Тёмный

CAN YOU HANDLE REAL CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM? 

e r g o j o s h
Подписаться 732 тыс.
Просмотров 686 тыс.
50% 1

Today I am roasting my dear subscribers in celebration of reaching 300K in our family here on youtube as well as 60K followers on Instagram!
My brushes and how to use them!
BRUSHES-------------▶ gumroad.com/er... ◀
HOW TO USE THEM--------------▶ • My Top 5 Sketching Bru...
What music do I use?
▶share.epidemics...
Need to improve? Get 2 Free Months of Skillshare!
▶skl.sh/ergojosh
Get Started with Procreate!
▶ • Beginner's Guide to Pr...
The BEST Screen Protectors!
Get Paperlike! ▶ paperlike.com/e...
▶ • Paperlike Screen Prote...
▶ • How to put a screen pr...
Want to talk 1 on 1? Join my Patreon!
▶ / ergojosh
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
All the other products that I use!
▶www.amazon.com...
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
Follow me on Instagram!
▶ / ergo.josh
Follow me on Twitch!
▶ / ergojosh
Purchases made through some links will provide some compensation to support the channel. Thank you!

Опубликовано:

 

1 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,1 тыс.   
@ergojosh
@ergojosh 4 года назад
Shoutout to @bibzart for the amazing thumbnail art! instagram.com/p/B_Ibf2-hb7B/?igshid=1e0acdctgqlo3
@toqa6735
@toqa6735 4 года назад
I improved my Instagram profile and art thx to your critique of my old profile ( @tout.00 ) *THANK YOU SO MUCH* and hopefully you'll remember and notice my improvement senpai xD
@bloodnessx
@bloodnessx 4 года назад
How can I join by one of ur criticism videos?;o
@KimbapGuru
@KimbapGuru 4 года назад
Do you do reviews on only digital art that has human aspects or do you do all types?
@Zaire82
@Zaire82 4 года назад
It's amazing in more ways than 1.
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@ramandraws
@ramandraws 4 года назад
I love how he roasts people according to their Individual Level... And That's how it is done
@hannahcho4957
@hannahcho4957 4 года назад
yup
@Not.Maxton
@Not.Maxton 4 года назад
I can't agree more
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@nanaochi
@nanaochi 3 года назад
@wolf GIRL True, lmfao. But to be fair, Angels fans know what they're getting into once they send him their art, especially old fans who know that everything he knows has been self taught and honed over the years without "real" help.
@saniberry
@saniberry 3 года назад
@wolf GIRL Lmao still love him tho
@bokamososedibana6940
@bokamososedibana6940 4 года назад
Guys lets just draw bald people ....the hair is just too much
@EmDoesArt
@EmDoesArt 4 года назад
planet Box *bald
@madisonwithalaurenspicture7033
@madisonwithalaurenspicture7033 4 года назад
How does someone being bold have anything to do with hair?
@vyaluvs
@vyaluvs 4 года назад
MadisonWithALaurensPicture he meant bald and i think you knew that lmao
@theflamingphoenix6986
@theflamingphoenix6986 4 года назад
@@vyaluvs tbh I was seriously confused until I saw the first reply, so I doubt they knew that.
@Hollabolla12
@Hollabolla12 4 года назад
*balb
@gourdman8140
@gourdman8140 4 года назад
Therapist: Thicc Will Smith isn't real, he can't hurt you. *Thicc Will Smith:*
@residententiy
@residententiy 4 года назад
*My sleep paralysis demon be like:*
@rae8562
@rae8562 4 года назад
@@residententiy 😳😥
@diabolicaldebacle
@diabolicaldebacle 4 года назад
*Will Smith laugh* YEAAAH
@liliz3483
@liliz3483 4 года назад
Video stared out strong lollll 🤣
@angierodriguezcastellini6980
@angierodriguezcastellini6980 4 года назад
😅
@Mijuki
@Mijuki 4 года назад
Conclusion: We all need to learn how to paint hair :D
@justanotherisekaiprotagoni7293
@justanotherisekaiprotagoni7293 4 года назад
Lolllll tbh
@Yourboyveggies
@Yourboyveggies 4 года назад
well that is tru
@josefinemuhanzu1122
@josefinemuhanzu1122 4 года назад
am i the only one who really knows how to draw hair?
@JaggedCanvas
@JaggedCanvas 4 года назад
@@josefinemuhanzu1122 painting hair is different from drawing hair bruh
@alieenoir
@alieenoir 4 года назад
it's my endboss omgg
@Sewius
@Sewius 4 года назад
These are great. So many styles to stea... I mean incorporate into my own.
