.Ive plugged other guitars into the amp,and they sound great.Its possible it could be the pickups.But I doubt it.I bought it brand new a few years ago and its always sounded terrible compared to my other guitars.Maybe I should measure The ohms on the pickups.Do you have any idea how many ohms the pickups on a american series strat is supposed to be?Thanks in advance.
@MrGuitarandvocals
@MrGuitarandvocals Год назад
@@GoldSeals I wish I could help you, but I have no idea. I swapped out the stock pickups in my strat for a Bareknuckle HSS set. The stock pickups were decent, but the Bareknuckles blow them away imo. Now that I think about it, the stock pickups sounded kinda muffled. Lol. My buddy has Texas specials in his strat and they are fantastic. No issues. It has to be the pickups. Best of luck!
@DRIIC-qw8us
@DRIIC-qw8us Год назад
The only way to do this is to use the same body and swap the necks. I'm sure you'd hear a difference but you gotta do that for it to be a proper test.
@robphillips8351
@robphillips8351 2 месяца назад
The maple board actually sounds like it has a bigger tone, more lows,mids and highs.. i don't know it's usually rosewood has a dampened high end but 🤔
@scu11ey
@scu11ey 9 месяцев назад
During the first half of the blind test, I thought B was the maple, and then during the second half I was no longer sure.
@HeyRavil
@HeyRavil 4 месяца назад
Fun thing is if you show this blindfold test to someone out of context, like they don't know what guitars are compared at all at what specific aspects are compared, like it could be just any guitars, I bet absolutely nobody will tell you "oh I definitely can hear it's two identical alder body strats, most likely fenders, but I notice that one is rosewood and other one is maple fretboard"
@BeeRumblin13
@BeeRumblin13 11 месяцев назад
I like a maple gloss board over dusty rosewood . At least on my Fenders.
@truthof7382
@truthof7382 Год назад
My issue with the two and Fender is they apply the poly on the maple necks after the Frets and bury the frets a bit. Not the case with rosewood.
@user-ih7zg6qw2p
@user-ih7zg6qw2p 8 месяцев назад
I hear differences with the fingerboards but their enough to notice. The maple sounds brighter and more tinny it has a distinct sound like it's got more treble. The rosewood sounds more softer or warmer as others say, I feel the rosewood has more articulation and that it's richer when playing licks & hammer on's. I don't mind maple with cleans but I think rosewood is better when distorted and more versatile.
@oliviergagnon2592
@oliviergagnon2592 2 года назад
The string actually touches the metal part of the fret so it doesnt matter whats underneath (wood)
@zemlidrakona2915
@zemlidrakona2915 7 месяцев назад
Good test. I liked the sound of A better, and I got it wrong, which means I learned something.
@SfcO1970
@SfcO1970 7 месяцев назад
I can hear it. to me its sounds like the maple neck is a little raw. However the neck pickups sounded pretty dang close.. Definite notice in the bridge pick up
@gqnelly
@gqnelly Год назад
So many factors go into tone. Each guitar is so individual. The strings...the pickups...the body...the wiring...the PLAYER....the amp. This isnt like an acoustic guitar where the tone resonates from the sound hole and the body (most notably the top). The guitar is amplified. I dont believe you fretting a note in a location that doesnt have a pickup will impart much tone differential. The string will have a frequency (note) based on where you fret it and the pickup (microphone) will grab it and add volume (along with tonal characteristics of the in the electronics / wiring of the pickup. Your eyes have more to do with it than anything....
@CEbding1996
@CEbding1996 2 года назад
The Rosewood sounds more 'Warm" and the Maple has more bright or has more of a "bite" to it.
@byronphillips6139
@byronphillips6139 Год назад
I watched a thing were Clapton said it’s a lot easier to do bends on a slick maple neck and I have a maple neck on mine but I really love tha way tha rosewood looks compared to tha maple 🍁
@jmacc9876
@jmacc9876 3 года назад
Close enough. Anyone who claims a big difference is just cork sniffing. Bigger differences in any two strats (far more than fretboard material) would be the electronics (obviously) and then the nut material the string guage etc. Fretboard material is almost negligible once plugged in to an amp at an appreciable volume. That said I'm a rosewood guy on my Fenders, more for the look than anything although maple is beautiful also. .
