What about the Hanafi mathab? They are a lot more lenient. This lecture basically means we can’t work at any retail store in the west selling anything edible. As much as I love sheikh Yasir, wouldn’t this be a serious burden on Muslims in the west? Especially when we have scholars of the same caliber like seekersguidance giving more lenient rulings.
plz, do you know an answer about selling to good to someone whose money is known to come from a bank loan, and if no do we have to ask each time the question where the customer's money comes from when we sell services or goods?
إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ يَأۡكُلُونَ أَمۡوَٰلَ ٱلۡيَتَٰمَىٰ ظُلۡمًا إِنَّمَا يَأۡكُلُونَ فِي بُطُونِهِمۡ نَارٗاۖ وَسَيَصۡلَوۡنَ سَعِيرٗا Verily, those who unjustly eat up the property of orphans, they eat up only a fire into their bellies, and they will be burnt in the blazing Fire! (English Transliteration) Inna allatheena ya/kuloona amwalaalyatama thulman innamaya/kuloona fee butoonihim naran wasayaslawnasaAAeera -Sura An-Nisa', Ayah 10
But the essence is the source of income. If you are involved in businesses that deal with interest (Riba), alcohol, drugs, pornography etc; in other words causes harm to the society, then it is forbidden. By mentioning the seller, consumer, writer etc, it means transactions and income generated therein. That is my understanding. Allah Knows best.
Majority products sold in such stores are halal for a few exceptions which is in minority. So in this case it's almost impossible for the person to do anything. And Allah knows best
Assalaamu 'Alaikum yaa Shaykh, I have a question. أَعُوذُ بِاللهِ مِنَ الشَّيْطَانِ الرَّجِيم، بِسْمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمنِ الرَّحِيم. I am an 18 yr-old looking for a job. The are 3 grocery businesses near where I live that serve khamr. If I take up a job there as a cashier would it be Haraam for me to scan what the customer wants to buy if it contains khamr? If so, could I give the money I make from the khamr products as Sadaqa?
Sadaqa have its own terms of acceptance out of which first one is halal source. The shiekh made it crystal clear and gave a very detailed answer about halal and haram job.
I wanna ask , is it haram to lie in order to avert a haram thing , e.g. one of our neighbors ask me to download a no. of songs for him and I accepted then I realized that it's haram so I lied to him by saying that my laptop didn't accept his USB and I swear by God ! So I wanted to know if it's haram or not .. And jazakum Allah khir
@Miss O’Genist i appreciate every single word u've written it down and acknowledge ur sympathy for my situation , eventually i pray that Allah guide us to the right bath , and help us holding our moral principles ameen
We have been warned NOT to swear by THE NAME of ALMIGHTY GOD unless we are telling the truth. This is more serious part of that situation. May Allah (The Most Majestic ) save us from doom
@@kalamullah23 Allah has prohibited in the quran that those who grow/make/ and sell intoxicant is haram ,but if a person is working in the organisation and they are selling intoxicant products it has nothing to do with the person working in the organisation. hadiths are lies and fabricated.
@@Shiraz354 1st, Allah doesn't mention anything in the Quran about growing and making intoxicants. 2nd, Allah commands in numerous verses to obey the Prophet. 3rd, Allah sent down the revelation including Quran and Sunnah and He promised to preserve it. You should listen to the second QA of Sheikh Yasir on Hadith.
Bro I do not know where you live but I am in North America . The way you think you cannot stay here. Riba as per sheik interpretation is everywhere so the salary you are making indirectly comes riba what is the difference someone selling alcohol and working in a office but income is indirectly riba ? Reflect bro
If it's indirect obviously we can't do anything for that. But if u specifically work in an organization which in majority deals with riba its haraam for us to work. Similarly if u work in let's say a factory of liquor brewery just because it gives you more earnings it's haraam
@@ahmedhajwani8980 Well the whole country deal like this , Bank of Canada increases interest to control inflation or decreases interest to boost economy. Ruling for a muslim working in a non-islamic state is completely different from working in a muslim country. That is why Imam Abu hanifa and all his students said '' there is no interest in a non-islamic state'' except Imam al'shaibani says interest is haraam , Read Kitaab al Kharaaj . ( the book of Tax ). See the problem are those who studies in Saudi Arabia and embrace Ibn Taymmiyyah , this is the problem.
@@SROUMALD this is only the opinion of Imam Hanifa. And as I said the entire economy deals with doesn't matter to us because what matters to us as Muslims is that whether the income which we earn comes from a direct from interest based dealing or not. That's important. Similarly if an organization directly deals with alcohol or pork. I. E the their main products include these haram objects and you work there or own one of them excluding the case of necessity then it is not allowed. Use your common sense. Don't try to be oversmart and learn to be respectful. Allah is all knowing. Salam
@@ahmedhajwani8980 Nope not only the opinion of Imam Abu Hanifa , it is all the 4 school of thoughts , 6 centuries after came Ibn Taymiyyah he distorted everything. For you , a drop a urine in a glass of water does not matter to you !! .Intoxicants and Pork are Haraam for Muslims not for non muslims.I think our society are brainwashed by some so call scholar who are influenced by Khawarij .What I am telling you does not come from me , Tons os scholar talked about it . We have to eradicate and get rid of all those scholars saudi arabia , they are dangerous , they have destroy muslims societies in the world , they enslaved muslims in Saudi arabia backup by those so call scholar , we are getting this from them . Real Arabs do not live in Saudi , most of them are from Morroco , Algeria , Tunisia etc ... They way of thinking are way better and close to the sunnah.