@ulitka5010
@ulitka5010 4 года назад
this made me blow air out of my nose lol
@rontorreon2447
@rontorreon2447 4 года назад
It's not stealing if you call it "reference."
@xxannaballsxx
@xxannaballsxx 4 года назад
Luv that
@Thollis1987
@Thollis1987 4 года назад
You said it right the first time!😅
@mehavecat7037
@mehavecat7037 4 года назад
@@ulitka5010 dont we all do that all the time tho
@fartsponge6680
@fartsponge6680 4 года назад
Me: This painting is perfect Ergo josh: needs more detail Me: needs more detail
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@Mayalee77742
@Mayalee77742 3 года назад
@@sosolinhasnba2k24 dude, are you in every comment?
@alicia-hd2cs
@alicia-hd2cs 3 года назад
This kind of joke is not even funny. It just means you’re gullible and cant think for yourself. I know I’m going to get angry replies but if you think about it, it is true.
@fartsponge6680
@fartsponge6680 3 года назад
@@alicia-hd2cs it's just a joke saying he's very professional I'm just complimenting him just like how I'd listen to A pro chef you idiot
@katythu5455
@katythu5455 3 года назад
@@alicia-hd2cs what if some good points were put up?
@EyeLean5280
@EyeLean5280 4 года назад
Honest critiques were a daily part of art school when I went. Aspiring artists have to develop a thick skin, fast, if they're going to survive and thrive in the art world. That said, there is a line that shouldn't be crossed. Critiques should be given with respect and with an eye to helping artists improve.
@danaisazombie
@danaisazombie 4 года назад
I think the problem is a lot of people on the internet don't actually understand what constructive criticism is. They think you can just call a piece ugly and that's constructive criticism.
@Thollis1987
@Thollis1987 4 года назад
Not just in the art world, they have to have thick skin in general in every day life m
@trashcraftretired189
@trashcraftretired189 4 года назад
I wish I got constructive criticism more often.
@ele_v.irtuosity5385
@ele_v.irtuosity5385 4 года назад
@@danaisazombie I don't think the op is talking about those times though. Their statement is still true that a handful of artists who get real constructive criticism disregard it or say they "feel attacked" when they could be using it to improve their art.
@elvingearmasterirma7241
@elvingearmasterirma7241 4 года назад
@@ele_v.irtuosity5385 Then there is me *Sobs* Thank you for the critique I really need it. No I dont feel personally attacked its needed. *Sobs*
@burnttoast5260
@burnttoast5260 3 года назад
The Title: ROASTING YOUR ART The Video: some person kindly talking about other people's art and giving them good constructive criticism with extremely calm energy
@croquemaster314
@croquemaster314 3 года назад
Tittle
@w0rmie5
@w0rmie5 3 года назад
tittle
@salvatoresandwich8450
@salvatoresandwich8450 3 года назад
@@croquemaster314 😩
@croquemaster314
@croquemaster314 3 года назад
@@salvatoresandwich8450 tittle
@3dstuff654
@3dstuff654 3 года назад
Is everybody pointing out the spelling error ?😂
@angelikaking1560
@angelikaking1560 4 года назад
I was just called a shitty artist by some random dude on insta and listening to you actually giving constructive criticism to the artists while drawing and using this vid as background noise was strangely really refreshing and soothing. Keep it up! :)
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@grassjuiice2036
@grassjuiice2036 3 года назад
@@sosolinhasnba2k24 You don't even have any art on your channel
@julien5664
@julien5664 3 года назад
@@grassjuiice2036 they obviously will give u some type of info to contact them...
@zenzonerzz4789
@zenzonerzz4789 3 года назад
Omg i was once on reddit and i posted an art piece that i made and someone replied "your art sucks". Guess which subreddit i was on. *BEGINNERARTIST* Like bish i already know that my art sucks, that's why im on the subreddit XD!
@annierminx
@annierminx 3 года назад
@@zenzonerzz4789 Like the person above, you can join on discord servers, reddit is not a really helpful place if you're searching for improvement, people there are just plain rude af
@soup1626
@soup1626 4 года назад
13:40 She drew Lisa! It's pefec- Josh: no.
@bryanpuerto6712
@bryanpuerto6712 4 года назад
😂 the hair.........
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@croquemaster314
@croquemaster314 3 года назад
@@sosolinhasnba2k24 no
@ingridstockman6668
@ingridstockman6668 3 года назад
Waddles:)
@sarroumarbeu6810
@sarroumarbeu6810 3 года назад
@@bryanpuerto6712 yup XD he's criticism is so good
@annaaolivia
@annaaolivia 4 года назад
I didn’t make it but I’m in the background at 12:47! proud 😂
@rosej4661
@rosej4661 4 года назад
U should be proud🤣 mine didn't even make it.. Like not even in the swoosh in the end
@angryquacks3876
@angryquacks3876 4 года назад
Same! Mine is the mermaid one at 12:29 !