@andym28
@andym28 Год назад
I used to switch off during generic demos but I recent years I'm hearing yikes I need to turn they brittle sound off. There's a significance between nickel and steel. I'm sure I could dial out the steel sound but I'll definately stick with nickel regardless of the hassle.
@ifodaniell
@ifodaniell 11 месяцев назад
I was working elsewhere in a different browser and therefore wasn't biased by what was being visually presented while listening to each example. I heard no difference. To me, I prefer Rosewood. I always have since first picking up an electric guitar. I don't like the rock-hard feeling of maple under my fingers. I like ebony, as well. It's just a preference.
@LB-yn2su
@LB-yn2su 19 дней назад
Rosewood more precise, more transients, Maple more mellow & round. Don't listen to anybody telling you it doesn't matter, it all matters, even and especially on an electric guitar.
@brunochiarini_guitar
@brunochiarini_guitar 3 года назад
I prefer the maple in clean tones and rosewood in dirtier tones. Maple doesn't absorb so much drive as rosewood, and kind of muffles the sound a bit, but that's just my opinion.
@Juno58
@Juno58 28 дней назад
I don't like the laquer finish at maple fretboards, it's kind of sticky sometimes.
@BrianPellerin
@BrianPellerin Год назад
I did what a nerd would do and ran the audio through the Decibel X frequency app. I’m starting to think Maple lacks just a little of the lowest frequencies but I’ve only started comparing.
@ladyluckdrums
@ladyluckdrums Год назад
Me too! on the blind test, I was opposite what they really were.
@RiffLair
@RiffLair 2 месяца назад
If you know what to listen for it's not hard to get right when side by side. Maple is snappier/brighter. When in a mix? Who cares?! I like unfinished maple with some gunk on it more though 😎🤟
@karlroszko
@karlroszko Год назад
The maple had a honk / quack kind of sound on the attack where the rosewood didn’t
@Glicksman1
@Glicksman1 3 года назад
I don't think that all maple or maple with a rosewood fingerboard makes as much of a difference or any difference, but no two guitars sound alike, so using two guitars to do this test proves nothing. Only by using one guitar and changing the necks would tell us something useful. Yeah, it would be a PIA to do that, but that's the only way to be sure that we're really hearing any difference or none.
@tobytoxd
@tobytoxd 2 года назад
Great comment!
@foxns7
@foxns7 2 года назад
Very true
@Flat_Stanley
@Flat_Stanley Год назад
This argument is ridiculous. It’s not a debate, or shouldn’t be. It’s science. There is equipment that can prove the difference in frequency and resonance than many of us hear. Some people can’t hear high pitch tones played at the same volume as lower pitches, it doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist. Some people can identify specific ingredients in a dish, if your palatte is less refined and unable to, does that mean the ingredients you can not identify are not there and the food snobs are wrong?
@bikeman1x11
@bikeman1x11 8 месяцев назад
difference is real- same as the neck material and body material
@donarmando916
@donarmando916 Год назад
Maple a lot harder? That's a generalization. There are different kinds of maple just as not all east indian rosewood has the same hardness. The cut makes also a difference, flatsawn, weird sawn or quartersawn. For maple it also matters quite a lot if roasted or plain. The thickness and construction of the neck plays also a role. As a luthier i think i know that there is nothing on a guitar that does not matter. I agree the pickups make a big difference too, but it's the summary of things that make the hearable difference. It's complex.and a lot of personal.taste is involved as always.
@donarmando916
@donarmando916 Год назад
Two identiacal guitars? If you don't swap the neck and use the same body, it's not identical. Bodies can also be very different from one to another even if the model is the same.
@michaelmeighoo5579
@michaelmeighoo5579 3 года назад
The next video should show the difference in strings. Not the normal stuff, the indepth things. The different internal shapes, materials, UK.. The seemingly insignificant stuff.
@kaneo67
@kaneo67 Год назад
wow i was right! guitar A sounded better, and i am not talking about the bends. normal strums sounded better on guitar A which was rosewood. but it may not be that which is the factor, i think its like another commentor said, they are two different pieces of wood in body and neck. The pickup identical specs I trust as being the same.I have two silver sky se's with rosewood and they sound almost identical. You can really hear that there are new strings on those two guitars
@Triumphcruiser
@Triumphcruiser Год назад
If the fretboard wood made any significant difference, would some guitars have large block inlays ? B bright C Dark I don't think so .
