C'est le dernier qui a parlé qui a raison - Amina - (HQ) France 1991 - ESC songs with live orchestra 

After so many years I come back to this fantastic song again and again. It was a small theatre play, one of the best performances during the song contest. She was the true winner! ❤❤

I am agree with you.

No Arabic songs in EUROvision! Don't they have contests of their own? Thank you.

@@AMNBatSE 😂😂🤣

​

Peut-être? Non. Sans aucun doute.

Yeah, normally I don't have a taste for these Arab influenced singing, grown up in rock and soul, it's just not my sort of harmony, but this is pure beauty, much aided along with this great performance

Televoting was introduced in 1997?

@@toringepedersen9614 Yeah that's true, but this song and Sweden's Carola had the same amount of points from the juries. The rules at the time stated that in case of a tie, the one who had gotten most 12 points would win; they had the same. So they went on to who had received the most 10 points, and that was Sweden. Today, however, the rules state that in a tie, the country that has received points from the biggest amount of countries wins, and that is what France did.

​​​@@rasmushayesandersen9676A la place d'un départage, il serait judicieux et plus juste d'attribuer 2 prix pour 2 gagnants. Cela ferait un pays de plus qui gagnerait et cela mettrait un termes à de fortes déception de ce concours qui chaque année se dégrade davantage. 😢😢😊 3:44

Et cette voix claire et suave comme enrobée d'une douceur particulière. Cette chanson a marqué l'eurovision. Quel beau souvenir.❤❤❤😊😊

Yes

A winner with the current rules 😊

@@aleksanderpagels288 But who would've won the televote, had there been one?

@@EldaMengisto Israel

Et non, elle n'a pas gagné malheureusement Elle termine au final 1ere a égalité avec la Suède mais, a cause du résultat de l'Eurovision 1969 qui avait fait polémique (4 vainqueurs ex-aequo), l'UER qui organise l'Eurovision a du créer un règlement pour départager les pays au cas où ça arriverait à nouveau A l'époque, le règlement était que si 2 pays (ou plus), étaient premiers a égalité, on les départagereaient au nombre de 12 pts, s'il y a toujours égalité, le plus grand nombre de 10, etc, et s'il y avait toujours égalité a la fin, les 2 chansons étaient déclarées gagnantes Hors, la France et la Suède avaient obtenu le même nombre de 12 pts mais, la Suède ayant obtenu plus de 10 pts a donc été déclarée vainqueure ce qui, vous l'imaginez avait fait énormément polémique en France avec notamment le commentateur français qui serait sortis de sa cabine a la fin du show en hurlant dans les couloirs Ce qui encore plus triste, c'est que la règle des égalités actuelles (en vigueur depuis 2008 décide que l'on met devant, le pays ayant obtenu des points de la part du plus grand nombre de pays. Hors, la France avait obtenu des pts de la part d'un pays de plus que la Suède et donc, aurait gagné avec ce système)

Completely agree

Yes

This would be the winner by today's tiebreaking rules

Cry about it, everyone can’t get their willing every day. France should be winning this but this was 1991. Forget it 😊

@@linuslimpan0 Sorry its hard to pick up on a joke. It was a joke. Of course I haven't been pissed off since 1991 over Eurovision 😸

I couldn't agree more! 👍

@@ivindjakobsen7781 😸😸🤠

El jurado español (con las presencias destacadas de Salomé, Loles León, Paco Clavel, María Casal y Alfonso del Real) se portó muy bien con ella y le dio 8 puntos bien merecidos.

« Huha » means him and « hiah » means her in arabic.

the arrangement for eurovision is amazing! I wish the instrumental were available...

Well, not according to the judges. And you're right this was a very good song, so good infact that it tied with Carolas song. But no song deserves to win. If so, there would be no point of having a competition.

That's your opinion and mine is defintely different . They ended in a draw, so she was the winner too. Anyways we declare that the winner of the Eurovision song contest in 1991 is Amina La france !! 🇨🇵🏆🇨🇵

What moment?

@@ElLuchador535 that drunkish moment while recounting her experience

@@ronfarkas That was SO embarrassing.

The Icelandic jury gave it 7 points, by the way.

Humilité, beauté, talent. C'a change de la Zara 😂

Unos opinan que habla del machismo en el mundo árabe, otros creen que habla de la manipulación informativa durante la Guerra del Golfo Pérsico durante la Tormenta del Desierto (El último que ha hablado tiene razón sería la traducción del título con su mise en relief y todo para hacer hincapié) e incluso lanza una indirecta al entonces presidente Bush de los Estados Unidos, en concreto, la frase Dime en nombre de qué nación elevas el tono en mi casa.

Para mí habla del uso de la fuerza y la tradición para apoyar la autoridad. El grito, el puñetazo en la mesa, el "aquí mando yo". Irónicamente, por supuesto, es decir criticándolo. Decir que es "en el mundo árabe", disculpa ​ @Carlos MS, tiene para mí un tonillo como si esas cosas no pasaran fuera de él. A mí me parece global. Como el machismo es también cuasi global, se puede decir que va contra esa forma de machismo, pero seguro que se da incluso fuera de ese contexto y la canción sólo menciona el sexo para decir que no hay diferencia ("Fille ou garçon: Tous ces dictons sont des leçons"). Es la (bellísima) intérprete, creo, la que hace que nos imaginemos una familia árabe y un hombre velludo pegando un puñetazo en la mesa del comedor. Es ella... y nuestros estereotipos, metidos en nuestros cerebros.

Wrong

@@moaadjo6731 You do not know anything, you are not cultured and educated, and you do not have the knowledge that she is an Arab woman known in the Arab countries and sings in French and Arabic, or do you think that all Arabs live in tents and live in the desert, or that they are uneducated, uncultured, and do not have a civilization?

Une honte

I agree

Agreed

The Danish jury (composed by 8 music experts and 8 music lovers and based at TV-Byen studios) didn't think the same and gave it 0 points and 12 to Sweden, 10 to Israel, 8 to Turkey, 7 to Ireland, 6 to Germany, 5 to Switzerland, 4 to Luxembourg, 3 to the United Kingdom, 2 to Norway and 1 to Portugal.

Це метафора

​@@user-mt6mu9uo8h ni l'un ni l'autre. 🙂😎🤓😁

@@mgobyABDOU ah ok ! 🙂

For me it would be more matter that more countries woted for France! But who am I to judge… France 💙🤍❤️

@@milanj.k.6936 That could definitely a way to pronouce a winner in a case like this. In 1968 there were 4 countries with the samme winning score. Don't know who was pronouced winner ,nor do I know wich criterias has been used.

تعرف تخرس

انت الهراء

Quel manque de goût

Ferme ta gaule😂

Caribbean. Sahara. African. Classic European

Yes. That one like for your comment.

I agree.

It’s beautiful dommage your soul isn’t deeper enough…

Tu ne peux pas comprendre

That's too bad. What do you not like about the song?

Not 15th for me, but neither she or Carola should have won.

@@nunovski2002 Then who's your favorite of 1991?

@@EldaMengisto For me Spain, or Portugal, with Israel, Finland, Malta, Switzerland and Italy in quick succession. I also like Turkey and Cyprus.

you have very bad taste in music. Sorry for you :-)

Isabelle ? 🤔