@bimorayendra1959
@bimorayendra1959 4 года назад
Same, I have my art in the background to
@atpidus_sad
@atpidus_sad 4 года назад
17:56! Top row, extreme right!
@nairabee245
@nairabee245 4 года назад
AngryQuacks thats beautiful!😍
@celinedraws4385
@celinedraws4385 4 года назад
Omg I didn’t think I’d make it in the video! I drew Spider-Man at 23:09 haha, thank you for the criticism! Definitely need to work on my anatomy
@charlesbell5500
@charlesbell5500 4 года назад
I would also add that his right arm is way too small, specifically the upper portion. I get you were trying to portray foreshortening, but the elbow should have come down a bit further. Either that, or you should have clearly indicated a curve at the shoulder since the arm is at that angle. The shoulder goes straight into the bicep when there would be a slight curve there. Also, the worst part about the face isn't the nose, it's the shape of the forehead. The nose is a feature that takes time to perfect and it's on par with the level of your other features so it doesn't stand out, but he looks like he has the proportions of a midget, and that's not what you were going for. The top of the head should have been around where his eye brows are or half way up his forehead. I can tell by looking at his left hand. If you put the heel of your palm on your chin and extend your fingers, your finger tips are going to approximately end up around your hairline. So it's too tall, and it's also too wide. A good rule of thumb when dealing with face shapes is that men tend to have wider jaws than foreheads and women are the opposite. Still, the forehead is way too wide. The facial features themselves could use some work but that'll come with time, I can't criticize you for that. It's just that you could have done better if the head was a bit smaller. I recommend getting a proportional divider so that your proportions are as accurate as possible, or at least somewhat accurate if you don't rely on it that much. You don't have to use it for everything, but you could just double check your work with it. After about 15-20 times of using a proportional divider, you won't even need it because you'll recognize the patterns of the anatomy and the proportions and you'll spot your mistakes as you go. Nice detail in the suit, that took a lot of work. And the lighting is very interesting.
@celinedraws4385
@celinedraws4385 4 года назад
Charles Bell Thank you so much for taking your time to write this! I was definitely made aware of the hand and head haha, but your extra feedback is so informative! I’ve drawn this about two years ago so I’ve been able to practice and improve since then, I’ll definitely keep your tips in mind :)
@beans3560
@beans3560 4 года назад
Charles Bell bro this is a whole essay I-
@maiqen757
@maiqen757 4 года назад
Charles Bell hello! I know that this criticism is for Céine, but if you don’t mind me asking, what is a proportional divider? I am very new to the art community, and it caught my attention.
@blakeellis9171
@blakeellis9171 4 года назад
The hardest thing for me is the webs, the eyes, and the pose. These are all issues unique to Spidey. I dont want to to draw him in the same pose every time like Todd MacFarlane who always does the "crotch lean" pose (look up his art if you don't know what I'm talking about)
@ArtVices
@ArtVices 4 года назад
me: wasnt chosen again also me comforting myself: mAYBE CAUSE IM TOO GOOD yEA YEA THATS WHY *sniffle sniffle* but yeS another great video!! and a composition video would be nice i think. def something i need work on :')
@jjjj.oiilolllud904
@jjjj.oiilolllud904 4 года назад
Awh my heart, you'll get it next time 🥺🥺❤️🤧
@vilestoenails6297
@vilestoenails6297 4 года назад
I wanna like but you have 666 likes and I don't wanna ruin it 🖐️
@ArtVices
@ArtVices 4 года назад
Meemaw LeCat op- 667 it’s all over bro ;(
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@forest5862
@forest5862 3 года назад
@@sosolinhasnba2k24 I will
@blmandendarstheangels1935
@blmandendarstheangels1935 4 года назад
Can you do a tutorial on drawing African hair?Im really bad at drawing/colouring my hair type 😅
@charlesbell5500
@charlesbell5500 4 года назад
The key is to not have too much contrast. The highlights should be mostly muted, unless the light source is close or strong. Because there's no straight and slightly curved locks, you won't get these long streaks of highlights like you would in other hair. Even long hair won't get those bright highlights because the planes of the hair always changes because it's mostly curled, which means the light doesn't get a chance to light up a huge portion of each section. Also, it's important for the mid-tones to be arranged in that squiggly pattern but they have to be blurred, they can't be sharp. Blurring the mid-tones will give the illusion of softness and it'll look like it's layered. Another thing to get right is the stragglers, make sure you add in those stragglers at the edge of the sillouhette, especially with sharp, curled highlights towards the top and dark strokes toward the bottom. But don't go too crazy with it. Make sure you get the actual shape of the hair right too, that hair type allows for all sorts of unique shapes, and it's important to nail that. Finally, where the hair integrates with the skin, there should be a relatively sharp edge, it doesn't fade into the forehead like other hair types.