@vivito-
@vivito- Год назад
maple is more colorful and bright, rosewood is warmer and darker/ less colorfull too
@jaimemonroyofficial
@jaimemonroyofficial Месяц назад
Rosewood is warmer, Maple stands trebles out.
@kaneo67
@kaneo67 Год назад
wow, they sound only slightly different, but I cant define in which ways.BUt those amrecian pro 2's sound so great in this clip. They always sound great but that's amazing.That is all the strat sound I would ever want. Am i getting that from my silver sky? probably...i am just de-sensitized to my sound. and this sound is new to me. wow what a warm sound....
@johnmirabile3535
@johnmirabile3535 3 года назад
MAPLE IS MORE VIBRANT, PERHAPS BRINGS OUT MORE HIGH END!! ROSEWOOD MUCH DARKER TO ME LESS SNAP I FEEL IT HAS MORE SIZZLE WITH OVERDRIVE...AND YOUR SOOO RIGHT IF I LIKE THE LOOKS OF A CERTAIN GUITAR ILL LEAN TOWARDS THAT ONE! GOOD COMPARISN!
@Zombie_13x33
@Zombie_13x33 2 года назад
I have 2 jackson dinkys. One with a maple neck and one with rosewood. There is a noticeable difference. Even with high gain the maple is brighter. I like the rosewood with it eq'd to be more trebly like the maple.
@andym28
@andym28 Год назад
I've been playing for so long I don't really mind about all this but I seem to be hearing a brittle harshness in all these sounds. Initially it must be the rosewood but I'm hearing it in every example. I definitely a nasty harshness from steel frets. I'm not sure if you can dial it out but I'd rather just put up with nickel frets and get them changed.
@steviem1000
@steviem1000 11 месяцев назад
I dont think it matters at all. without the other to compare youd never know. Lots of folk on these comments have got the blind test wrong, so are your eyes influencing your ears? Probably. Also, I think depending on the fretboard material, try as you may, I don't think you handle them the same way. I myself don't dig in to a maple board the way I would press more firmly into a rosewood board. I dont know why? So that slight playing difference is going to be audible. Be interesting to hear a blind test on a plywood board, which without the visuals, we'd be well confused. I repair electric guitars and lots pass through my hands. More important to have a great set up, nice shinny frets and the best amp you can buy for your budget. Most guitars I set up from 100 quid strats to American delux's or 100 quid second hand westfields to Gibson les pauls sound great through a big tube amp!
@justachristian4072
@justachristian4072 Год назад
There’s a video on RU-vid where a guy has ten identical spec guitars (Miami blue with maple fret board) and he does a comparison and they all sound slightly different.
@richardthorpe3059
@richardthorpe3059 9 месяцев назад
I don't think my ear is sufficiently finely tuned to tell much difference but I play maple only because I like the feel.
@vincentcuclair5522
@vincentcuclair5522 Месяц назад
The string goes from metal fret to metal saddle?!
@kaneo67
@kaneo67 Год назад
the rosewood is the better sounding guitar. and i prefer guitar A. I wonder which one guitar A will be?
@andym28
@andym28 Год назад
Brittleness and harshness in both guitars. I have nickel fretwire. Thing is I can hear it regardless of the amount of distortion. I think you can't get rid of it without losing clarity so I guess I'll stick to fretwire. M
Далее
3 Different Necks On The Same Guitar (I’m Shocked)
18:15
Rosewood vs Maple - Tonewood Blindfold Challenge!
15:55
Как подписать? 😂 #shorts
00:10
Просмотров 706 тыс.
Fender American Strats - What's the difference?
13:23
Просмотров 309 тыс.
SAME GUITAR, 4 BUDGETS! (Can you hear the difference?)
17:59
Rosewood vs Maple: Does It Matter? | Friday Fretworks
12:25
Playing THE FORBIDDEN RIFF in a Huge Guitar Store
14:00
Fender American Pro II VS Ultra
15:50
Просмотров 104 тыс.
Rosewood VS Maple
18:52
Просмотров 9 тыс.
Как подписать? 😂 #shorts
00:10
Просмотров 706 тыс.