Uneducated keyboard warriors in the comments are unacceptable, as well. Anyone with decent RU-vid knowledge knows that the company makes money off of ad revenue. Pay for RU-vid Premium or deal with it.
Also, the copyright holder of this recording has claimed this video, and since gerubach possesses no control over the audio, they can place ads wherever they want. If you want no ads for free, download AdBlock (RIP mobile users).
I love the organ used in this recording. The brightness of the third movement on those tiny 1' stops is incredible. Well suited to the music in my opinion. Bravo!
In all recordings I’ve found of this and others of the trio sonatas the 2’ stop is consistently on the right hand voice and the left hand dynamically submissive. I thought the compositional idea was an equal conception of voicing?
My favorite Bach organ piece! And the adagio is at the most suitable tempo I've ever heard (other versions are too slow)! I still prefer Kay Johannsen's Allegro, though. The registration here is too starry and the piece is played a little too fast for my personal taste. Overall good work!
***** Well, at least you didn't say Passacaglia in C minor or Prelude and Fugue in E flat major "St. Anne". In regards to Bach, they seem to be everybody's favorite compositions.
To teach you some patience; in order to give you the opportunity to prepare yourself for listening to the music; to take a cup of coffee, or a sip of wine....?
Early 18th century adagios are faster than 19th century adagios. Preston takes the mvt at a tempo you would find more suitable, no doubt. I think it sounds tedious at that speed, and I think that if Bach had wanted that tempo he’ve written Largo. I love the present version.
@@steveinmadison ty... note: since writing the comment I have gone to my old notes, and played the movement a few times. 🙄 wouldn't you know, I actually played it at the very tempo I was referencing as too quick. So out the window goes my adagio complaint. 😊
Sounds like the performer had a bit of trouble with the pedal part in the adagio, whether it was their own personal rubato, technical issues, or issues with this particular instrument speaking different, it was such a sad distraction when the pedal part wasn't in time! Other than those few instances, I love the reading of this so much! The Allegro has so much life in it and it's amazing to hear it played that way!! An even sadder distraction would be the constant ads DIRECTLY in the middle of a section. It's bad enough to have this fucked up by ads at all, but in the MIDDLE of a movement? I mean come on. Just put the ads at the beginning and end. The composer, performer, and you as the video editor, deserve quite a bit more respect than to have this work destroyed like that.
the "performer" Marie Claire Alain, who was one of the best french organist, (his teachers were Marcel Dupré and Maurice Duruflé...) has no "trouble" with the pedal part. I think you have problems with your ears...
@@MrDomi77 not really - actually, the pedal stops are a bit slow compared to the manuals, hence the impression that the feet are late (which is sure not the case).
Beautiful but the development from 10:00 for at least 4 bars to my opinion is completely missed by speed and too high registration. I feel you need a little more 8' and 4' selected here but otherwise very well played
Thank you for uploading! One of my favorite things to do it closely follow with the sheet music of keyboard works, so this channel is such an awesome place to go. Thanks again for all the work.
The copyright holder has every right to place ads on this video, unfortunately. However, you can either download RU-vid Premium or AdBlock to remove these unwanted commercials.
Something about the second movement reminds my of the sound font you would hear in a Final Fantasy game. It’s probably whatever stop is being used on the second line.
Some organ music actually uses 4 staves at times. With Bach's prelude on Aus Tiefer Not, you have 6 independent lines across 3 staves. Many choir directors and accompanists can read open score (4 staves).
Gerubach I’m not sure how to contact you directly. Would love it if you could perhaps look at BWV195 because the score of the 1st chorus would be very interesting to me. Thanks for all your great work.
For me the Adagio appears to be a perfect soundtrack for H. Hesse's "Das Glasperlenspiel" and particularly the episode of Knecht's first visit to the Chinese philosopher