@JFresh25
@JFresh25 4 года назад
I know someone who can really help you out, dm me on insta. Jdavis_art
@Zombina638
@Zombina638 4 года назад
moonfløwer :/
@cynthiawashington3132
@cynthiawashington3132 4 года назад
There's an artist on yt called It'sAJart who did a whole video on that.
@mathilda6763
@mathilda6763 4 года назад
I feel like natural African hair has a lot of 3d to it if it's not super short. it makes it super cool for designing characters with interesting silhouettes. Of couse keeping in mind the shape of the hair in general is a good choice but because curly hair is so much more structured I think it's especially important for this kind of hair.
@e.f.c.2341
@e.f.c.2341 4 года назад
*Rest of the Vid: *Cool Insights** 4:53 : *"OI SHE THICC BOI"*
@potatohugger6295
@potatohugger6295 3 года назад
Glad someone time-stamped this. Just as a reminder of course.
@ariiadnxe
@ariiadnxe 4 года назад
Him: spends five minutes on each piece of art. Me: He could do a whole movie on roasting my art 👁👄👁
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@nilsaiivyarts
@nilsaiivyarts 4 года назад
I wish I had someone to critically analyse every single drawing I make before posting... sometimes I feel like deleting everything once I realise the mistakes 😭
@valeriao9593
@valeriao9593 4 года назад
Omg same
@plipplup
@plipplup 4 года назад
you can join an art discord server! im in one and i often ask the people there for critiques and give others critique as well!
@nilsaiivyarts
@nilsaiivyarts 4 года назад
Georgipops :D You’re right, I have joined a few and it has been very helpful 🙂
@lirenya
@lirenya 4 года назад
pris many art discord communities are very toxic and sometimes all they say is that your art sucks and don’t bother showing you how to improve:/
@nilsaiivyarts
@nilsaiivyarts 4 года назад
Lirenya Yun absolutely
@Thumin
@Thumin 4 года назад
CONGRATULATIONS ON 300K JOSH!! LOVE YOUU!!!💜🎉🎉🎉
@ergojosh
@ergojosh 4 года назад
Ayeee thanks Thumin!
@cry_stalll
@cry_stalll 4 года назад
aa hiiii
@toqa6735
@toqa6735 4 года назад
I love your videos
@jana_ap6584
@jana_ap6584 4 года назад
13:22 Damn, that drawing of Lisa is ON POINT
@saff.k
@saff.k 4 года назад
I thought they just took a picture of Lisa and claimed it was art lol ejdiskwsks
@invix3447
@invix3447 4 года назад
💯💯
@melinadybbro5534
@melinadybbro5534 4 года назад
Jana _ap IKR this was amazing
@katekumpiranon3084
@katekumpiranon3084 4 года назад
@@saff.k FR
@sherrylrodriguez4597
@sherrylrodriguez4597 4 года назад
Ikr
@ItsCherrys
@ItsCherrys 4 года назад
i didnt get roasted 😔😔but at least made it in the video 24:40 (top right)
@xxannaballsxx
@xxannaballsxx 4 года назад
Tear my cherry out tear my cherry out -Beyoncé
@anastasiarussell400
@anastasiarussell400 4 года назад
Holy crap I made it into the video!!! 20:15 is my work. I know I gotta work on hair and composition😅 Thank you so much for the roast/critique Josh 🙏
@fluffmellow3919
@fluffmellow3919 4 года назад
Your art looks really good! I love the colors you used!
@tanbegum5002
@tanbegum5002 3 года назад
I love your at style
@jocelynnewcomb2579
@jocelynnewcomb2579 4 года назад
At 13:42 omg that painting is BEAUTIFUL. I thought it was an actual photograph/the reference. I was shocked when I realized they painted that. Amazing!! So realistic looking
@suchs4979
@suchs4979 4 года назад
i'd love a video on composition and im sure loads of other people would too
@vampyrcia
@vampyrcia 4 года назад
Literally when there’s something REMOTELY constructive people get so defensive and annoying. The situation gets tideous and it’s like,illegal to say your own opinion cause people will bash at you.
