While this tutorial is somewhat useful and I can appreciate you went out of your way to create it, I have to say - You should really try to remember throughout the recording that you are in fact doing a tutorial. You jump over steps without explaining, rapidly click multiple places and change values all over without mentioning half of what you did , and the fact that your mouse is invisible in the recording and your wide screen makes the video hard to read doesn't help either. The most frustrating step was the Accretion disk with volume. You look for something and can't find it, you mumble "Oh i need to maybe do this first ? Yeah i need the vdb" and then just move on?
I agree with this. The final result looks stunning, but I found it really hard to follow along. I also wasn't aware that I needed to purchase the volume file on your patreon in order to actually finish the project. If the thumbnail shows an end result, and "Tutorial" is in the video title, I expect a FULL walkthrough of the entire process up until that thumbnail. I understand that you need to make your well earned money aswell, and no matter how much you deserve it, I just can't help but think that this tutorial could have been something exclusive for your active patreons. I really wanted to create and to learn your workflow fully, instead of essentially paying for you to create the volume for me, @ChrisLambethMotion
Amazing work. Thanks for sharing. My question. Did you spend any time thinking about a black hole, from a perspective of popular representations, and how we *see* the effects? Or did you consider the physics, or some combinations? Next, assuming you thought about the effect, did you have you a basic idea for the shaders and nodes that matched your ideas for how this would work? Would you say your knowledge of RS shader nodes is deep? I’m very curious to know the level of the overall effect you understood in the abstract, vs *tweak mode*. Not many tutorials discuss this, and perhaps for some much of it is intuited, or however you want to label creative muse. Fascinating, again thanks for sharing.
Very cool tutorial and it looks great. The only issue I am having is jagged almost pixelated edges around the gravitational lensing when it curves around the top and bottom, any update that could help clean up the detail in that area?
Hi, first of all i love your work. I have a question regarding where you connected the fresnel node into the ramp node exactly at 5:11 from the output color of fresnel into which node? Thank you
i like the tutorial but the part where you said "you have to make sure your vdb is in the volume woo woo" ?????? like bro we trying to learn can you walk us through what you did? There is no cursor either so we can't see where you are navigating.
he cut it, But if you worked with pyro you can make it , just make smook on surface of disk and animate the disk by rotating and scene cache and easy, just make a box fix or bigger than the disk and put disk in the box, don't forget use collider on box.Cheers
thanks for the tutorial. One thing i found out: the ramp for the IOR is causing artefacts in rendering later cause its just 5% for a gradient, or am i wrong?
@@NaklarEZ I had no luck with that either. There is another method using two divide nodes, but the bending isn't as good, but there's no artifacts from what I've seen.
hello, make an effort next time to show the entire video without cutting because we don't understand anything. The tutorial lasts 20 minutes but in the end we spend the whole day finding the solutions. If you're doing a tutorial, do it well. Thanks
![C4D TUTORIAL | Creating a black hole [RedShift]](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