@@SROUMALD what the hell? Do you mean to say that if I am in a non Muslim country I am literally free to do any business like interest based business, alcohol selling, porn industry, and all of those haram institution just because I am in a non Muslim despite I having other business or jobs which aren't actually haram, but since they give me less profit I won't choose them
vaseela2 you misunderstand my intentions. Not blaming him for them at all but letting him/whoever controls his account know (since I doubt he will watch his own videos!) so that he can donate a portion of the proceeds with the intention to offset it. Wa salaam :)
vaseela2 it’s mind boggling that their are alcohol ads, on an islamic scholars RU-vid very odd? He actually does have control because the ads are algorithms that relatively play ads that are relevant to that RU-vid channel & throwing alcohol in their whether knowingly or unknowingly is a grave consequence that his Social Media team should have picked up on it and should remedy the situation ASAP. It’s something he and his team can take up with “RU-vid” if their reading this comments as their suppose to they should take heed to the advices given by those watching his platform
@@ohsomashaallah3013 i know this is a year old, but still commenting cuz others are probably gonna come across the comments. As far as I know, even if you purposely want no ads on your videos, youtube can still force them to be there and make money off of it while the content creator gets no share (since they didnt want it in the first place). Disgusting israel propaganda ads were being played before videos of other muslim youtubers recently.
plz, do you know an answer about selling to good to someone whose money is known to come from a bank loan, and if no do we have to ask each time the question where the customer's money comes from when we sell services or goods?
@Miss O’Genist please don't over-complicate our religion. Seeing a pig is not haram at all. Go to a zoo, have fun... And learn about the animals you see(that's the point of going to the zoo ya?:)
Yes it is haram. The curse of Allah is upon the person that sells alcohol, buys it, distributes it etc. HOWEVER, you did not know so you are forgiven inshallah. If you work in a restaurant where most items are halal (Not pork or alcohol) and you sell everything halal but the haram items, then it’s halal inshallah. And Allah knows best.
@@BlueHood345ok what about someone who washes dishes that may have pork on it. U are not eating or serving it u just throw it in the trash and clean the plates.
Hi Sheik, I do not want to correct you , but alcohol is Haraam for muslim not for non muslim , those hadith you are mentioning , the authenticity is doubtful , hence we are using doubtful hadith to guide the Ummah , that's why we are in trouble . I will answer to the person myself , Bro, only Allah knows your circumstances , you do not khave to listen to sheik all the time , the have given us enough problems for the last 13 centuries with their fatwas , Imam Abu Hanifa forbids only the drinking of alcohol or wine , but it is not forbidden to serve non muslim. Remember next time you have those issues , look into the Quran , there are a maximum of 17 forbidden things in the Quran , of you cannot find it , then it is your call not the sheik.
Well said @saleem Rounmaldaro - They sell alcohols in muslims countries by asking the non muslims to pay Jizya so they can sell or have them in the land. A young teenager may want to gain customer service experience and this place may sell pork or alchohol but thy are not responsible for these items, how could such things be classed haram. Hadiths are the worst things to rely on regarding haram or halal.
If you look at the Hadith the prophet forbids the Sahabas to ask about halal and haraam instead he said the Quran is clear. At this day and age we have to ask the sheik for everything as soon as soon as the sheik said it is haraam they love . We have mixed up Judaism and Islam.We have to stop this.only Imam Muhammad said that it is haraam to serve to non Muslim base on a Hadith which says from planting grapes with the intention of brewing to serving , the prophet cursed them . Well it is a linguistic approache not literal.
Saleem Roumaldaro : well, assalamu alaikum. I beg to differ with ur views that it’s permissible or okay under the circumstances of the young person to work in a store that sells alcohol products as its only haram to sell non-Muslims. Well I’m not a scholar but talking out of experience as I have worked in a duty free that sells alcohol products. Although I was involved in the section selling technological products like head phones, mobile phones,etc, occasionally I have to scan alcohol products as well. Well having said that, there are more than hundred times I had to sell to Muslims( now u can’t reason with ur mgmt that u can’t sell to these ppl, can u? ). It’s worth listening to advise of the scholarly people to obtain the mercy and pleasure of Allah swt. This world is a test, whereas alcohol will be served to u on a reclining chair, measures of which will be determined by you , and the drink will be served by voluptuous ladies adorning the finest of garments. Hold on brother, until then!
Well , what is the solution ? Begging ? Living in poverty , how do you know that he is drinking it ? May be he bought it for his boss . Imam Ahmad ibn Hambal one day he man came to see him he asked the imam “my wife is Christian and he drinks wine , now that we are married she keeps asking me for wine what should I do ? Imam Ahmad answered “ this is your duty to provide to her “ meaning if she wants wine you have to provide to her because she is no Muslim. What do you think this guy was buying it from ?Nowadays new so call scholar has made everything Haraam , it is no difference than the Jews whenever they have an issue they go to the rabbi. Use your brain Bro Allah like those who reflects