@Gloomyraindrop
@Gloomyraindrop 4 года назад
I do agree, BUT, a line needs to be drawn. There's a difference between constructive criticism and just flat out saying something is ugly or being mean. Being mean is not constructive criticism, at all. Pointing out a flaw or saying your opinion respectfully is. Some people try to hide behind "It's constructive criticism" as an excuse to be a jerk and hateful. BUT, if you are respectfully stating a flaw or something about an art and someone gets too defensive about it, that's on the other person getting defensive. For example, stating someone has same face syndrome, it's a bit tricky to discuss because some art styles, people do one face, but other people just simply don't want to or know how to go beyond one face where it looks like one girl is just cosplaying.
@vampyrcia
@vampyrcia 4 года назад
Raven M Yeah that’s my point. I just didn’t want to make it too long 🖤
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@wild_bumblebee
@wild_bumblebee 4 года назад
I read it as : Roasting Your Rat : and got very very confused
@maebholeary2734
@maebholeary2734 4 года назад
Your rats? Roasted
@mutomboinprogress
@mutomboinprogress 4 года назад
10:29 Awww that's my submission! (The girl in the orange top and trousers) 💃🏽💃🏽💃🏽
@sel224
@sel224 4 года назад
You draw so good! 💖💖
@cheesedgrill2148
@cheesedgrill2148 4 года назад
HEY THATS ME MOM! WE MADE IT MOM WE MADE IT! 28:24 IM THE RED STAR IN THE MIDDLE. Damn I was up there for a long ass time. Hopefully I’ll be chosen next time around best of luck to everyone else too!
@SweetiePieChannelLink
@SweetiePieChannelLink 4 года назад
e r o j o s h: can you handle constructive criticism? Solar Sands: Trust me buddy, they can’t.
@eatea5415
@eatea5415 4 года назад
lol
@sosolinhasnba2k24
@sosolinhasnba2k24 4 года назад
Anyone care to critique some art please?
@parentalonion6552
@parentalonion6552 3 года назад
@@sosolinhasnba2k24 Perhaps
@myname.1602
@myname.1602 3 года назад
@@sosolinhasnba2k24 ur art is deez nuts
@blmandendarstheangels1935
@blmandendarstheangels1935 4 года назад
I hope you do this again.I just started as a black artist.And I’ll like to know your opinion
@cry_stalll
@cry_stalll 4 года назад
your laugh makes me so happy :( especially this one lmao 25:05
@nilsaiivyarts
@nilsaiivyarts 4 года назад
Reminds me of Eddie Murphy ☺️
@urajeck6193
@urajeck6193 4 года назад
That name tho, felt
@eatea5415
@eatea5415 4 года назад
/UR A JECK / lol
@alicia-id4nu
@alicia-id4nu 3 года назад
almost 90 days 🤪
@jaimebeazer5948
@jaimebeazer5948 4 года назад
This is my favourite type of video from you!
@ergojosh
@ergojosh 4 года назад
Glad you liked it!!
@i_drink_cold_millk1045
@i_drink_cold_millk1045 4 года назад
4:53 ima take that u think its a 10/10
@dewdropart4180
@dewdropart4180 4 года назад
Thanks for doing this! Actually getting people to give good constructive criticism is so hard, but it’s so valuable.
@maixiong2682
@maixiong2682 3 года назад
I was at a art competition one time and a professional came to critique artwork. She literally called someone’s art “childish” and “boring” and that they shouldn’t even be in an art competition drawing that “badly”. I wish more professionals could be like you and actually give valuable criticism, not just telling someone their art is bad. Thank you for being so professional and informative!
@firelordOzai3
@firelordOzai3 Год назад
She should have been called out on it. I had something similar happen to me at work and I refused to take it lying down, I asked whether I was really expected to be publicly disrespected silently and escalated the incident with a formal complaint. You can be the absolute worst artist in the world and your work will be rightfully criticised but it should never cross over to blatant disrespect
@DeVaunToon
@DeVaunToon 4 года назад
Thank you for the critique man! You’re definitely right especially on the braids for the sailor moon, and I know ohnips! 😅
@EmDoesArt
@EmDoesArt 4 года назад
DeVaunToon it looked so incredible though, awesome job!
@alexandravanpaassen5441
@alexandravanpaassen5441 3 года назад
your criticism sounds super kind. Art school could never.
@charlotte7806
@charlotte7806 4 года назад
i hate it when people just put a art filter on a picture and say its art ugh
@3nvyTheStinker
@3nvyTheStinker 4 года назад
3:59 THAT'S MEEEEEEEE, YAY I WAITED FOR THIS VIDEO AND ACTUALLY DOUBTED BEING PICKED. Side note, the reference didn't have all the teeth so it was a swing and a miss
@jlockstv2712
@jlockstv2712 4 года назад
Niiiice
@queensaharaice7376
@queensaharaice7376 4 года назад
In that case you should've looked at other references of skulls and teeth placement, that would've helped. Immediately I could the teeth were off. Overall it looked very dope💕
@Realhuman111
@Realhuman111 4 года назад
Yessir
@randonameo
@randonameo 3 года назад
I swear if someone puts there own face in a generator to make it look like a drawing...and send it to him to so he can roast it.....💀
@myname.1602
@myname.1602 3 года назад
LMAO
@calliecorn
@calliecorn 3 года назад
I didn't expect to be greeted with Thicc Will Smith today But uh Thanks, that was a sight to see
@SilTK
@SilTK 4 года назад
Even tho my artwork wasnt picked on this video, im still glad that i participated on this one it was really fun doing it and it was my first tme actually participating on something like this and i just want to say thank you josh for sharing your tutorials your expirience etc. u deffinitely helped me to elevate my art. As someone who draw anime for his whole life thanks to your tutorials/videos i deffinitely am doing something that i woulndt imagine, the semi realism and realism style, and from the bottom of my heart I just want to say thank you so much. You're awesome man keep up the good work josh! You really helped me out! I will surely participate on your next roast art submissions! ^^
@blackout_ct1013
@blackout_ct1013 4 года назад
I hope he sees this :)
@SilTK
@SilTK 4 года назад
Blackout CT-5864 Honestly he actually did saw tis comment of mine and he actually reacted on to it the reason why it's not showing cause I edited this comment cause there was some gramatical error the "someone who draw anime" was actaully "some who draw anime" I had to change it and all of a sudden its gone hahahha, I didn't know that if you edited your comment the reaction will be gone still im happy that he noticed my comment it really meant a lot to me and thank you dude.
@loganwilliams6594
@loganwilliams6594 4 года назад
I think this one was definitely an edge above your previous roast videos tbh, the constructive criticism really shined once you pointed out the strong points of the artwork first.
@grandgrimm9358
@grandgrimm9358 3 года назад
I like how hes giving constructive criticism but hes nice about it rather than making fun of the work like ive seen other youtubers. A couple other art tubers ive watched critique beginner art and theyre just so rude about it.
@gc_p
@gc_p 4 года назад
Finally my work got choosen. It feels like an accomplishment 😂. Thanks josh i really need to work on the hair. Im rhe one on 15:56 btw
@kagaminelen2652
@kagaminelen2652 4 года назад
13:24 Me and my messed up kpop mind: Ha HoW yOu LiKe ThAt
@_elenimrk_
@_elenimrk_ 4 года назад
i knew i wasn't the only one!
@hystericallover5989
@hystericallover5989 4 года назад
ok
@elstagersaurus
@elstagersaurus 3 года назад
yOu gOn LiKe Da dA dA Da da dA da Da dA
@nosheenkhan9853
@nosheenkhan9853 3 года назад
Mee
@kagaminelen2652
@kagaminelen2652 3 года назад
Just noticed how quickly I got tired of that song
@dewantoroo
@dewantoroo 4 года назад
Why Am I always missing the submission post?
@Drauzet
@Drauzet 4 года назад
same here
@hellothere55551
@hellothere55551 4 года назад
Idk how it’s even possible... frustrating!!!😂😂
@toriiskarlet274
@toriiskarlet274 4 года назад
I didn't see it either XD
@selinathorn3625
@selinathorn3625 4 года назад
Same
@SharkyDaddy
@SharkyDaddy 4 года назад
I have no idea if that cactus is real or fake, but the fact that he is waving his hand so close to it is making me anxious,,,, just waiting for him to get stabbed or knocking it over
@TheJemmaGrl
@TheJemmaGrl 4 года назад
20:20 - I would buy a print of that! Gorgeous!
@smeft670
@smeft670 4 года назад
Josh: *trying to give constructive criticism and not hurt people’s feelings* Angel Ganev: this is *shit*
@TheRealZeldachu
@TheRealZeldachu 4 года назад
Oh awesome, I got to see myself in the background! Last on the second row on 21:27 , even that’s good enough for me. I always love these videos, it’s been good food for thought on my work!
@fizzyy1428
@fizzyy1428 3 года назад
13:23 If someone told me that was a real person I would believe them
@kelsey9195
@kelsey9195 4 года назад
I'd love to see you do a composition video! Composition is something I've been wanting to study the last few weeks, but I've been putting it off. Congrats again on 300k!!
@RAI-diate
@RAI-diate 3 года назад
If you picked the colours from this video you'd get a cohesive colour pallette Also his shirt colour is one of my favorite colours
@allisonsedar
@allisonsedar 4 года назад
Did I make in in??? Edit: I didn't, but I had fun doing it. Congrats Josh!
@evemontalvao5557
@evemontalvao5557 4 года назад
never thought I'd be so sad for NOT being roasted hahahaha
@evaniharradine1443
@evaniharradine1443 3 года назад
Someone posting their art for constructive criticism: josh: "oooii she thicc boii"
@myname.1602
@myname.1602 3 года назад
Lmao
@atpidus_sad
@atpidus_sad 4 года назад
Maybe 3rd time will be the charm? 😂 Josh, please don't wait till a million subs before doing this again xD. P. S. 17:56, the picture of Satyajit Ray peering into his camera, top right, was my submission. Maybe next time ;_;
@xyzabc-nu3vd
@xyzabc-nu3vd 4 года назад
I have a friend with the same name as urs😂
@sseokul3156
@sseokul3156 4 года назад
ooh i love that ! very talented
@dawn1681
@dawn1681 4 года назад
His voice is so *soothing*
@stupidcuts3757
@stupidcuts3757 3 года назад
Fun fact: you and me aren’t finished with the video
@rickeybernard8156
@rickeybernard8156 4 года назад
Dammit I gotta get in on these. I really love this serious. Especially when it's actually helping other artists, but that thumbnail had me rolling😂😂😂
@doodleyournoodles675
@doodleyournoodles675 4 года назад
I love these roasting your art video!😆😍❤💕 man my art is definitely so roastable. Also I like these videos because they're very informative and helps a lot with my art. The Will Smith one is just so funny!😂😂 A pretty good drawing but weird. Not going to lie I love it though.
@justdrawings7111
@justdrawings7111 4 года назад
16:01 there I am in the bottom right corner, well halfway, but still!
@impinkiepiuwu1832
@impinkiepiuwu1832 4 года назад
4:52 im ded😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@lollalofi3933
@lollalofi3933 4 года назад
15:33 when you live in Europe and you can’t watch them because you are sleeping ;-;
@catelynhale9992
@catelynhale9992 4 года назад
i like this critique video better because he was a lot softer with his critiques while still being honest being nicer with critiques will actually make people take them better rather than being more blunt
@octawleee
@octawleee 4 года назад
people shouldn't get offended when dealing with art, it's a very hard subject to understand, I've always loved to incorporate art in what I do but I get discouraged easily, although constructive criticism is very very useful since you can learn so much!
@codenamehoneytattoos
@codenamehoneytattoos 4 года назад
My Oluwatoyin Salau portrait is in the background at 14:25 and that’s honestly all I needed to feel seen and acknowledged as a digital artist. 😫 Thank you ergo Josh for giving great tips and general pointers that many can learn from!
@whoiissofi
@whoiissofi 4 года назад
i dont know how to explain it but he just doesnt look.. real. like a droid with AI or some shit, especially when I look at the hands.. or maybe im just hallucinating
@hystericallover5989
@hystericallover5989 4 года назад
which of the 500 art pieces shown?
@meamme8
@meamme8 3 года назад
I love the fact that you point out the things you like and pay compliment to their strong suits, and not just hyper focus on what they've done "wrong" and just laying into them about that one thing. I've struggled with learning new mediums because of the people around me just hyper focusing on what I've done wrong and not offering me any support or encouragement. I have a very nice Iwata air brush that hasn't been used but twice over the past years simply because everyone has to do nothing but criticize everything I do in my processes of learning and teaching myself.
@fortigo6794
@fortigo6794 4 года назад
can we talk about where th ohnips is though, she's my favorite
@brenanapeel26
@brenanapeel26 4 года назад
I really hope this becomes a series. It’s very enjoyable and helps artists improve
@da_namekev7682
@da_namekev7682 4 года назад
This was awesome, I love when people get their art roasted and I men that in a good way because people get to learn from this
@RonitManhas
@RonitManhas 4 года назад
Most humble roast I seen yet 😅😅😅. Congratulations for 300k, really luv ur content 🤙🏼
@camcamcamiiie
@camcamcamiiie 4 года назад
3:07 *big tiddy Bakugou*
@duckhugger7692
@duckhugger7692 4 года назад
That intro had me crying 😭
@thejinx6834
@thejinx6834 4 года назад
21:30 "She's a cake" always has been.
@justsomedudete3320
@justsomedudete3320 4 года назад
Congratulations for everyone who got chosen!
@marsofficial3798
@marsofficial3798 3 года назад
Brb gotta paint smthn so he can critique. I value this guy’s artistic opinion sm
@mamediarradrame5911
@mamediarradrame5911 4 года назад
Your videos are so entertaining and informative at the same time! A composition video would be very beneficial for sure.
@kevinn_9568
@kevinn_9568 4 года назад
I wish I came to know about this earlier I would've loved some constructive criticism
@namikosai9466
@namikosai9466 3 года назад
Squidward: "Everybody's a critic..."
@isabellasevillaaguilera9679
@isabellasevillaaguilera9679 4 года назад
Best intro in the entire history of this channel
@mightychondria666
@mightychondria666 3 года назад
My recent google searches: *how to handle constructive criticism* *what is constructive criticism?* *how can I positively accept constructive criticism?* *how to razz on people formally*
@angelacao3371
@angelacao3371 4 года назад
Thank you so much! I wanna defs improve on my anatomy after your constructive critique on my artwork. :) I drew the girl in the polaroid: 18:05
@UUdoubleU
@UUdoubleU 4 года назад
There is *no* critisizing the will smith one. You can *NOT* improve perfection
@megib901
@megib901 4 года назад
Not thicc enough.
@teresap2109
@teresap2109 4 года назад
YES! You are actually being helpful and explaining yourself while still being so encouraging and respectful! Thank you!
@yenifergavina1451
@yenifergavina1451 4 года назад
I think it's hard to give constructive criticism if you don't know what a person is going for in their art but he did a good job
@letsfindsomepeace9207
@letsfindsomepeace9207 4 года назад
I wanted to post my art as well but I was busy this time. Maybe next time.
@artsdragons2779
@artsdragons2779 4 года назад
I didn’t get picked but I got flashed in the background at 18:22 (bottom center) 😃
@mefovarka
@mefovarka 3 года назад
that’s not a roast, that’s constructive well-mannered criticism from a man that wants people to improve their art 💍
@okaybabe5473
@okaybabe5473 4 года назад
CAN YOU HANDLE REAL CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM? Ummm... Bruh NO. everytime i have new idea and get all passionate about shit i paint them so lovingly I feel special and shit But then I hand it to the world and im not specail anymore....days of work just gone because someone say something true like " aw it's cute. Okay work here. Bitch what the fuck my kitten heart can't handle that!. my work is fantastic!
@Kami-ux8nd
@Kami-ux8nd 4 года назад
I couldn’t stop laughing about you seeing my art but not wanting to have it fullscreen because it was too intense 😂😅
@breebiebreeb
@breebiebreeb 4 года назад
It’s super cool tho! I love the colors you chose for it :D
@Kami-ux8nd
@Kami-ux8nd 4 года назад
the breebster thank you ! My Instagram is @morbid.obscurities if you wanna see more like that ♥️
@anyatheangel
@anyatheangel 4 года назад
@@Kami-ux8nd which time is ur art at?
@groooah
@groooah 4 года назад
I probably can’t handle it. I guess, I don’t know. Let’s see.
@笑顔悲しい
@笑顔悲しい 4 года назад
*me being a noob in digital art* "Oh that looks nice" RU-vidr: "so, that isn't that way, you could have improved that, that seems placed random" Me: "Well, shit."
@imani7832
@imani7832 3 года назад
Bruh same
@TheJemmaGrl
@TheJemmaGrl 4 года назад
I love when Josh is speechless by someone’s art :)
@yasmeenali7899
@yasmeenali7899 4 года назад
You are very descriptive when you talk no wonder you are a great artist
@emerldjewlsxox5705
@emerldjewlsxox5705 4 года назад
I was thinking of sending in my art but I knew it was bad so I didn’t need ur criticism anyways I might join next time tho when I get a lot better.
@FirstNameLastName-ej3re
@FirstNameLastName-ej3re 4 года назад
Maybe you could find out WHAT you need to improve..
@Xweetibird
@Xweetibird 4 года назад
Ayyyyy my art is in the bottom right of the page on the first critique, I made it!! 🤣🤣🤣
@idajyrwa2180
@idajyrwa2180 4 года назад
I clicked sooo fast
@graysbygrace
@graysbygrace 4 года назад
Same😂😂
@Pobloonair
@Pobloonair 4 года назад
Me 2
Далее
HOW DO YOU MAKE ART THIS BAD!?
31:40
Просмотров 584 тыс.
🛑самое главное в жизни!
00:11
Просмотров 108 тыс.
DON'T MAKE THESE ART INSTAGRAM MISTAKES
19:02
Просмотров 1,2 млн
Let's Talk about Art Taboos.
23:01
Просмотров 255 тыс.
The drawing advice that changed my life
10:07
Просмотров 3,5 млн
DON'T YOU EVER DO GESTURE DRAWINGS LIKE THIS!
18:00
Просмотров 487 тыс.